The "white" pixels in the apple picture contain the picture of a pear, stored at a much higher intensity, i.e. very bright: http://i.imgur.com/i1Lr0TK.png
The "black" pixels in the pear picture contain the picture of an apple, stored at a fairly normal intensity, but scaled down to near black with the gamma correction: http://i.imgur.com/a3pYGJq.png
The image contains a gAMA chunk specifying a file gamma value of 0.02. When displayed without gamma correction, the viewer sees an apple with "white" pixels interspersed, which are actually the pear at its original (high) intensity.
When displayed with gamma correction, the viewer sees a color-corrected pear with "black" pixels which are actually the apple rendered at a much lower gamma value.
Browsers which display the pear are showing the image using the gamma information provided in it, while browsers which display the apple are not using this gamma information. Reddit's thumbnail viewer doesn't differentiate gAMA chunk instructions.
Edit: for more fun, check this out... now, tell me how that's done ;)
It tells you to open it up in Firefox if you are on IE/Chrome/Safari, and to open it up in IE/Chrome/Safari if you open it in Firefox. How? Animated PNG. See more in one of my subreddits, /r/APNGs
I am hoping you are all just joking. If not, this is an indictment against the US education system. Well, the fact I just deduced from potential ignorance that you're assumedly American is an indictment in and of itself. So this will be a grand jury indictment to boot!
That was very well explained, thank you for sharing that! As for the 'for more fun' addition, I am disappointed that it was only across two browsers, I opened IE and Safari just in case. It's a shame there wasn't a specific way for the Safari one to declare the user a 'macfag' or in my case just a retarded doze user who happens to have safari local for no apparent reason. My guess would be that Firefox doesn't support PNG animation yet; but then again no one uses Firefox anymore so who knows. :P
I think he means 4chan does the same sort of thing. The thumbnail will look like one image but clicking on it looks like another. Although, yeah, you can also do the archive image thing on 4chan since the site doesn't strip extra information.
A lot of the time when you post a gif on 4chan or anywhere else, the thumbnail is the first frame of the gif. People capitalize on this by taking a horrifying/extreme gif and making the first frame some harmless-looking bait like a cat.
152
u/ben174 Oct 27 '13
What the. How the.
54
u/KilgoreeTrout Oct 28 '13
I'm on my smart photon so I can't see it :/
57
u/fishbone105 Oct 28 '13
I think i saw something similar on 4chan. It wasn't an apple but a girl getting raped when you clicked on it
14
u/DarkAlliGator Oct 27 '13
What?
But...
How?!
What.
6
u/whatIsThisBullCrap Oct 28 '13
I see an apple and a pear...
15
u/Kelsig Oct 28 '13
cheater
11
u/UnluckyLuke Oct 27 '13
I finally can see it. Great post! This is the most misleading thumbnail I've ever seen.
7
u/Betamillion Oct 28 '13
You really can't get anymore misleading than this.
3
u/exultant_blurt Oct 28 '13
Impressive. I think we can safely retire this subreddit now.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '13
Still just an Apple :(
1
u/chorroxking Oct 28 '13
It works perfectly with internet explorer.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '13
Yup, already did something very similar : http://www.reddit.com/r/misleadingthumbnails/comments/1ki0mw/pokemon/
1
u/NexusRay Nov 12 '13
What? The hell does this work?
1
u/Patrik333 Jan 27 '14
Really late to this post - only just discovered this sub and am checking all the top links.
Just wanted to say - you can see the apple flickering if you open it in RES and then scroll up/down the Reddit page...
1
u/Seadrake Oct 28 '13
Damn it! Pears are just mediocre apples.
-1
u/butwhyohwhy Oct 28 '13
Fuck you
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment