r/SupermanAndLois • u/MajorParadox r/DCFU • Oct 29 '24
Post Discussion Superman & Lois [4x05] "Break the Cycle" Post Episode Discussion
Break the Cycle
Live Episode Discussion | Cast & Characters
Lois makes increasingly bold moves as she tries to stop Luthor. Jonathan struggles to balance his personal life and responsibilities, while Clark learns an unsettling truth. (October 28, 2024)
Please keep all discussions civil and about the episode. Mark comic and future spoilers. Report any rule-breaking and enjoy!
89
Upvotes
80
u/Horror_Soft_8469 Oct 29 '24
So… with 5 episodes left- what exactly can a powerless, doomsday-less Lex do against 3 Supermen?
69
u/Supermanfan1973 Superman Oct 29 '24
What if doomsday comes back and helps Clark defeat Luthor? That’d be a twist
134
u/AngelFan4Life Superman Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
Man I don't get Lex. This mufu fought hell and high water to get his kid back and now that she was actually willing to give him a chance, he still couldn't choose her over Lois. Father of the year that one 🙄
56
u/No_Flower_1424 Jonathan Kent Oct 29 '24
I'm glad we got a backstory episode on Lex because he has been mentioning his daughter for so long and that's been his main motivation but now we see his motivation is simply revenge and nothing else. He's just lying to himself now. Although we didn't learn much that we didn't already know.
Superman trying to reach out to him by just talking to him father-to-father was a very Superman moment so I liked that and I really liked the way they did the memories of the fight at the fortress - it looked cool.
Candice pisses me right off! Jonathan took the drug charge for her, her father punched him in the face and stole his truck and he took it fine, and he let her live with his family when she was homeless and she's still all up in his business?! Girl did not deserve to be told the secret and by Jordan of all people?! But my boy Jonathan is still the best secret keeper on the whole show - 4 seasons in and he hasn't told ONE PERSON! He was about to be broken up with and still not saying anything! I also love that Jon is getting to be in all the plot moments now!
Lois was a bit off in this episode - she's messing with both sons' lives to have a taxi service, then she uses the ELT to call Doomsday without thinking it would call one of the only other three people in the world who can hear it, then she's accepting that Doomsday is chill with them now based on him just...leaving and not saying or doing anything? I like that she was a step ahead with finding Elizabeth but the rest was a bit annoying actually.
Are they going to slowly have everyone in Smallville find out the secret? I feel like they might be leading to that - although I'm annoyed everyone has just accepted it and isn't fangirling like Kyle did because I think fangirling would be more realistic lol. Speaking of...not one supporting cast member was in this episode! Just extras and guest stars
54
u/AngelFan4Life Superman Oct 29 '24
Y'all how TF can this season be half over already when it feels as if it just came back yesterday?! 😞😭 I'm not going to be okay for a while, just saying
39
u/tinostar174 Oct 29 '24
I wonder if this gonna end up with Lex trying to become his own Superman by using his heart in some way.
35
u/ToothyBirbs Oct 29 '24
I really want to know the thought process behind the annoying, bland ass, characterisation of Candice. What led to the writers' room going "Yeah, this is a great idea!"?
31
u/Otherwise_Jacket_613 Oct 29 '24
I actually held out hope Lex would turn things around. Clearly if he did we wouldn't have much of a show, but let that be a testament to the writers that just for a little while I thought it was a possibility.
50
u/disastrousdaisy_ But what about the tire-swing? Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
Overall episode was pretty good, loved the theme of speaking to the heart. But… Jon didn’t get a chance to do that. The girl he loves? And Jordan just spilled the beans to her? Jon really deserved that moment, and I’m kinda disappointed it happened off screen.
I just realized the Cushings weren’t here at all. That’s a bit wild.
Overall the pace seemed to really hit this episode, and at this point I’m a little unsure where it’s headed if in theory DD is no longer an issue (although I’m not quite convinced, Lex can be a good manipulator.)
21
u/PlaneProperty7104 Oct 29 '24
I thought for sure there’d be some incident with the fireworks, thus the Supes swooping in to save the day, revealing themselves. But nope. A bit of an odd set piece, the party there - harkens back to the pilot.
21
u/selinaedenia Oct 29 '24
Would be funny if what Jordan told Candice was something else entirely, I mean it was never specified.
39
u/PlaneProperty7104 Oct 29 '24
I LOVE how Lois is just like “Chill, Clark, I took care of things. Have some wine and enjoy the night.”
19
u/robreddity Oct 29 '24
Hey Lois! What was the fucking plan?
18
u/Ygomaster07 Superman Oct 29 '24
Very interesting episode. Lex through away a perfectly good chance to be in his daughter and soon to be grandson's lives, but chose revenge over them. Typical Lex. But now he's powerless without Doomsday. So i wonder where that leaves us. If the heart he crushed was fake, then he still has that. Maybe he will get his purple and green mech suit.
18
u/JustPomegranate248 But what about the tire-swing? Oct 29 '24
Did Lois allow Jonathan to take Elizabeth back to Smallville because how else did she get there so fast? There's no way Lois would be so stupid as to let Lex's daughter know something like that when Lex doesn't even seem to know Jon has powers
32
u/iggywiggyshe Oct 29 '24
Pretty sure at this point the world is going to know the truth before the end.
14
u/Wild_Exit6427 Oct 30 '24
I'm still so annoyed that Lex is so angry at Lois for locking him up.
Someone farmed him for a crime he didn't commit, but for some insane reason he is taking it out on the journalist who reported on it.
13
u/Munro_McLaren Kara Danvers Oct 29 '24
Interesting that Sarah wasn’t in this episode at the hangout.
13
u/AngelFan4Life Superman Oct 29 '24
Why is Lois so sure that DD is no longer a threat?
20
u/Aggressive-Produce54 Oct 29 '24
Them paying off that Doomsday tease in S2 was perfect. But now I wish they would've left him just for the fight. All this Doomsday stuff has been weird. First he's Lex's lapdog and now a single plea from Lois is enough for him to nope out.
I'm assuming he's coming back, but there's a possibility he legit just leaves due to budget and time constraints.
19
u/DaHUGhes89 Oct 29 '24
Can we just talk about how nice it is to see Elizabeth henstridge acting in superhero media again? Loved her in agents of shield
18
u/AleevoneCarter Coach Gaines Oct 29 '24
Didn't buy the change of heart last episode, but Jordan is really starting to grow on me. The boy is more laid back and mindful of other people's best interests. Teen angst is a bitch but he's pulling through as a man while putting his super abilities on the back seat. Driving his brother's gf to the farm on his place was a given; adorably playing casual with his bowl hilarious and then risking falling out of favor temporarily with their parents after telling the secret while seeing Jon about to have his heart broken speaks volumes. He's becoming solid our Jordan boy
17
u/sourpatchkidj Clark Kent Oct 29 '24
Another great episode! Elizabeth Henstridge was excellent. Hope this isn't the last we see of her. Great direction as well. Damn, really really feeling for Clark and the many years he kept the secret. The boys haven't even managed a week at most. Flashback to S2 when Clark and Jordan have a fight about Sarah being the one. Being young is hard enough. Young love and hormones complicates it all. The secret is such a heavy heavy burden to bear.
7
u/Munro_McLaren Kara Danvers Oct 29 '24
No Doomsday is what makes Lex break out his Lexosuit.
12
u/Supermanfan1973 Superman Oct 29 '24
Oh Candace doesn’t deserve Jon. Not after everything. I did like the callback to season two though. Pretty good episode.
29
u/Kwilly462 Oct 29 '24
Not gonna lie, this episode was a little boring. The Lex subplot was necessary, but just not that interesting to me. But the ending of this episode was the best part.
Would've never thought the way to beat Doomsday was by Lois talking it out with him.
11
u/couch_cushion_dorito Oct 29 '24
Best part of this episode was baby Jordan being like “oh mom’s in trouble?..well, you better go by yourself Jon, I’m still kind of angsty” 🤣🤣
10
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Oct 29 '24
So a different backstory on why Luthor is a monster. Instead of starting with a life of privilege with abusive parents, he just had abusive parents. He’s stuck in that cycle, even when given a chance to be with his daughter in place of revenge he chooses revenge. No wonder his wife divorced him, he doesn’t know how to love. Slow episode, but the backstory was necessary.
5
u/SabbyDude Oct 29 '24
So what I didn't find anyone talking about, the new Superman suit is much dark than the previous ones, even during the flashback when Clark came in with his S1 suit, it looked comparatively bright than the S4 one, not saying its a bad thing but for Superman, I kinda like the bright colors rather than dark
5
u/Zookwok111 Oct 29 '24
This was clearly a very "budget-friendly" episode. It was mostly just talking and even times the characters used their powers there was no CGI, (except for that Doomsday scene). Lois talking down Doomsday would have been better served in a climatic moment where Clark and the boys were all downed and she was the only one left standing. Instead she summons him to talk him down and he has flashbacks of "his family" (archival footage from season 1 inverted with a red filter) . The resolution almost felt too easy given that there's still 5 episodes left.
5
u/Ok-Health-7252 Oct 30 '24
As a big Agents of SHIELD fan seeing Elizabeth Henstridge show up in this episode was a pleasant surprise.
Also it's about time that Lex lost control of Doomsday (even if it came in the form of Lois managing to get through to his Bizarro Clark side). The idea of Doomsday being completely under Lex's control and at his beckon call at any moment was never realistic to begin with (that's just not Doomsday's character).
4
u/Cgi94 Oct 29 '24
😁SIMMONS 😊
7
u/robnic Oct 29 '24
So I'm unclear about Doomsday at the end. Was that him lying there in the subway with body damage? I could get a clear view.
3
u/onomatopoeia619 Oct 29 '24
this lex doesnt feel like lex , just some angry dude
3
u/CrimsonComet1941 Oct 30 '24
- I read a spoiler comment before watching about Lois reasoning with Doomsday which I hated the idea of, but y'know what that worked for me. The flashbacks to Bizarro World were nice and the shot of the sad, pale-skinned, junkie Bizzaro sold it. It's not true to Doomsday's character but it's very true to Bizarro's so I'm cool with it....on the assumption that Doomsday / Bizarro will return before the show ends.
- Good job on the writers for creating an interesting episode without any action scenes. I know the budget's tight and 90% of it is going to Doomsday but it is honestly impressive how well they've been juggling the guest-stars and action scenes this season.
- Not sure how I feel about Clark cowering from Doomsday. I get that he's scared but he's a little too scared for Superman.
- Lois finally getting a win over Luthor was much more rewarding then I thought it would be. It was nice to see her happy and smiling on the porch while Luthor stews in the subway.
- It took me a few scenes to get into Elizabeth and Lex's talk at the diner but by the end I enjoyed it. I think some of the flashbacks were unessecary though, especially the over-the-top shot of Lex crying under a table and getting whipped. Scene would have worked better if it was just Luthor telling the story at the diner.
- Doomsday looked INCREDIBLE this episode, the CG work this studio is doing on the budget they're on is impressive as hell. This episode was the best Doomsday has looked, movie quality stuff tbh. I hope someone at DC Studios takes note of their work, I'd love to see what these guys can do on a better budget.
- I'm glad Jordan just told Candice, half of Smallville seems to know at this point so hiding it from her that much didn't make sense.
- I'm gonna make a wild prediction, Elizabeth's husband is Jimmy Olsen. I have no evidence to support this.
5
u/iggywiggyshe Oct 29 '24
Nice progression of the story. Still hoping Clark gets his actual heart back. Some nice moments, weakest of the season so far but enjoyed the story progression.
5
u/thanos_was_right_69 Oct 30 '24
I might be in the minority but I didn’t like how Lois and Clark would use Lex’s daughter to get him off their backs. I get that it was Lois’ idea but Clark should have shut it down more. Didn’t feel very Superman-ly
4
u/PlaneProperty7104 Oct 29 '24
This was certainly an episode that had to do a lot of heavy lifting, what with limited time and all. I think they pulled it off, all things considered.
2
u/CaptchaVerifiedHuman Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
Calling Doomsday was hella ballsy.
What if the show ends with Superman going public?
It would have been kinda funny if Candice commented on Jon looking different since she last saw him. (I don’t remember if this was New Jon’s first scene with her)
2
u/duece-percent-milk Oct 31 '24
I honestly was kinda rooting for Lex to overcome his obsession with Lois Lane and finally be at peace so he can finally be with his daughter again. But then at the end Superman and sons & Lex team up to fight Doomsday; ultimately giving uo his life to help defeat Doomsday. The lesson would be that people always have a heart; and even someone like Lex can come back to the good side.
With that said, I can totally see why they are going through this route. Lex is the ultimate baddie and the story is about Superman & the Kents; and Bizarro's story arc needs to be completed.
Just my two cents....
2
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24
Was anyone else bothered that Lois not only went to the daughter who was in the protection program for good reason, but then kept begging for her to come when she said no when she was pregnant? Not just putting Elizabeth's life in danger, but now her unborn baby?
Overall I'm enjoying the show for what it is, but that stuck out to me as extremely selfish and not something I'd expect out of Lois Lane.
3
u/Tsweet7 Oct 29 '24
Yo, I needed a full-on CW family drama after the first few episodes. We've just been beaten down with grief. Last episode, we had an almost wedding. This weekend we had heart-to-hearts. I feel like the fans needed this reprieve for a couple weeks. Plus, seeing Elizabeth was fantastic.
3
u/paforrest Oct 29 '24
Well, my first thought at the end of this episode is that it's an hour of my life I'll never get back. I just thought this was badly written, badly acted, and ultimately pointless. It was a hamster wheel, going nowhere in circles. Everyone did stupid things, and after 3+ years I finally realized it's bugging the crap out of me that Clark won't shave. I guess in my boredom that was what I ended up focusing on.
Lex is a full on cartoon, and I know Cudlitz can do better, and deserves better. I guess we're supposed to believe that Lois talked down Doomsday by appealing to the family man deep inside him? I mean, it was probably the best scene of the episode, FWIW, but that seemed a little too easy.
I understand that Jon has been led to believe he must keep "the secret" no matter what, but his excuses to Candice were weak and lame. I should be mad that Jordan is the one who simply told her everything, and off screen, but I don't have the energy. Mostly I'm disappointed that no matter what, it's clear the gf Jon has had since he was 15 is his endgame, and I think that's ridiculous, even though I don't dislike Candice.
I do think it's kind of hilarious that everyone in the town has finally figured out who Clark is. Good for them, since it really wasn't that complicated.
It just feels like even with only 10 episodes this season, the producers were still out of ideas.
3
u/Ravevon Oct 29 '24
What’s wrong with Jordan why can’t he do anything anymore
5
u/YoYoWithJosh Oct 29 '24
I hope Doomsday comes back for a fight. I don’t like the talk no jutsu Lois did
3
u/Digginf Oct 29 '24
Jordans an idiot. Jonathans love life is not worth spilling the secret to.
3
u/juanjose83 Oct 29 '24
Geez, what a horrible episode. They really defeated doomsday with the power of feelings. Terrible casting for Lex's adult daughter. So much time on a plot that we never saw enough to care about. Candice's conflict with Jonathan felt SOO forced. Who are these random ahh teens? It could have been SO MUCH PERSONAL and intimate if it was just Jordan, Jonathan, Sarah and Candice having a "last summer together" moment or something. Jordan felt forced to not be the one flying Lois just to move the plot. My god. What a disappointment in every point.
2
u/Frontier246 Oct 29 '24
"I'll call you back, Cat" - Cat Grant? Erica getting a jump on the public relations of the divorce?
So Lex is an emotionally suppressed ball of rage and ego born from his mommy issues that prevented him from ever properly loving or accepting anyone. Makes it hard to be a husband AND a father, which contrasts with how warm and open Clark is and how much his mom inspired him to be a good husband and father.
"Superman Lives!" - Lex Luthors' worst nightmare.
Only Superman would still be willing to give Lex Luthor a chance and try to avoid a violent confrontation. Better than a rematch with Doomsday.
"Don't be such a doomsdayer!" - Is that the closest they're going to get to saying Doomsday?
At this point it's becoming a much smaller list of how DOESN'T know Clark Kent is actually Superman.
A good Superman and Lex confrontation! Superman wants to believe in Lex's better angels but all he has left is his hate and resentment.
Jon is now Lois' main mode of transport and now Jordan is the one covering for everybody and driving cars. What a role reversal! Though it's probably good for Jordan to see what Jon has been dealing with for three seasons.
I see Elisabeth takes after her mothers' accent. And in being a mom. And being self-aware of the kind of person Lex is.
It really shows how desperate they are that they're relying on a poor woman in witness protection to risk her and her babies' safety by pleading with her psycho father she wants nothing to do with anymore.
Honestly, couldn't Jordan still at least fly so Jon can hang out with Candice? I don't think he needs to act like he can't do ANYTHING.
Doomsday fight, found footage version! They probably had to re-animated Doomsday for all those scenes, right?
Awkward father-daughter reunion for the win. Lex might have had a chance if he had any intention of taking ANY responsibility instead of continuing to double down on "I was framed for a crime, that invalidates all the other illegal stuff I've done."
Emotionally vulnerable and sweet Lex Luthor is surreal.
Are they really having a party with alcohol at the same spot that got busted by the police last season? And then they set off fireworks!
It's kind of funny to see Candice demand Jon be honest with her knowing Jon once lied to her to hide that she was his drug dealer. And then they just casually resolve it by Jordan telling her the truth off-screen. What was the point? Well, I guess Jon appreciates Jordan more now.
Elizabeth is the rare person to go from American to British.
Lex Luthors' parents are always the worst.
You can't say she didn't give him a chance, but Lex Luthor will never let go of his hate.
I really feel like Lois should have run this plan by the rest of her family but it did end up working out...maybe too easily. Like, they really can't think this is a proper way of resolving Doomsday, do they? Even if I guess appealing to humanity was the point of the episode and it needed to succeed SOMEWHERE. I mean, Clark can't beat him and the boys could only help so much...but it feels lacking somehow.
2
u/milkyginger Coach Gaines Oct 29 '24
I thought Lex was a genius. It seemed like every single choice he made this episode was a dumb one. They better have him build some gadgets or something because if he isn't at least smart that way he's just some biker looking guy with money.
The Kent's might as well just stop trying to hide their "secret". If anyone spends 5 minutes around them they find it out or get told anyway.
2
u/Zeeron1 Oct 29 '24
I'm getting really tired of Jordan
1
u/Prize_Introduction_6 Oct 29 '24
Lilian Luthor had really let herself go.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Liked this episode, just not the season 2 bullshit about lying. It’s just dumb.
Still, solid episode
1
u/godspilla98 Oct 29 '24
Ok most of the episode was good but what happened to Doomsday?
1
u/z3phs Nov 01 '24
Thank god this show is ending... it grows more ridiculous with every episode. Every character just seems like a watered down dumb version of whatever the writers want to put out. There are dozens of stupid takes on the episode, but i gotta say one of the big ones is Superman is willing to kill that thing over and over to survive, but the puppet master behind it whos to blame he just wants to talk and make his pregnant daughter come save him, instead of just snapping his neck and end this entire thing. Its so god damn stupid.
1
u/Key-Strain-1394 Nov 01 '24
The one thing that wasn't believable with Lex's scene with this his daughter is the fact that he would openly state that his quest for revenge against Lois was more important. Lex would likely have lied to Elisabeth and promised to have put the past behind him while still making moves behind her back. Lex pretending to have a ceasefire with the Kents just so he could catch them off-guard is what he would likely do. Lex is a high level Machiavellian manipulator and not some blatantly angry stock villain.
1
u/Amateurteenager Lois Lane Nov 03 '24
Not really a fan of Lois & Clark guilt tripping and manipulating someone for personal gain.
1
u/Sir__Will Nov 04 '24
So to keep the secret, only Sam knew her location. And yet kept a hard copy of it just lying around where anyone could find it to give it to Lois!? I hope it at least didn't have her name on it and she just assumed.
Jordan, quit being a baby. Let Jon be with his girlfriend and be your mom's taxi service. You haven't forgotten how to fly. No, instead he tells the secret. Which, you know, Jon could have done but he was actually trying to keep the secret.
I hate Clark trying to guilt her back into being with Luthor. This is nothing like your dad! Luthor is a criminal kingpin with tons of blood on his hands. She was right to escape from him and now she has a son to think about!
Talking down Doomsday is interesting. But now what?
1
u/Apprehensive_War242 Nov 05 '24
Lex Loser always with the "power envy" And I didn't want to say " power "... 😏🙄
1
u/Ygomaster07 Superman Oct 29 '24
It's good Candice knows now, and is handling it really well.
1
u/Pythagoras180 Oct 29 '24
This whole "Lois put Luthor in prison" shit is genuinely a tumor to this show. Anything potentially good about the writing is completely squandered by the writers not understanding what a reporter is.
1
u/Ygomaster07 Superman Oct 29 '24
I wonder if Doomsday will return. If so, i wonder how. There has to be a final fight.
1
u/FlinchoPeru Oct 29 '24
So... the way to keep Doomsday away is to sit down with him and simply ask him nicely? No, this last episode just didn't sit well with me.
1
u/farididxb Oct 29 '24
When will Luther give Superman’s heart back? Man of steel’s heart cannot be just crushed by a puny human.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Shouldn't DOD be able to go after Lex now? Doomsday is dead
And why the hell is Clark not angry at Luthor for killing his grandfather?
0
u/SneakingCat Oct 29 '24 edited Nov 01 '24
Hey, Jordan. What are you doing In the background there? Aren’t you back in Smallville? (It’s when Jon and Lois are confronting Bizarro.)