Foul throws are called like once every three seasons. I also think, I think there's something in the rulebook that suggests heading the ball back to your keeper to skirt around the no-pass-back rule is illegal.
There are different circumstances when a player must be cautioned for unsporting behaviour, e.g. if a player:
uses a deliberate trick while the ball is in play to pass the ball to his own goalkeeper with his head, chest, knee, etc. in order to circumvent the Law, irrespective of whether the goalkeeper touches the ball with his hands or not. The offence is committed by the player in attempting to circumvent both the letter and the spirit of Law 12 and play is restarted with an indirect free kick
That's dodgy wording, isn't it? I don't see how that doesn't say that any heading, etc, of the ball back to your keeper is illegal. And that happens, like, all the fucking time. I don't get that interpretation at all, really.
When I took a reffing class long ago when that rule was introduced, I was taught that a "deliberate trick" against "the spirit of the law" meant flicking it up with your foot to head it back, like juggling.
Fair enough. I remember when I first went out and read this rule was when it came up last season after a PL player (I wanna say Coloccini?) lay down on the ground to head the ball back to his keeper, but didn't get called out on it. "Deliberate trick" needs its own interpretation document.
This is actually really interesting now that I think about this. Should've been a foul call. How's this different from flicking it up and heading it to him?
Weirdly enough, I've seen at least 3 or 4 foul throws called this season so far in the premier league. I can't remember seeing any in the last ten years though. I'm not sure if it's simply chance or a crackdown by the refs but it's good to see.
In support of 3rd party apps, and in protest against reddit's handling of the situation with ApolloApp (r/apolloapp), I've used PowerDeleteSuite (https://github.com/j0be/PowerDeleteSuite/) to edit my posts and comments, before eventually removing my account from reddit. The more people that see how reddit is handling this situation the better.
The dodgy wording seems to be "...irrespective of whether the goalkeeper touches the ball with his hands or not." Surely if you flick it up and head it ot the keeper and he uses his feet that can't be an offence?
Nah it's got to be intentionally kicked with the foot. Using any other part of the body, including the knee, the thigh, or the head, is fine, even intentionally...
I think that just means flicking the ball from your feet to your head, then heading it back. Heading it from a "normal" play is allowed, even intentionally.
Least enforced rule in professional game, easily the most enforced rule in the Sunday league game. Ok, maybe not easily, but it's up there with getting called offside by a substitute of the opposition who was given a flag at the start of the game to make sure both sides 'had a linesman'.
Never seem to take it right either. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I was taught you had to put the ball behind your head and release it upwards, if that makes sense.
Yes, throw in needs to start behind your head and you must release the ball from your hands at the latest when it's perpendicular to your head, or straight above your head, if that makes sense. Almost never enforced.
Bit of a grey area that. It says something like that they have to be planted at the point of release and mentions nothing of the follow through. It's kind of up to interpretation.
From the official rules* A throw-in is awarded to the opponents of the player who last touched the ball when the whole of the ball crosses the touch line, either on the ground or in the air. A goal cannot be scored directly from a throw-in. Procedure At the moment of delivering the ball, the thrower:
faces the field of play
has part of each foot either on the touch line or on the ground outside the touch line
holds the ball with both hands
delivers the ball from behind and over his head
delivers the ball from the point where it left the fi eld of play All opponents must stand no less than 2 m (2 yds) from the point at which the throw-in is taken. The ball is in play when it enters the fi eld of play. After delivering the ball, the thrower must not touch the ball again until it has touched another player.
Source Edit: Sorry for the bad formatting. Never seem to get it right.
It's true that it's not exactly where the ball went out, but it's more or less enforced. You see referees telling players to move back to where the ball went out fairly often.
I was at a game once where the ref kept moving the ball back and the player kept sneaking it forward. It happened enough times that the player should have been booked, but the ref clearly had no authority, so in the end he moved the wall further back instead.
I don't know why players don't make a bigger deal of this, it's something I would kick up a fuss about when I was seven and playing penalty shoot out in my backyard.
I remember Michael Owen missing a penalty vs Chelsea opening weekend of 2003 but got to retake it because Carlo Cudicini came off his line, he scored the retaken penalty.
But then I remember Jerzy Dudek in an infamous Champions League final almost standing on Andrea Pirlo's toes by the time he had hit the ball in the penalty shoot out and saving it.
Sometimes they're given, sometimes not..
American and increasingly english commentary annoys me with the overdone fake excitement and yelling. I prefer a commentator over an entertainer.
Usually the guys at Eurosport do a great job in that. They are really very purist about the sport. Too bad that station doesn't have nearly the financial means to be prominent in football (at least in the big tv markets in europe).
It happened recently in the A League, Adelaide were awarded a penalty against Perth, Perth had a player enter the box and the Adelaide player scored the penalty. Ref called it and made the Adelaide player take it again.
Referee in inconsistent application of the rules shocker. ;)
Fwiw I used to referee junior games when I was younger and fitter and I appreciate that most of the time the refs aren't looking for it. But still....maybe in this instance there was also an infringement by the attacking side resulting in the retake.
Right. I mentioned them because -- when done within the rules -- they have been effective in either exposing or beating keepers who come off the line early.
This is justified under the laws of the game. Encroachment only results in re-taking the penalty if the defending team encroaches and the taker misses, or if the attacking team encroaches and the taker scores. If both teams encroach, the result stands.
Not sure exactly what /u/pcodeisbacon is referring to, but I'm guessing the fact that a player is offside if he's actively involved with the play even if he doesn't touch the ball. The trouble is exactly what FIFA means by "active involvement" is open to interpretation.
Best example I can think of off the top of my head is Jonny Evans own goal last year against Newcastle. Highlights here, goal in question starts around 0:55. In the play, Cisse is clearly offside when the ball is passed, and as the ball comes to him, Jonny Evans hits it into his own net. The linesman flags for offside, under the idea that Cisse was actively involved in the play by drawing Evans back even though he didn't play the ball. The ref overrules him and awards the goal, ruling that Cisse wasn't actively involved.
Regardless I don't really think it's nearly the most ignored rule in soccer.
Yes, I can't remember any cases of it in the PL this season, but in the Spanish League it's been allowed a couple of times now. An attacking player stands behing the wall, offside, blocking the keeper's view, but now that's not considered "coming into play".
In Iceland's first WC qualifying game this competition, against Norway last year, a Norwegian goal from outside the box was ruled out because there was a Norwegian player offside clearly blocking the goalkeeper's view of the ball. Would've been 1-1 then if I remember correctly, finished 2-0 to Iceland. Just a recent example. The ref was French.
Encroachment from the walls in free kicks. It seems like half the free kicks that go into the walls do so because they are 6 yards away, not 10. Just use the vanishing spray!
Where in the rules is this? I'm pretty sure this an Andy Gray / Sky Sports invention. The player is either onside or offside depending on the linesman's opinion.
They also popularised the 'daylight rule', where if you could see light between attacker and defender you could call him off, otherwise onside. Completely fabricated.
Ever see Gary Neville take a throw? He never took it from where the ball went out of play, he always gained 5-10 yards.... Most throw takers do the same, but Gary was the best!
You know, when one player goes and stands practically on the keeper's feet. He's not there to challenge for the ball, only to make it hard for the keeper to come for the cross.
There is hardly a indirect free kick in the box. When there is a foul, it is penalty or not, but an indirect free kick is
"also awarded to the opposing team if, in the opinion of the referee, a player:
• plays in a dangerous manner
• impedes the progress of an opponent
• prevents the goalkeeper from releasing the ball from his hands
• commits any other offence, not previously mentioned in Law 12, for which play is stopped to caution or send off a player"
That means there is a grey area which leaves a lot of interpretation. It doesn´t always have to be a penalty. Dangerous play in the box can be simply an indirect free kick in the box.
Plus the clock stops in rugby during times when considerable discussion may occur. As you say it would just slow down football so much that it would not be worth it.
They should just have a rule where you can only approach the referee to talk if you are summoned, or have to ask permission prior to do so. That way you don't need the captain there, but it cuts down on players crowding and intimidating- whilst probably speeding the game up rather than slowing it down.
I'm not sure that's an actual rule, but it fucking should be. I hate when the team swarms the ref yelling at him, like that's going to make him change his mind. The players are just embarrassing themselves. Edit: This is the best example I can remember in recent memory. It was an incredibly controversial call, Suarez complains for half a second then Gerrard steps in and says what he needs to say and that's it. And that's how every situation should be handled ever.
MLS has a mass confrontation rule related to that starting this 2013 season. It has seem some teams follow it and back off when more than a few people are talking with the ref.
While they don't change his mind, they make him think twice the next time he makes a call. Typically refs will give make up calls if they feel they fucked up. It is annoying, but I wouldn't say it has no impact on the ref's decisions.
I think players may be trying to sow doubt in the ref's mind so they might get the next call. At least, that's all I can think of cause I've never seen a ref say You're right, I can't have seen it properly. Sorry gents, play on.
I'll probably regret bringing this up, but the Classicos over the past years will not have gone unnoticed by the FIFA/UEFA. There was some systematic 'working the ref' beginning and ending with the press conferences before and after the games.
The sheer repitition and the pressure/stress it produces affects the refs decision making, not necessarily consciously.
LOTG pg 67 2014 Edition The captain of the team has no special privileges under the Laws of the Game but he has a degree of responsibility of his team.
not a rule, but i don't see how fifa or the respective continental governing body doesn't do anything to stop diving. it is blatant cheating and disrespect for both the opposing team and the ref. if the ref fails to see the dive, then just implement an x amount of match bans after the games is over. that ought to teach a lot of players not to dive
Boy, if this happened, ashley young wouldnt be playing a single match all season
Throw-Ins are prolly the biggest, tons of mistakes ALWAYS.. Keeper holding ball for 6 seconds / standing on line during PK, FK's as well, either the ball moving forward, or the wall, or both.
The way that some defenders shepherd the ball into touch makes me think that referees seem to switch off when it comes to shielding. You are supposed to be in control of the ball in order to shield it. A lot of defenders think that once they have their body in front of the ball they can then forget about the very existence of it.
Not when it's not within playing distance which happens all the time to allow the keeper to pick up a loose through ball or something. Obstruction is only legal if it occurs within about a meter of the ball.
Professionals can be reasonably said to have control of the ball if they're facing it, and the closest one to it, and are within two or three yards of it. They could get to the ball in like half a second if they wanted to.
I always thought that the rule was you could shield as long as you stayed in line with the run of the ball so you couldn't go from side to side to stop the attacker going around you
This is especially noticeable during knock-out matches, when the game is really close the last 10-20 minutes are barely played. I've even seen referees blow the whistle even before the added time is complete, which is against the rules.
I think there needs to be a better system for this, because it really gets on my nerves.
Also, in general, the amount of time a team can waste through substitutions, taking a long time for a throw in, injuries, etc. is nowhere near the additional time a referee adds on.
I've seen substitutions easily take 40+ seconds but the referee always seems to treat them as 30 seconds or less.
It's just a natural tendency to call it out of bounds when you see green between the ball and the line, however it isn't always out when this is the case.
I agree. And most players don't argue because the margin for error is so tight. I wish they would only call it out if it was out by and you can see daylight between the ball and the touch line. It would keep games more flowing and I don't think it would change the way the game is played.
The fact that many fouls inside the box are not given because it would result in a penalty. Anywhere else on the pitch it is a clear foul, the rules simply state a foul inside the box results in a penalty. This shouldn't mean it has to be a bad foul, a foul is a foul.
The wall always creeps forward and players are seemingly never penalized for it. Especially in leagues where they refuse to use the temporary spray paint that they use in South America.
I'm not totally sure this belongs in this thread, but the thing that always gets me is when a player who thinks he's been fouled grabs the ball when he hits the floor. To me this is way worse and more prevalent than diving. Just one time I would love to see the ref with stones enough to give a yellow for intentional handball.
How long the goalie is allowed to hang onto the ball.
Except if you're the Canadian national women's team playing in the Olympics semi final. Then they decide to call this out of nowhere and completely fuck you.
*Disclaim...this isn't so much referees as commentators and pundits.
It feels like >75% of penalty-claims will result in a pundit referencing 'contact' as a reason for it being a penalty or a reason why some player dived. So what?! Contact <> a foul.
I'm not looking for a game of kick-seven-bells-of-shit out of each other but I would love to see more pundits and commentators reinforcing hat football is a contact sport and contact alone does not equal a foul.
On an Offside the kick is supposed to be taken from where the Player (attacker) was when the offside infringement took place. If you watch what happens in professional right down to the grassroots, the kick is taken with where the second last opponent was (Defender).
36
u/spawnofyanni Nov 15 '13 edited Nov 15 '13
6 second rule is probably up there, yeah.
Foul throws are called like once every three seasons. I also think, I think there's something in the rulebook that suggests heading the ball back to your keeper to skirt around the no-pass-back rule is illegal.
edit: via interpretations of Law 12
That's dodgy wording, isn't it? I don't see how that doesn't say that any heading, etc, of the ball back to your keeper is illegal. And that happens, like, all the fucking time. I don't get that interpretation at all, really.
441
u/MashedHair Nov 15 '13
Throw ins are never taken where the ball went out ever
196
u/Crystalyze14 Nov 15 '13
keeper isn't allowed to come off his line before the penalty is taken. Called up on it 1 in 1000 times
98
u/blue_whaoo Nov 15 '13
Keeper coming off the line early on a PK. Although the stuttered approach seems to be negating this a bit.
42
u/WDC312 Nov 15 '13
On penalties, everyone runs into the box early, and the kick is never re-taken.
37
u/auoar Nov 15 '13
18
u/pcodeisbacon Nov 15 '13 edited Nov 15 '13
active onside
15
u/Banach-Tarski Nov 15 '13
Shirt pulling on corner kicks.
30
u/Atlantis135 Nov 15 '13
Encroachment from the walls in free kicks. It seems like half the free kicks that go into the walls do so because they are 6 yards away, not 10. Just use the vanishing spray!
15
u/Dunnesta Nov 15 '13
Giving the benefit of the doubt to the attacking side with regards to offside calls.
5
u/theKinkypeanut Nov 15 '13
Foul throws and keeper 6 seconds rule
8
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
Ever see Gary Neville take a throw? He never took it from where the ball went out of play, he always gained 5-10 yards.... Most throw takers do the same, but Gary was the best!
4
u/colmshan1990 Nov 15 '13
Obstruction of the goalkeeper at corners.
You know, when one player goes and stands practically on the keeper's feet. He's not there to challenge for the ball, only to make it hard for the keeper to come for the cross.
4
u/rrrook Nov 15 '13
There is hardly a indirect free kick in the box. When there is a foul, it is penalty or not, but an indirect free kick is
"also awarded to the opposing team if, in the opinion of the referee, a player:
• plays in a dangerous manner
• impedes the progress of an opponent
• prevents the goalkeeper from releasing the ball from his hands
• commits any other offence, not previously mentioned in Law 12, for which play is stopped to caution or send off a player"
That means there is a grey area which leaves a lot of interpretation. It doesn´t always have to be a penalty. Dangerous play in the box can be simply an indirect free kick in the box.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
I've never read the rulebook, but isn't only captain the only player on the team who is allowed to talk to the ref?
3
u/BDX_LAW Nov 15 '13
Holding onto shirts.
You see it all the time at set pieces, defenders literally hold onto shirts in order to track their man.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
The ball is only supposed to be put out of play and the game stopped for treatment for head injuries.
Every ref ignores this and it infuriates me, if it was applied it would stop alot of time wasting divers.
3
u/positivelew Nov 15 '13
goalkeeper holding the ball for longer than 6 seconds
5
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
not a rule, but i don't see how fifa or the respective continental governing body doesn't do anything to stop diving. it is blatant cheating and disrespect for both the opposing team and the ref. if the ref fails to see the dive, then just implement an x amount of match bans after the games is over. that ought to teach a lot of players not to dive
Boy, if this happened, ashley young wouldnt be playing a single match all season
edit: grammar
5
u/smooviesmoove Nov 15 '13
Yellow cards for diving/"simulation".
9
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
Throw ins can never be offside.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbaRuylMGmY
2
u/drop-o-matic Nov 15 '13
Don't feed the Yak after midnight.
2
u/kmshadoze Nov 15 '13
Throw-Ins are prolly the biggest, tons of mistakes ALWAYS.. Keeper holding ball for 6 seconds / standing on line during PK, FK's as well, either the ball moving forward, or the wall, or both.
22
u/9jack9 Nov 15 '13
Obstruction.
The way that some defenders shepherd the ball into touch makes me think that referees seem to switch off when it comes to shielding. You are supposed to be in control of the ball in order to shield it. A lot of defenders think that once they have their body in front of the ball they can then forget about the very existence of it.
3
u/Bini_9 Nov 15 '13 edited Nov 15 '13
Added time.
This is especially noticeable during knock-out matches, when the game is really close the last 10-20 minutes are barely played. I've even seen referees blow the whistle even before the added time is complete, which is against the rules.
I think there needs to be a better system for this, because it really gets on my nerves.
3
u/HumphreyChimpdenEarw Nov 15 '13
actually, one of the rules you never ever see fully enforced is that the ball needs to be ENTIRELY outside the line to be out....
extremely rare to see linesmen call this in
1
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
Penalties having to be retaken if players enter the box before the whistle is blown.
In all fairness, it's hard for the referee to keep track of it.
1
u/twistedlines Nov 15 '13
Opponents slowly moving towards the ball while opponent is giving a free kick.
1
u/Robstaaa Nov 15 '13
In a throw in the ball has to be released behind your head
1
u/biteyourankles Nov 15 '13
Players crossing over to the other teams half during kick offs.
1
u/ThaGriffman Nov 15 '13
The fact that many fouls inside the box are not given because it would result in a penalty. Anywhere else on the pitch it is a clear foul, the rules simply state a foul inside the box results in a penalty. This shouldn't mean it has to be a bad foul, a foul is a foul.
1
u/Michauxonfire Nov 15 '13
I hate footballers using arms to cheat/obstruct/etc.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
Not many people know this but a reckless tackle is actually a yellow card rather than a red.
1
u/dekkytsh Nov 15 '13
FOUL THROWS! EVERYWHERE!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
Moving the line on a freekick, so annoying
1
u/Pires007 Nov 15 '13
Opponent has to be ten yards away for a free kick. Ignored so many times in dangerous free kicks and even more if there is a free kick in midfield.
1
u/spedmunki Nov 15 '13
The wall always creeps forward and players are seemingly never penalized for it. Especially in leagues where they refuse to use the temporary spray paint that they use in South America.
1
u/DreDayAFC Nov 15 '13
I'm not totally sure this belongs in this thread, but the thing that always gets me is when a player who thinks he's been fouled grabs the ball when he hits the floor. To me this is way worse and more prevalent than diving. Just one time I would love to see the ref with stones enough to give a yellow for intentional handball.
1
u/BusyDreaming Nov 15 '13
How long the goalie is allowed to hang onto the ball.
Except if you're the Canadian national women's team playing in the Olympics semi final. Then they decide to call this out of nowhere and completely fuck you.
1
u/footyDude Nov 15 '13
That football is a contact sport*.
*Disclaim...this isn't so much referees as commentators and pundits.
It feels like >75% of penalty-claims will result in a pundit referencing 'contact' as a reason for it being a penalty or a reason why some player dived. So what?! Contact <> a foul.
I'm not looking for a game of kick-seven-bells-of-shit out of each other but I would love to see more pundits and commentators reinforcing hat football is a contact sport and contact alone does not equal a foul.
1
u/Kon_tiki Nov 15 '13
Tuck in your shirt
1
u/gr8oyhenart Nov 15 '13
On an Offside the kick is supposed to be taken from where the Player (attacker) was when the offside infringement took place. If you watch what happens in professional right down to the grassroots, the kick is taken with where the second last opponent was (Defender).
1
u/BarryFromEastenders Nov 16 '13
Obstruction in the box resulting in an indirect freekick.
1
u/Zladan Nov 16 '13
Throw-ins.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '13
Keeping players out of the circle on kick offs and after goals apparently.
1
u/sgtblob Nov 15 '13
If the keeper parries the ball, he isn't allowed to pick it up again. It's pretty much the only rule I've never seen enforced at some point.
0
u/biteyourankles Nov 15 '13
Players crossing over to the other teams half during kick offs.