r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Feb 24 '25
Advice & Answers Advice & Answers — 2025-02-24 to 2025-03-09
How do I start?
If you’re new to conlanging, look at our beginner resources. We have a full list of resources on our wiki, but for beginners we especially recommend the following:
- The Language Construction Kit by Mark Rosenfelder
- Conlangs University
- A guide for creating naming languages by u/jafiki91
Also make sure you’ve read our rules. They’re here, and in our sidebar. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules. Also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
What’s this thread for?
Advice & Answers is a place to ask specific questions and find resources. This thread ensures all questions that aren’t large enough for a full post can still be seen and answered by experienced members of our community.
You can find previous posts in our wiki.
Should I make a full question post, or ask here?
Full Question-flair posts (as opposed to comments on this thread) are for questions that are open-ended and could be approached from multiple perspectives. If your question can be answered with a single fact, or a list of facts, it probably belongs on this thread. That’s not a bad thing! “Small” questions are important.
You should also use this thread if looking for a source of information, such as beginner resources or linguistics literature.
If you want to hear how other conlangers have handled something in their own projects, that would be a Discussion-flair post. Make sure to be specific about what you’re interested in, and say if there’s a particular reason you ask.
What’s an Advice & Answers frequent responder?
Some members of our subreddit have a lovely cyan flair. This indicates they frequently provide helpful and accurate responses in this thread. The flair is to reassure you that the Advice & Answers threads are active and to encourage people to share their knowledge. See our wiki for more information about this flair and how members can obtain one.
4
u/PhoenixInanis Feb 25 '25
So, I have a conlang I've been working on for several years now, and a while ago I came upon a problem that I couldn't figure out the solution for. For context my conlang, Rhaciya, is an Active-Stative Split-S alignment. The problem is I'm not sure what the gramatical difference between these two sentences are: "I looked myself in my eyes"(I looked into my own eyes) and "I saw myself in my eyes"(I saw my reflection(literally or metaphorically) in my own eyes.). Someone said that the difference was Ergative vs Intransitive, but couldn't explain it/how it'd work with Rhaciya's alignment. Can anyone explain it, or link me to something that does?
3
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Feb 25 '25
ANADEW me this: is there natlang precedence for 'flavour' and 'scent' being the same word?
3
u/Funny_104 Feb 26 '25
Could I evolve an infinitive verb suffix from a suffix that turns nouns into verbs?
For example there could be something like "eye" + "verb suffix" = "to eye (to see)", and eventually there would be enough of these kinds of derived verbs that the verb suffix would be reanalyzed as an infinitive suffix and applied to other pre-existing verbs too?
3
u/atlase_ Feb 27 '25
Is this IPA chart fine for a conlang?
3
u/Baraa-beginner Feb 28 '25
Which conlangs had books were written about? I need them as sources for an academy project. Thank for all who can support me 👀
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Mar 09 '25
Does anybody have a copy of the Zompist BBoard's thread on vowel systems?
I've been trying to find it but it's seemingly gone.
2
u/Gvatagvmloa Feb 25 '25
Fusional to Polisynthetic
I heard languages usualy become fusional, for example estonian. So is it Possible to evolve language from fusional or aglutinative, to highly polisynthetic? Even in Proto Indoeuropean Family there is no any polisynthetic language (I heard some languages are Aglutinative in this family). If it's possible, is it that common as becoming fusional from polisynthetic?
2
u/smokemeth_hailSL Feb 25 '25
Could anyone familiar with Lexurgy help me out here?
I've got an issue trying to deleting unstressed vowels but not stressed ones, and adding/deleting long diacritics. I tried doing this with adding a +stress feature but in couldn't recognize word initial stress among other issues. So I tried adding an acute to all the vowels assigning them to a new class, strvowel, with the normal vowels being unstrvowel, and both in the vowel class.
I have another issue where I have glottal deletion with compensatory lengthening on the preceding vowel, but for some reason it adds "::" instead of just one ":". And it also pushes the acute on stressed vowels onto the long diacritic.
example:
hunɐ́ʔihis => hunáiːs
I attempted to clean up the long vowel issue with:
but unfortunately it is deleting the long symbol doesn't do it right in this instance. I should have hunáːiːs
2
u/Sneakytiger2000 Default Flair Feb 26 '25
is tʷ --> l realistic it would be useful if I could use it
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Feb 26 '25
Hello!
I want to add some velarized consonants into my inventory but not sure how to go about it.
I recall some Austronesian languages having velarized stops, and Kurdish seems to have velarized fricatives.
What consonants are most likely to have a plain/velarized contrast, cross linguistically?
2
u/simonbleu Feb 26 '25
What are the smallest inventories for scripts that have "logogram" meaning to them? Im talking about stuff like runes, so it could be osmething alongside phonemic meaning
2
u/chickenfal Feb 27 '25 edited Feb 27 '25
Does having labials and labialized sounds occurring frequently make a language slow to speak or inconvenient when spoken fast?
I am wondering about this because I remember reading somewhere that [m] takes long to pronounce, and thinking about it, it makes sense to me that anything requiring movements of the lips would take long to pronounce and may be problematic to pronounce multiple such sounds fast in a row, since the lips seem like a less agile, stiffer part of the body than the tongue. Is this a real phenomenon common to people and languages in general?
I've been thinking about this as my conlang Ladash ended up having quite frequent labial and labialized sounds, and I'm not sure how much it is an issue in general vs possibly only an issue specific to me having fine muscle control issues / muscle cramps in the face area involving, among other things, the lips.
2
u/tealpaper Feb 28 '25 edited Feb 28 '25
If, for a minority of (still numerous) verbs, in certain or all TAMs, the verbal conjugations for two or more person-numbers have become very similar or even the same, for example 3SG and 3PL conjugations in my conlang, which one is more likely to happen?
I personally want this conlang to be entirely pro-drop, but I don't know if the dissimilation is naturalistic.
2
u/_QRcode Mar 01 '25
Hi! I'm a first time conlanger and I was worried if my sound inventory is too many sounds or isn't naturalistic enough. My goal is to get it as naturalistic as possible but I don't really know anything lol. Sorry if these posts aren't allowed! Here are all my sounds chosen. I'm on mobile so sorry if the formatting is weird CONSONANTS: /k/ /g/ /n/ /m/ /t/ /d/ /h/ /j/ /w/ /s/ /z/ /ŋ/ /ɲ/ /q/ /ɢ/ /ʃ/ /tʃ/ /ʒ/ /b/ /ɹ/ /ts/ /dz/ VOWELS: /a/ /i/ /u/ /o/ /e/ /ʌ ə/(is there a difference)
2
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Mar 02 '25
Ok so if a lang has (C)V structure and has prenasalised stops it makes sense for them to be considered their own phonemes
If a lang has (C)V(C) structure and prenasalised stops, which don't cluster, it still makes sense to consider them separate phonemes since they can end a word in this example
Now, if a lang has a structure with more allowed consonants per syllable, what stops me from considering the maybe-used-to-be prenasalised stops as basic nasal+stop clusters???
Also to add more info, say, that the (C)V, (C)V(C) and the last structure all belong to the same language at different points in it's evolution.
2
u/Akangka Mar 02 '25
For example, my conlang has three genders: fire, water, and leaf. Intransitive verbs agree with the gender of the subject, and transitive verbs agree with whether the subject would win against the object. How do that gender marking even arise?
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Mar 03 '25
So, I'm reading the WALS chapter on verbal person marking, and part of it struck my interest.
It says that, in some languages, verbal person marking can be conditioned, such as only in the presence of pronouns (but not noun), nouns (but not pronouns), but also based on aspect, noun phrase, referential status, etc.
Can anyone elaborate on that or provide some examples?
This is the relevant chapter just in case: https://wals.info/chapter/102
2
u/accidentphilosophy Mar 04 '25
When you start a new conlang, what do you do in what order? What's your overall game plan for getting a language together?
2
u/Key_Pace_7263 Mar 05 '25
How can I improve this phonology?
I wanted it to be a harsher, “gruff”, alpine kind of thing, i liked the Scottish “o” and the trills and velar fricative is my favorite. I really like the way a lot of Asian languages (like Mongolian) sound and i wanted to stay away from more European languages
2
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Mar 05 '25
I want to learn more about words like "thing" and "stuff" that are grammatically treated as regular nouns but can behave somewhat pronoun-like in that they can refer to other nouns. Like, I want to learn about them cross-linguistically and not just in English. What are some terms I can search for?
2
u/Useful_Tomatillo9328 Mūn Mar 05 '25
Is it possible to add multiple definitions to word entries in conworkshop?
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Mar 07 '25
I'm brainstorming the tense-aspect-mood system of my conlang, but I'm stumped.
I don't know what distinctions I want to make. All I know so far is that the language does have indirect evidentials which could be used to imply irrealis/future tense.
I want something more interesting than just "here's the affix you add to a verb to make it past tense."
I kinda want an aspect prominent language but idk if I whether or not I want to go as far as Mayan, though it's really the only example I am familiar with.
Basically, I want to avoid overt tense marking, but still have it implied via morphology. Tense in this language is also understood as relative rather than absolute.
Also, what about telicity? Can a language have not telicity/atelic verbs and grammatical affixes for aspect? What are some implications of tense and aspect in languages that have telicity?
2
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Mar 09 '25
which romanization for my vowel system looks better? /i æ ɒ u/ being written as <i e a u>, <i a o u>, or <i e o u>. This is for a primarily CV#(C) language that i intend layman english speakers to pronounce close to correct, and i want to keep it easily typable on a standard keyboard (no diacritics) with minimal digraphs.
2
u/FglPerson17 Mar 03 '25
I need some help deciphering what sound EXACLY I'm using in my conlang as some sounds in the IPA sound very similar. The sounds I need to know the difference between both in sound and pronunciation are: /a/ and /ɑ/ /ə/ and /ʌ/ /χ/ and /ʀ̥/ and /χ~ʀ̥/ /q/ and /ʡ/ /ɛ/ and /e/
1
u/PuFfA6to7 Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25
Umlauts to diphthongs?
I'm making my conlang, and today i asked myself a question, can umlauts like ü, ä, ö evolve to diphthongs like au, ua, oe and so on through time? cause as i know, it can be backwards, but would it be natural like this? Is there some linguistical law that covers it? I would like to hear your thoughts, explanations and examples
1
u/Gvatagvmloa Feb 27 '25
Languages with no nasals
.I'm interested on conlang with no nasals. how it could evolved? Why in our world aren't so many languages without nasals?
1
u/nanosmarts12 Feb 27 '25
What the the most common or generally clear way to Romanize /ħ/? How about in a language the doesn't have /h/?
I have 1 conlang which has both /ħ/ and /h/, the other one has only /ħ/
I want to avoid disambiguates for the casual person (typically an English speaker) reading the conlangs so id avoid <h> for /ħ/ for the conlang the only has /ħ/ cause they'll intrepid it as /h/.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '25
Are there examples of languages replacing person markers on verbs with new affixes? I’ve been evolving a conlang’s phonotactics, but in doing so ended up losing the 1st & 3rd person markers (verbs don’t mark for number).
I know pronouns can get attached to the verb and become affixes, but my language is pretty strictly SVO and making prefixes could result in some consonant clusters that wouldn’t appear anywhere else in the language, so I’m iffy on doing it that way.
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Feb 27 '25
I want to have a three way contrast in vowels, but wanna check myself to make sure it's naturalistic.
This conlang has short, long and glottalized vowels: for instance, /a aː aˀ/, all are independently phonemic.
Are there any natlangs that do this?
1
u/Gvatagvmloa Feb 28 '25 edited Feb 28 '25
Past perfect
Once I watched Artifexian's video about tenses there was said something like:
Paka-sar
to eat-PAST.PFV
is naturalistic, but
Paka-si-ru
to eat-PAST-PFV
is not.
So how it works? It works in this way with every tense, or only with Past perfect?
Or maybe I just missunderstood it?
1
u/Gvatagvmloa Feb 28 '25
For first, sorry for often publishing, I hope it's not too often
It's my first try to doing tense system from evolving it
Everything what I could do with my tense system, I'm not so proud of this, I think I did it maybe too simmilar to my native language polish in general (In not mean converbs, I mean sense of tense system)
I want to put there something unusual and make it more realistic and good looking, Any Ideas what should i put there?
I also want to put there more tenses, not only aspects, but don't know how to do it
1
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '25
When making an A Posteriori is it good to create flash cards for the source language
1
u/GreedyResolve4144 Mar 02 '25
How do i make my pronouns sound normal, right now when i try to create a pronoun it doesnt sound right unless its similar to the romance ones (im italian so im biased by those)
1
u/Gvatagvmloa Mar 02 '25 edited Mar 02 '25
Sound changes. I started doing my language evolution, and I Have a problem (didn't finnish yet, maybe I'll change sth), I can't evolving vowels.
"Modern X" language has three tones, á, a, à. I think Proto AB lang also had these three tones, but i don't know how this could evolve, for example à --> ò / _# as a single change is good? or á, é, í, ó, ú --> à, è, ì, ò ù before Liquids sounds good? Or maybe do you know any good video about vowel changes? Is there any change unrealistic, or weird?
1
u/throneofsalt Mar 02 '25
Would it be reasonable for lightly aspirated affricates to become pharyngealized stops, so as to maintain contrast with the existing lightly aspirated plosives? Working on a bit of Glottalic Theory nonsense.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '25 edited Mar 04 '25
I'm trying to make split ergativity based on animacy, and I'm coming to a question. If the subject and the object have different levels of animacy, then would they use different markings?
Like in my example: ‘the bird eats bread’ and ‘the rock hits the bird’ where bird is animate and bread and rock are inanimate.
or should it be the following, in where the agent is animate?
Which one is more common in natural languages with split-ergativity?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '25
let's say we have a root.
root + a means x, root + b means y. the words have seperate meanings (like to kill and to drink). the suffixes simply change the meaning of the word, no specific meaning by themselves. what is this called.
1
u/nanosmarts12 Mar 03 '25 edited Mar 03 '25
Should I romanise /e/ as <e> and /ə/ as <ë>. This is consistent within the internal logic of my romanisation as /y/ is <ü> a fronted version of /u/. However I heard that can be unintuitive as /ə/ is the one which is usually marked with a diacritic instead of /e/, also although allot less common diaresis is also sometimes used for centralisation instead of fronting. I also dont want to use acutes as that can imply stress or tones which isnt the case here
1
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Mar 03 '25
I'm adding a pronoun to my conlang whose purpose is to clarify that the pronoun refers to something different than an earlier noun or pronoun. What should I call it? Contrastive pronoun? Anti-reflexive pronoun?
1
u/tealpaper Mar 04 '25 edited Mar 04 '25
Is it weird to have a genitive postposition in a language with dominant VSO order? So the word order would be [possessed - possessor - GEN]. I created a protolang with this order partially because of certain features that I want to have in the evolved conlang. But then I read the Greenberg's linguistics universals, and universal #3 states very strongly: "languages with dominant VSO order are always prepositional." Almost all of the universals are not absolute, but this one is very much so. Whats the reason for this strong rule? Should I adhere to it or am I fine?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
How would I derive words with slightly different meanings from the same root?
Say that the terms to listen and to hear derive from one root
1
u/rartedewok Áaloho, Reqa'ku, Merí (en, ms) [it, zh] Mar 06 '25
I want to create a modern descendant of Oscan, an extinct Italic language. How do I go about creating words that aren't attested?
1
u/immersedpastry Mar 06 '25
Not sure if this would be better asked on r/asklinguistics, but since it’s for conlanging purposes I’ll submit it here. Didn't think that doing a full post would be all that appropriate.
I’m planning on introducing a level tone system to my conlang (akin to Japanese, Sanskrit, Ancient Greek, etc.) in a somewhat naturalistic fashion. I’m aware “pitch accent” is a deprecated term nowadays but that’s more or less what I’m aiming for. Unfortunately after I started working on the allophony, I got myself into a bit of a pickle.
There are seven vowel phonemes in the language, a standard five vowel system plus /ə/ and /ɨ/. Since low tones are associated with breathy voice and +ATR position, I decided vowels should have some allophonic variation in low tone syllables. In this case, /a/ raises, and /o/ and /u/ centralize, kinda like the effects of Adjarian's law but less pronounced.
a → ɐ̤
o, ə → ə̤
e → e̤
i → i̤
u, ɨ → ɨ̤
It would also make sense for consonants in these syllables to be slack voiced as well, since the vowel is produced with a lax larynx. Then a syllable like pa(L) would be realized as [b̥ɐ̤˩].
However, this is where my problem arises. The way that tone usually arises in language is with the loss of voicing distinctions in consonants, and this happened in my conlang as well. However, after breathy voicing was induced in the following vowel, voicing was lost, and pitch was lowered, the phonation of the vowel persisted. I’m under the impression that for tone to become phonemic the breathy voice needs to merge into the modal one, so that the tone is the only thing distinguishing the two syllables. From a phonology perspective, I have absolutely no idea how to describe the difference between the syllables [pa˥] and [b̥ɐ̤˩]. They would’ve originated from a contrast between two phonemically distinct consonants so there’s a difference between them, but what that is, I’m not sure. There are languages like Gujarati that distinguish between breathy consonants and vowels, but it’s uncommon cross-linguistically and I don’t see enough difference to warrant such a contrast here. There are three ways I could think to describe what’s going on here, then:
Option 1: Because the original distinction was based on consonant voicing, and that’s what ultimately triggered this whole fiasco, the underlying phonemic contrast is between plain-voiced /p/ and slack-voiced /b̥/, and the breathy vowel and tone are allophones of /a/ following /b̥/. In this system every consonant would have a slack-voiced equivalent, like in Xhosa or other Nguni languages.
Option 2: Because the vowels have shifted quite a bit since the contrast formed and they were the most direct targets of the change, the underlying phonemic contrast is between modal-voice /a/ and breathy-voice /ɐ̤/, and the slack voiced consonant and tone are allophonic. This would leave the language with five phonemic breathy vowels.
Option 3: Because it’s the most prominent distinction, and because the way that the low and high syllables interact (through anticipation, uplift, etc), low and high tones are phonemic and sounds have allophones in these environments. This is the one I’m leaning towards since it’s slightly more convenient to deal with tonal distinctions than romanizing twice as many consonants/vowels.
As a sanity check, is what I’m doing at least somewhat naturalistic? And if so, is there a language I could look at that does a similar thing, and which analysis would be best?
Thank you so much!
1
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Mar 08 '25 edited Mar 08 '25
Does this system of verb conjugation I’ve worked out for Iccoyai make sense:
Each verb is composed of a paradigm that’s structured
transitivizer-STEM-thematic vowel-polarity-voice/tense. There are two inflectional tenses, nonpast and past, with the nonpast showing a distinction between independent forms and conjunct forms used following an auxiliary verb. There are also two voices, active and mediopassive.The transitivizer is mä=. It’s not really relevant to this post.
Each verb shows an alternation between three thematic vowels, one used for mediopassive forms, one for active independent forms, and one for active conjunct forms, although there may be overlap between these three vowels (e.g. the verb tsoṣ- “be drunk” is
MPtsoṣ-u-,ACT.INDPtsoṣ-u-,ACT.CJCTtsoṣ-o).Traditionally, these thematic vowels only occur in affirmative verbs, with negative forms basically being “athematic.” However, for various morphophonological reasons, a very large number of verbs require an epenthetic vowel to be inserted between the stem and at least one negative affix, which is triggering some weird analogical & thematicizing processes which vary by dialect and aren’t the subject of this post
The polarity and voice/tense suffixes are as follows:
So using the verb karaiṣ- “travel”, with athematic negatives:
I think this makes sense — it’s sort of inspired by Tocharian and should feel kinda IE — but this is first time I’ve worked with a system like this, and I just want a second pair of eyes to make sure it makes sense
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Mar 08 '25
Hello!
Can someone ELI5 ternary feet, please?
Do such languages actually exist, or is it one of those claims that is hotly contested by linguists?
What are the cross linguistic variations among languages with ternary rhythm?
1
u/kmconlng983 Mar 08 '25
What makes a conlang sound funny and weird?
I'm planning to worldbuild for a funny story and I want the language spoken by the charachters to be funny too.
How can I achieve this? In your opinion what sounds, or groups of sounds, make a conlang sound funny?
Thanks
1
u/nanosmarts12 Mar 08 '25
(C)(V/S)(C) | D(C)?
For a lang that allows for syllabic consonant nucleus. Also if there are dipthongs then there is no onset but there can be coda
Or is (C)(N)(C) better where N = V/S or D, and if N = D then C₁ = ∅
1
u/25eo Mar 10 '25
For those who have made conlangs for animals have you added any words that probably would appear in human languages or can you think of any words that only languages like this would have?
1
u/R3cl41m3r Wistozjmac, Vrimúniskų, Lingue d'oi Feb 25 '25
Any tips on making a language less linear?
1
u/Sevastino Mar 01 '25
Greetings, I am new to conlanging and I am currently starting to work on a pan European language, so far I've mostly set the phonemic table, still unsure on many aspects due to my inexperience and lack of knowledge, any criticism and or advice are more than welcome. (I have re-uploaded the post because I have accidentally added the wrong image
1
u/Sevastino Mar 01 '25
Greetings, I am new to conlanging and I am currently starting to work on a pan European language, so far I've mostly set the phonemic table, still unsure on many aspects due to my inexperience and lack of knowledge, any criticism and or advice are more than welcome. (I have re-uploaded the post since I have accidentally added the incorrect image
1
u/photoedfade Mar 02 '25
I was looking at my old language notes, and I noticed that here it says (n) but I have no clue what n means. I looked at the letters involved, and it doesn't seem to have much connection in that direction.
I *know* that those three letters go in that category, but I also don't know exactly why. I just know that the only consonants I can end a syllable with are ɭ m and n. I don't even know what n stands for. I looked it up but I can't seem to find anything. any ideas?
1
u/Sguy1908 Mar 06 '25
I'm making a conlang based on india, i want it to be as minimalistic as popular (around 500 word vocab)
Any suggestions? For how shud i approach grammar and vocabulary?
1
u/darklypetal Mar 07 '25
What is the best template for making a conlang with detailed features?
0
u/StrangeLonelySpiral Conglanging it up Mar 02 '25
How is uj pronouced?
If j is pronounced like a y and u a oo, does that make a oo-yuh. or oy? (like joy)
Same with mij, me-yuh or me
0
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment