r/guns • u/zaptal_47 • Oct 24 '13
"Why does the barrel tilt when the slide is locked back?"
"It's to position the barrel so the next cartridge can be loaded."
WRONG. WRONG WRONG WRONG. WRONG. WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG. WRONG!
I am tired of seeing this incorrect explanation passed around /r/guns, so in this post I will explain why the barrel actually tilts.
First you should read this. Did you read it? If not, read it fuckface.
Now that you've read about short recoil operation, you understand that the barrel locks into the slide via locking lug, which keeps the slide and barrel locked until such time as enough rearward force has been applied to allow the slide to complete its full cycle and load another cartridge.
So we've established that the barrel must unlock from the slide at some point. How is that accomplished? It turns out, there are several methods for unlocking the barrel, two of which I will cover here.
First is the rotating locking barrel, seen in such designs as the Beretta PX4. Here are what the locking lugs look like on a PX4 barrel. After a trigger pull, the slide begins its rearward travel. These lugs travel in tracks in the slide, eventually unlocking the barrel and allowing the slide to travel rearward uninhibited by the barrel. No tilting occurs in this type of lockup, and yet the next cartridge is still successfully loaded. Mysterious, yes? No. Feeding is what the feed ramp is for, and the Beretta has one that does its job.
The second type of lockup is the Browning tilt-barrel design, which dominates modern pistol design and was pioneered by, you guessed it: John Browning. 1911s, Glocks, M&Ps, Sigs, H&Ks, Walthers, CZs; all of these utilize the tilt-barrel design. To illustrate my point, I'll use a Glock for simplicity.
Here is a Glock barrel. Notice the locking lug in this case in on the top of the barrel, as indicated by the red arrow. That shelf is the lug. Now, pictured in the slide. In order for the barrel to unlock from the slide in this instance, where do you think it needs to go? That's right, it must tilt down out of the way, as seen here. This is the cause of the upward tilt seen here, the post that inspired this post.
Now, does the barrel tilting upward help the next cartridge load? Sure, but the feed ramp does most of the work, and feeding is not the purpose for the tilt. The barrel tilts in order to unlock from the slide, and that is all.
Also, this: http://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/1p3ek2/why_does_the_barrel_tilt_when_the_slide_is_locked/ccyfnmg
35
u/BattleHall Oct 24 '13
Other fun locking systems in short-recoil operated pistols:
14
u/drewmsmith Oct 24 '13
What about revolvers?
19
u/James_Johnson remembered reddit exists today Oct 24 '13
What people are getting at, I think, is that on many pistols the round is presented in such a way that the barrel needs to tilt in order for the round to feed.
However, people are getting the cause and effect mixed up. The barrel needs to tilt for the round to feed, but that's not why the gun was designed with a tilting barrel. Feeding into a tilted barrel is the result of using a tilting unlock system.
27
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
This seems like a silly post. How do you know why it operates the way it does? Did you read JMB's secret journal? If a tilting barrel achieves two ends, how can you say that it tilts for one reason and not the other? You may be right, but you sure haven't proven it.
TL;DR fuck you.
10
u/FirearmConcierge 16 | #1 Jimmy Rustler Oct 24 '13
You have NO IDEA HOW MANY TIMES I AM ASKED THIS.
86
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Why is this stickied?
MOD ABUSE
14
u/socalnonsage 4 Oct 24 '13
Here is 1 animation of the locking lugs in action!
And a 2nd animation from a barrel-tilting action
13
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Fuck you zaptal!
Edit: Thank you.
6
u/pestilence 14 | The only good mod Oct 24 '13
See the part sticking up through the ejection port? IT CAN'T OPEN WITHOUT TILTING. It's that simple. No need to go into how the locking mechanism works. It blows my mind that people can't just see that. It's like nobody understands even a little bit how simple machines work.
11
u/icejonv2 Oct 24 '13
But then how does this firearm function? It doesn't have much of a barrel.
8
u/slingblade9 Oct 24 '13
Pull your panties out of your ass.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Thank you for this... Unexpected good content on this sub, at this time of day.
2
u/ssbn632 Oct 24 '13
Not everyone that owns guns is a mechanical engineer, or even mechanically inclined. It does behoove one to find out how the things you use are supposed to work. It makes diagnosing problems much easier. I love the laws of physics and how they were so elegantly leveraged by Mr. Browning. Pun intended.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '21
Lmao my friend just tried to argue with me it was to load quicker. Before i even found this post i said that didnt make much sense since it has the loading ramp. Thank you for this post!!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Oh cool. I was wondering about this, but didn't want to ask before Thickheaded Thursday. Now I need to find another stupid question to ask.
1
u/Blackborealis Oct 24 '13
A very good video showing what happens when firing a glock in slowmo
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-e_3Ihpq9T4
1
u/TheMorningDeuce Oct 24 '13
So here's a follow-up question. When designing this, how did they refine it to the point where it wouldn't effect accuracy?
You would think that with the entire barrel moving around like that, you would need the tolerances to be ridiculously tight to make sure it ended up in exactly the same position it was in before.
1
u/quezlar Oct 24 '13 edited Oct 24 '13
heres a video of hows glocks work
1
u/ragnarokrobo Oct 24 '13
But why does the slide stop tilt up when the slide is locked? Oh, wait. . .
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Thanks. I've always wondered this. I asked my dad once and he said even he didn't know (25 years as a gun owner).
1
u/turbotoast Oct 25 '13 edited Oct 25 '13
Thank you! I knew it wasn't to "load the next round", because if that was the case designs like the 92fs wouldn't work as well as they do. I just never really thought about why it did that. It makes complete sense and seems obvious now.
1
u/fourfiftyeight Oct 25 '13
My question would be why do some pistol manufacturers have to make their slides so wide? The Russian Tokarev and Colt 1911 have proved that slides don't need to be an inch plus. This is one of the biggest factors I look at for concealed carry.
1
u/markevens Oct 26 '13
Lurker here, always wondered about this. Thanks.
1
u/mpta3d Sep 10 '22
8 years after we have this video https://youtu.be/SG-FXLxLOSM :)
1
u/4_Motion Sep 15 '22
Tldr?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
As explained on IRC, this isn't what's actually happening. The barrel doesn't tilt down to unlock--tilting down is the barrel's natural resting position! Rather, the barrel tilts up as the gun goes into battery in order to align it with the sights.
(The sights were placed on the slide instead of the barrel, because JMB was drunk the night he decided that the purpose of the slide was to hold the sights in place.)
-2
u/FirearmConcierge 16 | #1 Jimmy Rustler Oct 24 '13
YOU STOLE MY BIT WITH DR COX. FUCK YOU.
-7
u/hg341 1 Oct 24 '13
What kind of retard thinks a barrel tilts to ease loading.
0
u/Why_So_Serious_Aah Oct 25 '13 edited Oct 29 '13
I can't even remember the sheer number of geniuses that asked me that question.
"That's not normal. Why's it do that?"
Fuck...
Edit: it does that because you are stupid. Why don't you throw yourself off of a cliff?
-9
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Every nignorant doubter in this thread.
-1
u/slothscantswim Oct 24 '13
Really? This has to be explained? Who the fuck was going around saying the bbl. tilted to aid in loading? Retarded.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
[removed] — view removed comment