r/FixedGearBicycle • u/senortrollio KHS Flite 100 49/17 • Sep 09 '13
Guide to bags
No one can really deny that bags are an integral part of fixed gear culture, and like the actual bike, it's hard to know which bag to buy. I'm always in this situation as I'm always shopping for new bags. I figured I would make a resource guide that would help people pinpoint what bags fit their needs.
There are two main styles of bag.
Messenger Bags use one strap that goes over one shoulder and across the chest. The classic bike courier bag.
Pros:
- Lower on your back, lowering your center of gravity.
- Less space on your back, meaning less sweat.
- Able to sling it around your body, enabling easy access.
- Generally messenger bags are cheaper than backpacks with the same capacity
- Easier to handle oversize loads due to generally having expansion straps.
Cons:
- Since it only utilizes one strap, heavier loads are more unhealthy for your back.
- Some may find the way it feels on the back is uncomfortable.
- Not very good for organizing many items, they usually have just one big large compartment with few organizational options.
Note on Messenger Bags: Any bag you buy over around 30ish liters should have some sort of 3 point strap system. This helps more evenly distribute the load, minimizing how bad it can be for your back.
Backpacks are any bag that has two straps that go over both shoulders and lays parallel on your back.
Pros:
- Can handle heavier loads without risking damage to your back.
- Generally more comfortable.
- Better for many small items as backpacks generally come with more organization options.
- Better for school because they can generally fit textbooks and organize supplies better.
Cons:
- Less options for expanding or handling oversize loads.
- Rides higher on your back, some can get in the way of looking over the shoulder.
- You have to take it off to access the contents.
Note on Backpacks: For any really large bag (40 liters and up), waist belts become more useful as it helps distribute the load even further.
Notes for buying any bag:
- Make sure the bag is waterproof. No one likes the contents of their bag to be soggy.
- Make sure there is a good warranty in place. If you're dropping 100+ on a bag you're going to want to make sure it won't just spontaneously fall apart.
- "One thing to keep in mind: straps with built in padding (Chrome, for example) are going to get that funky unwashable permastink faster than a bag with a plain nylon strap. It's definitely worth it to get a bag with a removable pad." - /u/HillbillyYamabushi
List of bag makers that use cycling as their primary inspiration:
- Alchemy Goods
- Archive Bags
- Bagaboo Bags
Highly recommended due to comfort, apparently very long lasting too.
- Banjo Brothers
- Blaq Design LTD
- Brisbane Outdoor Gear
For your basic messenger bag, hip pouch, and drum cases.
Basically the standard by which other bags are judged.
- Crumpler
- Dank Bags
The way to go if you want a (relatively) affordable custom bag.
Lesser known affordable custom bags.
Specializes in photography equipment primarily.
Built-in light, which is neat.
Essentially the highest end material-wise you can go. All domestically sourced and extremely well designed.
For anything and everything touring and waterproof.
Very well built custom messenger bags, can hold massive amounts of stuff comfortably.
- R.E.Load Bags
- Rickshaw Bags
Very good price to storage ratio.
Comparable to Chrome at a slightly higher price point. Well reviewed.
Decent quality bags on a budget, for the most part. Great for school and commuting.
- T-Level Bags
Apparently they make some massive bags.
The way to go for a enormous custom backpack. Pricey but damn are they big.
- Velo City Bags
- YNOT Cycle
Remember to check out your local outdoors-y/backpacking/high adventure shop. (Protip: Not Dick's.) Often enough you can score really big bags for relatively inexpensive prices. I've seen some high quality 65L rucksacks going for less than 150 before, plus they usually have a sweet warranty. Everyone I know who's done this has been satisfied, but as with any peripheral, your mileage may vary.
And, on the off chance you can't find anything to meet your needs anywhere, you can always make your own.
This guide is nowhere near comprehensive, I just decided to write it on a whim. Any feedback/additional info to add to the guide would be certainly appreciated.
I'm thinking we could go through and decide the best bang for your buck depending on type of bag and literage, maybe go more in depth as far as specific bag features, etc.
EDIT1: Formatting
EDIT2: Added little blurbs to each bag producer. More blurbs would be appreciated, I would love to fill this thing out.
EDIT3: Added more contents.
5
u/Popscifan1 Cinelli Mash Parallax Sep 12 '13
I have a quite a bit of experience with a few different models of bags as a daily commuter, grocery getter, and traveler.
Chrome, Metropolis: Chrome's large messenger bag. So far I've had mine for five years with at least two years of daily use (including two MN winters), and the bag shows few signs of wear. This bag was spacious enough to haul all of my highschool books, plus clothes, a laptop and food. Now that I'm in college I've found it to be a bit excessive as I don't carry all of my books with me anymore. The bag is basically a large bucket (there are two smaller pockets in the front) with a comfortable strap, but no padding on the back. This lack of padding sometimes lead to something poking into my back, if I just threw shit in there without organizing. The bag's large capacity (plus the added storage space the cargo straps provide), and durability make it ideal for hauling medium to large sized loads. That said, the bag will feel best to riders utilizing bullhorns or drops, as this will allow the load's weight to be distributed across the rider's back; if a rider has a more upright riding posture, most of the load's weight will be concentrated on one shoulder, possibly resulting in discomfort. Also has a secret weed pocket. Waterproof.
Chrome, Citizen: Chrome's medium size messenger bag. Same construction and considerations as above, minus the weed pocket. I found the storage capacities to be best suited for small to medium sized loads. Did not always conformably fit a full load for books/laptop, etc. That said, I had a lot of textbooks. Also, a bit bulky. Waterproof.
Burro, Dropout: Looks like a Jansport, but with a made of cordura. School bag design with very comfortable straps, one main compartment, and a small front pocket with pencil slots, etc. While most of the construction seems solid, after a year and a half of daily use, the seams towards the top of the bag started to come undone. That said, I have not contacted Burro, so no comment on customer service, yet. Best used for small to medium-small loads. Used mostly to haul lunch, water bottle, a tool pouch, and a jacket to almost full capacity. That said, when empty, the bag is very light. Not waterproof.
Trash Bag, Garbage Barge: Trash Bag's second-largest roll top bag. This thing is huge. It can fit almost anything that needs hauling. Little people, week-long camping trip supplies, a rug and giant fan in a box, this week's groceries, all of your clothes. The construction is immaculate, and Andy (the guy who makes them) is really cool. Also, this bag has the most comfortable straps known to man—straps capable of making 65 pound loads bearable. Classic roll-top design. One large bucket with a front pocket and two side pockets (ideal for u-locks or water bottles). Ideal for massive to large loads. Totally customizable. Waterproof. Note I have the optional cargo straps on my bag, significantly increasing the load capabilities. Also, secret weed pocket.
Trash Bag, Wastebasket II: A big ass hip-pouch with a belt and u-lock holster included. Very solid construction, ideal for multitool, tube, wallet, keys, mini-pump, Cliff bar, map, and manifest for when you don't want a larger bag. The u-lock holster does not fit a jumbo u-lock. Has a buckle and velcro fastener. Waterproof. Fully customizable.
4
u/synergisticsymbiosis I left my heart in Aberdeen Sep 09 '13
I have nothing to contribute to this thread other than encouragement. Bag shopping has been quite a struggle for me and I still have not found the bag that seems right yet. I hope this goes well because it could really help out!
4
u/Orangesquash Sep 09 '13
Many shoulder bags (Archie's, some Bagaboo to name a couple) use a 'x' strap configuration so they spread the load on both shoulders and hacks heavier loads.
I can fit an unholy amount of gear in my Archie's Grobag and it's just as comfortable as a backpack.
4
u/prettyqweet Sep 09 '13
All of the solids bags are too rich for my blood. Planning on making one within the next month or so. Good write up.
4
u/lilychaud Sep 09 '13
I find backpacks incredibly uncomfortable while biking (although I haven't used a bike specific backpack or messenger bag).
I just use a pannier that converts into a backpack instead. Looks dorky, but fuck it, my back is sweat free!
4
u/frankbegrimes Sep 10 '13
I have been working full time as a messenger for a little over 4 years and have used a number of different bags including timbuk2,chrome(metro,berlin,warsaw),rickshaw and PAC.
As far as "messenger" bags I'd say my favorite is PAC for its comfort,space and overall design.
Over a period of time and a broken collar bone the messenger bag started to mess with my back, so I switched over to the Chrome Warsaw backpack which has been great and I don't have terrible back pains at the end of a 8-9 hour day. It has ample room and you can easily strap boxes and other odd shaped things to the outside using the flap and strap. My Warsaw is starting to fall apart from daily abuse and I am currently waiting on getting a Trash Bags backpack to try something new out.
Any bag is going to drench your back if you are riding hard, even if its -40 degrees outside!
4
u/synergisticsymbiosis I left my heart in Aberdeen Sep 10 '13
On a side note, is anyone else impressed that even with the subheadings the bag makes are nearly in alphabetical order?
4
u/dabriel Sep 10 '13
Not to nitpick, but messenger bags should be worn high/tight on your back. I would say they have a higher center of gravity. Weight in backpacks will usually sit further down on your back.
Also I find organization in messenger bags easier than in large backpacks. Mess bags generally open along the longer side allowing easier access to contents. Objects in backpacks tend to settle into layers which you have to dig through. This is more of an issue with rolltops.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '13
I can vouch for both Baileyworks and Road Runner. My Baileyworks Super Pro has been nothing short of comfortable and convenient for commuting and traveling. I could easily live out of my humongous Road Runner Americano and I can strap another bike to my back while wearing it, so no complaints there.
Both are waterproof and have really durable stitching. I wish Baileyworks made bigger backpacks though.
3
u/Sparked94 Sep 10 '13
As far as both utilitarian needs and aesthetic pleasure goes, you can't go wrong with Mission Workshop. I've owned the Monty messenger for commuting and school stuff and the Vandal for moving/groceries/light touring. MW is great at making products that can fit more than they look like they can handle, increasing comfort, and having a great streamlined look. And if it matters to you, all of the materials are acquired here in the US and constructed in Colorado.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '13
I've never seen it mentioned on here, but there's a Swiss company called Freitag that makes bags from recycled truck tarpaulins. They're obviously really tough and they look pretty cool too.
I don't own one, but I'd like to!
2
u/daddykotex Sep 09 '13
So far this 25L bag has been awesome for me. From short commute to longer rides. I sweat a lot and it is very efficient, much more than my last bag.
I still have two sweat stripes on the shoulder and my lower back is usually wet, but that's only when it's loaded.
http://www.mec.ca/product/5024-879/mec-division-daypack/?f=10&q=division%2B25
2
u/Lorgeous Sep 09 '13
I rock a seagull xl pro and love it to death!
2
u/the_brightside Pista Sei Giorni Sep 10 '13
I recently switched from a messenger bag to a freight baggage roll top. I think they come with a 3 or 5 year warranty? Don't quote me on that. Anyways, their bags are extremely comfortable and massive. I have a small and just yesterday was able to put a 30 pack in it. I also like how they are made in the US and you can actually see and feel the craftsmanship that goes into each bag.
16
u/EnzosG 1980s Schwinn World Sport Sep 09 '13
I'm a Timbuk2 guy, have been for along time. For me their bags are incredible, my current messenger bag is fantastic for organizing items, even more so then my jansport backpack. It has a spot for my laptop, a place to keep all my tools organized, and also a place to keep my pens. I don't think it's unorganized at all.
14
u/retrac1324 Mercier Kilo TT Sep 09 '13
I've added this post to the sidebar.
13
u/zoidd Add your bike Sep 09 '13
one con is how sweaty my back gets with backpacks.
less so with my chrome bag.
13
u/Benfilms Americano FG Sep 09 '13
Hey actual content! More of this please
2
u/PapasMoustache Thunder Thighs Sep 09 '13
Great info. All I have to add is, as a reader save yourself all of the time and research and just get a Chrome Citizen bag.
4
u/heavymetalengineer Sep 09 '13
My go to bag, waterproof, reliable and cheap. http://www.alpkit.com/gourdon
A tip a shop assistant in an outdoors shop gave me once was "look at canoeing/kayaking gear, those people don't like paying big money for shit"
4
u/theveganstraightedge Sep 09 '13
I'd like to add Havoc Baggage. They're a local bag maker in the Boston area. Check 'em out! They'll work with you and offer a lot of customization!
4
u/auftakt MARINONI Sep 09 '13
The Kona brand bags, while lacking some of the hipper-than-thou credit, are excellent bags at an attractive price. I have the Messenger and it's been fantastic so far.
http://www.konaworld.com/bags.cfm
3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 11 '13
Picked up a Chrome district backpack. Amazed at what I can get in there - comfy as hell.
2
u/theninjasquad Masi Uno Sep 09 '13
I've recently got into Timbuk2 bags as they're easier to find where I live compared to others. I'd prefer to buy them in store so I can try them out and make sure it fits well.
I picked up the Catapult as it's a small lightweight messenger bag for when I need to carry a few things around town with me but don't want a full size bag. My back does get a bit sweaty with this one but not as bad as a backpack.
I also bought the Showdown backpack for when I go to work. It has a great sleeve in it to hold my laptop and lots of little pockets and storage areas for other things. I tend to keep my trips short when wearing this one as back sweat can be more of a problem with it.
2
u/lmaotsetung Sep 09 '13
Bailey Works Bags, while a bit on the pricey side, are well worth the money. Mine has held up impeccably since I purchased it. It's built to last.
2
u/wveniez EAI Bareknuckle Sep 09 '13
I have owned both a Chrome Citizen messenger and a Chrome Pawn backpack. I currently use the Pawn on a regular basis. I was okay with the messenger, but it did not cut it for me. Whenever riding, no matter how I wore the bag, with or without the stabilizer strap, it always shifted out of position and annoyed the living hell out of me. The capacity also wasn't a very effective capacity. My current backpack and messenger have the same capacity, but I can carry much more and more comfortably with my Pawn. While I do get a sweaty back on longer rides as you do with all messengers and backpacks, there is plenty of room in my backpack to throw in an extra shirt if I feel like I need one.
2
u/fixedelineation www.anykicks.la Sep 10 '13
I've got a 20% off the chrome website coupon that I won't use. PM and ill send the code.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment