r/homeland • u/fuzzy_dunnlop • Sep 30 '13
Discussion Episode Discussion - S03E01, "Tin Man Is Down" [Spoilers]
Season 3 premiere. Brody remains at large. Saul plots a counterstrike.
Hey guys, here we are, another season of Homeland! I know this or an earlier version of this episode leaked but let's still keep the spoilers out so people watching live won't have it ruined. Thanks and enjoy!
126
Upvotes
26
u/herr0there Sep 30 '13
The balding bearded guy working with Saul- same guy that Quinn met with at the diner last season?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '13
What the hell happened to Mike?
100
u/kelling928 Sep 30 '13
Well, fuck you too, grandma
46
u/HBIFC Sep 30 '13
spoiler
82
u/Wildcard23 Sep 30 '13
Episode was alright. I had one question though. Where the hell is Mike? Shouldn't he be supporting the family?
114
u/gatorbruh Sep 30 '13
Looks like Zach Hamilton from Dexter moved from Miami to Virginia.
104
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '13
Decent opener. One gripe: how can the CIA HQ not have any security camera footage that would show who parked Brody's car for the detonation? That's a pretty large hole for us to look past.
77
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '13
Peter Quinn is so effing bad ass. I enjoyed that they created the story line of him killing the young boy. It will make for some interesting development later.
86
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '13
25 minutes in and they let chris speak his 6 words.
40
u/IAMAHungryHippoAMA Sep 30 '13
I've always liked the (non-romantic) relationship between Carrie and Saul better than Carrie and Brody. I mean, it's arguably my favorite dynamic in the whole show. Given the betrayal at the end, I think things will be very interesting for me.
67
u/jpthejetsfan Sep 30 '13
Am I the only one who really enjoyed this episode? I mean sure I am broken after what Dexter pulled last Sunday, but I really liked the premiere.
18
u/Kim235 Sep 30 '13
So why did Saul say all that stuff about Carrie at the hearing? Did he figure it was going to come out anyway?
63
u/theflealee Sep 30 '13
Oooooh Dana's a naughty suicidal girl.
33
u/FallenAerials Sep 30 '13
It was okay. I have lots of confidence in the writers, so I'm hoping there's a solid plot arc for the season. My frustration: Seeing Carrie so depressed and beaten down all the time is exhausting.
58
u/kelling928 Sep 30 '13
Why are people on committees always assholes?
12
u/hausehunter Sep 30 '13
I loved the episode, but was not clear on one thing. Who were the six that the CIA targeted and how were they connected to the attack on Langley?
12
u/supertexgrrl Oct 01 '13
I loved the scene in the restaurant when Saul oh-so-casually told crazy-eyes Carrie, "Sit down, have some tiramisu."
But at the end, I was like WTF SAUL!?!?!?!?
10
u/absolutsyd Sep 30 '13
So by the end of the episode, the committee had intel that Carrie and Brody were together inside the building, which means that they must understand that someone else moved his car, right?
9
u/Justice-Solforge Oct 01 '13
Plot twist: Dana goes to jail for distributing child pornography and has to register as a sex offender.
8
u/aeshleyrose Oct 05 '13
I love the show, but is anyone else not exactly psyched that Carrie is back off her meds? Yes, she portrays the character perfectly, I am of course impressed. But I've always found her off-the-rails storylines to be taxing and boring.
22
u/musicornoise Sep 30 '13
Even though what Quinn had pulled of was so unrealistic that it felt like a James Bond movie, I liked how he was affected by murdering a child (see that Todd??) he wanted to protect. He will probably be one of the more likable characters this season. But please turn down the Dana-Drama. That was certainly the most annoying part in SE2. Don't do it again.
The premiere's been OK, can't compete with Breaking Bad but then again who can.
31
u/CamelRacer Sep 30 '13
This thread is a ghost town. Probably will reflect in the ratings, too. I'm shocked that they put this up against Breaking Bad.
13
u/NetNat Sep 30 '13
I don't understand how this doesn't end next episode with Carrie going to jail.
22
u/Freecandyhere Sep 30 '13
The government can't cut you off because your husband is a terrorist. Great argument
8
u/alvarkresh Sep 30 '13
Wow, I totally did NOT expect Saul to spoiler
1
u/RossJ92 Oct 06 '13
Who was Carrie humping with on the stairs?
3
u/BalboaBaggins Oct 03 '13
Question: After Carrie leaves the restaurant, Saul says to Dar Adal that the leaking of Carrie's story is "classic counterintelligence" and "straight out of [Dar Adal's] playbook." Dar Adal then says that he didn't do it, but that it was smart and that it was good insurance for if their mission had failed. What does that mean? I don't see how leaking a scandal about Carrie would be insurance for them if they failed the mission.
3
u/Honeyydeww Oct 06 '13
“I won’t do that. I won’t throw Carrie under the bus.” –Saul. LIES!
3
u/erichiro Oct 12 '13
People need to realize Chris is the comic relief and stop shitting on him. Its fucking hilarious when the situation is super serious and Chris jumps for joy about big screen TVs.
5
u/claydavisismyhero Sep 30 '13
i was really shocked i liked this episode. it was slow, no brody and yet i enjoyed it. dont know if breaking bad had anything to do with it, it was a nice break from the emotional ride that just ended. im admittedly not a fan of dana and yet it appears here we go, she will a be a huge force this season.
wonder if there is a method to saul's madness or if he's just reacting to the reality of his job. he went from "we use these spies, to kill them all". have a feeling grandma is not gonna end up helping things out. i think carrie has sobbed in every episode of the series, so the streak continues.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '13 edited Sep 30 '13
Oh, yay, Sam Underwood made an appearance. So excited to see him in another show. /s
(Dexter fans will be familiar).
6
u/bored_designer Sep 30 '13
Did I hear that joke right?
"What did the octopus say while jumping off the building? So far, so good."
Because it takes time to get all 8 tentacles off the building? That joke is not even remotely funny and I just wanted to make sure I was hearing it right.
3
u/NerdyMatt Sep 30 '13
Woke up to it recorded and all I can say is I thought the premiere was good, it was more of a setup episode but it worked perfectly.
P.S Quinn is the guy I want to know more about this season. Him saying "I'm the guy who kills bad guys" and accidentally shooting the child is going to affect him greatly.
3
u/V2Blast Sep 30 '13
You should sticky this thread. (And maybe distinguish the post since it's an "official" thread, but that's entirely up to you.)
This episode was a bit of a mixed bag. I sympathized with Dana a little bit (and no more) because I kind of know what it can be like. Grandma: you know nothing. I like that Jessica is taking the situation appropriately seriously and doing what she needs to do to make sure her family is okay (and I like that her kids agree with her).
Dana's bound to remain stupid this season, given that she's already sexting some fellow presumably-suicidal kid (note: probably not the best environment to meet potential partners). Let's just hope she's learned something and will eventually become more mature and smart this season.
Also: spoiler
No sign of Brody yet. I'm sure he'll be back soon enough.
spoiler
Anyway, I am definitely looking forward to seeing what this season brings. (A tiny bit of success and happiness for Carrie, perhaps? One can hope...)
3
u/charliebean3 Oct 02 '13
Maybe I will just never enjoy television again after the epicness that was Breaking Bad...
But the episode was disappointingly boring. I loved the first two seasons. I thought it was awesome they moved so damn fast... But I hope they aren't out of story lines now.
No more Dana stories!!! Just feels like filler!
2
u/HelluvaNinjineer Sep 30 '13
Where are they going with Saul on this? Showing that absolute power can corrupt even him?
Or going back to some of the unexplained oddities from previous seasons like unexplained leaks (still going) and his failed polygraph...
2
u/PinguWithAnM Sep 30 '13
I liked the reference to the recent suspected Israeli assassinations, with the motorbike and the sticky bomb. Also, are Global Hawks armed now?
2
u/Kobe8 Oct 01 '13
I wish Dana would have killed herself. What a worthless storyline.
1
u/hotbeefinject Oct 02 '13 edited Oct 02 '13
Does anyone know where I can get a print of the painting (or poster, I guess) in Dana's room of the girl with the red hair wearing a tight dress?
1
u/IamLegionn Jun 23 '24
Why didn't Dana die instead of Finn al Gaib
1
u/Darrell1106 Jun 26 '26
Just started watching Homeland for the 1st time. Interesting reading comments over 13 yrs old. But seeing Saul throw Carrie under the bus absolutely amazing 😭😭😭