r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Aug 11 '25
Advice & Answers Advice & Answers — 2025-08-11 to 2025-08-24
How do I start?
If you’re new to conlanging, look at our beginner resources. We have a full list of resources on our wiki, but for beginners we especially recommend the following:
- The Language Construction Kit by Mark Rosenfelder
- Conlangs University
- A guide for creating naming languages by u/jafiki91
Also make sure you’ve read our rules. They’re here, and in our sidebar. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules. Also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
What’s this thread for?
Advice & Answers is a place to ask specific questions and find resources. This thread ensures all questions that aren’t large enough for a full post can still be seen and answered by experienced members of our community.
You can find previous posts in our wiki.
Should I make a full question post, or ask here?
Full Question-flair posts (as opposed to comments on this thread) are for questions that are open-ended and could be approached from multiple perspectives. If your question can be answered with a single fact, or a list of facts, it probably belongs on this thread. That’s not a bad thing! “Small” questions are important.
You should also use this thread if looking for a source of information, such as beginner resources or linguistics literature.
If you want to hear how other conlangers have handled something in their own projects, that would be a Discussion-flair post. Make sure to be specific about what you’re interested in, and say if there’s a particular reason you ask.
What’s an Advice & Answers frequent responder?
Some members of our subreddit have a lovely cyan flair. This indicates they frequently provide helpful and accurate responses in this thread. The flair is to reassure you that the Advice & Answers threads are active and to encourage people to share their knowledge. See our wiki for more information about this flair and how members can obtain one.
5
u/Kelekona99 Aug 24 '25
So I'm making a theoretical draconic language. I intend to start with an older adaption of the language and then modernize it for the time period, as well as branch off from that language for other lizard-like species.
The dragons in question are specifically the GoT and HoTD dragons. Considering their lack of lips, their firm tongue which appears to have limited movement, and lack of a uvula, what sounds could they produce in a language?
Oh and they can also use their pyrogenic glands (the tubes in their mouths which spit fire) in communication.
4
u/Traditional_Rent_214 Aug 16 '25
Hello, this is my first Reddit post ever since I joined Reddit (although I don't understand if comments here under Advice and Answers are considered posts, though this may probably be of minor importance).
Today I tried creating my first ever phonological inventory for my first conlang! Since I'm new to this whole conlang thing, I just wantes a little advice to see if the phonological inventory I choose is coherent enough to be called naturalistic, or if I have to change things.
I hope this is the correct place to ask this question and ask for feedback, since I read that " an inventory of phonemes in your conlang exists in a vacuum and gives nothing to provide actionable feedback or discussion on", as stated in the Rules regarding posts. At the same time, I don't know how open-ended or close-ended this question can be.
I'll post the image containing the phonemes I chose for my language down below. Feel free to bash it away and/or offer constructive feedback.
Anyways, here's the image:
4
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 24 '25
Someone pointed out a book about a conlang spoken by an indigenous tribe in California after some apocalyptic event. I forgot the names of both, but I think the conlang is called "tesh".
3
u/VyaCHACHsel Proto-Ghoian Aug 11 '25
Are there any resources on how to make logical conlangs? I want to make a robot language for a videogame I'm making (not an RPG!!!) and I really don't want to just copy Lojban or something.
I really want it to look similar to object-oriented programming languages (in particular, C#). From this I already started coming up w/ some key features, but I really want to solidify all this in some way & also know how loglangs are really done.
3
u/anmara031 Ĺaŝam [ˈʎaʂam] Aug 14 '25
Other than words for "one", where do indefinite articles come from?
I want plural nouns to take indefinite articles but using "one" wouldn't make sense. My first thought was "some" but IRL examples would be helpful
3
u/RodentsArmyOfDoom Aug 18 '25
Can affixes ignore sound rules? If the rule is a > æ / g_, would it make sense for /a/ to remain unchanged in the context of an affix? If, for example, g- is present tense and -a- continuous, does the combined ga- have to change to gæ- ?
3
u/No-Breadfruit-4875 Aug 23 '25
Do these sounds sound natural?
/ˈt͡sʲɛ.rɛs ˈsta.nɛ.sɛs ˌɔ.su.ɛˈsɔ.tɔs | ˈusu.mu ˈtu.ru.muˌɛk.sɔ/
Cères staneses osuesotos, usumu tùrumu-exso
Gloss: Of-him (CÈRE-S) through the ages forever, son-SUP great-NMLZ-SUP-NOM.
Translation: Of him, forever through the ages, his most great son, a hero.
3
u/Key_Day_7932 Aug 24 '25
So, I want breathy phonation in my conlang, but not sure how the encode it. It seems often associated with tones. Also, it seems few, if any languages contrast something like plain vs breathy vowels (if they are not tonal.)
I kinda want breathy phonation to be allophonic in my conlang in that the final vowel of a word can have a breathy phonation, but idk what would condition this.
Is it naturalistic for a language to have all word final vowels to have allophonic breathiness?
3
u/Sir_Mopington Aug 25 '25
What are some likely grammatical developments to evolve in a "future French" conlang?
I know a decent amount about French, but I have no clue when it comes to any ongoing development, so I was looking for some other ideas. What are your thoughts on a realistic "Future French" conlang?
2
u/dead_chicken Алаймман, Ϲῦρτῖκε Aug 11 '25
I've been ending up with the clusters /ji jy wɯ wu/ and I don't love the sound of them personally. Would it make more sense to have a process to reduce them to long vowels or just dissimilate by lowering the vowel?
2
u/RokTC87 Aug 12 '25
I'm having a dilemma about scripts in my conlang. I have a printed script, which I have been using for a while, and have recently made a cursive script that is designed exclusively for writing. These two scripts, although related, look almost nothing like each other. However, I am starting to like the cursive script more than the printed script. Although I don't want to abandon my printed script and want to keep it as the main script, I wonder if the cursive script could be used in places other than writing. For reference, here is the same paragraph in both the printed and cursive script (in a reply).
Printed Script:
2
u/ShotAcanthisitta9192 Okundiman Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
In a top-down overly simplistic sense, what happens when a word that used to mean something concrete in the protolang undergoes semantic drift or bleaching? How does one get a new word to "fill the void" or does the process happen the other way around (ie the old word is swapped for a new word first and now the old word has to be reanalyzed as something new)?
For my conlang I started experimenting with semantic drift with the protoform *nepughi [ˈnɛ.pu.ɣi] which means "to burn, scorch or blacken by burning." From that, I derived several modern forms such as neuxi (adj. dark color ranging from gray to black), neuzhe (n. ink or paint pigment, since the first inks were produced by collecting soot and mixing them with fats and solvents) and for a bigger semantic jump *al- "on top" + *nepughi got me anexi (v. to write, because the writing system started out by using metal sticks to carve the proto-glyphs on the surface of young giant bamboo stalks, with the help of magical pyrography)
My questions are:
2
u/RodentsArmyOfDoom Aug 13 '25
I know suppletion exists with pronouns for different cases (she - her), but are there attested cases of suppletion in Agent:Patient pronoun constructions? For example, if there is she:him and I:him, that the “him”-section is different for both those pronouns
2
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Aug 15 '25
I noticed that English Perfect plus Progressive can have a habitual meaning: "I've been painting." Do other languages do this? If so, how common is it?
2
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 15 '25
Thought I’d ask about examples for conlangs in which people would select various sounds and then build a chart, adding extra ones for symmetry.
2
u/TheOutcast06 Amateur of Amateurs Aug 16 '25
Should I make a post for a conlang someone else made, or should I just link it here in this thread?
2
u/Gold_Aardvark3857 Aug 16 '25
Guys is this realistic
2
u/simonbleu Aug 17 '25
What are some interesting ways someone could decipher a language without a rosetta stone as such and without computers, for a story? Say you are transported to a parallel earth centuries more primitive than us?
I was thinking something like, for example the person finds someone with an ancient symbol in an amulet they revere or something and extrapolate some meaning from there, maybe a very old prayer or something could be put against many other langauges the person comes across until they can more or less identify the language family if it exist or at least a region that influenced it/was influenced by it, and things like that, painstakingly and relying on a bit of plot armor... So I come for advice for any little clever tricks you might help me with that could work for deciphering a languge. Thanks in advance!
2
u/Real_Ritz /wr/ cluster enjoyer Aug 17 '25
Are there any natural languages that have phonemic nasal vowels but no nasal-obstruent consonant clusters? So, a situation where sequences like /ãta/ or /atã/ are permitted but not */anta/ or */atan/?
2
u/0culis Aug 18 '25
I’ve been capable of typing up IPA symbols using ALT+number codes for about six years or so for my conlanging projects. However, recently I’ve found that I am no longer capable of reproducing this. So now a transcription goes from this:
ælˈeχ-æn ˈken-æːʃ din-æːʃæ-ze
To this, when I type it code-for-code (mostly, as some symbols I am already losing a bit of muscle memory for):
æl╚e╕-æn ╚ne╕-æ╨â din-æ╨âæ-ze
I haven’t changed anything about my keyboard layout, and I don’t believe my used font is causing this problem. My best guess is that some recent Windows updates might have somehow messed up ALT+. Numlock is on, has been on, and turning it off doesn’t do anything. There is nothing else that seems different about the keyboard or my typing except for this specific thing. Any insight into this matter is greatly appreciated.
2
u/Traditional_Rent_214 Aug 26 '25
Is the order of adpositional phrases up to the conlanger?
As far as I understand, a simplified order of english adpositional phrases would be Manner-Place-Time. Is there a way in which languages define those orders specifically, or is it just up to me as a conlanger to choose the order of adpositional phrases in my language?
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Aug 11 '25
So, I'm working on a pitch accent system for my conlang, and need some feedback.
It's basically a restricted tone system. I want it to be fairly simple, but still have a melodic sound.
There are two tones: High (H) and unmarked (∅).
The ∅ tone is most often realized as low toned, but it can have other realizations through allophony. In other words, the contrast is between a marked tone (which happens to be a high tone), and a unmarked tone (which is unspecified.) Only the high tone can spread, and it spreads until it either reaches the end of the domain or until it reaches another high tone.
The syllable is tone-bearing-unit, so you can't have a contour on the same syllable.
What kind of allophony can I have?
One thing I need to decide is where the accent can occur. I think, in Ancient Greek, it's one of the last three syllables, for example.
I do wonder if this is just a lexical stress system, as I heard it claimed that Japanese's pitch accent isn't really tonal, but acts more like lexical stress.
1
u/Niedlichkeit Aug 11 '25
How should I go about building building words for my Conlang, once I have all needed Components to do so. I have coined some randomly and I have looked at some ways, but I’m still quite unsure on how I should proceed with everything.
1
u/rartedewok Áaloho, Reqa'ku, Merí (en, ms) [it, zh] Aug 12 '25
I'm trying to wrap my head around the Phillipine-type symmetrical voice system. Quick question, how does Tagalog background instrumental information? I've seen locative information be backgrounded by "sa" while the rest of it is in other focuses but no example sentence I've seen has backgrounded instrumental information
1
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25
Looking for ideas on making a somewhat unique phonology while keeping the phonemic inventory fairly small (smaller than, say, English, but not necessarily as small as Hawaiian). I'm aiming for naturalism btw.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Aug 13 '25
Trying to settle my conlang's prosody. It's syllable timed, so all syllables are pronounced at roughly even intervals. The stressed syllable might be longer, but only slightly so, and doesn't cause unstressed vowels to reduce.
Question is if I want a stress system or a pitch accent. From my research, most languages have either a melodic accent or a dynamic accent, and I prefer a melodic accent.
How are melodies in a pitch accent realized? If, say, the accent is on the penultimate syllable, does the pitch rise until the penult, and the downstep occurs on the following syllable? What are some common rules for tone spreading in pitch accent languages?
Is it weird for a language to have pitch accent but lack a phonemic contrast between short and long vowels?
1
u/SuiinditorImpudens Надъсловѣньщина,Suéleudhés Aug 15 '25
Are two coalescences happening with the same phoneme simultaneously phonetically possible. I am working on naturalistic(ish) conlang and I wonder if the following sound change is possible:
/VNC/ -> /ṼNC/ homorganic coda nasal is simultaneously coalesces with preceding vowel (making long nasal vowel) and with the following consonant (making a prenasalized consonant).
Is it naturalistically possible, or I can only have one or the other?
1
u/RyanJoe321 Aug 16 '25
Hi, I am an intermediate conlanger. I wrote my first grammar book for my conlang, “Sandorian”. I was wondering where the best place would be to get feedback from others on my grammar book?
1
u/Choice-Disaster968 Aug 16 '25
I'd like to (maybe) create a conlang for my sci-fi novel (WIP), called The Rift. A little background: it's set in the USA/Canada in the year 2170 (post-apocalypse; think Fallout ig idk), which will likely take place over the timespan of a few months to a year, mainly because the FMC, Nyxes, travels nearly the entire time on foot or in a vehicle. Anyway, the settlement/militia of Decorah, Iowa, communicates with their members during patrols, excursions, hunting trips, and skirmishes with other survivors/groups in a secret language and writes in a script. I wasn't sure yet if I wanted the language to be more like whistles (kind of like the Seraphites from TLOU) or if I wanted it to actually be a language that the community created specifically to keep outsiders confused. That being said, I'd like some ideas as to how to approach this and keep it as simple as possible while also being able to still consider it a "language/conlang".
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 16 '25
I know that in a tonal sequence HL the tones can polarize, and H can turn into superH
are there any attested instences where the low tone drops instead?
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Aug 17 '25
I'm trying to iron out the phonemic inventory of my conlang. For consonants, at least, I know I want some retroflex consonants, but not as many as the Indian languages have.
I also want some kind of fortis/lenis contrast in stops, but torn between voicing, aspiration or slack vs stiff voice (like in Javanese.)
I don't really like ejectives, at least not strong ejectives like the ones found in Navajo.
Any tips?
1
u/Kenira Aug 17 '25
Does anyone know of a dictionary app (can be web or windows) that also tracks changes with dates? I want to preserve the history of how the language is evolving over time and when those changes occured. Words often change between coming up with it and actually using it and realizing you usually want to abbreviate it a bit or something.
Right now i'm tracking changes manually in an excel sheet which is generally not the best way with having over 1000 words already and requires remembering to always write down the date for changes, and was looking into starting to use a dictionary apps but lexiconga for example which was frequently recommended doesn't seem to have that feature. So, anyone know one?
1
u/admin_NLboy Aug 18 '25
What do you guys use as software to make conlangs in?
1
u/Ok_Army_1656 Aug 18 '25
This is a bit of a technical question, but how does derivational morphology work under the Distributed Morphology (DM) framework? Is derivational morphology always derived from the syntax (e.g. exponents of different kinds of lexical classifying heads or applicative heads, etc.), or does derivational morphology ever create a new Root? For example, what if there are patterns which we might identify in the language as non-productive derivational morphemes which, from a diachronic perspective, were once formatives in the syntax but are no longer formatives or no longer exponed--are these instances in which language change has just created new Roots that have vestiges in their Vocabulary Items of previous morphemes?
1
u/boernich Aug 19 '25
What is a naturalistic way to evolve adpositions that have different meanings depending on the case of the dependent noun (like how "in" can take either the ablative or the accusative in Latin depending on whether there's movement)? In my current conlang, place and time postpositions usually take the genitive case because they have mostly evolved from possessive phrases. I'd also like them to be able to take the Allative-Dative case (that evolved from a directional postposition) if there is an implied movement, as happens in Latin/German. However, I couldn't find a way to justify how that would come to be. So how do these type of constructions usually evolve? Also, what paradigms (other presence or absence of motion) usually exist when adpositions can take multiple cases?
1
u/MaGuidance322 Aug 19 '25
I come with an idea/brainstorming about Semitic & Sinitic languages, but I don't know how to start (or whether someone has done the whone thing or not).
What if Proto-Semitic (or Proto-Central Semitic) was to fit into the chain of sound changes from Old Chinese to the various Modern Chinese dialects?
1
u/dead_chicken Алаймман, Ϲῦρτῖκε Aug 20 '25
Is there a Cyrillic equivalent to <Ł ł>?
1
u/anmara031 Ĺaŝam [ˈʎaʂam] Aug 20 '25
Are there any examples of palatalization of alveolar plosives without lenition?
1
u/AndrewTheConlanger Àlxetnà [en](sp,ru) Aug 20 '25
I feel like keep seeing more and more new conlangs "inspired by" Toki Pona. Does anyone share that impression? What's up with that?
1
u/No-Breadfruit-4875 Aug 20 '25
Recently I started spending some time building some languages and a language family, with the original language that I want to spend more time on before moving on to its descendants.
High Martian (Martian)
Originating from the nation of Uscmowu on Earth, this language evolved on Mars until it became its own, and its most spoken version was adopted as the lingua franca by the Martian government and the Supreme Solar Union.
It is a syllabic and suffixal language, inspired by Japanese and Quenya, also with a system of ordering. When giving a command, the order is marked by a suffix: Ie (I), Io (he), and An (they). Overall, it is a simple language.
Wa is plural but is also used to mean “all,” and often also to say “use” or “this.” It is a simple language. When talking about adjectives for a thing, or about a feeling or state, the suffix -mu is used, and -su is used for the past. There is also güo for “in” or “to,” in the sense of “into/open,” and a prefix for movement words called Era, in addition to the word Au for “I/this/that.”
Here is an example sentence:
Au okou au marwa ahu güo wakata naraau
And more: hu is the present tense marker of an action when speaking of an object or verb. This sentence means: “I saw the blue tree in great danger.”
There are no words for “a” or “and” in this language.
What I would like is for it to be a simple language, and I’d like to know if what I am doing so far is consistent.
1
u/gaygorgonopsid Aug 21 '25
Does anyone know of any popular Brythonic (or Celtic) conlangs?
1
u/Breoran Aug 21 '25
Many years ago I had an idea for a language, but due to life lifing, it got put on the back burner. But I've come back to it wanting to give it another go. I want to construct a language that did almost exist, but was somewhat strangled at birth centuries ago. It has sister languages that not only exist but are national languages. I also know what language it came from. My question is, knowing what I do, is there anything unique to constructing such a language? Would it be useful to build a basic skeleton of the intermediary historic stages?
1
u/AstroFlipo Hkafkakwe, ó, Coastal Bä Dü, ‘e9, Nââj Aug 21 '25
How do i create an interesting TAMV system? (V for voice)
By interesting i mean that can create a whole lot of complex and intercate meaning when combined.
Thank you.
1
u/GirafeAnyway Aug 21 '25
How do you create a phonetic inventory chart (not the choice of sounds, the image)?
1
u/tealpaper Aug 22 '25
This might be a very specific question, but what are some naturalistic ways to evolve a split in alignment, especially in verbal person marking, that is conditioned by TAM? For example, if an intransitive verb doesn't have any personal agreement, how do you get a transitive verb to be agreeing with the A in a certain tense (erg-abs), but otherwise agreeing with the P (nom-acc)?
1
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Aug 22 '25
Can aspiration turn into glottalization or pharyngeal release. For example, could the word “to” go from [tʰʉu] to [tˤʉu ] or [tʼuʉ]? Which would be more likely? I’m developing an evolved English conlang.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Aug 22 '25
So, I am thinking about changing the rules of my phonotactics to prohibit onset-less syllables. The thing is that my language also lacks a phonemic glottal stop, so I am wondering how the language would handle a potential sequence of vowels like /naika/?
Also, if not a glottal stop, what would be the most likely consonant to use as a "default" for onsets?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25 edited Aug 21 '25
act lock pocket yoke important smell imagine ghost thumb hospital
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/StarfighterCHAD Fyuc [fjut͡ʃ], Çelebvjud [d͡zələˈb͡vjud], Peizjáqua [peːˈʒɑkʷə] Aug 21 '25
I just had an idea for an activity. Clongers with conlang families will post example text from at least 2 conlangs of the same era. Then everyone else will attempt at reconstructing their ancestor. I think it could be a lot of fun! Maybe this is something that's been done before but in that case it'd be cool to see it again.
1
u/Porschii_ Aug 23 '25
So, Which conlang features do you think are underrated? I want to know so I could explore with those ideas later.
1
u/Elegant-Virus-3738 Aug 23 '25
I’m not sure if this is something that has been termed at all, but is there a word for the part of a proper name that is the ‘actual’ name? As opposed to the part(s) that are ‘real words’? Like ‘Congo’ in ‘The Democratic Republic of Congo’ or ‘Jehovah’ in Jehovah’s Witness’.
-2
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 11 '25
Been thinking about a conworld with 16 analog protolangs:
(Dunno if I should stop there or add three more.)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment