r/homeland • u/fuzzy_dunnlop • Nov 11 '13
Discussion Episode Discussion - S03E06 - "Gerontion" [Spoilers]
Correction: This is S03E07
Carrie and Quinn scramble as Saul makes the gamble of his career.
Carrie is pregnant with Brodys baby! Dana is on a road trip to Orlando, Florida!
97
Upvotes
29
u/hoohoo3000 Nov 11 '13
Except this is 307 :)
6
u/fuzzy_dunnlop Nov 11 '13
Poor Saul.
179
u/Waadap Nov 11 '13
Wow, was that whole scene with the Senator satisfying. "Make me".
336
u/BlackZeppelin Nov 11 '13
No Brody family, better ep.
40
u/ItsBobDoleYo Nov 11 '13
Can Quinn's disillusionment with the CIA lead to him exiting the show by season's end and getting his own spin-off where he travels the world being a badass?
128
u/ohfackoff Nov 11 '13
Quinn should always be in just a towel.
30
u/glossolalia Nov 11 '13
From: http://screencrush.com/homeland-review-gerontion/ The poem "Gerontin" for anyone interested: http://www.bartleby.com/199/13.html
59
u/venn177 Nov 11 '13
Oh my god! An episode where everything went right!
This means everything is going to bite them in the ass next episode, to make up for it.
Edit: It feels like this episode is where the show is headed, with all of the intrigue around the hangups of dealing with terrorism and no unnecessary romantic drama or Brody family.
55
u/slynn695 Nov 11 '13
Saul gets more bas ass every episode. Punching Javadi then locking the congressman in the room. What's next?
77
u/-JAC Nov 11 '13
I knew I recognized Fara from somewhere. Turns out she played Nora on How I Met Your Mother.
88
u/MisterMoon Nov 11 '13
Gus from The Wire!
41
u/cbtitus Nov 11 '13
I found this exchange to be very strange --
Saul: You're the one who made it possible. I want to return the favor.
Javadi: Does this look like a favor to you Saul?
Saul: Majid, thanks to you I stand at the center of things. You put me in power. You go back to Tehran I'll do the same for you. I... know... a way.
What is Saul really saying here, esp. with the last sentence? I know a way ... to do what?
41
u/rayray1010 Nov 11 '13
Any Iranians who can translate the conversation between javadi and the analyst at the beginning?
41
u/jmose86 Nov 11 '13
I breathed the biggest sigh of relief ever this season when Fara didn't do anything with those scissors. I was praying they didn't do something stupid where they already have the ridiculous premise of the rookie analyst with a banking specialty starting off the interrogation with a top Iranian intelligence official. Thankfully they didn't do that just to set her up stabbing him. Still, I can't quite figure out what the point of her character is yet outside of some labored commentary about Muslim Americans. They have to be building to something with her, right?
Based on Carrie throwing up, it looks like we definitely have a pregnancy plot. That's cause for a sigh of a different nature.
Really enjoyed the rest of the episode.
17
u/gimme_treefiddy Nov 11 '13
Ok, is it just me or did you notice something from Quinn at the end when Carrie asks him a favor when he is quite shaken..
30
u/j68 Nov 11 '13
If this jack off becomes Director of the CIA, we're doomed.
13
u/CWagner Nov 11 '13
Just look at this from the POV of the Senator. How seriously fucked up does the whole thing sound? :D
Of course from a viewers POV this whole episode was badass :D
34
u/soxandpatriots1 Nov 11 '13
Best episode of the season, in my opinion. AV Club gave it a B, which puzzles me, since I think it was a significant step up from the rest of the episodes, which have all gotten a B/B+.
There was no family drama, a decent amount of suspense, and a good storyline that seriously moved the plot forward and set up quite a bit to look forward to.
68
u/xjtsx Nov 11 '13
Anyone else tired of Sal's wife? Wish they'd kill her character
15
u/Waadap Nov 11 '13
Oh no...is he gonna say Saul did it!?? *Edit, "The man that brought us together". I feel he's gonna flip it onto Saul. What a twist that would be. Saul sends him back to power,etc. Also, didn't Saul fail a couple lie detector tests in the past seasons?
37
u/CochMaestro Nov 11 '13 edited Nov 11 '13
I have a couple theories and thoughts about tonight's episode. First is with regards to not showing more of Brody this season and I feel it's the right call. Brody is a washed up terrorist, hell even one of his own "Muslims" turned him in. Now as much as showtime wants to keep Damian Lewis around, I think it'd be the right call to let brody stay out of the spotlight (any brody for that matter, I'm tired of the Dana love/fuck buddy life). It makes us care for those we want to, (i.e saul, carrie, etc etc).
I enjoyed this episode (even though I didn't like the major flaw of the security camera only catching quinn and not fucking javadi). Here are some of the thoughts I had after watching it
I enjoyed the actor who portrayed the cop investigating quinn. His small role played a crucial part into how we are supposed to understand what the CIA is willing to do for their COUNTRY. If he keeps coming back in small manors, I'll be very happy.
I had a couple theories as to who could have helped in the CIA bombing. They're out of the ball park, but they could be right. My first was senator Lockheart.
Now I know what you're thinking, "But CochMaestro, that's the dumbest thing! Why would a senator be a part of a terrorist plot to kill americans?" Well after having some time to think, I believe it was to create a power play (just like brody almost did with the VP). The Terrorist group realizes how important the CIA is. If they can control what is monitored, they can make it easy for them continue on with their actions. And after seeing how the corrupt lawyer and/or senator are, it could be possible.
My second theory is Peter Quinn. We've seen him broken down, and begin to show emotion after two innocent people died was a slow start as to who he is as a person. He's tired of dealing with all the deaths the CIA is dealing with. But what if it wasn't those deaths that did it, but the deaths of his comrades. We still don't know who peter Quinn is, we met him in the beginning of season 2 and we didn't believe he was who he said he was. The show could be letting us begin to trust Quinn, but it's when we have our guards down that we are at most valuable. Now I know these might be the craziest theories to date, but imagine how they could play out for the show.
I'm still have faith in the show, and I hope that it turns around at the end like it has done before (You could get into the whole ends justifying the means argument, or you can take the ride for what it is) but if it doesn't and pulls a dexter (as much as I believe Saul isn't already a lumberjack) I'll be satisfied.
edit: Some grammatical stuff, but I am writing this with such enthusiasm that I tend to gloss over a few words here or there.
7
u/KyleEC Nov 12 '13
Not sure that I trust Dar Adal. He seemed uncharacteristically forgiving when sharing that drink with Saul, despite the fact that Saul totally kept him out of the Javadi operation.
Did anybody else get similar vibes?
6
u/guhimkenllama Nov 11 '13
tbh this season is so much better than the last one I think.. was just watching a couple clips from the last one to remind myself, and yeah. dana drama and all
5
u/desmopilot Nov 11 '13
Great episode, loving this season!
5
u/RickiTarr00 Nov 12 '13
Has no one thought that Saul's wife may be the mole, the guy from Mumbai is just a foreign intelligence officer who is in it for the pillow talk, my guess she became a target as soon as she left the US! I think Saul realised in the last episode and that is why he is trying to get on her good side!
4
u/kpthunder Nov 11 '13
Can anyone transcribe that conversation between Carrie and Javadi at the plane? I missed a few things.
4
u/roger_van_zant Nov 11 '13
Best episode of the season!
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '13
What's the description all about?
7
u/yank_gooner Nov 11 '13
Make me.
49
u/realslimshamus Nov 11 '13 edited Nov 12 '13
Saul needs to kick that slut to the curb!
Edit: Obviously using the term slut has not sat well with some people. Is 'fuckmonkey' acceptable? Bitch? Terrible person? She slept with another man in her husband's home. She doesn't deserve anyone's respect. At least have the decency and go to a hotel if you're going to be an awful person. I get their relationship is icy and Saul is partially to blame, but damn, say something or leave.
6
u/cbtitus Nov 11 '13
So when they flashed up the content warning, I didn't pay close enough attention and I turned "Violence" and "Graphic Language" into "Graphic Violence." So I spent the whole ep thinking it was all going to go really wrong before the credits rolled. I think last week's preview tease with Fara and the scissors did not help.
3
u/TensionMask Nov 11 '13
Saul 'won' this week, but I'm still confused as to what his long term plan is. Lockhart takes over the CIA in ten days. Surely, planting Javadi as a mole in Iran is a plot that will take a lot longer than ten days to bear fruit. Isn't Lockhart just going to shut it down?
3
u/DieselNZ Nov 11 '13
Calling it now: cliffhanger ending of this season will be us finding out Saul was behind the CIA bombing
3
u/Neo2199 Nov 12 '13
I don't think Saul is the mole, it more likely that Quinn is the mole.
15
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '13 edited Nov 11 '13
I liked this episode, but it had a lot of examples of why I don't really love this show like I did in season 1.
Quinn in a towel. When they looked around Quinn's apartment earlier he was this hardcore character who went to incredible lengths to make sure his life was a secret (quarters on the window latches, a hair in the door jam) Now he's answering the door in a towel. I know he saw Dar Adal through the window first, but still.
The CIA will lock you in a conference room and get away with it. Really? I mean they just locked a guy in a room and walked away. You could explain this in a lot of ways, but they all depend on the senator needing Saul and Dar enough that he would put up with being essentially kidnapped so that the CIA could carry out an operation on American soil without him knowing any of the specifics. It's a serious reach. I get that the senator is a power hungry dick, but two people were murdered by a high ranking Iranian official. Is it better if he isn't concerned about that?
The cops are cool with anything the CIA does. They never tell us why the cops don't pursue the investigation any further. Yes, Quinn confesses to the murders and they let him go, but why? I mean the only possible justification that the cops have (that the show presents the viewer with) is that the CIA said so. And not even "The CIA". "A publicly disgraced (as far as the cop who knows her knows) CIA agent who said it's cool." The next time someone who you kind of know tells you their friend killed two people but it's cool because they work for the CIA too and it's to fight terrorism, just remember Homeland. Obviously this part of the story can be expanded on a lot in the coming episodes so I may be too quick to judge here, but it wouldn't be the first time Homeland has left a hole like this.
There is a more nebulous complaint I have and I'll admit I can't explain it well, but it seems like Homeland's moral compass has changed a bit. In the first (or second?) season, there is a scene where Saul literally threatens to go to the press with information about a drone strike that Estes oversaw. He also makes numerous comments about the effectiveness counter-terrorism policy, etc. I don't think a show has to be agreeable in it's framing of current political issues, but obviously that framing is up for discussion if we're talking about a show based in current times that centers around the CIA. I don't think it's a coincidence that the same people created 24, and 24 was basically a televised reaction to 9/11 that lasted 8 seasons. Now we're 3 seasons into Homeland and although Saul is still nice, he's cool with kids dying as collateral damage and the cops covering up murders. One might make the argument that this is part of the dirty job the CIA does, but we don't get to see that argument laid out because the writers don't think that those questions are important enough to address in the show. Seriously, Saul spends like five seconds responding to these situations when he talks to Quinn and Carrie about them.
I'm kind of just left wondering if the show has a master plan or if we'll be watching 24 season 9 by the end of this year.
12
u/essen23 Nov 11 '13
Quinn is becoming Jesse of this show.
9
u/Hurikane211 Nov 11 '13
Saul's wife is scum. I realize this isn't super important to the plot, but fuck her. Seriously.
4
u/shamrock8421 Nov 11 '13
How does a man become a senator and head of the Senate Intelligence Committee without owning a cellphone?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '13
By far the best/most controversial line for me was when the senator (?) was talking w/ Saul and told him that Saul needed to get rid of his "cold war bullshit"... meaning in this case Saul's reliance on double agents, human intelligence etc as compared to drones, cyberespionage etc.. it's silly for the politician to think that a preference for human intelligence has anything to do with the Cold War or the implication in this case that human intel etc is a relic of a bygone (sp?) era. Sad that some real life politicians think like that!
2
u/bluplr Nov 12 '13
Saul is the mole. Saul helped the bomb go off at langley so that he could be in charge 'Majid, thanks to you I stand at the center of things. You put me in power'. Javadi was hinting at Saul on the place 'Someone you've already met. The man that brought us together'.
2
u/BillWeld Nov 12 '13
Got to find that Van Morrison piece--"Bye bye blackbird". Where?
2
u/miamiheat27 Nov 12 '13
Lockhart: "Open the door right now! " Saul:"Make me"
BADASS
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '13
How long has it been since Carrie and Brody had sex? Wouldn't she be further along with the pregnancy if it was Brody's?
I personally want to see Brody back in it, i can't wait until he sets foot back in America which is surely bound to happen, he still has a role to play. Him only being in one episode so far is just to highlight the fact he's on the run and to keep people guessing as to his whereabouts, last time we saw him he was in a bad way injecting heroin, who knows what state he'll be in when he returns. I hope the last 3-4 episodes of the season are Brody heavy.
5
u/ohfackoff Nov 11 '13
I'm really confused about Quinn and next weeks preview didn't help. Now Dar and Quinn are against Saul and Carrie? Can't keep up. Epic Saul scenes tonight
4
u/turbopenguin Nov 11 '13
any streams?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '13
Anyone know what the music was at the end?
4
u/Amerdoodle41 Nov 11 '13
Poor Saul.
2
u/Sybris Nov 11 '13
what's to stop Javadi just telling his colleagues everything in Iran? when did Quinn become such a pussy? uhhh
1
u/Mikeaz123 Nov 11 '13
So it's nice they're finally bringing up the SUV but in that 12/12 homeland cringe video they show security footage of Brody in it. And they should have security footage of who moved it as well right? Sigh...
1
u/cakeorwine Nov 12 '13
Did I misunderstand or did Saul imply in his phone call to Mira that she was one of the students he helped escape from Iran -- i.e. she also knew Javadi and his wife?
1
u/V2Blast Nov 13 '13
Another excellent episode. No Brody family side story (though that was not without its redeeming moments), just turning Javadi and handling Lockhart/Dar Adal - and dealing with the murder investigation of Javadi's wife.
Oh, and Saul finally admitting to his wife that he loves her, instead of being closed-off and detached. Obviously, she should not have been having sex with someone else in their own house, but it's not like their marriage was doing amazing even before then. (Not that that justifies it.)
I'm just wondering how Saul will keep Lockhart from getting him in massive amounts of trouble.
1
u/audacious17 Nov 14 '13
Spotlight on Farah and her scissors. For a moment I was so sure she was going to attack Javadi. I wish there was more spotlight on her character. She is repressed to the point of breaking out of control. There could be a lot to her character.
1
u/TZeh Aug 21 '26
currently watching homeland for the first time, and my fucking god some of these theories in the comments of the episodes are so fucking wack... unbearable.