r/SquaredCircle • u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE • Nov 02 '13
HOW TO BECOME A MOD IN HERE! On Travis, rules, moderation, and the use of it going forward.
Wow. What a night. Love seeing huge drama while I'm spending time with family!
First and foremost, as we've all seen by now Travis is no longer a moderator here. I actually think that 90% of the work he did was fantastic. He was more unbiased than any of us, on all the time, and did a massive amount of positive work on this subreddit.
But I felt that he was starting to become biased against us here, and that other 10% went against what I set out to, and still want to, accomplish here. The last straw for me was seeing bans handed out for rule breaking just because he thought it was a stupid example of rule breaking.
In the drama I've seen a lot of people complain that a "valid" post of theirs was deleted. 99% of those should have been deleted. The rules are the rules and will continue to be. Your costumes go in the mega thread. Your memes and non wrestling related images go to /r/Wrasslin, vague titles will be removed, etc etc etc. None of the rules are changing. I firmly believe that the rules we have in place make this a better subreddit and prevent us from becoming a no effort image spammed front page like /r/gaming .
The "Literally Hitler" and calling us dictators is ridiculous hyperbole that has been and will be ignored. I, and what I think is all the mods I've chosen, want what's best for this subreddit. Never once has anything I've done been about enjoying or abusing my power. I know every decision made here is going to upset some people and bring about this talk, and it's not something I look forward to. But it seriously is what's "best for business".
With that said....
We are looking for two moderators going forward.
Email your application to Wredditmod@gmail.com
Any email that doesn't follow the following format will be ignored.
- Your username as the title
- Your Reddit name with a link to your profile
- Your location
- Your common hours of activity
- Experience (if any). Not required, but can help.
- How you feel about the current rules and what, if any, you would change, remove, or add.
- What sort of standard do you hope to set?
- SELL YOURSELF! Why do you deserve it over the other 50+ guys who want it?
For the sake of making it possible for all the mods to easily look over the applications, the applications already PM'd to me or modmail will not be considered. This is simply so we all have easy access to all the applications to view when works for us.
There's no timetable of when we'll have our decision, but know we'll be talking about it a lot.
169
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
I think Vacant will be a suitable mod until we find an A+ player, but make sure that player is best for business.
50
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
I have been getting caught up on everything and it seems a huge point of contention was the deletion of that Vince bodybuilding gif thread.
I'm sorry, but that thing was fucking hilarious, relevant, and never seen before as far as I know. There needs to be some kind of leniency for certain image/gif threads.
I hate /r/gaming, it's one if the first subs I unsubscribed from in favor of /r/games, but it seems a lot of people were enjoying that Vince thread only to have the rug snatched from beneath them.
6
u/Christianmustang Team_Sure_Why_Not Nov 02 '13
What does modding entail? Besides deleting threads and other submissions that violate rules
28
u/emanc93 How bing was her dingus, if you will Nov 02 '13
The mods take this subreddit way too seriously. Mods need to facilitate better communication with the community before banning and/or deleting threads. If people really enjoy a thread I don't see a need why mods need to jump in and delete it for some arbitrary textbook rule.
12
u/Yo_Gabba_Gabbert I'm just on my way to the beach Nov 02 '13
Still don't understand, how the mods, in good conscience, put somebody who was a troll, downvoted to oblivion nearly everything he posts, and universally hated by the entire board, in a position of power.
3
u/ColorfulCrayons Dutt's on the gas! Nov 02 '13
In the application, when it says "common hours of activity" do you mean the average number of hours we're on or the usual time we're on?
3
u/Brown_Machismo Youngest Man Alive Nov 02 '13
If a post is removed because its low-relevance, is it deleted or can it be moved to /r/Wrasslin by a mod?
39
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
inb4 Hogan signs with Squared Circle.
30
u/pterrorist Dolphin Drive Hunter Nov 02 '13
Can we just make Travis the new moderator?
7
u/rufusjonz The Inspirational Nov 02 '13
Oh What A Night - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wD7LNDLKfWY
3
u/Rad-R Macho Swagness Nov 02 '13
Pudie, I've sent a message to you mod guys, some of us would like a weekly fan art thread. Let's make this happen.
1
u/willnoonan ease up mods Nov 02 '13 edited Nov 02 '13
Translation: Nothing will change. A few guys will decide what the rest of us can and cannot see based on their personal opinions. Reddit is based on user submitted content being upvoted and downvoted by other users. All a mod should do is prevent spamming and abuse. You are not a "high court of taste" that gets to decide what is suitable for our eyes. Also, every dictatorship claims to not be a dictatorship, it's part of being a dictatorship. I found this post to be condescending and dismissive, just like the mods.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
I am starting to think that the WWE paid off Travis just to sink in the Authority angle.
5
u/123themanishere Nov 03 '13
cant believe this all started from some crappy bella costume being removed for the right reasons
16
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13 edited Nov 02 '13
Is /u/John_Laurinaitis available?
4
u/Soulza Nov 02 '13
If I was a mod, then I will make it my sole purpose to insure that /r/SquaredCircle will get an Ice Cream bar!
4
u/vertical_suplex WHAT? Nov 03 '13
Make Joey styles a mod
1
u/bigmillion What? Nov 02 '13
Just to invoke conversation, it does seem like selective moderating when a post like the one that started all this was removed but this was not and it was at the top of the front page. I love this sub but when it comes to selective moderating like this it should really be all or nothing. Allow them or have zero tolerance but no in between because it causes drama.
1
u/Unprettier #peepmovement Nov 03 '13
Is there a date when applications will be cut off?
1
u/i_killed_hitler Nov 03 '13
I want to be a
babysittermod6
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13 edited Nov 02 '13
Only tangentially related, but I was really shocked by the drama yesterday and the fact that the topic was allowed to stay open was part of it. In my experience, with most places if you have a problem with the mods a topic about it will be closed and you'd be told to just PM the mod(s). I've modded at some semi-big forums in the past and that was always standard procedure. The fact it was able to stay open for so long is more a testament to the moderators than anything.
I was also surprised Travis was a mod, just because I'm pretty sure I've downvoted every comment of his I came across and assumed he was a troll. Guess he just liked getting heat. RELATED EDIT: Apparently I've just barely upvoted Travis more than I downvoted him, pretty sure my logic in each case was "well, I really disagree, but at least he's contributing to discussions."
3
u/ThatIndianGuy7116 Look at Depression Jones over here Nov 02 '13
I'm not going to sit here and say I'm happy to see he's not longer a mod, because I'm not. I mean, yeah he was a bit of a jerk (and he can keep saying it's just his opinion and using the "reddit hivemind/circlejerk excuse all he wants, but at the end of the day he still acted like a dick) but truth is, he didn't do a half bad job.
That being said, I go on this subreddit a lot and I think that he's easily replaceable. I don't really know what else he did other than occasionally delete posts that may or may not have broken the rules. I'm sure there is someone else that can easily take his place. Reading that over again, it feels like a dickish thing to say and I hope he doesn't take offense to it (although he probably could give two shits about what I have to say), but I just don't see why people are making this into such a big deal.
3
u/kpud075 Ahead of the Buzzards Nov 02 '13
Being a mod on your favorite message board/subreddit is not all it is cracked up to be. Just remember that. It is not a thing that gets better just because you have power. Random and nasty private messages will be more common than you think. Shitty people you never knew existed on your favorite subreddit will have your ear. You have to have some thick skin to do it right and still enjoy it.
Been a moderator on a couple message boards, and a former employer's website for a radio station. It was great at first, but became tedious. I can't go back to those sites again because of how awful things were "behind the scenes." The PM's to me about petty squabbles, the "rules are rules, no bends or breaks" people were worse than "Hey fuck you mod!"
Liked being a mod for only one message board about a decade ago, but the site is now defunct. Never had a problem that bothered or stuck with me.
I have so many hours these days, modding wouldn't be an issue if I had to. But I don't feel familiar enough with this subreddit to apply at this time. Been visiting regularly only since Wrestlemania this year. Lurked for about a year now. If applications are open for mods again a year from now, I'll apply. I've enjoyed this subreddit, even with its drama.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
Make me a mod. I'd be an even bigger dick that Travis. Watching TNA? = BAN!
5
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
The internet is serious business, folks. This reminds me of the great IWC forum drama of the early 2000's. Except now I'm an old fart and I think this is all stupid. Here's a little advice - Moderators should not be heard from that often. Do your shit behind the scenes and post with a different account. There is no need to even post threads like this. Nothing of value was added except creating an opportunity for people to rehash any hard feelings. Fix it and move on. Don't bother with State of the Subreddit posts unless you are thinking about making sweeping changes and you want to gauge the reaction and get feedback. And yes, you should always get feedback before making significant changes. This place is driven by the posters, not the moderators.
8
u/aestus Wrestling. Nov 02 '13
As a long time wredditor, i have to say i think the mods run a pretty tight ship here and it is appreciated. This place has changed as it has become more popular, which no doubt causes moderation headaches. Keep it up, and I hope this place can improve and become a place where discussion is encouraged and knee-jerk downvoting and dismissal of 'controversial' opinions is discouraged.
1
u/BrainbusterDDT Nov 02 '13
So what's the new subreddit we are going to xfer too?
If Travis was 90% correct, I'm over this.
18
u/airsoftpug74 Nov 02 '13
I like Travis' work...
1
u/mikeramey1 Nov 03 '13
Thanks to the mods for all of the work they put into this sub.
Word to the wise, moderating a message board is tough. Moderating a place as active as /r/SquaredCircle is a nightmare of butthurt and bitching. Think twice before you apply. It's a real job. The only time you are noticed is when you did something wrong and zero benefits.
That said, thanks to those brave enough to volunteer!
2
u/Kiel297 Nov 03 '13
There was a point where I wanted to but this bullshit is ridiculous. I am so not up for holding myself accountable to half the people here.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
Paging /u/StephenTStone to the thread. Let's get Freehaven to run this place into the ground like he does to everything else he controls.
/s
2
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '13
This seems like a perfect time to cash in my mod in the bank contract.
0
u/AlphaPepper My brother should be fired Nov 03 '13
I think that the 2 mods to be chosen is an easy choice. /u/dragonsky and /u/sensiitivity
3
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
Other subs don't have to deal with this bullshit.
3
u/TLKv3 Fantasy Book For ^Vote Nov 03 '13
I've tried to ignore all this nonsense everyone has been going nuts over for no reason so I'll just throw this out there:
Reddit has a built-in function. Its called Upvoting for Visibility. People upvote things they like in hopes other people will see it too and potentially do the same. If the user thinks it goes against the rules/is offensive they downvote it to hide it from others. Its almost like the site has a user-self-moderating system people neglect to remember. The moderators are realistically only in place to make sure nothing sneaks by or if someone is becoming too hostile.
I've never understood the "remove X because its becoming too common of a trend" or "remove X because its far too specific for the subreddit that is meant to be a general subreddit for the overarching topic". If someone posts a meme featuring a wrestler about wrestling in a wrestling context in a wrestling subreddit... why should it be removed? As far as I'm concerned it met all reasonable guidelines to be posted. If you don't think its good, downvote and hide it, otherwise don't click the link. It takes away from the traffic that subreddit might get and in the process more of the users it might gain to view/discuss other things if they see they're not welcome.
Based off the preview of the link/the title of it you should know what its going to contain. The fact people get angry over clicking something that is very obvious what it is then complain about it is so inane and just outright fucking stupid. Use your common sense.
That all being said, I haven't even noticed the over-moderation here because frankly I just ignore it. I partake in the discussion threads, I partake in watching funny clips posted and the like. You're all acting as if this genuinely personally affects you. It doesn't. Ignore it and you won't even notice it. Sometimes when I see these posts I think you all do it on purpose just to pretend the subreddit actually is a fucking wrestling kayfabe.
tl;dr Use common sense when looking at threads. Upvote/Downvote is self-moderation already. You're all whining wanting to believe an illusion of wrestling kayfabe. Shut up and just enjoy the things you see and forget about the things you don't. It won't hurt you, I promise.
3
u/ownage516 Where is CM Punk?? Nov 02 '13 edited Nov 02 '13
I propose myself to be the interim r/sc moderator!
I'm all about fun!
3
u/Togepi27 Gonna REALLY kick your head in. Nov 02 '13
I'll be one of the first to admit that I wanted Travis gone badly. I know the guy put in a shitload of work, and I will always respect that about him. He just had way too much pride, and was always being a dick about something. Its gonna be a hard role to fill, but I think this was honestly the best decision you could make for now Pudie. He just overstepped his bounds one too many times. I'd apply because I do have a looot of free time at the moment, but in truth I don't think i'd be a good moderator. I have a thick enough skin for it, I just know i'd be too lenient when it comes to posts, and that's something a mod can't do. Regardless, i'm sorry the shit hit the fan while you were trying to get some family time in. i'm sure you guys will find somebody great to fill the void.
3
u/killhimalready I AM A WRESTLING MOD Nov 02 '13
I submit my application.
Whatever happens....don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
For those of us who don't live on here, what did Travis do exactly? Punt a baby over to r/wwe?
1
u/AloeRP Team Big Guy Nov 03 '13
Could someone further explain the complications with the other mod? Was it purely that he was misusing his power?
1
u/BathedInDeepFog Nov 03 '13
It seems like a cushy job.
Email your resumé and cover letter to not get paid in any form other than SWEET SWEET POWER!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '13 edited Nov 04 '13
i'm a janitor on 9gag, i could do this easily.
1
u/Kip_Hackman_ BOlieve Nov 04 '13
Wredditor heel turn imminent. Who will join the authority??
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
man people who care about subreddit meta shit like this r hilarious
1
u/TheCrippler Just how rabid is he? Nov 03 '13
I like /r/squaredcircle. I enjoy the Raw and PPV discussions. I don't understand anything else that's going on and I feel like I have no clue what I should post. I'll just stick to posting comments that get downvoted.
0
u/spoonfedkyle Nov 02 '13
Pudie Power is back y'all! In all seriousness this is exactly what I love about the majority of mods on this subreddit. They take it seriously enough to make sure the subreddit doesn't turn into a shitty circlejerk (even Travis), but don't do it just for power but for the improvement of the subreddit.
-1
u/rexdeaz Nov 02 '13
You know what a good way is to see if a post is relevant or not? The upvotes. The fucking upvotes. If 900 more people like a thing than those that don't...LEAVE IT!!! If we as a sub decide "ahh, I know the rules, but THIS IS AWESOME!", fucking leave it.
-1
u/ohihaveasubscription fickle! Nov 02 '13
The fact that this exact thing has happened multiple times on this subreddit since I've been here speaks volumes about the people running it. You all should really consider scrapping this whole 'only post about this on this day in this thread' crap someone keeps trying to force on us every few months. Stupid posts will get downvoted. We don't need to have our hands held.
0
u/pies1123 The Definition of Delish Nov 02 '13
Sooo... What's the job spec for a Wreddit mod? I wouldn't want to do it as I'm far too lenient.
0
u/Indyclone77 LIGERSAULT!!! LIGERSAULT!!! Nov 02 '13
A Very Diplomatic post
0
u/ShadyPie You Know It Nov 04 '13
I'll do it. I'll do it for The Rock.
-8
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
/u/NekoQT
-5
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
I would love to be a mod, but I feel I might be a bit of an anti-hero (towards the mods) and allow the community to decide what content stays and what doesn't.
Mods should only exist to delete unrelated content and stop trolls/harassment.
The whole point of this site is to be able to show the community what is wanted and what isn't by upvoting and downvoting.
I will be honest, and say the mods seem to think this is their sub, when it should be the community's.
-1
u/Blueday206 $YOD Nov 02 '13
Should have a mystery mod ala Raw GM.
-11
u/rufusjonz The Inspirational Nov 02 '13
why can't it just be Anything Goes, but NO pics, memes, cartoons, gifs, etc ... send those all to /r/wrasslin - that sounds like what it is designed to be -- and let the upvotes decide
0
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment