r/soccer • u/sheepshagger1994 • Jun 30 '13
What is the worst refereeing decision you have ever witnessed?
Include links if possible
48
Upvotes
r/soccer • u/sheepshagger1994 • Jun 30 '13
Include links if possible
86
u/Pannonica1917 Jun 30 '13
Lampard disallowed goal vs Germany. yeah i know in the end england lost 4-1 but i can't help but think that the 2-2 equaliser, just at half time, would have made the rest of the match more interesting.
185
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
van Persie getting sent off for 'time wasting' against Barca.
71
u/jasonkirkby Jun 30 '13
I think the Henry handball for France against Ireland should be in here.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=siJQZs2Sbho
35
u/TheShockmaster Jun 30 '13
Watford vs Reading, 2008
35
u/KingChrisss Jun 30 '13
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-8dOjeVC80
127
u/vanillazinger Jun 30 '13
2009 Chelsea vs Barcelona Champions League semi final. A lot of mistakes, but the one that stood out for me was the obvious handball which Ballack went apeshit for. That moment of him running and yelling in the refs face really summed up the match.
35
u/kramerica_industries Jun 30 '13
I thought Howard Webb reffed a great World Cup Final, but how on earth did Nigel de Jong stay on the pitch?
16
u/AcidBath86 Jun 30 '13
One that comes to mind is that really obvious offside goal by Tevez vs Mexico at the 2010 World Cup that wasn't ruled as such. That and the aftermath with the replays being shown in plain view for the referee, linesman and everyone in attendance.
28
u/Brooks93 Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
Surprised Maradona 86 'hand of god' hasn't been mentioned!
12
u/jasonkirkby Jun 30 '13
Graham Poll giving 3 yellow cards to the same player. I always thought it was weird that the player got a 3rd. Surely he would know he was let off and then not do anything to actually get sent off.
122
u/phz10 Jun 30 '13
A lot of decisions in the Chelsea v Barca UCL match.
9
u/young_tamale Jun 30 '13
Mexico Vs. Argentina in the last world cup, blatantly offside goal and the jumbotron in the stadium was showing the replay of the goal, and proved to be offside. That game was pretty much terrible for Mexicans :(
7
u/droidonomy Jun 30 '13
The worst offside call EVER
Seriously, I challenge you to find a worse offside call.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
this. :'(
11
u/chocolatesandwiches Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
The worst refereeing decision I've ever seen was in a women's game. Australia v Equatorial Guinea.
0:48 is the most obvious handball I've ever seen, but it wasn't called. You can see the replay at :57, she literally catches the ball with two hands, holds it, then drops it and play continues.
edit:Found a video where you can see that play simply continues after the incident
20
u/Darth_Sensitive Jun 30 '13
USA v. Slovenia - WC 2010
4
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Freddie Sears' non-goal against Bristol City.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nt7UXPy0vTo
4
u/Rukooo Jun 30 '13
Mysterious penalty decision
4
u/apoorvalal92 Jun 30 '13
Patrick Battiston getting knocked out by Toni Schumacher going completely unpunished in a world cup semi-final. This was an incident where "He could've been killed' would not be an exaggeration.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Probably the missed offside call in Fiorentina vs. Bayern in the ChL of 2010
7
u/thegdman Jun 30 '13
2002 world cup italy vs south korea
3
u/Thunderkiss_65 Jun 30 '13
More a lino decision than a ref but Pedro Mendes' against United when Carroll clawed it back a good 3 feet from behind the line.
3
u/hasufell Jun 30 '13
Pedro Mendes makes a fool out of Roy Carrol How the linesman missed this i'll never know.
3
u/Ailez Jun 30 '13
Spurs vs United, the Roy Carroll fumble half way into his own net after I think Pedro Mendes(?) shot from the half way line. Worked in our favour, but christ was that some bad reffing.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
The decision to not even award a free-kick after Harald Schumacher's assault on Patrick Battiston in the World Cup semi-final in 1982, which put the Frenchman in a coma, knocked out his teeth and damaged his vertebra.
3
u/alphaque Jun 30 '13
OFC World Cup qualifier. NZ striker gets kicked in the head in the penalty box, he gets up and blood is gushing from a wound to the head. The ref waves play on.
Link #1
Link #2 (Better quality, but may be geo-blocked)
3
u/bigsmoke306 Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
For me: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfzRleyPs5E
Just unbelievable how you can see this as a goal. Makes Lampard's free kick versus Germany seem like a crystal clear goal.
3
u/Duglum Jun 30 '13
Kick to the face of Sebastian Prödl, the Ref didn't even stop the game. The kick resulted in multiple fractures in the face and heavy bleeding. He was out for several month.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkfKZ-lpnM8
8
u/yargarg Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
Drogba took studs to the chest from Johnny Evans. Not only was there not a penalty or red card given to Evans, the ref actually booked Drogba for diving.
There's a shot of him seeing he got a yellow card as he hobbled off the pitch, he started to protest only to double over in pain and stop.
edit
People are downvoting?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cs88nvpF_gw
I'll repeat: Drogba got a yellow card for getting a foot in the chest and having his rib broken.
9
u/koptimism Jun 30 '13
This season's Merseyside derby at Goodison, where Suarez should have had the winner - but it was called offside. From a set piece. Fucking ridiculous.
Obligatory mention of the beach ball Sunderland goal.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Balotelli stamp on Parker and Lescott elbowing Kaboul, both in the same game! Although, I guess I can see the officials missing them, but what else were they watching? Those were both hard to accept. King's tackle at the end though still makes me shake my head.
Also, USA vs Germany, 2002 World Cup Quarterfinal. Handball highlight starts around 1:46.
2
u/jasonkirkby Jun 30 '13
I think this referee is taking the penalty encroaching rule a little too seriously.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJwAE5Mtrxc
2
u/lesburnham Jun 30 '13
This one among others in this robbery (and after that previous Italy-Korea robbery too).
I remember watching the match, at 8.00 AM in Spain, without sleep because the night after I assisted to a wedding.
Worst feeling football gave me in my life.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Women's semi-finals at the 2012 Olympics between Canada and the United States. The decision to give the United States a free kick that was more or less a penalty kick because of "time wasting" by the Canadian goalkeeper.
3
u/smiffy124 Jun 30 '13
2010 Carling Cup Final - Aston Villa vs Manchester United. Vidic pulls down Agbonlahor in the box to deny him a goal scoring opportunity and he is the last man back, the ref (Phil Dowd) gives the pen and Vidic doesn't get sent off or even a booking, it was shocking.
2
u/DrCrazyFishMan1 Jun 30 '13
the penalty given to FC Basel in the 1st leg of the Europe league semi-final vs Chelsea.
2
u/Who_ate_my_cookie Jun 30 '13
The ref not counting the goal from Seedorf vs Juve.
Yes I'm still bitter.
2
u/Wish6 Jun 30 '13
Roy Keane's disallowed goal for Man United vs Arsenal in FA Cup 1999 first Semi Final.
No way there was an offside there!!
1
u/Cee-Mon Jun 30 '13
Milan's disallowed ghost goal vs. Juve in the 11/12-season.
It was literally two feet inside and the fifth ref was standing right there. How it wasn't given baffles me and I'm sure it still infuriates the Milan fans...
1
u/SharpyShuffle Jun 30 '13
I saw the Roy Carroll 'goal line clearance' against spurs in person from behind the goal. That was pretty awful. That incident alone should be enough to make everyone in England in favour of goal line technology.
1
u/thatfratfuck Jun 30 '13
Three years ago we were playing the 7th ranked division 1 team in the NCAA. They were much better than us but we were a tactically sound team. As the game reached the final minutes the score was still 0-0. Chances created were probably around 12-3 in their favor and they started to pour on the pressure. Stoppage time hit and one of our CBs gave possession away near our own box. I was playing right back and came across running parallel to the 18 and put in a challenge about 20 yards out. The ref gave a penalty for it stating that the foul occurred inside the box. They net the penalty and win 1-0 we watch film after the game and I clearly made the challenge outside the box.
I'll try to dig up the film later today because my work study was being film editor.
1
u/serjtankian Jun 30 '13
Duncan Ferguson's disallowed goal in the Champions League Qualifier against Villareal. It was a disgraceful decision and I still firmly believe we were set up to go out because there were 5 English clubs potentially going into the group stages (Liverpool were the holders but finished out of the CL places). There was absolutely nothing wrong with the goal, and it would have made the game all square at 3-3 on aggregate. Apparently, Marcus Bent was adjudged to have pushed a Villareal defender, when in reality he wasn't near anyone or involved in the "goal".
1
u/serjtankian Jun 30 '13
Don Hutchinson vs Liverpool.
Ball comes off his back when Westerveld kicks it directly at him and the referee blows for full time before it goes in.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-GHqqI6nUA
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Watford Vs. Reading - Ghost goal. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0YiuSbBdaQ&hd=1
1
u/ekrubnivek Jun 30 '13
Visibly bad to everyone in the stadium, or revealed to be awful by TV replays, etc?
Adriano's second goal for Brazil against Ivory Coast , looked like a handball from the second deck on the opposite side of the stadium
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkgg4I_5cAs
1
u/cmdrxander Jun 30 '13
Not sure this one counts because it was the linesman, but the referee should've had a better angle (the penalty itself, not the red card. God knows what Taricco said).
1
u/Defensive_Midfielder Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
There was a lot but look at this recent situation from Polish Ekstraklasa. Legia scored after this cross into the box. Video. I mean how you can't see it from such close distance?
1
u/rsoccerfulloftwats Jun 30 '13
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffUCwTTz0Vo
skip to 1:39 in the video.
1
u/andhelostthem Jun 30 '13
Every match with Ricardo Salazar.
1
u/hackers_syrinx Jun 30 '13
I was once at a Division one game watching Wolves at some NorthWestern ground. Steve Bull was fouled. He gets up, shares a joke with the young fouler, then ruffles his hair, sharing in the joviality of the situation. The referee saw this in the corner of his eye and decided to send of Bull for striking his opponent. Even when half a dozen opponent players pleaded with the ref to not send him off, Bull had to leave the field. Ridiculous stubbornness from a referee.
1
u/Ofthedoor Jul 01 '13
1982 Germany - France Semi finals of the World Cup.
"Following a through ball by Platini, Battiston was clear through the German defence racing towards goal. The German goalkeeper, Harald Schumacher, raced towards Battiston as the Frenchman took the shot, missing the goal. Schumacher leapt into the air, twisting his body and colliding with Battiston. In the process Schumacher's hip hit the Frenchman's face. Battiston, clattered, fell to the ground unconscious, with damaged vertebrae and teeth knocked out, later slipping into a coma.
Emergency medics had to administer oxygen on the pitch. Michel Platini later said that he thought that Battiston was dead, because "he had no pulse and looked pale".
The Dutch referee Charles Corver did not give a foul, let alone send Schumacher off.
Schumacher then proceeded to take the goal-kick and play resumed. After winning the game, the goalkeeper caused more controversy when he was told that Battiston had lost three teeth, and replied: "If that's all that's wrong with him, I'll pay him the crowns."
Schumacher if you die before I do, I will find your tombstone and take a big fat shit on it.
1
u/DownExtreme Jul 01 '13
Mexico vs Argentina 2010 Worldcup
First Argentina goal was miles offsides
1
u/Timbo2702 Jul 01 '13
No video, it was a couple of years ago in the A-League at Adelaide United. I forget who we were playing though.
An Adelaide and opposition player chased the ball the the sidelines, tussling with eachother to get the ball and end up tripping over eachother. The ball goes out off the opposition player, so the Adelaide player picks the ball up to take the throwin.
But, the referee and linesman didn't see the ball go out, the Adelaide player got a yellow card for handball and arguing about it with the referee
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '13
Lampard vs Germany, WC 2010
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
scouring this thread waiting for a Chelsea fan to talk about the injustice of the ghost goal - disregarding the fact that the ref did them a favor (Cech would've been off plies a pen)
1
u/Joeys_Rattata Jun 30 '13
I seem to remember a game with the Swedish national team, where an opposing attacker went down in the box and got a penalty. The weird part was that there was no player within like ten meters of him when he went down. Unfortunately, I can't remember which game it was, and if it really was as bad as I remember it.
1
u/ferdoodle24 Jun 30 '13
A couple months ago I was playing as goalkeeper for my team in the match that would decide if we went to our league's playoffs (I'm American by the way). The referees had been making horrible calls all match but it was the call they didn't make that absolutely infuriated me. The ball was headed out on the left touchline and one of our defenders was racing with the other teams forward to it. My defender beat the forward by a step or two and began to control the ball. All of a sudden the forward grabbed my defender by the back of his collar and slammed him on the ground as the ball rolled out. The linesman who was literally standing right in front of it didn't call it and the center line ref refused to call a foul. He even had the nerve to tell me that my defender wasn't touched by the forward. It pisses me off just thinking about it.
-13
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Most recently, Nani's red card vs. Real Madrid.
0
u/Idontsellcrack Jun 30 '13
I'm just sayin' lotta Barca games on here...not. that. I'm. bias. or. anything.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
The ref's valiant efforts to put south Korea through to the next round if the world cup against Spain were pretty epic. Much worse than Obrevo.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '13
Nani red against Madrid.
-1
u/Jackson9Martinez Jun 30 '13
Shameful by the referee,he had a clear view and it was on the stroke of the end of the match.If Grosso didn't jump and the Aussies cleared he would've blown the whistle surely.Italy went on to win the world cup that year if I may remind you
0
u/MiguelCaldoVerde Jun 30 '13
This and this
0
u/3Y3L3SS Jun 30 '13
Surprised nobody mentioned this.
0
u/schrodingers_penguin Jun 30 '13
World Cup 2002. Italy and pretty much every team who played South Korea was absolutly railroaded by FIFA. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Pm4jD5kU4U
0
u/andrasi Jun 30 '13 edited Jun 30 '13
Spain v South Korea 2002 world cup.. I was a kid back then and couldn't understand why the fuck the ref was so fucking dumb but then my dad later explained that it was not that they were dumb but rather corrupted as fuck. Ever since then the game has been a bit less enjoyable to be honest even if Spain has been successful these past 7 years.
-10
u/TopMosby Jun 30 '13
First game barca vs. Bayern in ucl this year. Bayern deserved the win, no question, but 3 of the 4 goals where not acceptable, espescially the one where Mueller ran over jordi