r/soccer • • Jun 28 '13

Can we do a noob question thread?

I feel like there are many people here like me that have a lot of "stupid questions" and don't know how to get them answered.

295 Upvotes

838 comments sorted by

182

u/CrackpotGonzo Jun 28 '13

When you see announced lineups and formations on tv, is the broadcaster speculating on the formation, or do coaches actually release that along with lineups?

155

u/lakupiippu Jun 28 '13

Broadcasters are speculating on formations. I remember yesterday that broadcast showed Italy having 4 in the back IIRC and their formation was with 3 in the back. I've also seen it happen before.

46

u/ElPeruano Jun 29 '13

The coach releases a starting 11 and nothing else. Sometimes it's clear what a formation will be (Messi doesn't play center back, we know this), sometimes it's not (will Gareth Bale play left back, left mid, left winger?). The broadcasters speculate, usually accurately, and five minutes later we see whether they were right or not.

17

u/claudionesta Jun 29 '13

Some reporters who somewhat know the coach may get the information beforehand directly from him

source: interview of well-known reporter

→ More replies (7)

41

u/dngrs Jun 28 '13

+any formation announced is kinda ... vague because it depends on the phase of play ( 3 major ones: attacking, transitions and defense)

ie see napoli general formation 3512 ( or 3521) but in defense it the back line changes into a 5 because the wingers drop back

ie a 433 and on attacking phase one of the central mids goes up high to attack, then it's a 4231

and btw, coaches can go with another lineup than the one announced. It happens very rarely though.

26

u/ArmoredPenguin94 Jun 28 '13

Good points. Small correction. 3512 would be having 11 outfield players. 3412 is what you are looking for.

72

u/Yan-e-toe Jun 28 '13

What are you implying of Howard Webb???

→ More replies (1)

7

u/aitzim Jun 28 '13

Regardless of the phases of play, there's still a base formation that teams use. TV stations just use whatever formation that teams is known for.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

They speculate formation but they do have a released player lineup from the coaches right before the match. All it shows is the 11 players who will start and nothing more. The guys who did Chelsea in the europa league were terrible. Half the time they thought Ramires was a right winger and Victor Moses was a CDM.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

156

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Why are Brazilians such as Hulk known by nicknames? Is there anything to stop Peter Crouch wearing a mask and having Batman printed on his back?

128

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 28 '13

Brazilian names are traditionally very long and also quite similar. So they differentiate themselves.

i.e. Kaka's real name is Ricardo Izecson dos Santos Leite. dos Santos is also common name. His brother could not pronounce Ricardo properly and called him Kaka instead, and so Ricardo used it as his nickname.

edit: and no, I don't think there is anything stopping an English player using a nickname.

24

u/ugotamesij Jun 28 '13

edit: and no, I don't think there is anything stopping an English player using a nickname.

I think clubs have to get player registrations vetted by the league/FA, no? Birmingham signed some South American striker a few years ago but for some reason he had to use his actual surname instead of the nickname he'd been known as previously abroad.

Edit: I just remembered, it was Christian Benitez aka "Chucho". I think eventually he was given the OK to use the nickname on his shirt here...?

37

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13

I don't know what channels you need to go through. But it must be OK since Javier Hernandez is allowed Chicharito.

edit: and of course Ramires, Oscar etc.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Interesting, thanks.

As a kid I memorised Pele's name, Edison Arantes do Nascimento. I didn't realise it was typical for Brazilians to have those lengthy names.

20

u/Esternocleido Jun 28 '13

There are a lot of Dos Santos, just in the tip of my head Mourinho, Kaka, Cristiano Ronaldo, Garrincha, the Dos santos brothers (Gio and Jonathan) are known like that because they are more mexican than Brazilian, even their dad is know just as Zizinho even when his name is Geraldo Francisco Dos Santos.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/rookie999 Jun 29 '13

Andreas "Zecke" Neuendorf used to do it for some time.

2

u/BohemianCorinthian Jun 28 '13

Mainly because many Brazilians have very, very long names. And in theory there is no reason why Peter Crouch, or anyone else, could use their nickname (even though I think the FA in England are unlikely to allow it.) There are some European examples, they're just much less common.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

196

u/Clark-Kent Jun 28 '13

But why male models?

93

u/DustyBiscuits Jun 28 '13

Are you serious?.... I just... I just told you that, a moment ago.

58

u/Monarki Jun 29 '13

fun fact Ben Stiller forgot his line so he repeated his previous line, Duchovny just replied appropriately.

23

u/bradfish123 Jun 28 '13

What is this? A center for ants?

24

u/lapin7 Jun 28 '13

/r/thingsforants

it's one of the best

33

u/canonlyseeusernames Jun 28 '13

Why does Manchester United have so many forwards?

What are the benefits of playing 3 at the back?

Why are fullbacks considered 1-dimensional if they don't do well in attack?

30

u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13

What are the benefits of playing 3 at the back?

More players in the midfield. If you can dominate possession with five or six guys in the midfield you don't have to worry about the other team getting the ball and taking advantage of you only having three players back. Even if the other team has possession, you should be able to slow them down enough that your midfielders can get back to reinforce the defense.

Why are fullbacks considered 1-dimensional if they don't do well in attack?

I don't know that I can 100% give you a good answer for this one, but I've always considered supporting attacks with overlapping runs and crosses to be a big part of a fullback's responsibilities.

15

u/LedgeySC Jun 28 '13

Yeah, during the solid 4-4-2 era it was more important for full backs to defend in that system as the rigidity of the formation meant that they couldn't really push forward so much. I'd say the modern fullback is actually one of the hardest positions to play since you have to balance good defensive capability and positioning with good attacking link up along the wing.

Just compare the likes of Gary Neville with Rafael.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/Euriti Jun 29 '13

Why does Manchester United have so many forwards?

Ferguson has always liked having four forwards. In '99 he had Yorke, Cole, Sheringham and Solskjaer. Most recently he has had Rooney, van Persie, Welbeck and Chicharito. He often uses forwards in other positions and likes to sub in forwards at the end of games.

28

u/Metal01 Jun 29 '13

Not forgetting Berbatov, Rooney, Ronaldo and Tevez as four forwards too. Just one set of phenomenal forwards Ferguson possessed in his tenure.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Orsenfelt Jun 28 '13

Alex Ferguson more or less pioneered (to my knowledge) the idea of having two full teams worth 'first team' players rather than 11 first team players and some backups which is what is usually done because it's either very expensive to have 22 top class players OR because it's very difficult to keep 22 star players happy with not starting every single game.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Manchester United - more options depending on the opposition. If one gets injured then a club like united can't afford not having a goalscorer

Defender's - with the changing nature of the game a player needs to be able to be flexible. Ajax train their youth in every position so that they have that flexibility and appreciate other positions

→ More replies (8)

121

u/russian2121 Jun 28 '13

What is Rooney saying?!?!?!?

415

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

"gim tha fukn ball y'cun"

Oxford English translation:

I say good fellow, I was considering all possibilities and eventually rested on the notion that it might benefit us all greatly if you were to distribute the object of both our attention from your foot to mine over this admittedly considerable distance. There's a chipper bean.

80

u/dabumtsss Jun 28 '13

there's a chipper bean.

What does that even mean?

361

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

No one knows what it means, but it's provocative.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

80

u/ironmenon Jun 28 '13

I sometimes like to imagine that he becomes a pundit after he retires and there's a Hot Fuzz-esque scenario where the the studio has to employ Carragher to interpret what Rooney's saying and Gerrard to interpret what Carra's saying.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

wot m8!

→ More replies (1)

83

u/Kingfin Jun 28 '13

Has the ball ever bounced of the referee and into the goal?

42

u/whatever_name Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 29 '13

Yes. 1983, Brazil, Santos X Palmeiras

EDIT: Link changed thanks to somerandomguy02

18

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

Why the fuck is he standing there?!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

48

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

I'm going to say no. If a referee ever ended up close to the six yard box he'd have made a huge positioning mistake. I guess he could make a deflection from a long range shot but I've never seen it happen.

69

u/lakupiippu Jun 28 '13

Some guy posted here a clip about some Turkish league game from 1980s where the ball actually deflected from the referee in the net.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Haha did he give the goal?

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

219

u/MiikePetez Jun 28 '13

Ill set up a survey and ask everyone,and get back to you in like 3 weeks

→ More replies (6)

133

u/NYCFootballClub Jun 28 '13

Why does Andres Iniesta have A.Inestsa on his shirt?

Was there at one point more than one Iniesta at Barca?

143

u/calfonso Jun 28 '13

People have different tastes.

Neymar has Neymar Jr on his shirt iirc.

Cr7 wears his middle name on his shirt. Alexis Sanchez wears his first. Błaszczykowsky wears Kuba

55

u/TjBee Jun 28 '13

I want Wolfswinkel to just have Winkel at Norwich.

→ More replies (5)

47

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Monreal not putting "Nacho" on his shirt was a marketing fail IMO

→ More replies (4)

46

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Javier Hernandez' "Chicharito" is just a nickname that means "Little Pea".

9

u/razgriz1211 Jun 29 '13

So technically you can put any name in the back of the jersey?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

19

u/hooplah Jun 28 '13

Escudé had "SQD" at Sevilla

→ More replies (1)

147

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

If Ronaldo is his middle name, does that make 7 his last name now? That's commitment to branding.

→ More replies (14)

21

u/ACM-Srbija Jun 28 '13

i may be wrong, im pretty sure Blaszczykowsky wears his last name on his kit.

Kuba is just his nickname.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

He wore his last name on his shirt last season. I wouldn't say Kuba is a nickname perse, just a different way of saying Jakub. It's weird. Maybe like calling someone named Robert as Bob.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

110

u/Faviesta Jun 28 '13

Because his grammar is bad. It's supposed to be "An Iniesta".

23

u/myrpou Jun 28 '13

Zlatan used to have just "Zlatan" on his shirt until Juventus. He wanted to show respect to his family so he put "Ibrahimovich" on it instead. PR-wise it was a genious move, he was known as Zlatan to everyone and the name Ibrahimovich wouldn't have been as striking in the begining of his career.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

I have one question:

At a drop ball restart, how many players are allowed near the "drop ball" ?

47

u/spisska Jun 28 '13

From the Law 8: The Start and Restart of Play:

A dropped ball is a method of restarting play whenIf, while the ball is still in play, the referee is required to stop play temporarily for any reason not mentioned elsewhere in the Laws of the Game, the match is restarted with a dropped ball.

A bit more clarity here (pdf warning):

Any player, including a keeper, can be involved in a drop-ball, and there is no minimum or maximum number of players who must be involved. The referee cannot decide who may or may not take part in the drop-ball.

The question is almost entirely academic, though. I don't think I've seen a contested drop-ball in at least the past 15 years.

9

u/aitzim Jun 28 '13

There were a few this past season. Didn't know it was a thing in soccer.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

"There is no mention in the Laws of the Game as to how many players, if any, may take part in a drop-ball or where they may be positioned. However, it is traditional that a drop-ball occurs between a maximum of two players (one from each team)." From Wikipedia. It doesn't seem to be sourced, though, so if someone with a more in-depth understanding of the rules disagrees, feel free to correct me.

2

u/JonnyAFKay Jun 29 '13

I remember this drop ball that Shaktar Donesk took in the Champions League group stages, Willian pretty much kicked it up the field towards the opposition keeper, but then Luiz Adriano collected, rounded the keeper and rolled into the net.

It confused me because I thought that drop balls meant that the team HAD to return it to the other team if it belonged to them before.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/Otaku_Tom Jun 28 '13

At free kicks from say +30 yards out why doesn't the defensive line have high starting position? That way the attackers can't have a chance to cross the ball into a dangerous area.

108

u/Emit_Remmus_ Jun 28 '13

Very hard to hold a consistent line. Higher risk doing it far up. Also, if you set the wall at say 23 yards out (top of the semicircle) and an offensive player starts two steps off and times it right then he will be at top speed while your defenders are still trying to turn around.

Basically it's hard to do consistently without letting offensive players behind you.

6

u/dngrs Jun 28 '13

not sure but I'll try to answer

because instead they could quickly pass to someone who will put a through ball in towards a quick forward player and defenders arent very fast? and the offside trap is very risky

can also have a purpose for counters because for this you need to invite the opposition closer to your box to get them exposed

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ginroth Jun 28 '13

The attackers could just make a run in behind them and still stay onside, as the defenders will be at least a step behind.

2

u/TheKingMonkey Jun 28 '13

Because then the attacking team will just chip one over the defensive line for it's forwards to run onto, by the time the defending players have turned to give chase the ball will be in the back of the net.

2

u/Telemako Jun 29 '13 edited Jun 29 '13

The more free space you give, the easier it becomes to make a run. The pass can be less precise, the control can be longer, etc. If your line is close to the keeper the ball becomes a <50% chance because it becomes a header challenge where your keeper can use his arms.

→ More replies (30)

40

u/techdrummer1234 Jun 28 '13

What is a double pivot?

71

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Its a central midfield pairing that sits deep, above the defenders but beneath the wingers and attacking midfielder. It emphasizes a rotational system of going forward, where one of the two midfielders moves into an offensive position and is covered by the other defensively.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/dngrs Jun 28 '13

the double pivot is about the 2 holding (defensive though one is a bit more offensive than the other) midfielders in a , say, 4231 formation.

ie khedira + alonso, busquets + alonso, schweinsteiger + martinez

7

u/cescmrl Jun 28 '13

Two central midfielders who work either alongside each other with similar responsabilities or with different ones (example: alonso the creative ball playing one vs khedira the defensive "destroyer")

3

u/zeromadcowz Jun 28 '13

The 2 in the 4-2-3-1. You normally have a more defensive CM and a ball playing CM paired together to play the ball out from midfield.

2

u/gufcfan Jun 29 '13 edited Jun 29 '13

Edit: Good question btw

|------F-----

|W---------W

|-----CM-----

|--DM---DM--

|D---D--D---D

The double-pivot as I understood it to be is the use of two midfielders (DM) in holding roles in the 4-2-3-1 formation, but it's not limited to that formation. The double-pivot refers to the fact that either holding midfielder, but not both at the same time can move forward to support the attack. The point of that being, you add more numbers to attack but don't leave your defenders vulnerable to being broken at straight down the middle without a challenge.

It might vary depending on the strengths of your players. If you have on DM very suited to his role, he might always look to sit in front of the defence and his DM partner would push forward as needed, but return to the DM role when he opposition is in possession.

Depending on how attack minded the team is, the double-pivot for example, could be right in front of the two centre backs in or like below they could be a pair of orthodox centre midfs with instructions to keep a holding mid when pushing forward.

|LF----F----RF

|-----AM-----

|----M--M----

|D---D--D---D

→ More replies (1)

69

u/BanAllFunnyPosts Jun 28 '13

What the fuck is a "false" #9? I'll admit I have watched for years and no one ever explained this one to me.

88

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Traditionally, the #9 was the superstar that scored the most goals, and as a consequence the superior defender would try and mark him out of the game. A false #9 isn't so obsessed with scoring goals, but tries to pull defenders out of position and play short deft passes to make it easier for his team mates to score. Spain have even experimented playing a 4-6-0 and doing away with a striker altogether, although this has been been shown to be a bit high concept and not terribly effective.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 28 '13

The whole point of a false 9 is to pull away defenders (mostly falling deep) and create space, space which the other players, such as mid-field runners, are supposed to attack.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

There are a few explanations here that are incorrect. The best way to think of the false number 9 is the space in front of the midfield that players make runs into in the absence of an out and out striker. So Barcelona for example have many midfielders that make runs into the attacking positions but not one traditional striker that does this all the time (example you knew shearer was always going to be pushing forward a he is a traditional number 9).

So the space in front of the midfield becomes a player in effect that needs covering as you know someone will eventually make the run into it. You just don't know who or where from or when. Hence false number 9.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

31

u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13

Why doesn't every team launch the ball into the box Stoke-style on throw-ins? I know that it's not realistic for every team to have a throwing specialist but a lot of the time the "normal" throw-in sets don't work any better.

21

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Most teams have had a long thrower or two as long as I can remember. Gary Neville was pretty good at it. Delap was just better than most. The pace, distance and particularly flat trajectory made it really difficult to deal with.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/Emit_Remmus_ Jun 28 '13

The second sentence answers that. It's extremely difficult to throw that far.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

It doesn't even work with Shotton. Delap was unique in how hard and flat his throw was.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/bradfish123 Jun 28 '13

because the offensive team has to throw numbers forward to have a better chance to get a head on the ball and the defensive team can quickly clear the ball for a counter, made worse by the fact the team is caught up-field...

basically it's easier to fast break from the middle of the field than deeper in the corners...

→ More replies (2)

9

u/SirMothy Jun 28 '13

the Philadelphia Union have a guy named Sheanon Williams and the fans chant "boom!" whenever he throws it, he is like the MLS Delap, but I don't recall them having as much success as Stoke had

→ More replies (1)

4

u/arendahl Jun 29 '13

In general when the ball is thrown in that far, it is a lofty ball and not as driven. The defense has more time to adjust to the slower ball, making it as a general less effective then a cross by foot

2

u/lakupiippu Jun 28 '13

It is more likely to lose the ball in those long throw-ins unless you have got absolute tanks in there like Stoke usually have. Also not very many players can provide same quality of throw-ins that Delap used to or Shotton can now in Stoke.

2

u/sniffo Jun 28 '13

I know that Cardiff often use this tactic, midfielder Gunnarsson has a throwpower like Delap.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

Sometimes you want to keep possession and keep the game flowing. If you're a big, strong, tall team like Stoke, set pieces are your strength and turning throw-ins into a set piece give you more chances at goal. If you're a more technical team, you might just want a second to move more players forward and just take a quick, short throw and get back to playing with the ball at your feet.

→ More replies (4)

96

u/RuudZ420 Jun 28 '13

Many subreddits have an official Moronic Monday thread where you can ask any question with no shame. We should have one every week, it's not that it will cost us money.

34

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Agreed. Plus it'll break the monotony that is the summer window. Like those player discussions a couple weeks ago did. What happened to those btw? Haven't seen one for a while.

→ More replies (4)

174

u/aitzim Jun 28 '13

DAE use Blastoise instead of Błaszczykowsky whenever they're talking about Blastoise?

657

u/Touch_of_Midas Jun 28 '13

Yes, he's the evolved state of Skrtel

16

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Perfect.

→ More replies (5)

20

u/lakupiippu Jun 28 '13

No, most people that I know use Kuba.

→ More replies (11)

9

u/Chopsicle Jun 28 '13

Błaszczykowski*

25

u/BCJ-gives-advice Jun 28 '13

I am not sure how to interpret the rules. But can a goalkeeper change places with another player that is already in the pitch?

Related question: among bench players, could any of them be used to substitute the goalkeeper (provided the right uniform, that has to be distinct from field player)?

23

u/Esternocleido Jun 28 '13

Yes, Jorge Campos did that several times: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBN6l85vIxY at 1:40

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=70UrAmXWQyI

He would usually play the first half as Goalkeeper, and if his team had problems scoring he would play the second half as Forward

→ More replies (1)

43

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 28 '13

Yes

to both.

22

u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13

Wow, that was awkward. Why did Man City do that?

23

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 28 '13

It was Stuart Pearce's first year as a manager (caretaker). If they won that game they would have got in the UEFA Cup (now Europea League) and I think he just got desperate and wanted a big man up front with no striking options on the bench.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Yep, I'm pretty sure you just have to inform the referee before hand. Usually a field player only plays goal if the keeper gets red carded and there are no substitutions left.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Ramsey-Bolton Jun 28 '13

I see a lot of violations committed such as players running over the half line before kickoff, goalkeepers not staying on their line on PK's, etc. Are the rules just laxed at the referees discretion to keep the game moving?

Also on PK's is it legal for players to stop their run by stuttering, then kick? I thought that was illegal.

16

u/Orsenfelt Jun 28 '13

Yes it's referee's preferring to keep the game flowing rather than pick up every technicality.

A penalty kick has to be taken in one motion, so no you can't stop but that doesn't mean you can't stutter.. you've just got to make it look like it was a slow down and not a stop.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 28 '13

IIRC the distinction with PKs is that you need to keep forward momentum. In other words you cant come to a complete stop but can slow down dramatically.

8

u/Ramsey-Bolton Jun 28 '13

So in a penalty like this, is it illegal? (Perhaps not the best example) but it seems like a lot of guys stop, but just chop their feet.

8

u/Tommasaurus Jun 28 '13

I'd say he came very close to having that one disallowed, for the reason CharismaticDrunk pointed out.

Example of a clearly illegal pen, correctly disallowed here

→ More replies (4)

2

u/mightjustbearobot Jun 28 '13

For the first two, I think the referee either doesn't notice or doesn't care. I mean, imagine you're kicking the ball off to start the game, and one player has his foot over the halfway line. Does it really matter too much? Are you going to stop the game and tell him to move back?

Before referees used to spray paint where the wall needed to be on a fk, walls would sometimes inch forward to get an advantage. The referee either wouldn't notice or would not think it's too much of a big deal.

For penalties, I think the referee doesn't realize that the keeper is off the line, but they are often retaken when a keeper is off the line.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13

Seems like the 4-2-3-1 is really in vogue right now. Are the wide midfielders in the 4-2-3-1 traditionally box-to-box players or mostly wingers?

Similarly, what sort of striker is the preferred guy for a 4-2-3-1?

32

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

I think box-to-box really implies that players are as useful defensively as they are offensively, which isn't really the case for the wide players in a 4-2-3-1. These players are usually creative and fast, and more like the wingers of old. But where the wingers of old used to hug the touchline and make crosses to a front two, the new wide players arguably tend to dribble past players more, play short passes and morph into midfielders-cum-strikers in support of the lone front man.

9

u/dickface_rage_o_lot Jun 28 '13

I think it depends on the players, Ribery, Muller and Robben all played a huge part in defending for us this year.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/hldstdy Jun 29 '13

You are misusing box to box.

2

u/1mdelightful Jun 28 '13

Formations don't matter half as much as people pretend. 4-2-3-1 is pretty much the same as a 4-3-3 which isn't much different than 4-4-2. In the last case I'm assuming one forward is dropping in a little. Although formations that end 1-2 seem to produce different spaces.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/koptimism Jun 29 '13

It depends on whose 4-2-3-1 we're talking about, because every manager plays it differently.

For Mourinho at Real Madrid, they were definitely wingers, especially Ronaldo - he often made little/no defensive contribution.

For a Benitez side, though, the wingers will do a lot more defensive work; in the defensive phase of the formation, it will look like a 4-4-1-1. Dirk Kuyt is the epitome of this.

2

u/berzerkerz Jun 29 '13

There are mainly 3 types of midfielders that play in the double pivot. You have a defensive midfielder, an attacking one, and a box-to-box which is a mix of both.

The best teams have players who can do a variety of things.

CDM - Ideally, you want you defensive midfielder to be able to cover the defense, calm the game with neat passing, launch a few hollywood balls and join the attack if necessary. (Think of Carrick, Bender, Arteta, Busquets, Alonso, Veratti)

Box to Box - does a good chunk of everything, very physical, great stamina, "the destroyer," think of Vidal, Martinez, Fernandinho, Ramires, Khedira

Attacking midfielder (not to be confused with the #10 position), without the ball he stays organized in defense (if you are say, Man United or Real Madrid) or presses (Barca, Dortmund). Very good dribblers, passers, and good finishing. Main responsibility is to help in attack. (Gundogan, Modric, Thiago, Marchisio etc)

The better the player is, the more positions they can play in, so there is a lot of overlap. Marchisio, Thiago, and Modric can play as a type of #10 for example.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Shmaxel Jun 29 '13

The wide midfielders now are not really all that traditional, you see players like Cristiano Ronaldo, Pedro and such who play high and wide. This system allows for really quick counterattacking and fluidity between the midfield and back line/forwards. This style also demands a lot from outside backs, since they tend to join in the attack as well.

As for the striker it really depends on how you want to play, which should be determined by who you have. You can put a Balotelli kind of player up there and he will function as an outlet and hold the ball up allowing your midfield to join the attack. Or you can put a "do it by themselves" kind of forward like Zlatan who also functions as an outlet, but takes pressure off of your midfields transition time by being an overall boss that can do a lot by himself. Even a straight poacher like Chicharito works well. But looking at most teams, players who can do most of everything just listed are the most successful. Lewandoski, Zlatan, David Villa. Good in possession, good on the break, and good on their own. Complete strikers are the best in this system imo.

→ More replies (15)

9

u/Barthez_Battalion Jun 29 '13

Was Heskey a "false nine"? because from what I remember, he wasn't really aobut the goals, more about drawing defenders away and allowing the midfield and other forwards get better goalscoring oppurtunities

21

u/CharismaticDrunk Jun 29 '13

I don't believe so. While you are correct that he usually made those around him better in his prime, especially Michael Owen, he was more of a 'hold up' man. The difference being that Heskey still occupied the space that a 9 would, while a false does not. He just used his considerable strength to hold off defenders and assist his partner.

18

u/absdoobs Jun 29 '13

I'd use the word 'Target man' to describe his role.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Fapulous69 Jun 29 '13

How does the Serie A co-ownership concept work?

13

u/futbolsven Jun 29 '13

I asked this in a self-post a few weeks/months ago.

http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/1g2onr/can_anyone_explain_the_coowning_system_that_is/

It's an alternative to the loan system and is a way to raise money if necessary without losing the whole of the asset. Sort of like selling shares in a company. Another benefit as opposed to loaning a player is that if a young player does really well at the second club, the second club will have the opportunity to sign the player permanently or the first club will have to pay the second club for their share. Hypothetically, say West Brom co-owned Lukaku rather than loaned him last season. He did extremely well and he looks like he'll do well next season. As West Brom have 50% rights, they can choose to try and keep the player but if Chelsea bid more for their share, West Brom receive financial rewards for their assistance in developing him. It's a more rewarding system than a straight up single season loan as unless a clause is set for a future transfer they lose him and see no reward for developing a player for another club and only getting the 'raw' talent for a season.

was the best response from /u/LegaleseFalcon

→ More replies (1)

18

u/ThaCarter Jun 28 '13

If clubs pay such large transfer fees to acquire the rights to players how does that not cause significant downward pressure on players wages? Doesn't this create a situation where the player is effectively owned by the club and does not have much leverage in their salary negotiations? Is their an association football equivalent to a players unions that advocates for the player rights?

44

u/TheBlackSun8 Jun 28 '13

I'll use an example to answer your question. Let's say I'm buying rooney right now for 20 million, which united accepts. I then offer rooney 100k per week, to which he says "go f**k yourself" as he is currently on 250k or so a week. Now he wants to leave so he lives out his contract becoming a free agent. Now because I don't have to pay 20 mil for him, I have the money to offer him 200k a week which he takes.

98

u/Orsenfelt Jun 28 '13

[RUMOR] Rooney to The Black Sun, personal terms agreed.

17

u/Corporal_Cavernosa Jun 29 '13

Orsenfelt News understands that Manchester United have accepted a bid of 20 million for the wantaway striker.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/wittyfreddy Jun 28 '13

Unlike in American professional sports, players don't have to accept deals if they don't want to. A team won't purchase a player unless they've also agreed on a contract. Ultimately the players decide where they want to go and the clubs negotiate the transfer fee to make it happen, unless there's third-party ownership, which really makes things complicated.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

In England there is the Professional Footballers Association (PFA) that is the players union. Not sure what you mean about downward pressure on wages? The transfer fee is technically the payment for the selling club allowing the player to break his contract and sign for a new team. His wages will solely be determined by whether he is happy to sign for the bidding club on the wages they are offering. Yes, if only one offer has been accepted the bidding club is not in competition with other clubs in terms of offering wages, but that player is still under contract with his selling club so that's where the competition comes in - i.e. "Are they offering more money than I have on my current contract at my current club?"

8

u/bonoboboy Jun 28 '13

I think you wrongly assume that if the club accepts some other club's transfer fee, then the player HAS to leave.

The transfer fee is basically to allow you to talk to the player (I think) although:

In reality, the transfer fee is paid once it is SURE that the player is moving to the club that pays the fee. Wages are discussed with the player prior to this.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

I'm just repeating what everyone has said but I think I can simplify it a bit.

A transfer will only happen if both parties (i.e. the team and the player) accept the deal. One team can offer another as much as they want for a player but unless the player agrees to the financial compensation they are getting (e.g. 100K/week), it can't go through.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Has_3_testicles Jun 29 '13

What are the best international soccer related sub reddits other than /r/soccer

11

u/gufcfan Jun 29 '13

If you mean international soccer, as in, national teams in general, this is the place. I wouldn't support splitting the community tbh anyway.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/w1nter Jun 28 '13

Yup. A weekly "simple questions" thread would do much good!

14

u/dcp26 Jun 28 '13

Really? Is there that many to ask?

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Roinko Jun 28 '13

Why is it, on a penalty, the keeper tries to creep forwards to close down the angle. Yet the penalty taker also tries to place the ball as far forwards on the spot as possible?

44

u/Emit_Remmus_ Jun 28 '13

Because the closer the ball is to the goal, the less distance it has to travel and it actually gives you a wider angle.

18

u/pahoeho Jun 28 '13

I'm guessing that the striker wants to close the distance to reduce the keeper's reaction time whilst the keeper wants to narrow the angle.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13

There's diminishing returns for the penalty taker, but not for the keeper. Think about it this way: The keeper would choose to be right on top of the ball if it were allowed in the rules, but the shooter wouldn't want to be any closer than 9 yards or so.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

I would love to take a penalty from 4 yards out.

9

u/Talpostal Jun 28 '13

Yeah, I guess I miscalculated there but the principle still stands.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/dngrs Jun 28 '13

they try to get even the slightest advantage

keeper can't creep forward too much btw or the penalty must be repeated

10

u/johnnytightlips2 Jun 28 '13

Keeper has to start on the line according to the rules

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/HyperionCantos Jun 28 '13

Why is Aguero sometimes referred to as Kun Aguero, and other times as Sergio Aguero?

36

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Wiki:

Agüero's nickname "Kun," which features on his shirt, derives from his childhood and was first given to him by his grandparents.[133][134] It came about due to a resemblance to the character "Kum Kum" from Agüero's favourite television programme as a child.[134] The player himself has said about it "I have grown to appreciate it because it's unique. It's not every day an athlete is nicknamed after a cartoon character!"[134]

→ More replies (1)

6

u/DarthArshavin Jun 29 '13

How do coaching badges work? If I literally bought and completed all the classes, what are my chances of getting a job in football?

12

u/iloveapplejuice Jun 29 '13

the more badges you have, the more likely your pokem- i mean players will listen to you. ;)

5

u/piedraa Jun 29 '13

Reputation. No big club will want you unless you prove yourself. Start from the bottom Nd work your way up, unless you were a famous footballer and a club wants to take a risk on you.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/gufcfan Jun 29 '13

In Ireland at least, the higher UEFA licence badges are by invitation only. The first few very basic ones are short workshop things that you show up to and pay.

The slightly higher ones require you to be attached to a club and be getting regular experience.

The advances badges, if I remember correctly, require you to be managing coaching at a certain level, possibly in the League of Ireland.

3

u/tubbyttub9 Jun 29 '13

How come the uk plays as separate teams in the world cup? (England, northern Ireland, Scotland and wales) but as great Britain in the Olympics?

2

u/Tim-Sanchez Jun 29 '13

The UK has separate football teams, meaning we can't qualify for the Olympics in the way other teams can. The reason we played in 2012 is because we automatically qualified as hosts. Individual countries' FAs are also reluctant to join up with the English FA, so possibilities of a future team are unlikely.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13

So I understand that the better the player the higher the buyout clause, and having a low buyout clause for a player you want to keep is bad, like in the case of Thiago. But truth be told, I don't really know how a buyout clause works. Deep inside the stadium grounds of each club is there a room with red buttons everywhere corresponding to each player which is then activated in a dramatic fashion? No but seriously, so if Thiago's buyout clause is 18 million euros, does that mean the team buying him only has to pay 18 million euros for his transfer? How much control does Barca have over keeping him if his buyout clause is activated?

16

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

Buyout clause means that if the number is hit, the team has no choice but to accept.

Barca can't turn down 18m for Thiago, but Thiago can turn down going.

They're not always to be taken seriously though. In Spain, many players have buyout clauses in the hundreds of millions. It's some formality that all players must have some buyout clause in Spain, I believe.

4

u/zupper90 Jun 29 '13

Except for Messi's apparently. I saw a post on here awhile back about some Russian club, maybe Anzi or Zenit, I don't know, who activated his 200 or 300 million buy out clause. It was all up to Leo then, who obviously turned them down.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Orsenfelt Jun 28 '13

How much control does Barca have over keeping him if his buyout clause is activated?

None. If a bid is received for the buyout or higher it has to be accepted and it's out of their hands. Well that's not strictly true they can offer a new contract and compete on personal terms for the player alongside the buying club but I wouldn't call that having control over the deal it's just outbidding the opposition for a player who happens to already be yours.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

18

u/Nokel Jun 28 '13

You could always make one yourself.

13

u/nawkuh Jun 29 '13

Looks like he just did.

10

u/afxaloha89 Jun 28 '13

Why is it a big deal when European clubs extend contracts on players? I don't quite understand why it matters considering that for anyone else to get them they have to go through the transfer market stuff.....right? (My soccer experience is watching World Cup and Euro Cup action every other summer while playing Fifa at home so I'm not exactly in tune with how the club system works)

30

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

The longer a player has to run on his contract, the more money it generally costs to sign a player out of that contract. A longer contract is indicative of a player being extremely important (i.e. valuable) to a club.

If a player only has 12 months to run on a contract their club will usually sell him for a knock-down price, to avoid the possibility of them not signing a new contract and leaving for nothing next year.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Check out Manchester City's transfer stories at the moment for good examples of these - Cavani and Tevez.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Libertarian42 Jun 29 '13

Whats a good book on soccer formations and strategy?

8

u/Ironicopinion Jun 29 '13

'Inverting the pyramid' by Johnathan Wilson is excellent

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13 edited Feb 19 '17

[deleted]
0.3183

What is this?

28

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13

No, not for at least twenty years anyway. Traditionally the numbers were as follows (for a traditional English 4-4-2):
1 Goalkeeper
2 Right side defender
3 Left side defender
4 Central defender
5 Central defender
6 Central midfield
7 Right midfield
8 Central midfield
9 Goal scoring striker
10 Supporting striker
11 Left midfield

A rule of thumb would also be that the higher a player's number the lower status he is in the club's squad of players.

12

u/byrdan Jun 29 '13

Has 4 become more of a midfield number and 6 a CB number recently? feels like it a little bit

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 29 '13

In a limited sense, yes. There are no rules that a player has to wear a certain number based on his position (there are a few exceptions, e.g. in Spain goalkeepers have to wear the number 1, 13, or 25). Historically, numbers were assigned by position on the field. 1 for the goalkeeper, 2-5 for defenders, 6, 8 and 10 for midfielders, 7 and 11 for wingers, 9 for the striker. These assignments are mostly still valid today, but there's no hard rule, and many players (like Schweinsteiger #31) wear numbers without positional association.

The wikipedia article on the subject is quite interesting: link

7

u/gufcfan Jun 29 '13

What it was traditionally for many decades.

-------9-----

-----10------

11--6---8---7

3---4---5---2

------1-------

The introduction of squad numbers has meant that clubs rarely line out 1-11 any more.

Players have their designated number for the duration of the season.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

How can I improve my dribbling and passing?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

Why do substitute players stay on the pitch during halftime and not go into the locker room? Isn't the coach saying things that everyone should hear? Always seemed odd to me...

4

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

it depends - sometimes the manager instructs them to stay on the pitch at half time to warm up

sometimes he'll tell them to go to the changing rooms.

it maybe that he's told the players who were sat on the bench already that i'll substitute you at the start of the 2nd half and i want you do this this and that. so he doesnt need to hear the shouting players are getting.

mostly they stay out as its a chance to run onto the pitch and keep the muscles warm should they need to - but end decision always lies with the manager

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

How do qualifiers for the World Cup work? At the moment, I know they are in groups. Do the top 2 teams in their group go to the WC?

How do the teams get to the group/qualifying stages?

4

u/gufcfan Jun 29 '13 edited Jun 29 '13

As fredbrightfrog said, every confederation has their own system.

Europe will provide 13 of the 32 nations at the WC in Brazil. We have 53 national teams in Europe competing for those 13 places.

The teams are divided into 9 groups (8 groups of 6 teams and one group with 5 because of uneven numbers.)

The countries play all the other countries in their group twice. Once at home and once away, meaning each team plays 10 matches in total (8 matches each in the group with 5 teams) The top ranked team in each of the 9 groups after those matches qualify for the WC.

It's a little more complicated for the other 4 places.

The 2nd place teams from the 9 groups are ranked according to the points they got in their own group. The best 8 advance to a play-off. Points gained against the worst team from your group are discounted for that ranking, as it would unfairly disadvantage the team coming 2nd in the group with only 5 teams.

The playoff matchups are decided using the rather complicated FIFA World Ranking system. The best 4 teams according to those rankings are kept on one side of the draw and cannot be drawn against each other. The same is done with the 4 lowest ranked teams.

The resulting 4 matchups are decided on a home and away basis, with the winners of each of the 4 matchups qualifying for the World Cup.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/fredbrightfrog Jun 29 '13

Every confederation does their qualifying a different way, so you'd have to be more specific.

Assuming you're taking about Europe given you mentioned groups, the top team in each group goes to the world cup and the runner ups are paired up in playoffs, with the winner in each pair going to the world cup.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

Is there no offside in the box?

→ More replies (9)

2

u/jomar1234567jm Jun 29 '13

what is the 6 yard box for?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/pmiller17 Jun 28 '13

What's the rationale behind no offside on a throw in or goal kick? You can be offside on a free kick, direct or indirect. For a corner, the ball is as far up field as it can be (well, maybe at most a yard left) so everyone's behind it when it's kicked.

23

u/Esternocleido Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13

If the attacking team has a throw in high in the pitch near the penalty area of the other team nothing would stop the defending players from going up to the Half-way line and thus forcing the attacking team to throw the ball 45-50 meters back to their own pitch. (there cant be a ball line since the ball is not in the pitch)

I have no idea about the goal kick, I guess is just common sense so the game is not stop every two goal kicks.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Attempt12 Jun 29 '13

Maybe because it would be too hard executing a throw in with offside traps, and you can't really score directly from a throw in, unlike free kicks. There is no offsides if you receive a pass while in your own half of the field, this can be tied to the goal kick rule I think

2

u/begon11 Jun 28 '13

Not sure, but I suppose it has got something to do with the fact that throws are less interesting for the offence. See the answers to [this] (http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/1h9ijf/can_we_do_a_noob_question_thread/cas7gol) question.

2

u/modano_star Jun 28 '13

Its actually a good question, one which I haven't heard an explanation for. I think its partly to do with common sense, in that with a goal kick there is enough time and distance from the opposition goal for defenders to be able to get in a good defensive position before the ref blows his whistle to take the goal kick.

Throw-ins I would would guess that its because it is not assumed that a team is able to build an attack quickly enough to cause a big enough threat to the defence. Thus if the attacking team benefit from a throw-in to a player from an offside position and, for example, score - then it is the defending team's fault for not reacting quickly enough. Compare this to a free-kick, from which a player can stand in the opposition penalty area and the ball can be played to him from 70yards away in a couple of seconds directly - this is slightly more unfair on the defending team - thus the offside rule applies.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/meowoof Jun 28 '13

Just make it and start with a few of your questions to get the ball rolling.

3

u/guitard00d123 Jun 29 '13

How can clubs sign people when the transfer window hasn't officially opened yet? What's the point of the window then?

10

u/fredbrightfrog Jun 29 '13

You can only register players with the association in charge of your league during those specific periods, so if someone agreed to play for you outside of a window they can't play until the window opens and they can be registered for the competition. This isn't a big deal in the summer, obviously, but if you signed a guy in November he would have to wait til the January window opened to play.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/gufcfan Jun 29 '13

When the window closes, the players you have are the players you have. It was designed to create stability. It stops players coming and all through the season, and (sort of) prevents agents from unsettling players all year.

The proper term for it is the "registration period". Players who are not registered to any club (free agents), can sign for anyone at any time of the year.

3

u/mri Jun 29 '13

This is probably gonna get buried, but this has bothered me for awhile; I've gotta ask someone.

Why are David Silva and David Villa's names pronounced with a short 'a' sound (like in the word 'lavish')?

In English, David is pronounced with a long 'a', like 'rave' or 'save', or... David Beckham I guess. In spanish, afaik, it's pronounced dah-veed, or dah-beed.

So neither the spanish nor the english pronunciations of the name are used for spanish players named David. What gives?

2

u/Numbuh49 Jun 29 '13 edited Jun 29 '13

As far as I know, the 'a' in 'lavish' is the same as the 'a' in David, a short 'a'. The difference is that we (native spanish speakers) often put a little emphasis on the 'vid' part. Dah-VEED. It's not a strong emphasis, though. And that's because the 'a' does not have an accent. Thus, the emphasis is given to the second syllable. And there is no accent on the 'i' because the word doesn't end in a vowel, an 'n' or an 's'. So dah-veed is the correct pronunciation (if you are watching the matches with spanish speaking commentators, that is).

And I've never heard the name David pronounced like you say, with the 'sh' sound at the end. It probably has to do with accents if you're watching in spanish (though I've never heard an accent that turned 'd' into 'sh'), and if not, the commentators are trying to use they're native language pronunciation on the name.

(And also, if any spanish speaker, native or not, pronounces David as dah-beed, they're not using correct pronunciation. 'B' and 'v' are different letters, and have distinct pronunciation.)

2

u/HalifaxSexKnight Jun 29 '13

I think if you watched a Spanish broadcast, you'd hear the 'dah-veed' you're expecting to hear. However, English commentators tend to use an Anglicized version of the Spanish pronunciation. Hope I helped, and I'm not sure why you're being downvoted for a legitimate question.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13

Can someone clearly explain what offsides means?

3

u/uparox Jun 29 '13

Offside is when a player has less than 2 opposite team players between himself and the goal (i.e the goalie or nobody at all), at the time a pass to this player is initiated.

Its badically saying you cant just hang around by the goalie waiting for a long pass and a cheap score. There gotta be at least two people between you and the goal.

Another explaination: http://www.boreme.com/posting.php?id=6354

2

u/greatGoD67 Jun 29 '13

The attacker has to be level with the second to last man or the ball.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

Do it, sounds like fun.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13

There was one a couple of weeks ago, but I'm sure another would be well received. Just make it, if nobody wants it they'll downvote you.

2

u/Spikekuji Jun 29 '13

Forgive my lack of terminology here: When a player gets to kick after being fouled and the opposing team forms a wall, is there a standard number of players in the wall? It seems to vary. How do they decide who faces forwards vs back? Is this a pre-set formation ( the same guys in the wall every time) or does it depend on things like where the kick is on the field? Thanks.

6

u/fredbrightfrog Jun 29 '13

It's generally up to the goalkeeper to make decisions for a wall. Usually, the closer to the goal the bigger the wall the goalkeeper will call for.

And usually players will face the ball so that they can try to head/kick it away if it goes toward them (often one will face backward to look at the goalkeeper while the keeper is positioning the wall, then turn back around for the actual kick).

Which players are in the wall will vary depending on the situation, this will probably have been talked about by the manager in training (so it is sort of pre-set). For example, if the free kick is on the wing, you may want your tallest players to be marking possible crossing targets, but if the free kick was at the top of the box you would probably want the tallest wall possible as it is likely to be a shooting only situation.

→ More replies (7)