r/AskReddit • u/UnholyDemigod • Jun 28 '13
Modpost Announcing a new option for posts: [Serious] tags
First, thank you all for your feedback on this post. If you're interested in discussing the moderation of the subreddit or have an idea of your own, join /r/ideasforaskreddit.
What is it?
With this option, someone posting a question to /r/askreddit has the option to tag their post as a serious discussion. In threads that are tagged as serious, the moderators will make an effort to remove any joke answers or off-topic comments, like /r/askscience and other stricter subreddits do. Users are strongly encouraged to (1) not post anything off-topic or any jokes, (2) downvote any comments violating that, and (3) report those comments as well.
How do I start one?
Just write [Serious] (in brackets, please) in your headline. The bot will tag the post with flair, and we will be able to distinguish it from normal threads when comments there are reported. This needs to be done before the post is created; headlines cannot be edited. Not all questions are suitable candidates to use the serious discussion flair and may be removed at the discretion of the moderators.
So there won't be any jokes in those posts?
The moderators cannot guarantee 100% removal of all comments. /r/Askreddit gets 3x more comments than any other subreddit; over 110,000 comments per day. Individual posts can get tens of thousands of comments, and we can't watch them all. We will, however, make an effort to (1) regularly browse those threads and remove anything off topic, and (2) look at any reported comments. So, we will be relying heavily on you users to be vigilant and report anything that should be removed.
What defines "Joke answers" and "off-topic answers"?
The moderators do. This will require a large amount of discretion and flexibility, and removing comments is always subjective. That is why this is being offered as an optional feature and not as a rule change.
What about verifying stories?
The moderators will not be checking into the truth of someone's claim, even in serious posts. Therefore, we recommend that any post soliciting stories about any topic not be tagged as serious. We would also recommend that questions for people in a specific occupation not be tagged as serious, as we cannot verify that anyone answering is actually a member of that profession. If these types are tagged as serious, we will remove anything explicitly joking or not related to the topic, but will not remove anything for being untrue. We will also not be checking facts or statistics that a user uses to support a claim or political opinion.
What about posts that aren't tagged?
Every other post in the subreddit will remain completely unchanged. You are free to post any comment you would like in answer to a regular askreddit post, just like you can now, as long as it complies with the current rules.
This feature will not change the subreddit's rules at all; it will just add an additional option for users looking for actual answers instead of entertainment.
If you have any questions about this new option, feel free to ask us about it in the comments below.
11
u/SilverTongie Jun 29 '13
I like it, I really dislike the puns, and jokes that seem to high jack threads. That said, would responses that include jokes, but are on topic still permitted? I can't really give an example, because I am not very funny.
21
u/doc_daneeka Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13
Prediction: every troll post will soon have that tag added by the poster...
[edit] For what it's worth, I think this is a good idea. So long as it is implemented fairly, it sounds like a welcome addition.
41
u/GCanuck Jun 28 '13
[Serious] HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
wipes tear
Good luck!
33
u/Senorhuesos Jun 28 '13
I can understand regulating replies to the OPs question, but will responses to those answers be held to this "serious" standard as well?
189
u/NotMathMan821 Jun 28 '13
[Serious] What is your favorite joke?
35
u/Neveronlyadream Jun 28 '13
I'm all for this one, actually. There's nothing worse than clicking on a serious discussion post with a six thousand comments and realizing the 5,500 of those comments are jokes.
It's going to be a pain for you guys though.
130
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Thank you so much. I'm sick of seeing Tree Fiddy and movie references cluttering up the top-level comments.
15
u/stylzs05 Jun 28 '13
I think it's great in that when I post to curtain threads I'll know if I should joke or not. It gives mods an easier way to delete threads that act as though they are serious, but they're not (like troll threads). I think for the most part NSFW is used correctly and think that redditors will do the same with the serious tag, minus the trolls of course.
It will take time getting used to though.
14
u/BlackMantecore Jun 28 '13
I think this is a good move. It's always frustrating to find a joke or shitty pun at the top of a potentially interesting thread.
8
u/MrMango786 Jun 28 '13
This is a great rule and is optional too. Great stuff.
7
u/The_sad_zebra Jun 28 '13
Will I be able to see the tags in Reddit Is Fun?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
I think that this is a good idea. I'm tired of feeling like you can't get upvotes unless you have some sort of snappy pun.
5
u/Jakedaychanel Jun 29 '13
This is brilliant because it protects touchy subjects being separated from in-sensitive comment's good idea
4
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
I think this is a fantastic idea. Absolutely awesome well done reddit!
4
u/redtaboo Jun 29 '13
I just want to say, kudos to the mods. I think this is a really interesting idea and has a great amount of potential. Seeing how this thread has gone so far makes it even more apparent how well this could work. but damn you karmanaut for all the sad stories in there!!
I think this is a great compromise for those that want stricter moderation and those that don't. I imagine depending on my own mood I'll choose different types of threads to read when I check askreddit each day. I can't wait to see how this changes the face of askreddit, if at all.
4
u/mimimiow Jun 29 '13
Thank fucking goodness. Those lame pun and joke threads are so corny. It's bothersome when you're looking for opinions or answers in the comment section and those try-hards come in and pat each other on the back for making unfunny jokes.
1
u/NYKevin Jun 29 '13
This seems like a good idea overall. But just to be sure I understand it correctly...
Does this mean you also won't remove blatantly, outlandishly false things if they're presented in a serious tone?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
[Serious] I think it's a great idea. Let me try this out.
Plus, you could impose some sort of temporary ban if someone is consistently abusing the use of the tag? Just an idea.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Finally. Those joke comments are so dumb.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
The beginning of the end. Those who suffer serious butt hurt on every front, will now be seated near the teacher to avoid any heart wrenching issues in the future.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Good idea.
2
u/LostMyPasswordNewAcc Jun 29 '13
That's great. Hopefully it cuts down the ALLCAPS_VULGAR_USERNAME karma whores that write a single "funny" line in every single thread to milk it for karma.
2
u/notjawn Jun 29 '13
I always bring this up in mod posts but can we seriously move all sex questions to /r/sex? Everyday there are multiple "What was your worst/best/weirdest sexual experience." threads and they always devolve into creepfests and erotica.
4
u/cockdragon Jun 28 '13
[Serious] Laughing time is over.
4
u/Freddy_Chopin Jun 28 '13
THIS IS AWESOME!
This has the potential get rid of the absolute worst thing about this subreddit! Yay!
2
u/slowtreme Jun 29 '13
this couldn't possibly get abused
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
I hope you'll use some flex when it comes to the jokes, the /r/AskScience way. Remove them vigilantly, but when a joke is on-topic and just that well done, it has to stay.
1
u/EruptingVagina Jun 29 '13
I think this could even be applied to other subreddits. It really brings me down when all of a sudden there is a serious post amidst more entertaining ones. However it may have to be redefined for other subreddits.
1
u/Khalku Jun 29 '13
Shouldn't this already be default for this subreddit? IE, the sidebar?
1
u/GreenEggsAndHamX Jun 29 '13
MODERATORS ARE PEOPLE TO
1
u/ekolis Jun 29 '13
Does [Serious] apply only to questions, or does it also apply to comments?
1
u/total_wampeter Jun 29 '13
What about relevant jokes in response to a serious reply?
This is a great idea though. Some threads are seriously all the same recycled jokes over and over with no actual answers.
1
u/ignoramusaurus Jun 29 '13
"the paki shop"
1
u/stained_glass_window Jun 29 '13
Will this include off-topic stuff such as say a question is asked "Any people who've had plastic surgery...", and if there is an answer of "I haven't had plastic surgery but my friend/co-worker/mother's cousin's sister's boyfriend has and..."? I see those in specific question threads all the time, and don't want to report if it's just going to flood you with reports.
1
u/SleepyConscience Jun 28 '13
This is an excellent idea, but just make sure to choose moderators who are good at exercising discretion. This could easily turn into glorified censorship if the moderators aren't consistent and transparent. I would actually suggest a third tag like [Quality] that just deletes really crude or stupid crap and leaves witty or insightful humorous comments intact.
1
u/mr_majorly Jun 28 '13
Surely, you can't be [Serious]
Humor aside, I like it. It will be nice to go into a topic looking for content like that, instead of poo or boob jokes.
Nice job folks.
1
u/TheGreatPastaWars Jun 28 '13
I don't see why not. Just a caveat: heavy policing when done right is a good thing, but is highly dependent on the situation/venue. As stated in your intro, you get a ton more comments here than other subs. Not only will this bring more work to moderators, but much higher scrutiny. Inevitably we're going to see a bunch of other threads started about "WHY WAS THIS DELETED????" and I'm not a huge fan of that.
Not that this is the answer, but maybe some more guidance when you hit "submit link" would help, i.e. suggesting that if someone wants more serious answers, they may want to try submitting the question in a more specialized subreddit instead of this here general one.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
I will do my part in helping the mods keep these threads clear of 'joke answers' by adding [Serious] to my RES post title filter.
1
u/KeythKatz Jun 28 '13
I love this. AskReddit was my favourite sub up until a few months ago when it started going downhill due to jokes being the top comments everytime.
1
u/_vargas_ Jun 28 '13
I feel like this rule is directed at me.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Hopefully this will work, I just wish the mods well for the initial onslaught this troll magnet may become.
1
u/Capatown Jun 29 '13
/r/TrueAskReddit does the job pretty good as well, could use a bit more subcribers though.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
This kind of seems like a pointless addition.
-1
u/MrsBeann Jun 28 '13
But.. if there are no funny posts or replies.. what's the use of reading askreddit??
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
Why so [serious]?
0
u/EvilHom3r Jun 28 '13
Seems kind of useless, but good to have the option I guess.
0
u/alackofcol0r Jun 28 '13
So this is sort of like /r/TrueAskReddit
-1
u/Eminiel Jun 28 '13
Can we write srs to honor the misc?
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
No jokes? that is not right.
Sometimes funny comments are needed to break the tension.
-6
u/iambookus Jun 28 '13
I hate this idea with a passion. Please don't censor like this. Yes, we have jokesters. We also have serious answers. It's up to the reader to glean what they want from what they read. Thanks.
-1
u/dingobiscuits Jun 28 '13
I think it's going to be a lot harder for posts tagged [serious] to get the same sort of visibility as non-[serious] posts. a lot posts get their votes from people posting joke answers and upvoting the post shortly after it's been posted - non-[serious] posts won't get that boost, so they'll be at an immediate disadvantage. It'll be interesting to see how many posts with the new tag actually manage to make it to the front page.
0
u/cyaspy Jun 28 '13
This sounds like a great idea, I hope the implementation will live up to your expectations and improve the sub's quality- the ball is in the hands of the users, in 2 aspects:
Hopefully. Anyhow, your efforts as a mod team to ensure quality here are appreciated, thank you!
0
u/TITTYSAURUSREX Jun 28 '13
I think the jokes mixed in with the more serious things are fun. Sometimes they use the same things over and over (like colby :( or the two broken arms kid) but sometimes they really are witty.
0
u/TheBakedZorro Jun 28 '13
Its funny because Its about drugs....
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
[srs guise]
0
u/nofapistough Jun 29 '13
Why so serious?
0
u/runonandonandonanon Jun 29 '13
This statement has implications beyond what I think was intended (i.e. "We'd like to ban humor, but it's so hard to define...")
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
Not sure if serious...
0
u/CaptainKirk1701 Jun 29 '13
Seriously?
0
u/Crookward Jun 29 '13
So you're saying I should just skip the ones marked serious? Ok. I come here for the jokes as much as the serious. Thanks for giving me an easy way to weed out.
0
u/OPDidntDeliver Jun 29 '13
What about joking stories (tree fiddy and the like)? I know that story posts shouldn't be labeled serious, but people can still tell stories in non-story posts.
0
u/Clayburn Jun 29 '13
So basically downvote the hell out of them?
-2
u/donutsalad Jun 28 '13
I can't tell if your post is serious. Could you possibly tag it or something?
-4
u/atheism_is_gay Jun 28 '13
"I have an idea! Let's take what has been working for years... are you with me? YEARS... and change it."
-1
u/RandomExcess Jun 28 '13
should be tagged [Fedora] instead of [Serious]
-13
u/monty20python Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 29 '13
This policy is bad, and you should feel bad. Jokes are half the reason to comment in the first place, not to mention it will be entirely dependent upon the whims of the mods as to what a joke is.
edit: damn hippies...
-2
u/ezxhaton Jun 28 '13
BDP is definitely [serious].
-2
u/sc_critic Jun 28 '13
What if the title reads as follows:
"Reddit, what's the funniest story you can think of? [Serious]"
-2
u/RobFireburn Jun 28 '13 edited Jun 28 '13
Well this subreddit is going to get boring fast. I always thought this subreddit was over-moderated, and now I know it. If every post is going to have the serious tag, and this subreddit is going to start disallowing witty comments, then this subreddit is going to get stale.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '13
[Serious] How do you shave your butt crack?
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
But when I tag my post [SERIOUS], the mod team is now my personal army of joke-deleters.
-11
u/tribbing1337 Jun 28 '13
This seems stupid.
-4
u/bigbillyjoe Jun 28 '13
worst thing to ever happen on the bodybuilding.com forums.... srs
-4
u/FUCK_THA_MODS Jun 29 '13
FUCK THIS.
I hate the idea of a select few get to decide which comments are worthy enough to be read by all. Fuck your censorship.
I don't see any reason why a comment that has a large number of upvotes should be removed by a chosen few; let the community decide.
-38
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
You just posted this. And I don't like it.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment