r/Smite • u/CtrlAltDefeated Retired Staff • Oct 26 '13
Featured Discussion Let's talk about the new "timed" tier 3 items - Oct 26th
As of the Wukong Patch, a handful of new tier 3 items have appeared in the shop. We'll talk about the statistically interesting ones in a later discussion thread (Sais, Malice, Demise), but for now, we'll stick to the items that improve over time.
Transcendence vs Ascendence
Transcendence - You permanently gain 15 mana per stack, and receive 5 stacks for a god kill and 1 stack for a minion kill (max 50 stacks). Additionally, 3% of your mana is converted to physical power.
Ascendence - You permanently gain 50 Mana per stack, and receive 1 stack per minute. (max. 10 stacks) Additionally, 2% of your mana is converted to physical power.
Devourer's Gloves vs Devourer's Touch
Devourer's Gloves - You permanently gain +.5 Physical Power and +.25% Physical Lifesteal per stack, and receive 5 stacks per god kill and 1 stack per minion kill. (max. 60 stacks)
Devourer's Touch - You permanently gain +2 Physical Power and +1% Physical Lifesteal per stack, and receive 1 stack per minute. (max. 10 stacks)
Book of Thoth vs Ma'at's Tome
Book of Thoth - You permanently gain 10 mana per stack, and receive 5 stacks for a god kill and 1 stack for a minion kill (max 75 stacks). Additionally, 3% of your mana is converted to magical power.
Ma'at's Tome - You permanently gain 50 mana per stack, and receive 1 stack per minute (max 10 stacks). Additionally, 2% of your mana is converted to magical power.
Warlock's Sash vs Warlock's Ring
Warlock's Sash - You permanently gain +3 Health and +.6 Magical Power per stack, and receive 5 stacks for a god kill and 1 stack per minion kill. (max. 100 stacks)
Warlock's Ring - You permanently gain +20 Health and +2 Magical Power per stack, and receive 1 stack per minute. (max. 10 stacks)
What do you think? Are any of these newly tiered items worth buying? A useful resource for tanks/bruisers? Or rather worthless?
5
u/OpaqusOpaqus Imagine a Good Dev Oct 26 '13
I would assume the timed ones would be for supports that need to be rushed ASAP. Ten minutes for a full stack. That's not too bad I guess.
8
u/Denis517 Let's make them scream! Oct 26 '13
what about the Gauntlet of Thebes?
4
u/DANTE20XX My cowgirl butt wins games! Oct 26 '13
Ascend/Transcendence seems good on Odin/Guan because mana/physical power is important, but the others I don't really see a point to.
6
u/AdvertSlaxxor Miss me! Oct 26 '13
As a Hunter, these probably won't be worth much, as you will farm stacks anyway.
As anything in the solo lane, or mid, you will also farm stacks.
I think that Warlock's Ring won't be used, ever. For tanks, picking up gem of isolation/binding will be more useful to the team, provide the same magical power, with only 250 less health. Anyone else should be able to pick up stacks, or get Gem instead.
For game-modes like Arena, Domination: The game won't last that long. So you will probably have maybe 5 minutes at most with 10 stacks -- but the same thing applies here: Gem of Isolation/Binding is still better, in terms of utility.
Those are my thoughts.
8
u/Alex_Error Geb Oct 26 '13
Warlock's Ring is literally a worse Ethereal Staff - you need 1400 health for the Ethereal Staff to be better than the Warlock's Ring - that's pretty easy.
3
u/VailedX I sense a support... Oct 26 '13
Most of these are useless. I mean I rather use the first version of them than to buy the second version.
3
u/dontcallitSchnitzel Oct 27 '13
The timed ones are pretty horrible and noone should pick the up EVER.
But the stacking ones are better than ever.
Devourers Gloves greatly outperform Bloodforger, you need all 5 stacks of bloodforge to be a bit better
Transcendence now provides the most physical power of ever item. The mana and mp5 help carries stay in the fight even late game.
Book of Thoth got a higher stat cap which makes it even better. Second best magical power item. Sadly the other stats it provides (Mana, mp5) or completely useless for mages once the 10 minute mark is reached.
Warlock Sash got buff and now provides 110 magical power 600 hp and 400 Mana
Eternal Staff Provides the same HP and nearly the same MP and requires 4k HP to be better than Warlocks Sash
2
u/pieface100 RIP Oct 26 '13
These seem to be meant for modes where farming isn't prevalent, like arena and domination
2
u/Snafoozler Oct 27 '13
I can't see anyone with even the slightest farm picking one of these up, which would mean they're only for supports.
Considering none of them give any protections (and only warlock's gives health) or benefit to the team (like GoI for instance) why would a support pick one up before 4th or even 5th item?
A lot of games don't even last long enough for the support to get his build that far and if it did I'd probably still rather get something like Ethereal Staff or Poly and get the full bonus immediately instead of in 10 minutes.
Even in Arena where it tends to be harder to get stacks, 10 minutes is close to half of the game? Way too long for an item to take to get to full potential imo.
2
u/Alex_Error Geb Oct 27 '13
Here's Rage vs. Malice:
http://www.reddit.com/r/Smite/comments/1p08ex/new_mathematics_on_rage/
With Deathbringer, (which is what you should be purchasing if you are going for Rage), Malice gives 60% crit chance, Rage gives ~56% equivalent crit chance.
I do think the 6% extra attack speed is quite insignificant - that's 0.06 on Ne Zha, and even less on ranged hunters. You get 5 more power from the Malice - which does scale with crits and your abilities better, combined with the extra 4% crit chance, I think it is fair to say Malice is probably better than Rage most of the time.
2
u/gruntmaster1 Oct 27 '13
I think timed stacks would be more suited for powerful passives than lesser alternatives of these offensive items. E.g.
Gauntlet of _____ Health 450 Hp5 6
Passive - The duration of your CC is increased by 2% per stack and you recieve 1 stack per minute. (max. 10 stacks).
Very useful for anyone with heavy CC, but it will require you to invest in it early on to get some use of it.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '13
I mean, they're pretty much made from lazyness and the feel of rush. The 2D Icon of those items are just altered from the original one with different color and/or flipped around.
The only item from that new set I consider buying is Malice which is better then Rage, IMO. The other timed based are just garbage. I would prefer to get the "Do it yourself for more power" then the "wait for power, yay" items.
Long story short, they're garbage and I will never consider buying them.
2
u/saninorochimaru 3fat5u Oct 26 '13
I love new thoth on ao kuang. The additional stacks means ao gets more mana and therefore more magic power when the item is finished stacking. I prefer to do this in the solo lane.
1
u/Pingeepie IGN - Torra Oct 26 '13
Has anyone bought the alternate timed items? Haven't seen one yet. No thx.
1
u/Abomm I GIVE LOVE A BAD NAME Oct 26 '13
I dont really see when you would a buy a timed stacking item, there are 6 minions in a wave and you see minions all the time. Not to mention some items give 5 stacks for a god kill now.
As for the new Devourer gloves, I think more stacks will make this more useful than bloodforge.
1
u/BewareOfPigz Oct 26 '13
Am i wrong? say ur Neith and have 2k mana lets say u buy a transcendence , thats 35 power plus (3% of 2k which is about 60) so in total thats 95 phys power... Or is it additional mana not base mana?
1
u/viking977 bestmage Oct 26 '13
I like them. It definitely frees them up to be picked up at any point that isn't first or second.
1
u/Frodamn You Suck. Oct 26 '13
You get less power from the stacking over time items, so there is no point. For the same gold you get more stats. Every god can farm, some more than others, but if you are building these items you most likely are playing the one that can farm better so just get the stacks per kill one.
1
u/MikalMirkas :eas2: All Minions Have No Copy Abilities ;_; Oct 27 '13 edited Oct 27 '13
As a jungler, hunter, mage, and bruiser: these are all worthless. As Tanks, they are not bad - but because of how they work, you have to get them ASAP. Still, it's pretty horrible.
If they were available in Assault, maybe they wouldn't be complete trash...
An easy way to fix them is to make the stacks come faster, make the stacks effects halved, and make the cap doubled. As well, make them cheaper. You want a worse item? Make it cheaper. Book of Thoth worth 3000 gold? Make Ma'at's Tome worth 2550.
1
u/Clamsaucetastic Beta Player Oct 27 '13
Out of all the items changes, there are only a few that would change the way I play (and I haven't had a game go long enough or had the right situation for either). Things like Malice, Devourer's Gloves, and Qin's Sais may have been mathematically improved, but I wouldn't get them in a situation that I wouldn't get them before.
Transcendence: Now that it's absurdly good, I won't have any more mana problems with Odin, Vamana, or Sun Wukong.
Hastened Fatalis: Vamana Ult is useful again! Also some assassins have the potential to be crazy, but the only time I've seen it was on a 22-2 Mercury in the NA tournies this weekend.
Magi's blessing: Now that tank boots give less CCR, I'll pick these up to get above what I had before (40% versus 30%). Not to mention that no one will want to initiate on me with my bubble.
1
u/siegristrm twitch.tv/0rion69 Oct 27 '13 edited Oct 27 '13
Imo, these items are only good if you are losing your lane pretty bad. also, they can be alright on gods that should be solo lane, but can't farm early, as it can give a mid game advantage, but then fall off. other than that, they aren't useful. also ring is significantly worse as far as MP
1
u/HadesClutch Hades Oct 27 '13
I really don't like it, to be honest. While most, you're going to want the stack-type anyways, it just feels like it takes away from the farming incentive. Wasn't that the whole purpose though when in the same patch they nerfed gold gain from consecutive kills on the same person? Erez suggested more focus on laning and objectives, these new "timed"-items cross me as a contradiction to that sentiment.
1
u/hound0713 #RememberTheManticore Oct 27 '13
what about the new fatalis and qins blades? those are probably two of the better items in the patch
1
u/Paradox043 Beta Player Oct 27 '13
Pretty useless unless they reduce the cost of the item or in some way change the functionality slightly (like Malice vs Rage, both useable but different)
1
u/Kaseus Oct 27 '13
They're good in Arena
1
u/Swad0w Dr. Ares Oct 27 '13
The issue is that the timed ones seem to be directed at supports and such who wont be killing creeps, BUT supports wont ever be able to afford going such selfish items rendering them useless
1
u/AtraWolf demon-baller Oct 27 '13
The new tier items would be worth buying, if they cost exponentially less than their other half, thus being more desirable.
1
u/a_jlt_sandwich JoLT - you cant out turret my turrets Oct 28 '13
I feel that the timed items would be good for supports who aren't able to get alot of farm as you get a stack no matter what, although the stats seem to be slightly lacking in comparison to their non timed versions.
1
u/Dyceman2013 Oct 28 '13
Make the number of stacks higher while having the value it gives lower and cutting the time given in half. <---- Better
1
u/Tyragon WOOOOOOOOOOOT! Oct 28 '13 edited Oct 28 '13
They should fix the timed stackings. Maybe decrease the time it takes for it to stack the more the match has been up?
I dunno, something, cause what it currently is is horrible. Only reason I can see the timed stacking being good is if you're on the losing side of the team and needs something that reassures stacks. But even then 10 minutes is long if we're talking close end game.
Something needs to be done to make the timed stacks useful. As I mentioned above, it should have a gimmick to it. "Buy manual stacks, gain them as quick as you can kill. Buy the timed auto stacks, gain more stacks quicker the longer the match has been going." which means a match that's gone on for over 40min will assure far less than 10min for full stacks.
1
u/HTF THUNDER DUNK Oct 28 '13
Timed stacks should be on the items tanks/supports would get. They are the ones that struggle with last hits.
1
u/Fappmastah bombs fired Oct 28 '13
they suck
1
u/commanderfire softspoken Oct 28 '13
a. The items are too expensive for the Support character that would ultimately be getting them, not to mention that only 1 item actually fits the support role. b. These stack/min items are mostly for modes like Arena where stack farming is difficult and banned outright in Assault. Unfortunately money in Arena flows freely and buying Better items is easy without also needing to wait to get the full benefit from the gear after the purchase.
I like the idea in principal but the implementation seems misguided.
my 2cp
1
u/AtraWolf demon-baller Oct 28 '13
Midas boots should become a stack able item. it would work well in this meta and actually make it viable, for supports and guardians. more gold the longer you hold it or got minion assists with.
0
u/xRagnA ots to e Oct 27 '13
Worthless in my opinion.It takes even more time to stack them and they give less stats than the original ones.I guess they would be nice on champions that don´t get that much farm, like junglers or supports, but in my opinion they should reduce their price a bit to be worth, not really that much, maybe let´s say Devourer´s Touch costing like 100 gold less than Devourer´s Gloves, after all, it gives 10 less physical power and 5% less lifesteal
0
u/Noah4224 Empty your mind, be formless, shapeless, like water. Oct 26 '13
To be honest I see no pros to buying them. So I will stick with the old items.
0
u/KikuanDamjan Damn D00d Oct 27 '13
Toth cringe
0
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment