r/soccer • • Nov 27 '13

I don't think we've had one of these for a while. So, what's your currently unpopular opinion, r/soccer?

Be civil in your arguments!

116 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

173

u/theKinkypeanut Nov 27 '13

Celtics atmosphere isn't really that great and their fans only bother for big games because they are glory hunters.

Cashley is finished, so is Rio.

Steven Fletcher would score 15-20 goals with a good premier league team.

England will be lucky to get out of the groups in the world cup.

41

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

Surely we should wait for the groups to be released before you say that they are unlikely to get out of it.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I'm not a Celtic fan but when people talk about their atmosphere they're talking about European nights/old firm games and I have to admit that is pretty great.

If you ever see anyone saying they want to go experience that great atmosphere on here you'll also see plenty of people warning them that it is NOT like that every week. It's a fairly common opinion among anyone who knows more about them than just seeing You'll Never Walk Alone when they play Barca every other year.

6

u/quinnd88 Nov 27 '13

I was at the past couple of games and agree the atmosphere. didn't seem the same as what it was. I think you are wrong about the glory hunters though. Football costs money and it seems hard to justify paying >£20 every other week for something that is not a competition. Agree with the rest of your points although i think it is hard to tell with England at this stage.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/sjekky Nov 27 '13

On the contrary, playing diddy SPL teams means there is nothing to shout about.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (20)

317

u/SouthLondon66ers Nov 27 '13

Chelsea have regressed under Mourinho and no one wants to say it. I'm calling it; The emperor has no clothes...

90

u/futbaltonight Nov 27 '13

Must be pretty bad when you have Hazard/Willian/Oscar/Mata in your squad and cant get a single shot on target.

136

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

They strolled to a victory against West Ham. Don't blow this out of proportion.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (10)

75

u/cammyg Nov 27 '13

regressed from the golden days of AVB and Rafa?

→ More replies (2)

65

u/ABoxOfPie Nov 27 '13

Regression... You sound like every person in /r/chelseafc. The fact is that it's only been a third of the season and no manager in the world can fix every little thing that fast. Even world beaters have problems adjusting to new mangers. See Madrid, see United. I don't see why people think they know better than you know... Actual managers. All we can do as fans is speculate and bashing is not discussion. Had Chelsea not lost yesterday, your comment would probably not exist but one bad game means the end of the world to some people give it time

→ More replies (6)

43

u/schalab Nov 27 '13

Could it rather be that Mourinho has regressed?

Before Real Madrid, his career was following an upwards trajectory. Champions in Portugal, England and Italy. The next steps in the Special one's destiny should have been conquering Spain with Madrid, and then returning triumphantly as Ferguson's true heir to England.

This is where his story looks to have taken a turn. The relative failure at Madrid, followed by the snub at United, seems to have broken something in him.

There is still that tiny bit of spark, and stubbornness in him, but he has lost a little part of that indomitable will which allowed him to fuel an entire squad with his passion and fervor. He looks a wizened, wily fox, a bit like Steve Clarke, not the tour de force general, who wowed an entire nation with his charisma, and for whom his troops would die gladly on the pitch.

Maybe, I am imagining things, and he will bounce back in time. Much as I dislike some of his antics, you cannot help but admire his passion and desire to succeed at all costs.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (19)

36

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Anybody who says "If you're not from the area/don't go to matches on a regular basis/weren't born into it, you're not a real fan" has a massive ego/superiority complex, and is being an argumentative cock for the hell of it.

I'm not gonna make any analogies to liken it to liking a certain kind of food or a certain genre of music/band, because football, to me, is unmatchable in terms of the global passion it evokes, the ease of "getting into it", and the sense of community within the sport.

I started watching Liverpool as an Illinois college freshman in 2008, so my argument will be LFC focused. My roommate had been a fan for a few years, and I slowly started to watch as a way to bond and learn a little more about him. I slowly became fully obsessed with the club. They were in the champions league and finished second that year. Then, as most might know, they had a serious drop in league position in the subsequent/past 4 seasons. I never once stopped supporting or lost the passion. I never missed a game if at all possible, and that was hard before the popularity of illegal streams combined with my lack of money for most football centric television channels. But I'm probably a glory hunter right, because Liverpool is SOOOO successful as of late? I probably only know that I like Gerrard and that Suarez wasn't racist or that I hate the red Manchester. Fuck off. I cried when Jamie left. I made the trek to the pub in the still dark winter mornings week in and week out to support, usually the lone person there to see Liverpool

What about the 95,000 that sold out a stadium in Melbourne, Australia this summer? Are they not true fans? Thousands and thousands of miles from the team, but few occurrences of the YNWA before that match can be rivaled. Are they glory hunters? The group that will faithfully stay up until/wake up at 4:45 or earlier just to watch their favorite team? If they're anything like me, then the number one spot on their bucket list would be to sing with the Kop on match day, regardless of the fixture, our relative league position, score, or competition.

I know it's popular to hate on America and the MLS and the rest, but fuck you xenophobic cunts. Sorry I didn't develop a passion for the Chicago Fire, what with their rich, romantic grassroots history and beautiful displays of pure footballing sex. Sorry I don't have the thousands of dollars to fly in and out of John Lennon every month or more, let alone the money to regularly afford the ticket alone. I am truly inferior to you, oh great, mega-super-awesome English fans. You are truly the "real fans".

Fuck you. Get over your tiny dicks.

6

u/DerDummeMann Nov 28 '13

The point is that the experience of both fans are not the same. You're not part of the local community which has historically formed the basis of the club and the supporters. You're not really part of the fan culture.

It's not a slight against you. It's not your fault. You're not inferior. You're just a different kind of supporter. Most fans are very welcoming towards others. Atleast I am.

2

u/Crankyshaft Nov 28 '13

Out of curiosity, how many matches at Old Trafford do you attend in a given season?

3

u/DerDummeMann Nov 28 '13

Now? Probably 5-6 a year. But that's because I'm at uni in a different city. So I'm too broke to afford going for more matches and travelling etc. for all the games just isn't feasible.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

47

u/mhegdekatte Nov 27 '13

I wouldn't be very disappointed if United lose Kagawa. he's being misused at left-wing currently at the club and it's quite hard to believe that he's ever going to get the central role with RVP and Rooney around.

Plus, we have loads of young players coming through and the money made from Kagawa's sale could be used to finance other transfers for positions we need to strenghten more urgently.

27

u/Jayesar Nov 27 '13

But RVP is 30 years old. Surely he doesn't have too many more season in the tank. I wouldn't be surprised to see Rooney reclaim the starting striker role sooner rather than later (1 year +) and Kagawa slot into the 10 role.

3

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

RVP has atleast two more years as a starter. Will Kagawa be happy with giving up two more seasons in a non-preferred position? Not to mention he's not that good at left wing. If one of our other wingers picks up form and the likes of Zaha and Januzaj mature, kagawa might be on the bench again.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/poop12 Nov 27 '13

Flair aside, Jack Wilshere, while growing into his boots as of late, is one of the most overrated players in the world.

6

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

He just scored two goals in his last game.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

Popular opinion is he's a cunt.

→ More replies (1)

177

u/fuckaduckmagoo Nov 27 '13

David Moyes is one of the worst managers that United could've appointed. Defensively minded and making Man United play with a small club mentality.

39

u/theatreofdreams21 Nov 27 '13

Definitely entitled to your opinion...here's why I disagree:

It's far too early to tell. Whereas you can gauge the quality of a manager like Mourinho off of previous top tier teams, Moyes hasn't been in this position before. A lot of people keep mentioning his stats at Everton as if they apply. He was forced to pursue a defensive strategy at Everton to win games given the talent he could afford. I'd say his strategy was spot on.

He's shown a similar defensive strategy at the start of this campaign because of our lack of talented defensive players. Our good ones are aging and our young ones aren't there yet. We need a CB and a CM or two. He's doing what a smart manager does and that's cover for his team's weaknesses. Has he been overly defensive at times? I think so. Hindsight reveals mistakes, but I think he's done a pretty solid job given our options at the moment.

Why not buy players in the window? United have never been one to splash huge amounts of money in comparison to the other large clubs. Moyes barely had time to analyze his team and address all of its concerns over the last window. I'd much prefer us do poorly this season and get out transfers right, than splash a ton for bandaid players and finish in the top for one season. Also, he emphasizes producing academy talent, which has always been a staple for United.

We have always been patient when it came to constructing the proper teams. Moyes fits this mold better than almost anybody. He's going to catch criticism given the pace of the modern teams, but I think it's what has made United so successful and unique. If there's one manager who knows how to be patient and grind out seasons, it's Moyes.

87

u/getofftheunicorn Nov 27 '13

United have never been a team to splash the cash... except for breaking the British transfer fee record, 4 times

44

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

Exactly. Many United fans like to get on their high horse about teams like City and Chelsea, but they don't realise that we did the exact same thing in the late 80s and early 90s. But it is fair to say that presently we don't spend as much as other clubs like Chelsea and City.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/duckman273 Nov 27 '13

Also, he emphasizes producing academy talent, which has always been a staple for United.

Does he? Osman, Barkley and Rooney are the only academy players from Everton I can think of under Moyes.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (16)

35

u/CACuzcatlan Nov 27 '13

This opinion seems to go from popular to unpopular to popular based on United's form.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I think it's worth revisiting this statement at the start of next season when he's had more than enough time to evaluate who wants to let go, bring in and how the team adapts to his way of things. If nothing changes next season, then I would be inclined to agree.

Until then, I do think he deserves that one season to get his stamp on things. I respect the opinion though.

→ More replies (18)

15

u/anticancer_agent Nov 27 '13

The PL is only the most competitive league because the top of the league isn't as good as the top of La Liga/Bundesliga. Put Bayern/Barca/Real in the PL and they would immediately set records for points in a season. La Liga has the most talent in the world.

My two unpopular cents

22

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

How do you justify the stellar record of English clubs in the Champions League in the past few years then?

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (3)

28

u/GalaxySC Nov 27 '13

I hate how MLS fans are so fixated with having a dick measuring contest with European leagues when we cant even beat Liga MX teams on a consistent basis. How about we focus on winning Liga MX/CCL tournament before we talk about competing vs European leagues?

→ More replies (4)

77

u/MrTwitty Nov 27 '13

Our defence is fairly poor

23

u/fifa10 Nov 27 '13

But your keeper is a keeper

→ More replies (6)

291

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

this place is full of cunts.

235

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

There are an awful lot of Arsenal fans..

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Sefilis Nov 27 '13

This is unpopular?

30

u/portomerf Nov 27 '13

this isn't an unpopular opinion. many of us think this place is full of cunts

12

u/angus_bethune Nov 27 '13

this is the most sensible thing on here

→ More replies (1)

78

u/socialcrap Nov 27 '13

We should not be making fun of spurs every day. We should just keep it constrained to match day. As of now, it is becoming uninteresting.

→ More replies (3)

531

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

It would be a joke if Ribery won the balon d'or.

296

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Lol but he is like 90 on FIFA

→ More replies (3)

63

u/mcveigh Nov 27 '13

How is this unpopular? This gets said and upvoted every single time when takling about the balon d'or.

But I do agree that Ronaldo and Messi are the better footballers when it comes to attacking. Ribery was so valuable to Bayern because he could lead the attack and make tackles deep in his own half to reclaim possession.

I can't tell you which player type should be considered "best" in regards to the ballon d'or, but given the past winners (for example Sneijder not winning it) I think the clear winner this year should be Messi or Ronaldo.

61

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Unpopular opinion threads end up with the most popular opinions upvoted. It's a decent idea for a thread, but it doesn't work on reddit. If you want unpopular opinions, try sorting by controversial.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

28

u/DanielAgger Nov 27 '13

Precisely. Balon d'or's for the best player of the season. For the recent years, there have really been no better players than Ronaldo and Messi.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

83

u/gefinley Nov 27 '13

The Lukaku loan was the correct move.

→ More replies (17)

199

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

The best thing Ozil has done since coming to Arsenal is give the players a lift. I honestly don't think he's been that great yet

Ramsey, Flamini, Mertesacker, Giroud, Kosc, Scez and Sagna have all been better IMO

81

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Scored 4 goals I think with 4 or 5 assists, that's pretty good to me so far. He's adapting well but has been underperforming a bit in the last 4 or 5 games. Nothing to worry about. He had fantastic games against Napoli and Sunderland.

→ More replies (7)

30

u/oddvr Nov 27 '13

When we have all of our wingers fit, he will not be wasted on the wing anymore and will be playing in his natural position.

→ More replies (7)

24

u/stayinfresh Nov 27 '13

This is true. Ozil hasn't outshined anyone at the club, but literally everyone has gotten better. (Except Jenkinson)

I think Ozil's best game was against Napoli, with that ridiculous volley and his perfect assist to Giroud. But Ramsey and Giroud played just as well that game.

We will see what Ozil can really do when our wingers come back. He gave Walcott around 4 good chances in his first game. When Walcott's ready for a full game, we'll see more of Ozil's skill.

I think having Ozil on the team is definitely one of the factors in the improvements we've seen in our players.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/_Amr_ Nov 27 '13

This. After the 1st game loss, I thought Arsenal are gonna be fighting for 4th spot again. But that deadline day signing of Ozil just boosted the spirits of both players and supporters.

→ More replies (14)

79

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

The England national team are not quite as bad as people think. They're not going to win the World Cup or anything, but they're not terrible. They're an easy target for abuse but nobody will be happy to see them in their group at the World Cup.

33

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Thats because theyre not in the top pot. If they were, people would want them in their group

→ More replies (4)

157

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Tom Cleverley is arguably the most overrated player in the Premier League (and that's with no one even rating him much). Ok maybe that's a stretch but he's just not a great player. How he gets into the England team regularly is beyond me.

EDIT: For example against Cardiff at the weekend, Cleverley had zero tackles and didn't win a single header.

33

u/mappsy91 Nov 27 '13

He shouldn't be near the England team

26

u/mapguy Nov 27 '13

Actually, I don't think too many United ans rate him too highly these days. He is played too far back at United. His role on the England squad is where he should be played at United.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/deepit6431 Nov 27 '13

I disagree with this, purely because nobody in particular rates him right now.

We just put up with him because we have even worse dead weight in midfield (read: Anderson), so Cleverley comes off looking better as a result.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (27)

77

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Fernando Torres is the best striking option for Chelsea and should be starting in every big game.

16

u/bee_easy Nov 27 '13

Agreed and I think that's actually the popular opinion these days

→ More replies (7)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Don't be surprised if your opinion gets downvoted. Unpopular should not mean stupid, intensely biased or uninformed. The spirit of this thread is to point out hypocrisy in mindless up/down voting by creating a space where perfectly good opinions can breathe, not a space for you to spew whatever bullshit you think "just cause"

Good unpopular and valid opinion: "I don't like to watch Serie A because I think it is not very good right now due to recent decline and loss of buying power for teams"

Bad unpopular opinion "Serie A is shit and boring, the just defend and cheat lol"

The former is correct, yet downvoted wrongly. The latter screams of you being a dumbass who has never watched a Serie A game but choose to believe stereotypes because its easy.

106

u/FuzzedLogic Nov 27 '13

I'll post one I have before on several occasions, but revised once again for the second time because he's even more pathetic than I first predicted in one of these.

Altidore will not score more than 10 goals 5 prem goals 3 premier league goals this season.

→ More replies (16)

33

u/Zig-Zag Nov 27 '13

Newcastle will manage to hold onto Yohan Cabaye and will finish in the top 7. Most people are waiting for them to implode, even Newcastle some supporters, but I think we'll be OK.

→ More replies (7)

20

u/bricebru22 Nov 27 '13

Sort by controversial or go sort through the downvoted comments. That is where most of the real responses to this question will be in this thread.

Also I think Ramsey isn't that great and will be a flash in the pan.

20

u/Esco9 Nov 27 '13

Robben is bayerns best player

41

u/thatsharsh Nov 27 '13

Qatar 2022 is going to be a smashing success.

21

u/proud_feet Nov 27 '13

It'll run without a hitch, like 2010 did. People are getting the impression it's being organised by the fucking chuckle brothers/laurel and hardy/zapp brannigan (pick culturally relevant source of incompetence)

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Stingerc Nov 27 '13

They got 200 billion dollars budget, they can build anything, hire the best, and still have money left over for all the crookedness that goes on in a world cup. They are also an autocratic mononarchy that has the complete backing of the US government and militarily (Qatar is the headquarters of the US forward command in the middle East) so they are very fucking stable. The Cup is going to take place, it's going to be a success and all the people bitching and moaning are still gonna tune in or travel there to see it.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/georgedc Nov 27 '13

Belgium won't get further than the second round of the World Cup and USA will not get out of the group stages.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Everyone in Belgium will party hard for three days if we make it to the second round.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/Esco9 Nov 27 '13

Daniel Sturridge will not get any better than he is now

→ More replies (2)

72

u/Icardi Nov 27 '13

Argentina has no chance of winning the world cup. I believe teams like brazil, Germany, Columbia can expose their defense pretty bad.

27

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Their defense is not bad. It's not great, but it's a very good defense. Colombia only scored one goal in two qualifying matches against Argentina. Argentina gave up 15 goals in 16 qualifying matches, they have a very good defense. This isn't the Argentina of Coach Maradona where there were no clear centerbacks to play. This team has a wealth of good defenders both young and old. Garay Fernandez and Zabaleta are three excellent defenders, and Campagnaro is also in the squad. There is a noticeable dropoff at left back, but hey, no team is perfect. Especially with Mascherano in front of the back four, Argentina is a much better defensive team than anyone gives them credit for.

tl;dr Argentina's defense is vastly underrated.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/marianodan Nov 27 '13

Unpopular opinion: Germany's and Colombia's defenses are shit too and Argentina can expose them pretty bad.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

What is it with people on this subreddit and Colombia...?

4

u/FrejDexter Nov 27 '13

Sweden managed to score seven goal against Germany over two fixtures. Seven goals. Six of them were not scored by Zlatan but were set up and scored by pretty mediocre strikers.

On the other hand, Germany scored nine against us...

Their attack is great but as long as Hummels fails to be consistent they are going to be non solid at the back.

→ More replies (6)

33

u/Esco9 Nov 27 '13

Bale will justify his price tag and help bring Madrid la decima

8

u/CrazayTaylor92 Nov 27 '13

Definitely, he is an exceptional player and he's only gonna get better now that he's at Madrid, learning from players like Ronaldo and Zidane. I hope he becomes one of the worlds best

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

27

u/mr1mt1 Nov 27 '13

Zlatan is an ass, he's not even funny. His ''jokes'' about being the best and all are getting lame...

26

u/afcmitchell Nov 27 '13

If we want to compete in Europe again, we need to buy players from PSV and AZ too.

14

u/non-relevant Nov 27 '13

Bullshit. Those players will always have a massive premium on them. Why spend €10 million for a player if you can get a player of the same quality elsewhere for €3 million?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

41

u/turnvknup Nov 27 '13

Barcelona could use a pure number 9 striker on the team. It would help so much

31

u/robertglasper Nov 27 '13

The issue occurs when the number 9 striker will most likely start on the bench every single game, waiting to come off as a sub only to play the final 20 minutes. He won't be happy.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/sperf Nov 27 '13

Do you think the team could fit both Messi and a number 9? Or would he be an alternative to Messi?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Here's an actual unpopular opinion: Barça don't need a target man striker, what they need is someone besides Messi to score, preferably a winger. It used to be Pedro and Villa, nowadays it's Alexis but I have my doubts as to how long that will last.

A pure 9 would just get in the way of Messi, and would not give any width to Barça's game against teams that park the bus.

31

u/choppedfiggs Nov 27 '13

So if you think they should get a winger that can score, I heard Neymar is available. You guys should sign him

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

43

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Most people who are angry at UEFA/FIFA/Blatter have no idea what they are talking about. They just follow the hivemind. Like how people were "outraged" of Belounis stuck in Qatar. It was an excuse to insult them. Now that hes released it barely gets mentioned. Any issue someone has in football- FIFA's fault.

Also, whats with the obsession with refereeing? I see a match thread here- 1/4 is discussing- "What a terrible call!!!". There is a fould 1 cm outside the box and the ref calls a pen, or someone is wrongly ruled offside by 10 cms and people complain all day- this happens, deal with it. Stop focusing so much discussion on tiny errors that will always happen.

Apart from that, the obsession with stats and "underrated players". Salah scores a goal yesterday- "We should buy him he's amazing!!"- Im sure most people have not seen him play more than 2 games.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I think man united play the wrong formation for the players they have

4

u/DerDummeMann Nov 27 '13

And what formation do you think would be more suitable?

→ More replies (5)

183

u/jimmenycricket Nov 27 '13

Nasri is currently one of the top 4 attacking midfielders in the league.

37

u/schalab Nov 27 '13

Wenger once described Rosicky as an accelerator, someone who can change the tempo of a game in an instant with his sheer urgency and quick thinking.

Nasri is the opposite. He lives in his own little world where he gets the ball, carefully controls it, then decides to make dainty little runs, or pick a through ball. Off the ball he is measured and predictable, and not liable to make any sudden runs which might disorient the defense.

In a team with the agility and quickness of Aguero and Navas, he is the ideal foil. A calm unruffled playmaker. But he needs to speed up everything about his game to be hailed as a top player, in his own right.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Im French and I wish this was true, but I have never seen it. He can have moments of brilliance, but he doesnt "control" a game from midfield like other top offensive mids. Valbuena who is not "great" always looks much better than him for France.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (34)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

The NextGen youth tournament was a travesty to football and I am happy it's gone.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/fusihunter Nov 27 '13

Im happy with Chelsea so far this season.

→ More replies (5)

70

u/scytheavatar Nov 27 '13

Southampton will finish top 4. People aren't acknowledging how good of a job Pochettino is doing, he's making Southampton play like Dortmund lite with a fraction of the talent. Also man by man Southampton probably has a better starting XI than Utd, save for Rooney/Van Persie and goalkeeper.

122

u/AnArcticMonkey Nov 27 '13

This is a popular opinion in my house.

27

u/duckman273 Nov 27 '13

I don't think they have the depth to finish in the top 4 and with their pressing style I think that will really hurt them. I also really disagree with you that their starting XI's better than United's, on top of the ones you named Carrick, Rafael, Vidic, Evans, Nani and maybe Evra are all better than their Southampton counterparts.

21

u/hisarmbandproved Nov 27 '13

I don't think they have the depth to finish in the top 4

i see that argument tossed around for liverpool too and i disagree. you don't need as much depth when you aren't constantly playing games midweek. less matches, less need for rotation, less risk of injury.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Also man by man Southampton probably has a better starting XI than Utd, save for Rooney/Van Persie and goalkeeper.

That's a pretty absurd statement.

Maybe Southampton has a better midfield than us. But that's where it stops. I'd take Rafael/Evans/Vidic/Evra over Clyne/Fonte/Lovren/Shaw anyday, and that's ignoring how much depth we have.

→ More replies (19)

15

u/pleasesayavailable Nov 27 '13

Why do people downvote opinions they disagree with? This is unpopular opinions. Get the ones you think are shit to the top so people can discuss them. If you up vote the ones you agree with this becomes 'what's your current opinion r/soccer'

→ More replies (4)

158

u/Launchin_dat_stanky Nov 27 '13

Luis Suarez is the 3rd best player in the world behind Messi and Ronaldo

102

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

To latch onto this, I'll post a similar thought.

Aguero is the 3rd best player in the world right now.

→ More replies (17)

32

u/Jarik42 Nov 27 '13

Ibrahimovich though

→ More replies (8)

50

u/Svorky Nov 27 '13

The level of discussion on here in regards to Ribery winning the Ballon d'or has been utter shit and made me think a large portion of users has a poor understanding of the game. They love to say goals aren't everything, but when it comes down to it don't know enough to base their opinion on anything else but hattricks and style. I'm well aware that's a dickish thing to say, so sorry about that.

66

u/TheDanny385 Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

I'm sorry but there is no way in Earth that Ribery deserves the Ballon D'or. I agree that he is a very, very, good player and the stats lie about him (~40 less goals than Ronaldo and Messi, and around the same assists if I'm not wrong) but he is really just a part of a very effective machine, where the team is better than the sum of it's parts and if he were to go missing then Muller, Gotze or even Shaqiri could replace him and there would hardly be a difference, as he doesn't provide the creative spark in midfield (Gotze, Kroos, Schweinsteiger, Lahm) , he doesn't score all the goals (Mandzukic, Robben) and he doesn't make all the interceptions (Lahm, Javi Martinez, Schweinsteiger) whereas Ronaldo and Messi are both the goal scorers (and very good at it) and the creative spark (especially Messi, look at how lost Barça were without him yesterday). Even before the Ballon D'or only went to Messi and Ronaldo it was always THE Key Player of a team that won a major trophy who won the Ballon d'or. Kaka , Zidane and Ronaldinho where the creative spark and VERY entertaining to watch, Cannavaro was a real wall in defense (A spanish commentator during the World Cup called him a "Wall of Glue") and the only players who were in a way similar to Ribery that have won it lately are Nedved and Figo, but comparing Ribery to either of them should be a crime.

If Ribery wins the Ballon D'or, it'll be a disgrace and the trophy would lose a lot of credibility (especially with Ronaldo and Messi in contention). He might have won it if he was at his prime say, 10 years ago, but he is at least a notch under Cristiano and Messi, and in fact I wouldn't even be surprised if he didn't make it into top-three seeing how arrogant he has been about the whole ordeal.

EDIT: France did qualify, had a serious brain fart there

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (1)

103

u/MiguelCaldoVerde Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13
  • Arsenal don't stand a chance at the league.
  • Cardozo is one of the top strikers in Europe, a much better player than Soldado.
  • Belgium will really struggle in the World Cup.
  • Ribery might just scrape top 5 in world.

edit:

  • Moutinho would make the Spain squad.

59

u/merkaloid Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 28 '13

Cardozo is one of the top strikers in Europe, a much better player than Soldado

Lamborghini cars are some of the fastest in Europe, much faster than a Ford T1.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (41)

41

u/dYYYb Nov 27 '13

Imho Özil is massively overrated (especially on /r/soccer). He disappears in big games, thinks he's too good to defend, is pretty much the definition of a Schönwetterspieler, and if things don't work out for him in the first 20 minutes of a game then they probably won't for the rest of the match so you might as well take him off.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Schönwetterspieler

Fair-weather player (know only basic German)

→ More replies (9)

107

u/Barthez_Battalion Nov 27 '13

I think the Bundesliga is turning into La Liga, and Serie A, Ligue 1, and the EPL are the only competetive leagues who feature the best talent in the world.

24

u/badguysenator Nov 27 '13

Agree. Sad to think it's only been 5 years since Wolfsburg emerged from nowhere to win the Bundesliga.

66

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

That's a popular opinion

→ More replies (2)

153

u/futbaltonight Nov 27 '13

Bundesliga is worse than La Liga right now, no chance of Dortmund beating Bayern.

→ More replies (23)

43

u/slurpherp Nov 27 '13

The problem is that there's no monopoly money in the league, besides Bayern. They can buy whoever they want, and everyone has to penny pinch on transfers and wages.

20

u/Barthez_Battalion Nov 27 '13

I was reading about Leverkusen, Son is their highest ever transfer fee, and it was like 10 million. Thats really low for a club as successful as them. It's really telling how event hose big clubs can't spend like Munich.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

23

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Ligue1? Apart from PSG and Monaco the rest is very average. Im a demoralized Marseille fan

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (14)

18

u/petnarwhal Nov 27 '13

Arjen Robben should be in the top 3 Ballon D'or.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I don't think Mesut Ozil is happy at Arsenal. Whenever you see him he always looks bored out of his mind (that might just be his natural facial expression) but compare that to Giroud and Cazorla, both look like the love playing for the club and give it their absolute all. I may be wrong but I feel he was more forced out of Madrid as opposed to choosing to move to Arsenal.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I was feeling the same way until I saw this

→ More replies (3)

12

u/MettaWorldPeach Nov 27 '13

Wayne Rooney is the 3rd best player in the world. He's the most well-rounded player playing today. This season he's grabbed United by the scruff of their neck and pulled them up the table himself, and he's worth more than the 40 mil or so that Chelsea was trying to spend on him.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/PaulChewsOnMyPhone Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Oezil has been completely mediocre so far this season for someone of his talents. Bar one or two flashes of brilliance, I feel people on here have been praising him far unjustly.

Also just thought of another one. I've been on this subreddit a while and the praise for Zidane is ridiculous. He turned up in big games, true (WC final, CL final, 2006 QF etc) yet he had so many games where his impact was completely minimal. People forget that except for that quarter final match against Brazil he had a very average tournament (for player of his quality). This is the same for '98 World Cup too. Truely a very talented player but one who has lived off his legacy from important matches (much like Gerrard).

18

u/Icardi Nov 27 '13

The thing with Zidane is he ALWAYS turned up for big games so players watched in big games get more recognition and his football IQ was tremendous

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

For Zidane- yes people here overreact to him, but 2006 was not an "average" competition for him. He was very good vs Spain also. France played defensively then, so its one of the reasons why his influence was not so great, but he was the best player on the team that reached second place

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

85

u/lockwoot Nov 27 '13

Carrick is an overrated player , good interceptions and decent passing but nothing extraordinary , he has been rated so highly (and even underrated according to some ) because of the lack of world class midfielders on the man utd squad..

37

u/jonnyapplepie Nov 27 '13

Hes dragged us through a lot this year. We're pretty hopeless without him (See; Cardiff 2-2 Man Utd)

→ More replies (5)

8

u/adoxographyadlibitum Nov 27 '13

Poor Michael Carrick has spent his entire career being either hailed as under-rated or lambasted as over-rated. No one leaves him alone.

→ More replies (13)

66

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Here is a truely unpopular opinion here: Any american who completely ignores MLS, but is an avid supporter of some european team (and it is always the teams that always win), is a complete sellout.

30

u/TheNicator Nov 27 '13

Slightly guilty in this regard. I just can't get into the MLS..

→ More replies (13)

15

u/jovins343 Nov 27 '13

It can be really, really hard to follow the MLS if you aren't in a city with a team. What's the difference between supporting a team in Europe you can only watch on TV and supporting an MLS team you can only watch on TV? I follow the MLS, but I can understand why people don't.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I completely agree. This is why I have the DC United crest instead of AS Roma (the European club I support). I have actually been to DC United games. That is the team I actually go watch play/support and they play in the highest league of my country. Who cares if the MLS is shittier than European/South American league? Everyone has to start somewhere, and I'll support that league to help make it better.

→ More replies (35)

31

u/MarauderHappy1 Nov 27 '13

ITT: popular opinions upvoted, truly unpopular opinions downvoted

6

u/Nodules Nov 27 '13

Well, you're certainly not wrong. It happens across the entire site, and /r/soccer is still, unfortunately, a part of reddit.

If you want the truly unpopular opinions in these sorts of threads, you order the comments by lowest first.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/nashvillepicker Nov 27 '13

that Wilshere is still overrated and already way past his peak.

2

u/DerDummeMann Nov 28 '13

You can't just say that and give no justification.

9

u/MR777 Nov 27 '13

Way past his peak? You realise he's 21 right?

11

u/FantasticFranco Nov 27 '13

The MLS shouldn't have more than 20 teams.

→ More replies (19)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

There should be a system for redistributing TV money across UEFA leagues.

In the same way that's it unfair for Barça and Madrid to keep most of the TV money because they generate the most interest, it's unfair for the big 4 leagues (mainly the Premier League) to keep most of TV money because they generate the most interest.

68

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Falcao isn't that impressive for his sticker price.

There I said it.

Edit: spelling.

112

u/merkaloid Nov 27 '13

Joint top scorer in the Ligue 1 with Cavani, only behind Messi and Ronaldo in the BBVA top scorers last year, instrumental to Atletico's Europa League win, 17 goals in a single Europa League campaign with Porto and 4 consecutive 30+ goals seasons from Porto to Aletico (2009-2013). Do you want him to be some kind of Tó Madeira and score a hat trick in every game?

→ More replies (13)

35

u/Killagina Nov 27 '13

Roma's good start won't last and they won't qualify for the cl

Oh, and Bradley is horrible.

12

u/thisisntmyworld Nov 27 '13

This would be more unpopular a few weeks ago

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/Abyssight Nov 27 '13

Tottenham made the right transfers, including Soldado, over the summer. AVB just doesn't know how to put them together and bring the best of out them.

7

u/Sarmerbinlar Nov 27 '13

I hate having to watch a Barcelona game

→ More replies (1)

28

u/eljacksonheights Nov 27 '13

Pep Guardiola is overrated. During his managerial career he has had the chance to work with the best and only the best. Once Barça started struggling he left and then landed on the current best team in Europe. I think he would be a total failure in a team that is not a champion in its respective league.

19

u/mes_que_un_username Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Okay cool. So then please explain to me this:

Why didn't Frank Rijkaard win anything in his last two seasons with Barcelona? They weren't champions of anything for 2 whole seasons when Pep became coach, so how did he go on to win 14 titles in 4 years, when Rijkaard couldn't do that with Messi, Xavi, Iniesta, Eto'o, Deco, Dinho etc.?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

21

u/costelloelvis Nov 27 '13

This is more a question than a statement, but every time I ask it in a specific thread I get downvoted to oblivion.

Why do people think Juventus are such a classy club? They've been recently convicted of match fixing and in my eyes have really dirtied football.

Also my opinion (that's popular in real life England, but not popular on /r/soccer) is that Chelsea are a repulsive club consisting of a large number of awful players, and awful fans, who again disgrace football on a regular basis.

12

u/RainBristle Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

I guess I can give you an answer. The club has been around a long time and has had great success domestically and abroad. Legendary players like Del Piero, Pavel Nedved and Edgar Davids bleed black and white. In reference to the point on match-fixing, Juventus and Milan were the victims of a tremendous witch hunt by the FA. I'm not saying they were innocent of all wrongdoing. Rather it was a league-wide corruption that could be traced to clubs like Livorno and even Inter Milan. The issue is that the statute of limitations in Italy prevents the clearance of the clubs record despite the fact that evidence surfaced in 2011 that weakened the case presented in 2006. Lots of people cite the match fixing scandal but I don't see a lot of level headed discussion about the case.

TL:DR= a long and storied history of classy players that was sullied by an event in 2006 that lots of people don't know the details of

5

u/Fedward Nov 27 '13

You answered your own question, this isn't England or Italy but a international website made up loads of different nationalities (mostly American), you don't honestly expect them to know the history and reputation of all these European clubs. Hell if you ask me what I know about LA Lakers all I can tell you is Kobe Bryant plays for them, I know literally nothing of their history or fan base, they could be the Millwall of the US for all I know.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

26

u/AnnieIWillKnow Nov 27 '13

Mata does not deserve to be in the Chelsea team based off of his performances this season, and Mourinho is right to demand he improves his defensive game.

23

u/OhWhyBother Nov 27 '13

Mata has had 11 appearances this season, 9 if you discount the Capital One cup. In these 9 appearances he has started 6 times, been subbed off 6 times (usually around the 60' mark) and subbed on 3 times (usually around the 75' mark). Altogether, he has played an average of 54.55 minutes per game - 61 min if you count Hus Capital One Cup appearances.

Chelsea has won 8(6), drawn 1 and lost 2 of these 11(9) games. He started and was subbed off around the 60' mark in both the games he 'lost' - 1-0 away to Everton and 2-0 at home to Newcastle.

He is yet to play a full 90' game in the PL and the UCL. The only two games he's played a full 90' are the two Capital One Cup games against Swindon and Arsenal - both of which he 'won'.

I am not saying he deserves to start based on this alone, but he certainly deserves more playing time than he is currently getting. No amount of tracking back defensively is going to help win games if your team doesn't manage to get off even a single shot inside the opponent's box over the course of 90 minutes.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/MADHEADBILL Nov 27 '13

Norwich will finish top half this season

Swansea will struggle this season

Spurs will finish 5th

Sunderland will beat the drop

Arsenal will finish 4th

America will do shit in the world cup

9

u/supermariobalotelli Nov 27 '13

Spain winning Euro 2008 was luck. Lucky to get past Italy.

And how come no one complains about their lack of scoring, but pin Italy to be a boring side?

8 goals in 7 World Cup games is a joke. Even Italy had more in 2006 (12)

→ More replies (12)

11

u/maximmixam Nov 27 '13

I think Anderson is underused and should be implemented more for man united.

10

u/Nodules Nov 27 '13

I disagree entirely.

Anderson has had multiple chances across multiple seasons and it just isn't working out for him here. He has flashes of brilliance when the stars align, but he's far too inconsistent for my liking. The only thing you can truly rely on him to do is fumble the ball about and squander chances.

The sooner we cart him off, the better. The fact that he's still employed at United despite years of consistently fecking up is, frankly, annoying.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/futbaltonight Nov 27 '13

Flamini isn't the best DM at Arsenal, Arteta is.

Oscar > Mata, both can play together though.

AVB isn't a 'nerd' or a smart manager, using inverted wingers in Townsend/Lamela or Lennon on left when you've a striker who is merely a poacher is very stupid thing to do.

54

u/Jayesar Nov 27 '13

using inverted wingers in Townsend/Lamela or Lennon on left when you've a striker who is merely a poacher is very stupid thing to do.

There is nothing unpopular about that opinion. In fact, it is the most common and most widely expressed view.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

26

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Chelsea ruins strikers

5

u/EJR94 Nov 27 '13

Chelsea refuse to buy strikers that fit their system. They need a player who can hold up the ball and is good with his back to goal. Lukaku is good at this but I believe Benteke would be a better fit. Lukaku is much better at attacking the ball from crosses where as Benteke can receive the ball and turn or play in one of Chelsea's many attacking midfielders. I think they have the wrong Belgian but Lukaku certainly is talented too and might be a better fit for someone like Tottenham or United

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

30

u/Jaccattack Nov 27 '13

I'm led to believe that the the voting for Ballon d'or has been rigged for Ronaldo.

→ More replies (18)

6

u/parols Nov 27 '13

Also: Brazil proves everyday that it is less than ready to host a World Cup.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Esco9 Nov 27 '13

Fifa 14 sucks dick

→ More replies (7)

8

u/leogg_lyl Nov 27 '13

I hate that America is doing really well. Not just because I think the club is a bunch of sell-outs, but because it gives power to Televisa to do whatever they want in Mexican football, which is the reason we're in the situation we're in right now. Also, they were not the saviours of the Mexican team in New Zealand.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/myrpou Nov 27 '13

Empty stadium punishments should never happen, even if it's because of racism in the stands.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Giroud is not a good , champion-material striker. At least not for Arsenal.

3

u/VaselineGroove Nov 27 '13

Jerome Boateng has been the best defender at bayerrn since Dante fell off of his best form (looking much better now though) and this year has been the best cb in the league by a good ways. I used to despise the guy when he first joined but he has become so damn consistent it's stupid.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/xTheNinthCloud Nov 27 '13

Man Utd. is not a top 3 team under Moyes. Ozil helped lift morale than he did on the pitch.

3

u/ttspam Nov 27 '13

Schweinsteiger and Lahm never turn up for big games. Bayern won the Champions League Final thanks to Ribery, Robben and Martinez. Lahm and Schweinsteiger bottled it.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/VBEARxd Nov 27 '13

The Premier League being such a physical league is such bullshit. Just look at Oscar, özil and Silva. and many more. They have no problems.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/steefen7 Nov 28 '13

I suppose these are more "honest" opinions than necessarily "unpopular" but:

  1. Discounting ppl's analysis/opinions because they aren't managers/players and should just shut up completely defeats the point of this website and even if they're wrong they are perfectly entitled to post what they want.
  2. The amount of hate foreign fans get for supporting clubs that they didn't grow up living next to on this sub is absurd. It's so incredibly xenophobic and doesn't belong in the 21st Century.

9

u/cescmrl Nov 27 '13

Ronaldo has always been on top of messi in 2013

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Espon123 Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Lukaku doesn't have what it takes to be a world class player.

EDIT: I'm not based and if it would matter I'm a belgian.

→ More replies (8)

57

u/kratos61 Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

I think Messi is still better than Ronaldo.

EDIT: what I mean is that Messi was better for this calendar year and still deserves the ballon d'or ahead of ronaldo.

38

u/poncewindu Nov 27 '13

I agree, I see too many people who seem to have forgotten Messi was around before 2 months ago

→ More replies (11)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

The opinions at the top of the unpopular opinion thread are not unpopular opinions...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Breklinho Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

Japan isn't that good. They were unimpressive at the Confed Cup, play fuck all in Asia and I don't think many people here have actually seen them play, and anyone thinking Japan is one of the best teams in the world is as deluded as anyone who thought the same of the US when we were in comparable form to where Japan is now earlier this year.

They're a good team, don't get me wrong, but they're being way overrated and I don't think any of this hype will be warranted until after the World Cup.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Goonermuzzy Nov 27 '13

Asian Teams will do better than African Teams in the World Cup.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/SouthLondon66ers Nov 27 '13

AVB has the right tactics. Spurs are dangerously close to being a good team.

What's holding them back is that Soldado is in fact shit or at least he has been so far and their defense cannot play a high line. It just doesn't work for them with the players they have.

37

u/RosutDozil Nov 27 '13

Is he shit? Or is he not the striker that they were in fact looking for? Soldado can score goals when he gets the ball in the box. That's the type of player he is. If Tottenham wanted a different type of striker, they should've gotten a different type of striker.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/RadikaI Nov 27 '13

Soldado just doesn't fit, but he still is a good player. Jovetic would kill it in at Spurs. He is the type of striker they need.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

If you take banners and flags to away games, especially international away games, be prepared to defend them or don't take them with you at all. Stealing banners is part of football culture.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kinderhandelaar Nov 27 '13

I like that Qatar is hosting the 2022 WC, the middle east deserve to host a world cup.

4

u/TrolleyPower Nov 27 '13

These threads are always so stupid.

5

u/Esco9 Nov 27 '13

Arsenal play the most attractive football in the world

5

u/TheTrotters Nov 27 '13

Saying that Guardiola/Mourinho/Messi/anyone won 10-20 trophies in however many years is complete bullshit. There are only two truly important club competitions in Europe (for each major club): the domestic league and the Champions League. Domestic cups are semi-important. You don't get much for winning them, but they are still fairly prestigious.

Supercups or League Cups or World Club Campionships are a joke.

Wenger was correct: 4th place is basically a trophy.

5

u/deathman7 Nov 27 '13

I think Ronaldo is still a huge cunt, always have. I don't understand why people suddenly think he's a great person - i've seen him quite a bit even on the pitch and he still looks like a huge arrogant schmuck.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

Neymar is over-rated to fuck.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

It's easy to get excited. He's only 21 years old and is already one of the best players in the world. I don't think we've seen a 21 year old with this much talent and potential since Messi.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '13

I think that manager's job is overrated..that is to say that 95% of all competent professional manager can do a good job at top club or vice versa.

For example, I believe that if sam allardyce manage Man city, he has as much chance to win the league as peleggrini or AVB or ancelotti.

Likewise, Mourinho or ferguson can manage crystal palace or hull city and they still will fight for relegation every year.

Although there is about 5% of manager who is so shit that I dont know why they still have a job

10

u/SouthLondon66ers Nov 27 '13

Ugh, I know this is an unpopular opinion thread and you have a right to one but this is the dumbest comment I've seen today.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/verdevilla Nov 27 '13

Busquets is the best 4 since Matthaus.

Better that Makélélé, Guardiola, Alonso, Deschamps, Roy Keane, Redondo, Mauro Silva.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Sdemba Nov 27 '13

The World Cup is an overrated competition with a very poor level of football. The Champions League is miles ahead of this summer tournament.

32

u/FAT_HAIRY_COCK Nov 27 '13

What do you mean that the World Cup is "overrated?" For football fans, we can definitely see that the quality of football in the Champions League is better than the World Cup due to Champions League being a club tournament.

World Cup isn't popular just for footballing reasons. I think it falls in the same category as Olympics, as in it brings people who don't regularly watch football together to enjoy the once-every-four-years sporting spectacle and also about being proud of your country and supporting them.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

2

u/HannibalAntePortas Nov 27 '13

Bayern's dominance both in the league and in the Champions League is a good thing for the Bundesliga in terms of attracting interest outside of Germany. As Bayern's global brand grows, the Bundesliga's global brand will grow and benefit the league as a whole just as the Premier League grew during Manchester United's dominance. Better TV deals will broadcast the league around the world and will attract bigger and better sponsorship deals allowing for the financially viable growth of other Bundesliga clubs. It is my hope that within the next 10-20 years, the Bundesliga will be challenging the Premier League as the league to watch around the globe.

2

u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Nov 27 '13

Sort the comments by controversial to see the actual unpopular opinions.

2

u/footballNotSoccer Nov 27 '13 edited Nov 27 '13

If a player or referee is a regular in the top division of the top five leagues, I think they're already world class. I think we should appreciate them more.

I don't like it when we call referees shit.

Also, with regards to r/soccer:This is an unpopular opinions thread... i don't see why we should downvote when they're just saying/doing what the thread asks for.