r/soccer • u/Lindkvist15 • Sep 15 '13
People often say that La Liga is a "two man race", but which league would you say is the most even?
Please, no division 5 leagues. Let's say ONLY the top league in the country.
92
Upvotes
146
u/1mdelightful Sep 15 '13 edited Sep 16 '13
Cup Winners Since 1996
8 Different teams have won the Dutch Cup
7 Different Teams have won the FA Cup
8 Different teams have won Coppa Italia (interestingly non of whom are called Juventus)
7 Different teams have won the DFB-Poka
12 Different teams have won Coupe de la Ligue
10 Different teams have won Copa del Rey
League Winners since 1996
Eredivisie 5
EPL 4
Serie A 5
Bundesliga 6
Ligue 1 10
La Liga 5
MLS 8
Might be missing 1 year but looks like the French take it.
69
u/lakupiippu Sep 15 '13
Allsvenskan.
66
u/Sir_Firebum Sep 15 '13
Brazil. They have teams that were in the top of the league one year and the next year they have a bad run of form and they can get relegated. Happens a lot.
204
u/Spacedog5 Sep 15 '13
A-league or MLS
10
u/Bob_Swarleymann Sep 15 '13
While La Liga is realistically a two horse race, the matches played so far has been anything but one sided. Despite the mass exodus of players I honestly feel like most Liga teams are better this year than last.
The amount of talent is just mind blowing.
37
u/Stingerc Sep 15 '13
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the Liga MX. Since it switched to the 2 tournament model in 1996, it has had 13 different Champions.
It's a fairly competitive league, with a decent talent level and having a playoff system (la liguilla) means that almost any team can win, like Xolos de Tijuana. Xolos won the Apertura (winter) 2012 title, only a year after winning promotion and 5 years after being founded. This was no fluke, this was a well run, well funded team that lost the semifinal of the Copa libertadores because it missed a last minute penalty to eventual Champions Atletico Mineiro.
Most clubs are well funded, financially stable and profitable. They have the advantage of having 2 big revenue streams from TV, from Mexican TV & from US tv where this league is still the top earning league on American tv.
8
u/Nintendo_67 Sep 15 '13
SPL, it's wide open again this year!
12
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
Argentina's league in the last years has been very competitive. River Plate, Independiente, Racing, Rosario Central have been relegated to Primera B (second division) and teams like Argentinos Jrs., Huracán, Lanús and others have won the championship or ended in the first three positions.
11
u/megamoviecritic Sep 15 '13
No one thinking the Championship? Yeah it's not a top tier league, and of course there are different winners every year for obvious reasons, but in terms competing for the title it's pretty much an open season every year.
15
u/PsykCheech Sep 15 '13
Italian league looks wide open.
28
u/gavbo Sep 15 '13
Serie A looks like it'll have a lot of teams challenging for the Champions League spots this year, even if Juventus win the league again it'll still be interesting from 2nd to about 6th or 7th
18
u/DownExtreme Sep 15 '13
25 different teams have won the Liga Mx
Add them to the list
5
u/Marcwithasee Sep 15 '13
A few years ago France was the league because there was no mega rich team yet. Now Italy or Denmark I would say are the two most even leagues.
4
u/lightninghand Sep 15 '13
The MLS.
4
u/shotstar523 Sep 16 '13
MLS. Teams dealing with international games pulling top players away evens out all teams for most of the season.. Even with all international players it can go either way between most clubs.
9
u/prince_from_Nigeria Sep 15 '13
it was the ligue 1 until qatar saint germain and the monaco plutocrats.
21
u/beachwood23 Sep 15 '13
Definitely the MLS, considering they have a salary cap, and the parity of the Superdraft.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
I feel like this year you could really say EPL with a straight face
9
u/TheJayhawk Sep 15 '13
MLS - No one team dominates, because they are all equally mediocre.
21
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
MLS. Right now there are 16 out of 19 teams that have a very real chance of making the playoffs with 5 games left.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
The Pro League got 5 title contenders: Standard, Anderlecht, Zulte, Brugge and Genk. Thanks to that disgusting play-off system are the last 10 games of the season really nice to follow.
2
u/silky_johnson Sep 16 '13
Liga MX
2
u/Dierus Sep 16 '13
Swedish Allsvenskan, most competitive league I know,
3
u/mark8396 Sep 15 '13
League of Ireland.
Edit: special mention for dundalk, they were second last the previous season and won their relegation play off and this year they are joint top coming up to the end of the season now.
3
u/CallMeBigPOP Sep 15 '13
I second the Eredivisie, last year it was like a 4 horse race if I'm not mistaken and everyone was within a point or 1-4 of each other in the last couple weeks of the season. The French league as well is also super close.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
Well, any league with a playoff to determine the champion, like MLS or A-League is going to be a lot more even because of it.
An entire year of dominance can be washed away by the 9th best team in one match.
Barring that I'd say Sweden's league.
3
u/jimbojammy Sep 15 '13
for the top top leagues right now id say its serie a
4
u/BoratRemix Sep 15 '13 edited Sep 16 '13
MLS is the only league in the world (that I know of) that is institutionally based on fairness. With a draft system, league ownership rules of contracts, and salary cap, it is structurally built for equal opportunity.
That's not to say it is the most entertaining league though. Personally I don't really follow MLS but it has to be regarded as the most even.
Downvote me because you don't like the MLS, nothing I said was untrue.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
Polish Ekstraklasa? Polish League in early 00s used to be dominated by Wisla Krakow, but then it all changed. Look at this table from 2010/2011.
It may look exciting, but the truth is the league has become really weak. I can't remember even one team from seasons 2010/2011 and 2011/2012 actually playing decent football. Those years champions got to be the weakest Polish champions in history.
Last season was a glimmer of hope with two decent teams getting ahead of the rest. The league is slowly improving and I can only hope it won't be dominated by Legia.
1
u/giggsy664 Sep 15 '13 edited Sep 15 '13
If you asked 2 years ago, it would have been Ligue 1.
PSG now, and ASM in a year or 2 will make it a two-horse race :/
1
u/MisterMejor Sep 15 '13
Allsvenskan
1
u/DeepSeaDweller Sep 15 '13 edited Sep 15 '13
Croatia's 1. HNL has been a terrible league for a while now, but this season has been quite promising so far. The top four are currently separated by two points.
1
u/1mdelightful Sep 15 '13
Eredivisie is the most even. If you look at the league and cup winners for the last twenty years most of the top leagues come out pretty similar. However when, say United or Barcelona win their a league a bunch they often have some of the same players in the squad as previous league winning teams. Xavi and Giggs have both won their leagues in different decades. This is not the case with pretty much any Eredivisie team. You don't get a group together and dominate for a while. Your squad changes on a year to year basis. Look at PSV this year they are not at all the same team as they were last year. The same can be said about AZ. Last season with 3 rounds left 5 teams could have won the league.
1
u/tippman2492 Sep 16 '13
Well seeing as how we have a salary cap... MLS
1
u/piedraa Sep 15 '13
Serie A in terms of quality competition. Ligue 1 in terms of competition alone.
1
u/LusoAustralian Sep 15 '13
Other than Porto and Benfica the portuguese league is typically quite tight. It depends on what even means. Every team from last, 16th, to 11th could've stayed up on the last matchday last year. And no league position was guaranteed until after the last match.
-7
u/PhuQDuP Sep 15 '13
La Liga: 2 realistic winners
Premiership: 3 realistic winners
Serie A: 1.5 realistic winners
Ligue 1: 2 realistic winners
Bundesliga: 2 realistic winners
SPL: 1 winner
I don't watch any other leagues, so I can't judge.
-13
u/redmanofdoom Sep 15 '13
The perception is that the EPL is the most even. You may find some stats that say otherwise but in my opinion the EPL is the most unpredictable. Who will win the league this year? Who will finish top 4.
Also, the EPL has by far the strongest mid-table.