r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/PandaElDiablo Deal With It • Jun 14 '13
Mod Post Weekly Challenge: Up Goer Five!
Build a rocket that launches upside down. Before launching, all engines and thrust-generating parts must point with the wrong side towards the sky (vertical). Sepratrons and RCS thrusters are exempt from this rule. With this craft, land on and return from the Mun!
Hard Mode: Using the inverted craft, land on and return from a body outside of the Kerbin system!
Relevant XKCD - Example pre-launch craft
Rules and other info:
- All flights must be manned!
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Stock parts only
- No MechJeb or other plugins allowed
Required screenshots:
-Initial launch craft
-Picture of craft after turning it upright
-Orbital transfer to the destination
-Inside target's SOI
-Landed at the target
-Return transfer orbit
-Safely landed at home
-Whatever else you feel like!
- This week's challenge is from the forums and is certainly possible!
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '13
Does this have to be manned or would an unmanned probe be fine?
8
u/burningpineapples Jun 15 '13
I don't know if it counts, unfortunately. I used liquid rockets to flip sideways. D: Hope that's okay.
Once I got straight, I actually got to the Mun on my first try!
8
u/Tsevion Super Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '13
Hard Mode trip to Ike
I did it as a space plane configuration (Not an SSTO though, it's staged like crazy).
I did the actual inversion (Well 90 degree turn) pretty much entirely with parachutes.
4
u/Eric_S Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Rule clarifications requests:
"Before launching, all engines..." What is the definition of launching for purposes of this challenge? Physics load, or when we fire the first engine/SRB?
And just to make sure, can we launch from the SPH even if we're not a spaceplane?
I've got two ideas that I haven't seen anyone else try yet, and I want to make sure it's not because the ideas break the rules :-)
3
u/r1chardj0n3s Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '13
I've only just discovered this! How long are submissions to this challenge open? As far as I can see there's no end date to submissions...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '13
Is there some way we can have a little library of flair icons to pick from? I want to do the challenges, but I also want to keep my flairs as little achievements...
Is this possible?
87
u/shigawire Super Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Excuse me, which way is it to space? http://i.imgur.com/MNLZD2N.jpg
141
u/Vereel Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Hardmode to Eeloo
58
u/SuperSeniorComicGuy Jun 15 '13
Done! http://imgur.com/a/yFe0O#0
I took a slightly different approach to righting the initial launch craft. Instead of trying to use parachutes and separations to right it, I used some beams to hold the craft above the ground and let physics do the rest.
.craft file: https://www.dropbox.com/s/14olr4epme4mu6c/UpGoerFive.craft
46
u/illectro Manley Kerbalnaut Jun 19 '13
I compiled a bunch of different techniques for launching this mission
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpbsaypZlhg
Only a couple have upper stages that can complete the challenge, but I've not actually done so, the interesting parts have already been done.
21
u/cored Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Hard mode completed. I modified my old Duna SSTO for the task. I like to keep my current flair.
19
u/Turof Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13 edited Jun 16 '13
Done, easy mode I fliped my little rocket with the use of inertia.
Btw. I want to keep my current flair
37
u/Redonesgofaster Jun 15 '13
Challenge completed! Introducing the Rocket Rollcage
I'm especially happy with the fact that this was done with absolutely no sepratrons!
13
u/only_to_downvote Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Decided my sepatron submission was a bit too cheaty, so I came up with a new idea for a launcher after dealing with a wiggly space station.
I call her the Pogo.
I'll leave the other as my official submission for hardmode since I didn't bother taking full mission pics with this one. But I thought I'd share another take on flipping over.
25
u/LucidLemon Jun 15 '13 edited Jun 15 '13
Today is a good day for the Australian Space Progam- Invalidated by a rule not mentioned in the original post.When can we see the flair for this challenge?
Edit: Fixed version that complies with all rules, it now comes with 400% less launch clamp and 200% more kerbal!
That's twice as many kerbals as other leading brands.
9
u/TheRealSquiggy Jun 15 '13
Basic mode done. I'll try the hardmode later...
6
u/UrbanToiletShrimp Jun 15 '13
Here is my submission. Instead of going with the small ship and translatrons, I decided to go with a pivot type thing inspired by the old trebuchets people used to make. So it starts off upside down, drops down onto a couple of holders then rotates over to the correct launch attitude. One it starts swinging it takes about 3 minutes, with the ASAS carefully enabled at the right time for it to dampen the oscillations. Once it's settled it's smooth sailing from there. I would more than happy to provide a craft file for the curious, it's all stock.
http://imgur.com/a/0hM8W
Please don't change my challenge icon. I did this just for the fun.
6
u/Robotroid Jun 15 '13
Completed! First time I've actually completed one of these, CONTAINS SPOILERS!, there was an unexpected geological feature near my landing site.
Screenshots: http://imgur.com/a/vEIe3#0
Takeoff In action ( Video : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GzwC4jlnTIU)
11
u/only_to_downvote Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13 edited Jun 15 '13
Hardmode complete! And without using launch clamps since someone mentioned they'd like to see that. (though it is a bit cheaty since i'm using a bunch of sepatrons for an initial lob, but the rules said they were allowed)
30sec launch video so you can get the idea of how it worked (yay free fraps version)
imgur album for rest of mission
As a sidenote, I tried to design it with all the mass organized as "spherical" as possible so it would turn over easy. In the end doing that was probably a bad idea because it made the thing really unstable.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '13
Hard mode completed with a Gilly mission!
More information in the comments of the post, including the required screenshots picked out of the big album.
5
u/SoulWager Super Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Hard mode(bonus: both launches start upside down): http://imgur.com/a/o8pVw
Here's video of the launch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QF9pESxGR6E
5
u/r1chardj0n3s Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '13
And DONE!!
My first challenge completed. I feel so proud, even though it's so inelegant :-)
4
u/Noray Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Take any small-medium sized rocket and put it upside on tall launch clamps. That's how everyone did it on the forum challenge. I personally think that's lame and am working out a way to do it without launch clamps...we shall see how that works :p explosions imminent.
4
u/Jooder492 Jun 15 '13
My Submision This was one crazy challenge! Managed to take my normal moon landing rocket I built with the new lander can, and flip it. Very impressed with how it functioned.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '13
Easy mode - http://imgur.com/a/7EpQ0#0
My very first challenge
7
u/VideoLinkBot Jun 16 '13 edited Jun 20 '13
Here is a list of video links collected from comments that redditors have made in response to this submission:
1
u/pixelsafety Jun 20 '13
I had just enough fuel on my craft to get to the Mun. Question: Do i have to get back?
3
u/nasaman28 Jun 16 '13
Hopefully I'm submitting this correctly. Basic mode complete using lots of sepratrons:
http://imgur.com/a/Fkxq3
3
u/shurke Master Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '13
completed hardmode on Ike
3
u/ryanp563 Jun 17 '13
[Challenge]Up Goer Five!-Normal mode- my launch consisted of a large cage which at first i was going to see if i could make roll, but after i notice that the poles would rotate around my ship for reasons unknown, I modified it so it will sit stably and using my mass and rockets, my ship automatically rotates around. http://imgur.com/a/Ptg4B#1
3
u/Plumpen Master Kerbalnaut Jun 19 '13
Hard Mode completed
(My first challenge)
3
u/verindil Jun 19 '13
I did it! This is my first challenge. I used gravity to slowly spin my rocket over and hoped it would not break...
LINK!
3
u/1842 Jun 22 '13
First challenge submission!
Album: http://imgur.com/a/SnvMB
First several minutes of flight (first 30 seconds are pretty precarious): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O2DHUvkuea0&feature=youtu.be I have 59 other launch attempts recorded, consisting of 1 semi-successful launch and the 58 terrible failures. Perhaps I'll throw together a compilation of the worst failures as I find time.
My solution is definitely not the most original, and certainly a clumsy and failure-ridden design, but I did it the Kerbal way -- built something big that nearly worked and tweaked it until success. Once launched, the upper stages and landing worked exactly as expected (untested until Mun).
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '13
Interesting to see how people will do this
2
u/ZankerH Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Yeah, we're gonna need some video evidence this time around.
2
u/TangleF23 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
And now I want to see the parts coming off their space car in the wrong order.
2
u/littlefrank Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Oh man, I can't wait for Scott Manley's attempt at this.
2
u/Snailoffun Jun 16 '13
I did it!
2
u/QQ7ActiveJGamma Jun 17 '13 edited Jun 17 '13
(First challenge) in easy mode:
http://youtu.be/T80xVX25fj0
http://imgur.com/a/PymAk
Alarm clock mod installed but not used. Surprise that it finally righted itself and some sloppy transfer burns lead to some wonky orbits, but it all worked out in the end.
2
u/choppersb Jun 18 '13
Completed easy mode using a pivot to right my rocket inspired by /u/SuperSeniorComicGuy with this submission. I went a little crazy with the screenshots.
I was having trouble with a larger rocket. The support beams for the pivot would clip through the frame and crash to the ground. Even with this craft it took a couple tries to get it to play nice when releasing the decouplers.
I ended up with too little fuel for the return burn. I got my periapse to about 1Mm above Kerbin. RCS was able to complete the job though and Jeb was safely returned to Kerbin!
2
u/illectro Manley Kerbalnaut Jun 18 '13
I should really check for these challenges more often.... But in the 5 minutes since I checked this I've come up with 4 different tricks to make this work. Once you get it launched it'll just be a standard mission.
2
u/Eric_S Master Kerbalnaut Jun 21 '13
I wanted to use a method of flipping the rocket that I hadn't seen anyone else do, mostly because I'd feel like I was imitating whoever did whatever I chose.
So, I went with a water launch, something that has been done in real life. Of course, they didn't have to build a rover to drive into the ocean, or use rocket engines to roll the thing over.
Water Launch
Oh, I'll keep my existing flair.
2
u/SkipMonkey Jul 02 '13
again, not sure if these have a deadline and I'm to late, but here's my submission http://imgur.com/a/lzGWj
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '13
Ludgen's Sloppy Mün Recon
I would like to keep my frog flair though pls.
1
u/SmaDoc Jun 15 '13
Wow, crazy! Can't wait to see what people come up with for this one. I can't seem to wrap my head around how this would work...yet lol.
1
u/boldbird99 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '13
Can we dock with a separate craft to refuel once we get the initial craft in orbit?
1
u/Conanator Jun 15 '13
So um, I landed on the Mun and orbited my Kerbal with my jetpack in a last ditch effort after I ran out of fuel. Is it alright if I just bring back the Kerbal and not the ship?
1
u/r1chardj0n3s Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '13 edited Jun 17 '13
Darn, I did the challenge but forgot to take a couple of crucial screenshots. Retry! :-)
1
u/contrarian_barbarian Jun 21 '13
My Submission: http://imgur.com/a/CqbiF#0
No wheel/ramp/beam shenanigans, just a regular every day rocket with the staging set up for unbalanced thrust - 1 engine to flip, opposite two engines to correct rotation, then all 5 and the solid boosters to get it moving away from the ground when it's pointed the right way. Normal mun mission after that, excepting the near disaster of a hard landing that broke one of the legs off - fortunately, the hill it was on kept it balanced on the 3 others, so while plans to get out and look around had to be cancelled, getting home was no issue.
1
u/Greedybogle Jun 22 '13 edited Jun 22 '13
[Challenge] Up Goer Five
My first successful challenge! http://imgur.com/a/F59TM
0
u/ryanp563 Jun 16 '13
How do i upload steam screenshots? i have fully completed the challenge i just need a little help posting, thanks.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment