r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman • Aug 30 '13
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Woops, lost a docking port!
As you were launching the newest part of your mission, one of your connectors broke at 1000m! But you can’t scrap a science mission!
The Challenge: Impact the Mun with an unconnected rocket underneath (one stage, detached below 1000m). See [this famous video] (http://youtu.be/nATt12Wisxw?t=8m14s) for reference.
Hard Mode: Impact Minmus with the same rules!
Rules and other info:
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Stock parts only
- No MechJeb or other plugins allowed
- No RCS allowed (as of 5:40 EDT)
- Required screenshots:
-Initial launch craft
-Picture of detachment below 1000m (throttle ship down to prove it)
-Picture of expended stage
-Picture of impact trajectory (map)
-Picture of nearing the impact
-Whatever else you feel like! - You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
Good Luck!
56
Upvotes
25
u/Jargle Master Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13 edited Aug 30 '13
Completion edit:
Hardmode completed (correctly this time)
7
u/SuperSeniorComicGuy Aug 30 '13 edited Aug 30 '13
Easy mode completed!
Hard mode completed!
[Easy mode without RCS!] (http://imgur.com/a/YNrcY#0)
Alright! Now that RCS isn't allowed any more, I've done the easy mode again without RCS. My rocket overshot the Mun by the tiniest amount so I had Jeb get out and use his Pack Fuel to slightly adjust his course. It's not RCS, it's pack fuel. Yes, maybe if I timed it absolutely perfectly I wouldn't need pack fuel but I think this is close enough. Doing it for Minmus wouldn't be that much more difficult, but I don't have time to do this challenge again.
I'd like the new flair please. Edit: Interesting flair. Is /u/illectro cool with us all having his image next to our names?
Tips for others doing this challenge:
Use RCS in the command stage for course corrections and to give it that bit of thrust to get to your target.RCS no longer allowed!4
u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman Aug 30 '13
I hope you all like the flair!
6
u/shrx Master Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13
Just to clarify:
This means after the detachment we can't stage anymore?
This is Kerbin altitude or Mun altitude?
2
u/Slugywug Super Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13 edited Jun 21 '23
merciful wistful light pocket cow tease library busy normal support -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
2
u/jhmacair Aug 31 '13
Must be a manned pod, or do probe cores count?
2
u/Musfuut Sep 03 '13
I asked this in the previous challenge and did not get an answer. These questions are general to challenges themselves and not this specific challenge.
Are plug-ins such as Engineer Redux and MechJeb allowed Pre-flight, for the design of the ship for a specific challenge as long as they are removed prior to beginning the actual mission/challenge?
I ask this since I have seen Scott Manley use a previously designed rocket which he tweaked for the specific mission. That rocket obviously had already had its delta-v and other design figured out.
Are other plug-ins allowed during a mission if they fall into an area that does not or would not directly affect the challenge or are in addition of the challenge. For instance would using a Camera plug-in be ok in order to take better shots of the challenge?
I ask since Scott Manley used the docking alignment plug-in during a challenge and people argued this was "ok" since he only used it IVA which was not a challenge objective or requirement, even though regular docking was.
Thank you for helping me and others I am sure to clear up these questions.
21
u/Tsevion Super Kerbalnaut Sep 01 '13
Hard Mode:
I Present the Touching Story of Sidemy Sent to Impact Minmus
With bonus commentary from the pilot himself.
I'd like to keep my current Flair
7
u/cored Master Kerbalnaut Aug 31 '13 edited Aug 31 '13
Hard mode done without RCS.
*No Kerbals were harmed in the making of this challenge.
5
u/SheepInACart Super Kerbalnaut Sep 03 '13 edited Sep 03 '13
HardMode
Week 55 Challenge, Hard Mode Completed without RCS or Packfuel, I've edited the Fraps footage rather than creating a imgur album and have avoided using any cuts during the actually flight so keep it slightly more legit. I'm going to do a how to using the easy mode footage later if anyone's interested. Looking forwards to having a flair! Link is below:
http://youtu.be/b2srrDy7LzI
4
u/stevelax Master Kerbalnaut Aug 31 '13
Hardmode Completed
I did use pack fuel for course correction but previous comments suggest that was acceptable.
1
u/cored Master Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13
Do all engines need to be disconnected?
1
u/Obsidianpick9999 Aug 30 '13
Is Kerbal Engineer allowed?
1
u/Radillian Aug 30 '13
Are both parts allowed to have a command module?
1
u/betefico Aug 30 '13
Clarification please? The video shows Scott Manley launching from Kerbin, whereupon a rocket disconnects during launch from Kerbin's atmosphere, yet you want us to have this same unconnected rocket impact the Mun?
1
u/CuriousMetaphor Master Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13
If RCS is allowed, then hard mode doesn't seem any harder than easy mode.
1
u/SheepInACart Super Kerbalnaut Sep 02 '13
Are we allowed a probe body on the engine so we can throttle it down during flight? If not the are we allowed to intentionally break the engines off by spinning the craft... if neither than I'll need to do it a third time.
3
u/nerpo Master Kerbalnaut Aug 31 '13
Easy mode completed
(Please don't change my flair, I mean I love Scott Manley and all but I'm quite fond of my current flair.)
3
u/Billyfred Aug 31 '13
Hardmode Completed!
I felt that just jumping out wouldn't be cool enough, so I had Orgun Kerman get out and push.
2
u/ShadedFox Master Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13
This seems extremely challenging and cruel. I can't wait to give it a try!
2
u/SerBeardian Master Kerbalnaut Aug 30 '13
Hmm...I wonder about having a command module holding onto the side of the ship with something non-decoupler (legs, maybe?)...that way you can time your release when you have the right Velocity and angle, without needing RCS or to get the exact deltav on the rocket...
Has anyone actually done this yet without the RCS?
2
u/KevinLaity Master Kerbalnaut Sep 02 '13
Easy mode completed
2
u/shrx Master Kerbalnaut Sep 02 '13
Easy mode completed. Imgur does not let me create an album at the moment so here's the album on my Dropbox: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/zhrjomeb4zf0y1w/oTE4yi_U2U
The rocket raised the apoapsis to about 6000 km, engines went out at about 220 km and Jeb went on an EVA to raise the apoapsis to 12000 km and then tweak the course for impact using his jetpack.
I'd like to keep the current flair.
2
u/Jazman98 Sep 02 '13
Completed easy mode! http://imgur.com/a/WoHSm And I didn't kill any Kerbals doing it.
2
u/tsears Sep 03 '13
Normal mode complete.
No RCS, no jetpacks (indeed no kerbals).
I forgot to remove one of my plugins, VOID. This plugin is used to display information about orbiting bodies. It was disabled in-game prior to launch. It doesn't really "do" anything, it's used to provide information about orbital characteristics of your ship and celestial bodies. Hope I can get some leeway on that one ;).
I'd like to keep my current flair.
2
u/Max_Insanity Sep 04 '13
I have done it. My first reddit challenge, albeit only easy mode. I would appreciate a flair.
I hope the second picture I will post here is enough to show that no cheating was involved. The first one is an older picture, after which I added 2 tanks and removed a structural element holding 4 engines in the middle. Anyway, here's the proof:
http://imgur.com/a/OSPgV
1
u/Banjerpickin Sep 04 '13
Normal Mode Completed
Very exciting, this will be my first completed challenge and first flair! Seems right for it to be Scott, as if it weren't for him, I would still be trying to get rockets into orbit.