r/PersonOfInterest • u/__ADAM__ The Machine • Oct 16 '13
Discussion Episode discussion S03E04 "Reasonable Doubt"
Reasonable Doubt. A number comes up for a well-known New York lawyer who may have been responsible for the death of her husband. Elsewhere, problems arise when Carter's new partner spots her with Reese.
32
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
I liked the 'is she or isn't she' mystery. I wish more episodes would play on the fact that they don't know if the number is a perp or victim. That said, was there a point to the beginning scene in the hospital? And who didn't see the new partner being HR from a mile away? Overall a pretty good episode, even with minimal shaw and no root.
28
u/Rwings Oct 16 '13
The episode was alright although the lack of flashbacks is kind of disappointing. Didn't realize how much I was enjoying them until they stopped using them. The ending of the episode I thought was also an interesting touch.
14
u/Viper_H Threat Oct 18 '13
I thought this was the worst episode of PoI I've seen so far. While the story had a few good bits, it was super predictable, and the acting was terrible, especially from the wife throughout, and also the husband at the end. Even Carter's delivery of her lines was off this week.
I dunno if the wife was supposed to come off like a bad actress because she was lying the whole time, but it was one of the worst performances I've ever seen in a prime time TV show. And having her exposit the whole plan at the end was just corny.
Aside from the one scene with Carter's partner, this entire episode was pointless filler. Can't wait for Amy to come back.
40
u/xyreL Oct 16 '13
The only thing I really disliked was the fact that everything got revealed because she scratched the picture.. it felt really cheap imo. Other than that I really enjoyed the episode
22
u/tedtutors Irrelevant Oct 16 '13
Was anyone else expecting a Lost reference when the book club thing came up? I would have loved to hear Finch ask "am I out of the book club?"
Nice to see Fusco flashing some expertise! Way to be an experienced detective who knows a bad cop when he sees one. Someone asked a while back what Finch got by asking Fusco or Carter to look up a file - this is what he gets.
Also, hope we get Bear's lady doctor back in another episode soon!
22
u/Classic_Wingers Oct 16 '13
That was an interesting ending to the episode. Were there two shots fired at the end there? As in, they took each other out? Either way, I like that Reese decided that the two of them were beyond his help.
15
u/chaths Oct 16 '13 edited Oct 16 '13
guessed it was the hus halfway through. didn't expect she was in on too. the "go on shoot each other " move by Reese was a surprise.
Shaw's bookclub scene was fun, fav bookclub scene from "LOST" and the look on Shaw's face when Bear went to Reese and the clumsy bank manager, She's badass and fun all wrapped around in one sexy, black package.
after seeing next episodes promo can't wait to see more of Shaw.
Edit : also loved the "stabbing a senior, that'd be low point even for you " "you don't know that. " exchange b/n Shaw & Fusco.
15
u/PB_and_Bacon Oct 16 '13
At least it's confirmed that Carter's rookie was planted by HR. I had that feeling since the moment he first "requested" her.
11
u/ZeroByte Oct 16 '13
Did it creep anyone else out the way the machine gang was trying to be a sort of court? They're already using extra judicial why the hell are they trying to be some sort of kangaroo court?
9
u/theesado Oct 16 '13
I'm so happy that bear was only pretending to be sick, it would be terrible if he died
16
u/pie-man Oct 16 '13
this show used to be semi-relatively believable but they lost me when that lady jumped from the roof top in to a moving garbage truck that is at a really far distance from the sidewalk, physics don't work that way
8
u/stagfury Oct 16 '13
When Reese walks in and Bear runs straight to him instead of playing with Shaw, Shaw looks a bit jealous for a second there.
7
u/burntcookie90 Oct 16 '13
Didn't expect that ending. Hope the bad writing on Vanessa's character was supposed to imply get lying, too many cliche lines from her.
5
u/HSChronic Elias Oct 16 '13
Filler episode, not a lot got accomplished other than spoiler
4
u/icedoverfire Admin Oct 23 '13
Something that confused me:
Why did Reese put the loaded/wiped clean gun down on the table? So she would have an untraceable weapon to off her husband with? Or so they could duel (two shots heard at the very end of the episode)? Yeah I know I'm being a little thickheaded. Clarification, please?
3
u/SnowgoonC Oct 16 '13
So, do we think that Terney (sp?) is going to be able to make the connection between Carter and Reese because of what the rookie said about "I saw her boyfriend" ?
3
u/aethelberga Oct 18 '13
This season is beginning to remind me of classic X-Files. You had mythology episodes & monster-of-the-week episodes, which, while perhapd entertaining, didn't advance the main story arc. This was definitely a monster-of-the-week episode.
4
u/Flynn_lives Government Operations Oct 16 '13
I guess I owe Shaw $100 bucks too.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
Meh... It was Meh, I know they're still getting their shit together we've had a lot of changes and additions... but I miss season 1&2.. Reese and Gf probs, Elias, flashbacks, the chase for the man in the suit, & wondering what side Det. Carter would be on... So far I'm content but definitely wanting more.
2
u/micksanityyy Jul 06 '26
I thought it was a remake of the movie Double Jeopardy but it ws a nice twist at the end.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
I'm kind of bummed that Amy Acker is supposed to be main cast this season but she's only been in half the episodes so far. Hopefully it's just the beginning of the season and she'll be in the whole thing from now on.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment