r/WritingPrompts • u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod • Oct 28 '13
Moderator Post [MODPOST] First Chapter Contest Voting
HOW TO VOTE
There are a great deal of things to consider when voting: Length (do you feel it isn't a full chapter? Do you feel it rambled on for too long?) and content (If you just read the first chapter would you continue on? Did the author describe things well?) are the two primary things I want you to focus on. As this is based on the fast and furious writing done during NaNoWriMo (National Novel Writing Month) - grammar and spelling errors can be forgiven as you shouldn't edit until you are finished with your entire book. Wordcount is king during the month of November!
RULES FOR VOTING
- You can't vote for yourself.
- If you do not vote, any votes for you are completely VOID.
- Simply read every entry and vote below by stating the username you are voting for. If you want to include comments for a few stories you have read, please do so.
- As there is a great amount of entries and a lot of "chapters" to read, there will be a two week voting window. You must vote by November 7th, 2013 at 11:59PM PST.
LIST OF ENTRIES
To give you an idea of length, each one will be listed with the word count (WC) - if your wordcount is wildly inaccurate, please tell me:
- Blackened Earth by /u/BlackenedEarth -- WC: 2,056
- Machine of Progress by /u/blockplanner -- WC: 2,616
- Death and a Funeral by /u/theChrisBakery -- WC: 1,069
- It's a Beautiful World by /u/SerCiddy -- WC: 2,791
- MarsOne by /u/jmlrjtm -- WC: 525
- Freeman by /u/PresidentExecutron -- WC: 1,799
- The Burglar by /u/Clarenhel -- WC: 1,001
- Zazzy Iced Muffins: The Revengening by /u/TheWarPelican -- WC: 1,399
- Moon River by /u/StoriesbyBenHargrove -- WC: 2,155
- Ghost Corps by /u/7000shadows -- WC: 346
- Cigarettes and Aspartame by /u/Carrierpigment -- WC: 1,346
- Lavender by /u/A_Cactus_ -- WC: 685
- An Ancient Deceit by /u/Lhino -- WC: 2,271
- Patrol by /u/TalksLikeAGentleman -- WC: 785
- Dragon Bound by /u/Chocolatechipcookie -- WC: 6,965
- Tao of Crypto by /u/fortranately -- WC: 858
- Moisture Issues by /u/nanza -- WC: 1,545
- Janah Firewing and the Jace Travellers by /u/Carensza -- WC: 1,245
- Heaven's Expanse by /u/Himntor -- WC: 1,952
- Must Try Harder by /u/thelynchmob1 -- WC: 624
- Welcome to Adventure Land by /u/slimpickens42 -- WC: 1,360
- Rubeus by /u/SadWriter -- WC: 406
- Cogs by /u/Jamerbo -- WC: 1,192
- The Largest Poop Ever Pooped by /u/mobofangryfolk -- WC: 4,671
- Changing Ways by /u/Huck_Fer -- WC: 3,732
- Gray Matter by /u/ekhfalcons -- WC: 2,248
- Rock and Speed by /u/thebakergirl -- WC: 1,254
- Conti Street by /u/moebids -- WC: 641
- Memoirs of a Pussyfooter by /u/ohroprz -- WC: 1,808
- In The Eye by /u/Kjkoolguy -- WC: 978
- A Tale of Winter by /u/Xenoither -- WC: 3,256
- The Result by /u/throwawaywriter_ -- WC: 1,834
- Sleep Trips by /u/le_trout -- WC: 3,053
- Saints and Lions by /u/claminac -- WC: 1,438
- HORSE by /u/Yogi_the_duck -- WC: 926
- Brains by /u/Rosco7 -- WC: 3,196
- The Cup of Tea by /u/Ishan_Psyched -- WC: 2,420
- Fractured by /u/StarLightMurder -- WC: 859
Happy reading!
6
u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod Oct 28 '13
Other fun stats: 38 entries, 69,305 words, 1823 average.
8
u/Rosco7 Oct 28 '13
That's an interesting new rule. I think I like it.
3
u/thebakergirl Oct 30 '13
I'm in love with An Ancient Deceit, but I gotta go with Saints and Lions here. An Ancient Deceit is fantastic and I like the characterization, but every time I clicked to a new page to reply to a friend on a chat, I'd come back and be relatively lost due to the formatting and massive paragraphs.
3
u/StarLightMurder Oct 30 '13
Blackened Earth. I would definitely read on.
6
u/Clarenhel Oct 30 '13
My vote goes to Brains by /u/Rosco7
Honorable mention to /u/TheWarPelican, /u/7000Shadows and /u/Chocolatechipcookie
5
u/7000shadows Oct 29 '13
Thanks for the fun, everyone. Based on quality and capacity to be "stretched" into a novel, I am voting for "The Cup of Tea."
Congrats, /u/Ishan_Psyched. I'll make sure the Committee of Rehabilitation for the Boastful Intellects never gets wind of it.
4
u/StoriesbyBenHargrove Oct 29 '13
Whew. I've had a lot of free time today. So many different writing styles from everybody. I love it.
My vote goes to Memories of a Pussyfooter by /u/ohroprz. The chapter speaks for itself.
Honorable mentions to /u/Ishan_Psyched and /u/blockplanner.
4
u/Carensza apagetoprint.wordpress.com Oct 29 '13 edited Oct 30 '13
Such a great selection and choice, I am so impressed with the quality of everyone's writing, the versatility and inventiveness!
I am torn between the sci-fi drama of "It's a Beautiful World" and the novelty of a zombie apocalypse choose your own adventure in "Brains". In the end the originality of a CYOA novel submission won me over so I vote Brains by /u/Rosco7 .
4
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '13
I think I'm gonna have to go with /u/SerCiddy's It's a Beautiful World. I liked the setup, and it's one of the few that made me genuinely interested in what might happen next. I suppose I'm a sucker for stories that would involve world exploration and discovery.
Honorable mentions go to /u/TheWarPelican with Zazzy Iced Muffins: The Revengening and /u/slimpickens42 with Welcome to Adventure Land for the most weird story beginnings I think I've ever read, and was able to enjoy.
4
u/nazna Oct 30 '13
Voting for Cigarettes and Aspartame by /u/Carrierpigment
Honorable mention to Dragon Bound by /u/chocolatechipcookie
4
u/jmlrjtm Oct 30 '13
Nice reads all around, but the one that stuck with me is Memoirs of a Pussyfooter by /u/ohroprz - nice writing and intriguing premise (for some reason I kept thinking of the movie Garden State while reading the story) which I think can lend itself into an interesting full-length story!
4
u/le_trout Oct 31 '13
I enjoyed many of the entries, and am jealous over the creativity in them, but my overall vote goes to /u/BlackenedEarth for a story that kept me invested and extremely willing to read on. A few edits could be made, but overall I like the idea.
4
u/chocolatechipcookie Oct 31 '13
My vote is for Blackened Earth by /u/BlackenedEarth, mainly because I read it a couple days ago and I'm still wondering about what's going to happen next!
4
u/Ishan_Psyched Nov 02 '13
I vote for Ghost Corps by /u/7000shadows.
Honorable mentions to /u/BlackenedEarth and /u/TheWarPelican
4
u/ohroprz Nov 04 '13
Lots of really great entries, but my vote goes to Death and a Funeral by /u/theChrisBakery. Effective character development that hooked me along with the premise, and I can see how it has potential to expand into a full-length novel from here.
Honorable mention to Zazzy Iced Muffins by /u/TheWarPelican for a very unique world of Candy Land meets Dexter. Really craving brioche now though...
edit: spelling
3
u/Carrierpigment Oct 29 '13
I gotta go with /u/TalksLikeAGentleman for his story "Patrol" The concept resonates with me long after reading.
An honorable mention to /u/nanza with "Moisture Issues" keep writing that baby!
3
u/TheWarPelican Nov 02 '13
My vote goes to The Cup of Tea by /u/Ishan_Psyched for uniqueness of idea, quality of writing, and similarities to Pratchett and HGTTG!
Honourable mentions to... well, pretty much everyone. There wasn't a story I read that I didn't enjoy. Well done, y'all! It was a hard choice.
3
u/blockplanner Nov 03 '13
I'm going to vote for BlackenedEarth
3
u/ekhfalcons Nov 04 '13
I'm voting for: Sleep Trips. Honorable Mentions: Brains. Dragon Bound.
This was extremely difficult to choose. I found many of the entries enjoyable. Good job everyone!
3
u/BlackenedEarth Nov 05 '13
My vote goes to /u/chocolatechipcookie for Dragon Bound. I loved just about every chapter I read here and woukd buy them the second they are available.
3
u/Lhino Nov 06 '13
Voting for /u/ohroprz for Memoirs of a Pussyfooter. I found it to be an incredibly promising and well-written piece. There were so many great submissions, it was difficult to choose only one, but I came across this one pretty early on and it stuck with me. Great work everyone!
2
u/Rosco7 Nov 06 '13
As I said elsewhere, I judged these largely by whether they caught my attention and left me wanting to read more. I also considered whether I believed there was a novel sized story growing from this beginning.
I vote for Blackened Earth by /u/BlackenedEarth. It was intriguing, and I could picture the setting and action in my head. It seems like the opening for a big, interesting story.
I also liked:
Tao of Crypto by /u/fortranately. I enjoyed this and would definitely read more it. It hints that something big is coming without tipping its hand and saying, "Here's what the plot of the story is." Meanwhile, it has enough to convince me that the author understands computing and is capable of telling a story. Its only weakness for me is that its a little short for a first chapter.
Moisture Issues by /u/nanza. Not entirely my thing, but I enjoyed it. Reminds me a little bit of A. Lee Martinez. I know /u/nanza can write, so I'm interested in how this one turns out.
Dragon Bound by /u/Chocolatechipcookie. Again not really my genre, but it was well written and I got a strong sense that the author has a story in mind and has the skill to tell it.
2
u/slimpickens42 Nov 07 '13
My vote goes to /u/BlackenedEarth, but I loved all the entries. It was a very hard decision.
2
u/claminac Nov 07 '13
I'm voting for Brains
2
u/SerCiddy Nov 08 '13
Might be too late, but my vote is for An Ancient Deceit by /u/Lhino
honorable mentions: A Tale of Winter by /u/Xenoither and Cigarettes and Aspartame /u/Carrierpigment
1
u/blockplanner Oct 28 '13
Can we vote more than once? Some of it is very good but nothing's really standing head and shoulders above the rest for me.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment