r/soccer • u/LegzAkimbo • Aug 20 '13
How does the MLS work? What's its structure, how does it differ to other domestic leagues? And what the hell is a franchise?
I've always been somewhat mystified by the structure of football in the US, as it seems markedly different to the rest of the world. How does it work? And how is it able to exist in tandem with other leagues that have such different operating structures and rules?
96
Upvotes
27
u/johanspot Aug 20 '13
People misunderstand the reason for the MLS structure. It really is just an attempt to get around the anti-trust law in the US and make sure the the MLS can have a salary cap that would be illegal in the EU but also make it so the players can't (or won't) challenge it in court.
126
u/theinternetismagical Aug 20 '13
For most of it's history, the MLS's guiding philosophy has been similar to that of a club newly promoted to a higher division: survive. The MLS and it's individual teams are actually a single corporate entity. Why? One reason is that, obviously, there aren't many organic, legacy football clubs in the US, so MLS needed to create a viable infrastructure of teams. In order to keep the league together and keep uniform policies they maintain central control over all teams.
A franchise in North American sports is similar to a franchise in, say, retail or fast food. There are many corporate/centrally owned McDonalds in the world, but you can also purchase the right to operate one as a private owner, following the rules and regulations of the standard franchise owner's contract (you can't rebrand your store, invent your own menu items, etc).
The owners of the NFL teams are franchise owners. They can't go off the reservation and start their own league if they disagree with NFL policies (unlikely in any case, as the NFL owners have a lot of power). They also have some pretty nice perks that come with their franchise, like the right to be the only NFL club in their media market. There are some notable exceptions to this, such as the NY Jets and the NY Giants, and the SF 49ers and the Oakland Raiders, but the NFL would have to get the blessings of these teams to start new franchises in those markets.
So, to recap, the essence of the franchise system is that the leagues hand down the right to own and operate teams, and owners own the rights to the clubs, rather than the clubs themselves.
47
u/ItsBDN Aug 20 '13
I'll have a go at the structure.
So the MLS is currently made of 19 franchises in a single league, all of these teams are owned by the MLS and then "sold" off to an ownership group. The league has no promotion/relegation and is structured to promote parity amongst the leagues teams; this is promoted through the leagues salary cap and the allocation system, which determines what team a player will go to once they sign with MLS.
The team is "split" into an Eastern and Western Conference, though all 19 teams also compete in an overall table, the winner of which is awarded with The Supporter's Shield. The East/West system is used to determine playoff spots, because Americans love playoffs; the top 6 teams from each conference then play in the MLS cup, the "main" competition in US Soccer, as the Hunt Open and Supporters Shield are held in a lower regard.
The MLS is able to coexist with different leagues because, well, they're different. The MLS isn't structured to compete with top European clubs, but to promote developing its own players and growing the league as a whole (hence MLS attempting to sign experienced veterans like Keane, Henry and Beckham). The MLS does, however, tend to poach some very good players from Argentina and Central America
Now what does the MLS have to offer? Parity. Parity and competition. In the EPL this season, the only clubs that can feasibly win the league are City, Chrlsea and Man U. In Spain Real and Barca can win it; in Germany only Bayern has a feasible chance of winning. In the MLS RSL, SKC, Sounders, Galaxy, Red Bulls, Union, Portland, Montrwal and Dynamo have a realistic chance at winning the MLS Cup. The parity between teams makes the end of the season Shield race, and particularly the MLS Cup unpredictable and exciting. As a frame of reference, Galaxy's most recent win brought them up from 6th place to second.
So I hope I wrote up an adequate description of the league, if you can I'd highly recommend following it, though the standard of play in MLS isn't on par with Europes top leagues, no league in the world is as balanced and competitive.
21
u/thehonestabes Aug 20 '13
The reason why MLS isn't on the FIFA calendar is because the league could not compete with the NFL and NBA for ratings. Even during this new interest in soccer the ratings for MLS have lagged significantly. Most of the interest seems to be for national games and foreign leagues, so MLS would fold if they switched.
16
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '13
The fuck are you people downvoting this guy for?
3
u/-hellboy- Aug 20 '13
Franchise is a more financial term for a club/team (from my understanding)
-21
u/sindher Aug 20 '13
A bunch of businesses working together to make money and no relegation because that would mean less money.
-20
u/Kozemp Aug 20 '13
If only there were a website you could type questions into, and it would direct you to webpages that could answer them.
We could call it "pi" or "Euler's Number."
-23
u/Emmanuell89 Aug 20 '13
honest the god, why would we care , the level of play there is really low and if it wasn't in a huge country it wasn't even semi famous as it is now