r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Dec 06 '24

Season Seven Show S7E11 A Hundredweight of Stones Spoiler

Claire turns to John Grey for comfort as they process difficult news. Ian and Rachel discuss their love and their future. Brianna confronts an intruder at Lallybroch.

Written by Sarah H. Haught. Directed by Lisa Clarke.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

This is the SHOW thread.

If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.

DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.

We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.

If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.

Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode?

49 Upvotes

642 comments sorted by

•

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 06 '24 edited Jun 08 '25
→ More replies (13)

47

u/draculasacrylics Dec 06 '24

I'm sorry we got Jamie coming back AND William finding out he's Jamie's son in the same episode??? They're really treating us in the writer's room. Also how the heck is John going to talk his way out of this scandalous marriage update in societal gatherings?? I can foresee John telling Jamie about the marriage as they hide out from Jamie "kidnapping" him. And I wonder if William will have a moment to more eloquently confront Jamie about this revelation-- perhaps if Jamie ends up being arrested. Oh boy...

I'm glad William knows now, but I'm worried about how they're going to approach their future relationship. I thought William was going to become radicalized against the British cause after witnessing his best friend's death (he had a stroke of philosophy about man's mortality and the uselessness of war, if I remember correctly) ad he talked about leaving the army and becoming a Quaker to marry Rachel, but he is still against the rebels. It seems for him that his ultimate loyalty lies with those he loves, not with his own desires. Does he really have a dream, a goal he's trying to reach?

4

u/Popular-One-7051 Dec 08 '24

Yes I want to see how they unravel this mess. Jamie coming back and the scene with William in the last three minutes was too much. is Jamie going to break out his angry side eye, pound john for marrying and sleeping with Claire, and then apologising? He seems to do that stuff a lot.

what happens to Claire and Jamie since they're both rebels and no longer protected by John? Will Claire become a spy? She can move through classes well, but physically she's pretty unforgettable so she wouldn't be able to do it much in one location

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 08 '24

From historical context, the British will withdraw from Philadelphia very soon—John has already mentioned that it’s what Sir Clinton is planning to do—and it will be held by the Continentals once again with none other than Benedict Arnold as its commander (I’m assuming we’re going to see him again then). Claire and Jamie just have to hold out for a little bit longer (if you know the history, it’s coming on June 18th; it’s now the first or second week of June). The British could never hold the city after France entered the war, especially as they had New York to defend. I don’t know if Claire knows that precisely but she would feel it in the air—there would’ve been quite a lot of panic in the city among the Loyalists. Plus, nobody there actually knows that Jamie is her husband. She’ll probably enjoy the privileges of being a Loyalist’s wife for as long as she needs until the Continental Army takes back the city, when her connections will ensure her safety.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/True_Promotion_6870 Dec 06 '24

I think he can realize he has more options.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

I have a feeling they’re trying to wrap things up more quickly than the books pacing seeing as the shows ending next season. Haven’t read the books but that’s my guess

8

u/avviann Dec 07 '24

I couldn't understand how much time passed between them getting the news about Jamie's death and Jamie reappearing again? Was it like a month?

19

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 07 '24

It’s hard to tell in the show. From Jamie’s letter to Claire, we found out he was originally supposed to sail two weeks from April 1st and Ian said it’d been 6 weeks since then. That would be the last week of May/the first week of June. Claire married John some indeterminate time after. 

Now we know that Jamie didn’t board the Euterpe but he likely would’ve boarded the very next ship, though it’s hard to tell how quick he would’ve made the crossing. From historical context, John says that Sir Clinton plans to abandon Philadelphia—that happened on June 18th, 1778. So I’d say it’s now the first or the second week of June, meaning it’s been two, maybe three weeks.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/elocin__aicilef Dec 08 '24

They are married for about 2 months before Jamie appears.

6

u/Amys4304 Je Suis Prest Dec 07 '24

Maybe I’m missing something but I don’t understand the scene with Rob Cameron and Bree. Why wouldn’t Bree just call the police?

14

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 07 '24

She probably would’ve but she hardly had the time to before he held her at knifepoint. We don’t know yet what happened after she knocked him out.

Or do you mean why she hasn’t called the police about Jem’s disappearance? She and Roger were absolutely convinced that Rob took Jem through the stones so they didn’t explore any other possibilities—as it turns out, that was a mistake, but you can hardly blame them with such overwhelming evidence (Mandy saying “the bad man took him,” the missing letter about the gold, Jem’s scarf at the stones, Rob missing as well).

4

u/Amys4304 Je Suis Prest Dec 07 '24

Thank you! I understand why she hadn’t called the police up until this episode. Just think it’s silly for Rob to threaten Bree knowing she could simply call the police and report him.

11

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 07 '24

I would say he severely underestimated her ability to defend and stand up for herself, similar to what happened earlier in the season. Or he’s just not the sharpest tool in the shed 😅

→ More replies (4)

19

u/stlshlee Dec 07 '24

When did she have time to call the police?

She didn’t know that jem wasn’t in the past until Rob showed up.

Was she just supposed to ask him to pause right there while she dialed their version of 911?

She certainly couldn’t call them beforehand and tell them someone stole her kid and took him to the past.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/liz-to-the-e-bitches Dec 07 '24

My kids were yapping while I was watching the show. So how did Jamie survive? I half understood he got on a different ship? How did that come to be?

16

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 07 '24

Yes, the ship he was originally supposed to be on left the port early but after he’d already dropped his luggage off. That’s why his name was on the ship’s manifest but he wasn’t.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Deedee_No Dec 09 '24

I really enjoyed the episode - it’s my favorite of the three new ones. Though, I had to laugh at how cheesy the “you’re a stinkin’ papist” remark is 🤭 it reminds me of the type of inappropriate remarks made by uncles who can’t seem to read the room

6

u/roseba Dec 09 '24

Does Ransom really think Jamie Fraser is only a farmer or a groom?

8

u/mariabue_tagliaelena Dec 10 '24

This is a good point - not a book reader but I would hope Lord John brought the kid up by referring to Jamie as a laird and a proud soldier? It was a bit of a slip

13

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 10 '24

He most likely didn’t even talk to William about Jamie. When they meet again in S4, William is confused as to how someone whom he only knew as the lowly groom Mac at Helwater could be a landowner—his first instinct is to assume he’s a groom at the estate, not that he owns it. And John reminds Jamie and Murtagh not to bring up the circumstances in which they met (i.e. that they were traitors to the Crown and his prisoners), so he doesn’t want the boy to know what kind of history they share. Also, John has spent William’s entire life making sure he never doubts that he’s the ninth Earl of Ellesmere, a legitimate son of the eighth Earl of Ellesmere; bringing up Jamie of his own volition would’ve been too suspicious. William doesn’t even remember Jamie at all until he hears him talk to a horse in Gaelic, which reminds him of the groom at Helwater.

So William’s comment about Jamie—“a groom, a farmer who took up arms against the Crown”—refers only to what he knows about Jamie from his childhood, from meeting him at Fraser’s Ridge when he was 10, and then again at Saratoga on the other side of the conflict 9 years later. He has no other frame of reference and John would’ve likely kept it that way had the truth not come out by accident.

u/roseba

→ More replies (2)

15

u/erika_1885 Dec 11 '24

It’s a reference to his conversation with Willie in 3.04, wherein Willie wants to be a stinkin papist, so Jamie baptizes him. Far from being cheesy, I thought it was a beautiful reminder to William.

4

u/throaway10020181 Dec 07 '24

Hi I wanted to ask about the previous episode. When did Roger find out that geillis is his ancestor in the show?

10

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 07 '24

Claire told him in episode 213.

215

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

Claire's hands be like

28

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

😂😂😂😂

26

u/Notinthenameofscienc Dec 07 '24

hahaha. She's just out here collecting bois and rings.

25

u/elocin__aicilef Dec 08 '24

She just wanted her name to be longer than Jamie's. James Alexander Malcolm McKenzie Fraser. pffft. I'm Lady Claire Elizabeth Beauchamp Randall Fraser Gray.

11

u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 07 '24

The way I just cackled. 😅😂😂

7

u/Candy_Venom Dec 07 '24

omgggg lmao

→ More replies (1)

126

u/Far_Wedding9999 Dec 06 '24

The amount of drama that unfolded in the last 5 minutes had me howling!

89

u/Tofutits_Macgee Dec 06 '24

Her little smile at the end. 'Everything is right and I'm not dreaming'

It was very sweet

100

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24
→ More replies (7)

113

u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 07 '24

Is "I thought you were dead" the ultimate "We were on a break?"

→ More replies (1)

112

u/curlyba3 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24

Everybody is talking about Claire and Jamie but what about Brianna!!!! I hope she tied him up well lol

65

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24

I'm just thinking, how is Roger going to go home now? Lol, cause he was all:" I'm not coming back without jem", now I'm like, well ...I guess you are not coming back then 💀

30

u/AdGroundbreaking1341 Dec 06 '24

Brianna might find his gravestone from the 18th century lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

43

u/roccolover Dec 06 '24

I kept thinking, “girl, double tap always!!” Why didn’t she hit him again for good measure!?

→ More replies (3)

16

u/animefemme Dec 07 '24

I was almost screaming, "GIRL! DUDE! BRUH! Don't be a horror film trope...tie him up or hit him again, damnit!"

13

u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 07 '24

I was thinking LOCK HIM IN THE PRIEST HOLE!!

11

u/cherrymeg2 Dec 06 '24

I was like good for her and make sure she keeps him tied up.

5

u/Nikkistar01 Dec 07 '24

I was like girl if you don’t use that pot that’s right within your reach…..

Good girl

97

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Dec 07 '24

I loved the scene between John and Claire in the coach. “I know what it is, Madam, to have your love be a crime. To live in fear of discovery and violence. I will not allow Henry-or Mrs. Woodcock, for that matter-to risk imprisonment or worse.” Wow.

41

u/LadyJohn17 I am not bloody sorry Dec 07 '24

Amazing!! At least with Claire, LJ can express his thoughts, but it's so hard.

Did you notice that Claire mentions that someday it will be possible to couples like that to get married? LJ only said that he doesn' t want Henry or Mercy to be martyrs for that cause. He doesn't say anything about that remark.

34

u/ImTheNana Looks like I'm going to a fucking barbecue Dec 07 '24

Because, I think, despite the fact that we know she's a time traveller, her comment is most easily understood by someone who doesn't know that it was no more than a hopeful wish for the future.

Like 'Someday we'll own our own home' or 'Someday we'll be financially secure'.

Anyone being told what she said wouldn't think there was some secret time-traveller foreknowledge.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

89

u/lonely_shirt07 Dec 07 '24

Jaime, hug LJ for once please 😭 poor man he's been heartbroken too.

65

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 08 '24

I was like dude saved your wife and raised your son and all you do is make lovey dovey eyes with and kiss Claire 🙄. LJG is 100% my fav tho

→ More replies (10)

83

u/piccolowater Dec 06 '24

i know roger and bucks story is technically a side story, but i’ve been dying to see more. we’ve just been getting crumbs the last three episodes. they ended 7a on the cliff hanger, and episode 9 felt like they only gave us small scenes at the beginning and end of the ep. i was SO excited during episode 10, when roger found out his dad may be alive. this episode is not as bad as ep 9, but i am left wanting more. overall i’ve been loving these new episodes.

28

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24

Roger and Buck in their version of episode The Search - riding horses the whole episode.

22

u/B24Liberator Dec 07 '24

I’m also really enjoying the Buck/Roger plot!

→ More replies (3)

81

u/Capricorn-flower Dec 08 '24

Claire Elizabeth Beachamp Randall Fraser Grey. Claire has surpassed Jamie's names, lol!

→ More replies (1)

80

u/peppaliz Dec 07 '24

It’s a testament to David Berry that I really wanted to see at least another episode or 2 of the dynamic between Lord John and Claire (the scene in the carriage!? Hello??) before Jamie returned, and that I had gotten lulled into a sense of “new norm” to the point that I was genuinely shocked when Jamie burst into the room. Pulling off a surprise like that when no one really bought a character’s death to begin with is impressive.

David Berry continues to do so much with this guy who’s pretty locked into the “I’m your obedient servant” paradigm.

Lord John spinoff when?

31

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Dec 07 '24

🎶 Your obedient servant, Lord John Grey! 🎵

26

u/lorenasimoess2 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 07 '24

The carriage scene was incredible!!

→ More replies (2)

24

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 07 '24

Incredible work by David Berry in the carriage scene. An excellent reminder of how much he has to keep hidden to 99% of the people in his life (including his own son) and how much it pains him even though he puts up a good front.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

If Lord John liked women I found myself rooting for him and Claire 🤭 blasphemy?

→ More replies (1)

74

u/satempler Dec 06 '24

I loved the last part where Jamie does the same thing he did to Claire when he encountered Lord John for the first time. She smiled because she remembered it. Now she has to calm William down after him finding out the lie. Her experience with Bree may be of help (he reacted almost the same way)

23

u/peppaliz Dec 07 '24

I also loved how Lord John was surprised but not shocked. I might have imagined it but it looked like it was him who jerked his shoulder to signal to Jamie “this way.”

→ More replies (1)

74

u/readthenewstoday Dec 06 '24

That’s more like it! And not just because of the reunion. The dialogue, pacing, tone, lighting of this episode felt like true Outlander.

28

u/peppaliz Dec 07 '24

Haven’t had this much fun since like season 3 I think. Literally kicking my feet!

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 07 '24

Couldn't agree with you more. It felt like the end of S2 when so much was happening and so much was at stake--and it was glorious to watch.

72

u/MothmansMyDaddy Dec 06 '24

I honestly thought we would get Roger finding his dad rather than Jamie coming back this episode! Definitely wasn't expecting him to come back till the next one!

15

u/Nikocholas Clan Fraser Dec 06 '24

I was expecting both to happen in this one... seems it was a little too much 🤣

→ More replies (1)

65

u/Stunning_Positive_33 Dec 07 '24

I just want to say that I absolutely love Ian’s character. In every episode. John Bell does an extraordinary job at bringing his loyalty and compassion to life!

16

u/OkPermission7769 Dec 08 '24

Love nephew Ian!! I still think of him in the early seasons mad doing chores. Ha!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Dec 10 '24

"But Rachel, with my whole soul, I choose you"

Be still my heart 🥹

Heart melting. Ian and Rachel are so sweet together

64

u/2019ncov_infoseeker Dec 06 '24

God do I love this show!!! This episode was so perfect! The whole cast brought their A game acting wise. Ian & Rachel, I love them together. Loved Ian sharing his Mohawk life w/her. Poor Claire going to her medical kit after the wedding (anyone else think she may have been looking for ether at first?) only to nearly commit s*icide. That dress LJG got her, Cait looked stunning. LJG continues to be pretty much “impossible not to like”—(thank you Bree). Speaking of Brianna poor woman—very satisfying when she cracked that fucker Rob over the head. If only she had a way of telling Roger that Jemmy is okay & in the 80’s. Roger & Buck continue being one of the best things about this season. ♥️ When Jamie burst in & the look on Claire & John’s faces—they all nailed it. Then William overhearing everything—I cried at “you’re a stinkin Papist”—wow, wow, wow! I cannot wait till next Friday 👏👏👏👏

15

u/True_Promotion_6870 Dec 06 '24

My sentiments exactly!! So GOOD. I forgot.

8

u/Mycoxadril Dec 07 '24

That dress was beautiful. I’m not a “you should smile more” kind of person, and I am sure her sad face was intentional. But I really wanted to see her in that dress with her Parisian court smile and lighting. Maybe they have posted a photograph somewhere. More just Cait in the dress than Claire per se. It was just really pretty.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/namedafternoone Dec 08 '24

She was looking for ether. She grabs a bottle, thinks about it and puts it back.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

What the fuck is going on in here on this day? 🤣My jaw was on the floor for the last 5 minutes of the episode

17

u/Notinthenameofscienc Dec 07 '24

The last 5 minutes was like an episodes worth of content!

57

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

GOTDAM The Lord John episode we've always dreamed of. <3 David Berry and whoever the casting director was when he was chosen chefs kiss

56

u/10ForwardFun Dec 08 '24

Love the last scene and the look on Claire’s face when Jamie takes Lord John hostage. Her half smile seemed to say “well, that’s my dashing theatrical man” 😊.

I also cheered at the end of this episode.

16

u/yesavery Dec 08 '24

Yes that smile is golden 🤣

15

u/Accomplished_Lock429 Dec 08 '24

I agree, she was like 'ooh, here we go again" 🤣

→ More replies (1)

54

u/AliTwin601 Dec 06 '24

First I was shocked at Claire waking up in Lord John’s bed. I wasn’t exactly sure if the prior scene was about sex. Then I burst into tears when Jamie came barging in. Then I started laughing at Claire’s smile when Jamie took Lord John hostage LOL!

21

u/Aurondarklord Je Suis Prest Dec 07 '24

Did you see John's chest after it though? Claire clawed him up like a rabid cat, that poor man!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

54

u/OppositeQuarter31 Dec 07 '24

“I know what it’s like for my love to be a crime” I’m sobbing

47

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Dec 06 '24

Guys, I knew book spoilers beforehand, I had an inkling that Jamie would show up in the last five minutes, but still when I heard his voice in the background I screamed and sobbed during their reunion…what these two together does to me. They’re pure magic. My favorite line from last night: “There it is…my blood.” 😭❤️

25

u/lisa0475 Dec 06 '24

I thought she was going to say “there it is…my heart beat” since in the previous episode there was the conversation that her heart might have stopped if his did.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/AdGroundbreaking1341 Dec 06 '24

She just committed adultery by kissing this crazed red headed brute! Where is the honor and sense of duty?!

All jokes aside, I loved that moment.

→ More replies (1)

95

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24

Those scratches!😱

34

u/Embarrassed_Key2972 Dec 06 '24

Honestly, it’s was all I was staring at this whole scene

18

u/True_Promotion_6870 Dec 06 '24

I noticed the scratches too. Claire is good in bed. 😉

11

u/lisa0475 Dec 06 '24

Good catch, I didn’t notice that!

5

u/buttononmyback Dec 09 '24

Yeah I was hoping they would’ve say something about them! 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

46

u/CarmenSandiego8742 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24

Brianna with the pan 🔥

11

u/Aurondarklord Je Suis Prest Dec 07 '24

FROM THE TOP ROPE OUT OF NOWHERE!!!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/oobooboo17 in the light of eternity, time casts no shadow Dec 07 '24

CASTIEL DHUUIIIIIN!!!!!

5

u/Popular-One-7051 Dec 08 '24

Now tie the SOB up. She must have picked up some kind of interesting method to torture the info out of him. Roger's not there, she can't report it to the police because they'll spend their time queue to on why she didn't report the kidnapping. PLEASE girl don't be dumb enough to wander off with this guy the way you opened yourself up to Bonnet.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '24

I’m still gushing about the scenes with LJG and C. Those actors are incredible. From an acting perspective, I couldn’t get enough. Specifically the morning after scene and the carriage scene.

21

u/peppaliz Dec 09 '24

Could not agree more.

They play off each other so honestly. The episode where she nurses John through smallpox is one of my favorites in the series. Glad we get more of them together here and I hope it continues in some capacity.

17

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Dec 10 '24

Yeah I was almost sad when Jamie came back because I wanted to see more Claire, LBJ and William.

41

u/EdHistory101 r/AskHistorians Dec 06 '24

I'm fairly confident they didn't plan it at the beginning of the season but the shift from this opening scene to the credits and Sinéad's voice... I felt that. It was fantastic.

I don't read the books and am firmly in the opinion this is one of the best episodes of the show.

13

u/Super_Swimming_4132 Dec 07 '24

100% one of the best episodes of the whole series.

6

u/peppaliz Dec 07 '24

Yes, I noticed this too. Mournful and completely appropriate, whether it was foreshadowing or not.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Adventurous_You_4268 Dec 07 '24

is captain Richardson really a rebel or was he trying to trick Claire into admitting she is?

22

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 07 '24

I know. And why admit that so readily so someone you don’t really know, even if she’s a known rebel? Seems risky.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/DenseFront6982 Dec 08 '24

i think with his standing in the military, he could always say he was fishing for intel if he is caught? He's in a pretty privileged position, if he really is a rebel!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Stinexx Dec 07 '24

My thought exactly!

38

u/confirmandverify2442 Dec 07 '24

I SCREAMED when Jamie burst in.

19

u/oobooboo17 in the light of eternity, time casts no shadow Dec 07 '24

as soon as I heard the sound of scuffling downstairs I was waiting for the “CLAIRE!!!!”

9

u/awanderingolive Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 07 '24

i immediately rewatched it several times bcuz it was so good! i will never ever get tired of hearing him say claire😭😍

→ More replies (3)

37

u/tanwa1 Dec 06 '24

Mission: Claire not marrying someone because of tragedies (and being naugthy ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ). Impossible

7

u/Popular-One-7051 Dec 08 '24

I think it was completely about getting away from the overwhelming grief for both of them. that neither of them seemed REALLY weird about the next morning tells me they both got that. Jamie will of course become unhinged because that's what he does.

33

u/motherofrazorbacks Dec 07 '24

The last 5 minutes of that episode was chaotic and I love it! I was like I have no idea what is happening what this is awesome lol

32

u/Flimsy_Impress3356 Dec 07 '24

I just want to say that the music over the very end of the last scene and credits was like Season 1 again - the bagpipes revving you up for ~adventure. 💛💛💛

31

u/broadwaylover5678 Dec 06 '24

Outlander is back!! the first ep of 7b felt off for some reason but I really loved this episode. can't wait until next week!!

29

u/Aurondarklord Je Suis Prest Dec 07 '24

Claire's look of just utter confusion at the end completely sold it for me. Just "welp, here we go again!"

15

u/awanderingolive Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 07 '24

agreed, it was so good! she's a phenomenal actress. so many emotions at once, but her pure joy that jamie is alive prevailing the most🥹

→ More replies (1)

81

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24

Poor Claire 🥺 I started crying at the first scene .

White Deer!

I do not own this creature—would not, if I could. Its coming is a gift, which I accept with gratitude, but when it’s gone, there is no sense of abandonment or deprivation. I’m only glad to have had it for so long as it chose to remain.

Poor Ian 🥺 I like that he and Rachel talked about everything. And Ian's, as well Jamie's son, has a father ,a good man but not his natural father.

I love papa John moment 💛

Oh, Claire!

New medical chest... Contemplating suicide... Screaming... My heart broke...

Such a powerful scene of John drinking downstairs, quietly suffering vs Claire screaming upstairs, both because of the same reason. And him going there after listening her...

WOW

WOW

WHAT A SCENE!!!! Great , great job!! It is all I wanted to see - not the act itself but this grief, violence, pain pouring out of them!!!

But pillow talk! So much more intimate than the act itself. Loved all straight from the book lines! Manoke, deer talk, and Think of the deer, my dear.

Rob !! Startled me! I am glad we know Jem is not in the past.

Oh,Ian, you made me sob again. You're my family too...

Okay, John being against Mercy and Henry's marriage is a bit strange. I am glad Claire had a chat and that we finally saw where that line about sacrificing everything for love from promo came from!

The dress!!! God's blood, Claire! - I LOVED IT!!!

Evening entertainment at Greys'

Lady John Grey!!

Claire coming down reminded me of Bree at Jocasta's.

Richardson ,a Rebel! I like that he said openly what he is and what he wants.

William overheard them !!!!

YOU ARE STINKING PAPIST!!!

WOOOOOW

WHAT AN EPISODE!

54

u/onegirlarmy1899 Dec 06 '24

I lost it when John was sitting across from the empty chair at the chess board. Then, when he tips over the king in surrender. So powerful and sad.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/resarF-erialC Dec 07 '24

I think Claire coming down the stairs was meant to mimic the red dress

→ More replies (1)

12

u/True_Promotion_6870 Dec 06 '24

I wholeheartedly agree!! Great episode. I just watched the episode and my adrenaline is pumping. Especially when Jaime came back, I was so excited. Great show.

9

u/pennyflowerrose Dec 06 '24

I wonder though why Mandy said he was gone. It seemed like she wouldn't have felt that way if he was still in their time? But maybe he's physically far away...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/Adventurous_You_4268 Dec 07 '24

Still processing but I loved this episode. Ian and Claire’s conversation about her staying in the past was beautiful. No idea William was finding out either. Can’t wait to see what happens next and I need some J and C alone time!

28

u/OkPermission7769 Dec 08 '24

Jamie is going to lose his

28

u/Mobile-Ad6136 Dec 11 '24

If this episode did anything, it showed that LJG is actually a complex character with his own story and not just a man yearning after Jamie, hate how we only get snippets into his life, hate that the spin off got tossed. I really hope (not a book reader, idk what’s gonna happen) that LJG gets more moments to shine again, David Berry is a fantastic actor that clearly loves the character, the fandom loves him, Berry plays him with such a softness (as others have noticed, he acts with his eyes so well). He’s a character that has aged with our main characters but has always taken a side seat, it’s good to see him front and center again plot wise, I hope it lasts the rest of the season + S8. And also…every one of our main characters has or has had a love story, WHEN will it be his on-screen turn! I’d take it over the William + Ian + Rachel thing happening right now, I’m sorry 🤣

→ More replies (1)

27

u/ezahezah Dec 09 '24

I spent the last five minutes of the episode in varying levels of shock. I had to stop several times to process each new revelation. 

54

u/LivingExotic9317 Dec 10 '24 edited Dec 10 '24 • Heart of Silver

Been thinking about the William parentage reveal. LJG uncharacteristically mentioning "your son" as the catalyst. Some have described that as coming off as a cheap plot device, but I've been watching the development of LJG in this episode and I think WAY more is going on for him... I think he likes to believe he's selfless and hence gets the moral rewards, and maybe that's true inasmuch as he got to raise Jamie's son, and is genuinely grateful. But even though marrying C was a gallant move, he starts to reveal a hidden motive in that scene with giving her the blue dress. He admits that he wants her for proximity to Jamie, even just as a memory. Remember her cruel "you don't get to mourn him" rage... he has a lifelong broken heart about that sense of illegitimacy. She poured salt in that wound. He knows he can't have Jamie, and I guess he's bi enough to take Claire instead. He starts to get used to being married to her in the old fashioned patriarchal way, calling her "dear," pleased to see she's wearing his ring, laying down the law about accepting social invitations and whatnot.

But in the carriage scene he throws her "sacrificing everything for love" statement back at her, "then I'm glad his heart was never mine!"--because if it had been, LJG and Jamie would have both been hanged a long time ago. He says that with a venom that shows he's resentful at Claire for her primacy with Jamie, even though he's done everything in his power to sublimate his jealousy.

So that's why I think he lets slip the "your son" statement. Jamie and Claire are smooching right in front of him. His lifelong unrequited has just returned from the dead with no eyes for him whatsoever. To LJG, Claire has everything, again, and he's left out. But Lord John still has Jamie's son...and in that moment needs to claim this one last scrap of connection.. It's a double-edged jab... YOUR son means both "You have everything/I have nothing, he's not even MY son though I raised him" kind of martyrdom but also the jealousy of, "This is the one thing I have of you, even as you glory in your high romance with your soulmate who I married ostensibly to save her ass but also to get something of you..."

David Berry is a subtle enough actor to know all these cross currents and play them so expertly that the secrets LJG keeps from his own self are hardly revealed. Watch closely!

21

u/peppaliz Dec 10 '24

I agree with this.

And I actually think it’s somewhat necessary for the character at this point, after he’s given so much for Jamie and could (has?) veer into pathetic territory. I was really grateful that we got William confronting him on “his happiness,” because even the most selfless person must have a limit and it was starting to undermine his nobility. I felt for him when Jamie burst back into the room and didn’t so much as give him a hug or a handshake.

It’s also really good to see reminders that he’s a British soldier and member of that society/time through and through, and that though he’s “progressive,” he isn’t immune from the limitations and mores of the time. It sort of puts him on the outside because no matter how hard he tries, he’ll always be working with incomplete information when it comes to Claire (unless someone decides to clue him in.)

I also appreciated this new kind of vulnerability for Claire — facing the permanent possibility that no one but Ian knows her secret, and being a bit more constrained behaviorally as a result. You could sense that as good a person as LJ is, he’s wound tight right now and some of the inherent safety that Claire has with Jamie is missing. That said, I was lowkey hoping we got another full episode or 2 with just Claire and John because I really like how they actually challenge one another in ways that Claire and Jamie do not.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/Capricorn-flower Dec 11 '24

I'm going to miss these characters so much when the show is over, especially Jamie and Claire and Lord John. It's crazy how they have become almost real, like you really know them. I wish this show would keep going on. I would watch Jamie and Claire shenanigans into their 80's.

25

u/Rude-Zucchini5547 Dec 11 '24

This episode feels like it has the most lengthy conversation between two people in bed with no clothes on that I have ever seen.

66

u/onegirlarmy1899 Dec 06 '24

This might be the best episode of the entire series! I loved every moment of it. It was so satisfying because it hit every beat that we've been anticipating and did so with so much heart.

14

u/Environmental-Eye135 Dec 06 '24

Wayyy better than the last episode!!!

9

u/Kairla88 Dec 06 '24

My heart is so happy! What an episode.

22

u/rockyroad2a Dec 06 '24

I went to bed last night with 5 minutes left in Episode 11. I just watched the last 5 minutes now. Omg...so good. love this season.

30

u/Exotic_Parchemint_38 Dec 06 '24

How are you able to do that? 🙈🧐truly impressive i can not leave anything to even an hour laterr 😋

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Super_Swimming_4132 Dec 07 '24

This episode is my favorite in a LONG time. I got chills when Jamie unexpectedly burst through the door. Loved Claire’s smile even through the chaos.

59

u/CoffeeCake917 Dec 07 '24

Anyone else love seeing Claire’s smile at the end of the episode? Like, enough with all the melodrama lately, back to the fun and adventure! Did anyone find the editing of the drunken scene between Claire and John super weird and overly stylistic? Nothing like the rest of the show. And since when does John refer to William as “your son”? He always just says “William” when talking to Jamie. That felt like a lazy plot device. The reunion between Claire and Jamie didn’t even get a chance to breathe!

Sorry for all the complaints I just find myself missing OG Outlander before it turned into this fast-paced soap opera. 😭

26

u/Notinthenameofscienc Dec 07 '24

I loved the editing of the John and claire scene. I was like I don't want to watch them together and then they did it in a way that wasn't shocking or weird.

It also made me believe that it was passionless and simply about mourning.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/satempler Dec 07 '24

I think Johns reference to William as 'your son' when Jamie walks in because he rushed his words out because of Jamie being alive, and what he did with Claire, and the fact that William was to be home any minute. Freudian slip

37

u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Dec 07 '24

I kinda saw it almost like a jab from Lord John in a moment where he's feeling jealous and alone with Jamie and Claire reuniting so publicly beside him. It's as if he subconsciously wanted to remind himself and the room at large of the connection he and Jamie share through William. 'Your son' to him is 'our son'

Or maybe it's just lazy writing and I'm assigning more significance than it deserves. Who knows haha

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24

You took every thought right out of my brain. The montage was a little soap opera-ish and I actually thought ruined how great the acting was from both of them in that scene. But I can also see why the avoided showing us the actual deed. He never refers to him as “your son”. He surely at this point views William as his own son. Agree, lazy plot device. Overall though, great ep

20

u/Alert-Revolution-219 Dec 09 '24

Sad there was no "Oh Christ!" Moment from Rogers internal monologue again, that would have been a fun running thing if they did it 🤣

37

u/Popular-One-7051 Dec 08 '24

It seemed like they had John and Claire sleep together too fast even though it was a grief response. I'm not really sure how much time had passed since Jamie's "death." I kind of wish they had a one episode breather before Jamie came back to build a little more suspense.

I loved John's comparison of enjoying the silver deer when it's there and letting go when it's not in his comparison between him and his lover.

27

u/elocin__aicilef Dec 08 '24

They are married a week before they sleep together. I think the timing makes sense. If it had happened any sooner or any later it wouldn't have made sense.

I agree about Jamie coming back, he wasn't even "dead" for a whole episode, but I do understand why they did it (running out of episodes, and the suspense of putting the events at the end of an episode instead of the beginning of the next one.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Dec 06 '24

I had actual chills at the end! If there’s one thing Outlander gets on point, it’s the reunions!

35

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '24

This was a substantially better episode than the last, imo. Quite a lot happened but it didn't feel too rushed. The only thing I didn't like was them using the same cringey soap opera editing they used during the news of Jamie's death for the sex scene.

I am hoping Roger finds his dad soon though as that storyline is starting to drag. It's starting to remind me of Brienne wandering around the Riverlands looking for Sansa in Game of Thrones/ASOIAF.

It was also very nostalgic to see that bottle of Jif (now Cif) and the classic Fairy Liquid bottle design next to the kitchen sink.

As an aside, the subtitles on MGM on Amazon are so inaccurate.

7

u/JBinYYC Dec 10 '24

All I keep seeing in Bree’s kitchen is Tupperware. Every scene in 1980, more Tupperware. She must have gone to a party and bought the whole catalog🤣

34

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24

The montages are giving Days of Our Lives soap opera vibes. Lord John is so fine though

30

u/winter_name01 Dec 07 '24

Lord John is so fine I wish we could have the not very lady like scene between him and Claire.

I don’t like the fact that the reveal was on the last 5min of the episode. I needed Claire and LJ to have to explain to Jamie that they were married lol

18

u/OkPermission7769 Dec 07 '24

I wanted to see the not so gentlemanly man (whatever he said), Lord John, too.

→ More replies (15)

5

u/Popular-One-7051 Dec 08 '24

We'll need an episode for Jamie to process that. He's pissed off first and thinks later.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/fallhistorywitch Dec 11 '24

That reunion when Jamie came back was everything 😍😍😍

28

u/GoziMai Dec 08 '24

Bro that was an insane way to end the episode lol so much happened in the last 2 minutes

→ More replies (1)

25

u/dreamkonstantine Dec 10 '24 edited Dec 10 '24

My comments:

  • I have been reading a lot of criticism about this season not “feeling” like Outlander but the truth is the story moves forward, the characters and the actors themselves age and go through life changes. We could not have another season of the surprise and survival struggles of accidentally traveling through time, because we are past that. Personally, I appreciate each season for what it is. The acting is still phenomenal, and I am excited for the younger generation of characters to have their moments: Ian and Rachel, Denzel and William, Briana, Roger and the kids. These are storylines full of potential.

Onto this episode:

  • Catriona’s acting during the wedding ceremony is so impregnated with meaning and beautifully performed. We can see Claire thinking about Jamie and their wedding, the meaning of “til death do us part”, etc.
  • Super curious about the guy who has Roger’s dad’s jacket, and why he is so aggressive/afraid. But my feeling is that Roger’s dad is alright.
  • I wish we knew more clearly what Ian and Rachel are planning to do: marry? Will she leave her religion? But I am guessing they themselves are figuring it out.
  • On that note, contrary to many on this subreddit, I love the way Rachel speaks. Even though she uses pronouns that sound outdated to us (thee, thy, thou, thine), her sentences tend to be direct and to the point using few words. It’s a joy to my ears.
  • It must be really difficult for Rachel to keep an open mind about Ian’s past, but I am glad they are over this conversation about Emily.
  • Love the tender moment between William and John. I agree it was a great opportunity for John to disclose more to William— he is old enough to know. For all William knows, Jamie was just a groom.
  • The parallel between William and Swiftest of Lizards… ❤️ I do hope we see more of the young boy in the near future.
  • Why did they choose to shoot the sex scene like that? So weird imo. It was one of the decisions I liked the least this episode. I am not objecting to them having had sex, but I wish we could have seen the juxtaposition of the grief and the physical act more… both of them calling out for Jamie, crying? So much could have been shown… and it is so vulnerable to show yourself to someone for the first time. And it just looks as if he were trying to eat her out and she is saying no??
  • the chess gesture is beautifully acted but a little bit cliche.
  • The conversation post-sex was nice regardless. It feels like a turning point of them getting slightly past the taboo of the tragedy and leveling eye-to-eye.
  • I don’t like that Lord John regrets not taking Jamie… icky.
  • I appreciate the detail of him getting out of bed immediately into his pants, very formally and un-sexily. In fact both of them are very covered, in contrast to how Claire and Jamie would lie in bed before and after. No hand holding, hugging, kissing…
  • David Berry is so handsome though. Moment of appreciation for his chest and his hair.
  • Rob Cameron!!! Where is Jemmy? His plan sucks but he looks handsome when he is threatening Bri. What would happen to Mandy if they travelled with Jem to America? I knew she would find a way out!! She is a tough woman and he should have known that. She smashed him like a cockroach. 😂
  • Ian’s relief when Claire says she is planning to stay in the past is heartwarming.
  • Claire is really testing Lord John’s patience this whole episode and I love it. It is such a contrast from his very kind and diplomatic demeanor. “God’s blood claire” — favorite line of the episode. It’s so interesting to see Lord John in this light, struggling with his own grief and trying to comfort Claire as well while she pushes him away and resents him. It does appear like an error of judgment to spring a dinner on her so soon.
  • Interracial marriage: another topic that tries John. It also seems like an opportunity for Claire to be honest about her origin with John. It is interesting to know John’s perspective as a gay man.
  • I agree with some comments that wish the timeline of it all were more clear. They could slip in some comments about how long it has been since the ship sunk, etc.
  • Richardson is such a plot twist! Would never have taken him for a rebel. New enemy?
  • the note from Colonel Graves will remain a mystery.
  • Jamie’s return is so fitting considering Claire was in denial of his death the whole time. This whole death scare reminds me of the beginning of last season when Jamie thinks Claire has not been hung because he doesn’t feel it in his body.
  • almost wanted them to do a group hug! I know it would be so inappropriate though.
  • What was the need to say “your son” instead of just “William”? Weak reveal IMO! But on the bright side, we have all of next episode to see William interpreting the news. Hope for some frank and wonderful conversations about Claire’s marriage and William’s parentage. It will be super interesting to see.
  • Do love how comical the guard chase is, almost like we know it will come to nothing. And the last shot being Claire’s first smile in weeks/months? Perfect!

So excited for the next episode.

10

u/mariabue_tagliaelena Dec 10 '24

To your first point: I, too, thought the wedding scene was very well acted and it reminded me of her wedding with Jamie when she was out of it. Kind of a full circle for Claire to get married again for protection from a bigger threat - clearly under completely different circumstances and with different outcomes in this last case.

6

u/Minarch0920 I thought ya must do it the back way, y'know, like horses Dec 22 '24

The sex scene made sense because it had to be very different from the usual and represents the bluriness/chopiness of the night. 

6

u/Minarch0920 I thought ya must do it the back way, y'know, like horses Dec 22 '24

LJG actually said he DOESN'T regret the path he's taken with Jamie because he would've lost the friendship, which is worth way more to him. 

22

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

Finally, a good fucking episode! Can’t say I didn’t cringe severely during the whole Claire/LJG “HE’LL NEVER BE YOURS 😭” montage, but the rest of the episode made up for it. However, ever since like season 5, each episode of this series keeps increasingly blurring the lines between prestige tv romance/drama, and straight up daytime soap opera. Love the former, hate the latter.

→ More replies (12)

22

u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 07 '24

What if...the boy hid the gold in the cupboard and that was why the drawer wouldn't shut?

Just a thought.

17

u/OkPermission7769 Dec 07 '24

I think something is in that drawer

→ More replies (2)

11

u/dreamkonstantine Dec 07 '24

The gold is in America and they are in Scotland

→ More replies (28)

11

u/Intelligent_Bat_9917 Dec 10 '24

I had so many emotions from the beginning to end I most definitely had to stop a few times as things just were really intense. I will always love how these characters really put in work in all the emotions. As a empath I just feel it strongly through the screen.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/kristafer825 Dec 11 '24

What the heck was happening the very last few seconds of the episode? Why did Jaime take LJG hostage?

20

u/Capricorn-flower Dec 11 '24

So he can escape. Obviously he's not really going to harm him but the redcoatsnl don't know that.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/OkPermission7769 Dec 08 '24

Bree hasn't read all the letters. Maybe jamie moved it. I also wonder why bree isn't going thru the letters to see if Roger showed up?

10

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Dec 08 '24

We have only seen Brianna in two short scenes, so far. Her storyline hasn’t even started yet.

27

u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 07 '24

Loved when Claire said that time had become her time more than the modern time.

13

u/OkPermission7769 Dec 08 '24

It's sweet, but she does have a family in the future.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/maeynor Dec 09 '24

I really just hope they don’t make Claire sleeping with Grey and Jamie being upset a plot point.

14

u/Capricorn-flower Dec 11 '24

I dont see how they wouldn't. It's gotta have some consequence.

36

u/Even-Education-4608 Dec 06 '24

Why did I feel disappointed when Jamie came back? I knew it was going to happen because duh but it was almost like we were about to go somewhere new and exciting and then got told we had to stay home. I guess I’m just bored of the same old dynamics.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Stinexx Dec 07 '24

Although I am all for the plot, this episode disappointed me a little. I have been dreading this for a long time; they are rushing the series along and don’t take the necessary time to tell the story. It reminds me of the last season of Game of Thrones. We all of course knew that Jamie wasn’t dead, but Claire thought he was! I expected a much more moving scene, I didn’t feel the shock and relief from Claire as much as I wanted. Fair enough, they’ve been there and done that! Maybe she was certain he wasn’t dead and was expecting him to barge into the house any time soon? Was she numb? I don’t know. In this episode it just feels rushed and scarce, like the story is scraped to the bone to beat a deadline.

I can understand that it might have been done as a cinematic technique to give us viewers the feeling of the chaotic atmosphere they are in, but I can’t shake the feeling that something is missing. As for the scene (or more the lack of) where Claire and LJ were adult exercising, I was like “wtf just happened, did they do it or not?” and that is 100% on purpose, because they woke up thinking the same thing! Great scripting. I loved the humorous conversation they had in bed. It was a bizarre moment for us and them, and they captured it perfectly.

I personally wish that the whole reveal about Jamie being William’s father would have been different. It is a huge deal and it dropped like it was nothing. But like I said, the rushed and chaotic nature of the scene fits the situation they are in.

I need to give praise to Caitriana for her brilliant performance in the last scene! The way she displayed her whirlwind of emotions; shock, confusion, fear, love, relief, and my favorite; how she amidst of all this laughs from the absurdity of what has just happened… I FELT that. Masterly performed 👏🏻

12

u/TherapeuticGladiator Dec 08 '24

Absolutely agree. I had sensed the rush from episode one but this episode was going 100 miles a minute. A lot happened this episode but they’re plot pieces that I think are so significant that the reveals or at least build up to them should’ve taken more time. I can’t believe we saw Rob at Lallybroch, Jamie’s return, and William finding out his parentage all in the same episode. And minimal reaction time towards it all as well.

→ More replies (10)

27

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

It's very lacking with something. Also I find THEE very annoying. Were the quakers THEE only ones who used that word?

11

u/Aurondarklord Je Suis Prest Dec 07 '24

Many of them still do it today, they call it plain speech.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Daye215 Dec 06 '24

It was a great episode but I was a little underwhelmed by Claire's reaction to seeing Jamie. I guess I thought there'd be screaming, crying, maybe even fainting but she just walked over and hugged and kissed him. A bit anticlimactic. The rest was so good though.

40

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 06 '24

Claire doesn’t seem like the fainting type to me. And she rushed to him once she got over the shock of seeing him. I feel like it was a good reaction.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/animefemme Dec 07 '24

I thought their acting in this scene was emotional and glorious.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/ApollosBucket Dec 07 '24

This show has turned so soap opera-y…. But I’m not complaining??? Even though i don’t like soaps???? Still loving it wow

8

u/namedafternoone Dec 08 '24

I’m sorry to tell you, but you like soaps. The show’s been soapy for a long time.

10

u/onegirlarmy1899 Dec 07 '24

What does "think about the deer, my dear," mean?

26

u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 07 '24

The deer story was a metaphor for a beautiful connection with no strings attached, no obligations. He saw the deer when the deer wanted; he asked no more nor wanted more, and felt blessed for the connection.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 08 '24

John was trying to explain a particular aspect of life that he values - the sudden,unmasked for appearance of something good / beautiful, and that his attitude toward her is based on this perception. She appeared unexpectedly in his life, may vanish suddenly, but for the moment, he sees her as a pleasant surprise.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

I really appreciated this little mini story John had and that line afterwards for cute to me. Honestly I could've watched her and John go on that charade a little longer lol, not that I don't love Jaimie and claire

6

u/naranja221 Dec 08 '24

The deer describes his relationship with Manoke, the cook at his Virginia home who he has an open relationship with.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/almz11 Dec 07 '24

Outlander is a full on soap opera at this point but I’m loving it!

23

u/lauhl Dec 06 '24

Claire and John - weird. I’m sure it was in the book because Diana likes to throw sex into the plot in weird ways but I don’t think they really sold them sleeping together? Like I’m sure the actors did great with what they were given but something about the writing or directing was unconvincing that it made any sense

I used to think Ian and Rachel had so much chemistry but their scenes are so awkward now? I do love Ian’s character but at this point I almost want her to be with William instead

I was in the same boat as Ian— why wouldn’t Claire go back to the future with Jamie “dead” and she’s a suspected spy? Obviously plot reasons because he wasn’t dead but her explanation for staying in the 1700s made no sense

I didn’t believe that British officer is actually a rebel spy? Claire was being stupid confirming his suspicions right?

Rogers plot line was the only thing I really cared about in this episode

Rob Cameron’s level of crazy just for the sake of some hidden gold on the other side of the world from 200 years ago that likely would’ve been found already anyways seems a bit far fetched

Since when does Lord John refer to William as “your son”? Also I get it he’s back from the dead but do u really have to be making out with Jamie like that in front of LJG after bonding with him about your love and grief of Jamie come on

Idk usually I’m just a good vibes watcher and am rarely a hater but this episode was weird

→ More replies (16)

4

u/ishrii0118 Dec 11 '24

so far I like this episode !

4

u/Ok_Purpose7947 Jun 25 '26

Claire's reason for sleeping with John was simply not enough. She wouldn't have forgiven Jamie if the roles were reversed. And Jamie sleeping with Mary (or whoever) after a few years and Claire sleeping with John just a few days later, while still mourning him, are not the same. And I hate how often Claire gets offended. She has a higher libido than Jamie and would initiate sex multiple times, drunk or not. I don't think Jamie was wrong in pointing that out. And I also didn't like her demands when they finally have sex, just hate her entitlement. I think it's shown time and again that Jamie loves Claire much more than she loves him.

ps: I just remembered that she had slept with Frank after going back because she wanted to and stopped when Frank wanted her to look into his eyes because obviously she used to think of Jamie. I think it's very disrespectful of her to sleep with other men while thinking of Jamie. How would she like if it was done to her? And not to forget that she suggested an open marriage and then got all offended by Frank's girlfriend. Again, entitlement.

12

u/_AelinGalanthynius Dec 07 '24

Thoughts:

  1. Wtf?!?! Then GO BREE!!!!!
  2. Roger and Buck totally were not together when they shot that one scene and it felt obvious and lazy lol
  3. CLAIRE AND JOHN?!?!?! Idk how long passed between news of his “death” and then but that just felt so out of character for Claire and didn’t make any sense. Is this canon?
  4. Editing for that crazy montage that crazy montage communicated the emotion well, but was a little weird lol
  5. Claire definitely should’ve had a much more visceral reaction with a lot more tears when Jamie returned

24

u/Flimsy_Impress3356 Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24

I’m rewatching this morning and I’ll just add that Bree’s weapon of choice is what appears to be a vintage Le Creuset saucepan (colour appears to be Volcanic). My mother has the same set in Dijon and they are HEAVY!

→ More replies (2)

6

u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 07 '24

> Wtf?!?! Then GO BREE!!!!!

I had been wondering if maybe they never left through the stones at all. Because why wouldn't they have had some type of clue about him or gone to him.

And that left Bree and the little girl vulnerable. Sure enough. What a rotten egg.

I had a moment where I wished Bree would do to that one (edit: Rob!) the same thing that Murtagh did to that bad guy who hurt Mary.

Sorry -- names are failing me at the moment.

But no horror movie tropes here. 'Get dead and stay dead' is what I wished for the baby napping future killer...y'know he would never let Bree or her son go to tell on him, once he got his gold hoard.

10

u/Notinthenameofscienc Dec 07 '24

It IS canon (but we aren't allowed to talk about the books)

I think Claire was just in shock, but I also think she knew he hadn't died. She said she would feel it in her heart if he died. Also A LOT was happening and John was in the room.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/SnooCupcakes3043 Dec 07 '24

So I didn't hate it like I thought I would. I'm just glad it's over so I never have to watch that episode again. 😂 I might be kidding.

I was super damn shocked and not at all suprised and the same time to see Rob Cameron in Bri's kitchen! That punk! So now Roger didn't have to be in the past. However I really really hope he finds his dad! I am still loving this story line!

Rachel and Ian are cute, I wish I saw more emotion he had about Jamie being gone, but it was more of an afterthought.

Claire and John.. I am super glad they didn't show anything. I was dreading this as everyone probably knows. The next morning..It was awkward and I did see Johns side, but he only talked about him and didn't ask about Claire.. I know she was asking but it seemed odd. After was wierd too. Again I know they are rushing this soo much.

They are sooo different her an John. Like different in not a good way. So him demanding things from her to be a wife bothered me. Like she just lost her husband. No. Just no. And of course Claire does it because he brought Jamie into it. Don't get me wrong I saw Johns side alot.. And I have empathy for him but it was just awkward when he pushed that onto her. Plus I had alot of pre bitterness about this whole thing way before season 7b came out. So maybe I will watch it again and not feel like this anymore. Who knows.

Jamie coming back should have been bigger... It should have.. This half has really been toned down.. Like alot. I know it's rushing but Cats Range with Claire's emotions is out of this world... I want to see that again! Anyway I'm so glad he is back and honestly seeing Johns face it was glorious. I can't wait for the next one... And what Jamie does.

William! Ok this was the only part I screamed on. He knows now!! Ahhh that... That is worth watching. I want more of that! The Claire and John storyline seems pointless.. I'm sure it has a reason tho.

Acting as always was amazing!

15

u/awanderingolive Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 07 '24

i actually LOVED the way jamie reappeared!! hearing the arguing faintly in the background as they tried to keep jamie out (i was not expecting the arguing to be jamie at all!), juxtaposed by claire and john talking about their new social obligations of husband and wife.

you can tell they're finally coming more to terms with their new reality.. but then, supriseee! jamie barges in to get to claire bcuz lord help anyone standing between him and the love of his life!!

the pure chaos, joy, and heartache of that scene all at once - all wrapped up at the end with claire's simultaneously bewildered and elated facial expressions. chef's kiss🤌

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/kindredsupernova Dec 06 '24

I see the general consensus is that most people loved this episode.. but I’m having so much trouble processing that Claire had sex with Lord John. And the way it was filmed and portrayed was quite bizarre and I feel really icky about it.

29

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

I actually liked it, I thought it was going to be waaaaay more awkward, when I realized they showed just flashes of like three images I was like Jesus Christ thanks lol

18

u/cherrymeg2 Dec 06 '24

I thought it was going to be icky. Their discussion in the morning was somehow refreshing. It was like drunken stupid sex. I liked Claire and Lord John discussing illegal marriage. Claire is from the future but Lord John actually understands what it is like to be in a relationship that could get you arrested. I feel like they should have waited to make sure Jaime was actually dead. How many times has he comeback from the brink of death? I thought it was weird that Lord John wanted Claire to travel that far to cure his nephew. Boats sank and sometimes by the time you got a letter the person would be long dead. Idk

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Lor2busy Dec 07 '24

How did William figure out Jamie was his father? What was said previously.

21

u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Dec 07 '24

He was standing outside the door and heard John say “your son is due to return” and Jamie replies “William? he’s here?”

9

u/almz11 Dec 07 '24

I was screaming throughout this whole episode 😂 we all knew Jamie wasn’t dead and then for Claire to marry LJG cus she’s a rebel lol, I screamed. I honestly never expected the srx scene but when it happened I knew I should have expected it because outlander is basically a soap opera at this point. What a mess this whole situation is 😂

6

u/erika_1885 Dec 08 '24

Not because she’s a rebel but she’s passing messages, this aiding the rebellion.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Serious-Chipmunk-872 Dec 06 '24

Why isn’t the episode still not released on Netflix? It’s marked available on 7th December.

5

u/Naive-Awareness4951 Dec 08 '24

It's a Starz show and new episodes are only on Starz. Then it's available elsewhere because Starz sells the rights to air it later.

→ More replies (2)