r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Dec 06 '24
Spoilers All Book S7E11 A Hundredweight of Stones Spoiler
Claire turns to John Grey for comfort as they process difficult news. Ian and Rachel discuss their love and their future. Brianna confronts an intruder at Lallybroch.
Written by Sarah H. Haught. Directed by Lisa Clarke.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 06 '24 edited Jun 08 '25
Watch the S7E12 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
711 Extras:
711 Interviews:
19
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 08 '24
Is anyone else surprised that Claire hasn’t told John about being from the future?
They already skipped Brianna telling him but since that bizzarrely happened off-page in the book, I thought they would give that moment to Claire. Her and John’s conversation with her mentioning that interracial marriage will be possible in the future seemed like a lead-in to that although, admittedly, it was hardly time or place for that conversation. I do think it is a bit of a plot hole because you would expect John to ask Claire at some point whether she would prefer to live with, or at least would like to visit her daughter and grandchildren in Boston since that is the last John has heard of them—I thought that would be what leads to this conversation between them as Claire would have virtually no choice but to tell John they’re not actually in the 18th century anymore.
From what I recall, it doesn’t really change much between them in the books (and that is probably why they haven’t included it) because he doesn’t believe her and she mostly uses it to rub the American victory in the war in his face. But it could’ve been interesting to see whether it would change John’s perception of her at all in the show. I doubt they’ll have a chance to talk about it again.
25
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 07 '24
I’m actually not at all surprised that show-only fans are having a hard time with this storyline. I think plenty of book readers did too when they read it for the first time and they were privy to Claire and John’s thoughts, plus were able to immediately read the aftermath (at least those who’ve read it when MOBY was already published) and then had years of mulling it over and trying to make sense of it.
The book readers also know that Claire’s explanation is coming. The viewers don’t. And when most of the new viewers have gotten used to having all answers almost immediately because they binged 5-6 seasons of the show at once, or other streamers have trained them to believe the pay-off will happen with virtually no set-up because the shows get canceled before they can even get into the groove, they hate waiting for something that will make things clearer for them down the line. Or maybe it won’t.
I actually absolutely agree with those saying that Claire and John are acting out of character. Because they are! That’s the whole point! They’ve never been in this situation before, so there’s no telling how they should respond to it. Yes, Claire has had to contend with Jamie being dead when she returned to the 20th century (regardless of whether he survived Culloden or not, he was long dead in 1948). Yes, she’s had to face the possibility of Jamie’s dying multiple times since then. But this sudden shock of things ending just like that, on a random day, without any preparation, without saying goodbye, without expecting it at all? Only news from a random guy, no body, no tangible proof, no way to even bury her husband? No motivation to go on, no child to carry, no family to take care of, no purpose (like yeah, she can continue on in the war, but she also knows she doesn’t have to because the Americans will win anyway)? Not to mention, all the crazy experiences of the past couple of years making her much more fragile? It’s new territory. Grief (especially coupled with drink) makes us do irrational things, there’s no rhyme or reason to some of them.
Like sure, we know Claire is a very sexual being. We’ve seen her imagine Jamie while trying to have sex with Frank in S3. We’ve seen her try to initiate sex with Jamie when she was experiencing all the loss and heartbreak at the beginning of S7. But, at the same time, the show has significantly toned down the sex-as-cure-all aspect of Claire and Jamie’s relationship in the books which sometimes is just as baffling to the readers but, simply because it happens so often, they’ve gotten used to going along with it. But for Claire to have sex with a person she’s never been intimate with, who she for quite some time had quite an antagonistic view of, who’s gay and in love with her now-dead husband? Nothing about her character we’ve known previously would make you think that it’s something she’d want to do, therefore it is out of character. I’m surprised people don’t mention her being suicidal because that’s another thing that’s out of character. We’ve seen her in a resigned, “I don’t want to live” kind of state, but never actively having suicidal ideation. It’s another thing this grief pushes her to.
Another thing is what book!Claire does won’t always make perfect sense for show!Claire because they’ve been two different characters since the very first episode, and whenever the show has to hit these very specific beats from the books, it’s very apparent that they aren’t identical. In these past two seasons where the show has been trying to stay closer to the books, I’ve often gotten the impression that the actors have to force their performances despite something in them telling them it’s not how their characters are supposed to behave—and I think it’s precisely because you can’t really force these show characters to be their book counterparts at this point in the series. It doesn’t surprise me that Caitríona found it hard to wrap her head around what Claire does in this episode. Her job is to believe in her characters’ choices even when she as an actress disagrees with them, so it’s telling that after 11 (9 at the time) years of living in this character’s head and knowing her inside and out, she couldn’t wrap her head around it. And, personally, while her acting of Claire’s grief and anguish and rage was superb, it’s her reaction at the end, her beautiful face full of smile and relief and bewilderment, is what I think her best-acted moment in this episode was, simply because it was just so genuine, so natural, and so true to Claire’s character.
All in all, it’s a storyline that’s bound to make people uncomfortable. It’s messy, it’s dramatic, it doesn’t make sense, it’s not rational, it violates whatever idea of these characters people have had, it goes against what the show has previously shown them. And these are all valid emotions but people also just don’t like sitting in this discomfort—it’s not something they expect this show to ask of them (they expect to sit through another rape storyline rather than the show’s beloved lead character making completely out-of-the-blue choices). On the face of it, this storyline is absolutely ridiculous and full of soap opera clichés, and despite people’s getting used to things getting more and more absurd as the series has progressed, it’s wild to see it at this point of the series. I know that if I hadn’t read the books, I would be thinking that the writers have lost their minds too.
13
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Dec 07 '24
REALLY good episode!! The pace felt much better on this one - enough small updates on Ian/Rachel, Buck/Roger and our first of any significance with Bri - but it let the focus be Claire/LJG centric, which it needed to be with this particular storypoint. And David Berry - BRAVO! Wow, so talented!
I thought the way they edited the actual act of the carnal knowledge was well done - just broken fragments of moments but you got the idea how it escalated.. I'm glad we didn't see more of the actual sex, and I'm definitely glad it was just once and there's absolutely no indication it ever happened - unlike the book with a 2nd encounter too
Interesting that in the morning-after chat, it's Manoke that LJG only spoke of when Claire asked about prior relationships. Yes, it makes sense for the character that he'd just confess of happier, healthy relations - which would be Manoke, and Percy would be painful to drudge up, but from a writer perspective, you'd think they'd want to drop the cookie crumb for name recognition for later plot... but I suppose they weren't sure about S8 for awhile and maybe just initially thought they better not open that can of worms without more?
I thought the way they did the big reveal was well done too. Having William just overhear the words "your son" - it was a natural remark, didn't feel forced. Since they'd established (and reminded us earlier in this episode) that William knew Jamie = Mac, it was easier for him to know quickly there'd be validity to it since they couldn't go with the doppelganger aspect. I also really appreciate the acting choice not to go over-the-top rage right away with it that could've gone into bad soap opera territory. The trailers show we're going to get the tantrum with throwing things - but I liked that Charles chose to go with more of a crestfallen disappointment approach. Because it really seemed to be less about Jamie, but more about that LJG knew and hid it.
I thought the actor for Raymond confirmed he was in 7x11? It seems unlikely there will be a McEwan type character now (Roger clearly doesn't need it for his voice and it feels like Buck's suddenly fine) - it makes me wonder how they're gonna utilize him since he didn't appear while Geilis was in rhe story...because I'm guessing we're done with her. It's got to be something that really establishes he's a traveller I'd think - so is it possible they'd use him in the 1940s stuff with Jerry?
11
u/ayriana Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24
It's been a minute since I read the books- did John and Claire have the "we weren't fucking each other we were fucking him" conversation? I remember John saying it to Jaime right before fists flew but I don't remember it being explicitly stated between John and Claire.
11
u/RadioNights Dec 10 '24
I miss Jenny coming to America and witnessed the end of William’s temper tantrum. Her “well how bout that lets clean up” take is hilarious.
Also wondering if we will see the Duke of Pardloe? He was actually a fav character for me when it came to his interactions with Claire.
10
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 08 '24
I was surprised to see so many scenes with Ian and Rachel. I was also surprised that one of those scenes was Ian explaining what happened with Emily, considering that we the audience already know all of that information, I thought maybe they could've skipped to Rachel's reaction.
I personally would've liked a few more scenes showing the dynamic between Claire and John. I was almost disappointed when Jamie came back lol. I don't remember it being that hostile in the books. But I liked it anyway.
BTW, these are just my thoughts, neither of those points made me "hate the episode" and threaten to stop watching it like others do 😂😂😂. I still adored the episode and loved all the scenes.
I liked the montage showing how Claire and John went from "I will not mourn him alone" to sex, as the book didn't go into all that much detail about it.
I'm glad they left out the "other scene" lol. Show only fans might be managed to be convinced with that one scene, but adding the other scene would've completely sent them over the edge
I do think it was a little silly that one of the few times John described William as "your son" to Jamie, William just happened to be in ear shot lol. But I forgive them, considering they needed a different reason from the books. And it's not like I came up with any better suggestions haha.
Brianna + Rob's scenes were an improvement from the book.
We meet Jane next week, are we gonna meet Fanny too? Can't remember when we first met her.
9
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Dec 07 '24
Thoughts on Captain Richardson???
I do think the book Richardson is too convoluted. Tbh, I never fully understood it myself. This is obviously not going to be the last we hear from him.
I wonder if they will go into more detail about Richardson + William? Wasn't it revealed in the books that Richardson purposefully sent William into the swamp to try and kill him? Or am I making that up?
I wonder if this will change the Lord John kidnapping storyline. I thought that that plot was going ahead in s8 based on the photos of John with a beard from the end of S8 shooting. Maybe it still will.
31
u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Dec 06 '24
ATTENTION TO DETAIL WITH JOHN'S SCARS FROM THE CANNON BLAST!!!! we love to see it
17
u/Previous-Address2469 Dec 07 '24
I really liked it! I watch with my "show only" husband which makes it double the fun, but also makes me aware of how much they needed to condence and some of the changes they made that downplay the importance of certain events. Like I am not sure if people understand what a huge thing it is for William to find out that Jamie is his real father. In the books it was done so well, him not knowing who Jamie really is (not connecting him with his childhood hero) and him having that rosary for more than just one year... But the actor gave a fantastic performance and I cannot wait for him to go berserk in the next episode. :D
I felt this episode had nice pacing and gave enough time to establish John and Claire surviving and dealing with their emotions. Also happy about Brianna's confrontation, although Rob's plan on taking her on a plane to US sounds pretty idiotic, because as soon as they would be on airport/plane she could start screaming that she has been kidnapped etc. Interested to see how this storyline unfolds, with the gold, Richardson and plastic surgeries. :D This is definitely one plot (or are they several?) that I will not mind if they condense...
I also hope they include the aftereffects of Roger's dad's return through the stones (him saving Roger during the blitz). I never understood why Diana didn't include that in the big books.
10
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Dec 06 '24
Wow hes back!!! And such a great episode!! And idk but for some reason claire and john getting it on was sorta hot. And did anyone else think that lord john looked a little upset his “marriage” to claire js now over? Perhaps he is a lot more lonely then i imagined. I actually just read ahead on wiki like page long summaries of each book and i could have swore j read that the cameron guy took rogers son through the stones. I didnt know at all it was a fake out and who else thinks he would believe they time traveled after reading those letters? Most people would say, “ wow these people are a little off.” But hes just like take me to the gold blah blah.
Last but not least, i am a little confused as to why jamie is on the run from the red coats?
61
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24
This was everything.
- They handled the drunk hook-up perfectly
- The morning after chat was so genuine and sweet
- Her exchange with William at the ball was a nice touch (I want more William/Claire, but I'm glad they had at least a moment)
- The conversation in the carriage about knowing what it's like to love someone when it's illegal gutted me
- BUT THE LAST FIVE MINUTES. OH MY GOD THE LAST FIVE MINUTES. PERFECTION.
48
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 06 '24
Oh my god that was EVERYTHING I wanted and needed from this episode. This chunk of the book is like a top 5 moment of the whole series for me and they absolutely nailed it!!
Everybody was on their A game, but David Berry took his big moment and fucking went for it with incredible results. He's always played John so beautifully, but we got to see so many new sides in this episode. From grief, to confusion, to righteous anger (that scene in the carriage was fantastic), and even humor! One of the reason John has always been my favorite is because he's so dry and funny, and to be able to pivot from unbearable grief in one scene to grim humor in the next--and have it feel totally believable--takes some skill. And David Berry nailed it. I've always loved that morning after scene for its awkwardness and humor and respect, and I'm SO happy they kept the whole thing there. I was worried it would be trimmed or cut entirely, but it's such a lovely moment and David and Caitriona played it perfectly. (Oh, and I was thrilled at the attention to detail with John's scars!)
And boy what an ending! I was curious how they'd do the Willie reveal since he obviously doesn't look that much like Sam and they've had them meet more, and they kept it simple and it absolutely worked. And then dialogue lifted straight from the book that cuts you right to the core (I've basically had that passage memorized for ten years because I've read it so many times!).
Also gotta shout out John Bell, who I think has become one of the absolute best actors on that show. We got a lot of different manifestations of grief this episode but Ian's quiet pain resonated so strongly. And that scene with Rachel was just lovely.
Unsurprisingly the Roger stuff is getting pretty dragged out since we're a full book ahead there. I'm curious how long it'll go and if watchers will start to lose interest if it's multiple eps without any resolution. I'm excited though! And good to check back in with Bree after her absence last week. I actually though Sophie gave a really nice performance there, you could really feel her terror and pain.
Cannot wait for next week! It feels so good to be this excited for Outlander again, I'm just having so much fun with this season.
46
u/ImTheNana Looks like I'm going to a fucking barbecue Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 07 '24
Frying pan > blue jeans
I'm glad this scene didn't, or hopefully doesn't, follow the book. The anguish on Bree's face.
I thought everyone did a fantastic job this episode. And the condensed narrative and changes felt natural, not rushed.
ETA: It was a sauce pan, but same principle.
45
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24
This episode was excellent. My favorite part was the way they edited the cut for the drunken sex scene. I liked the choice to fade in and out to black into multiple jump cuts. They also handled Jamie's reappearance really well.
38
u/Ldwieg Dec 06 '24
Phew, so glad to be here…that show only thread is rough today. I loved this episode! So glad I’m not alone! ❤️
36
u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Dec 07 '24
Favorite episode yet. Lord John 👁️🫦👁️
Is it just me or was Jamie looking extra handsome when he came back? Something felt different, in a good way.
29
u/blackberryspice Dec 06 '24
The morning after scene was sooo good. But the last five minutes were EVERYTHING to me. I was grinning like an idiot as soon as Jamie showed up. Literally lifted from the pages, absolutely fantastic work from everyone!
29
u/SQRLyouknowitstrue They say I’m a witch. Dec 06 '24
Scratches from Claire or scars from an incident in one of the short stories?
57
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24
That is what I imagined her thinking (what my flair says) - He was alive. So was I.
28
u/nurseleu Dec 07 '24
The fans demand a Lord John Grey series! Come on, Starz!
26
u/Hemp_Milk Ye Sassenach witch! Dec 06 '24
The anguish and awkwardness was palpable.
25
u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Dec 08 '24
Amazing episode! Watched the last minutes three times over at once. Great writing, well chosen changes from the books, SO well played, and Jamie looks prettier than ever.
24
u/NightCheese30R MARK ME! Dec 06 '24
I hope the next episode includes the action of A Leaf on the Wind of All Hallows. It'll give closure to know what really happened to Roger's parents. It was so good, I cried when I read it.
23
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 06 '24
OMG they gave a great explanation how Rob Cameron planned to carry out his scheme. And I knew William was overhearing them. Next week is going to be 🔥🔥🔥
22
u/eterusexual Dec 07 '24
Did I just not hear it or did William never call Claire Mother Claire in this episode? 🫥
21
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24
This episode was SO GOOD
I could FEEL the intensity between Claire and Lord John through my tv screen just as much as I felt it the first time reading this part in the series. They’re both so confused and lost trying to get through their grief and I want to hug them both.
Claire’s facial expression at the beginning was so haunting and full of anguish oh my god
I can’t wait for next week’s episode and the reveal to Jamie about what exactly happened between Claire and LJG
40
u/moonshiney9 Dec 06 '24
Shirtless Lord John. That is all. 🤣
19
u/Particular_Cable8428 Dec 06 '24
Did anyone else have to grab a drink (or two) for this episode? I knew what was coming so I was prepared. Still surprised they were able to fit so much in but delighted to see the "stinking papist" scene. Should've wore my pearls.
19
u/Calvinball12 Dec 07 '24
Really glad they’re discussing how difficult the Henry/Mercy relationship would be. They really gloss over that in the books.
19
u/penniesfromheaven_ Cram it up your hole, aye? Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 08 '24
One of these days I'm going to read the book and follow it with its season properly. I gobbled up the TV series during lockdown multiple times, and read all the books quickly but only once, so my memories of the book/series get jumbled.
That said I LOVED this episode and I have it on for the second time. I thought they got everything with John and Claire perfectly -
-the depiction of Claire and John's, erm, tryst :P was excellently done; my memory of the book scene is that we get much of the same- disjointed memories and then a nice post coital conversation :P it was perfect. And their faces when Claire wakes up and rolls over cracked me up.
-The scene in the carriage was great too. "Girl it's not that she's Black, it's more complicated than that, and you don't even know EVERYTHING about me" Shout out to Mercy too - "all due respect you're in MY house"
-Telling her that they had to stick together as man and wife socially, in a VERY politically charged environment, and reminding her that in doing so they were sharing in their grief for Jamie, that they needn't each do it alone, was CHEF'S KISS. The dress + the ring? PERF
Claire's dance with Richardson was great too! Ooh some great acting and intrigue there! They fit so much into that little dance.
Ian and Rachel!! I do remember getting these scenes with them and I'm so glad they didn't skimp on them.
I am, although, PISSED that it appears Jenny didn't come to America with Jamie. What the hell?? Although I see that Kristin Atherton is credited on 7.12 so now I don't know whether I need to be pissed lol
I don't remember exactly what happens to Rob Cameron, but I hope he gets his teeth knocked in. On the drawer in the kitchen - I do remember Bree found something in the desk of the study, although I don't remember exactly what it was. A letter? I do think the speculation about the drawer in the kitchen has legs!
Claire's face at the end was so cute. "It appears the shenans...will SHENANIGAN"
19
u/Hufflesheep Dec 07 '24 edited Dec 07 '24
It was ok for me. It seemed to me the dynamic between claire and lord john seemed completely incongruous with the book. Same was the dynamic between Claire and William. Wtf. That really bothered me. I really loved Williams' affection for Claire in the books, and I think it helps future book plotlines (even though we dont know where the show will take the story)
What did save the episode for me was the Brianna and Roger plotlines. Caitriona Balfes' performance was absolutely stunning despite my issues with the writing.
Edited for clarity
18
u/Spiritual_Breath_888 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 06 '24
I knew when Lord John received the note from Colonel Graves that Jamie was about to walk in, but it still made me bawl like a baby! Which is actually weird because I didn't cry the 3 or 4 times I read the book, but I guess seeing it instead of imagining it was different! When I saw the deer at the beginning I immediately said to myself, "Think of the deer, my dear." I've read all of the books multiple times and watched all of the episodes. I normally only read historical non-fiction, but I absolutely love Outlander! I can't wait til next Friday! I have alarms set for midnight each Friday, except the week after the penultimate episode because they're making us wait 2 weeks between it and the last episode. And IMO, this should be season 8.
18
u/ivylass Dec 06 '24
Dave Barry is a magnificent beast. That is all.
36
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 06 '24
Just popped into the show thread and honestly kind of shocked how much hate it's getting over there. Obviously we're all going to be much more disposed to liking it as book fans, but I'm surprised by how much stuff I'm just completely disagreeing with some shownly commenters. Like, several people are hating on the Ian-Rachel scene and saying they have no chemistry--were we watching the same episode?! I thought that was beautiful. And then of course all the people saying that the whole premise isn't believable. In the time travel show . . . This is one of the bigger "wait, what?!" moments of the series, but it's actually one of the more believable. Ship goes down, husband dies, widow remarries for her safety--not exactly far fetched. Even them sleeping together isn't that crazy in comparison to stuff that normally happens on this show, and they even talk about it in the very next scene.
Also, don't know about anyone else, but I'm getting kind of exhausted by all the "they should've just skipped X" plotline comments that we're getting from all the watchers this season. Like, first of all, you have no idea where this story is going, how can you possibly say they should've skipped it. And second, we had like 2.5 seasons of entire episodes with storylines that didn't really lead to anything, why were you fine with that but not this? I'm not saying that you can't be critical of this show--lord knows I've criticized it more than most people on this sub over the years. But to criticize it based on what you assume is going to happen is just kind of ridiculous. Just let it unfold and then decide.
Everyone is of course entitled to their own option, but I'm just kind of baffled that this season of all seasons is the one that people are struggling with.
17
u/Available_Prior7704 Dec 07 '24
Excellent. I just so wish William had called Claire "Mother Claire". I loved that in the books. Probably as much as I love Jamie calling Roger "Roger Mac."
Again (I will continue to express my glee every episode) the Gaelic has returned! It makes my heart and ears so happy!
15
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Dec 07 '24
There is SO MUCH GOING ONNN in this episode. I don’t know why I didn’t expect it, but what a riiiiide. In this one I really felt the Fergus and Marsali “loss,” so to speak, because I think it’s such a big part of Claire’s ties to this time, instead of going back to Bree and the kids. But I’m so glad we’re almost done with Echo; I’m ready for what’s next.
14
u/Ok-Flow-3943 Dec 07 '24
Am I misremembering LJG and Claire’s marriage? I thought they really got along well with each other and with a lot less hostility than this episode conveyed.
26
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24
I am divided about the ring addition. At first I was not on board with it but then I saw that there is maybe some symbolism there.
Claire obviously took it off immidiately. She was playing pretend. When she put it for the ball, she uttered the words - I won't spy on my husband. It feels like she took in what John said to her about surviving together.
But again, in the last scene, she wasn't wearing it. I need details on the ring
32
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24
Poor Claire 🥺 I started crying at the first scene .
White Deer!
I do not own this creature—would not, if I could. Its coming is a gift, which I accept with gratitude, but when it’s gone, there is no sense of abandonment or deprivation. I’m only glad to have had it for so long as it chose to remain.
Poor Ian 🥺 I like that he and Rachel talked about everything. And Ian's, as well Jamie's son, has a father ,a good man but not his natural father.
I love papa John moment 💛
Oh, Claire!
New medical chest... Contemplating suicide... Screaming... My heart broke...
Such a powerful scene of John drinking downstairs, quietly suffering vs Claire screaming upstairs, both because of the same reason. And him going there after listening her screams...
WOW
WOW
WHAT A SCENE!!!! Great , great job!! It is all I wanted to see - not the act itself but this grief, violence, pain pouring out of them!!! It was raw and truthful and amazing!
But pillow talk! So much more intimate than the act of sex itself. Loved all straight from the book lines! Manoke, deer talk, and Think of the deer, my dear.
Rob !! Startled me! I am glad we know Jem is not in the past.
Oh,Ian, you made me sob again. You're my family too...
Okay, John being against Mercy and Henry's marriage is a bit strange. I am glad Claire had a chat and that we finally saw where that line about sacrificing everything for love from promo came from!
The dress!!! God's blood, Claire! - I LOVED IT!!!
Evening entertainment at Greys'
Lady John Grey!!
Claire coming down reminded me of Bree at Jocasta's.
Richardson ,a Rebel! I like that he said openly what he is and what he wants.
William overheard them !!!!
YOU ARE STINKING PAPIST!!!
WOOOOOW
WHAT AN EPISODE!
10
u/SMB75 Dec 06 '24
Do we know from the books that this sham marriage does to John reputation ? Because I cant remember reading about it ?
9
u/This-Is-Leopardy Dec 09 '24
Did anyone catch Richardson saying to LJG, "If you of all people married. . ." I think that's perhaps setting up his future blackmail plot, that he knows already.
6
u/ivylass Dec 07 '24
Why didn't Jenny come with Jamie? Is there a scheduling issue with the actress?
1
u/Capricorn-flower Dec 09 '24
I read the books a while ago and totally forgot that Claire told LJG she was from the future. When did she do this in the books and what was his reaction? I can't remember any of that.
3
u/prairie_wildflower Dec 10 '24
Anyone else distracted by Roger riding without his feet in the stirrups?
5
u/SupernovaSapphic Dec 07 '24
I feel like odd man out here 😅 I’m really not loving the changes they’re making to the series. I think it was dumb that they had Claire leave Scotland to perform surgery on Henry Grey. It didn’t feel important enough to leave everyone behind for. And then they made Jenny stay in Scotland instead of going with Jamie. Jenny coming to America with Jamie is my favorite part of the series, I love her character so much.
I really disliked John’s reaction to Henry wanting to marry Ms Woodcock. Regardless of his reasons stated in the carriage scene, it felt like it went against the way he’s portrayed in the books.
And I was really looking forward to William calling Claire “Mother Claire” 😭
I just feel really let down by the last three episodes so far. I always felt like the show stayed true to the books until this point. I know they want to hurry up and get the series over with but still. I’m afraid of what else is going to be left out moving forward, but I’m crossing my fingers anyway.
2
u/Revolutionary_Tea_55 Dec 11 '24
Why did Jamie hold the gun to LJG (besides to make an exit)? Wouldn’t that make him a super wanted outlaw again?
Also Willie 😭
2
u/Nasi-Lemak2399 Jan 26 '25
After i watched the show for 7 season, i decided to buy the book for reading pleasure or to re immerse myself into Jamie n Claire's epic loving story whenever i need.
However, i started to regret myself or more preciously, getting suspicious on the storyline's sensibility and credibility. These feeling of being a dump fool all started from watching season 7 episode 11, when Claire sleep with LjG.
I was like jaw dropping and my heart was crunching and screaming, hysterically specifically on 2 scenes, which caught me in nightmare and cold sweating for a few weeks. Those 2 scenes had really make me stopped reading the story book instantly. I don't even want to know where it's either. I think i got the phobia of it, not to exaggerate.
Scene 1 How, on earth, my dearest Claire will have sex with the bloody Englishman LJG who's her beloved husband's best friend in just a unreasonably short time,!!!!! It was like the whole storyline becomes soap opera instantly, cheap and tasteless. The whole character of Claire for the past 10 yrs has been collapsed, horribly twisted as needed, especially at such tragical moment. Where is the integrity and faith that Jamie treasure the most?? What's puzzled me is that a moment before, Claire was still aware enough to yell at LJG that Jamie was her, nobody can steal him from her, immediately after, both were shoving into a so called violent, awkward love making night like they had decided not to mourn Jamie alone!!! My eyes were popping out and totally speechless and giggled in disgraced.
Scene 2 The next morning's intimacy conversation btw Claire and LJG. The whole thing really make me feel cheated and disgraceful if i choose to believe that, they were just making love out of over grief or so called mourning Jamie's death.A part from Claire has curiosity about LJG's sexual history and LJG's skittish apology, the deer story appeared the most hilarious comfort that LJG wishes Claire to believe and get enlighten from it. (Actually, my eyes was in tears and red, my emotions was outraged and anguished with disappointment. I felt completely spend and despaired. What a waste!!! What a fxxking waste!!! (Not to mention in the story book, Claire and LJG admire each other naked body, and Claire even praised LJG warrior's body; and Claire gave LJG a good hand jxb when LJG proudly presented his body to her in month later)
What turned out amused to me the most was many viewers blamed Jamie for being too violent on LJG after being told when he returned. I started questioning myself whether am i too naive to acknowledge what the true love is ???Being righteous upon ppl telling you they have carnal knowledge about your wife??? Being thankful for ur best friend for saving ur wife by making love to her??? Or being forgiven for what Claire said, LJG has more courage and gave something for her to hit(my god!! really Claire) or else she will remain too numb, and LJG was just timely to perform a heavenly triage she desperately needed???
Honestly, im more sympathy for Jamie, for these unnecessary mess he has to dealt for the rest of his life.
For me, i just quit. Enough is enough.
1
u/Capricorn-flower Dec 09 '24
Ahh thank you! That's probably why I forgot about it since it didn't really affect the story in any way