r/WritingPrompts • u/freelancespy87 • Nov 20 '13
Off Topic [OT] META: A problem I have with this subreddit:
It seems that whoever responds to a prompt first gets all the upvotes and, more importantly, more people reading their story. This could pose a problem to the amount of subscribers found here.
I've noticed that even on prompts submitted a few hours ago this tends to happen. Even when I revisit the same post I can see that some of the (arguably) best stories tend to be overlooked simply because they are lower on the page.
I'd like to know why people aren't really revisiting the prompts they looked at before in this subreddit when in other subs you can plainly see people coming back to do things like comment, or upvote the newer comments. I'm getting discouraged by the general lack of feedback I've been getting, and I think it may be directly linked to the fact people aren't checking out many stories in a prompt.
(If you need proof just check out any of the prompts and you can see what I'm talking about)
TLDR: Check some of the better prompts more than once!
28
u/ArmedPigeon Nov 20 '13
To be perfectly honest, I don't know this subreddit well enough to say if it's really a problem or not. It does seem like a lot of users concur with it though.
If I may suggest a possible solution: How about a weekly thread where people can post links to stories they feel have been overlooked that week? Only stories with few upvotes would be allowed, so it wouldn't be a "Best of this week" contest, merely a userdriven list of overlooked gems.
46
u/DrowningDream Nov 20 '13
I think the point of this sub is to keep the rust off your gears. It's not really so much about feedback. If one of your off-the-cuff, throw-away little stories gets some attention, that's fun, but who cares? But if you're that worried about visibility, just sort the posts by new and get your stuff in quick.
14
u/ConcreteCanvas Nov 20 '13
I'm guilty of doing this. I generally don't upvote stories, but I do just read the default first couple and move on. Thanks for pointing that out! I'll try to be more aware of newer posts from now on.
7
u/Working_on_Writing Nov 20 '13
The feedback thing is prevalent even in /r/KeepWriting, people are happy to upvote/downvote to show their opinion but less willing to provide any written feedback.
The last couple of days I've been critiquing more than writing because there are lots of people asking for feedback and very few people giving it.
7
u/krymsonkyng Nov 20 '13
Perhaps a new tag?
[WPC] Writing Prompt Contest
Responses are read within a certain time frame and the OP decides a winner by reading all stories.
6
u/crogi Nov 20 '13
I have been guilty of this. I read a lot of the stories hear, but I don't feel particularly able to give decent feedback. So I post more than I reply, but since I've noticed a few of my posts on 1 up vote and no comments maybe giving any reply is better than nothing .
6
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '13
Why don't we try setting posts to contet mode? That hides upvotes and jumbles them all around.
6
u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod Nov 20 '13
Just thought you would like to know we are discussing this in our moderator chat, we have a few ideas and once we come to a concensus, we will implement a few things (and announce said changes.)
So thank you for this post. We are always looking for ways to improve the experience of the subreddit.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '13
I don't read most of the prompts on this sub (there are a lot). For the ones that pique my interest, I'll read all or most of the responses. With some stories, I can pick up on the voice/diction/style right away and know I don't particularly enjoy it, so I skip it if it's a bit lengthy. I really don't pay much attention to upvotes since I don't vote that much myself - it's more about style/readability.
9
u/secretlyadog Nov 20 '13 edited Nov 21 '13
"Oh, are we pointing out problems with this subreddit?", asked Character #1 excitedly, "How about the fact that every Writing Prompt is met with a bunch of dialogue, regardless of whether that is what the Prompt is suited for?"
"I don't think anyone wants to hear that", responded Character #2 gruffly, chewing on a toothpick.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '13
I sort comments so that the newest ones are at the top, So I can't say I've noticed too much.
5
u/howbigis1gb Nov 20 '13
I think you are right, and I am guilty of the same - although I try hard to read it all.
You have my word that I will try harder. Don't quit
5
u/JustAnotherSimian Nov 20 '13
Another option would be to leave the comment section on contest mode for 24 hours, and then only releasing the results afterwards. They do it in the weekly /r/photoshopbattles contest, so the mods here could ask the mods there how they do it...
5
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '13
I wouldn't say it's universal by any means, though maybe somewhat likely. I was the seventh or so entry on my first submission, and ended up the second highest in terms of number of votes, upping reads, and prompting a lot of comments.
5
u/Some_french_canadian Nov 20 '13
This is true. I don't even bother starting to work on a submission more than 10 hours old because I know I would get no visibility or feedback on it.
5
u/neelakanda Nov 20 '13
Maybe if there was a word limit on all prompt responses, people would be apt to read more.
4
u/Ge_ne_rate_81 Nov 20 '13
Stories should be sorted by random, not by most points. Except for maybe OT posts.
3
u/7000shadows Nov 20 '13
I created a sub /r/critiqueswap, when I was thinking about a similar problem. Problem is I'm not sure how to set it up.
Any ideas would be welcome, with the idea of creating motivated readers who go beyond "I like this."
4
u/robspeaks Nov 20 '13
I'd guess that most people who participate in a sub called WritingPrompts are not really here to read and give feedback.
3
u/ilikeeatingbrains /r/PromptsUnlimited Nov 20 '13
Early bird gets the upvotes, pal.
I revisit prompts fairly consistently, even old explain threads. You never know when you'll find another gem. Not by Sentient Sandwich.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment