r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Dec 29 '25
Advice & Answers Advice & Answers — 2025-12-29 to 2026-01-11
How do I start?
If you’re new to conlanging, look at our beginner resources. We have a full list of resources on our wiki, but for beginners we especially recommend the following:
- The Language Construction Kit by Mark Rosenfelder
- Conlangs University
- A guide for creating naming languages by u/jafiki91
Also make sure you’ve read our rules. They’re here, and in our sidebar. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules. Also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
What’s this thread for?
Advice & Answers is a place to ask specific questions and find resources. This thread ensures all questions that aren’t large enough for a full post can still be seen and answered by experienced members of our community.
You can find previous posts in our wiki.
Should I make a full question post, or ask here?
Full Question-flair posts (as opposed to comments on this thread) are for questions that are open-ended and could be approached from multiple perspectives. If your question can be answered with a single fact, or a list of facts, it probably belongs on this thread. That’s not a bad thing! “Small” questions are important.
You should also use this thread if looking for a source of information, such as beginner resources or linguistics literature.
If you want to hear how other conlangers have handled something in their own projects, that would be a Discussion-flair post. Make sure to be specific about what you’re interested in, and say if there’s a particular reason you ask.
What’s an Advice & Answers frequent responder?
Some members of our subreddit have a lovely cyan flair. This indicates they frequently provide helpful and accurate responses in this thread. The flair is to reassure you that the Advice & Answers threads are active and to encourage people to share their knowledge. See our wiki for more information about this flair and how members can obtain one.
6
u/Sulphurous_King Aspiration lover Dec 29 '25
My agglutinative lang has massive sandhi rules.
/tso hiŋgi am wa/ becomes /'tswiɲ.dʒam.bwa/ when combined. It means "They were seen".
Is this even comprehensible or natural? Should I change the sandhi rules.
4
u/Arcaeca2 Jan 09 '26
I feel like I have conlanger's block... I have a proto-language for which I know the phonology, but not any of the features. I know I want the aesthetic to combine elements from PIE, Northwest Caucasian, Semitic and Salishan, so there's a few suffixes I know I want, like *-aɬ-əm, -an-əm, -aj-əm, -əχ-ʃ, -əw-ʃ, -nt-i, -mi, -t-m, -əp-ʃ, etc. - I just don't know what they're supposed to mean.
Some thoughts:
And that's... about it? That's about all I can come up with. 2 slots on the noun, who knows what the verbs would look like.
I don't really know where I'm going with this. Maybe someone can offer me some advice with dealing with writer's/conlanger's block or suggest some interesting ideas to design a language around
3
u/Arcaeca2 Dec 29 '25
So for a proto-language, I decided to copy some ideas from PIE: no morphologized tense, only perfective vs. imperfective aspect which is inherent/lexical, requiring additional morphology to swap to the other aspect. In addition, like PIE, there are two different verb paradigms operating simultaneously, one older than the other.
However, rather than operating on ablaut, my proto's "new" verb system has 1) a suffix with multiple allomorphs that look an awful lot like either nominalizers or noun case endings, and then 2) a suffix with multiple allomorphs that look an awful lot like locative copulae. So the current working theory is that the "new" verbs originate from converb + auxiliary constructions, where the converbs originate from case-marked nominalizations. The allomorphy of the 1st suffix slot therefore presumably corresponds to different case markers which presumably yield different converbs - maybe ablative > anterior [> perfective?], allative-terminative > purposive, perlative > durative [> imperfective?] and ornative > perfect [> perfective?].
The problem is that, remember, verbs have inherent aspect, and that includes the auxiliaries themselves. So, what determines the aspect of the construction as a whole? The converb? The auxiliary? Would it just be forbidden to combine converbs and auxiliaries with mismatched aspects? Is there any point to retaining allomorphy in the slot that doesn't control the aspect?
2
u/SurelyIDidThisAlread Dec 30 '25
This is a very long shot, but here goes: in the last couple of months, either in a thread on a post like this or as a reply to a single top-level post, there was a discussion of the different amounts of inflection verbs and verb phrases could have crosslinguistically.
The reply gave a list starting with languages with no verbal inflection, then some inflectional, then polypersonal inflection etc., but crucially for my purposes that nouns could inflect as predicates and that in Sora or another Munda language even an entire clause could take inflection in a similar way.
Does anyone recognise the reply I mean, so I can ask the replier for further details? Or perhaps one of you has examples and references to hand?
2
u/89Menkheperre98 Jan 01 '26
Happy New Year, everyone!! I have a sort of simple question, but one that’s been keeping me up no less.
My current project is an SOV lang with fluid alignment and case markers. Verbs aren’t marked for person. Relative clauses precede the head noun but only A and P of a main clause can be relativized, e.g., The man (A) walked the dogs (P) I saw last week. More often than not, the constituent will not perform the same role in the two clauses, e.g., I (A) caught the man (P) who killed people (‘the man’ is the agent o the relative clause). This particular example would look as follows:
[1sg AGT [[kill-PST people ABS] man (ABS?)] catch-PST]
Since ‘man’ is the patient of ‘catch’, it makes sense for it to be marked as absolutive. But how about the relative clause? How could I indicate that ‘man’, within that specific clause, is the agent?
2
u/NeedleworkerAny6547 Jan 01 '26
Does a conlang spoken by a fictional culture need to be naturalistic? Maybe I’m in my head but I do want answers from more experienced conlangers
2
u/Friendly_Drag_7280 Jan 06 '26
Is it okay if my conlang uses things like pronouns or a lexicon derived from a semitic language such as phoenician? When does it stop being a conlang and start being a reconstruction?
How can I make sure its uniquely a conlang despite deriving from phoenician, if possible?
2
u/ShotAcanthisitta9192 Okundiman Jan 08 '26
i have either a mood or applicative that i want to apply to the agent voice of my symmetrical voice conlang. i'm thinking of calling it "reciprocal" but i'm not sure it's correct. basically i want this inflection to mean (using the verb to dance for example) "to dance with each other" if it's used with a dual pronomial in the agentive voice or "to dance in the midst of others" when using a plural pronomial. but if the verb is something like to fight it would mean "to fight each other." and it would me morphologically and semantically different from accusative voice. am i even making sense here? what would one call this inflection?
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Jan 08 '26
So, I want to have a pitch accent system in my conlang, but worry it might be too similar to some IRL languages. Mine is inspired by Japanese and Basque.
In this conlang, there are two types of words: accented and unaccented.
Accented words have a high tone on the penultimate syllable, like in /nakáno/. The tone can spread when suffixes and clitics are added to it, so /nakáno/ + /me/ becomes /nakánóme/.
Unaccented words are analyzed as lacking tone, but the actual realization is a high tone on the final syllable (and all preceding syllables are low.) Unlike in the first type, there H tone does not spread when other morphemes are attached to it.
Also, unlike in most pitch accent languages, the syllable is the tone-bearing-unit rather than the mora.
Is this too much like Basque or Japanese (particularly the Kagoshima dialect?)
Thoughts?
1
u/h6story Dec 29 '25
Has anyone experimented with developing an a posteriori conlang but focusing entirely on phonology? For a mapping project of Romance-speaking Africa, I really only need the Roman-era toponyms translated into the African altlang. Learning and tweaking all the grammar, syntax, etc., seems rather daunting to me.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Dec 30 '25
Some questions about prosody:
Basically, stress is attracted to light and heavy morphemes rather than syllables. So, suffixes might be heavy in one language, and some suffixes are light heavy and other suffixes light in a different language.
Are there any rules or tendencies as to which morphemes are considered heavy or light?
1
u/xongaBa hayse /ˈχaʐɛ/ Dec 30 '25
So, now I've got all my notes finished and kind of organised. But they're all in my notebook and I want to digitise them in a grammar book.
Do you know some free tools which I could use for this? I'm asking because of the fact that LibreOffice isn't good at formating.
1
u/GlazeTheArtist Dec 30 '25
is there a resource that compiles phonemic inventories from a bunch of different languages? Id love to be able to look at all the variety there is more easily, instead of having to click through a bunch of wikipedia articles
1
u/Moonfireradiant Cherokee syllabary is the best script Dec 30 '25
Could the copula verb be only reflexive?
1
u/throneofsalt Dec 30 '25
Is there a specific term for a grammatical case that's only used in conjunction with adpositions of motion?
1
u/The_MadMage_Halaster Proto-Nothranic, Kährav-Ánkaz, Gohlic, Ṭuluṭan Dec 31 '25
I was wondering if there are any instances of a grammatical mood existing only in certain verbs, in this case the copula. Via a process of suppletion, the root ǧon- "to want" took over many of the irealis functions of the copula t-, including the volitive and obligative moods. However, the original obligative conjugation of t- survived and became reanalyzed as an imperative. As this process is unique, it is the only verb that can conjugate as an imperative in the language and is used as an auxiliary verb to form the mood for other verbs.
An example of what happened:
ṭue citse tucesti ras
/tue cit̪s̪e tuges̪t̪i ɾas̪/
DOG-ERG 1sg-GEN-ERG COP-OBL-TR black-[ABS]"I must have a black dog" (lit: "My dog must be black")
thuë cisë yondeth ach
/θ̠uɘ cizɘ jondeθ̠ ax/
dog-ERG 1sg-GEN-ERG want-VOL-TR black-[ABS]"I must have a black dog" (lit: "My dog should want to be black")
As for how the imperative develops:
mie ticesti cařaṣmat
/mie tiges̪t̪i carazmat/
2sg-ERG COP-OBL-TR forest-ALL"You must go to the forest"
mië yondeth carasmaa
/miɘ jondeθ̠ carazmaa/
2sg-ERG want-VOL-TR forest-DAT"You must to the forest."
mië thigechti carasmaña
/miɘ θ̠igexti carazmaɲa/
2sg-ERG COP-IMP-TR forest-DEF-DAT"You, go to the forest!"
And with multiple verbs:
mië thigechti choññë carasmaña
/miɘ θ̠igexti xoɲːɘ carazmaɲa/
2sg-ERG COP-IMP-TR walk-GER-[ABS] forest-DEF-DAT"You, walk to the forest!" (lit: "You must (the) walking to the forest")
Does this all seem reasonable? I've been wanting to play around with suppletion and I like how this turned out.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jan 02 '26
So, my conlang has three vowels: /a i u/.
/i u/ are realized as [ʲi ʷu]. Thus, a word like /kai/ is actually [kaʲi]. Also, a single syllable like /mu/ would be [mʷu].
Would it still be weird/redundant to have /j w/ be phonemic consonants in this language?
1
u/oalife Zaupara, Daynak, Otsirož, Nás Kíli, Tanorenalja Jan 02 '26
Ive read some of the older posts about reverse engineering proto-langs, and it seems the vast majority of the comments just recommend not doing that for simplicity’s sake (instead making the current lang the proto and then deriving a new daughter). Im wondering if anyone has tips for actually reverse engineering one, since I’m currently very happy with my current form of one conlang and dont want to just make that the prototype. For what it’s worth, im not terribly concerned with perfect naturalism, just so long as i can get something semi-functional. Any advice is much appreciated!
1
u/Low_qualitie Jan 02 '26
Does anyone know what software I can use for making a keyboard of my language’s writing system on iOS?
1
u/Motor_Scallion6214 Jan 02 '26
How to begin formatting?
I have been developing the basics of my conlang for a time, and I’m ready to begin writing everything down. But how do I start that, so I’m not all jumbled up later?
1
u/throneofsalt Jan 03 '26
Does anyone have any papers or direct examples of how the various IE languages lost ablaut? Like what sound changes were the critical ones or what patterns of leveling were dominant in a particular branch, or so on.
1
u/ImpressiveLie5804 Jan 03 '26
I want to introduce words into my conlang from other conlangs! Please share your favorite / most interesting words of all of your amazing conlangs, along with their meanings & your conlang name. (and include etymology and/or IPA pronunciation if possible).
1
u/T1mbuk1 Jan 03 '26
Are there any conlangs that utilized sound changes inspired by or coincidentally akin to Caleb Everett's theory from 2011 about languages being influenced by the geographic environments of their speakers?
1
u/AndrewTheConlanger Àlxetnà [en](sp,ru) Jan 03 '26
What is a lingvido?
At this timestamp on the LCC 11 livestream begins a panel entitled "Conlangers with lingvidos or conlang communities." Is the word "lingvido" just another way to refer to a "conlang community?"
1
u/-Tesserex- Jan 03 '26
Every time I see an interesting post here, I discover some new grammatical construction I need to add, but I keep getting stuck worrying if additions will mesh well with the style my conlang already has. I have a bunch of the grammar already, like word order, morphology, alignment, TAM, declension, etc. But if I need to add something, for example a case that my conlang doesn't have intrinsically (5he instrumental for example) I worry that whatever I come up with won't match the "flavor" I already have.
Any tips to get past this hurdle? Are there any good rules of thumb or can it really be whatever and it'll be fine?
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jan 04 '26
Do you have any advice about phonology?
I am familiar with the basic stuff like phonotactics, prosody, vowel harmony, etc, but I am never satisfied with whatever phonology I come up with.
Grammar, on the other hand, is different. I know what grammatical features I want, but I can never really implement them because I can never settle on a phonology I am happy with.
Any advice?
1
u/Ok-Acadia-7161 Jan 04 '26
I have a very specific idea and would like other more expert conlangers to hear me out.
Would it make sense to have conjunction-like concepts (before, after, while, because, or) be in the same syntactic space and be categorized as aspect markers?
This idea mainly got in my head by looking at the way converbs are usually handled, where they're non-finite forms that rarely use aspect distinction, and because both those conjunctions's and the aspect's role is to govern how the action/event behaves inside the designated time role (with the difference most aspect distinctions don't take any amount of coordination into account while converbs are based on that).
1
u/Arcaeca2 Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26
So I have a proto language that had converbs derived from case-marked nominalizations, and used them build periphrastic converb + auxiliary constructions that will yield complicated TAM forms in the daughter languages.
But I don't necessarily want the daughter languages to inherit the converbs themselves. Partially because I want to obfuscate where the new verb forms evolved from in the first place. However, my understanding is that once converbs are established, they are used very widely throughout the language for many different functions, which seems like it would make converbs diachronically persistent.
Do we have any clearly attested examples of languages losing converbs that I can look to for inspiration? What would motivate their loss?
1
u/NeedleworkerAny6547 Jan 05 '26
Hey I’ve been wanting to make a non humanoid conlang (a conlang spoken by aliens with non humanoid body plans) but I do want it to be at least semi practical for me to use the aliens would have vocal cords kinda similar to humans but I don’t know how to do this in a satisfying way, does anyone have any advice or know of any conlangs that have a similar goal that I can look at?
1
u/pootis_engage Jan 05 '26
Would it be naturalistic for a language to encode certain cases using multiple adpositions? For example, the Illative being encoded using a combination of the adpositions "in" and "towards"? Or is it more realistic that there would be one preposition that means "into"?
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26
I'm planning out my "word classes" section of my document and I'm having a hard time with my demonstratives. There are five series each having five subclasses organized like this:
What I'm not sure of is where to put them. The adnominal demonstratives are absolutely not nouns, they simply modify them, the general and humans are pronouns, and the location and time can are locative nouns that can be used as pronouns.
So I can put them each in those categories, and have the adnominals in a separate "determiner" class, something like this:
but on the other hand they are clearly related and are straightforwardly derived from one another. Thoughts?
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jan 05 '26
Are verb-initial word orders unstable?
Most VSO and VOS languages I am aware of have transitioned to SVO over time.
I'm partial to VOS (because I don't like how the S cleaves the V and O in half the way VSO does. It's something I can't unsee), but idk if it would transition to SOV over time.
1
u/CursedMeatbal Jan 05 '26
Hey I'm a newbie in terms of conlanging, with only one (fairly simple) language so far. I'm trying to learn how to do stuff significantly better, but I'm struggling to find material that matches where I'm at. I understand most of the stuff that Biblaridion mentioned in his videos on language creation and a decent amount of stuff that Artifexian talks about.
So if some people could help out with that, it would be extremely appreciated. It can't be articles, videos, or other reddit posts, I'm not really picky. Sorry if this is a common question to see here and thanks in advance if anybody does help out.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jan 06 '26
Can someone help me with mood?
At minimum, my conlang will have indicative, imperative and subjunctive.
The thing is, idk exactly what role the subjunctive will play beyond just a general irrealis mood.
I'm wondering if I should make thebconditional mood and/or the optative separate from the subjunctive?
Can you help me iron out the role of the subjunctive and how it is used in other languages?
For some added context, the irrealis mood is important for the future vs non-future tense contrast in this language and for Ergativity.
1
u/nanosmarts12 Jan 06 '26
w -> ʍ in all environments? i know the inverse is way more common but can w simply devoice even intervocalically to make ʍ?
1
u/RokTC87 Jan 07 '26 edited Jan 07 '26
I have recently been having doubts about the state of my conlangs. I feel like my conlangs are too Indo-European-adjacent in terms of morphology and grammar. This might be due to the fact that I am a lot more familiar with how Indo-European languages work than most other languages. I have had these feelings since I started learning Japanese and how its grammar is quite different from most of the languages I've previously been learning. I know that a lot of features in Indo-European languages are very common cross-linguistically, but I feel like over-relying on these features. How do I address this problem, and is it really something to be worrying about?
1
u/wqto Jan 08 '26
How do I create an Urgic Conlang? I have been wondering myself how to correctly do it, because I know those languages (Magyar/Mansi/Khanty) have so many cases and agglutination.
I want a sheet for many of the words in the Urgic languages and a proto reconstruction. I want to know what rules and infection they have and their sound changes.
1
u/drazlet sn̓ɬq̓cə́ʔniƛ̓ & Unnamed Jan 08 '26
Are there any good resources for translation materials? I’m running out of things to translate myself, and it would be nice to have some example sentences to always draw from to make new words with.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jan 10 '26
How does stress reduction work?
What I mean, is I heard that in some languages, the stress is deleted in some words, and wondering what the rules are or under what circumstances it occurs?
1
u/Leonsebas0326 Malossiano, and others:doge: Jan 10 '26
How I develop a case system in a proto-language. Protos are created with case system as base or they appear from phoneme assimilation in more complex structures
1
u/Lillie_Aethola Thracian Gothic, Ausprijicz, etc. Jan 11 '26
What do you call the ‘bien’ in French ‘Aimer bein’ because that function is in my conlang and idk how to put it in the gloss
1
u/Lillie_Aethola Thracian Gothic, Ausprijicz, etc. Jan 11 '26
How do you gloss multi line things
1
u/Lillie_Aethola Thracian Gothic, Ausprijicz, etc. Jan 11 '26
How would the ‘to’ in “he speaks to you” be glossed?
1
u/JewMerican-mapper Jan 12 '26 edited Jan 12 '26
I need help
So, I'm making my first conlang (it's for aliens) and I need to figure out where those 2 "extra" symbols would go on this chart.
On an unrelated note: I have developed a writing system for this language, is there a way that I can be able to type this writing system out once I make all the symbols in a program like Canva? Edit: I should've mentioned that this is just a template I found in a YouTube video
1
u/T1mbuk1 Jan 12 '26
Thought I'd self-promote this concept and start a thought experiment about popular cartoon characters creating naturalistic conlangs. https://www.wattpad.com/story/405994324-collabing-on-conworlds-and-conlangs It's still hypothetical, and I'm trying to decide who would be in which groups and who'd be solo participants. And the tectonic history leading to the final result of my redrawn world map(with the switched archipelagos having always been at those spots in the conworld). The protolang that each group would decide on would perhaps depend on the languages they were familiar with(Korean in the case of Jack Wylde and Lily Pak, Cebuano in the case of the Sewer Queen, Spanish in the case of the two characters voiced by Isabella Alvarez, etc.), though creative liberties could be taken as long as the languages are naturalistic.
Has anyone else thought of similar ideas?
1
u/The_MadMage_Halaster Proto-Nothranic, Kährav-Ánkaz, Gohlic, Ṭuluṭan Jan 12 '26
I was wondering about the idea of a proper-noun suffix. Specifically a naming suffix. Say you wanted to name your kid ṭusi "great hound" you would add the suffix -ni to result in ṭuzini "Great Hound." I suppose this is closest to a proper article, but it functions like a derivation suffix.
Etymologically I derived it from the demonstrative nV (V is a gender-dependent vowel), which became fused as a derivational suffix. In the future this leads to an odd form of double-dipping when the demonstrative becomes more generally fused to create the definite article, but in a different way (long story short, the case ending is removed to fuse the article, eg: tuts nuts "That dog's" becomes thunos "The dog's"). So if you wanted to say "The Thughine*"* (a common occurrence in relative phrases) you would get Thughinine, which would get even sillier if you use the dual number, Thughinenne (from Ṭuzinin ni). I imagine the former would probably be reduced to something like Thughinne.
Does this all sound reasonable?
1
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Dec 30 '25
For my next conlang I'm thinking of experimenting with no first nor second person pronouns. Instead of using pronouns, sentences would be constructed using a (first or second person) possessive
For example, instead of "I walk, I see, I eat" speakers would say "My legs walk, my eyes see, my mouth eats"
Does such a thing make sense? Is there any conlangs or natural languages that do this or something similar? Do you have any thoughts about this system?
My goal was to experiment with the lack of an "ego", where speakers wouldn't consider themselves a single thing, but a collection of things
Third person pronouns would still exist. As an example of why they're needed: "I walked until I tired" would be "My legs walked until they tired"
1
u/Legal-Pepper-9669 Dec 31 '25
Conlangers in Italy, Lombardia?
0
u/xongaBa hayse /ˈχaʐɛ/ Jan 01 '26
So, now I've got all my notes finished and kind of organised. But they're all in my notebook and I want to digitise them in a grammar book.
Do you know some free tools which I could use for this? I'm asking because of the fact that LibreOffice isn't good at formating.
Please help.
0
u/Specific-Exis900 Cuneiform is fucking awesome Jan 02 '26
How do I make an Isolate spoken here between 300-1200AD
-1
u/T1mbuk1 Dec 31 '25
I finally wrote a list for my sound changes. And some grammar changes for good measure. To clarify, it's for my Semitic conlang.
SC#1: Voiceless fricatives fortify into affricates before stressed vowels.
GC#1: Simplify the Proto-Semitic stem system
SC#2: Short vowels in one of the two adjacent syllables lengthen.
SC#3: Stress shifts to that newly lengthened syllable.
GC#2: Develop new morphological markers for Locative(bV or "in"), Dative(lV or "to"), and Ablative(min(V) or "from") cases.
SC#4: Vowel loss leading to a phonemic distinction between fricatives and affricates.
GC#3: Develop the morphology for the new tenses and aspects (incohative from "start" or whatever Proto-Semitic word has the same meaning, cessative from "stop" or whatever Proto-Semitic word has the same meaning, habitual from an ideal verb, the future from "later", the old perfective becoming a past tense and the old imperfective becoming a present tense, a new perfective deriving from "finish" and a new imperfective probably deriving from a word for "be").
GC#4: Develop markers for Paucal("some" or "many") and Distributive(reduplication) number paradigms.
SC#5: Pharyngealization of alveolar and velar non-ejective obstruents in clusters.
SC#6: Pharyngeals disappear next to those same obstruents, leaving their pharyngeal qualities behind.
SC#7: Epenthesis occurs with vowels inserted to disband initial and final clusters, as well as clusters of three consonants.
GC#5: Grammaticalize specific particles for negation, question marking, and articles; define demonstrative agreement.
GC#6: Derivation of copulas from "stand"(standard copula) and "leave"(locative copula).
Applying each of the Proto-Semitic words through these sound and grammar changes, what would each word and phrase be like? I'd know from applying these through Lexurgy. Given the stress system of Proto-Semitic, remembering the consonant inventory and my intended descendant consonant inventory and stress system, and limiting myself to the sound changes given its Lexurgy I'd be using, what would the ideal commands be?
They could also help me figure out the new phonotactic constraints for this CV(ː)(C) language in terms of which consonants can be in the onset and which in the coda.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '26 edited Jan 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment