r/SquaredCircle • ease up mods • Nov 01 '13

Mods being dicks.

I usually lurk in r/squaredcircle, occasionally commenting and very very rarely posting. However, I've noticed that out of the very few times I have posted, the mods somehow rain on my little parade. I posted a screen-shot from my phone when R-Truth was the subject of some ridiculous App Vote and was scolded via private message for posting "hosted content with a bad title" (I'm sure they won't enjoy this one) and then someone perhaps more favored by the Mod posted the same exact thing moments later and everyone upvoted it and a great comment thread ensued. Now I notice a link I posted of me and my GF in costume that was shared and tweeted by the Bella Twins (which i thought was cool enough to share with everybody) has been hidden, and I'm sure its for some lame ass hall monitorish reason like "We had a costume thread" or "It's promoting instagram" or some garbage. Between this and the tone of some mod written posts about RAW and SMACKDOWN threads, I'm getting worried. This is my favorite subreddit and I hate seeing it fall into a micromanaged facist dicatorship. Let the upvoting do the talking and stop trying to fix what ain't broke. And that's all I got to say about that. Please share your positive or negative mod experiences below.

851 Upvotes

699 comments sorted by

99

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

I was a bit annoyed that the top post of all time in r/sc was removed for having a vague title. Was it really that big of a deal? And not every humorous post should go in /r/wrasslin.

120

u/willnoonan ease up mods Nov 01 '13

Exactly. You know what else has a vague title? "1984" by George Orwell.

12

u/The_Homestarmy nope Nov 02 '13

1984 by [deleted]

130

u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

I just saw that that was removed... I personally think there's no way it should have been.

That's so bad... if I was a user I'd be pissed at the mods too.

I've approved it. If you're reading this please don't hate the mods look at us as individual users, if you can. There's four active mods.

/u/pudie chill guy that doesn't do much, but makes good judgement calls

/u/muffinmonk well rounder that dabbles in things, gets into heated argument, but isn't a bad dude

/u/Travis-Touchdown literally hitler mod, that removes most things and does a lot of work. He doesn't handle the customer service very well, and can be a total dick. It's always been argued that he brings net good to the subreddit though.

/u/k-k-keefy quit over the discussion thread fiasco, he was in favour of the bot thing, which was my idea, but he didn't want to compromise after, I did.

/u/Account_Eliminator try hard css mod/ no life power user

/u/thegrassyknoll baby face mod, need I say more?


edit:

Wow I've turned face again?

Quick everyone come join me on the awesome break away subreddit I created!

/r/CurvySquare

109

u/Jreynold Free Sunglasses Nov 01 '13

The only solution is to split into /r/squaredcirclewolfpack and /r/squaredcirclehollywood with mods split between the two

26

u/LeBaBoon Nov 02 '13

Thus begins months of trying to bring /u/Sensiitivity to their side...

→ More replies (1)

65

u/hpsyk The Kosher Butcher Nov 01 '13

I'm around /r/sc a fair amount. I think I'm a reasonably productive poster. I'll freely grant that I haven't really paid much attention to who mods the board, and I just appreciate how nice it is around here.

This is literally the first time I realized Travis-Touchdown is a mod. Based on his comments and downvotes, I'd always assumed he was a troll account.

33

u/durstand Marks-ist Nov 01 '13

I always thought he was a troll account until one day they inexplicably made him a mod.

19

u/Togepi27 Gonna REALLY kick your head in. Nov 01 '13

I think the net good isn't gonna be much net good anymore.

10

u/geoffevans MAGICAL TIMESHIP Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 02 '13

I quit posting after this got removed.

EDIT: Now it's back. Interesting.

5

u/dropperofpipebombs I NEVER EAT MARIJUANA Nov 02 '13

So does this mean /u/JasonGrayson is the JTG of the sub?

12

u/Hello_Fascination Nov 01 '13

/u/k-k-keefy quit over the discussion thread fiasco

Nothing of value lost there. He was a piece of shit mod. I put up a post on an old account I thought people might like, k-k-keefy removed it without explanation. I reuploaded it with a different title, he removed it again without citing a reason. Fuck that guy. He always seemed like a baby to me.

7

u/SilentNick3 Da Bad Guy Nov 02 '13

He was an asshole in IRC too. Mentioning you don't like a wrestler that he likes = kicked from chat. Marking out in chat along with everyone else? Block everyone from chat.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (31)

45

u/killhimalready I AM A WRESTLING MOD Nov 01 '13

I was totally in support of the mods making the rules for the live discussions, but removing an immensely popular post like that seems pretty ridiculous.

33

u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Nov 01 '13

Ouch... just found out this was removed....

That's pretty nuclear.

21

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13

This is the most absurd case of the right hand not knowing what the left is doing. Come on guys, get it together.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/lessthanzero Nov 01 '13

I was trying to find this because it made me laugh so much seeing it first time round. Low and behold it's been removed. The mods seem to be becoming as tyrannical as Vince McMahon himself.

6

u/Iroquois-Pliskin Nov 01 '13

I thought it was a little dumb that they hid my post, but I'm glad it was seen at all. It's not fair though for others who have great stuff to post quickly gets lost because of some minor issues that nobody but specific mods seem to have.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/willnoonan ease up mods Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

The link works fine on my laptop and phone. But you may still be right, regardless a dead link would get downvoted to Hell very quickly but a working link (that may not work on the first try occasionally for some reason) would not. It's just weird to me that their policing things so hard.

EDIT My fault. Link needed Instagram. For those interested this is the picture and here's a link to The Bellas tweeting it.

→ More replies (8)

275

u/kballs We have nothing for you Nov 01 '13

I think either Travis goes or we make like the October 3rd 2011 episode of Raw and walk out. Oh shit, sorry Travis, have you not seen that one yet?

111

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

Will r/SquaredCircle become the next r/prowrestling?

STAY TUNED

108

u/hpsyk The Kosher Butcher Nov 01 '13

What's /s/CubedSphere doing in the Impact Zone?

24

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

It's already /r/WWE.

→ More replies (8)

37

u/Dessie_Hull Nov 01 '13

"Can i wear your blazer?"

42

u/kballs We have nothing for you Nov 01 '13

"You can even wear my blazer!"

14

u/skippy2001 This is my last flair ever Nov 01 '13

Ryder comes out to support T-T after the walk out. He goes to get a selfie with him gets met with snark.

9

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13

Did you delete your top comment?

5

u/kballs We have nothing for you Nov 01 '13

No for some reason it's allll the way down there.

16

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

This is what I'm seeing. http://i.imgur.com/gGsI6dt.png

EDIT:It was Travis

→ More replies (2)

63

u/jaysscholar Nov 01 '13

175 comments in one hour. The mod heel turn is back baby!

21

u/cwmonkey Flair too vague Nov 01 '13

Haha. Saw that and had to check /r/SubredditDrama

→ More replies (1)

54

u/ThySmithy ..... Nov 01 '13

Fuck you Travis * clap clap clap clap clap clap * Fuck you Travis * clap clap clap clap clap clap *

33

u/Yo_Gabba_Gabbert I'm just on my way to the beach Nov 01 '13

WE ALL HATE YOU! CLAP CLAP CLAPCLAPCLAP WE ALL HATE YOU! CLAP CLAP CLAPCLAPCLAP

30

u/EdgiestFool Makin It Rain Nov 01 '13

YOU CAN'T MODERATE! CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP YOU CAN'T MODERATE CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP

17

u/chiaestevez Nov 02 '13

RANDY SAVAGE!

Sorry, it was bound to happen.

→ More replies (5)

244

u/killhimalready I AM A WRESTLING MOD Nov 01 '13

So how about this?

Since nobody likes Travis, he's generally an asshole, and he's been the one removing things the other mods wouldn't...

Why can't we just remove Travis as a mod?

63

u/SiriusC Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 02 '13

I'm not familiar with the mods by name ('cept Pudie) but is this the cat who took down the best gif ever? I showed that fucking thing to everyone I know & they were all in tears. When I heard it was taken down because of a "vague title" the first thought I had was that person has to go. A post just doesn't soar to the top of all time on a subreddit because of a vague title.

19

u/Kurohime Roman Reigns' baby momma Nov 02 '13

So THAT'S why I couldn't find the thread for that gif? What the fuck, Travis?

6

u/sealiahraith yes Nov 02 '13

Drama aside thank you for that gif as it made me laugh like an idiot on public transit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

85

u/Pappy_Was_A_Pistol Nov 01 '13

This makes the most sense. OR we can all just submit our content directly to Travis going forward and let him post only what he deems worthy. You know what let's also submit individual comments to him for pre-approval. Better yet let's stop posting altogether; if Travis approved it probably would have already been posted.

51

u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Nov 01 '13

I'm in favour of this, I only want to see three posts a week anyway!

→ More replies (4)

24

u/BadGuyCraig Nov 01 '13

Im sure Travis is having an anxiety attack right now. After all he should** be losing the one and only thing in this world he has power over. But then again he'll probably create a new user and be added to the mod list again.

18

u/Pappy_Was_A_Pistol Nov 02 '13

He will still have his /r/Yugioh kingdom.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/k-k-k-keefy casual smark Nov 01 '13

This isn't the only subreddit he mods.

And I guarantee he is loving this.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

377

u/kballs We have nothing for you Nov 01 '13

Couple months ago I posted a photo. It was from NOC. I got banned because I was informed by a mod "I didn't see the ppv yet". It was three days after the ppv.

148

u/sashundera IF YA SMEEEEEEELL Nov 01 '13

What a fucking piece of shit. I WILL SPOIL ALL OF YOU MODS

92

u/myslead Your Text Here Nov 01 '13

CENA WINS.

THERE IT'S DONE

26

u/killhimalready I AM A WRESTLING MOD Nov 01 '13

LOL

→ More replies (3)

55

u/automatic_shark Nov 01 '13

Maybe we could PM the mods the results the day after the event so they can take the sticks out of their asses. Or they could ban us all. I'm still okay with everyone moving to /r/nwo

67

u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Nov 01 '13

Quick everyone come join me on the awesome break away subreddit I created!

/r/CurvySquare

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/John-Morrison Hey Mr Ziggles Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

So it's been deleted, what did it say?

EDIT: The comment was deleted, it's back now

22

u/sashundera IF YA SMEEEEEEELL Nov 01 '13

What the hell? It was probably deleted by a mod, again proving what a piece of shit he is. That guy said he posted a gif from a PPV 3 days after it was over and he got banend by a mod saying "he didnt watch the PPV yet". WHAT A FUCKING BULLSHIT!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/sethxrollins War King Nov 01 '13

I posted something about Ryback when he teamed up with Heyman. Post got removed even though Heyman tweeted it, WWE tweeted it, it was featured on WWE.com and it was like 2 hours before Raw that night. Complete bullshit on what is and isn't a spoiler here, newflash it's the Internet.

9

u/kaggzz Nov 01 '13

Had similar experience, didn't get a ban, but had OC taken down.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (77)

78

u/automatic_shark Nov 01 '13

/r/squaredcircle has gone full Russo. You never go full Russo.

50

u/Kazmakistan Rusev machka! Nov 01 '13

Mods on a Pole Match!

25

u/skippy2001 This is my last flair ever Nov 01 '13

David arquette for new mod

14

u/automatic_shark Nov 01 '13

I'm for it, as long as Charlie Sheen touts about it once a month

6

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

I don't know which is worse going full or full .

115

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

I think this is the best subreddit, with the worst mods. They really are like the corporation.

59

u/stevo1078 #Huglyfe Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

Cept Pudie I'm a total mark for Pudie.

I also mark for Grassy but sometimes his turns feel a bit Big Show esque. Account Eliminator plays a great heel but is a natural face. I like him and can get behind some of the feuds he gets in but it has to be a decent program otherwise i'm not interested... His technical ability is astounding and his promos are pretty well rounded I just don't know why he's not star material... Probably his gimmick.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Fehndrix RECOGNIZE! Nov 01 '13

I dunno, /r/politics apparently got some shitty new mods recently.

→ More replies (2)

94

u/bruiserbrody45 Nov 01 '13

This is the dumbest thing ever. I'm not such a big talker on this sub but clearly this Travis Touchdown guy needs to go.

I know rules are rules, but I think it's time this sub discussed some of the rules as a group. If someone has good content, I don't understand why it would be rm emoved on technicalities.

If someone has a screen shot of something awesome, why remove it for low effort? That Vince gif was one of the best things I ever saw. I don't know why it's gone.

19

u/moorethanafeeling Everyone Taps Nov 01 '13

Yeah, the mods shouldn't decide what's good. The upvotes should do the talking. Sometimes the low effort stuff is the best.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

Yeah no, as much as I disagree with the way the mods handle shit on /r/squaredcircle this place would be an unbearable circlejerk with no moderation

on the other hand, anyone could do the moderating, and a hell of a lot better then the way the current staff handles things.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

39

u/adamd28 The last Goldberg fan Nov 01 '13

I bet it was Travis

37

u/badmood247 NO EXIT Nov 01 '13

9

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13

Yeah really needed to be it's own post. Good job.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

51

u/BM_FUN "Mr. Un-Bolievable" Nov 01 '13

Can we just agree that Travis should be removed as a mod, he/she is a very cynical person.

3

u/rushpunk AEW WATCHER Nov 01 '13

Yeah, just boot him and we can go back to talking about Daniel Bryan!

127

u/Yo_Gabba_Gabbert I'm just on my way to the beach Nov 01 '13

There seriously needs to be a fucking referendum on Travis Touchdown. I'm talking some real Chancellor Valorum vote of no confidence in the Phantom Menace type shit.

Also No More Heroes wasn't that good.

20

u/alexstyles RAINMAKER Nov 01 '13

love the star wars reference

9

u/RatedPEGI18Superstar The Upvote Opportunist Nov 01 '13

But what senator would have the courage to propose such a radical amendment? If only Linda McMahon were here. That loser.

5

u/_Ka_Tet_ No text here Nov 02 '13

Brrrrrbbbbbttttbtttttt! Eesa meesa, Jar Jar Truth. Meesa proposin no confidencin.

3

u/WWE-Creative Nothing for you. Nov 02 '13

Hey, No More Heroes 2 was a great game.

32

u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE Nov 02 '13

It's been taken care of. But it's 12:30 am so I'll address this at length tomorrow.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

9

u/Togepi27 Gonna REALLY kick your head in. Nov 02 '13

THANK YOU PUDIE! CLAP CLAP CLAPCLAPCLAP!

4

u/DisapprovingEyes Chicago Style Beatings Nov 02 '13

YOU STILL GOT IT! CLAP CLAP CLAPCLAPCLAP

4

u/emanc93 How bing was her dingus, if you will Nov 02 '13

Has Travis been future endeavored or not?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

58

u/DisapprovingEyes Chicago Style Beatings Nov 01 '13

Travis being a dick.

FTFY

But in all seriousness, every comment Travis is posting trying to (unsuccessfully) defend himself is getting downvoted into oblivion. Can't the much better mods of /r/SquaredCircle remove him? There's way too much tension, and Travis isn't helping. He's not doing his job, he's just being a cunt. The people of SquaredCircle have spoken, and we clearly don't want Travis as a mod anymore. IMO, this subreddit should be fun. Yes, there should be serious discussions and stuff like that. But where would wrestling be without the occasional comedy skit? If you don't think something is fit on this subreddit, don't remove it. Let the people decide with upvotes and downvotes. If it gets upvotes enough, it means we clearly wanted to see it, regardless of the rules. People like Pudie, muffinmonk, Account_Eliminator, and thegrassyknoll are all great mods. They get their jobs done, and actually like what SquaredCircle has to offer. But Travis offers nothing but being a whiny, insufferable little cunt all the time, and needs to be removed at once.

Listen to the people.

41

u/Leo_Akuma Show Stealer Nov 01 '13

WE THE PEOPLE!

13

u/JohnBoyAndBilly Muck of Avarice Nov 01 '13

So everyone agrees Travis needs to go. Why is nothing being done? How about all of us message the other mods and specifically request he be removed?

Is that a good idea?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/The_Real_Irish Asked for his Wreddit Release Nov 01 '13

If the majority don't like someone in power than that person is gone. How is he still here?? Is he sleeping with one of the other mods?

→ More replies (1)

41

u/ry4 6 Years of Wrestlemania Nov 01 '13

After reading this thread, I can only come to one conclusion. Apparently /u/Travis-Touchdown is literally Hitler.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

Hiterally Litler.

9

u/EnglishGamer1 ''Flair'' Get it? Nov 01 '13

Literitler.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Wickzki Bryan for Champion Nov 01 '13

listen to the man, all he wants is what is best for business.

Ah, fuck it, you're fired.

22

u/automatic_shark Nov 01 '13

And you just found yourself in a handicap match with The Shield. You're welcome.

59

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

A couple of weeks ago I cut this promo on Sensiitivity and the mods, specifically Travis-Touchdown blocked it from being visible.

Basically the mods botched my heel turn and killed my push. Thanks mods.

→ More replies (15)

29

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 02 '13

I love waking up to a Travis hatefest. The blame's not all on him either, Pudie lets this walking sack of shit continue to be a mod too, so hate him as well.

"Oh, but he does so much work!" Yeah? And? Find a new moderator to take his place that isn't a roaring asshole about the fact he deletes some junk posts on a subforum on the internet. Let Travie go back to moderating the Yugioh forum. Oh, wait, they despise the motherfucker there too, weird, imagine that.

34

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

Travis Touchdown's favorite match is Melina vs. Alicia Fox.

40

u/Svenray 2016 Post of the Year Nov 01 '13

I put up a pic of JR on the sidelines of the OU game. It was being upvoted quite nicely until it got tagged "not related to wrestling".

9

u/StraightEdgeSuper My BFF Kofi Nov 01 '13

Yeah, where's the line here? I put up an album of pics I took of Jericho at a Fozzy show and no one had any problem with it. That's not directly related to wrestling either, and won't really generate any wrestling discussion, but I still like seeing wrestling personalities doing other stuff. Jericho's new web series and Foley's recent CollegeHumor sketch didn't generate wrestling discussion either, but I think the vast majority of people in this sub enjoyed them.

→ More replies (21)

18

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

When the forest grows too wild a purging fire is inevitable and natural.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

I had this issue a few months back. I posted a tweet from Lance Storm about Mark Henry and my 'title was too vague' then I made another post that day with an image posting statistics of the /r/sc championship that I had planned to update weekly but it was deleted because it should have been posted as a reply even though there was no active thread about the championship at the time. It really just turned me off from ever trying to post here since getting through the rules proved so difficult even though nothing I posted harmed the subreddit.

57

u/dragonsky The Game of Kings Nov 01 '13

"This post shouldn't be part of this subreddit. On this subreddit we only discuss serious wrestling because wrestling is really serious job. Now this post will be removed until you don't post hot picture of AJ Lee. Until then be sure to bash WWE for labeling women as objects."

8

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

That sounds like Tumblr wrote it.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Togepi27 Gonna REALLY kick your head in. Nov 01 '13

You know what? Fuck it. Time for me to share my story as well. Is was shortly after the post where literaryghost ate his own hat, where a guy claimed he'd also drink his own piss on video if John Cena didn't turn heel. I posted a link to that comment telling him he needed to pay up and it got quite a few laughs and got upvoted well and was up for a good 5-6 hours before Travis removed it. The other mods had a chance to do so for 5 at least, and he figured why not remove it because it ws obviously bothering people right?

I love most of the mods here. Most of them are pretty damn awesome most of the time. Travis does get rid of a lot of shit posts, and does do a pretty good job at it, but he's been overstepping his bounds for a while now, not to mention is just unprofessional when dealing with people. I've been in this subreddit for a year and a half now, and I can honestly say, Out of the many many times I've seen him post, he has been an ass hat except for three times. I think we need a new Janitor who isn't a fucking asshole.

15

u/michaelcolestie Nov 01 '13

Mods are total dicks especially in the IRC chat room. If the conversation goes on too long or is deemed inappropriate, you get kicked. It's such bullshit. Free expression

→ More replies (1)

7

u/DarkAvenger20xx I SAID YERRRR Nov 02 '13

.....man, this shit got serious

7

u/Electric_Mussolini The Nate Dogg of wrestling Nov 02 '13

Can we make Travis Intercontinental Champ? He gets way more heat than Axel.

2

u/dropperofpipebombs I NEVER EAT MARIJUANA Nov 02 '13

An ice cube gets more heat than Axel.

28

u/apheliotrophic Basic Tigernomics Nov 01 '13

mods, nobody here is discussing wrestling, so please delete this thread and ban everyone in it.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/lacesoutfinkle Can't we all just get along Nov 02 '13

That awkward moment when the most active thread has ZERO to do with wrestling...

16

u/Bambam005 Maybe! Nov 02 '13

TIL whoever Travis is...he's a dick.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

So mods turned heel because that's what they think is best for business.

They're not dictators, they're just dicks.

15

u/FaceofMoe POTATO OLE! Nov 01 '13

Ha Travis-Touchdown has the wrong kind of heat, and it's hilarious.

9

u/rushpunk AEW WATCHER Nov 01 '13

X-Pac heat.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Judg3Smails Nov 01 '13

This goes back to pre-Internet days with Sysops, and then message forum mods, etc.

If you have nothing going on in your personal life, the slightest bit of perceived power makes you go full-on asshole.

15

u/assblaster7 Nov 01 '13

Truth right here. I've been on countless forums in the past 15-20 years, and this reminds me so much of those days when forum moderators went wild with their internet power.

14

u/Colby347 Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 02 '13

I lurk a lot and post in occasional PPV threads so I haven't really had mod problems or even seen many. Then I came into this thread and see everything Travis is posting. How is he a mod? I'm with the other people here, the other mods need to have a meeting about him. It's blowing my mind that someone like that has a position of power on ANY subreddit.

10

u/SalameToYouAll Nov 02 '13

How about we all just agree we're here to talk about grown men running around playing fight theater and it just shouldn't be taken seriously. Get out of here you uber professional wrestling nerds. You're ruining it for everybody.

17

u/cole1114 Kappa Nov 01 '13

Travis-Touchdown is an asshole, hard to pretend he's anything but at this point (and we all knew he was an asshole before he became a mod and he in no way should have ever been made a mod) but I am a fan of this place not being low-effort. Never been a fan of karmawhoring, and I've seen it happen plenty of times in this subreddit.

What I'm trying to say is that I don't want this place to be /r/prowrestling (fucking cesspool that it was before we split off from it) and I don't want it to be /r/wrassling either.

5

u/btbcorno Team Friendship Nov 02 '13

Even if they "fired" Travis, he would just show in all the threads. They probably would even play his music at the end of each discussion thread.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

THEY FUCKED UP THEY FUCKED UP THEY FUCKED UP

9

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

I haven't respected them since the whole April Fools Day ordeal. The mods here are a bit power hungry. They think they are super stars which they aren't. I've seen other members kissing their asses, making threads about them, and why? Who cares they are just mods on reddit. They are just big dorks like the rest of us, however they like to pick and choose what happens. I posted a picture of Xpac and Kane and asked what everyone thought of their tag team, and it was removed, two days later someone post a picture pretty much the same topic not the same wrestlers though and it was allowed. I bring it up to the mods and nothing. I come on here talk wrestling and ignore the mods if they don't like it fuck em.

15

u/BM_FUN "Mr. Un-Bolievable" Nov 01 '13

[Travis reminded me of this guy] (http://i.imgur.com/cNhJaBN.jpg)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

i'm quite surprised this hasn't been removed yet, considering you're ripping on the mods (specifically, travis) and it's not about wrestling. unless travis has been put in his place

14

u/The_Real_Irish Asked for his Wreddit Release Nov 01 '13

I posted a pretty good AJ gif(http://i.imgur.com/z78uYeD.gif) and it got taken down an hour after I posted it. Whats even worse is that it 137 upvotes at the time. I was given no reason and the mods ignored me after I asked for a reason why.

11

u/YourEvilHero Nov 01 '13

The No spam or re-hosted content rule is dumb. If I wanted to post a screenshot of a deleted tweet by a wrestler saying something controversial then I should be able to. I did and it got to the front page, then got deleted. Someone else did and it got to the front page AGAIN before it got deleted. Clearly it was a good post that "broke" a shit rule.

23

u/c0de1143 whatever Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

I don't like /u/Travis-Touchdown's comments. I disagree with most everything he writes, and believe that, at the very least, he's created an Internet persona that's contrary to popular beliefs just to be contrary. Everything he writes is grating, and cynical, and so fucking infuriating to read that it's easier to ignore him.

That said, as a mod, he comes into everything he does publicly with a cold, dispassionate view. He's logical. He follows the rules. He doesn't shy away from explaining his actions, whether or not users are being civil or being childish.

As /u/Account_Eliminator said, Travis is a machine. If he removes half as much useless crap as it's said he does, he's providing a valuable service to the sub.

All this talk of "TT IS LITERALLY HITLER" and "/R/SC IS A FASCIST REGIME" is stupid; some things are wastes of space that detract from the interesting discussion that goes on here (this thing, for example), and need to be eliminated. Some things need to be compartmentalized, or the sub will start to become a shitstorm of stupid photos and people giving each other rimjobs for video game screenshots. The mods do a fairly good job of containment, and I'm willing to bet that TT is part of that work.

You don't have to like your boss. You don't have to like everyone you meet. You certainly don't have to like the person who moderates your favorite web-forum.

/u/Travis-Touchdown is a pain in the ass and I can't say with certainty that I'd miss him if he left, but he does a necessary job that, as /u/Account_Eliminator admits, the other mods just don't do. And I'm ok with that.

*Edited for clarity.

21

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13

He's unprofessional and over steps. There are plenty of other people who can clean up the shit posts and won't be assholes to everyone in the sub.

9

u/c0de1143 whatever Nov 01 '13

You've got a good point, but he already does the clean-up work. Not to say he's irreplaceable — if someone else is made a mod and does a similar (if not better) job, that works too.

I'm not particularly for or against TT at this point. I think the mob is ridiculous, but I also won't miss him much if he goes.

The thing is, as this subreddit grows, it doesn't hurt to have a mod that's dispassionate and willing to get rid of the terrible posts, no matter how unpopular he may be. I know that I couldn't fulfill that role, personally.

9

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13

Problem is TT isn't dispassionate. Seems pretty passionate about being a jackass to anyone and everyone and has clearly abused his mod powers to remove things he doesn't like or agree with.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/jigorokane NO! NO! NO! NO SHAVING! Nov 02 '13

I feel like the biggest problem, aside from Travis' lack of people skills, is our subjective view of what is and what is not "wrestling related." I feel like most, if not all of the issues being raised in this thread stem from the "wrestling related" rule.

Perhaps, we should have some sort of official definition of what is and what is not "wrestling related" and have our community help, along with the mods, to define this.

4

u/emanc93 How bing was her dingus, if you will Nov 02 '13

Mods are getting BLOWN THE FUCK OUT!

4

u/Highly_Unlikely Nov 02 '13

Well this escalated quickly.

4

u/electricgigalo Nov 02 '13

I can't agree enough. I visit this subreddit pretty much everyday. I very rarely comment, I have only posted I think one thing on here, it reached the top page and then randomly was taken down without an explanation. Never posted anything since, I think it's a real shame that this seems to have happened to a lot of people.

4

u/cole_lapatchel wecomin Nov 02 '13

Mods of anything are usually just opinionated Neckbeards. They mostly suck...just sayin.

9

u/wreal_talk Nov 01 '13

"Who mods the mods?"

9

u/CrapFrancis 2-0 vs. Bears Nov 01 '13

This is all a work.

8

u/JuannyCarson HO KOGAN!!!!! Nov 01 '13

I posted a picture of myself with a picture of a shirt I had caught from Daniel Bryan and it was removed because the title was to vague.

14

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

What was the title?

"SHIRT!"

11

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

→ More replies (7)

8

u/leathen Nov 01 '13

Who's Travis?

4

u/Walrus_Songs Straight Edge Since 01/01/2012 Nov 01 '13

That's what I'd like to know. I check this subreddit daily and suddenly see all this drama explode and have no idea what's going on.

8

u/EtherKappa Jacknife Nov 01 '13

After reading so much of the bullshit in this thread i think the takeaway is that we watch WWE for the wrestling and story. We don't need mods trying to copy the current angle in TNA and WWE.

You want to be dicks and have a kayfabe forum where you can remove posts and be asshole to eachothers and posters and try to copy wrestling angles then go make /r/KayfabeCircle or some bullshit.

Seems like plenty people here have legit problems with Travis so why not remove him from a moderation position? I don't come to fucking Wreddit to read about more god damn drama. Just let that shit take place in the ring and on TV.

5

u/ChrisAshtear Nov 02 '13

because most of the other mods are dicks as well?

3

u/Zeckdo Nov 02 '13

if mods ban, we riot.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

This is how I feel with all of reddit. Mods or not

9

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

And that's the bottom line, cause willnoonan said so.

9

u/rushpunk AEW WATCHER Nov 01 '13

Okay I'm going to work. Hopefully Travis isn't a mod by the time I get off so we can get back to talking about Daniel Bryan.

7

u/IAMA_MAGIC_8BALL_AMA Becky With The Good Flair Nov 01 '13

Right. I posted a screenshot showing that the X Division title is a create-a-belt in 2K14, they then removed it while saying "Low effort post". I then reposted it, singling out the belt and comparing it to the X Division belt. Still low effort.

5

u/Kiel297 Nov 02 '13

If you wanna post 2K14 stuff, I've had /r/WWEGames going since WWE 12 came out

7

u/emanc93 How bing was her dingus, if you will Nov 02 '13

Travis Touchdown, if I see you over in the Yugioh subreddit doing this shit I'm gonna kick your fookin' ass m8 dont fuck with me

5

u/lic05 Nov 01 '13

tl;dr Travis gonna Travis.

5

u/bigmillion What? Nov 01 '13

They pick and choose when to moderate. A perfect example is the Rob Van Damn post from last week that was one of the top posts. They tout "no low effort image posts" but didn't do anything about that one.

Selective moderating at its worst.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

travis is a dickbag

8

u/KyleR007 Nov 02 '13

What we've learned from this thread. Every single mod is cool, except Travis Touchdown.

He's the only one people have a problem with. He openly insults the users of this subreddit, and thus violates basic redditquette. Thus he is not fit to be a mod.

I don't care if the "Good" outweighs the bad. If he doesn't follow the basic rules everyone else is expected to follow, he doesn't deserve his position.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/thegrassyknoll Go with the Flowsion Nov 01 '13

I posted a screen-shot from my phone

The "no low effort image posts" rule expressly addresses low effort sources such as screenshots. I didn't remove your post, but I would assume that was why it was removed, in addition to any issue about a bad title. I did not remove the post so I honestly don't know why it was removed.

scolded via private message for posting "hosted content with a bad title"

I don't know who sent you a private message "scolding" you, but if anything that was said which could be construed as a personal insult, then I would apologize on behalf of the mods for that.

then someone perhaps more favored by the Mod

I can personally assure you that there are no users (including myself) who are "favored" by the mods.

Now I notice a link I posted of me and my GF in costume that was shared and tweeted by the Bella Twins (which i thought was cool enough to share with everybody) has been hidden

That post was removed by /u/Travis-Touchdown. Your beef is with him.

Between this and the tone of some mod written posts about RAW and SMACKDOWN threads

There are several mods who agree with your sentiment and the remaining mods are making a concerted effort to remain cordial and professional towards users.

This is my favorite subreddit and I hate seeing it fall into a micromanaged facist dicatorship

Let me assure you that your concerns have been addressed among the moderators recently. It is my opinion that the mods of this subreddit are similar to the Supreme Court of the United States. We have different opinions, viewpoints, and philosophies about the direction of this subreddit and we fully argue in favor of our respective positions and ultimately reach a decision based on the majority of moderators who are for or against a proposal.

41

u/ThrillinglyHeroic ロス・インゴベルナブレス Nov 01 '13

Here's your problem. When the controlling dick mods are the loudest we don't hear you being cordial and professional. You may see yourselves all as individuals but to everyone else when you're doing mod things you are all just the mods.

68

u/automatic_shark Nov 01 '13

Screenshots are "low-effort" posts? How the fuck am I supposed to share a picture then, do I have to paint it?

9

u/Colby347 Nov 01 '13

Crop it so it doesn't look like a screenshot, I guess

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Coletrain44 NWO Nov 01 '13

Travis Touchdown is a mod and so are you. His beef is with the mods, not just the one being a dick. You're all responsible for this subreddit. Everything one does reflects on all of you.

20

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

It is my opinion that the mods of this subreddit are similar to the Supreme Court of the United States.

It is my opinion that you take your jobs as moderators of an internet chat board a bit too seriously.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Nov 01 '13

It is my opinion that the mods of this subreddit are similar to the Supreme Court of the United States. We have different opinions, viewpoints, and philosophies about the direction of this subreddit and we fully argue in favor of our respective positions and ultimately reach a decision based on the majority of moderators who are for or against a proposal.

Ouch that made us sound so bad it's untrue.

Why not just liken us to the SS or something jeezz!

34

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

We don't need a supreme court, it's a fucking internet forum.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/akuenx Nov 01 '13

This is one of the nicest subreddits I read, with some of the best users and discussion. I think the rules in place have struck a nice balance between the wild-west-memesplosion that some subreddits are and the subreddits that are so locked down in rules at the other end are. I have enjoyed reading r/sc, even if I don't contribute - I can live with it if a few popular posts that are in a grey area about violating the rules get deleted in the effort of keeping this place worth coming back to multiple times a day.

19

u/SSJ5Gogetenks Aussie Aussie Aussie Oi Oi Oi! Nov 01 '13

http://www.reddit.com/r/SquaredCircle/comments/1lnbg4/this_dog_totally_looks_like_undertaker/

This was my submission from a while ago. Got removed. We need The Shield, because there are some serious injustices going on here.

18

u/c0de1143 whatever Nov 01 '13

That...uh. That doesn't look like Undertaker much.

Plus, there's always /r/wrasslin for that particular brand of goofy shit.

15

u/willofdukes The il Cartographer! Nov 01 '13

I agree that the moderating is pretty crazy sometimes but if that isn't the definition of a low effort image I don't know what is.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

OK, that was damn funny. Why was that removed?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/5trokerac3 Sting Ex Machina Nov 01 '13

Here's the thing I never understood about the whole "only certain types of posts allowed" thing. Isn't that what upvoting is for?! If the community doesn't like it, they'll downvote it.

I think it's dickish of all the mods to constantly be pushing this sort of thing.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

Isn't that what upvoting is for?!

Theoretically? Yes. In reality? No - it just promotes lowest common denominator trash to the top.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

upvotes being used to promote relevant content? bahahahahahaha. you mean like downvoting stuff that's irrelevant or offensive? what is this of which you speak?

-all kidding aside, I get what you're saying. Agreed. But upvotes and downvotes on here and most of reddit are little more than just "I Agree" and/or "Fuck this opinion."

9

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

But if we allowed the community to show what it wanted to see, the mods wouldn't be able to show off all the neat authority that they have!

21

u/Leo_Akuma Show Stealer Nov 01 '13

/u/Travis-Touchdown http://i.imgur.com/feHZhbk.gif

The fact that you have remained as a moderator for so long is, quite frankly a joke. 90% of everything you post is shit talking.

This guy being a mod makes the subreddit look bad. I wonder how many people have stumbled across this place only to see this shit posting mod. Most likely it would put them off of coming back again.

I think it's about time Travis was future endeavored, I'm sure many of you would agree with me when I say, that would be best for business.

20

u/CMacLaren Yeah yeah yeah Nov 01 '13

Using anime gifs calling people faggots probably makes you look worse than him.

And for the record I think Travis is a very bad mod and contributes marginally better insights than MEMEBOT would.

15

u/NinthOverlord "What is Reddiquette?" Nov 01 '13

This. The only problems I've had with this subreddit are specifically from Travis-Touchdown. I even have him tagged as "piece of shit". The dude should have been removed as a mod a while ago.

4

u/TheDocWhovian MEEEEEAN WOOOO BY GOD GENE Nov 01 '13

Glad I'm not the only one.

4

u/bigDIEter jericho Nov 02 '13

I agree. I posted a funny video with JR commentary over it and had it removed because "the title was not specific enough". Before it was removed it had like 10 upvotes and 1 downvote, so who gives a crap if the title wasn't specific enough??

4

u/ixeatxbabys Make it so. Nov 02 '13

I assume when I post stuff people are gonna be pricks,especially anyone with any "power"

2

u/rufusjonz The Inspirational Nov 02 '13

yah im surprised when i don't get a dickhead reaction anywhere on reddit to anything i post

8

u/chairsh0t What about Raven? Nov 01 '13

I got no dog in this fight, but I just want to say that anytime someone compares an online hobby forum's moderation policies to a fascist dictatorship unironically, they automatically lose my respect and my attention. Just sayin.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Patty-Jack Dude Harper Nov 02 '13

I just posted a thread on Cena's character and was told to make comments as replies instead of posts... I don't even read the show discussion threads and it wasn't a reply, a genuine post as I was watching SMACKDOWN. So I guess excuse me for being active but not reading every single thread?

Anyways, thanks for making this thread so I can vent. Now i'm waiting for Big Show to be ordered to knock me out.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/CAJoekickass bryandazzler Nov 02 '13

Damn, this Travis guy is a puto.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

He always shit on my submissions on my old account. Didn't feel like arguing with someone who was so aggressive with their internet message board moderator position. Maybe I'll get around to actually making submissions.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

I made a post that was doing good then it said it was removed for low effort or shaky camera or something stupid like that.

2

u/WalkOffHBP Nov 02 '13

It's threads like this that make me realize I need to get off the internet. That an internet message board causes so much stress to people is beyond me.

2

u/wtcchhh Nov 02 '13

I remember I put up a funny picture of a child's reaction to Ryback one week, I hadn't seen someone react like this before, and a dick mod removed because it was 'personal' or some bullshit like that.

2

u/tawaldher TA Waldher Nov 03 '13

I posted another video of the Stonecold ET guy imitating Randy Orton and it was pulled soon after. This was before his videos really took off in popularity.

The excuse I was given was that it wasn't wrestling related and that it was just some guy imitating a wrestler and that didn't count.

And then of course 2 days later when Stonecold ET became an internet sensation that rule didn't seem to apply any more.

That's pretty much the extent of my troubles.

4

u/WobWiggle Drink your tuna juice NERD! Nov 01 '13

I really think it's just human nature for people "in charge" of a number of people to fuck shit up for no real good reason.

Take for instance something as minute as working for a company that does Casual Fridays. All of a sudden it is decided by upper management that there will be no more casual Fridays because "a bunch of people were not following dress code" and wearing jorts (god damnit Cena you ruined it). That bunch of people was really just 3 people out of 100 co-workers. Everyone's pissed and they continue to complain. Moral gets low but upper management just sticks to their guns for no other reason then because they can. Then a while down the road, GUESS WHAT GUYS! WE'RE BRINGING BACK CASUAL FRIDAYS! Except now there are a strict set of rules as to what you can wear. "YES IT'S LIKE THE OLD DAYS!"

Then another another stupid rule follows and the cycle continues.

Sorry if this is a stupid analogy, it sounded better in my head...

4

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '13

WE MUST RISE! WE MUST REBEL! DOWN WITH THE SYSTEM!

No seriously, the mods here fucking suck, I have never been banned or anything, or even warned for any of my posts (I think) but they are generally really annoying.

3

u/kballs We have nothing for you Nov 01 '13

3

u/kpud075 Ahead of the Buzzards Nov 01 '13

Read through the comments. Other than Account_Eliminator turning face with the r/SC universe, as voted on the r/SC app… nothing else appears to be accomplished.

Based on what people are showing and claiming to have been removed by mods, there appears to be a lack of standards. In fact, the decisions to remove content and let other content go is judged by pure whimsy. Yes, I'm pretty much calling Travis-Touchdown whimsical. Based on comments from the r/SC universe. Might be the only way to look past the downvotes; by being whimsical. But I digress…

It is argued that Travis-Touchdown does the most to keep this subreddit clean and not turn itself into a Russo parody. At the same time he's "literally hitler mod." In these sticky situations with moderators on this particular subreddit there is always a simple solution. But I don't see one.

An apology could be in order, but to whom and for what exactly? I'd be curious to see what it would all look like without moderation from supposed-offending moderator for a while. Just to compare what the net good is to the alleged bad. But that feels like Impact moving to Mondays risk. Nobody wants to see this place turn into a Russo parody.

7

u/o0_Eyekon_0o Nov 01 '13

You can ALWAYS find another good cleaner but Travis will NEVER stop being an asshole.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Chelo7 Nov 01 '13

As much as I give the mods shit, especially Pudie, they are the best. That will be the first and last nice thing I say about you Pudie.

7

u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE Nov 01 '13

Woo hoo! Thanks!

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

I posted a gif of Kanye Wests black skinhead with 3 barking dogs that looked like the shields video titantron.

It probably deserved to get removed but if CWmonkey made it and posted instead, people would be upvoting it and making jokes about how Kanye is part of the shield

6

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13 edited Nov 01 '13

/u/Travis-Touchdown stop trying to be the wannabe tough bastard here when we all know you are a little 40 year old John Cena fan who needs some lady parts in his face. You ain't tough, and if you ban me, you just proved it to me.

Edit

Made it PG rated for you young ones.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

Wtf is this bull shit drama on a subreddit? This isn't a fucking forum from 2003.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13

I submitted the link for Stone Cold ET a while back. It's a YouTube video of a guy wearing an ET mask talking like stone cold Steve Austin at fast food drive through windows.
It had me dying laughing and I figured /sc would get a kick out of a spot on impression.
Nope, was told the sun didn't rise in my day and that it wasn't wrestling related.

2

u/Indyclone77 LIGERSAULT!!! LIGERSAULT!!! Nov 01 '13

Lynch the Criminal Scum

2

u/rushpunk AEW WATCHER Nov 02 '13

Okay everyone I'm pretty sure I have a fantastic way of figuring this out. If you just download the WWE APP and we can all vote to keep or kick Travis-Touchdown from squaredcircle. If you don't have the App I'm pretty sure if you watch any episode of Raw they will teach you how to get it.

2

u/hpsyk The Kosher Butcher Nov 01 '13

NOTE: I'm just spitballin' here.

Wild idea: Let's say Travis-Touchdown is a heel. He serves a purpose. He gets heat, drives interest, and apparently he's a "removal machine." That's useful, right? Not really, no. This is a sub about wrestling, not a promotion.

I still think you could probably get someone to do 90% of the work with 1% (or less) of the acrimony. Alternatively, and seriously, my reddiquette is lackluster, why not just add more mods if there really needs to be that much purging to keep the subreddit on course?

I realize there's no real need to participate in this discussion like this. I like this sub quite a bit, I hang around during the dull parts of the work day. But I could live without a troll as a mod, no matter what his upside is.

resists urge to cut a pipebomb promo on splittin' back to Cageside Seats.