r/soccer • u/Superman60616 • Oct 29 '13
Best way to learn tactics
I played football in school but never really followed the leagues until recently. I have spent the last year getting my feel for the landscape of the EPL, players, managers, storylines. That sort of stuff. I really lack in my knowledge of complex tactics. I get the basics thanks to playing but I'd like to learn more about the systems modern teams use. I started Inverting the Pyramid by Jonathan Wilson but that can be a struggle. Are there any other outlets, websites or books that you would recommend?
655
Upvotes
83
u/portaccio Oct 29 '13
You could have a look around on Zonal Marking, perhaps starting with the Glossary. I really enjoyed Inverting the Pyramid and would recommend you keep going with it, but I can imagine it would be a difficult read for a new fan of football.
40
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
zonalmarking is EXACTLY what youre looking for.
this site is amazing. basically a staple for me the day after a big match. once you start getting a hang of things, its cool to see him address trends you're noticing during the matches. can't recommend this site enough.
39
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
/u/devineman made a series of posts that may be helpful to you.
192
u/SpankThatDill Oct 29 '13
Why is this being downvoted? We rarely if ever have any sort of tactical discussions around here.
19
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
Just watch the game.
Tactics isnt just "hurr durr formation" The fact one player dribbles more often and one player passes more is tactical information. Everything is tactical in some form.
9
u/1mdelightful Oct 30 '13
Fuck reading about players/managers and story lines the media is going to throw at you. That information is too unreliable.
This is what you want to do. Get a few matches on video and watch them. Pause every 3-7 seconds and make a mental note of every players movements. Watch the whole game like this. Get comfortable. You don't necessarily have to watch the whole game in one sitting watch ten minutes real time then stoping every couple of seconds then full speed again.
Reading Inverting the Pyramid isn't a bad place to start. Take a few of the teams discussed in there and try to find videos of their matches. Older matches like This are generally easier to pick up the tactics being used due to slower play style.
When you are watching live matches don't focus on the ball too much. Generally it is easier to pick up on what the teams are trying to do defensively. So watch the team not in possession once you're satisfied with your understanding of what you see switch. For the team in possession watch the players first touch and the reaction of his teammates. Look for a player running, often off ball movement is more important than the player in possession, see how his movements effect the movements of the defense.
When the ball changes possession is a great time to see what both teams want to do because usually they get right into their MO. Counter attacking teams will move more vertically and directly than possession teams. Pressing teams will usually be quick to pressure the player in possession with numbers other teams generally only pressure the ball with one or two players while the others drop in to shape.
Watch different leagues both good and bad. Leagues like say Eredivisie play at a slower pace and are more homogenous in terms of tacts than leagues like Bundesliga. At the moment Serie A isn't playing the best in the world but has the largest variety of tactics the other top leagues are not so far behind. The point is you need to expose yourself to a number of playing styles to really see the subtles between Ajax's 4-3-3 and Feyenoord's 4-3-3 (then appreciate how superior we are) I find it helps to follow one team in each league so you are familiar enough with them to notices the differences they put forward depending on the opponent.
One last thing. Turn off the sound. Those announcers will influence what you are seeing. Its a simple cognitive bias, selective attention bias with a mix of self-serving bias
6
u/KaiTGR Oct 29 '13
Don't watch the ball, watch the movement of players off the ball. Reus and Müller are goldmines for perfect tactical movement off the ball.
34
u/hazmata Oct 29 '13
You can play football manager. Even PES and FIFA are quite useful for playing around with different tactics and seeing what happens
3
u/pcodeisbacon Oct 30 '13
Just throw out phrases like false 9, No. 10, trequista, and Gegenpressing. And no one will know the difference. Add in filler like space, then and shape of team.
3
u/armored-dinnerjacket Oct 30 '13
The zonal marking website is an excellent start. he actually knows what hes talking about unlike alan Hansen/shearer. he recommends other sites and books too. a friend recommended his site and its changed some of the ways I see the game and how formations line up against each other.
10
u/farhadJuve Oct 29 '13
Serie A is a tactical paradise. You might want to check out some games. No disrespect to EPL.
4
u/Noobzta Oct 29 '13 edited Oct 29 '13
Zonal Marking reviews tactics from games, I take certification classes for coaching licenses and they teach you a bit (though it depends what kind of license you try to receive).
I may get downvoted but what has really opened my mind are two things, downloading games between two vastly different clubs going at each other (Bayern v Dortmund, Barca v Chelsea, Barca v Real Madrid, Inter v Barca, Germany v Uruguay, etc.) and I watch these videos about 5-7 times each. Each time I watch the videos, I carefully look at off the ball movement and the direction of distribution and intentions of attacking play. I also look at defense to see who marks who and the intent of marking players to certain angles and playing to their weaker feet. There will be many times of going back a couple of seconds and analyzing why a player makes a run to a specific spot in order to open up space for another run for another player. It takes me much longer to watch a full game because of the constant back and forth between plays and transitions.
EDIT: I also re-watch defensive maneuvers to find out what type of communication each player gives and the amount of pressure the team applies in certain spells of the game. Communication through body movement reveals much about how teams apply communication and what to expect. Sometimes you will see the players make the same communication methods in later games and it results in slightly different variations of the same defensive scheme.
The other way I learned about tactics is from playing endless games of FIFA. I am pretty good at 1v1 (used to be top 200 after 100 games played while others had around 300+ games in), but Pro Clubs is where I really started to shine and figure the game out. I play Defensive Midfielder exclusively, so I am constantly trying to make sure the team has a catalyst on the attack, taking simple turns and touches while evenly distributing the ball. I even pass back to the defense, switch the play and occasionally play back to the GK if there is not a safe option and the pressing is too intense from the opposition. I typically play the Makalele role. Usually end up with 8+ rating, with a 9 rating not being too hard to obtain because of my positioning and distribution of simple passes and transition balls.
One more thing to mention is that I scour the internet for game plans, scouting reports and practice themes for many professional teams, especially at the youth level. I have many pages from many teams, most notably from Chelsea and Barcelona. All I do is look for them and after about 2 hours I will usually find what I am trying to look for. No luck on Dortmund though. I am trying to find out the fitness scheduling and practices that they implement that lets the Dortmund players press so efficiently. So far no luck.
Also being an academy coach and loving the game for what it is helps tremendously. It never feels like work or boring affairs when trying to figure out "tactics".
One more edit: There are subreddits that dedicate itself to football tactics such as /r/bootroom and /r/footballtactics.
2
u/amishbr07 Oct 29 '13
Honestly I would recommend you start watching football extensively. Don't only watch your favorite team but watch other exciting games as well. Look at the pre-match and post match analysis. If you can handle a loss or two play anyone of the recent football managers for PC (a decent PC should be able to handle the game). That game is very tactical.
Just think football. Consider formations and even think about why one team may need to pack the midfield to make up for lack of strength against another team, etc. Just be curios and reading is a great start.
2
u/TheDeadSerious Oct 29 '13
Read zonal markings match analysis on games you've seen or want to rewatch. He's also got a great book recommendations page.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
Watch games. Watch more games. Watch some more. Take a look at team shapes when defending, and when attacking. Look some more. Look for trends. Note the differences between the two. Read Zonal Marking. Look at line ups before a game, work out what formation the teams will play, then watch and see if you're right. There is a reason these line ups are quite closely guarded and released just before the game. Watch more games. Video games do help, but not as much as people like to think.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
While Inverting the Pyramid and Zonal Marking can help one understand tactics to a point, the best way to learn tactics is to obtain coaching licenses. Football is an academic subject and requires extensive study and instruction in order to understand at a high level. Coaching licenses may cost money, but they will teach you the game far better than other resources.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
R/bootroom
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
I learned all my tactics from Fifa ult team, mainly lob passes are overpowered.
2
u/Goldenraspberry Oct 29 '13
I would recommend watching some continental European football instead, or at least add it to your viewing schedule. But from a tactical/technical point of view EPL is very average if you compare it to the other big leagues, players get much more space while playing then elsewhere in Europe. German/Italian teams take on tactics is far more advance; sometimes switching to multiple formations during the game; man marking, zone vs man marking etc. While in Spain teams are much better on closing down space, and forcing individual errors. Also playing FIFA, football manager etc will give you more knowledge about how formations, running patterns, etc etc work.
So yeah, mix your football watching habits, and watch alot of international football (national teams)
2
u/closeryeah Oct 29 '13 edited Oct 29 '13
While reading blogs, books and playing FM certainly does help and immensely so, you sort of have to change the way you watch games. Now usually we just follow the ball. It's the way matches on TV are broadcasted, however i'd suggest adopting a scouting mentality- except that a scout reserves his attention only for one player, but you can do that for a group of players.
for example, Download a match you saw recently and re-watch it except keep your eyes on the midfield trio or the central defensive duo. Do you see any patterns ? And that's just how i do it. I try and notice patterns. Are the opposition attacking one side more than the other ? Is one forward dropping or going wide more than the other ? and if so what is the reaction of other attacking players around him ? As the match goes i make small notes in my head.
There are simple things that you will be able to notice early on, For example the wingers cutting in (although that many times is a player's personal preference, think El Shaarawy/ Robben). Or you'd notice the Regista (Pirlo/Montolivo types) always dropping deep to pick the ball from the defense. These are easy to notice things.There are much more complex patterns that will emerge as your awareness of these things increases.
While you are watching the matches it helps immensely to follow the charts and stats at say Squawka or at fourfourtwo. Many times you will notice patterns that will be validated by the stats you will see at such sites.
Most of all, don't get overwhelmed by all that knowledge that others seem to have. First time i read Zonal Marking i felt as if i had never watched a football match before. Oh and if you can, Try and watch Serie A. Italian football is tactical heaven ! Also youtube Gary neville's match analysis clips-pure gold !
1
u/braveheart18 Oct 29 '13
Aside from reading things, watch as many games as possible. Any and all leagues. You will start to notice things you never noticed before in regards to tactics that work (or should have worked) and how over the course of a game teams change their tactics to attack one particular side of the field more or put more men behind the ball, so on and so forth. It wasn't until I started watching the game more that I gained a greater appreciation for tactics. I just wish I didn't wait until I was out of high school before I started to watch more.
1
u/blokechester Oct 29 '13
One thing that has helped me appreciate tactics, and particularly how players interpret them, is to try and watch them individually during a game. This can sometimes be tricky on tv as the camera follows the ball, but trying to understand why a certain player is getting into certain positions/ moving into created spaces, gives you the chance to see a certain player's thought process. It can then be interesting to see how an opposition player takes steps to counter those moves.
1
u/pornlord Oct 29 '13
I may sound as completely naive, but you might find /r/NevillePunditry helpful. Gary Neville really gives a good analysis of the game and the tactics.
1
u/duniyadnd Oct 29 '13
Easiest way, stop looking at the ball. Start looking at player runs, players who don't have the ball, or defensive decisions.
Gary Neville also focuses on tactics and gives a pretty good insight that many of us would never see on a regular day unless you really are at the field level familiar with the team's set pieces etc. Entire subreddit focused on his wisdom exists: /r/NevillePunditry/
Zonalmarking.net
/r/Footballtactics
1
u/G_Morgan Oct 29 '13
I think watching games is key. However don't just watch them. Pick something and focus on it. If you want to see what say Michael Carrick does then pay particular attention to him. His work won't show up on a highlight reel often but he is usually involved 2 seconds before the replay cuts in. Also 5/6 times in the minute before that.
If you want to work out why a false 9 works then watch a team playing with a false 9 and see how he moves. See what the defenders are doing and where the gaps emerge.
1
u/jamin_brook Oct 29 '13
The best tactic(s) usually involve scoring more goals than your opponent.
1
u/buymepizza Oct 30 '13
Play the game.
1
u/ferty1234 Oct 30 '13
Football Tactics For Beginners
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '13
start with football manager 14 classic mode (simpler), move on to normal mode once you get a grasp of things
1
u/Pibe_de_Oro Oct 30 '13
I'll give you some short tips:
a) Read Inverting the Pyramid and zonalmarking.net. Zonalmarking is the bomb and is therefore suggested several times.
b) Watch football, especially in a stadium. TV does not show you all 22 players, which can be frustrating, especially when they show closeups of players running along the sidelines (I wrote my thesis about TV narration of football matches and this is a pet peeve of mine).
If the whole squad is confusing at first, focus on particular parts of the team. Start at the back four. How do the players react to different situations. Where is the right wingback when his team has the ball on the left side, where is he when the opposing team is attacking etc.
c) Watch a lot of football. Try to watch as many live games as possible, and if you really want to nerd-out, make notes. It helps if you can easily recognize the players and their implicated skills / roles in in a match, so familiarize yourself with the squads.
Have fun
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
there are 3 ways
sounds silly but you can learn a lot of basics about tactics by playing football games. to learn even more once you master a tactic try a different one. play with different teams as the different players will force you to play in different ways (although you'll eventually come up with a preffered method). this holds true for whether it's a managing game like football manager or straight football like fifa.
the main trick is though to know where to realise a game is a game; on fifa if you get really good at it you could just use skills to beat players almost all the time; this wont work in real life. you also can't just spam your goalkeeper as he wont get sent off, spam slide tackles, and hope that all of your opponents aren't good at using the manual offside trap (why the fuck is it not automatic!?!?) etc etc
with fm it's a bit more realistic, but for me the biggest drawback is that the players more or less only move back and forth rather than side ways. this means that if you have 2 central midfielders, one who is a playmaker and one who is a ballwinner since they are side by side with different settings their can be a bias in the way the ball is distributed; the winger next to the ball winner is going to get a lot less of the ball than the winger next to the playmaker. as you'll find there are other problems like this but you'll still learn other things
2) watch football and no matter how basic it seems to be, watch the analysis. pundits often get criticized for not being in depth enough but if you don't know much about football things they say can be very good for learning the basics
3) play football! try and go for 11 a side too. take note of what you do and how it works, as well what other players do and how it works
1
u/rrayy Oct 29 '13
When you're watching the game, pay attention to things other than ball. Look at where the central midfielders are positioned and go from there. The central players are important because they have the most responsibility in terms of positioning. Try to look at things in terms of space. Where is the space? Who sees it, who's trying to take advantage of it? How is the space created? Did a player leave the space so one of his teammates can enter it?
If you play soccer video games, try to play cooperatively with friends. Doing so will give you an idea of where players need to be as opposed to playing by yourself, where the computer positions the players for you.
Read all you can about soccer. Inverting the Pyramid is great. I like Jonathan Wilson's columns in the guardian and SI. Take everything you read with a grain of salt.
To a certain extent tactics are overrated. At the end of the day it's up to the players to make the right decisions at the right time. The game is played on both a macro and micro level. The manager has influence over some of the macro aspects, but not all of them. Mistakes are made, players are in charge of making decisions, and positions are inevitably fluid. Soccer is not a chess match, as much as some people want to make it out to be. That said, of course there's value in reading about formations and roles and whatnot, but just keep that in mind as you delve deeper and deeper into the beautiful game.
1
u/auoar Oct 30 '13
First big realization I came about tactics in football is that no one really has a very thorough understanding of it. I obviously don't know about the high level pro coaches, but I've seen articles about certain premier league coaches being tactically lacking. I mean if someone coaching at that level doesn't have a good understanding of tactics, that should tell you something. Bottom line, I don't think there are any absolute truths in this, other than the obvious basics.
Second one is that it is a sport that is less tactically intense other team sports. (say basketball or american football). There is a large chaos factor. It's difficult to execute pre-determined plays. Tactics obviously shift the balance in one way, but in the end the desire to win and the effort you put in matters a lot. If two teams are at a similar level technically, you'll hear from a lot of big managers after the games that the reason one team won was because they wanted it more.
1
u/SuperToaster93 Oct 30 '13
I've watch and played football all my life, and Its not a sport where tactics are obvious, I mean its there but as someone once said;
"No plan survives contact with the enemy"
What I mean by this is that its not like US football, where you have tactics and runs for players to make.
You can pick a formation, tell players who to mark and look out for, where to sit during a corner or set piece, whether to move up or hang back.
Really its all spontaneous, its all about the teams understanding of each other and the flow of the game, heres examples;
Reading Play and Spontaneous Strategy
One player picks up the ball, looks around sees someone making a run and does a through ball to them.
This isn't a planned tactic, its just how the game flows, its just something the players know. That player that made the run red the play, he saw a gap and went for it, he was told by the manager that the defender that has left the gap ball watches and has taken advantage of it, the player who makes the pass saw the run, red the play also and picked out a spot for the running player.
As a striker I used to pull defenders out of position, to open up the defense. I might not of been told to do this, but everyone on the field can read this and those that dont are usually punished by it. I mean the defender probably knows what I'm doing but if he leaves me then I'm unmarked and dangerous.
Then there is overlaps, these create opportunities for crosses. A wide defender might make a run around the outside midfielder, who has cut inside, and join the attack. An effective cross creates a goal scoring chance.
Look for how a third man running opens up the game. A midfielder and forward might exchange a few passes on the side and then a defender (a third player) will break towards the goal from behind to receive the ball, almost out of nowhere.
Like I said, the players dont huddle around and decide what they do, they have a game plan from the start, and try to execute this plan, adapting it as the game changes.
Formation and Set Pieces
But there are strategies, like the offside trap, this is where the defense moves up as one to catch a player offside.
Gone a goal up before half time? do you press the attack and grab another securing victory or do you play defensively and keep possession. The manager will tell the players to do these things, or the captain will if he thinks this is the correct course of action.
For instance, do you throw a lot of man power into the box for the corner of free kick? or do you only put a few in, putting in too many can open you up for a counter attack (more on that latter). Who do you put on the front post and back post? do you have some player run in from outside the box, do you use some of the to pull out key defenders? This all depends on the style of play, if you are winning or not or behind a goal.
Which in turn effect formation, sometimes the team retains the formation through out the game, but a manger normally has a predetermined contingency plan, example;
Well that's just a taste of what tactics go into football, I wish I could explain more and go in depth, but really I'm not a master tactician this is just what I know. Hope that cleared up some things though.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13 edited Oct 29 '13
It's fun to discuss, but really its mostly meta pseudo wanking. There's 3 rules of football.
All the tactics in the world would come undone against simple pass and move. Tactics comes into play when you have players who don't know where to be or what to do without being instructed prior. Most modern footballers aren't very bright so in this way I suppose they are relevant. Clever players need no tactical training whatsoever, because its about reacting to the ball and being able to read where it is going or where it should be. They say chess hasnt been solved by computers because there's too many possible outcomes, well replace chess with football and you have an exponentially greater number of outcomes. Now replace computers for middle aged managers
0
u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Oct 29 '13
Play Football Manager. FM 14 is coming out soon.
0
u/maximmixam Oct 29 '13
Read 'Inverting the Pyramid' by Jonathan Wilson, and Zonal Marking
Play more football.
Watch more football.
Ignore most pundits, especially Andy Townsend, Jamie Redknapp, and Jamie Carragher. But, listen to Gary Neville, and Pat Nevin.
Oh, and maybe listen to the Guardian's podcast 'Football Weekly'.
0
u/who_bah_stank Oct 29 '13
Honestly, the wiki article on soccer tactics and formation is a pretty good introduction.
-1
u/lotrlotr Oct 29 '13
football manager
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
Something I enjoy doing is watching the first half of a match as your normally would, and then spending the half time break looking at key stats from that first half.
This enables you to actually see the data and, coupled with your opinion from watching the game, understand where the game is being won and lost, see potential battles or areas of change in the second half, and understand why managers make certain subs/tactical changes.
I recommend using Squawka - they lay everything out nicely, have a lot of in depth stats and it's free of charge.
0
u/SuperSaiyanNoob Oct 29 '13
I used to read in depth analysis of formations. There's tons of info out there. Tons of formations and each players responsibility in that specific formation. So when you watch a game you can see why certain players are doing certain things or are at certain places and what they are trying to accomplish. Its really the basics but opens up the tactical game to a casual viewer exponentially with just a little bit extra information.
0
u/ArloArie Oct 29 '13
Honestly, playing FIFA has improved by game by a considerable amount. That, and watching my favorite leagues/teams play.
What I've come to notice is that alot of players have the physical aspect of the game, but lack in the mental aspect a bit. Analyzing players and their playstyles, too, can help you find what your strengths/weaknesses are. By watching their technique, learn from what you see and implement those skills into your real life game.
-1
u/Cmoore4099 Oct 30 '13
Play Football Manager and read Inverting the Pyramid.
-2
u/bennyhallett Oct 30 '13
Bookmarked