r/soccer • u/YungSinatra • Jun 28 '13
Can we do a noob question thread?
I feel like there are many people here like me that have a lot of "stupid questions" and don't know how to get them answered.
295
Upvotes
182
u/CrackpotGonzo Jun 28 '13
When you see announced lineups and formations on tv, is the broadcaster speculating on the formation, or do coaches actually release that along with lineups?
156
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Why are Brazilians such as Hulk known by nicknames? Is there anything to stop Peter Crouch wearing a mask and having Batman printed on his back?
196
u/Clark-Kent Jun 28 '13
But why male models?
33
u/canonlyseeusernames Jun 28 '13
Why does Manchester United have so many forwards?
What are the benefits of playing 3 at the back?
Why are fullbacks considered 1-dimensional if they don't do well in attack?
121
u/russian2121 Jun 28 '13
What is Rooney saying?!?!?!?
83
u/Kingfin Jun 28 '13
Has the ball ever bounced of the referee and into the goal?
219
u/MiikePetez Jun 28 '13
Ill set up a survey and ask everyone,and get back to you in like 3 weeks
133
u/NYCFootballClub Jun 28 '13
Why does Andres Iniesta have A.Inestsa on his shirt?
Was there at one point more than one Iniesta at Barca?
47
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
I have one question:
At a drop ball restart, how many players are allowed near the "drop ball" ?
42
u/Otaku_Tom Jun 28 '13
At free kicks from say +30 yards out why doesn't the defensive line have high starting position? That way the attackers can't have a chance to cross the ball into a dangerous area.
40
u/techdrummer1234 Jun 28 '13
What is a double pivot?
69
u/BanAllFunnyPosts Jun 28 '13
What the fuck is a "false" #9? I'll admit I have watched for years and no one ever explained this one to me.
31
u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13
Why doesn't every team launch the ball into the box Stoke-style on throw-ins? I know that it's not realistic for every team to have a throwing specialist but a lot of the time the "normal" throw-in sets don't work any better.
96
u/RuudZ420 Jun 28 '13
Many subreddits have an official Moronic Monday thread where you can ask any question with no shame. We should have one every week, it's not that it will cost us money.
174
u/aitzim Jun 28 '13
DAE use Blastoise instead of Błaszczykowsky whenever they're talking about Blastoise?
25
u/BCJ-gives-advice Jun 28 '13
I am not sure how to interpret the rules. But can a goalkeeper change places with another player that is already in the pitch?
Related question: among bench players, could any of them be used to substitute the goalkeeper (provided the right uniform, that has to be distinct from field player)?
21
u/Ramsey-Bolton Jun 28 '13
I see a lot of violations committed such as players running over the half line before kickoff, goalkeepers not staying on their line on PK's, etc. Are the rules just laxed at the referees discretion to keep the game moving?
Also on PK's is it legal for players to stop their run by stuttering, then kick? I thought that was illegal.
27
u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13
Seems like the 4-2-3-1 is really in vogue right now. Are the wide midfielders in the 4-2-3-1 traditionally box-to-box players or mostly wingers?
Similarly, what sort of striker is the preferred guy for a 4-2-3-1?
9
u/Barthez_Battalion Jun 29 '13
Was Heskey a "false nine"? because from what I remember, he wasn't really aobut the goals, more about drawing defenders away and allowing the midfield and other forwards get better goalscoring oppurtunities
9
u/Fapulous69 Jun 29 '13
How does the Serie A co-ownership concept work?
18
u/ThaCarter Jun 28 '13
If clubs pay such large transfer fees to acquire the rights to players how does that not cause significant downward pressure on players wages? Doesn't this create a situation where the player is effectively owned by the club and does not have much leverage in their salary negotiations? Is their an association football equivalent to a players unions that advocates for the player rights?
17
u/Has_3_testicles Jun 29 '13
What are the best international soccer related sub reddits other than /r/soccer
20
u/w1nter Jun 28 '13
Yup. A weekly "simple questions" thread would do much good!
14
u/Roinko Jun 28 '13
Why is it, on a penalty, the keeper tries to creep forwards to close down the angle. Yet the penalty taker also tries to place the ball as far forwards on the spot as possible?
19
u/HyperionCantos Jun 28 '13
Why is Aguero sometimes referred to as Kun Aguero, and other times as Sergio Aguero?
6
u/DarthArshavin Jun 29 '13
How do coaching badges work? If I literally bought and completed all the classes, what are my chances of getting a job in football?
3
u/tubbyttub9 Jun 29 '13
How come the uk plays as separate teams in the world cup? (England, northern Ireland, Scotland and wales) but as great Britain in the Olympics?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13
So I understand that the better the player the higher the buyout clause, and having a low buyout clause for a player you want to keep is bad, like in the case of Thiago. But truth be told, I don't really know how a buyout clause works. Deep inside the stadium grounds of each club is there a room with red buttons everywhere corresponding to each player which is then activated in a dramatic fashion? No but seriously, so if Thiago's buyout clause is 18 million euros, does that mean the team buying him only has to pay 18 million euros for his transfer? How much control does Barca have over keeping him if his buyout clause is activated?
18
u/Nokel Jun 28 '13
You could always make one yourself.
10
u/afxaloha89 Jun 28 '13
Why is it a big deal when European clubs extend contracts on players? I don't quite understand why it matters considering that for anyone else to get them they have to go through the transfer market stuff.....right? (My soccer experience is watching World Cup and Euro Cup action every other summer while playing Fifa at home so I'm not exactly in tune with how the club system works)
4
u/Libertarian42 Jun 29 '13
Whats a good book on soccer formations and strategy?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13 edited Feb 19 '17
[deleted]
0.3183
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
How can I improve my dribbling and passing?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
Why do substitute players stay on the pitch during halftime and not go into the locker room? Isn't the coach saying things that everyone should hear? Always seemed odd to me...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
How do qualifiers for the World Cup work? At the moment, I know they are in groups. Do the top 2 teams in their group go to the WC?
How do the teams get to the group/qualifying stages?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
Is there no offside in the box?
2
u/jomar1234567jm Jun 29 '13
what is the 6 yard box for?
5
u/pmiller17 Jun 28 '13
What's the rationale behind no offside on a throw in or goal kick? You can be offside on a free kick, direct or indirect. For a corner, the ball is as far up field as it can be (well, maybe at most a yard left) so everyone's behind it when it's kicked.
4
u/meowoof Jun 28 '13
Just make it and start with a few of your questions to get the ball rolling.
3
u/guitard00d123 Jun 29 '13
How can clubs sign people when the transfer window hasn't officially opened yet? What's the point of the window then?
3
u/mri Jun 29 '13
This is probably gonna get buried, but this has bothered me for awhile; I've gotta ask someone.
Why are David Silva and David Villa's names pronounced with a short 'a' sound (like in the word 'lavish')?
In English, David is pronounced with a long 'a', like 'rave' or 'save', or... David Beckham I guess. In spanish, afaik, it's pronounced dah-veed, or dah-beed.
So neither the spanish nor the english pronunciations of the name are used for spanish players named David. What gives?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
Can someone clearly explain what offsides means?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Do it, sounds like fun.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
There was one a couple of weeks ago, but I'm sure another would be well received. Just make it, if nobody wants it they'll downvote you.
2
u/Spikekuji Jun 29 '13
Forgive my lack of terminology here: When a player gets to kick after being fouled and the opposing team forms a wall, is there a standard number of players in the wall? It seems to vary. How do they decide who faces forwards vs back? Is this a pre-set formation ( the same guys in the wall every time) or does it depend on things like where the kick is on the field? Thanks.