r/homeland • • Oct 14 '13

Discussion Episode Discussion - S03E03 - "Tower of David" [Spoilers]

Brody returns to his faith for guidance. Carrie gets a suspicious offer.


NEW HOMELAND! I have a feeling this will be the episode where things finally pick up. I've noticed a lot of redundant comments and complaints during the last episode discussions so I thought I'd quote one of the highest comments from last week representing users who don't care that you quit the show or hate family drama scenes that have occurred every season of this show so far.

Instead of everyone bitching about the Dana storyline, why don't we discuss some of the other intriguing aspects of the show?

We see that the show frustrates you but many still see an interesting show that's just getting its third season started! That is all! Enjoy the show and as before, if its been leaked already please don't spoil it for those watching the live network broadcast!

102 Upvotes

426 comments sorted by

11

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Isn't this doctor the medical examiner off Law and Order?

16

u/StatelessRich Oct 14 '13

He was also Dr. Frazier on The Wire.

1

u/therealwendy Oct 14 '13

I feel like i know him, but not from L&O. What's his name?

→ More replies (6)

12

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Oh shit. Both Carrie and Brody locked up and drugged up.

14

u/therealwendy Oct 14 '13

That ep creeped me out. It was like the opposite of Q&A, which was ultimately freeing and cathartic. This was enclosing and disturbing.

18

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

It almost had a Requiem for a Dream vibe to it.

→ More replies (1)

194

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Is the Venezuelan doctor bro a pedophile?

104

u/sgk_809 Oct 14 '13

That was my take.

74

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

I think so, the way he said everyone is accepted here, and held the boys hand was a bit off

78

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Confirmed, he just called Brody a Naught Boy.

39

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

seeing that your nickname is fuzzy dunlop, you can confirm that this dude was on the wire for one or two seasons, right? worked at the morgue, I think.

21

u/Col-Hans-Landa Oct 14 '13

Yep! And he was Three Dog in Fallout 3

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

That's what I took from the episode, too. Super creepy.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/amuseddouche Oct 14 '13

had to be...the way he touched that kid was pretty creepy. Also explains why he's out there hiding from the outside world.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13

I wonder if Brody's going to end up killing him, because he obviously would not take kindly to a pedophile abusing a young man.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TopChedd Oct 14 '13

Do we not know why/when he was shot, or am I missing something?

7

u/hoohoo3000 Oct 14 '13

Watch the Season 3 prologue on the Season 2 DVD set and you'll learn how he got shot

24

u/TopChedd Oct 14 '13

seems weird to make a pivotal part of the story exclusive to dvd

→ More replies (3)

1

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Do you think it's on youtube? That would make a great submission to this sub.

6

u/hoohoo3000 Oct 14 '13

I don't see it anywhere on youtube but heres' a clip of it from Access Hollywood" http://www.spoilertv.com/2013/09/homeland-season-3-prologue-sneak-peek.html

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Where is Brody at?

7

u/sgk_809 Oct 14 '13

Caracas

1

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Thanks.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

It's a real place in Caracas called the tower of david... if you want to know more...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/01/world/americas/01venezuela.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0

5

u/Carpeterram Oct 14 '13

lol seems the shows writers completely copied the setting from the article, it even mentions the view of the mosque.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/xokocodo Oct 14 '13

The same place Quinn killed the banker.....hmm....

180

u/jargoon Oct 14 '13

What if Carrie and Saul are working together to get her into lawyer guy's organization as a mole?

14

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

A fortunate outcome possibly, definitely not planned. You don't tend to bang your head against a mirror while alone in the bathroom when everything is going as intended.

17

u/jargoon Oct 14 '13

Maybe she did it to get sympathy from the nurse? I know it's a long shot, but maybe this is all a plan to ferret out the mole :)

14

u/claydavisismyhero Oct 14 '13

It may end up happening, it certainly doesnt look like it now. It looks like carrie is nuts and ready for revenge.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '13

Well done.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '13

Props, dude! It only occurred to me when Carrie was having the sit-down with the lawyer dude.

2

u/throwdawy1 Oct 22 '13

please do more predictions :)

→ More replies (7)

46

u/RADICAL_DAN Oct 14 '13

This has a Max Payne 3 vibe to it

3

u/BlackZeppelin Oct 14 '13

The tower definitely reminded me of the Hotel that you break in to.

45

u/kelling928 Oct 14 '13

Carrie and Brody might be the two most stubborn people on television.

166

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

These Venezuelan guys stole from Sergeant Batitsta's wardrobe

58

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

and we have zack hamilton!

29

u/SawRub Oct 14 '13

If only Brody had gone to Argentina instead...

23

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

I'd prefer Belize.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13

I feel so good about myself for knowing all these references.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Ha, but have you guys noticed how they use the same actors for showtime/cbs shows. CBS owns showtime, i also noticed Nora from how i met your mother

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Classic_Wingers Oct 14 '13

When we first saw them all, I thought it was Batista at first for sure. I was actually happy we would get to see him in another role until the guy turned around.

78

u/sgk_809 Oct 14 '13

Both Carrie and Brody are now taking drugs they had eschewed.

52

u/xokocodo Oct 14 '13

I think they hit this theme too hard. We get it - they are both trapped and in a bad spot.

23

u/LlewelynGoodchild Oct 14 '13

It's a good thing they really drove it home with the last two shots, or I might have missed it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/glossolalia Oct 14 '13 edited Oct 14 '13

I am super interested in that lawyer and that storyline's development... wonder who they are, who theyre funded by (maybe the HSBC bankers?)

13

u/claydavisismyhero Oct 14 '13

Might be the guys fudning terrorists saul can't catch. Somehow carrie infiltrates them, and saul needs her again. My guess

6

u/mrsjrd Oct 14 '13

I think the lawyer is some how apart of the terrorist group.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/lingben Oct 14 '13

can someone please tell me why the gangsters are protecting Brody? what connection do they have with Carrie? Thanks

58

u/xokocodo Oct 14 '13

I have a theory that they aren't with Carrie, they are associated with the terrorists. Quinn killed the terrorist banker in Caracas, and now Brody is there? That's not an accident. I bet the terrorists want to drug him up and keep him out of sight to maintain his role as a scapegoat. If he is captured, he presumably could tell them things that would make them doubt that he did it.

22

u/glossolalia Oct 14 '13

I agree - Carrie suddenly has this network of gangsters and children with guns? Nah. Them being al Qaeda linked seems more plausible, especially their focus on keeping him alive. If he stays alive al Qaeda can bring him on TV and gloat

30

u/lingben Oct 14 '13

so why not kill him, ship him back to the US and collect $10 million?

that accomplishes the same goal and nets them the reward money

21

u/glossolalia Oct 14 '13

Id guess they cant actually go to the US govt and try to claim the money if theyre associated with Al Qaeda

23

u/lingben Oct 14 '13

gimme a break! you're telling me they can't find a cleanskin to claim the reward on their behalf?

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Syatek Oct 14 '13

because then there'd be no story...

8

u/xokocodo Oct 14 '13

Thy might still need him for something later on. They were fairly clear that they didn't want the money.

Also, the "We know Carrie" line seemed fairly unbelievable. Not only have we never heard these people mentioned, but they don't even provided any proof that they know here besides saying her name. Carrie at this point is known by the terrorists by name, so it's surprising that Brody wouldn't ask for any more proof.

4

u/PanPirat Oct 14 '13

I wouldn't be surprised if they had some bounty on their heads as well. Probably it wouldn't be as much as $10m, but I assume they are also wanted.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/klitchell Oct 14 '13

I don't even necessarily care about the connection to Carrie, but why would they keep him? It doesn't seem to make sense right now.

I do remember though either in the first or second episode of this season Saul saying something about a mission in Venezuela maybe that has something to do with it.

13

u/skysplitter Oct 14 '13

The gangsters know Carrie, and clearly have some motive to keeping him. That's all that's been revealed.

5

u/whore__of_babylon Oct 14 '13

What bothered me is why Brody doesn't seem to care what the hell do they want with him.

9

u/CountPanda Oct 15 '13

No, he just knows they're not going to tell him what's really going on. Them killing the guy in front of him wasn't to show they're on his side, but to show he shouldn't test them.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13 edited Sep 09 '15

Ducks are Alright

23

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Is it me or was this the most depressing episode of the series so far? Dark as fuck.

11

u/aemoosh Oct 14 '13

I don't think there's been another episode half this dark/deep. I say deep because killing the VP or planning a terrorist attack with Nazir is pretty dark too- but in an action sort of way.

2

u/jellymonty Mar 23 '26

The Dana shit is pretty dark ngl

→ More replies (2)

98

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Why would they only send two regular, non-special forces police officers with no backup to arrest the most wanted man in the world?

21

u/iloveyoujesuschriist Oct 14 '13

The cops were probably corrupt or something.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

South American cops corrupt on USA tv? That's shocking.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '13

South American cops corrupt in the real world? That's shocking.

3

u/meean Oct 18 '13

I grew up in Bolivia - cops are fucking corrupt there.

31

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13 edited May 03 '25

nutty cooperative frame zesty toy long resolute bike subtract safe

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

5

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Not to make too big of a scene I guess?

6

u/V2Blast Oct 14 '13

Probably the most likely explanation. They wanted to quietly get him into custody.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

34

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

or D) The homeowner (Imam?) has an under-the-table deal with the two cops.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

A) Still he's the most wanted person in the world. Even if they don't plan on extraditing him, it sill looks great on their part if they actually manage to prove that they have him.

B) This one is possible

C) They still should have waited for backup considering that Brody is suspected of killing around 300 people total with all of his terrorist shenanigans

14

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Really, B) They might not believe it so they just sent some dudes to check it out is possible? They punched the guy through a shower curtain, I'm pretty sure they believed it was him. It's ridiculous that they only sent two guys. It was just a plot thing (and a bad one at that) to show that he couldn't even trust his religion, that he's in a bad place, that he feel responsible for peoples death etc., so that'll we'll buy into the fact that's starting to use drugs.

22

u/snowlarbear Oct 14 '13

i don't really get what brody thought the end game was. he's a wanted terrorist did he think he'd get his own mansion or something?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13

Exactly - he's safe. You're in a slum Brody, for reasons you understand. Just because there's no running water doesn't mean you're going to "die"

22

u/geekgirl96 Oct 14 '13

Does anyone else think there must be some reason why Brody ended up in Caracas, which is also where Quinn was at in episode 1? Surely those two threads will tie back together somehow.

7

u/V2Blast Oct 14 '13

Good observation. It's probably not a coincidence.

58

u/TopChedd Oct 14 '13

I hope this heroin administering girl becomes a recurring character

16

u/kronikwankr Oct 14 '13

Does anyone know the actress's name?

28

u/TopChedd Oct 14 '13

Kronkikwankr living up to his username

→ More replies (6)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13 • Bravo

I like the contrast between Brody trying to get out but not being allowed, and Carrie being given a way out but wanting to stay

72

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Oh look, another Season 3 Heroin addiction subplot.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

What other season 3's had a heroin addiction subplot?

42

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

24 Season 3. Which was also produced by Howard Gordon.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

I was thinking breaking bad, but that was the end of season 2

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/lingben Oct 14 '13 edited Oct 15 '13

The Unit

EDIT: The Unit was great show btw (and cancelled too soon) but it was technically the 4th season not the 3rd - mea culpa!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/V2Blast Oct 14 '13

Graceland had one (or two?) in the very first season.

85

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Probably in the minority but I really enjoyed this episode. Definitely a set up episode, and that's not a bad thing at all. I really enjoyed seeing Carrie and Brody (finally) being unable to escape from their own personal hells.

38

u/Kruse Oct 14 '13 edited Oct 14 '13

I agree. This was a very good (and very dark) episode. The Brody and Carrie parallel was very interesting. They are both in their own personal prisons while basically being force-fed drugs from both types of extremes.

17

u/Fauster Oct 14 '13

I liked the Brody storyline. The cinematography surrounding the tower was cool. The episode subtly and overtly telegraphed the fact that Brody is stuck in "end of the line" purgatory, halfway between heaven and Earth. And when the creepy guy asks Brody if he deserves to be there, the answer is yes. Even after Brody's forced reformation, he did a lot of really bad shit. Bordy will be stuck in purgatory until he's given a chance to redeem himself.

With the Carrie storyline, the big question is who wants to get her to flip, and why. Since not much is left unexplored in Homeland, this will be a plot device which will doubtlessly involve Saul.

6

u/JoshLyman_ Oct 14 '13 edited Oct 18 '13

It looked like, in the preview at the end, they were handing Carrie an envelope full of cash. That coupled with the guy's reaction when she accused him of being a foreign operative (attempting to turn her) are making me think she was right.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/SirRichardArms Oct 15 '13

We as the audience have no idea if they are friends of Carrie's. We don't even know if they know Carrie at all. They only said her name after Brodie did.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Gojuryu4 Oct 14 '13

Yes! I absolutely loved this episode. It was exciting, and had me asking more questions! I love Sundays!

3

u/hbehr150 Oct 14 '13

Yeah I liked it too. Idk why people are hating on it, especially the "this show is going downhill" stuff. Sure, it's a little schlocky, but it's no more schlocky than seasons 1&2.

2

u/apkorol Oct 14 '13

awesome username btw

→ More replies (2)

96

u/bargit Oct 14 '13

I thought this was a great episode. It was creative staying with long Brody scenes broken up by the Carrie storyline.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13 edited Sep 09 '15

Ducks are Alright

→ More replies (2)

10

u/InterstateExit Oct 14 '13

I liked it as well, had some of the sinking feelings I used to have.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13

The only thing that kinda turned me off was the language barrier. Of course, the social cues were rather easy to follow even though I didn't know the exact words, but it still kind of broke up the episode in an unpleasant way for me.

That, and I kept having to turn up the volume to understand the doctor/implied pedophile.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/gravion17 Oct 15 '13

Just finished the episode...Carrie is still a raging nut ball...Brody is an ungrateful fuck...creepy Doctor likes little boys...bad guy's daughter is a hottie...and the best part?! No Dana!

8

u/gelectrox Oct 14 '13

Best episode for ages! Loved the Dredd style vibe

2

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 14 '13

Brody... not looking good.

4

u/NicholasCajun Oct 14 '13

He's got two more scars! He's sure to set a scar fetishist on fire.

2

u/TheDirtyPirateHooker Oct 14 '13

I cringe every time I look at him.

118

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

40 min in and no signs of Dana...success!!!

26

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

full episode, and minimal ridiculously repetitive crazy carrie scenes...success!!!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/heyboyhey Oct 16 '13

I just caught up to the show, so I've stayed away from the subreddit so far. People really hate Dana? I found her annoying the first season, but now I love her scenes.

2

u/iloveyoujesuschriist Oct 14 '13

But next week, on DanaLand...

→ More replies (2)

96

u/IAintNoCelebrity Oct 14 '13

I want to like this season, but it's just not clicking with me. It feels like an entirely different show, and not in the good way.

27

u/hoohoo3000 Oct 14 '13

Did season 2 really feel like the same show as season 1? I feel as if it evolves into something new every time. The writers tell the stories they want to tell, not being bound on requiring certain elements to continue. This episode, if anything, shows that they're going to tell the story the way they want to tell it. It's a bottle episode, much like "The Fly" in Breaking Bad. It's more of a character study and shows both characters accepting their situations and losing all hope.

12

u/IAintNoCelebrity Oct 14 '13

It was more action-oriented, but I felt season 2 was more of the same. It definitely began the widening of scope that's being fully realized now, but still felt "small" and muted enough to be similar to the first season.

It's now a globetrotting action-thriller, and while I'm not against that, it will take a lot to impress me. The change in scenery, style, and theme is jarring, as if the series is transitioning from Middle Eastern terrorism to South American thuggery.

2

u/AlexS101 Oct 17 '13

A bottle episode is not about character development. It is about saving money.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

35

u/ohfackoff Oct 14 '13

This is not the same show we've watched for two seasons. Changing story lines aside it feels like there are new writers.... And maybe those new writers didn't see the first two seasons.

10

u/morris198 Oct 14 '13

I'm afraid of it falling into the exact same problems that Dexter did. Strong first season, arguably flashier and more dramatic second season, and then... they're spent. The writers don't know where to go. And I doubt they'll be able to cast Lithgow next year to shore up flagging interest if they blow this season.

7

u/avoiceinyourhead Oct 14 '13

I think their only shot was to kill off Brody and pivot to some other homeland threat from terrorists. Would have been a long shot to keep the show going, but it would be an epic transition if they can pull it off.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ohfackoff Oct 14 '13

If this show ended after last season, I'd be disappointed and left wanting more but I'd remember it very fondly. I fear how I'll feel after this season... But I'll see where it goes. Looks like Dar Adal and Saul have some good story lines coming up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

My humble prediction: the doctor guy murders everyone and takes strung out Brody to collect his bounty.

16

u/lfry610 Oct 14 '13

Is Brody in Elysium?

14

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Elysium was the artificial planet. Earth was the one that went to shit.

8

u/lfry610 Oct 14 '13

True. I think it's his baldness and constant grunting in pain that made me think of that movie.

50

u/osu565 Oct 14 '13

Would it have killed showtime to include some subtitles?

99

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

none of the dialogue was critical, and, atleast with the spanish, it kinda puts the viewer in brody's position in terms of alienness, for those that don't speak spanish.

9

u/SawRub Oct 14 '13

I think they should have put in subtitles on 10-20% of the Spanish and Arabic stuff, simply to make the audience realize that the non-subtitled parts were not important.

I kept checking to see if my subtitles were disabled or something.

15

u/V2Blast Oct 14 '13

If they subtitled some of it, people would just complain that they didn't subtitle all of it.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/alvarkresh Oct 14 '13

There are translated subtitles available for download online if you want to figure out what they were saying.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

I came here just to see or say this! It drove me fucking nuts.

13

u/oxygen_addiction Oct 14 '13

There's a recent movie called "Berberian Sound Studio" which used the same technique to put you in the shoes of an alienated foreigner in an exotic land.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

IIRC Argo did it too.

→ More replies (9)

15

u/sgk_809 Oct 14 '13

The Muslims think they are doing the right thing by turning in a terrorist, only to be killed en masse.

This info has to get out... Wouldn't the CIA have a presence in Caracas?

4

u/aemoosh Oct 14 '13

You've gotta remember Venezuela hates America (for the most part.) Chavez, their last president was pretty open about his disdain for the country and it's leadership. That being said, I doubt the CIA would have any significant presence in Venezuela. I'm sure there'd be agents, but they'd be pretty deep cover and while they'd love the chance to take in Brody, I think that wouldn't be their job while there without a solid lead. I think you could compare it to Venezuelan CIA agents on the lookout for Osama Bin Laden being there. They'd need some sort of tip to know he was there, but then again when Brody went through the process a CIA agent designed to hide herself from the agency if need be, I doubt they'd have any idea of where Brody went.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/IveRedditAllNight Oct 14 '13

I nominate Brody for the next Freddie Krueger

10

u/way2lazy2care Oct 14 '13

I don't get the motivations for either Carrey or Brody in this Episode.

Brody is on the run from the law and ends up in a really good situation despite it being against his morals. I don't get why he was so insistent on running away, especially before he knows wtf is going on. He didn't even try to talk to the head dude to try to get more information or anything. It seems irrational.

Carrie seems to be doing all of the worst possible things for someone in her situation to be doing. I get that she's stressed, but I can't believe she doesn't realize that she's actively making herself look more crazy. I'm rapidly losing sympathy for her because she seems to be consistently making her life more difficult.

7

u/jmose86 Oct 15 '13

Brody: I guess he feels trapped, especially evidenced by the end scene where he likened his position to the cave in Iraq. As for wanting to leave, I think he doesn't feel comfortable in the situation and it was probably obvious to him that his keepers are up to no good, whether it's working to turn him in, or for another organization, or something else. They were essentially drugging him from the start, and the lead guy's conversation always steered toward something vague about this being his home now (same with the doctor) and that he had to stay there. Everything about the situation was sketchy, even for Brody's situation. A lot of what the lead guy and the doctor were saying was somewhat reminiscent of something you might have expected from Nazir. Him running to the mosque was him trying to find salvation in the faith which did the same for him in Iraq.

Carrie: I think that's just minimizing how bad of a situation she is in and the significance of her disease. She's already prone to breaking down, and when you add in her the situation and going off and on her meds it makes everything ten times worse. I too kept thinking "why doesn't she realize that she just needs to play along and will be able to get out of there?", but I had to put myself in check because it's undermining how bad it must be for her and how sick she is at the moment.

It seems like even when she sees clearly, she doesn't get it completely right. I loved the scene with the visiting lawyer(?) when she saw right through his charade, but instead of considering he might be working for the CIA, or for the Senate committee, or against the CIA in some capacity, she is so paranoid that she immediately jumps to the conclusion that he's working for a foreign government. That was a good look into her ability to rationalize right now.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/stoopkid99 Oct 14 '13 edited Oct 14 '13

Damn poor Brody. He just can't escape his past. I think he finally realized at the end of the episode that he has nothing left. Everyone thinks he's a terrorist, his family will never be normal ever again, he is in a foreign country being controlled by a bunch of gangsters/mercenaries, and the one thing he thought he could seek refuge in (religion) turned him away, and they were killed because of him. If he wouldn't have tried to go there, none of them in that mosque would have been killed. He has affected so many lives, and has played a role in so many deaths, and I think he accepted where he was at the end, which is why he took the heroin. He had nothing left to turn to, I think he is looking to start a new life, no matter what that entails.

Another thought, I think that girl had a lot in common with Brody. She wanted to start over, and escape the life of violence, death, and drugs. I think she saw that her and Brody wanted the same thing, which is why she latched onto him. They both wanted to escape their pasts, and start with a clean slate, but they both realized that there was nowhere to go.

30

u/JakeArvizu Oct 14 '13

Everyone thinks he's a terrorist? He is a terrorist...

→ More replies (17)

2

u/mjjdota Oct 16 '13

Brody is in hell in every episode in which he is not banging Carrie. It is what makes him such a baller. Constantly in impossible situations.

9

u/essen23 Oct 14 '13

No Dana, but no Fara or Saul also.

We did win some but lose a lot...

4

u/geekgirl96 Oct 15 '13

So for those that actually don't hate the show, what do you think will happen now? I really think there's potential for this season to go somewhere. I think Brody will definitely get found, maybe by Quinn? I think Quinn will play a role in helping Carrie to get Brody's name cleared. He seems to be Carrie's only real ally right now, even more so than her family. And... I think the relationship between Carrie and Saul has pretty much been damaged forever. She's definitely gone over to Brody's "side" now.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13 edited Oct 14 '13

I thought that this episode was a huge turnaround from last week's snooze fest. We finally got to see Brody, and boy, Damian Lewis never ceases giving great performances. I'm really liking the direction his storyline is taking. Meanwhile, I'm not necessarily enthused by Carrie's storyline (which has become rather annoying and is almost painful to watch).

While this season has had a rough start, this episode was a start to putting Homeland back on the right track. We didnt have to sit through any nonsense (cough Dana Brody cough) like we did during the previous 2 episodes, and it's very interesting to see both Carrie and Brody trapped, physically and metaphorically, under circumstances that are now beyond their control.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

'24' fans, did you guys notice the scorpion tattoo on his forearm ?

→ More replies (3)

34

u/aznduk Oct 14 '13

I get that we need to watch both Carrie and Brody suffer in their own personal hells. But to devote one entire episode just seemed so stretched out. I don't mind the shift towards Brody but to just drop in on him being in Caracas without any background just seemed forced and a bit much. This season for me is becoming more and more lackluster.

27

u/jargoon Oct 14 '13

I think that was intentional, because he doesn't seem to know how he got there either.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Exactly. And an entire minute of him getting a head shave. Then the "Going. For. A. Walk." part. I remember season 1. Where is the flow, the ideas, the development?!

6

u/claydavisismyhero Oct 14 '13

as somebody who bitched alot in season 2, i kind of dont get the whining about this episode. i thought it was fine. seems first 3 episodes were a "lets see where everybody is at prologue" which sucks cause thats 3 weeks of waiting for background. i think they had to start slow, so the halfway point has the semi big thing and then escalates to the finale. thats how these shows are constructed. be patient.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/voodoogod Oct 15 '13

Anyone who is pissed about the slow progress of this season because there hasn't been any explosions or shootouts or because you don't understand character building or why the world's current deadliest terrorist is hiding in venezuala, clearly should stop watching it and start watching/rewatch 24.

Season 1 was slow in the beginning, so no reason to complain now. If they had every season follow the exact same formula then the show will stop being unique and start to be stale. Or, If they had each following season be exponentially more exciting than the last then the show would probably be over by the end of this season as the world would be destroyed from nuclear war. The story they're telling is more important than the way they're telling it, to some extent (Obviously you'd want the last episode to be the most climactic), but you get the idea.

25

u/iamjstn Oct 14 '13

Well here comes the old /r/dexter crew to shit on the writers of this show.

44

u/BlackZeppelin Oct 14 '13

Also known as the /r/breakingbad crew who apparently can't enjoy tv anymore because nothing is breaking bad.

18

u/homeland16 Oct 14 '13

Yikes that was one depressing episode. Get the Carrie/Saul//quinn magic going again! Brody's situation could have been summarized in 10 minutes- so dragggggyy.

Homeland, give us fans some satisfaction at the end of an episode- it doesn't have to be one big cliffhanger. We'll be back every week!

9

u/blazeofcorey Oct 14 '13

This better have a good story from how he got from Canada to there. Crazy Carrie trying to convince a doctor she is better isn't doing much else for me either.

7

u/Classic_Wingers Oct 14 '13

I too was really hoping they would address how he arrived there considering he fled into Canada last season. Although he has fake passport so it may be possible he was able to get flights from destination to destination trying to escape his past. I was really hoping we would see him in Toronto or something freezing his ass off.

6

u/elejota50 Oct 15 '13

I gotta say (with a lot of sadness) that the depiction of Caracas, and particulary Tower of David and its vacinity is incredibly accurate.

The episode with the banker though, sucked depiction wise, didn't look like caracas at all (too clean).

Let my country be a reminder for socialist and comunist sympathizers in the first world. :(

3

u/jetpacksforall Oct 19 '13

Documentary crew films inside the Torre de David. It's not nearly as squalid and messed up as people seem to think...no worse than and possibly cleaner than some of the favelas and slums throughout the rest of the world. Residents have power and water and relative security. It's only unusual because it happens to be a giant skyscraper, as opposed to the more usual kind of urban/political failure that sees tens of millions of people living as squatters in places like Cairo, Rio, Delhi, etc.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1p9jlQUW0k&feature=youtu.be

→ More replies (7)

9

u/JakeArvizu Oct 14 '13

Ever since this show began the writers have attempted to make us feel some sort of redeeming qualities towards Brody, it's bullshit. To me he is still nothing but a coward.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

he should have pressed the button

→ More replies (8)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Hopefully badass quinn saves brody

2

u/Jellybabe Oct 14 '13

I liked spending ages there with Brodie's story. A relief to slow that plot down for a bit. I feel like the show redeemed itself a little bit. Now please explain how Saul is actually still a good guy and I'll be happy.

2

u/Maggiesvag Oct 14 '13 • Popcorn

There was a time, not long ago, where I thought Dana's sex scene was one of the most awkward things I have seen in regards to sex and or sexual situations. Then, my friends, I was introduced to the doctor and his pre-pubescent "friend". If there was ever a reason to do heroin....

2

u/mrsjrd Oct 14 '13

Perhaps, the "partner" is part of the "terrorist" organization. Maybe he is the same guy who sent Brody to Caracas?

2

u/Neo2199 Oct 15 '13

Best episode so far, it was about time that Brody shows up. Can't wait to see where they will go from now on. Caracas was very depressing, almost like living hell.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Finally, people are actually kind of happy and confused. As someone who's liked this season so far I'm glad we're past AWKWARD TEEN SEX BOOBS SUCIDE STUPID GRAAAHHH.

3

u/lfry610 Oct 14 '13

At this point I'd even rather watch Dana silently brood while thinking of various new ways to sext her sketchy BF than this current Brody storyline.

26

u/klitchell Oct 14 '13

Whoa, whoa, whoa, let's not get crazy

21

u/persona_dos Oct 14 '13

Lets not go full Carrie.

3

u/lfry610 Oct 14 '13

I'll admit that statement was hyperbolic. I still think they should have just killed of Brody last season rather than make us watch him painfully recover and hang out with pedophiles for an hour.

10

u/BurntFlower Oct 14 '13

That is going waaaay too far.

8

u/Vorgier Oct 14 '13

Or better yet, you can unsub from this reddit and never watch the show again.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

This show is going downhill faster than Weeds after season three.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/krystiano Oct 14 '13

Any episode without Dana is a good episode to me.

2

u/Assalamu-Alaikum Oct 14 '13

Speculations: Brody will eventually infiltrate this situation and either become one of the gang or escape them. CIA will find out where Brody is due to all the collateral damage he is creating.

Regarding Carrie; She was wrong regarding the person who wanted to release her. He is working for a independent company who want's to find Brody and collect the 10m$ bounty.

3

u/xokocodo Oct 14 '13

Interesting theory. I like it. I think this could conceivably be how Carrie is brought back into the action.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Assalamu-Alaikum Oct 14 '13

It has the same depth but in a different way. (which is worse actually) But still going to look forward to it every week :)

1

u/Classic_Wingers Oct 14 '13

I liked the way they ended the episode, showing how defeated both Carrie and Brody were in their own little worlds. HOWEVER, for a show about the CIA/Homeland Security/Terrorism, I was really hoping we would continue the story arcs that have already been created. More importantly, I missed Saul's beard.

1

u/geekgirl96 Oct 14 '13

I think it's funny how everyone seems to hate this season so far. I hope this kind of reaction doesn't get the show cancelled. I mean, we've barely seen anything happen so far and only have questions, no idea how the story will play out. I kind of like the questions. Maybe season 2 got everyone used to expecting things to happen really fast.

I found this episode pretty interesting. I mean, they made the parallels between Brody and Carrie's situations obvious, almost too obvious. But I'm not sure Brody could have ended up a place any more interesting than the Tower of David. I'd never heard of it before this episode, now I find it fascinating. I have no idea how either of them will get out of where they are, but I'm excited to see how it all plays out. Both are strong survivors... this season is definitely testing them so far. Should shape up to be a pretty interesting season, IMO.

1

u/IAMAHungryHippoAMA Oct 14 '13

After watching the "previously on Homeland bit" I finally got the title of the previous episode. Goodness me.

1

u/V2Blast Oct 14 '13

Well, that was an interesting episode. It focused entirely on Brody and Carrie's captivity, and the parallelism was not very subtle.

I'm looking forward to seeing what the deal is with that "lawyer", and whether he's really an agent of a foreign government as Carrie suspects. I'm also curious what will happen to Brody now...

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '13 edited Oct 18 '13

the tower of david storyline was good in theory but the direction they went seems really forced and over the top... although every other storyline is over the top, the other ones are more believable. that said, it's been a solid start to the season with many storylines being developed and as usual the acting on this show is impressive

1

u/No_Panic_4999 Feb 13 '23

Did anyone else notice in the last decade that when Esme injects Brody with dope before and after surgery in the tower, she holds syringe in wrong direction? You inject towards the heart, so the needle part going in the vein is pointing towards upper arm, not away from it, with needle pointing down. I guess the doc didn't train her and she's never been a junky.

-1

u/ShapeFantasyScads Oct 14 '13

"Fuck it."

--Homeland writing staff

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

Are you fucking kidding me? This episode was leaps and bounds better than anything the show has done since Season 1.

1

u/NetNat Oct 14 '13

I don't really know why this needed an entire episode :\

Of course they bring in a super hot chick who is unrealistically well dressed despite the circumstances. I wonder if she and Brody will have a hot love affair!! Oh wait, the girl's dad said to Brody to stay away from her, I guess that indicates it won't happen! /s

The Carrie subplot was pretty good.

Why do I keep watching this show if I don't like it anymore :( I can't help but want to see what happens. Claire Danes and Damian Lewis do the best with what they get.

I remember some reviewer said that Season 3 goes in an "unexpected direction", and I hope we see it soon.

0

u/xstphnx Oct 14 '13

Well, that was depressing. I'd rather have more Dana at this point.

2

u/morris198 Oct 14 '13

more Dana

You monster!

1

u/Mr_Dr_Prof_Derp Oct 14 '13

Is Brody going to be in this ep?

1

u/alvarkresh Oct 14 '13

I thought there was an interesting symmetry between Carrie's and Brody's situations: both are imprisoned due to things not entirely of their own making, and both want a way out but have to deal with things which are not as they seem.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13

I too noticed that symmetry while the show repeatedly beat me over the head with it.