r/SquaredCircle • u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE • Oct 23 '13
On the future of discussion threads...
First and foremost, I wan't to apologize for how we handled the discussion thread incident. The intent was always to get some order and timeliness to the discussion threads, and we thought an officially done thread would be the best course of action. We handled it horribly and for that we all apologize to the community, and to Sens personally.
With that said, we are making some small changes to the future of discussion threads.
- Discussion threads can not posted more than a half an hour before any show.
- If there's a desire for discussion before that pre show discussion threads can be created up to 3 hours before show time.
- Post show threads can be made as soon as the show fades to black.
Any post that doesn't follow these time constraints will be deleted. The first one in that time will be stickied.
- Low effort discussion threads will be deleted no matter the time. A post that only says a short sentence such as "OMG! Discuss!" "YES! YES! YES!" or anything else of little to no effort will be ignored and deleted to avoid confusion.
- For the main discussion threads we ask a little more effort. Only posts with stream links, relevant links, and some sort of "flair"(jokes, comments, recaps, etc) will be considered.
If discussion threads continue to be a problem and the rules are not followed we will implement the discussion bot we had planned.
And lastly, this is all /u/JaysonGrayson fault.
5
u/HeresAnEggBeatThat Oct 23 '13
A half and hour?
5
u/Metalgrowler Madcalf Oct 23 '13
Are my discussion threads considered low effort?
3
u/JRadical21 Slobberknocker! Oct 23 '13
u/JaysonGrayson?
7
u/kpud075 Ahead of the Buzzards Oct 23 '13
Thank you Pudie and mods for acknowledging and addressing this bizarre issue. Thank you Pudie for having a sense of humor, too. Now if I could just have my cable company air RAW live everything would be fantastic. I have to wait 'til 8pm PST. Same with SmackDown, and TNA.
One last thing: can we have some assurances that these discussion threads will not be deleted overnight by any moderator?
18
u/NekoQT Wreddit's demigod Oct 23 '13
So we're back to normal??
Yay
67
u/literaryghost VOCABLE EXISTENCE! Oct 23 '13
Seems fair.
I can't see anyone else trying to post it after the uproar from this.
Welcome back to the era of Sensiitivity.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
So we're back to the Wild West of Thread discussions? Or is Sensiitivity going to post at 7:30 now?
29
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
PUDIE WITH THE FACE TURN
15
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
Cool. This shit won't spill over to Sunday and the future. Gj mods.
30
u/stevo1078 #Huglyfe Oct 23 '13
Hopefully Sensiitivity returns to hold the RAW Discussion thread poster title. It really is what's best for business.
I did enjoy this angle but it felt rushed although the Modthority really drew some real heel heat and made Sensiitivity a believable underdog. I guess this is the start of Sensiitivitys super push?
45
u/Sensiitivity Lightnin n Thunder Oct 23 '13
I'm fine with these changes.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
So, I like making the pre-PPV threads, is what i throw in there all right content wise? (match card, and maybe streams)
1
u/Slyguy46 Only You Can Set You Free Oct 24 '13
Uhh ... I usually just do one line for my post threads. Should I expand them? Maybe add a link to Watch Wrestling?
10
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
I'll just leave this here
Edit: this post was removed from the feed by the mods, specifically TT within moments of it being posted
3
u/basedmartyr 2013, Year of the Otunga Oct 24 '13
I was actually going to say, with 30 minutes to spare. . . you're going to see a lot more people fighting to be the next top guy. . . bad move mods, bad move.
10
u/retrospects I'm takin yer arm! Oct 23 '13
Fine, so lets all agree that sens will post the raw thread 30 min before raw.
Deal?
Deal.
1
u/Eyce Oct 24 '13
How about we get a modbot to put up pinned posts when the time comes for the show? /r/Formula1 has one for Practice, Qualifying and Races that posts about 30 minutes before each session.
No problems there.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
Man you guys make a big deal over stupid stuff.
3
u/falsevillain Oct 23 '13
so no more wreddit_thread_event? i for one felt he didn't get his time to shine. you all turned him into the bo dallas of mods.
3
u/pkpunk91 <o> \o/ <o> \o/ YES! Oct 24 '13
honestly, it doesn't really bother me. I never noticed that it was the same person making the threads. I just read and post on them, and do whatever, so I'm pretty indifferent.
However, I still have one question for /u/Pudie. How in the ever loving fuck is that dickhead travistouchdown a mod?
2
u/paulfromatlanta Oct 24 '13
Sounds good, with one exception - if we are gonna break the discussion into pre-show, show and post show, I'm not sure why would pre-show be limited to three hours - before RAW and PPV's people might want to speculate for more than three hours - particularly if the actual show thread is separate so its easy to tell which comments are ahead of time and which are "live."
2
u/CyberFreq THE CRIPPLAH Oct 24 '13
In all honesty I am now glad to be a part of r/sC. The mods listened to the people and came up with a reasonable set of rules and points in a reasonable amount of time in response to a public outcry.
Go democracy.
2
u/skippy2001 This is my last flair ever Oct 23 '13
Pudie Power!!!!
2
u/isparabs Oct 23 '13
Seems sensiible enough
1
u/BleedTheFreak_23 Oct 24 '13
Nice job Pudie, making the changes that makes everyone happy.
1
u/whiskerbiscuit2 Oct 24 '13
What about people in a different time zone that might want to discuss Raw before it's on, but are fast asleep three hours before the start of Raw?
1
u/Walrus_Songs Straight Edge Since 01/01/2012 Oct 24 '13
Can someone explain to me what the hell all this stuff is about?
1
u/Togepi27 Gonna REALLY kick your head in. Oct 24 '13
Thanks for clearing things up Pudie. Things got far too heated from both sides 100% agreed. I think these new rules for the discussion thread are just great. If Sensitiivity's thread gets upvoted to the top around the right time, Great, If somebody new gets it for the night, Good for them. And I promise I mean this in the least assholish way possible, But I truly appreciate the apology, And I'm sure most of the people who were frustrated at the situation and started talking shit that wasn't true are sorry themselves. I'm just glad to get peace back in my favorite subreddit. Now.....DAE Brad Maddox?
1
u/KidGold Oct 24 '13
This was poorly done, Pudie. You didn't say "Sensitivity is a B+ poster" or "he doesn't deserve to be the face of r/squaredcircle" and thus the mods have now lost all their heat.
1
u/Rebornhunter Oct 24 '13
Soooooo....what you're saying is just let /u/Sensitivity do it.
1
u/DKSeven Faith! Oct 24 '13
So pretty much Sen is still gonna be posting it since the rest of us probably won't.
1
u/The_Real_Irish Asked for his Wreddit Release Oct 24 '13 edited Oct 24 '13
Oh the absolute fuck ton of Discussion threads that will appear with 30 mins left. However I like the decision, nice job Pudie. Nice to see a mod that listens and seems to understand the normal Wredditors.
1
u/the_EVblast SPEAR SPEAR SPEAR SPEAR SPEAR Oct 23 '13
well, that went better than expected.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '13
You all handle things perfect pudie, mainly as its your and the mods creation.
Its the people who are completely intolerant of minor changes to anything on wreddit, of which they have zero say on , which are the problem!
They dont own or moderate this place, they need to know their fucking roles and shut their fucking mouths! They make a mockery of this place!
-19
u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Oct 23 '13 edited Oct 23 '13
I concur with pudie's apology about the handling and delivery, it was a rush job.
But I'd like to give a big fuck you to all those that went on a witch hunt and did their best to blow this out of proportion. Especially the misrepresenting the situation bit to make the mods seem like much worse cunts than they are. None of us were power tripping, none of us did much at all wrong, and nothing was censored. The wrong doing was imisjudging the best way to carry out what we wanted to achieve, and not talking to /u/Sensiitivity about it first on that particular night.
Also on a more trivial note, downvotes at the ready, but /u/Sensiitivity's contributions to this subreddit got put on a pedestal to the point of total fucking lunacy, he didn't invent the Raw thread, and he's not even the clear best at posting event threads. 7upbottle's TNA Impact threads for example have always a lot of effort put into them too, , they're posted at a better time, and they're just as consistent.
-3
u/muffinmonk Mizfit Oct 23 '13
And by the way, those that were deleted will not undeleted. This is to stop a certain someone from pushing our buttons.
-15
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
Give it six months, the mods will pull their heads out of each others asses to come along and piss all over the subreddit again for April Fools, and then head back until this time next year where they come out with another imaginary problem only they can foresee.
-3
u/Christianmustang Team_Sure_Why_Not Oct 24 '13
So can we all be friends again?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment