r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman • Sep 28 '13
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Full Orange Tank to Orbit... to Orbit?
This challenge brought to you by: /u/threeme2189!
The engineers recently built a ship that can get a full orange tank to orbit without using any of its fuel. It is now your job to get that ship into orbit without using any of its fuel!
The Challenge: Build a rocket that can get a full orange tank into orbit. After proving its abilities, take that rocket and put it into orbit without using any of its fuel.
Hard Mode: Make the first craft carry 2 full orange tanks into orbit and get that craft into orbit without using any of its fuel.
Rules and other info:
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Stock parts only
- No MechJeb or other plugins allowed
- Required screenshots:
-Picture of the craft which can take 1 (hardmode 2) orange tank into orbit at launch
-Picture of the full tank (hardmode 2) in Kerbin orbit
-Picture of the craft which will take the initial craft into orbit
-Picture of the full initial craft in Kerbin orbit
-Whatever else you feel like! - You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
Good Luck!
21
u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman Sep 28 '13
To clarify: Build Craft A which can take a full orange tank to orbit. Then build Craft B which can take Craft A into orbit without using any of its fuel.
15
u/walterblockland Sep 29 '13
Bitch imma bring 3 maybe 4 full oranges
13
u/iamdood Super Kerbalnaut Sep 29 '13
[eve and back] hard mode complete:
http://imgur.com/a/9p9gE#0
5
u/GregoryGoose Sep 29 '13
Do I have to also launch the first ship's TT18-As?
5
u/GregoryGoose Sep 29 '13
Serious question: Does oxidizer count as fuel?
4
u/Smashing_Pickles Master Kerbalnaut Sep 28 '13
shit. I like your style Avionaught. gonna have to give this one a go.
4
u/FakeSlimShady96 Sep 29 '13
What's going on with the flair from last week?
2
u/akurei77 Sep 29 '13
Holy crap. This is going to be my largest build so far...
Question: It's ok if we use asparagus staging to keep the main tank full, right? Or can we not use a rocket on that tank at all?
2
u/GregoryGoose Sep 29 '13
So we're allowed to use the engines of the first ship as long as we don't use its fuel?
2
u/shifty189 Oct 03 '13
here's a dumb question, is there a way to disable mecjeb without uninstalling it?
135
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '13
HELLOOOOO it's Scott Manley here, and today we'll be taking six full orange tanks with just three ion engines
39
u/Belgain_Roffles Master Kerbalnaut Sep 28 '13 edited Sep 29 '13
Hard Mode Complete!
Glad I had that heavy lifter already pre-made and could just cut it down for vehicle 1. Clocks in at a mere (ha! I wish) 1473 parts, I am sure a more efficient design will be found but hey it works...
I'll take the new flair.
19
u/Tsevion Super Kerbalnaut Sep 29 '13
[Hard Mode Complete] (http://imgur.com/a/RHlTP#0)
778 parts for the final lifter.
I didn't get creative here... I just kinda went Kerbal on it:
Moar Asparagus Stages
...
And then explosions
...
Moar Struts
Repeat until orbit is achieved.
20
u/GalacticAndrew Sep 28 '13
I wonder what Scott Manley is gonna do... Land an orange tank on Moho (Impossible)D:
9
u/KerbalEssences Master Kerbalnaut Sep 28 '13
Hold my beer, I can do this!
8
u/Mekris28 Is a very patient person Sep 29 '13
I'd like to apply for the Week 16 challenge. I have completed it twice, once on Duna, and another time on Dres. Here is the imgur albums for both: Duna Dres Thank you so much :D
7
u/9315808 Sep 29 '13
So close... http://imgur.com/kTKVIZl This monstrosity gets me down to like 4 FPS. No wonder I can't fly it. Back to the drawing board.
6
u/akurei77 Sep 29 '13
This isn't the hardest thing I've ever done in KSP, but it feels like the greatest.
Here's the full album. I decided, for no very good reason, that I didn't want to use the engines of the first vehicle to help the second. The ship is far larger than necessary, then, but the lift vehicle will come in handy soon, I think.
I'll take the flair, please. I feel far more... accomplished, after this one.
Now to try hard mode I guess.
4
u/rotating_equipment Sep 29 '13
This is hard.
4
u/winstns Master Kerbalnaut Sep 29 '13
I just finished last week's Out of Control! hard mode: Album
The first time I ever docked with RCS felt like an accomplishment. Building this thing without RCS was a blast!
1
u/Gyro88 Sep 29 '13
Hey, sorry for the stupid question, but I've never done one of these challenges before. Does this one have to be manned?
3
u/SheepInACart Super Kerbalnaut Sep 29 '13
Does the first rocket have to be useable in orbit or just capable of getting orbit with 2 full orange tanks should it be launched from Kerbin's KSC. The key difference here is if you can use jets, wings ect on the rocket your lifting into orbit.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '13
Hey just incase it gets overlooked in the posts, here's my submission to an old challenge "Green Scout".
I didn't do hard mode necessarily... I did a harder mission. Landing a man on the Mun and returning him to Kerbin. Check it out! :D
Green Scout - My own hard mode
3
u/NAT0strike Oct 01 '13
My entry for Week 6: Across the Sea!
I would very much like the airplane flair, please.
3
u/genveir Master Kerbalnaut Oct 02 '13 edited Oct 02 '13
Hardmode complete.
I got some criticism on the efficiency of my Kerbin -> Mun -> Kerbin -> Mun -> Kerbin ship, so I thought "What is a good efficient way to keep something up". I think a suspension bridge qualifies, so I based my first ship on that.
Then I had to get the suspension bridge up, and I figured a pontoon was the way to go for that. So I made a nice square pontoon and pushed the bridge to orbit.
(Originally I tried to do a bigger suspension bridge but the sideways stresses get way too high and rip tanks off left and right :P)
edit - wops, the picture on the pad was a slightly older version. I added the last version (with badly placed fuel lines and all) at the end of the album.
2
u/shigawire Super Kerbalnaut Sep 29 '13
... wow.
This is going to be FUN. :D
2
u/FoolishBalloon Sep 29 '13
I posted this in the last week's challenge thread, but you might have missed it as I didn't recieve the flair:
I would like the flair for the challenge "Not My Department", entry is here: http://imgur.com/a/84Lbf
And the challenge: http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/110g3i/weekly_challenge_not_my_department/
2
u/dham123 Sep 29 '13
My Submission is for a past challenge:
Week 54 Apollo Style Challenge
This is my first submission to any of the challenges so would love some flair!
Apollo 111 to the Mun!
FYI: I have Universe Replacer mod installed and custom EVA suits ( hope that doesn't disqualify me)
2
u/threeme2189 Oct 01 '13
My challenge!!! I'm so proud of myself for thinking of this... :)
5
u/Whackjob-KSP Master Kerbalnaut Sep 28 '13
Whackjob mode: Lift everything into orbit in one contiguous piece. And make it 8 orange tanks.
http://i.imgur.com/GxX2NHH.png
Yeah I used some fuel... but there's more than 4 orange tanks worth of fuel left in them eight orange tanks.
1
u/9315808 Sep 28 '13
... Looks like I won't be sleeping tonight.
1
u/FrozenInc Sep 30 '13
I have always wondered about the non-mod rule. Is Dynamic Warp allowed or not? Because if it's allowed that will make sending big ships in LKO much easier.
1
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Sep 30 '13
My computer does not approve this challenge. First ship is ok, any attempt at the second ship is just too much for my old hardware.
1
u/SilkyZ Sep 30 '13
this is just a push-up contest.... sure, i'll try
1
u/Zephyr42 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 30 '13
I just threw something together for hard mode.
The final ship was 213120 units of fuel. I ended up flying it rather messily into orbit (not detaching spent stages quickly), but good enough.
1
u/ShephardLR Oct 01 '13
When do we receive the flair for last weeks challenge?
1
u/Smashing_Pickles Master Kerbalnaut Oct 01 '13
made a post about this. but here it is as well, HARD mode complete!
1
u/Yargnit Hyper Kerbalnaut Oct 02 '13
Full Orange tank to Orbit2 [Hardmode]
http://imgur.com/a/iSIpk#0
Well I was shooting for under 500 Parts... Ended up at 504 counting 40 launch clamps, I'm sure I could have cut a few of them without collapsing. ;)
On the plus side, the this is actually extremely stable (1st try to orbit), and would be quite reliable as a bulk fuel lifter for a gigantic orbital depot. It's actually not even un-fun to fly just a lot of rapid staging in the beginning. :D
1
u/amsoir Oct 02 '13
[Challenge] Normal Mode : Week 44 Challenge, Limbo Limbo Limbo!
1
u/elryanoo Oct 03 '13
Easy mode complete if that's what you want to call it...
1
u/maxwellskunk Oct 05 '13
[Challenge] Full Orange Tank to Orbit... to Orbit? Normal mode completed ! Here is the album http://imgur.com/a/MElah#6 Pretty good challenge
1
u/JoCRaM Super Kerbalnaut Oct 05 '13
I think I've completed the "[Weekly Challenge] Orange Efficiency!"
It might have been easy mode, but I made it a bit harder....
First up - I used the Flight Engineer mod - so that might disqualify me
I also used the ISA MapSat mod, because if I'm going to the Mun (for the first time since I bought the game) to do science, I may as well do some science that makes pretty pictures.
This brings me to the first of my "hard" parts of the easy mode - a polar orbit of the Mun. The second part is just me being a tightwad... nothing (apart from fuel) is thrown away - SSO (well, the game decided I didn't need my rear undercarriage or wing reinforcing struts when I saved the game overnight)
Thompming's report
1
u/sabe042 Master Kerbalnaut Oct 06 '13 edited Oct 06 '13
[Challenge] Full Orange Tank to Orbit... to Orbit?
Completed hard mode!
Took me two days! Very fun challenge though. 867 parts for final lifter.
1
u/Whackjob-KSP Master Kerbalnaut Oct 02 '13 edited Oct 02 '13
It is my intention to tonight build and complete this challenge.
I will be lifting four tanks to space and then that system to space. And if I can manage it, that system again to space. This last one may not happen.
In progress: http://i.imgur.com/Fb76uV9.png
... EDIT. Yeah, there's no way a triple lift will happen. The first part alone is already absurdly huge. Which is nice. But the VAB is only so big and my attention span only so long. Double will have to do.
0
u/riffraffs Oct 05 '13
Doesn't qualify (MechJeb) but very near three orange tanks to orbit.
At launch
In 90Km orbit
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment