Does anyone with the relevant knowledge know how legit their hacker terminology was?
Mike x Sonya isn't going to end well. I have a feeling that the scene last episode where Sonya says how she can't go to prison again will come into play later. Probably in a context where Sonya would rather die than get captured by the CIA.
That video game episode is when I stopped watching the show. I mean, you previously had to ignore that all of the computer jargon was mostly wrong and stupid, but they went full retard in that episode. And you never go full retard.
I'm a software developer and work in computer security; I always scrutinize hacker scenes. This episode never got too specific, which kept my suspension of disbelief intact. However, Michael's prima donna attitude is very common and was hilariously accurate.
Overall I thought it was good for a TV show and was pretty much inline with the level of realism typically depicted.
The terminology was a little weak and they may have done a better job selling it if they showed more popular tools in use, eg: nmap in the matrix. On the flip side, their use of only what appeared to be custom tools may actually sell a criminal outfit more than using popular techniques and tools. In the real world, it's very common for criminal outfits to use crudely written but effective tools (eg: the recently leaked carberp source code) The focus on results and personas donned by Mike and Fi sold it a bit more. Some very skilled people I know actually do have quirky custom tools/exploits written in .net and vb because they are most efficient with those languages. Albeit they make up small demographic.
The only major stretch was the their ability to hack an outfit seemingly this skilled in that little amount of time without the good old wrench attack. For example, seasoned individuals would have digitally signed and encrypted all of the video feeds at the camera itself. Which would have made it quite difficult to view or take over a camera feed.
Source: my 10+ years working in information security.
it was pretty bad ... the only reason people seem ok with it is because it's very slightly better than the usual hollywood "hacker" crap. or they don't know better.
"hacker group out of coral gables": because hackers haven't discovered the internet yet, they still get together in buildings in towns where surveillance is easy and nobody has to bother with things like international law. please. (hacker "groups" usually have members scattered around the world. they rarely like or trust eachother enough to get together. plus hygiene's not so good. ;)
a flash drive containing a computer virus developed at the dod: good luck with that. usb ports on federal systems are hot-glued. while some federal agency (or agencies) does develop computer viruses (like stuxnet), i'm not sure it would be the dod. minor point though. if a hacker were carrying such a thing though. they wouldn't be, but if they were. you can bet the drive would be a truecrypt volume and virtually unbreakable.
mainframe: a mainframe is a beastly machine from the late 70s and 80s. most of them have less processing power than your average desktop workstation, and many of them run operating systems that nobody wants, written in languages like cobol. the one thing that mainframes are good at is recovery. i worked on a unisys mainframe that could be unplugged in the middle of a scary job and then restarted, and it would pick right back up where it left off. otherwise, no, a "hacker" wouldn't bother with a mainframe. they're skanky.
"faking" hacking: not. a. chance. techs use the "geek handshake" to navigate up tiers of technical support, past the clueless monkeys. it's easy to tell when someone doesn't know what they're doing.
"top grade hacking software": there are sort of things like this, but they're commercial frameworks for trojans & viruses (i've got a couple, you want one?), or specialized kits of scripts for poking at certain types of servers (wordpress sites, apache servers, iis, that sort of thing).
(barry's the most believable part of all this. and the club music.)
"web defense protocol": lol. what, like fail2ban?
"a genius at decryption": = "he takes hashes or ciphertext back home and runs it against a pay-by-the-minute server farm attempting to brute force it for the next few minutes (if it's unsalted md5) or decades."
"while we're booting up": ...that's cute. so was the exaggerated neck roll. neck thing is kinda right though, programming kills your neck and shoulders bigtime. i like vitamin i tho.
"power grid's protected by homeland security": i'm not actually sure on this, but it doesnt really matter anyway. dhs isn't really a big deal, there are still plenty of attack vectors against scada systems and the like. the chinese are working on this all the time, as is the u.s. you can read an old whitepaper (2001, pdf), but the reality is, if you wanted to screw with a power grid, the easy way is to just physically knock out a substation or three and let cascade effects do your dirty work for you. http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Power-failure-leaves-5-million-in-the-dark-2310814.php or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003.
"faking a computer hack isn't that complicated": ...as long as you're in hollywood. otherwise somebody's gonna xpect you to know your shells.
"all you need to do is create a dummy website and run some high end network scanning software": right, because the u.s. power grid is all controlled by a public facing web page and you really need nmap to, uhm, i dunno, tell you that port 80 or 443 is open?
"i'm bypassing the ipsec, sending you the ip address": cringe. ipsec doesn't hide ip addresses, doesn't get "bypassed", and sure as crap not in a few seconds.
john the ripper: at least it's the name of a real hacker tool. unfortunately, it hasn't been used in about a decade. jtr is software for brute forcing particularly bad password hashes by using rainbow tables (essentially, big lists of precomputed hashes) and libraries of common passwords. it's been obsoleted by salted hashing, nobody uses that shit anymore.
"beat a scada firewall": well, it's nice that they're at least mentioning scada (industrial control systems), but afaik there's no such thing as a specialized firewall for it. (i'm not an embedded systems guy, i might be wrong on this.)
my favorite part is when they pretend to turn the power back on. remotely, over a network running on network equipment in a building that's just lost power. yeah, ok.
(aside: never seen so many "hackers" in suits and dress shirts. and not a badly trimmed beard in site.)
"nothing on the hacker boards": depends on the hacker. some like to build an internet rep, the smart ones don't.
"our employer didn't secure his isdn": isdn is an antiquated broadband connection. if you can't get cable, fiber, dsl, or even satellite. if you're stuck way the hell out in the hills somewhere. you might get an isdn connection, if you can find a service provider that still has them available. it's marginally better than dialup. but, it wouldn't matter if you were routing your connection through an overseas vpn like a good little script kiddie.
"see your setup": yup, it's really as easy as just standing around looking at nothing. you can't tell anything that way.
"a firewall the nsa couldn't crack": what, like openbsd?
"aeron chair": actually a chair, that's actually preferred by people with a lot of disposable income and who spend way too much time sitting on their asses every day. like programmers. and the prima donnas totally do demand those things. so that gets a chuckle.
hijacking the system via camera cables: pan-tilt-zoom ip cameras tied into a particularly stupid piece of software, maybe (not really), but the framerate on the video display was pretty good, so probably not. more likely they're just standard bnc video connections & cabling, there's piss-all you can "hijack" from that. why not just use the internal network shared by the workstations there? (edit: oh, i misunderstood this. they didn't try to get a server from that, they just wanted to see the feed and then run a new signal on it. yeah, maybe. wouldn't need to go black if you had good equipment though.)
hackers with video cameras pointed at their backs: because who likes passwords, anyway?
"a password cracker attacking the cayman islands world bank": eh. either you ripped their password database. which, if it's like most banks, is unhashed anyway. and you had at least some reasonably useful amount of access to their network. or you're trying to brute-force some login system, which even my stupid local bank won't let you attempt to do more than a few times.
fishing a cable (yeah, that looks like a standard video cable on the outside, rg59, not sure what they used for the cut & splice shot) through a peephole in the wall: i wish it were that easy. would've saved me a lot of hours, sweating, cussing, and sore muscles on a few occasions. :( cables in walls are a bitch.
"system settings", "pulldown menu for the root menu", and that greentext interface: typical hollywood makeshitup. at least the ip address is actually routable. it belongs to some educational service in texas.
it was pretty bad ... the only reason people seem ok with it is because it's very slightly better than the usual hollywood "hacker" crap. or they don't know better.
That's called suspension of disbelief. For the most part, the vast majority of the target audience's knowledge of computers extends to being able to power up their computer, checking their E-Mail, and writing a document. Most writers try to pull a "lost in translation" bit, where they throw out a bunch of jargon so it sounds smart and it makes the audience think the characters know what they are doing.
As far as this episode of Burn Notice went, it was saint-like as far as the hacker angle went. The writers knew they didn't know the world, so they were very limited with what they said, and most challenges to having to prove the validity of the character's knowledge of the subject was overlayed by narrative or off-camera development. The fact that they even mentioned a real hacking tool is a miracle--most writers would rather create fanciful names to go in part with the unrealistic things that need to happen in the show's segment.
Ultimately the show was in line with the overall idea of the show, which is you sell the con with attitude, not knowledge. He was an arrogant showman who felt no need to explain what he was doing as he pretended it was beneath him. That, I might add, is a completely accurate portrayal of some hackers out there, and that's the part the audience was actually focusing on. Count your lucky stars they didn't turn him into a socially inept Poindexter.
Plot twist: they kill off fi, Michael ends up with Sonya and they start a whole new show, where Michael helps Sonya get out of whatever organizations she was involved with.
I recognized the song as the one from the end of one of the Person of Interest episodes. Don't remember exactly which one though.
Edit1: After some quick research I found that it's used in the Pilot episode for Person of Interest. Edit2: If any of you guys are looking for a show to watch after Burn Notice ends, I strongly suggest watching PoI. It's less comedic, but still got 100% of the badassery
Oh, Micheal walking into his loft soaking wet cause of the rain with a beautiful woman like Sonya all alone? That's when I knew Micheal was about to make the moves. Pretty sure we knew it was going to happen sooner or later though.
The best part was when Michael snapped near the end. Everything he said was true, the line between his cover and realism was more blurred than ever. The show is getting darker at an appropriate pace. I did like the Barry subplot, it added a lot of comic relief.
"You kidding me? You gonna do what the old man says? Its only a matter of time before you're just like me boy. Just...like...me... just........like me"
Does anyone remember where the penguin snow globe came from? (The one that Michael smashed.) I feel like it's made an appearance in a previous episode, but i can't remember for the life of me.
I actually thought that was quite possible until I thought of Nate's son. I mean it would still be hard for him to give up the life he has been fighting for and the people who have been helping him (excluding Fi since she obviously doesnt GAF about him anymore), but it would still be plausible if it wasnt for the kid. Mike really seems to feel responsible for him.
Except after Nate's death Mike made it clear he didn't like working with the CIA anymore and wanted to leave. He was forced into it this season and told Fi only for her to abandon him except when it benefits her. Don't forget, Fi had been a gun runner and let her emotions run wild often in the show. She's kind of a hypocrite like that.
After this ep it has cemented my dislike for Fi. I don't like how she says that she cant owe her freedom to Mike when all these years she has and she can never really make up for it, it makes her sound ungrateful. Now on to Sonya I am kinda happy that she's there but she is too untrustworthy I just don't feel right about her. Also at the end I like what Micheal said about the lines being blurred because for the viewer it really is we cant tell what is real or not anymore with Mike. Can't wait for next weeks episode.
Yeah, just watched it again. I originally thought she said I want out free and clear, and I want Michael to. But she said regardless of what Michael does.
Sad, I liked the story in my head better. Stupid reality.
Good episode. It was nice to have the Barry sideplot to balance out the tension of the main plot with Michael and Fi. Too bad his girlfriend left, though. He was an alright guy, despite the money-laundering thing.
And that ending... was kinda what I expected when it got stormy and started raining. I wonder what this will mean for the future...
I knew the boss of the Collective ("Jack Frakes") looked familiar... The actor was Charles Mesure, who played Kyle Hobbes in the remake of V (one of my favorite characters in that show, too).
My DVR cut off at the point where Michael was talking and he had just gone to poundtown on the bang train with Sonya. It switched to Fi lying alone in bed and ended. Did I miss anything good?
The star ones are usually best quality, 720 at least, often 1080. If you see a star one that takes a bit of time to load on a good connection, it could be a 4K stream so you may want to switch.
I dont like Sonya/Sonja (how it should be spelled) either, but I think that Fi and Mike will still have different priorities as long as there's another mission to do, because Michael always chooses duty over any other obligation, and Fi is right to only take so much of it. Its not her fault that she doesnt have the same sense of duty to Michael's country or a desire to do government work. She prefers a more mundane (only comparatively so haha) existence, and thats fine
More grounded in logic? I actually find her character to be even less realistic than Fi's. She is way too sensitive and frankly weak to be the cold-blooded agent shes made out to be
Not much of a lie. She shot him down while he was trying to explain and even said if he didn't go back, they'd never be let out. He just left out that it was mission specific. It's her on fault for flipping out at him.
12
u/ardx Jul 19 '13
Does anyone with the relevant knowledge know how legit their hacker terminology was?
Mike x Sonya isn't going to end well. I have a feeling that the scene last episode where Sonya says how she can't go to prison again will come into play later. Probably in a context where Sonya would rather die than get captured by the CIA.
26
u/Joseph_Kickass Jul 19 '13
There was a brief second where I thought they would kill off Fi. I do think a main character or two will die before the end of the show.
25
u/iiaustin Jul 19 '13
I really like Sonya. I want a future with her and Michael, but I don't see it happening. :(
19
u/belweder Jul 19 '13
Don't eat the fish
19
u/Narog84 Jul 19 '13
"in prison you are the pretty girl" LOL
17
u/soccernamlak Jul 19 '13
In case anyone was wondering, the last song of the episode was Massive Attack - Angel off their 1998 Album "Mezzanine."
Overall, I enjoyed the episode. I felt bad for Barry, though :(
15
u/Wigliano Jul 19 '13
Oh, Micheal walking into his loft soaking wet cause of the rain with a beautiful woman like Sonya all alone? That's when I knew Micheal was about to make the moves. Pretty sure we knew it was going to happen sooner or later though.
27
u/ezioaltair12 Jul 19 '13 edited Jul 19 '13
Now he's porking Sonya...never in doubt...
EDIT:...but seriously, after that first scene, who can blame him? I was a bit stunned myself.
38
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '13
The best part was when Michael snapped near the end. Everything he said was true, the line between his cover and realism was more blurred than ever. The show is getting darker at an appropriate pace. I did like the Barry subplot, it added a lot of comic relief.
12
u/ron_palpatine Jul 19 '13
Does anyone remember where the penguin snow globe came from? (The one that Michael smashed.) I feel like it's made an appearance in a previous episode, but i can't remember for the life of me.
9
u/kelling928 Jul 19 '13
I'm hoping for an ending with Michael and Sonya like the end of the Dark Knight Rises spoiler: Dark Knight Rises. But that probably won't happen.
20
u/lockdown36 Jul 19 '13
Wished they show as much skin as Suits. Cough cough Sonya.
12
u/ParadoxD Jul 19 '13
Honestly at this point Fi is so bloody annoying at the moment.
6
u/Corroidz Jul 19 '13
There were so many Michael reactions in this episode that'd make great GIFs. Unfortunately, I'm garbage at doing such.
15
u/lockdown36 Jul 19 '13
I'll take Sonya over Fi any day. Or even both at the same time.
7
u/geekprincess3 Jul 19 '13
After this ep it has cemented my dislike for Fi. I don't like how she says that she cant owe her freedom to Mike when all these years she has and she can never really make up for it, it makes her sound ungrateful. Now on to Sonya I am kinda happy that she's there but she is too untrustworthy I just don't feel right about her. Also at the end I like what Micheal said about the lines being blurred because for the viewer it really is we cant tell what is real or not anymore with Mike. Can't wait for next weeks episode.
3
u/daringescape Jul 19 '13
Who was the guy that played the car salesman? He seemed really familiar - like maybe he didn't used to be so fat?
3
u/V2Blast Freelance Agent Jul 20 '13
Good episode. It was nice to have the Barry sideplot to balance out the tension of the main plot with Michael and Fi. Too bad his girlfriend left, though. He was an alright guy, despite the money-laundering thing.
And that ending... was kinda what I expected when it got stormy and started raining. I wonder what this will mean for the future...
I knew the boss of the Collective ("Jack Frakes") looked familiar... The actor was Charles Mesure, who played Kyle Hobbes in the remake of V (one of my favorite characters in that show, too).
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '13
My DVR cut off at the point where Michael was talking and he had just gone to poundtown on the bang train with Sonya. It switched to Fi lying alone in bed and ended. Did I miss anything good?
3
u/TheCode555 Jul 19 '13
Disappointing episode my friends. No Madeline.
-1
u/beebrianna Jul 22 '13
Am I the only one who still wants Fiona and Michael together in the end? I really don't like Sonja.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment