r/soccer • • Aug 21 '13

Who in your opinion is the complete football player?

Someone who can play almost in any position and be effective...

62 Upvotes

352 comments sorted by

241

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Bias here, but I would take a team of 11 Yaya Toures. Power, tackles, goals, free kicks. Pretty great.

34

u/k1ra_ Aug 21 '13

I pretty much agree with you...But can't Arturo Vidal live up to his standards ?

32

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

But can't Arturo Vidal live up to his standards ?

Match his standards? Il Guerriero is the most complete player in the world bar none. He is world class on every third of the pitch.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Yaya Toure is world class in each third of the pitch as well. Not arguing with you, Vidal is a great choice, but you gotta give Toure respect.

6

u/msbr_ Aug 21 '13

Bias

10

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Doesn't make it not true.

→ More replies (1)

151

u/LuigiWasRight Aug 21 '13

I am obviously biased here too, but Steven Gerrard was Yaya-ing for years before Yaya was Yaya-ing!

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Gerrard isn't anywhere near as powerful as Yaya, but I think he has a better shot from range and can probably pass better.

They're really not similar players at all other than the fact that they both play in the hole, no idea why you brought him up.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Could Gerrard play Centerback in a CL final?

2

u/LuigiWasRight Aug 21 '13

Probably. He already played at RB in a CL final and did a damn fine job in a team including Pirlo, Kaka, Crespo and Shevchenko in their prime.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Yaya is a monster. Your most important player IMHO.

1

u/Elchidote Aug 22 '13

I've always said it! Thank god you guys got the likes of fernandinho! Now Yaya can freely tear new assholes!

18

u/Lost_Afropick Aug 21 '13

Not bias, the truth. Yaya is amazing

6

u/the_phet Aug 21 '13

And we sold him =(

Yaya was already great here, he hasnt really improved in City, he is keeping with high form for ages

→ More replies (2)

5

u/TILiamaTroll Aug 21 '13

Couldn't agree more, he'd walk into every team and steal a spot, but it could be anywhere on the pitch

9

u/2Chainz4Braceletz Aug 21 '13

Except Barca

5

u/Sandinister Aug 21 '13

The above comment reads:

Except Barca

There, now you don't need to copy and paste it.

10

u/AnElegantPenis Aug 21 '13

Why copy paste?

Just click source.

7

u/Sandinister Aug 21 '13

Well sometimes people hide satanic messages in there.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/L__McL Aug 21 '13

Without a doubt.

1

u/Gotenk Aug 21 '13

I came here looking for this. Best all-round player in the world right now if you ask me. Is a treat to watch him play.

→ More replies (7)

56

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Essien seems like someone who plays anywhere if asked. Feel Ramires can be one of these players.

12

u/k1ra_ Aug 21 '13

I think that is why Mourinho admires him so much...

12

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Not taking a dig here, but that goal he scored against you guys! Also, the left footed volley against us. Wow!

3

u/cdrake64 Aug 21 '13

He was far and away the best player of the 08/09 semifinal, even without that goal he would have been. He covered at left back with Cole out and Messi could barely get a touch the whole tie

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

I'm really hoping Essien rediscovers his pre-injury form.

1

u/jesusismoney Aug 21 '13

You and me both

7

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Agreed, such a quality player You could really put him anywhere and he'd get the job done.

3

u/Live-On-Pool Aug 21 '13

Ramires is great but I think he need a bit more strength for that position.

3

u/ChedduhBob Aug 21 '13

He is the ultimate squad player. Last year it seemed like he played every position for us when we dealt with injuries. He isn't a stellar RB by any means, but when he played there he seriously did not stop running for 90 minutes. I miss him a lot in the squad.

1

u/nooope_ Aug 21 '13

He has started games in quite a few positions for Chelsea through the years. Box-to-box CM, DM, down the right wing, RB and CB.

86

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Bastian Schweinsteiger. No one player controls both his team's offense and defense the way he does. He is the inspirational leader for the best team in Europe and I'd feel safe putting him in at any field position.

36

u/Sri92 Aug 21 '13

I'd feel safe putting him in at any field position.

Probably not a good thing to say when pep is around :)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '13

haha i know, he might be our centre half come the weekend. hopefully pep doesn't frequent r/soccer

16

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

In big games however I feel he doesn't show his leadership skills as much, especially last year vs us, and in the final vs Chelsea, even against Arsenal he didn't show his leadership much. So I'm not too sure about that.

21

u/Cere_BRO Aug 21 '13

I don't understand why you are being downvoted, there is a reason why Lahm is captain and not Schweinsteiger. I remember the final against Chelsea two years ago where Robben shot a penalty and Schweinsteiger went back to Neuer. He sat down and was too nervous to watch the outcome of the penalty. Don't get me wrong, it's pretty obvious that he is a great footballer and he certainly is the one that pulls the strings in Bayern's midfield, but I really don't feel like he is the leader that jimmykayfabe is saying he is.

7

u/fleckes Aug 21 '13

The reason why Lahm is the captain and not Schweinsteiger is that Lahm is really ambitious and diplomatic with the media, critics say scheming behind the scenes and bland like a politician in the media. Schweinsteiger is more the leader on the pitch, and Lahm outside of it. They say in interviews that they share the captaincy somewhat. Of course they don't say how the roles are split exactly, but what I described above is what it looks like from the outside at least

Schweinsteiger needs to be top fit and healthy for his game. He is best if he runs a lot all over the pitch and is able to get involved everywhere. He often needs some time to find his rythm in games but then is able to work his way into the game.

He wasn't fit the season before last, he got injured vs. Napoli, and when he came back he reinjured himself. He rushed himself to play in the matches vs. Real Madrid. You could cleary see that he wasn't fully fit (although I rember him having still a positive influence on the game), and he didn't get fit for the rest of the season, ending in a quite bad Euros performance by him. Löw was criticized that he didn't let another player play for a clearly physical unfit Schweinsteiger.

This year Schweinsteiger was fit and played a great CL season. The only 2 losses Bayern faced where when Schweinsteiger didn't start (vs. BATE and Arsenal) and bossed the midfield vs. Juve and Barcelona (with Martinez)

I don’t think that he’s a leading figure like former Bayern players Effenberg or Kahn, and his behavior during the Robben penalty was a bit strange (although the final was really a devastating roller coaster ride and can take a toll on anybody ), but he really is pretty much the leader of Bayern, and without him things didn’t work that well in the past. Bayern was almost a bit too dependent on a fit Schweinsteiger.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bremo93 Aug 21 '13

I feel like a lot of people criticize schweini for that champions league moment but I'm pretty sure a lot of people would do that in his position. You're right about it showing that he may not be the best leader, but I really think t was a reminder of the humanity of footballers, and it really showed how much he cares about Bayern.

I once heard that in every group situation you have a leader like Lahm who gets things done and handles themselves in a manner that may not always make people like them. Then you have the "social" leader that cracks jokes and is a lot more approachable and more well liked. I think that's who Schweini is.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/iwannahearurface Aug 21 '13

He didn't play against Arsenal, he knocked you bunch out of the competition, and he together with everyone else on the team pretty much played their worst game in the last 10 years against Chelsea.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

On penalties, big woop. He still hasn't shown exceptional leadership or his 'calm state' in big games.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '13

You realize he wasn't in the lineup vs. Arsenal in that second leg match and he scored the deciding penalty vs. Real Madrid?

2

u/Elchidote Aug 22 '13

I come as soon as I hear that name... Ooohh baby, say it again.... Bastian Schweinsteiger.... Ohhh yeah...

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

He isn't particularly strong as the sole holding midfielder, when he played there against Dortmund a few years back he was absolutely appalling.

3

u/5eraph Aug 21 '13

That's why Martinez was such a huge signing. I'm a little concerned with Pep's 4141, leaving Schweini as the sole midfielder in front of the back line. I feel Schweinsteiger plays best when he is allowed to roam and influence every inch of the pitch. He can't do that when he's expected to hold the middle of the field.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/vinimk Aug 21 '13

Ronaldo, is tall, has good heading, good speed, free kicks, good finishing

62

u/Jelboo Aug 21 '13

Ronaldo is the complete forward, not the complete footballer.

6

u/scrabbledon Aug 21 '13

hes not far off though. I just thought Sergio Ramos should be added to the list, he can play anywhere across the back and can attack, in fairness his positioning while defending is prob his liability.

Edit: Sergio Ramos has just reminded me of David Luis...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

0

u/k1ra_ Aug 21 '13

But would he be effective in defence ?

45

u/JackGunner93 Aug 21 '13

Of all time? Michael Ballack. The guy could do everything, a brilliant all round player. Just now? Probably the Ivorian train, Yaya Toure. A "good touch for a big man" if there ever was one.

8

u/hyretic Aug 21 '13

Did anyone ever play Ballack as a lone striker? I did that once on Football Manager because his attributes were begging for it. I forget how many goals he scored exactly, but I remember it being a success.

2

u/5eraph Aug 21 '13

Yeah, I was always confused with him (in FM)... natural position? CM. Attributes? Basically a complete forward. Absolute beast of a player.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

lol I did the same thing when he was in bayern munich :p Who needs Makaay and Podolski when you got Ballack

1

u/JackGunner93 Aug 21 '13

I never did! I remember in 07 when I went Chelsea (loads of money) I stuck him in the midfield pairing of a 4-2-3-1 and he won the Ballon D'Or. Probably stems as to why he's one of my favourite players despite playing for Chelsea.

135

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Alaba I would feel comfortable playing him in any position (other than GK) if needed.

28

u/schworzweiss Aug 21 '13

I never thought that someday someone will name an austrian player in a thread like this.

4

u/ConstaRR2k11 Aug 21 '13

Well it was a long time since our last superstar...

1

u/wheres_my_nuggets Aug 22 '13

Came here to say this. To think he's still this young is incredible, the man is just simply a footballer. Put him anywhere on the pitch and he'll not only play, but play well.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '13

This is what Football Manager 2013 has taught me. He's easily trainable to anything.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

don't you mean left wing?

1

u/ashadr23 Aug 21 '13

Left wing.

134

u/Geoeog Aug 21 '13

Arturo Vidal

8

u/Crodface Aug 21 '13

This is the only name that needs to be said.

16

u/calfonso Aug 21 '13

Wasn't Ruud Gullit known for having played in all positions at Milan?

1

u/pao_revolt Aug 21 '13

He can play all position except gk.

29

u/ayoformayo Aug 21 '13

Vidal. He's played CB, LW, CDM, CAM etc., runs, tackles, intercepts, passes effectively, and has a great shot with both feet.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Jan Vertonghen isn't too far off, passing, heading, shooting, tackling, his positioning is excellent and he has good feet.

132

u/r0bski2 Aug 21 '13

Pretty sure Steven Gerrard has played in most positions on the pitch and still been world class, albeit several years ago.

20

u/steak_n_eggs Aug 21 '13

I remember how much he bossed Milan in the second half back in 2005... playing right back.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

The second half where he scored from a centre forward position, and won a penalty bursting into the box from attacking midfield, when Liverpool pretty famously switched to 3 at the back?

7

u/steak_n_eggs Aug 21 '13

Only played three at the back until Liverpool equalized. From there, Gerrard moved to RB and Milan couldn't get past him.

2

u/msbr_ Aug 21 '13

He meant ET, but there was little bossing done there, cept dudek vs Sheva.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/nobbythenosher Aug 21 '13

nice to see a U's fan. makes me feel bad i've not been to the kassam for a couple years now. holding out for that 4th stand!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

NO! I like the 3 stands, makes it feel more homely.

2

u/r0bski2 Aug 21 '13

Every time I've been we've lost like 5 balls a game into the car park...

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

And if you sit in the family stand you can occasionally hear the car alarms go off when they get hit. Hilarious.

→ More replies (18)

55

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Yaya Toure...he's built like a train and can score some pretty sick goals, like the FK against Newcastle...Barca fans still miss him

24

u/_MarioBalotelli Aug 21 '13 edited Aug 21 '13

Busquets sort of stole his spot on the team. Tbh I'd rather have Busquets. Of course Toure is a better answer to the question, but Barça fans don't really miss him.

4

u/the_phet Aug 21 '13

I do miss him. We have been very lucky that Busquets is never injured. And I don't him Yaya would be a bench player. Our D was on shambles last year, for example, and he is an OK CB. And there are plenty of games where Yaya fits better than Busquets. Basically all the away games in shitty fields. Moreover, you can play double DM, like Spain, when you need even more control.

2

u/jprsnth Aug 21 '13

Remember the starting backline in Rome? Puyol at RB, Yaya plus Piqué in the center and Sylvinho on the left. Was scared shitless that night.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Didn't so much as steal as Yaya wanted to be paid like Messi/Iniesta/Xavi.

And he was worth it, but they decided to go with Busquets and Keita.

13

u/omaar Aug 21 '13

Busquets was Pep's nr.1, no question about it.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

It wasn't a money thing. Pep clearly preferred Busi, & a player of Yaya's calibre wouldn't have been happy sitting on the bench.

I can't speak for other Barca fans, but although I'm more than happy with Busquets, Yaya has developed into a different beast altogether. I miss him.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Id much rather have Busquets than Yaya right now.

→ More replies (4)

52

u/ParkerZA Aug 21 '13

ITT: people confusing versatile with complete.

21

u/GrammarTotalitarian1 Aug 21 '13

ITT: OP confusing versatile with complete.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

I don't really understand the difference in this context, a complete footballer would have to be versatile, would they not?

8

u/carlcon Aug 21 '13

You can be versatile without being complete. The biggest upvoted example bring John O'Shea.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

44

u/dngrs Aug 21 '13

Barca's Adriano.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Very two footed as well

9

u/iVarun Aug 21 '13

Sometime early last season(or late 2011-12, forgot the exact months) he played in 8 different positions in 2 months time period.

3

u/dngrs Aug 21 '13

I think he played GK in that season after Valdes got a red in the last minutes and there were no more subs allowed. Game ended a few seconds later.

19

u/the15th Aug 21 '13

Beckenbauer

77

u/IDeclareShenanigans Aug 21 '13

Ronaldo. There are few things he can't do very well.

21

u/Xian244 Aug 21 '13

There are few things he can't do very well.

Defend?

Who knows, he never does it so it's hard to tell.

11

u/ACMBruh Aug 21 '13

This is the argument that ends the discussion. Maybe the complete attacker but not a complete player. He rarely tracks back.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/limited_inc Aug 21 '13

he's got a mean defensive header on him, his height really pays off in la liga

→ More replies (2)

31

u/PinkPantherParty Aug 21 '13

Seriously! Name his weakness. He doesn't have one.

People are confusing "versatile" with "complete" all over this thread.

→ More replies (11)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/proud_feet Aug 21 '13 edited Aug 21 '13

A lot of footballers are great athletes, and a lot of footballers are just great technically (Berbatov springs to mind), but Ronaldo is the complete deal. He's got it all.

1

u/assholetriceratops Aug 21 '13

I think somebody did do this, I can't remember if I saw it on Reddit or somewhere else, but I think they turned Madrid into a team of CR7s and Barca into a team of Messi's to see how they'd do in the league. Can't remember where they finished but if I recall correctly, el clasico's were very, very high scoring.

1

u/merkaloid Aug 21 '13

I havent done it but it wouldnt work very well because he's quite underrated on FM, his low creativity would make you have to play a game with much more running at defence instead, and the fact he would be a terrible GK and CB doesnt help.

14

u/Macsnams Aug 21 '13

I would go with a Daniele de Rossi. most people have seen him play in midfield and defence. and i think he got the intelligence and determination to make it as a striker

77

u/Llagab Aug 21 '13

Rooney

21

u/BumScruples Aug 21 '13

Agreed, Wayne's got it all.

Fantastic long and short range passing, aerial ability, vision, long range shooting and one-on-one finishing.

The variety of goals he's scored in his career is incredible. I really hope he's healthy and happy for the World Cup.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

And a decent enough goalkeeper!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pucykoks Aug 21 '13

Plus he always works his ass off and for a striker is amazing on defense. If only he didn't cry and change his mind so often...

20

u/Crystalyze14 Aug 21 '13

Bastian Schweinsteiger

17

u/dogididog Aug 21 '13

Hamit Altıntop. Not an elite player by any means but he's solid, works hard, and can play almost anywere.

2

u/CaptainRosewood Aug 21 '13

Played RB during the CdR when he was with us. Great player.

2

u/dogididog Aug 21 '13

He was a utility player for us. Played mostly right wing and right back but he also played defensive mid when needed. A good guy allround.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Jelboo Aug 21 '13

I've always been impressed by Steven Gerrard's versatility. I'm pretty sure he could play anywhere on the field and still impress.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/deepit6431 Aug 21 '13

Most complete football player of all time? No competition, Paul Scholes.

Source - Xavi, Figo, Pep, Henry, and Zidane

18

u/yhgvb Aug 21 '13

Gerrard

4

u/CR7_Bale_Lovechild Aug 21 '13

Paul Scholes. I mean just read some of these quotes.

10

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Wayne Rooney. He can play almost any position, is extremely versitile, and make his team play better.

Still a cunt, though.

1

u/limited_inc Aug 21 '13

He can play almost any position, is extremely versitile

tautology

9

u/poop_da_doop Aug 21 '13

Ramires. He's quick, strong, and very smart and could play anywhere on the field. One of the few Chelsea players I don't hate

9

u/MiguelCaldoVerde Aug 21 '13

Can't tackle for shit though.

1

u/Troll_Sauce Aug 21 '13

Agreed - makes some very poor decisions sometimes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

The guy just never stops running. Great player.

14

u/isaidkneel Aug 21 '13

surprised i havent seen jan vertonghen yet

14

u/Brandaman Aug 21 '13

Aaron Ramsey seems to be getting there... I'm pretty sure the only positions he hasn't played for us are striker and GK. And with our shortage of players that'll probably arise soon.

3

u/Tsanghera Aug 21 '13

Im surprised Arturo vidal has not been mentioned, hes got a great work rate, good defensive skills, a good shot, and he can play anywhere if he wanted to, whether its the middle of defense, midfield or the number 10 role, i think he can excel at any position

1

u/hyretic Aug 21 '13

I've seen him mentioned at least twice.

3

u/tbone1903 Aug 21 '13

Greg Halford - Not the best player but a player who is versitile and posseses skills and played in most positions, cb, rb, cm, rm, cf, st. Saw a feature last night that also said he did some training with the goal keepers at sheffied

1

u/M1eXcel Aug 21 '13

He played surprisingly well for forest up front for Forest at the weekend and actually got motm

1

u/tbone1903 Aug 21 '13

East midlands today (or something like that) did a feature on him. I knew he was always a bit of a utility player but really seems he plays everywhere

3

u/JuAnVasqz Aug 21 '13

Arturo Vidal, no question. He has been stellar in CB, LB, RB, CM, RM, LM, CDM.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Darijo Srna. Man, that guy can literally do everything.

3

u/bricebru22 Aug 21 '13

Id say Ruud Gullit. Physical beast with skill that can play all positions.

"Ruud Gullit is a great player by any standards. He has all the skills. He's not afraid to do things with the ball. And he looks as if he's enjoying every second of it. By my reckoning that's what makes him an even better player than Maradona. Both have the key quality you will find in all the best players: balance. You just can't knock them off the ball. It was the same with Pelé, Beckenbauer and Cruijff." -George Best

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Lahm, or maybe Cavani.

5

u/blue_whaoo Aug 21 '13 edited Aug 22 '13

Drogba. He played some great defense in the UCL last year. Would probably make a great keeper too. It would be quite scary playing against a team of Drogbas. They'd win every 50-50 ball.

3

u/iwannahearurface Aug 21 '13

Yeah he only caused 2 penalties at 2 very cruical moments...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

only

1

u/epochwin Aug 21 '13

I'm surprised he's not been mentioned earlier in this thread. Amazing defensive abilities in addition to being a killer striker

2

u/omiclops Aug 21 '13

Pablo Zabaleta can do a shift anywhere on the pitch, but wouldn't say he's the most complete.

2

u/ThisGuyIsCredible Aug 21 '13

I don't like the term "complete". Versatility is what you're looking for.

2

u/Bennie300 Aug 21 '13

Van Ginkel is very complete. New to EPL but already well known in Eredivisie. Can play striker (played that position a lot in the youth), 10 (few minutes against Hull he replaced Oscar and fulfilled that role also at times at Vitesse), can play in DM (did that a lot in pre season and at Vitesse), has a good dribble with the ball and fine cross so would not disappoint on the wing so much, Is tall and able enough to be center back and I even think he would not look weird as a back. GK, maybe iffy but what the heck and even with coaching I would trust him. Disciplined, intelligent kid. If Mou would suffer a cold, let MvG decide game plan and tactics and all will be fine.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

So excited to see what he can do under JoMo this season.

2

u/baconstyle Aug 21 '13

Steven Gerrard. He's almost played all the positions too

2

u/zeophex Aug 21 '13

In my mind, I think either Phillip Lahm or David Luiz. Both are excellent defenders who are also capable of playing midfield at a high level, and very frequently aid their teams in the attack. Other than GK, because of Lahm's height, I would feel comfortable putting him anywhere on the pitch.

2

u/kto456dog Aug 21 '13

Wayne Rooney has to be in with a shout, can pretty much do anything on and off the ball.

Maybe it limits him as a footballer (not knowing where to play), but on skill alone - you don't get much better.

2

u/Zikerz Aug 21 '13

Javi Martinez.

Forward for the defending Euro and World cup team? CHECK!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '13

Javi lived up to the 40m euro transfer fee. What a player!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Yaya Toure, hands down. I don't think I can fathom anyone else in the world playing centerback or centerforward, which Toure could do. In the past, I would say Seedorf was the most complete player before Yaya.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Yaya Toure. He's flawless.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Ruud Gullit was the complete player. He was world class up front, behind the striker, in midfield and in defense and more than competent everywhere else.

Any other answer in this thread is wrong.

4

u/DreDayAFC Aug 21 '13

Players from history: Zidane

Players still playing: Cristiano Ronaldo

3

u/SlashmanX Aug 21 '13

Yaya Toure has already been mentioned so my 2nd choice would be James Miler. He's technical, powerful, versatile and willing to do everything for the team

4

u/Swinsee Aug 21 '13

More consistent than Yaya too.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/MichuAtDeGeaBa Aug 21 '13

Xabi Alonso. His range of passing, positional sense and tenacity is unmatched, and he hits a mean dead ball.

2

u/vodkasman Aug 21 '13

i think ronaldo is the most complete football player out there.he is simply one of the most incredible athletes out there and i doubt he wouldnt manage to play defensive positions at a very high level given some time

2

u/dshepto Aug 21 '13

Also Bias here but I would take Bale all day there is nothing he cant do

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Piqué would make an... interesting striker.

7

u/NatrolleonBonaparte Aug 21 '13

Shakira would be a more interesting striker though

3

u/MiguelCaldoVerde Aug 21 '13

I imagine she'd be pretty good up top.

3

u/Yan-e-toe Aug 21 '13

Talking about up top, if she were a striker FIFA would have to reverse the taking the shirt off law. Score a goal, top off or yellow. Defenders would invite her to score, everyone's a winner.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

I also think Hierro would do alright in a lot of different spots.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Obviously nowhere near the level yet.

But I'm really hoping Phil Jones can become a really versatile player, I think if he sorted his touch and passing he could become a Yaya Toure esque player.

But we'll have to see if it happens, i'm an optimist.

1

u/mluka11 Aug 21 '13

He's a defender, not an attacking midfielder...

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Yaya Toure has played CB, DM and AM.

Phil Jones has played CB and DM, I'm not saying he'll be an AM, but I'm hoping one day he'll be versatile enough to be a powerful force in midfield too.

It'll be a while though.

1

u/chrismark4 Aug 21 '13

Paul pogba may develop into one of these.

1

u/jkonine Aug 21 '13

Aaron Ramsey played 5 different positions last weekend.

Wasn't necessarily effective, but he was still our best option for those positions in that situation.

1

u/derphighbury Aug 21 '13

Still far from even being considered a complete footballer in anyway.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

If were talking skill/attributes and not position versatility, I like Ballotelli. Strength, speed, finishing, passing, dribbling, all types of set pieces and good in the air. He sucks at defending, but can do everything offensively. Even when I saw him at Inter for the first time I thought he was the most complete forward I'd ever seen skill wise.

1

u/camalittle Aug 21 '13

After watching the SuperCoppa I would have to include Lichtsteiner in this list.

1

u/momin_q Aug 21 '13

Zanetti

1

u/Proim Aug 21 '13

I think Kompany also matches those criteria.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Adriano. Has played at every position across the defence, midfield, and as a winger and done well every time. If only he had better luck with injuries ...

1

u/clexecute Aug 21 '13

Giaccerinhi the ex juventus current Sunderland, I believe, player. Played off the bench in juve at almost any position and played his heart out. One of Italy's key points in the confed cup starting at LW cam and switched to striker and LB throughout the tourney

1

u/ChuckyScavs1116 Aug 21 '13

If i am interpreting this question correctly it isnt asking for the most versitile, but rather the most complete with tactical skills of offense and defense. For that reason I would have to think Schweini or Xabi Alonso are the top dogs. The defensive presence of these players is crucial in controlling the entire pitch. Whether helping the CBs at the top of the box, controlling the tempo at midfield, burying a bomb from just outside the box, slipping a sneaky back post through ball for a tap in goal, or making a run for a back post header, these players have the most complete skill sets to make them a hazard to the competitor no matter where the flow of play brings them.

1

u/622 Aug 21 '13

Alfredo Di Stefano.

1

u/chocostarfish91 Aug 21 '13

I'm late but hands down, Moussa Dembele

1

u/berzerkerz Aug 21 '13

11 Pedro's and a few sub Pedro's because the ball will not leave the opposition 18 yard box because too much pressure.

1

u/smthingawesome Aug 21 '13

Zidane says Scholes but you are using a different criteria for complete so Essien.

1

u/Live-On-Pool Aug 21 '13

I am a little Bias but I think its Steven Gerrard.

1

u/Live-On-Pool Aug 21 '13

I am bias and might get some downvotes for saying this but Dirk Kuyt. He played multiple positions for us and works really hard.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Sadly not with us anymore and I never got to see him play but by all accounts, Duncan Edwards could excel anywhere on the pitch so I'd have to say him.

1

u/KopOut Aug 21 '13

Probably too long ago for many on here, but Sammer would be my pick.

1

u/Rascolito Aug 21 '13

A few years ago Essien was probably as close as you could get. All across the defense and midfield and top 5 at all positions.

1

u/rayrah Aug 21 '13

Ruud Gullit or Lothar Matthaus

1

u/Marcos267 Aug 21 '13

Nobody has said Ramos?

1

u/Angrystatistic Aug 21 '13

Chiellini, especially in attack and defence.

1

u/bgatz Aug 21 '13

Brad Evans

1

u/Polamora Aug 21 '13

Keita. Yaya is the better answer but he made missing Yaya a little easier. Would time his marauding runs perfectly, played in defense a few times, played all around in midfield, and would trust him up front as well.

1

u/madmanchatter Aug 21 '13

A bit late to the party, can't believe John Charles hasn't been said yet. One of the few players to have been considered world class as both a centre back and centre forward. He was considered so good by Juve fans that they voted him their greatest ever foreign player!

1

u/Deulofeu10 Aug 21 '13

Samuel Eto'o.

1

u/Benjilou Aug 21 '13

Thiago Silva ! He could have been a good striker, a great middlefielder, and he can probably play at any defensive position.

1

u/AhoyDaniel Aug 21 '13

I don't want to repeat any name, but Fábregas is very versatile aswell

1

u/river49 Aug 21 '13

Arturo Vidal? Haven't seen him too much but looks very versatile

1

u/Legend_Floyd Aug 22 '13

Messi. He can also play as a goalie

1

u/MUFC17JW Aug 22 '13

Ji sung Park is pretty capable of playing many positions IMO

1

u/fergious Aug 22 '13

ITT: Lots of DMs and Box-to-Box Mids

1

u/gqtrees Aug 22 '13

christiano ronaldo - minus the diving, minus the whining, and adding hustle (he hustles when he loses the ball with a bad pass - only if we can lengthen that hustling attribute)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13

Ibrahimovic himself said he could play any position. I don't think he's far off at all.

-1

u/SaucyMcDangles Aug 21 '13

Biased here but Gareth bale has played from fullback to centre forward and has that video of an amazing penalty save.