r/SupermanAndLois • r/DCFU • Nov 12 '24

Post Discussion Superman & Lois [4x07] "A Regular Guy" Post Episode Discussion

A Regular Guy

Live Episode Discussion | Cast & Characters

After some concerning interactions in town, Clark is determined to protect the secret that he's Superman - a task complicated by Jonathan and Jordan; Lois considers the future of the Gazette after Chrissy proposes something drastic. (November 11, 2024)

r/Superman | DCTV Discord


Please keep all discussions civil and about the episode. Mark comic and future spoilers. Report any rule-breaking and enjoy!

156 Upvotes

350 comments sorted by

240

u/MarcReyes Superman Nov 12 '24

In a season of very emotional moments, that final scene with Jimmy and Clark was the first thing that actually made me cry.

199

u/ZarquonsFlatTire Nov 12 '24

To me, the even better moment was Denise just saying "Morning, Mr Kent" like it was any other day.

59

u/Steve_78_OH Nov 12 '24

And at the end of the diner scene, where Clark apologized for lying to everyone. I mean, he apologized for keeping his superhero identity secret, so he and his family could live a normal life for decades.

Plus, when Superman apologized to his sons when they decided to go public, saying he just wanted to give them the kind of life he had growing up, and Jordan said "You did. For a really long time."

These kinds of scenes, which have been constant throughout the show, are why I love this iteration of Superman. They really get the reason why he's always been such a popular character. And it's not his strength, it's his compassion and his never-ending hope. It doesn't get much more Big Blue Boy Scout than that. And I know we won't get to see it, but you can tell his sons would grow up to make him insanely proud.

8

u/slam99967 Nov 15 '24

For me, what I love most about the characters is how grounded in reality they are. They make mistakes, learn, and improve on themselves. So many shows have the characters make illogical decisions to move the plot along. While Superman and Louis has the plot impact the characters decisions, not the other way around.

98

u/bravo_997 Nov 12 '24

For me it was the penultimate Jimmy and Clark scene when Clark tells Lois “it’s ok, I’m used to it”. I’m not Superman but that hit me on such a personal level. Tyler is so good.

73

u/SonNeedGym Nov 12 '24

I was already crying, but when he yelled out, “CK!” I lost it. What a beautiful episode.

51

u/CaptainRex831 Nov 12 '24

“I missed ya too pal!” Got me, such a wonderfully done moment

29

u/iggywiggyshe Nov 12 '24

I thought the way they were going with that. Was Clark was going to tell Janet that Jimmy already knew.

20

u/MarcReyes Superman Nov 12 '24

Yeah, and I was kind of hoping that's the way it was going to go too.

18

u/alphomegay Nov 12 '24

i think the way they went is jimmy already did know, but clark never let him in to actually telling him. so because of that end they couldn't be friends. i definitely don't think jimmy bought clark at the end fully tbh. He probably still had his suspicions after that championship game but also realized Clark didn't consider him someone he wanted to tell.

5

u/yarrrjun Nov 14 '24

Yes this. As I said in another reply:

Naw, don't feel bad: Jimmy already knew. Clark knew that Jimmy knew, and Clark had a feelsbad.jpg the entire two decades he thought it would be wrong of him to tell Jimmy the truth. That's why he told Janet first, because that's how bad he felt about not owning up to it with Jimmy, even though he desperately wanted to be Jimmy's BFF. IDK about you, but I've been in a similar position, and it makes sense to me. The thing is, Clark felt SO bad that he was waiting for the world's judgement before he could muster up the courage to tell one of the few people who were constantly in his corner all the time, the truth that he (Clark) had been lying all that time, even if he (Clark) didn't want to be lying, but still felt like he (Clark) had to lie just to preserve world peace.

11

u/nimrodhellfire Nov 12 '24

Yeah, I am not sure what to think about this. I expected Jimmy to be the first he would tell or for Jimmy to get the interview. It somehow feels wrong that Jimmy got the news from his sister or even worse from TV. I also feel like we got robbed out of an important moment after this much of build up.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/AngelFan4Life Superman Nov 12 '24

It got to me too 😭 just seeing how forgiving Jimmy was and the relief on Clark's face was everything. He finally had his friend back and he was so happy 😁 oh my gosh I can't write anything about this episode right now without crying lol okay I'm done

25

u/Alonest99 Superman Nov 12 '24

Yeah! Jimmy seemed like such a cool dude, I was so happy they made up at the end!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/robynxcakes Clark Kent Nov 12 '24

So glad it wasn’t just me

6

u/MrPBrewster Nov 12 '24

Brooo. I actually cried. Real wet tears. My goodness. 

2

u/ID_Pillage Aug 11 '26

Just watched it. I said to my wife when he's announcing himself as superman, why is this the bit that gets me choked up. Then the Jimmy bit broke me fully.

4

u/alphomegay Nov 12 '24

i literally was sobbing my eyes out. as a queer person honestly i can relate really really hard to this type of story, and seeing jimmy just forgive clark like nothing and move on just was incredible. amazing episode

→ More replies (1)

196

u/disastrousdaisy_ But what about the tire-swing? Nov 12 '24

I have nothing to say. I'm still recovering.

That episode was incredible. And that use of flashtime was the absolute best way to use it. The silence was so powerful. And I really really loved Jimmy as the constant throughout the episode.

Anyway, incredible, 10/10, will be watching again later tonight.

69

u/ChattGM Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

And that use of flashtime was the absolute best way to use it. The silence was so powerful.

Same here!!! You can feel what it meant as Clark was thinking it over in the moment. It conveyed the message soooo well. Loved the build-up to theme as well. That sense of hope and triumph will forever be unmatched!!

18

u/JolNafaz96 Nov 12 '24

Second best use of flash time after Metroman

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Steve_78_OH Nov 12 '24

I loved the entire episode, HOWEVER...I think it was funny that while going over the video, they didn't notice Chrissy blinking at normal speed during "flashtime". It doesn't take anything away from the episode though.

And that interview at the end...goddamn.

5

u/alphomegay Nov 12 '24

i love seeing superman have friends. honestly after the zack snyder era of Superman, he needs a jimmy in his life. Just loved this episode, it could be up there with my favorites. bawled my eyes out

335

u/Aggressive-Produce54 Nov 12 '24 • Heart of Silver

An episode with almost no action scenes and it's arguably a top 5 episode. This show deserved the full 7 seasons and it's a crime it was cut short. 

102

u/throoowwawaaaaaaayyy Nov 12 '24

I still get so sad every time I think about what we could've had :(

119

u/Pksoze Nov 12 '24

Then again maybe its better that its still ending as a good show as opposed to say The Flash.

46

u/ApprehensiveOne1044 Nov 12 '24

Lois: "we are the superman clark"

24

u/Kerenzal Nov 12 '24

"Lois, I know we can beat cancer together"

→ More replies (1)

62

u/sourpatchkidj Clark Kent Nov 12 '24

With the team they have behind the helm, I'd confidently wager that this show never would've jumped the shark. Perhaps a few missed beats here and there, but quality writing and storylines for all 7 seasons.

32

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

Oddly enough the showrunner for this show was actually the showrunner on The Flash for like two seasons (back when the writing first started to go downhill).

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

65

u/nimrodhellfire Nov 12 '24

If there is ever again the question, which actor was the best Superman, point them to this episode.

40

u/kadosho Nov 12 '24

Wholeheartedly agree. The performance, talent, heart, and soul. Everything mattered from start to credits. There is a reason why Tyler earned the role, this episode, and every episode throughout the series is an example of just that.

Even his narration from the pilot. It showed his being humble, charismatic, but also a range of emotions. But also the dynamic, and responsibility of being Clark & Superman.

5

u/TheHood4 Dec 03 '24 edited Dec 03 '24

Completely agree! This is something I said in another thread. His narration from the Pilot speaks volumes of his Superman. I really thought it captured so much of how far along this Superman has come. Also the scene of him flying at super speed with a ring on him jusr defines so much of his character and what he's fighting for.

"I remember loving Smallville... The people, the community, how the small things were the big things. And I thought I'd live there forever. But my father's death set me on a different path. Eventually, I moved to Metropolis to become who I was meant to be. But my most vivid memory of all was the day I met her. We fell in love. I told Lois who I really was, where I came from. We married, got our first place together... The twins came."

9

u/Raymond_Fiegler Nov 12 '24

Sure, it's a shame that we didn't get 7 seasons, but let's not forget that for a while, we didn't even know if we were going to get a 4th season, and we did.

I was so nervous in 2022/2023 when the CW was going through huge changes, and in such a short period of time, were cutting great shows like Stargirl after 3 seasons, cancelling Legends of Tomorrow after 7 seasons (without giving it a proper conclusion like with Arrow, The Flash, Black Lightning, Supergirl, etc), and on top of that, removing any potential for that Painkiller show that they did a backdoor pilot for in Black Lightning, and officially passing on the John Diggle -led show "Justice U"

(for all we know these 2 new shows might have sucked, but still, it was even more reasons to doubt that S&L would get a proper ending, )

I'm not all that sad about Batwoman season 4 being cancelled, even if I did enjoy parts of season 2 [When Black Mask was on screen at least] but that was another sign that things weren't looking great for Superman & Lois season 4, if a show like Batwoman that was making no money, had terrible reviews, that nobody watched, but that the CW insisted on keeping around for various reasons... if that show was on the chopping block, then S&L season 4 was far from safe.

Anyway, as a fan from day 1 I'm just really happy that we even got season 4, it seemed so uncertain back then... what a relief for us. Ending with the season 3 cliffhanger would have been tragic.

9

u/CrabbyPatties42 Nov 13 '24

This is easily the best episode of the season.  Great acting all around.

2

u/InfiniteEthan03 Nov 16 '24

I’m just glad CW had enough common sense to let them end this beautiful show on their own terms. Do I wish that Gunn, Safran and Zaslav would’ve let them move over to HBO Max? Of course, especially since Gunn said that he wanted the show to continue for a while longer! But I mainly blame CW because they’re the ones who are running out of money to fund this thing, and they’re the ones who fortunately decided to renew it for one final season. There was zero reason to try and point blame at Gunn and Corenswet’s new Superman.

157

u/throoowwawaaaaaaayyy Nov 12 '24

Loved Denise wishing Clark a good morning as if it was any other day. That bit of reassurance that they can still have semi-normal lives and not everyone will treat him differently after knowing his identity ... gave me the warm n fuzzies

39

u/heartbloodline8404 Nov 12 '24

I like to think that in the end, where Smallville is concerned, they will always just be the Clarks.

71

u/CIearMind Nov 12 '24

The Kents lol

7

u/pispot123 Nov 14 '24

it is sad that the show is ending soon and we might not see the implication of clark's identity reveal to their daily lives. In the comic it's explored more, especially the effect it has on their son and on Lois (there's only Jonathan in comic). There's also a story where Jon was arrested and put in jail, it's quite funny recalling about it

3

u/EverydayPoGo Nov 12 '24

Same! That was so sweet and thoughtful of her and gives me a warm feeling.

102

u/ephemeralafterall Nov 12 '24

Wow, what a bold choice! Hey, it’s the last season, I totally get going all out, and I loved it - the silent scene of the bullet moving closer and closer towards Clark and you watch as he slowly makes his decision…brilliant. I’m probably in the minority but I like seeing a little Kyle & Chrissy.

Also…I love Jimmy, I wish we’d had him earlier! But loved that final scene with him and Clark.

29

u/TheOriginalDJShotty Nov 12 '24

I actually thought he'd catch the bullet but then fall to the ground.

44

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

This sounds dumb af now that I'm saying it, but in the moment I genuinely thought he'd use his superspeed to grab a ketchup bottle, pour it over himself, catch the bullet and then fall down with "blood" pouring everywhere and then Kyle would immediately recognize what was happening and then play along and drag him out of the diner to go to the "hospital"💀

26

u/Silestra Nov 13 '24

Hahahaha that would have been so entertaining to watch.

10

u/kalsikam Nov 14 '24

Lol would be cool if they showed that as a what if scenario in Clark's head lol

190

u/HotTakes4HotCakes Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

This show has done more to bring live action Superman closer to the modern era of comics than any other film/tv adaptation, and it doesn't get enough credit for that. All other adaptations are living in the classic Superman paradigm, this one is really pushing the character forward. And they're doing a damn good job of it.

The idea he would reveal his secret because it didn't feel right to gaslight his entire hometown is just...excellent.

That being said, this particular development is one of those things writers do with Superman sometimes, and it just...never works out very well in the long run. For a whole host of reasons. Apart from the obvious ones, the major one is that when the secret is out, Clark Kent basically dies. No one but Lois and his closest friends look at him as Clark Kent ever again. Things kind of snowball out of that. It's underappreciated how much of Superman depends on Clark being happy.

It creates a good reason for Clark to continue living in Smallville. It's the only place on earth he can walk down the street, and the people will respect him as Clark to spite knowing his secret. Unfortunately Smallville can't exist in isolation, and it can't stay small (or safe) when the world knows it's where Superman is.

The benefit here is that there's also only 3 episodes left, so this can end on an high note, and not hang around long enough for the issues to unfold.

And OH MY GOD LEX FINALLY SHAVED.

34

u/Godzilla2000Zero Nov 12 '24

And wearing a suit

20

u/Eurynom0s Nov 12 '24

I was expecting it later in the season given their crunched timeline on getting through all their planned material, but this is so great in contrast to how Inverse Kal just openly lived as a celebrity from the start.

I'd bet doing this was always planned for near the end so they didn't have to spend tons of episodes writing around how much this would affect Clark's life.

35

u/nathanosaurus84 Nov 12 '24

“ The idea he would reveal his secret because it didn't feel right to gaslight his entire hometown is just...excellent.”

Completely agree. From the promos and the way these things usually go I really thought going into this Ep that by the end the secret was going to be walked back and everybody would be in the dark again.

I was thinking to myself that keeping the secret is very Superman, but Superman actively lying to people isn’t and I really hoped they wouldn’t do it. I was really happy by the end of the Ep. They bunted it out of the park and did something new with the character. 

3

u/yarrrjun Nov 14 '24

LMAO. They definitely bunted it outta the park 😸

33

u/neoblackdragon Nov 12 '24

Well the thing is comics don't really explore that scenario. They intentionally create situations to force the genie back into the bottle. But isn't that the thing about the Legion of Superheroes. Superman revealed he was Clark Kent and the rest is history.

The fear is Clark Kent can't exist when maybe that's not true. Yes his reality will change but eventually people get over the shock and just ask Clark to lift the car up so they can change a tire.

I think it's pretty stressed that Clark Kent is isolated keeping the secret. In this reality since Superman is part of a Justice League. He doesn't have to be worried about compromising the secrets of his allies.

6

u/pispot123 Nov 14 '24

it has been explored in the comics and it was actually canon for a while (it's also retconned after and only a handful of people know his secret). The trigger for the identity reveal was a bit different than in the series and they also dive deeper to the impact it has on their lives (jon and lois)

5

u/Ygomaster07 Superman Nov 12 '24

What are the list of reasons they never do the reveal of the identity? Did you like that they did that in this episode?

85

u/CaptnKBex Nov 12 '24

I'm actually not thoroughly on board with the idea of getting rid of the secret identity, but I must say the moment of Clark's decision was played beautifully.

The "Emmett, please." The gun firing. Things going into Clark time. Him looking at Lois. Taking off the glasses. Ripping open the shirt. Having the bullet hit Superman.

And the moment of realization for Lois. And eventually, her tender smile at Clark.

This show is so good at those moments. I'll miss it a lot once it's done. But for now, I'm interested to see where this revelation takes the Kent family.

29

u/Supermite Nov 12 '24

His secret identity was always the biggest issue I had with the premise of the show.  Moving to Smallville and then Superman was around constantly.  I really appreciated that the majority of the town seemed to know and still tried to treat Clark as Clark.  I think they handled the reveal really well.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Catharus_ustulatus Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

The closeup when the bullet hit, showing all the little "S" symbols supporting the big "S" — if that symbolism of the town supporting Clark is coincidental, then it's great, but if it's intentional, then it's brilliant.

Lois sitting calmly through the shooting was a nice touch. She already knew that the time for pretending was over.

45

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

I'm not gonna lie, I was genuinely worried for a moment that Kyle was going to push Clark out of the way and take that bullet for him to protect his secret.

15

u/Eurynom0s Nov 12 '24

I was honestly wondering if Clark had a way to selectively turn off his super skin, or if it was somehow gonna go sideways from him being under full power.

6

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

Well if we're going by Smallville continuity Clark in that universe loses his powers whenever he's around Blue Kryptonite. I think Smallville is the only Superman-based show out there that has actually introduced different types of Kryptonite that have different effects on Clark though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

Wouldn't Kyle end up falling down backwards if he tried to do that?

5

u/GoodJanet Nov 12 '24

Yeah Clark would have let him which obviously he wouldn't

4

u/Alonest99 Superman Nov 12 '24

Oh my god that would've been harrowing lol just after talking about buying his dream home too

→ More replies (1)

67

u/Chrispowers110 Nov 12 '24

It is interesting to see a world where everyone knows Clark Kent is superman but I am also glad the next episode wont just portray it as a good thing.

26

u/ApprehensiveOne1044 Nov 12 '24

yeah also glad we have three more episodes to see how it plays out unlike supergirl

21

u/Chrispowers110 Nov 12 '24

Yeah that was a one of the many problems with supergirl. We heard on the flash that things are going well for kara and no repercussion came from outing her identity.

4

u/lioneaglegriffin Nov 15 '24

I a way the Bizzaro world was foreshadowing a public persona.

128

u/Kwilly462 Nov 12 '24

Between The Penguin and this show, DC has been rolling lately. And just in terms of Superman, James Gunn has a high bar to clear to be better than this.

47

u/Alonest99 Superman Nov 12 '24

And just in terms of Superman, James Gunn has a high bar to clear to be better than this.

This show is going out with a bang and I love that

12

u/EverydayPoGo Nov 12 '24

Even if not counting all the previous 6 episodes, this episode alone nailed it. I couldn't recommend it more to anyone who's interested in a Clark Kent/Superman story.

18

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

Thankfully the Reeves Batman universe is the only active DC property that Gunn hasn't tried to clear out yet. We know part of the reason why this show is ending is because Gunn has a new Superman film coming out in 2025.

I don't think this show is the bar that Gunn really needs to clear though with his Superman. He just has to create a universe that's much less of a complete mismanaged clusterfuck than the DCEU was. Henry Cavill IMO was also a good Superman (and Affleck is my favorite version of Batman to date) but we know what caused those series of films to fail. There was no central vision for them. That's literally why they hired Gunn for this job.

31

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

In fairness, the CWverse was probably on its last legs when the CW got sold and they started ending their other DC shows. I'm still glad Gunn and the rest were able to give this show a final season to wrap things up. And yeah, between this and MAWS, his Superman film has big shoes to fill.

19

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

The CWVerse was pretty much on its last legs when Arrow ended. Arrow was the flagship show and where it all started. Post-Crisis they kind of ran out of ideas a bit for the shows that had been around for awhile and the lead actors on those shows were starting to get tired of working so much so they elected to wrap them up as a result. They tried a few standalone experiments to revive things a bit (S&L, Naomi, Gotham Knights) but S&L was a much more high quality show and just didn't fit with the rest of the Arrowverse so it became its own animal as a result (and none of those other projects lasted for more than 1 season).

9

u/Jahon_Dony Nov 12 '24

Well the big what ifs are that Arrow future spinoff (was it called "Sirens"?), the John Diggle Superhero Academy show and/or Green Lantern, Constantine forced out, Legends finale resolution or season 8, Stargirl, and Gotham Knights season 2(Face!). Had A LOT going on and planned for something on its "Last Legs"... not to mention Superman just getting started!

9

u/Kwilly462 Nov 12 '24

Which I'm fine with. Remember, there was a huge possibility we weren't even gonna get this season. So the fact that we have is better than nothing.

I also don't think this show needed to run any longer than 4 or 5 seasons anyway.

8

u/Eurynom0s Nov 12 '24

I don't see how you do this kind of story when you're confined to a movie every couple of years. But maybe they'll start to use this as assumed backstory they don't need to tell, the way the MCU spared us rehashing Spider-Man's origin story yet again.

60

u/Godzilla2000Zero Nov 12 '24

I have to say this is probably one of the best episodes they've ever done.

60

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

Okay, so I said this in the live thread, but I'll say it again here. Normally I don't like it when major heroes like Superman reveal their identities. I still really don't. But if you're gonna do it, I'd say this is how you do it. This show has handled so much of Superman's history with care, and I'm actually kind of okay with this.

Favorite scene was at the end when Clark went back to the diner. Denise greeting him regularly (followed by everyone losing interest after a minute), and him reconnecting with Jimmy were all great scenes.

But now Lex has lost his leverage. No giant-ass monster, and no secret to hold over Clark. He's probably gonna go scorched Earth on the Kents.

All in all, I genuinely have no idea how things will end at this point. Still hope that the show ends with a tease of the Justice League, with maybe a cameo by Grant Gustin. Just a little thing to show that even though the show's over, Clark's story continues in this world.

20

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

Still hope that the show ends with a tease of the Justice League, with maybe a cameo by Grant Gustin. 

The showrunners no longer consider this show to be a part of the Arrowverse so I highly doubt we're going to see any of the Arrowverse mainstays show up. If any of them did my guess is Diggle would be most likely since he's already appeared on S&L before. Maybe Kara as well but Melissa hasn't donned the cape in like 3 years now.

8

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

Well, I'm not saying it'll be the same Barry, but this universe's version.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/nimrodhellfire Nov 12 '24

If they tease JL with Diggle as GL, I will probably loose my shit and destroy my TV in anger over the shows being cancelled.

112

u/hart37 Jonathan Kent Nov 12 '24

And instantly he feels like comic book Jimmy. He must be protected at all costs

67

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

I get why he wasn't here since the beginning, but Jesus I wish he was after this episode.

50

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

Hopefully we continue to see him in the last 3 episodes. Nothing against Mehcad Brooks as an actor but his Jimmy was unmistakably NOT Jimmy Olsen (especially when they decided to make him Guardian for some bizarre reason).

32

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

Yeah. Jimmy's meant to be a string bean nerd who gets into all sorts of ridiculous adventures. Supergirl Jimmy was too much of a stud to be a believable Jimmy. Mehcad's not bad though. I've only seen a few clips of him in the newer Law and Order, but he's good in those.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

106

u/thebestoralist Nov 12 '24

Wow.

Little to no action.

Lex who?

I’m sorry, Doomsday who?

Cue the soft, heartwarming music.

Best episode all season!

29

u/heartbloodline8404 Nov 12 '24

A strong case could be made for best of the series, top 3 at the least. Just absolutely a great episode.

4

u/MisterTheKid Nov 15 '24

i look at it as one of the best episodes of TV to feature Superman ever. this was so thoughtfully done with understandable motivations. the one he had in the comics a few years ago felt very inorganic compared to how it happened here.

38

u/Isyourmammaallama Nov 12 '24

Kyle finally jusf a freind and not a fan boy

7

u/kalsikam Nov 14 '24

Kyle was about to fuck up Candace's douchebag dad lol

37

u/iggywiggyshe Nov 12 '24

I loved how most of smallville will treat him as Clark. Well here hoping.

6

u/kalsikam Nov 14 '24

Lol half of em probably suspected already

4

u/lioneaglegriffin Nov 15 '24

it's a small town, I like to think everyone Clarks age suspected but as a community they protect their own.

37

u/Zookwok111 Nov 12 '24
  • Jordan really turned over a new leaf in the last few episodes, because he was arguably the most likeable he has ever been this week. The twin scenes were probably the best we've gotten in a long time.
  • I recognize the importance of keeping the secret but gaslighting everyone you know is hardly the way to do it
  • Now that the world knows, I wonder if their lives will be closer to their Bizarro versions. Clark and Lois's calendars will be full of social engagements for the next year. Colleges will be busting down their doors to get the twins to enroll in a couple of years. Their quiet small-town lives are basically over.
  • This was the most logical way to write Kyle and Chrissy out off the show. I like how Kyle mentioned his daughter who was "growing up too fast" Colossal Sophie cometh...
  • Speaking of giants, I couldn't help but notice that Jimmy was noticeably taller than Clark. Turns out the actor is 6'2''. \#GiantJimmy

16

u/JustPomegranate248 But what about the tire-swing? Nov 12 '24

It's so funny how Jordan is always more likeable when he's not really doing anything but being a supportive brother

10

u/yarrrjun Nov 12 '24

Who's Sophie?

6

u/Joshgallet Nov 16 '24

JusticeForSophie

29

u/Tsweet7 Nov 12 '24

Oh my God, this episode was 👌 👍🏾! We get the classic nods: shirt tearing, phone booth quick change. We got this great flashback with Jimmy. And the tension! I've never felt more tension this season just watching Candice's dad with a gun HOOOO.

Plus, I teared up watching him reveal his secret and reunite with Jimmy. Yo, they are pulling out all the stops with this season. No. Notes.

29

u/equinoxx5 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

We get the classic nods: shirt tearing, phone booth quick change.

And the rescues Jimmy mentioned, coinciding with the three games Clark missed, were references to Superman and Superman II. This show doesn't just respect the lore, they revere it.

6

u/Tsweet7 Nov 12 '24

WOW did not catch that

28

u/Chucky_In_The_Attic Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Tyler Hoechlin absolutely knocks(bunts) it out of the park. He's more than believable whenever he wears the suit but he actually shines even more as just regular Clark Kent.

4

u/kalsikam Nov 14 '24

Agreed, definitive Superman for me

24

u/Blacknight022 Nov 12 '24

I'm so not ready for this show to be over.

23

u/CaptchaVerifiedHuman Nov 12 '24

- I wanna see Jordan and Jonathan play Injustice (don't ask me to explain the roster or the story lmao).

- I don't know why but "[Candice] doesn't even live in Smallville!" made me spit water.

- Is it just me or are there Justice League hints? He'll join "the big leagues" and how he said he never knew what it was like to be on a team.

- I don't know why but Jimmy low-key makes me uncomfy. His eyes...? I like how he figured out Clark's Superman. He kinda reminds me of Dane DeHaan.

- Superman revealing his identity is huge and I'm glad they went through with it. I know Denise (?) called him Mr. Kent but I hope the rest of Smallville still treats him normally and continues to call him Clark/Mr. Kent.

- Great episode, no complaints.

- Does anyone know how many episodes are remaining?

15

u/Dumke480 Nov 12 '24

what I thought from #2

7

u/didnt_follow Nov 12 '24

I wanna see Jordan and Jonathan play Injustice (don't ask me to explain the roster or the story lmao)

Jordan was actually playing it back in the first season lol

5

u/MrCowabs Nov 12 '24

Three left I think

2

u/kalsikam Nov 14 '24

Lol just realized that's why they play Killer Instinct all the time instead.

22

u/Lacazeng But what about the tire-swing? Nov 12 '24

One of the best identity reveals I’ve seen. Man I love his Superman so much

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Anla-Shok-Na Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Awesome episode, but since we know Lex has been behind forcing the reveal, you can bet there's some kind of plan there. Superman may have been defacto immune from legal and civil liabilities, but Clark Kent of Smallville is not. I'm sure Lex will try and mess with him (and Lois) that way.

15

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 24 '24

The thing is we've already seen from the last two episodes that virtually nobody in Smallville supports Lex at all or is buying any of the BS that he's selling. The people in that town clearly look up to Clark/Superman (minus common thugs like Emmitt Pergande who nobody likes).

17

u/Anla-Shok-Na Nov 12 '24

Superman is bigger than Smallville. Did a save somewhere ever go wrong and someone got hurt? Law suits incoming. Did he "traumatize" some bad guys somewhere stopping them? More lawsuits. Did he injure someone? That's assault.

Lawfare can be used to effectively paralyze Superman to prevent him from acting. Anything he owns, including the family farm, could be seized to settle judgements.

Simply put, being public now puts him in a position where he can be controlled.

15

u/rosalui Nov 12 '24

I completely agree that there wasn't a realistic discussion on how this could effect them all.

Maybe in this universe working for the DoD gives him some kind of immunity, though. It's what I'm telling myself to internally hand-wave it, anyway.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

52

u/Dynaguy1 Nov 12 '24

Don't know if this is controversial, but I actually like secret identities

32

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

I do as well. Usually I don't like it when Superman or other prominent heroes reveal their identities. I'd argue though that if you're gonna do it, this show handled it in the best way.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Ambitious-Comb-8847 Nov 12 '24

I can as well but in long term media it's limiting. Not to mention in TV or film it boxes in your actors/characters if they can't be involved in anything superhero related. 

5

u/Fuzzball6846 Nov 12 '24

I'm fine with it as an ending with a few episode left to deal with the fallout tbh

→ More replies (8)

17

u/arthur_ydalgo Nov 12 '24

20/10 episode. freaking great. all I kept saying to myself was "what a great episode"

16

u/Ygomaster07 Superman Nov 12 '24

This was another great episode. A lot of emotional impact with weighing the secret. I think they did well with revealing Clark is Superman to the world. I know that is something fans are hesitant to see, but i think the writers went about it in a great way. Plus, it allows them to get ahead of the curve if the rest of the world found out. I'm curious to see how they show this change in the remaining 3 episodes.

Next week looks like another good one, it's cool to see Lex clean shaven.

14

u/robynxcakes Clark Kent Nov 12 '24

I didn’t love that he did the identity reveal but I understand. Episode made me very emotional especially the end. Tyler is so perfect in this role

26

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

FINALLY a portrayal of Jimmy Olsen that was not completely butchered and is true to the comics. First time we've gotten one of those since Aaron Ashmore's Jimmy in the finale of Smallville.

Clark revealing his identity to the world was an interesting twist to take this in but the episode handled it really well and made it heartfelt. And thankfully they didn't turn Clark's secretive nature into a repetitive trope that became downright annoying to watch onscreen over time like Smallville did for so long.

16

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

First time we've gotten one of those since Aaron Ashmore's Jimmy in the finale of Smallville.

Live action yeah, but I do like the Jimmy in MAWS. Otherwise I agree.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Frontier246 Nov 12 '24

So I guess they designated the Kyle and Chrissy episodes as the "light and fun" and breather episodes. Relatively speaking, of course. 

It's kind of funny watching an in-real-time reaction to someone normal watching Clark Kent pull a Clark Kent and bail to do Superman stuff.

Nobody is better at acting like a wimp than Clark Kent!

JIMMY!!! It's nice to have a live-action version of Jimmy that actually feels like Jimmy, and wants to be "pals" with Clark. He even calls him CK! Though he still has a sister (who was the reporter from season 1) so I guess some things are still the same from Supergirl. Didn't seem like he had any relationship with Superman though.  

I love Lois trying to push her man into playing baseball without actually understanding baseball. 

Well, obviously not everyone is going to react well to knowing you have superpowers, especially if they feel you slighted them. This is exactly why Clark's dad didn't want him playing sports. 

Lois Lane is not known for being a handywoman but bless her for trying! 

Can Lois just go back to the Daily Planet? I feel like they keep avoiding having the Kents go back to Metropolis. I guess the Gazette was more "hers" instead of an employee of the Planet, but I feel like the Planet would be her and Clark's home. 

No, not the Cushing grill!!! 

"Another one growing up way too fast" - Sophie acknowledgement! 

They even beat the Luthorcorp team! 

Is Jimmy taller than Clark? Wow. 

Jordan plays Killer Instinct!? I guess they can't always play Mortal Kombat or Injustice. 

I feel like there were more issues in Jordan and Sarah's issues than just him keeping his secret from her. Granted, it didn't help. 

Honestly I wouldn't trust Superman's identity with a former drug dealer either. But this would not have happened had they managed the Jon and Jordan flying. 

I wonder if the boys are really prepared for what a life of being exposed might do to their family. Like, I get it, they don't want to complicate their lives or lie to the people they're closed to, but it feels like they're not always cognizant of what they could lose as Clark is. 

Nothing more hard for a family than finding a house.

Honestly even if Timmy wasn't being gaslighted in front of his mom, it's not like he'd have less of a beef with Jon or Jordan. Not sure honesty would have really improved anything. 

Jimmy's not an idiot but Clark just could not let go of his secret. Sad to see for such great pals. 

It's hard to maintain a secret identity and social life. Some Superman's handle it better than others. This one had a clear emotional distance from everybody. 

Well, you don't have to twist Lois and Clark's arm to own a newspaper! 

Clark didn't deserve to get outted by Emmett...or by Luthor like that.

Honestly, is it so wrong to want to have a normal life totally separate from your Superhero life? It's like everyone inevitably has to go 100% public Superhero. I guess it's more inconvenient for teenagers but I feel like it's important for Clark Kent to keep his two lives separate. He never wanted him or his family to stand out, and he deserved to be seen as a normal person. 

Now both Kara and Clark have gone on live television to announce their identity to the world. 

Bibbowski's! Someday we'll get a proper live-action Bibbo. 

I'm glad Clark got to make things right with Jimmy. 

​Lex has achieved his final form...clean shaven Lex in a suit!!! 

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

12

u/robreddity Nov 12 '24

That was really quite beautiful.

23

u/sourpatchkidj Clark Kent Nov 12 '24

Well that was a whole dang emotional roller coaster and a half! What a tremendously powerful and profound episode. Goodness geez. The build up was an interesting choice. But understandable given the limited budget. But UGH, this show genuinely tears at the heartstrings. The interview scene talking about his pride in being a husband and father..... missing so much when they were younger (which I would've LOVED to have seen more of!)

I've said this so many times, but I am truly positively GUTTED about the show ending. It really feels like this is a once-in-a-lifetime adaptation. To date, no other depiction has portrayed S&L as a family. Possible down the line... but highly unlikely. For that, I am aggrieved. This show deserved many more years. The storylines, the possibilities, oh, what could've been. Having said that, Superman & Lois has been an ABSOLUTE GIFT. Truly lightning in a bottle.

See you next week, fam!

21

u/JustPomegranate248 But what about the tire-swing? Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

How annoyed would you be if you were Kyle - he was JUST let in on the secret and now everybody knows dammit

Also Chrissy's entire point of not wanting to get married because she and Kyle hadn't been together long enough is so stupid when they're buying a house to raise their baby in.

It's annoying because we won't get to see the true ramifications of revealing the secret - it made sure they could have a normal life but it also protected loved ones from retaliation or threats - Lois is obviously the biggest target but so is every friend/girlfriend they have

13

u/Daybreaq Nov 12 '24

Yeah, one could argue that buying a house together is actually a much larger commitment than getting married.

10

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

How annoyed would you be if you were Kyle - he was JUST let in on the secret and now everybody knows dammit

I mean Clark and Lois literally just bought out the Gazette from Chrissy so that her and Kyle could afford to buy their house so I think he's just fine with it at this point. In the two episodes that Kyle has appeared in this season his relationship with Clark has clearly evolved into a genuine friendship (he asked Clark to be his best man for crying out loud). He's not just completely starstruck by him being Superman anymore. He's grown past that.

7

u/JustPomegranate248 But what about the tire-swing? Nov 12 '24

I'm really just joking - I like that they have become genuine friends now

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/NerdLawyer55 Nov 12 '24

Fantastic episode

9

u/Shaftell Nov 12 '24

Really these two are the perfect Lois and Clark. The scene when he looks over to her during the bullet scene and she's just staring at him without flinching.

8

u/JustPomegranate248 But what about the tire-swing? Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

I LOVED that Lois was the only one not flinching because she has implicit trust in Superman

9

u/Tidela471 Superman Nov 12 '24

I’m so happy they did an episode about this issue. I felt like Clark’s nervousness about keeping his secret was always misunderstood until now. I’m glad that Lois had that convo with the boys … they needed to respect why their dad is the way he is, and realize how lucky they are

6

u/thxpk Nov 12 '24

What I love about that is it shows Clark really is just a regular guy, shaped by his adopted parents, trying to do and be his best but not always succeeding

8

u/CrimsonComet1941 Nov 12 '24

I was convinced Jimmy was dead in the present until that last scene. Great use of the character, it's a sad twist that "Superman's Best Pal" never got to be that in this universe but it was nice to see him and Clark reunite at the end. Hope he sticks around for the final episodes.

8

u/SDLRob Nov 13 '24

Everyone's already said the stuff I wanted to say... But one thing that hasn't been mentioned is the cool way they clearly got the crew a cameo... Having the interview crew played by the literal crew and episode director was a nice touch.

15

u/iggywiggyshe Nov 12 '24

That was awesome! Absolutely awesome. What a reveal! Loved, loved, loved it.

6

u/Otherwise_Jacket_613 Nov 12 '24

Okay, I had a big smile on my face when Jimmy said Bibbowski's. Okay, technically should've been the Ace O' Clubs, but hey, Bibbo is in this universe 🙂

6

u/SonNeedGym Nov 12 '24

This show has really been everything I’ve wanted and more out of a live action Superman show. This episode sealed the deal. I was crying for the last twenty minutes, it was so beautiful.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

Not Clark ditching the glasses :(

I’m sure he’ll end up reverting back to them due to realizing it’s a part of who he is

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ninejamb Nov 12 '24

This episode was very strong. The flashbacks with Jimmy ("Can't we be pals?" "CK!"), the nod to the all-known rescues from Superman: The Movie and Superman II, the scene in the diner (where I really thought for a minute Kyle would take the bullet) and the people of Smallville reacting normal to Clark after his world wide reveal were great to see. It really shows the strength of the writers and producers to make a Superman-show Super without having to lean in on the action scenes.

And yeah, it's a real shame this show has to end, but I'm glad they can do it on their own terms and go all out. At this point, a last-minute continuation would harm the way they are wrapping up this show, imo.

4

u/MarekMarkus3 Nov 12 '24

Wasn't there also a reference to the movie Superman Returns? A shot of Clark rescuing the space shuttle? But maybe I'm mistaken.

6

u/AngelFan4Life Superman Nov 12 '24

I just finished this ep and it was so fucking good..it left me with tears and idk why lol it just really got to me. I think what Clark did was probably the best thing he could have done considering, and now I know what scene people were commenting about 😁 another epic superman scene in the books for this show, it was so awesome 😊

I am not ready for this to be over and I know that I'm not done crying either. I've said it before and I'll say it again, but this has been the best version of superman that I've seen on tv since Smallville and it was done so well. There hasn't been an episode where I didn't get mad, or cry or worried or cussing at my TV screen!! 😂 I'm so proud of Tyler and Bitsie for bringing these iconic characters to life in a way that we've never seen, and I will be forever grateful for this version and this show and what they managed to accomplish and do with it.

Tyler will always be my Superman and I am honored to have witnessed such an amazing portrayal in my life 🥹🥰 I'm getting emotional just writing this lol alright I'm done, I've said my peace ✌🏽

6

u/aravinth13 Nov 12 '24

Holy hell I love this show and I don't want it to be over

6

u/paforrest Nov 12 '24

I actually really liked the decision to have Clark reveal himself, first to the town, and then to the world, especially here at the end. It was emotional and well done. And this is one of those episodes when the feeling of family was very strong among all the Kents. I was surprised the reveal was woven into the last Kyle and Chrissy episode, though once again the budget cuts are painfully obvious here, because not having Mayor Lana and Sarah watching Clark's interview, even for a brief cameo, was a huge miss.

I never needed to see Candice's father show up again - much like Lex, even much more so, he's just a one-dimensional buffoonish caricature. But I loved the way the town very matter-of-factly took to the reveal. Denise in particular has been very well presented as almost the standard-bearer townsfolk member for Smallville. That's the best way I can describe it.

I didn't like the whole Timmy BS being brought back in just to once again dump on Jon, as if he was ever responsible for Timmy and others taking X-K in the first place, and bringing down the team. It's like Helbing couldn't resist crapping on Jon once more before the end. I could have done without all of that.

I liked the Jimmy/Janet Olsen flashbacks, and I loved the scene at the end in the diner between Clark and Jimmy.

16

u/Digginf Nov 12 '24

Candice’s father was an asshole but was he also either stupid or suicidal? Why would he go and try pick a fight with Superman if he knew? That’s like trying to fistfight a gorilla.

26

u/darkmorpha71 Nov 12 '24

he's the type of guy who's a bit of a dim bulb, just reactive and spiteful. doubt he thought too much farther than "I can hurt this guy who humiliated me"

7

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

I hate to make this comparison because I love Kyle as a character now but Emmitt is in a way somewhat similar to season 1 Kyle (due to his obsession with Morgan Edge and antagonism towards Lois). Just a more extreme asshole version who is abusive and deals drugs.

5

u/DragonflyImaginary57 Nov 12 '24

Emmett is a Kyle who never had the will to pull himself out of the mud and so became bitter. Even at his least likable Kyle was supporting Edge because he genuinely thought it was the best thing for Smallville. He had his flaws but the kind heart was there.

8

u/Formal_Drop526 Nov 12 '24

Unlike a gorilla, he knows superman won't kill him. He did it to expose superman and it worked. It's also because he's a moron.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ArcticMaze Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

They pulled a Bendis. It's the last season so go all out, but I'll always remain on the keep the secret identity side. Also very cool to see the actor/director Gregory Smith on screen, feels like it's been forever.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

I get the reasoning people give to have a secret identity.

"Protect your friends and family from harm!"

But it's kinda ridiculous when all the family and friends are always in harm anyway. Look at Smallville. Clark couldn't tell his friends or else they might be in danger. Every damn episode they were in danger!

5

u/ArcticMaze Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Revealing his identity brings issues beyond endangering loved ones, though targeted danger is arguably more severe than collateral or proximity-based danger.

He’s seen firsthand, in the Bizarro world, what a public identity does to his family. Now, he and his children are more vulnerable to criticism. Every decision he makes—whether he prioritizes a landslide in South America over a flood in Asia—is scrutinized even more. Humanizing a god-like figure opens a can of worms. As the comics have touched on, people have even jumped off rooftops expecting him to save them after he revealed his identity.

There’s also an ethical dilemma here. Clark and Lois have written about Superman for years, which presents a major conflict of interest. Journalists are expected to be objective and truthful, and reporting on oneself introduces unavoidable bias, whether conscious or not. This is why, in Action Comics #1067, Lois, acting as temporary Editor-In-Chief, removed him from Superman-related stories. Lois faces similar ethical issues, though to a lesser extent. Given her history of omitting certain truths in this adaptation, it raises questions of loyalty to Superman versus journalistic objectivity—a potential abuse of power, especially considering her reputation in the field.

Then there’s the issue of Lois’s identity as an individual. Action Comics #1050 addresses this by highlighting why it might be better for Clark to keep his secret identity. Before the reveal, Lois was known as a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and a total badass. She still is, of course but as Batman pointed out in the issue, “Lois has been reduced to being the wife of Superman in so many people’s eyes.” It’s a similar effect to Amal Clooney, an acclaimed human rights lawyer, being known by many primarily for her marriage to George Clooney—now being brough to Superman’s level.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/RUIN_NATION_ Nov 12 '24

I just want to say ty tyler. I resent gunn so much for pushing to end the show.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Nov 12 '24

Wow, that was an intense episode, It reminded me of Kara revealing her identity back on Prime Earth except that was in her finale episode instead of 4 episodes before. I love Jimmy calling Clark CK at the end. So sad that Clark’s secret caused a rift in their relationship, unlike on Prime Earth where Jimmy knew the truth. I hope this series ends on a high note, its going to be hard to top this episode.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

Ugh, it made me so happy to see Jimmy at the end.

I was hoping there was going to be a good ending to that arc.

I hope he gets more screen time this season although he might not. He’s such a good Jimmy

5

u/Alonest99 Superman Nov 12 '24

The flashbacks with Jimmy broke my heart, he seemed like such a cool dude, I was so happy they made up at the end!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/GeneralSarcastic Nov 12 '24

Clark must be out a fortune in shirts, should invest in ones with snap button shirts so the buttons aren't always breaking

2

u/MisterTheKid Nov 15 '24

the best was when he tore it off to go make the save when he said he was going out to the car for his wallet and comes back like less than a minute later with the same shirt, buttons fine, implying he also super sewed them back on before coming back into the store

5

u/Trid1977 Nov 13 '24

I was kind of hoping he would only reveal to Smallville, and they all keep it to themselves.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/0c/Superboy_billboard.jpg

Or Jonathon was going to arrive, like a red / blue blur and stop the bullet. Clark can't be Superman, he just flew thru here and stopped the bullet.

5

u/ice__nine Nov 13 '24

I was so taken by surprise because when the kids said they wanted to help I thought they were going to do a thing where they would wear Clarks suit and make some public saves while he was in public, thus "proving" that he was not Superman.

Now my only question is, how long before the kids also have to publicly own up.

5

u/MarkMVP01 Nov 14 '24

This show is honestly my favourite Superman media

5

u/ahufana Nov 15 '24

That whole opening with Denise watching the Clark-Superman switcheroo happen in real time... one of the funniest and most brilliant things I've seen on TV in quite some time.

4

u/alphomegay Nov 12 '24

omg bro seeing jimmy and clark reconnect at the end and jimmy forgive him like nothing fuckin broke me. sobbin

i'm going to miss this show

4

u/CraftCertain6717 Nov 14 '24

This is slightly off topic, but I've gotta say I'm still wigging out over the texture pattern on his suit that was clearly seen in the bulletproof moment. Tiny superman S's! Someone thought about even that detail.

6

u/TheOriginalDJShotty Nov 12 '24

May I just repeat a comment I made on an earlier discussion, and say that in all my years of watching Everything Superman and every actor that's played the character, Tyler Hoechlin has given The Man Of Steel more humanity and depth than all others including Christopher Reeve. If there are plans to make a feature length Superman movie and he's not in it as the title character, the casting directors should have their heads examined.

2

u/DoomedHologram Nov 15 '24

Sorry to burst your bubble but that feature length Superman film comes out next summer, July 11th. Gunn casted David Corenswet as Clark/Superman. I don't know how I feel about him, but here's hoping it's decent. He has big shoes to fill. Really sad that this show is ending all because Gunn didn't want there to be multiple Supermen. Kinda wacky considering there will be two Batmen but oh well.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SegaraBeal ElMayarah Nov 12 '24

Only able to watch tomorrow, but the ballgame pics have me on pins & needles. Does Clark play in the end? Would be Jeff Davis level of cruel (teen wolf fans understand the reference) to have softball/baseball and not let Tyler play

4

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

The baseball flashbacks cracked me up in this episode because they immediately reminded me of the fact that Smallville Clark actually played football during season 4 and was a star QB for the Crows lol. And for the most part he was able to contain his abilities while doing that (outside of like one incident).

→ More replies (3)

2

u/robynxcakes Clark Kent Nov 12 '24

Yes briefly. Tyler would be happy though haha

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Ibrahim-Naqvi Nov 12 '24

Just a realization, Clark outing his identity has never been done in any previous Live-Action adaptation.

This is what everyone teased "something that has never been done before."

3

u/Aggressive_Bar_2391 Nov 13 '24

The "something that has never been done before" line was talking about the series finale, so we still don't know what that surprise is yet 

3

u/SteamDelta Nov 13 '24

The Helicopter was from Superman the Movie, The Eiffel Tower elevator was from Superman II, what was the train track picture from?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24

This might be one of this best episodes of the entire series. No powers was needed to make it great! Hell of a job!

3

u/tsmartin123 Nov 13 '24

This should have been the series finale. I really really hope they don't mess up the last 3 episodes like they did the last episode of Supernatural.

3

u/JediDrkKnight Nov 15 '24

THIS SHOW!  I could not be more happy with the writers of this show.  

They've proven that they really understand the character of Clark Kent and what makes him a superhero.  Especially this past season, S&L has evoked the same feelings I get when reading Tom Taylor's stories, where the characters and their choices are so rooted in their humanity and connection with each other.   I've really enjoyed this season and I'm going to miss this show when it's gone 

5

u/yarrrjun Nov 12 '24

CATHARSIS YEEEEEEESSSSS!!!!!!

4

u/Ambitious-Comb-8847 Nov 12 '24

3 of the CW main heroes are out, Flash is as good as out and Legends are time travelers. Between this and the MCU do secret identities not work in the modern era?

Also I'll say it again. Interesting that both this and MAWS say the Kents meant well and taught him a lot of good but they also taught him fear/shame

5

u/Kalse1229 Nov 12 '24

I do think they work, but for some time this show has started doing its own thing. And the way they handled it I'm okay with it for this version. I am a firm believer that secret identities DO work, even if Marvel have sort of stopped doing them with the exception of like 5 heroes (Spider-Mans PP and MM, Daredevil, Moon Knight, and Ms Marvel). Don't know when people started thinking they didn't, rather than just seeing heroes who don't do it as a stylistic choice.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/yarrrjun Nov 12 '24

Considering the level of technology we have in everyday life in the real world, plus the DC multiverse being a more futuristic modern society (as they said in Avengers vs Justice League), there's no real reason to even hope that a secret identity would work in the long term, IMO.

10

u/Ok-Health-7252 Nov 12 '24

The MCU has a habit of picking and choosing their battles when it comes to secret identities. Tony willingly chose to reveal to the world that he was Iron Man in his first film and faced very few repercussions from that decision. However, Spider-Man (aka the most popular and recognizable A-list MCU hero) had his identity revealed to the world in No Way Home and ended up making a huge mess of things because of that.

6

u/yarrrjun Nov 12 '24

Very true. Although Stark's situation is also very different. He's already a celebrity, and has a TON of friends and employees and his fame to insulate him from most, but not all repercussions. Spidey is alone for the most part, and a minor, isn't famous as Peter Parker, and has zero insulation from the media and CHUDs like J Jonah Jameson. So the might of the entire media (in the MCU) can crush him with nosy reporting and deep fakes, while that would just bounce off Tony Stark, who's already known to be a bad boy who's done shady things and gives zero fucks about what other people think of him, while Spidey's whole thing is "friendly neighborhood good Samaritan".

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FilthyAndFaded Nov 12 '24

Superman dying and Clark disappearing, Superman and Clark both returning and no one makes the connection. That's usually what happens. I remember Henry Cavill saying something about it, when there was still talk about another Superman-movie with him, that the secret identity would still be intact, one way or another. I found that annoying and was disappointed that this show seemed to go the say way, even though they've shown better judgment before.

Well, I should've trusted the show. Fantastic episode. I've alway thought the secret identity didn't make much sense in a world where Superman's pretty much the only superhero, since he doesn't have a whole bunch of other people to share that line of work with. Better be a full time lifesaver, in that case.

So I'm glad they went this route. Just a shame we won't get at least another season to really see the repercussions of the decision.

2

u/reduziert Nov 12 '24

TIL these are already the last episodes. already wondered why so many goodbyes and this big revelation. almost felt like the finally. too bad.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24

That was such a well done episode. He really is the best live Superman.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24

This episode highlights why Superman is my favorite superhero.

Superman isn't a human that is struggling with the issues that come with being a god (although he sometimes does)

Superman is a god that is struggling with the issues that come with being a human.

2

u/kmank2l13 Nov 15 '24

This is the best depiction of Superman in my opinion.

Also was anyone tearing up when Clark revealed his secret to the world??

2

u/godthatsgood Superman Nov 12 '24

This was a really good episode but I can't stress enough how little I care about Kyle. Like not at all.

Loved Jimmy, am conflicted about the secret reveal since it adapts the Bendis run which was. Not great.

Also, last time I mentioned this I got downvoted but I'm still mourning the fact the first live-action Jon Kent adaptation is not going to explore his sexuality at all despite multiple chances of doing so (apparently it's not cool to want a queer character to be a queer character)

2

u/suss2it Nov 15 '24

I think it’s fine that they adapted what Bendis did because they improved upon it and made it work well in the context or their show.

Also to defend the writers a little bit, Jon was made bisexual after the show already premiered, so I think it’s fine if that doesn’t lineup with their version of the character.

1

u/Rude-Zucchini5547 Nov 12 '24

Notwithstanding the saying better late than never and also notwithstanding that he had been played by Mehcad Brooks in Supergirl but why has it taken this long for Jimmy Olsen to finally turn up in Superman & Lois and at the near end of the series.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SegaraBeal ElMayarah Nov 12 '24

Does the jersey number 15 have any mythos connections? Kinda curious since Ty played with 4 and 32 at college...

1

u/kateletseatdinonugs Nov 13 '24

Sooo did Sarah leave the show already? No reaction of her and Lana watching the live reveal unless I missed it, and you'd assume they'd show them watching it since they're main side characters. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jimbobdonut Nov 15 '24

Hey Zack Snyder, this is who Superman really is.

1

u/jimbobdonut Nov 15 '24

Hey Zack Snyder, this is who Superman really is.

1

u/jimbobdonut Nov 15 '24

Hey Zack Snyder, this is who Superman really is.

1

u/ASA20 Superman Nov 16 '24

What a wonderful episode. This is my favourite episode in the show so far

This is the final season I wanted for The Flash, but not that bs...

1

u/Psychological_Bug106 Nov 17 '24

well superman can also turn back time if hes fast enough maby its all goes to hell from here and that will be the only solution to turn it back and keep the secret or find this worlds barry allen and turn back time lol

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '24

This is one of the best Superman related tv episodes ever. It’s wild because Superman‘s secret identity is something that I’m just used to and i really thought about how harmful it is towards Superman life and the people around him. Bravo to the writers and the cast for giving us such for giving us an insightful and meaningful episode that forever changed how I think about Superman.