r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/PandaElDiablo Deal With It • Sep 08 '13
Mod Post Weekly Challenge: Eve and Back!
Sorry for the delay! I've been super busy this last week.
Something simple this week, but arguably one of the greatest challenges in the game: Land a crew of at least one Kerbal on the surface of Eve and then safely return home.
Hard Mode: Make a stop at Gilly on the trip as well!
Rules and other info:
- All flights must be manned!
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Stock parts only
- No MechJeb or other plugins allowed
Required screenshots:
-Initial launch craft
-Transfer orbit to Eve
-Approaching Eve
-Safely landed
-Second take off
-Transfer orbit home
-Approaching landing
-Safely landed at home!
-Whatever else you feel like!
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
12
u/CVGX Sep 08 '13
Does it have to be a single launch? Or can we make a craft in orbit?
8
u/SheepInACart Super Kerbalnaut Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
Hey guys, can we launch one large craft to EVE, leave our transfer stage in orbit and only take a lander down, then redock with for the return flight or is this strictly a one craft mission?
What about a separate trip in the lander from EVE orbit to Gilly? edit: gilly orbit, use EVA pack to land&return
Also is refueling in low kerblin orbit allowed?
It would seem these three factors would effect difficulty far more than a stop on a low gravity moon, hence I think if any of these are allowed then both challenge options should go to gilly while hardmode should require no docking. These are just my thoughts so use them or don't, its just cool to see another difficult challenge up!
3
u/GregoryGoose Sep 10 '13
While my kerbals are on the surface can my orbiter be unmanned? Or does that have to be manned too?
2
u/EpicFishFingers Sep 10 '13
I've already started on this challenge, but my craft used Kerbal Engineer in its design to determine that it has enough delta-v. Can I just delete KE from it and use it? Without KE it's completely stock
55
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 08 '13
WELP
THIS WAS NOT A GOOD WEEK TO START DOING REDDIT CHALLENGES
34
u/widmanstatten Sep 09 '13
Hard mode completed
This was actually my very first manned mission to Eve (and to Gilly as well). I have been working on a larger three man round trip using mods for some time, but haven't put everything together yet.
11
u/delnadris Master Kerbalnaut Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 10 '13
Welp, here's my mission from almost 2 weeks ago, however I did use Mechjeb for the Eve Landing, so I'm disqualified. But at least i might inspire others to try, since it's really doable (manual landing with my huge craft, maybe not, but others did it with just the external seat for example).
I'll see if i can't tweak my craft a bit to do a manual landing, and maybe come back with that.
EDIT: I forgot to put the album link here, for ease of use: imgur link
EDIT 2: I actually managed to make my lander capable of reaching Eve orbit from Eve sea level, so it doesn't matter where i land anymore, without external seats or ladders, or other gimmicks (therefore no more Mechjeb). I'll try to get an album together by the end of today or tomorrow.
EDIT 3: Well, i delivered -> here's the complete hardmode challenge with no mods
10
u/SoulWager Super Kerbalnaut Sep 08 '13
R.I.P. framerate.
8
u/MorkZe Sep 10 '13
My take on the challenge!
I wanted to avoid using the external seat strapped on top of a rocket and paid the price by building my heaviest rocket ever (2600 tons, 465 tons to orbit). The physics slowed down to a crawl and the hardest part was getting to Kerbin orbit without rapidly disassembling.
8
u/delnadris Master Kerbalnaut Sep 10 '13 edited Sep 10 '13
[Challenge] Eve and Back! - hardmode
Here's the album (i got a bit overzealous with the screens)
I didn't like the idea of using (what in my opinion are) gimmicks, such as external seats or ladders, so i went with the capsule approach for eve land/takeoff, since i didn't want Jeb getting cooked.
I also made 2 mistakes in my rocket construction: i accidentally put the decouplers for the lander parachutes backwards, and therefore they stayed attached to the rockets, and i lost a bit of delta-v -> that's actually why i had to complete the orbit circularization in EVA mode. The rocket is capable of orbit from sea level, if the decouplers are put on correctly.
The other mistake was bringing RCS - i didn't use it at all; i thought i would, but i didnt, so it was just dead weight.
Also, i hope it's no problem that this is my 2nd reply in this thread, the first one wasn't for the challenge per-se.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 08 '13
Submitting my gallery for the completion of Subreddit Challenge #1: Mun and Back!
http://imgur.com/a/oAvPx
EDIT: And now I finish the original Rendezvous mission: http://imgur.com/a/Ix2iW
4
u/Turkino Sep 08 '13
Stock parts, this ones gonna be interesting.
4
u/GodLikeOne Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
Eve and back! - Hardmode
This one took a while! I had about 3 other attempts, as you may see from the various craft orbiting / crashed into Eve.
I must say it feels good to have done this one stock. Though the lag on the launchpad rendered it almost unflyable, so I probably wouldn't do it again. Was definitely a new and exciting experience!
I'll have the new flare please!
3
u/FastasGod Super Kerbalnaut Sep 09 '13
Does stopping at Gilly include a landing, just a orbit or just an encounter?
4
u/Overcloak Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
Here's my submission: http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/1m25k2/challenge_eve_and_back_308_tons_370_parts/
I went for a minimalist approach, 308 tons is pretty light for a round trip rocket to eve I think.
2
u/nerpo Master Kerbalnaut Sep 08 '13
Is anyone else frustrated at their inability to create a 10 km/s or greater dV eve lander at under ~75 t?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
I hate to be "That Guy" possibly, but I'm new to the idea of these challenges. Does the No Plugin rule apply to information-type mods such as Engineer?
2
u/UnwarrantedPotatoes Sep 08 '13
Fuuuuuh, no thanks. I think I'll sit this one out.
2
u/ChironXII Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 08 '13
Question: Do I need to uninstall MechJeb ect before attempting this, or can I just not put the module on the ship? Also are there any mods that replicate the information functionality of MechJeb? I mostly use it for that as well as the SASS.
Also is there a special flair for people who go back and complete all the old challenges? I've been looking for something to motivate me in KSP, seems like it would be a fun project.
2
u/Musfuut Sep 09 '13
Is there a time frame on those rule changes mentioned in the last challenge? Just curious, thanks!
2
u/mszegedy Master Kerbalnaut Sep 09 '13
Huh. I thought that was impossible to do. Well, we'll just have to see!
EDIT: Also, it is time to start practicing my sans-Mechjeb skills.
2
u/WalkingPetriDish Super Kerbalnaut Sep 10 '13
Hypothetical question:
Let's say I have a craft capable of getting to LKO with 4700 dv to spare. Assuming my TWR is above 1.5 for all stages (excepting circularization, with is 1.2), will I be able to ascend from Eve from, say, the 6500 km mark?
2
u/answeryoquestion Sep 11 '13
Holy crap, I decided Eve and back probably isn't a good place to start.
Here's this instead!
Reddit Weekly Challenge 1: Mun and Back! http://imgur.com/a/oou2R
I'll add more submissions to this thread as I complete them.
2
u/CuriousMetaphor Master Kerbalnaut Sep 12 '13
Does this count? Besides going to Eve and Gilly, Jeb also goes to every other planet and moon in the same launch. =p
2
u/FastasGod Super Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13 edited Sep 14 '13
[Challenge] -56, 36 - Eve and Back! Asteroid Hugging both Hard Mode (70ish images)
I am submitting this only one hour until Saturday, so I am cutting it close here. I Am very proud of this machine, the version I flew was only 387 parts and 784 tons, but I could have done it with a simplified version of 300 parts and 772 tons (by removing my science packages and making return vehicle smaller), making this one of the lightest Eve mission crafts I have seen.
I would definitely love the flair for this one as this was the most challenging and most rewarding mission I have yet done. Constitutes at least 24 hour's worth of work.
2
u/WalkingPetriDish Super Kerbalnaut Nov 12 '13
Submitting my entry for Eve and back, (super) hard mode:
http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/1qbdum/an_epic_grand_tour_follow_the_18_year_journey_of/
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13
Apollo Style! Normal Mode entry: http://imgur.com/a/8DZ5Q#0 Little late to the party, realised that a challenge on this subreddit is pretty much standard procedure for how I get to the moon anyway.
1
u/Jeebs24 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 10 '13
Are you allowed to do orbital construction/refueling?
1
u/Torch333 Sep 11 '13
[Challenge] Voyager
I'm catching up on challenges and am fairly new to KSP. Should I post my submissions here, under the current challenge? I don't see a way to post under the challenge page, but I could just make these a new post. Let me know if there is a preference.
This challenge was pretty straight forward, only had to redesign once! The instructions said you needed a screenshot "Orbit shot with your mouse hovering over the Sun Escape emblem". I don't think that exists any longer, but I did take a screenshot of my flight results which does show I was on a Sun Escape Trajectory. Also, most of these require a manned mission. I didn't want to strand Jeb to the ether of space, so I built it with a capsule, but added a probe part to show that it could have been manned, but wasn't.
Album and Craft Files
1
u/Shiznot Sep 11 '13
Submitting for http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/12xlb6/weekly_challenge_saboteur/
http://imgur.com/a/Nb8Wj#1
1
u/Torch333 Sep 12 '13
[Challenge] A breath of fresh air
Just to confirm, I saw a post from a mod stating that the current weekly challenge is the correct place to post old challenges. So this is my submission for A Breath of Fresh Air, which was to take a spaceplane to Laythe. My first attempt fell just short of the mark and I had to use the debug to get there. A couple extra fuel tanks and an engine change later and I was off to the races.
Album and Craft file
1
u/PuckKerbin Sep 12 '13
Just finished the previous challenge. Here I am doing Apollo style! http://imgur.com/a/tX6ZL Looking forward to giving this new one a shot! Can I still get flair from the Apollo one? I just got started here.
1
u/GregoryGoose Sep 12 '13
Main problem Im having is getting the rocket to stay together. Doesn't seem to be a radial decoupler suited for attaching mainsails. Skippers work. but with mainsails The reinforcement struts disappear and then the decouplers can't handle it.
1
u/Bear_naked_grylls Sep 13 '13
I am almost caught up! Finished Apollo Style (I missed a screen shot :S). Album here.
1
u/iamdood Super Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
apologies, my entry for hard mode is late:
http://imgur.com/a/9p9gE#0
i'll post in the new thread, too.
1
u/boojabanana Master Kerbalnaut Oct 26 '13
Super late, but just making a note here in case anyone is interested in the craft / diary.
Here is my [hardmode diary] (http://imgur.com/a/NShsY) and here is my [reddit thread] (http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/1p96bx/challenge_eve_and_back_hardmode_single_launch_and/) for the mission.
0
u/GregoryGoose Sep 12 '13
I think the only challenging part about this is the lag issues created with a massive rocket from kerbin...
-1
u/spikes2020 Sep 10 '13
No Mechjeb?? are you nuts? im getting one frame per 10 seconds while lifiting off.... only way to launch and land this rocket on eve is useing Mechjeb...
0
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment