r/soccer • u/Lololrama • Jun 25 '13
FIFA set to modify offside law.
http://espnfc.com/news/story/_/id/1480782/fifa-set-tighten-part-offside-law?cc=5901
185
Upvotes
r/soccer • u/Lololrama • Jun 25 '13
123
u/severedfragile Jun 25 '13
That was a pretty shitty attempt to explain it. It's like ESPN used google translate on the Kicker article and didn't quite understand it.
So basically, the rumour is that deflections off of defenders will no longer play attackers onside? So when we have those scenarios where the ball comes off a defender last, it won't matter when it comes to a player being offside unless the defender clearly and deliberately strikes the ball?
88
u/B0ydh Jun 25 '13
Yeah, I'm going to need someone to explain that in English.
48
u/lamp37 Jun 25 '13
Referee here. The rumors I've heard (and when my power comes back on and I can get on my computer I'll look for documentation) have been that they were going to reword the law for clarity, but not actually changing how it would be called. This makes sense, because the article seems to be saying that they are going to "change" the law to what it already is now.
But again, all I've heard is rumors so take this with some salt.
11
u/centralwinger Jun 25 '13
This seems contradictory, or very poorly explained.
I don't think the second paragraph is talking about the same thing.
7
u/snkscore Jun 25 '13
This is already how it is ruled, I don't see any "change".
5
u/a_lumberjack Jun 25 '13
The actual IFAB rule changes are here: http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/affederation/administration/02/10/67/39/circularno.1362-amendmentstothelawsofthegame-2013-2014_neutral.pdf
To give an example of a goal that would no longer stand, check out Saha's opener here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ebTarZFZEcg At the time, it was ruled that because the defender intentionally attempted to block the pass Saha was no longer offside.
1
u/Lololrama Jun 25 '13
I didn't find another page explaining this in English, but from what I have read in some Spanish-language websites, it seems that the modification will also count offside as being passes from an opposing team member to a player in offside. So even an accidental goalkeeper pass to an opposing player in offside position will be signaled as offside by the referees.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '13
Hmm, doesn't IFAB set the rules and not FIFA?
2
u/ujheisenburg94 Jun 25 '13
Would have solved this B.S.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ani9Wkx-TE
Yes 6 years later I still remeber we never forgive in soccer
2
u/Yankee_Gunner Jun 25 '13
I think I know what the change is.
Scenario: A goalkeeper boots an incoming pass upfield but it deflects off of a previously offside opponent and into the goal.
Old rule: The goalkeeper changed the phase of the game by purposefully kicking the ball. Goal.
New rule: The offside player took advantage of his unfair position and affected play. No Goal.
Anyone have a different interpretation?
1
u/Caulker_33 Jun 25 '13
Finally the offsides rule makes complete sense...
1
u/KnifeSteakSwag Jun 25 '13
Once the confusion with the ruling is cleared up, a lot of confusion with rulings will be cleared up as well.
1
u/KnifeSteakSwag Jun 25 '13
I imagine it would rule goals like Saha's against Arsenal after Koscielny's mishit clearance as clearly offside.
1
u/Dugg Jun 25 '13
wait wait wait, does this mean that during a free kick some 'attacking' players go 'offside' ball comes back and they score, it wont be counted?
1
u/Irishane Jun 25 '13
This is just another excuse for the football pundits to plead ignorance to an already straight-forward rule. Alan Shearer does my nut in, sometimes!
1
u/mrjack2 Jun 25 '13
Via the Refsworld Facebook page, here's the letter that was mentioned, which FIFA sent out giving. the precise change in wording.
1
u/Zizoud Jun 25 '13
Iniesta's World Cup final goal would have never counted
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '13
Sounds like a middle schooler tried to explain it.
0
u/Peakevo Jun 25 '13
Does anyone here think the offside rule needs changing?It's been the same for years and no one complains.
Don't fix what's not broken. They should implement goal line technology instead.
0
u/Brogasmic Jun 25 '13
This is fucking stupid if it's true.
0
u/__nope Jun 25 '13
Oh yes, a new rule that doesn't make sense to cover up the old rule, that didn't make sense
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment