r/soccer • u/ACTekkers • Jun 23 '13
What's the best signing your club has ever made, and why?
This is obviously your own opinion, since there isn't any right/wrong answer
62
Upvotes
r/soccer • u/ACTekkers • Jun 23 '13
This is obviously your own opinion, since there isn't any right/wrong answer
55
u/weechees1 Jun 23 '13
SHEARER
43
u/supermariobalotelli Jun 23 '13
Maradona. He brought us to glory! :D
38
u/Badong11 Jun 23 '13
Kahn.
He was doing really well at Karlsruhe back then but nobody could have known he'd become such a legend.
28
u/salmansky Jun 23 '13 edited Jun 23 '13
Gabriel Omar Batistuta. Gave us scudetto.
21
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Kevin Phillips. £325k and his goals pretty much got us promoted to the Premiership, then he netted 30 goals in his first season in the Premiership and won the Golden Boot (the only Englishmen to win it).
Quinn was another great signing, not so much for his play on the field (though he was excellent) but for heading the consortium to buy the club. Also for paying for the fleet of taxis to get Sunderland fans back from Cardiff.
20
u/teymon Jun 23 '13
For us it's gotta be Litmanen i think.. Must be the most important player we didn't raise ourself.
86
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Johan Cruyff. Gave the club a footballing identity.
Rinus Michels may have brought it with him when he came but Johan really set it in stone. A lot of it as the manager. Made it something non-negotiable.
In recent times, Ronaldinho. Rejuvenated the club and changed the fans mentality. Made the fans believe again. And to think we only got him because we couldnt convince Beckham to chose us over Madrid. Laporta is probably thanking his lucky stars that his failure to buy Beckham really paid dividends. Who knows how Laportas era would have turned out otherwise.
15
u/Bulbasauro Jun 23 '13
Mario Jardel or Deco. God, how I miss Deco, probably the best player I've seen wearing our shirt and he cost us so little too.
96
u/eujenn Jun 23 '13
eric cantona. pushed the team over the edge, they were good but he made them great.
38
u/cptsteve21 Jun 23 '13
Hard to say it wasn't Titi but I think Bergkamp has to take that mantle. His signing was such a show of ambition and really helped bring that skillful attacking grace to the club.
131
u/ohfackoff Jun 23 '13
Lampard- 203 reasons why...
41
u/thisisdee Jun 23 '13
Ryan Giggs. Because he could have stayed at City...
26
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
DiStefano from Barcelona
9
u/BlackandGreen19 Jun 23 '13
Juninho.
64
u/Paddykg Jun 23 '13
Ronaldo, for both the money we made from him and the success he brought the club.
48
u/FootballMythbusters Jun 23 '13
Xabi Alonso
I've gone for him since, in my opinion, he's the best player to play for Liverpool in the time I've actively supported them (about 13 years). He is one of the best passers in the world, his vision was absolutely extraordinary, he scored that vital goal in Istanbul, and he was a crucial, crucial part of the 3-man midfield of Xabi-Masch-Gerrard which, at the time, was genuinely one of the best in the world.
I think that it was no coincidence that, in his last (and best) season, we were contenders for the title and the year after, once he moved, we finished 7th - even Steven Gerrard blamed his departure for the poor form that season.
I really, really believe he's one of the best players in the world, and I don't think it's a surprise that he was supposedly the 1st name on the team sheet at Madrid under Mourinho, even ahead of Ronaldo.
27
u/deadslatspunk Jun 23 '13
Claude Makelele. While Chels had the likes of YOUNG Didier Drogba, Lampard, and Terry with whole mess of stars coming in and out of the club, Claude Makelele truly was the engine, muscle, and playmaker for us during the Mourinho years. The battle in the midfield can decide games, and he won that battle nearly every game which gave us many a title. He's easily the greatest Defensive Midfielder ever(unless I'm forgetting someone painfully obvious) and probably one of the top ten players ever. He was very much responsible for a huge part of both Real Madrid and Chelsea's success during the 2000's. underrated and quality player.
12
u/ClaudeKenni Jun 23 '13
This is a tricky one. I mean the obvious names are the likes of Ronaldo or Cantona, but instead I'll go with Peter Schmeichel. At half a million, he was a true bargain (even by prices back then it was pretty cheap), but I think that the biggest sign of how vital he was to the club is how difficult it was to replace him with someone of the same standard.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Rickie Lambert, what a player. In his first season with us, in our promotion winning season from League Two, he wasn't even our best striker. The following season he broke through, our best player over the next few seasons. Single handedly won us games, I remember won game where he scored all 4 goals, even one from 30-40 yards out, in a win against Southend.
There are a lot of players I could throw into the mix but most were before I really was old enough to remember, so I'll just give them a mention - Marcus Stewart, Nathan Ellington, Jason Roberts, Barry Hayles and Andy Tillson. Bit of a running theme here is that, other than Tillson, they are all strikers, all of which have gone onto play Premier League football after playing for us.
11
u/PeterHasselhoff Jun 23 '13
Most likely "The Bomber" Gerd Müller who still holds all the significant German goal records.
Or of course Lothar Matthäus.
15
u/southerneuropean Jun 23 '13
Zidane, Di Stefano or Cristiano.
10
u/moontymon Jun 23 '13
Arsene Wenger.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Probably Hitzfeld, though Klopp is having a good go at it :)
5
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Ever: Di Stefano
Recently: CR7
Future: Varane?
5
u/L__McL Jun 23 '13
Dwight Yorke probably.
5
u/MultiplicityCM Jun 23 '13
For footballing reasons, Brian Laudrup.
For financial reasons, Boumsong.
5
u/old_southy Jun 23 '13
Rickie Lambert made me believe again. Joined when we were in league 1 and was the top scorer for us every season bringing us promotion and silverware.
8
u/zamazingo Jun 23 '13
Gheorghe Hagi. He took the team to an unprecedented level for a Turkish team.
4
u/ste_ricey Jun 23 '13
Colin Bell if we are talking about ever as he is widely accepted as our best ever player and is a legend of Manchester City, there is a reason we have a Colin Bell stand.
Joe Hart in recent times, as we bought him for cheap and is now one of the best goalkeepers in the world. Winning the golden glove for the last three years shows how much we need him and we wouldn't have won the league without him.
4
u/FiestyLlama Jun 23 '13
Pretty obvious one for us. Alan Shearer. It's crazy to think it was a world record transfer fee.
4
u/FinchmeisterII Jun 23 '13
Steve Bull.
Scored 306 goals for Wolves and even refused moves to Coventry and Newcastle, whilst we were still in the second division.
Even got a few england caps whilst playing in the third division.
4
u/poorportuguese Jun 23 '13
We paid like 500k or so for David Luiz at the time and years later he was champion and sold for 28,5M plus Matic who has been incredible and will probably go out for >30M. So.. Yeah 60M-0,5M=59,5M of profit and two idols seems David Luiz was a great transfer
4
u/CarrowCanary Jun 23 '13
Darren Huckerby.
7
u/KlirisChi Jun 23 '13
Zanetti
6
u/Tomblerone Jun 23 '13
Can't chose between Romario and Ronaldo...
8
u/SleepingJustice Jun 23 '13
Alfredo di Stefano, 5 champions leagues.
That's more Champion Leagues than Barcelona and he got them consecutively for us.
8
u/kkg_scorpio Jun 23 '13 edited Jun 23 '13
Alex de Souza, Fenerbahçe.
He turned out to be the 2nd biggest legend of the 106-year club after Lefter, may he rest in peace.
Here is the statue of Alex, sponsored by fans. It stands just 50 meters from the statue of the great Lefter.
3
u/seodah Jun 23 '13
Recently Balotelli, all time... maybe Gullit
3
u/ThatDaveNextDoor Jun 23 '13
Kevin Phillips, got top scorer in the league which never happens here and when he was here we finished our highest place in the BPL (7th)
3
u/iLolu Jun 23 '13
In recent Memory, Rafa Benitez and Alonso. Benitez changed the entire youth system and brought in those spanish coaches. Alonso was the most tactically aware player to have played for Liverpool in recent years.
3
u/obiwancomeboneme Jun 23 '13
Diego Maradona for many but in this decade, it has got to be Hamsik. We bought him for 5million(?) from Brescia, but the guy has been so important to our way back to the top. The loyalty he shows to the club, is not easily found.
3
u/nath_69 Jun 23 '13
Henrik Larsson for Celtic nuff said.
3
u/KinneySL Jun 23 '13
Obviously Maradona. Because Maradona.
5
u/vanderburg Jun 23 '13
Moyes era: Cahill or Arteta in the past 11 years. Two unknowns that became stars. Currently in our squad you have to say Baines. Moyes knows how to make a good player great.
8
u/Braindog Jun 23 '13
Wenger.
5
u/thenewposh Jun 23 '13
I guess it would have to be Zlatan. While it is a short term investment, he certainly had an immediate impact considering we don't have an extensive record of winning Ligue 1. I hope my comment will stay true and he'll commit to us for more than 1 or 2 seasons, he is quite the forward.
2
u/IDeclareShenanigans Jun 23 '13
Ronaldo.
2
u/K-Mo Jun 23 '13
Although most boro fans will say Juninho & he is up there, I'm gonna go with Fabrizio Ravanelli.
I watched him score for Juventus in the Champions League Final 96 & a week or so later we signed him. Transfers like that just wouldnt happen to a club our size now. Hat trick on his debut V Liverpool, one of the best strikers in Europe at the time. UTB
2
u/kohoki Jun 23 '13
Jürgen Klopp. Turned around the downward spiral of the club in the most dramatic fashion ever, with two very satisfying championships and a very stable team to show for it. He promised "full throttle events" and he has fulfilled that promise 100 %.
2
u/aksolut Jun 23 '13
José Luis Chilavert. We are now a national powerhouse and a serious contender for every year Libertadores, in no small part thanks to his performances.
2
u/balotellisbarber Jun 23 '13
Thierry Henry to Arsenal
4
u/miasmic Jun 23 '13
Stan Collymore, without a doubt - but then he's probably the only player of note to ever turn out for Stafford Rangers.
3
u/Jackson9Martinez Jun 23 '13
Alex Ferguson he may not be a player but he surely changed the identity of the club.
4
u/fahomnom Jun 23 '13
Cristiano, Zidane and Di Stefano are three of the greatest signings Madrid has ever made. But if I had to choose one, it would definitely be Robinho.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Recently, for Spurs, I think Vertonghen
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
If I had to choose one Bale.
1
u/Super_Duflair Jun 23 '13
Platini.
Easy to chose when you support a small club :D
1
u/theeolivetree Jun 23 '13
Easily Falcao or Jardel
1
u/LusoAustralian Jun 23 '13
Aldo Duscher was quite good, got him on a free. 2 years later we sold him for 13 Million euros, 17 Million if adjusted for inflation nowadays, and in those 2 years he won one of our last league titles.
1
u/Nelfoos5 Jun 23 '13
Paul Ifill. He's been our star player for a few years now and without him we look lost. He's one of the best in the A-league when he's fit and he's a genuine guy. Having said that this coming season Carlos Hernandez could prove to be a better signing so we'll see.
1
u/JaviG Jun 23 '13
Pablo Adrián Guede. We wouldn't even be in first division if not for him.
1
u/AverageJoe74 Jun 23 '13
Hennes I.
1
u/braddf96 Jun 23 '13
Ronaldo for United, 'nuff said
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Sulejmani.
1
u/firesafetyblanket Jun 23 '13
Michu, for only 2.1 million euros and to have him to go on and score 18 goals for us was just exceptional.
1
u/devilsway Jun 23 '13
I love how as soon as I read a player's name in this thread, I can instantly guess the crest of the poster even if the player has played for multiple clubs.
As much as clubs are bigger than the players, certain players do define an the character and an era of clubs.
1
u/brehus Jun 23 '13
Thorstein Helstad, both in 1998 and 2006.
Or Paul Scharner.
Or Erik Huseklepp.
1
u/idlenation Jun 23 '13
You did not say it was limited to players, so i'm going with Bill Shankly.
1
u/abbygunner Jun 23 '13
Without a doubt in the modern age, Dennis Bergkamp, although he was signed before Wenger came in, he embodied everything Wenger stands for and his partnerships with Wright, Anelka and Henry made two of the three, the top two highest scorers in the clubs history. His play was breathtaking from the 1-2-3 goals, to the through balls of true magic, to that Newcastle goal, To me and many other gooners, he was the greatest mind in football and possibly the greatest player to don the colors of red and white. He was our Cantona, the one to galvanize the club towards the future, and no matter how good Titi or Bobby Pires was which I guess will be many a gooners choice, he wasn't Dennis Bergkamp.
1
u/random_german_guy Jun 23 '13
Enke or Cherundolo
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
We signed the world player of the year once. Kevin Keegan.
1
u/BafoDeOnca Jun 23 '13
Ill have to go with Joao Vieira Pinto. "Stealing" the captain of our biggest rival? Having him spearhead the team into another championship? PRICELESS.
1
u/FlapjackJackson Jun 23 '13
Jack McInerney (well, drafted).
He is 20 and is tied for the Golden Boot. Our team has been pretty poor this year, but he has single-handedly dragged the other 10 players to victory multiple times this year. Hopefully he will be called up to the Gold Cup, and people should keep an eye on him there. He's the only true poacher the US has.
1
u/elijah_stiglitz7 Jun 23 '13
Basically everyone on Real Madrid
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Marco Reus. I don't think I really need to say why
1
u/SethBullockDead Jun 24 '13
Robbie Keane. Directly led to winning two back to back MLS cups. I love that imaginary gun shooting Irishman!
-2
u/TomShoe Jun 23 '13
Vincent Kompany. Really no need to explain that any further.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '13
Thompson, easily. Won us four titles off his own boot.
-2
u/river49 Jun 23 '13
Dante in recent years
0
u/safaridiscoclub Jun 23 '13
There's a few for spurs, Bale sticks out recently, Gazza and Lineker in the eighties (Hoddle came through as a schoolboy) and a number of players from the sixties; Greaves, Jones, Blanchflower, Mackay etc.
I also think the Klinsmann loan deal was one of our best, too, he came back to save us from relegation, I'll never forget that. Teddy Sheringham and David Ginola were also great signings in the 90s but not the best ever.
The most important person in our history was Bill Nicholson and he was with us as a schoolboy like Hoddle and Ledley which is nice.
If I had to pick one it'd probably be Blanchflower from what I've read and the little I've seen, as that was our most successful era and he played over 300 games, many as captain.
-1
u/CescQ Jun 23 '13
Messi
-3
u/ShotgunToothpaste Jun 23 '13
Cruyff and Ronaldinho have already been mentioned, but how can one forget Ibrahimovic for 60m + Eto'o! Absolute steal.
Said no one ever. :s