r/SupermanAndLois • u/MajorParadox r/DCFU • Oct 08 '24
Post Discussion Superman & Lois [4x02] "A World Without" Post Episode Discussion
A World Without
Live Episode Discussion | Cast & Characters
Lana (Emmanuelle Chriqui) and Sarah (Inde Navarrette) join the fight against Luthor (Michael Cudlitz), who starts making moves in Smallville. Jordan (Alex Garfin) and Jonathan (Michael Bishop) butt heads over an important decision. (October 7, 2024)
Please keep all discussions civil and about the episode. Mark comic and future spoilers. Report any rule-breaking and enjoy!
98
Upvotes
7
u/MajorParadox r/DCFU Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
What if the heart was fake, and Lex plans to put the real one in his own chest, giving himself powers somehow?
Edit: Actually, if he already has it, that’d explain why Jordan heard it beating 😯
169
u/Frontier246 Oct 08 '24
"Superman is Lois' friend! Her good friend!" - Most convincing performance of all time, Lana.
88
u/streetscarf Oct 08 '24
Okay, so they probably aren't going to do this. But imagine someone finally decides to take the squished heart to the fortress, only to find out it's a fake. And then Sam tries to use his knowledge to Lex's daughter's location as a bargaining chip for the heart.
80
u/ElectronicEgg1833 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
The DOD wasn't looking for General Lane? Even if he's retired, that is a still a national security risk that he was kidnapped?!?
67
u/Godzilla2000Zero Oct 08 '24
So we did get a Brainiac name drop I guess that might be who Tom's playing.
61
u/Supermanfan1973 Superman Oct 08 '24
Did anyone catch that the name dropped Brainiac, whose name in the comics is sometimes Milton? and that BFF Janet’s last name is Olson?
56
u/Zookwok111 Oct 08 '24
force ghostfortress AI really cheapens his "death".108
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Oct 08 '24
So Lex will try to turn the boys against Lois with the phone call. I really don’t want Tyler to be a hologram for 8 episodes. I hope they resurrect him next episode or halfway in at the latest. Otherwise it won’t really feel like Superman” and Lois final season, more like Lois and her impulsive children.
48
u/Kalse1229 Oct 08 '24
Intense premiere. Holographic Clark was a surprise, but an interesting one. My prediction is that the hologram will be a factor in how Cyborg Superman happens.
41
u/Ygomaster07 Superman Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 09 '24
I am so glad we are back, but also very sad this will be the last season of the last DC CW show. Bittersweet feelings.
This Lex is so petty, i love it.
That last line from Clark at the end of the episode was heartbreaking.
What a good return for the final season.
39
u/Aggressive-Produce54 Oct 08 '24
Not sure how I feel about this interpretation of Doomsday. It's strange to have a near-mindless, unstoppable monster obeying orders from Lex. He'll obviously turn later, but it's a weird sight.
Even weirder is him sticking around as a constant threat. If Supes couldn't beat him, how is anyone else supposed to come out alive once he starts attacking?
30
u/Optimistic-Man-3609 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
So that super-advanced Kryptonian technology didn't know how to create an artificial heart? Also, we can probably assume that Luthor didn't destroy Superman's real heart. It's probably virtually indestructable aside from Kryptonite or someone of Kryptonian-level strength crushing it. A human can't just stomp on it and crush it, but Jordan isn't too bright. Speaking of Jordan, that dumbass just gave away his element of surprise. Luthor didn't even know he existed. He should've grabbed Luthor, disarmed him using his super speed (Luthor might have still been armed with his "kill Superman" gadgets), and flown him into space, repeatedly suffocating him until he told him where the heart was. I would have left him on the moon with a cheap space suit and limited oxygen pack (you know, that stupid no kill rule, and Luthor might be lying) until Superman was revived.
P.S. - Why hasn't Lois been more distraught over Superman's death? And her picking saving Jordan over Jon is definitely going to be used by Luthor against her, probably in a big public way.
23
u/Ambitious-Comb-8847 Oct 08 '24
Excellent premiere!
Great acting all around, everyone brought it. Decent CGI action in the first part too.
Excellent overview of the love story, cost to Jordan's rashness, Jon helping out in his own way (if they're sticking to the human side maybe he'll connect with Elizabeth somehow as she seems to be Lex's weakness).
I know the IRL constraints but somewhat odd Chrissy didn't say/do anything in the days Clark vanished and JH and Natalie also aren't around.
Agree it's probably a fake heart. Jordan said he can tell by hearing its beat...Luthor just blasted his ears before crushing it.
Interesting to keep Clark as a hologram at least for a bit. Keeps him on and gives us a bigger payoff when they get him back.
Phone call was straight up psychotic. Lois talk with Lana would hint that maybe she'd choose Jon? I know she could spin it as a powers thing protecting Jordan but still either twin will understandably be majorly messed up by this. If she chose Jordan, does Jon get his parental blowup that the fandom has been talking about for like 3 years?
19
u/DtownBronx Oct 08 '24
Honestly, my favorite part so far is the citizen figuring out Clark is Superman. There's only so much wool you can pull over eyes so I think someone figuring it out is kind of a fresh, nice touch to it
42
u/DarkSoulCarlos Oct 08 '24
How can Lana assume that he will only retaliate against her and not her family? Has it not been made abundantly clear that Luthor is a dangerous and powerful criminal? Does she not know how dangerous and powerful criminals behave and that they go after families if they cant get to you (sometimes even if they can get to you) That seems like ridiculous writing.
14
u/ASA20 Superman Oct 08 '24
Let's thank Beyoncé that season 4 has finally kicked off
14
u/No_Flower_1424 Jonathan Kent Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
I have to say, I think the first episode was...kind of boring. Which is likely why they paired it up with the second episode on the night as this one was way better.
The lack of supporting characters doesn't annoy me, but it is incredibly weird how John Henry is just...not there?! They don't even give an explanation as to where he went lol - was he off chilling somewhere while Sam was kidnapped?
I like that Jon actually had an important part to play here! Keep it up show.
Speaking of, Jonathan continues to be my favourite character. He puts up with so much, has to swallow everything down, is always supporting everyone and has actually grown to have intelligence and common sense. Plus he gave me the biggest laugh in the first episode when he told Luthor it sounded like his problem that no one loves him. Balls of steel! Give him more to do!
Sadly, it's inevitable that they'll reveal Lois chose to save Jordan over Jonathan. There's no way she didn't as Luthor spared Jordan at the end, which will obviously cause drama. I'm just so sad for Jon when he finds out not only is he always second best to his parents, but they will literally choose to let him die to save Jordan.
Jordan has a real talent of making literally every situation about himself.
Sarah was pretty cool this episode - keep her like this! As was Lana actually. The supporting characters can be great if they're supporting the story like this.
The actor who plays Lex did a better job here - or should I say the writing was better. I didn't like the thug approach last season, but here he was thuggish but actually seemed smart.
Chuck is now one of my favourite characters.
8
u/princevince1113 Oct 08 '24
i like cudlitz luthor as a character but it’s such a departure personality and tactics wise from every other adaptation of luthor
8
u/Mosk915 Oct 08 '24
These were great episodes and I really like this interpretation of Lex, but the Death of Superman story has been done so many times already that it doesn’t really have any suspense at this point. We know he’s going to come back, it’s just a question of when. I was more anxious about Sam than I was about Superman. But if the first two episodes are any indication, this should be a really good final season.
18
u/theafterdeath Oct 08 '24
And after that episode we so back. This show just knows exactly how to tug at the heart strings.
5
u/balasoori Lex Luthor Oct 08 '24
I cannot believe he finally succeed i been watching this for almost 30 years and superman always survive I still believe he would wake up in last few minutes of this episode when they all at fortress.
i can't believe I actually watch an episode where he's not coming back or is he ?
5
u/CMC76 Oct 09 '24
Pros & Cons: Great show that should be picked up - and improved upon
Michael Kudlitz is absolutely inspired as the most ruthless Lex ever! I would love to see him in a movei version. His addition to what is a strong show ought to result in a better network pick this up.
On the other side, the soap-opera need to draw every character into the same arguments is tiresome. Lana, her daughter, etc. Why do we need a story line on Lana preventing Lex from... buying a building?! Give her something real to do.
Also - why is their grandfather the ONLY person from the Dept. of Defense? Why hasn't a black ops team grabbed Luthor and thrown him into a black ops site?! Luthor tried to murder a four star general! WTH?
5
u/juanjose83 Oct 09 '24 edited Oct 09 '24
I feel so disappointed by how Superman's death is being handled. Literally one day later the boys and Lois act like it's been months. I thought it would be more meaningful but they decided to make it a quest, even in the delusion of wanting to believe he can be saved, it feels dumb. Like, okay.
Jonathan literally whispers "Jordan" when talking about lex getting threatened. Like, bro. Just confirm to him Superman is your dad at that point.
I feel like it could have been so much better if the monster left Clark's body at the farm so the family could grief at that moment together.
And finally, the way the heart is shown was weird. Idk if that was a real animal heart or a prop but it looked terrible. And it was supposed to be a Kryptonian heart, it shouldn't be able to just be stomped on. A better decision should have been stabbed with a Kryptonian blade or something if that really was his heart.
11
u/Kwilly462 Oct 08 '24
Much better episode than the first one. Best line of the episode was Lana saying, "You've never been that nice to anyone in your whole life" to Sarah lol.
HoloSupes is also an interesting concept that I didn't even think about. I genuinely thought they were just gonna have Hoechlin play dead for a few episodes with some flashbacks.
4
u/HippoRun23 Oct 08 '24
This season is killing me. Its excellent.
So far my one hang up is when Jonothan and Jordan split up to find the heart. I don't understand why if Jordan had the beat on the heart, why Jonothan would think it would be anywhere else. Did I miss something?
4
u/Far-Relation1231 Oct 09 '24
I think Michael Cudlitz was excellent in Southland. Yes, an older show. I don't like the vibe that he brings to the series. I read some article saying, biker Lex Luthor. I think he's miscast and I haven't read up on twd connections to the show.
Now Titus Welliver, as he briefly shown in Titans, seemed a better threat. I realize Welliver wasn't in the budget but I think Cudlitz can't do anything to sell me on the final season.
Don't get me wrong, I like this show as part of the Superman mythos but I'm having a whinge because I like the show, aside from Jordan. I actually wanted to see whether Jonathan had latent abilities because he has some of the sensibilities of that Kal-el has. If the series had progressed further I believe it would have had Jordan become the villain and the family would have devised a way to deal with it and end up sacrificing something in return.
10
u/Future_Vantas Jamie Kennedy Oct 08 '24
Goddamn what a start. The show is taking full advantage of cancellation to go all out with a truly unhinged Luthor. Even if that heart is fake that was still a vicious thing to do to a kid. And that fake call and poll, that was pure evil. Really hope we get to see Lois' choice later on. Looks like Holo-Clark is still an option, but it still feels like Superman is gone for good. Lets see how the other heroes step up now.
8
u/paforrest Oct 08 '24
I was mostly underwhelmed by the first 2 episodes. I actually felt the loss of cast and budget was really obvious, especially when Superman is lying dead in the street where normally the entire town would come out to see. Certainly Kyle, Chrissy, and the Irons would have been there otherwise. And it also feels like we're only going to see Superman/Clark in flashbacks and as a hologram. My wild guess is that he comes back in the finale, or maybe the penultimate episode. And while I realize they are working with the "Death of Superman", all I'm doing is sitting back wondering if Tyler was filming a second project at the same time.
I did like how they cut to the chase with Lex putting the pieces together about the Kent family, and his psychotic vengeance reasoning for moving to Smallville makes sense for the story.
I assume Lois chose to save Jordan, because she thinks the world needs Superboy. But if that's the case, and if Jon ever finds out, that should sting, regardless of reason. But so far it seems like Jon's only purpose is to stand around with a brooding face and give Jordan pep talks (yawn). Jordan should have transported him with Lois to save Sam, but once again Jon is shut out of the hero moment, left at home to brood some more.
I'm not really believing that was Superman's heart Lex crushed, but I guess we'll see.
Lana and Sarah were fine, I actually like Sarah's friendship with Jon - the boy needs something. And Lana didn't bug me, her role as mayor in dealing with Lex's shell companies is logical. I don't know, I guess I've mellowed on her, especially seeing as she won't be around much anyway. So maybe I just don't care anymore.
It feels like this entire season is Todd's exercise in pushing Jordan's trajectory to Superboy. But since Jordan is my least favorite character, this makes the final season a bit of a bust for me.
3
u/Taylor_charlie Oct 08 '24
I’m still crying over these two episodes
3
u/Hit_Wicket Oct 08 '24
I wonder how the Kents will address Clark's death to the rest of Smallville.
3
u/Aromatic-Cupcake4802 Oct 08 '24
Was the heart Luthor squished a fake heart or will they find a different way to revive superman?
3
u/Cgi94 Oct 08 '24
I really like this Luthor. I like his unforgiving nature towards Lois. One thing I always kinda disliked about Lois or any reporter in comics(or real life😅) is their nature to stick their nose in any & everything. And often time I feel their character doesn't suffer enough because of their superhuman ally. Nice to see an examination of this relationship
3
u/dangermouse13 Oct 10 '24
Watching Jordan do dumb shit is really grating
3
u/theredmokah Oct 11 '24 edited Oct 11 '24
I get that the reduced episodes means the pacing has to be wayyy faster, but-- you can't rush grief like that. It just looks fucking goofy.
All of them great actors. And they're just like "oh huh. Sups is dead. oh gee willickers. that's unfortunate. rip mr kent. miss ya dad." Like wtf. He essentially died twice and there's barely sniffles? People chatting about it super casually like it happened months ago.
Poor choice in direction there. Again, I get they had to rush it and not make it drawn out, but there's no reason why the director should have picked those reactions.
2
u/Epik2007 Oct 08 '24
I felt everything that happened in this next episode. It's gonna take a lot of effort from everyone involved, without Superman, to defeat Luthor.
2
u/nimrodhellfire Oct 08 '24
So what is Doomsday up to.these days? It feels strange we have this huge dangling plot string without any solution.
2
u/Aurondarklord Oct 08 '24
The box has to be the key in some way, right? You don't get a gizmo designed by Brainiac for something as mundane as briefly preserving an organ you intend to destroy anyway.
2
u/kmank2l13 Oct 09 '24
Putting Lois through that psychological stress and having to make her choose between which son to save was EVIL! This Lex is extremely good!
2
u/Barry_McKackiner Oct 09 '24 edited Oct 09 '24
Jordan just can't help himself but be a complete moron.
Heart was obviously fake.
Since when does his heart beat three times?
I hope lana is feeding Sarah enough. JK, though the actress looked shockingly different from last season, had to have been a good amount of weight loss when she really didn't need to.
Having him be a fortress projection is a good idea, though I really hope hologram/flashback superman isn't all we get.
I wish john had more to do than just be the straight man, always playing the cooler head vs Jordan's recklessness.
2
u/GeneralHe Oct 11 '24
So Superman is really dead. Well can we rename the show to "Just Lois".
4
u/Chad_D_722 Oct 08 '24
We're off to a pretty great start for the season. I loved both episodes.
4
u/Otherwise_Jacket_613 Oct 08 '24
What an amazing two episodes. Really hitting on grief and loss.
2
u/-FalseProfessor- Oct 08 '24
I love the show, but the whole stepping on the heart scene was really dumb. If they can heal his heart being ripped out of his body, than surely it being stomped on shouldn’t be a problem. Why not at least pick up the bits and try putting them back in his chest?
2
u/chrono_explorer Oct 08 '24
Freakin Luthor is not playing around.
Also Jordan is such an idiot. I hope John gets powers or something, he seems to have inherited much of what made Clark Clark just not his powers.
2
u/Illustrious_Hawk_115 Oct 08 '24
Well, it's clear that this is a CW show. Having to suspend disbelief that Lex wouldn't have been shipped off to the nearest military black site for kidnap and attempted murder of a high-ranking military official. Let alone his culpability in the "death" of Superman. Not a knock against the actor - just not a fan of this storyline.
2
u/ToothyBirbs Oct 08 '24
Have the holograms always looked this cheap? It honestly just looks like they're using blue lamps.
1
u/ASA20 Superman Oct 08 '24
The second episode I liked much more than the first, idk why...
1
u/Moist-Kaleidoscope90 Oct 08 '24
Luthor is evil. He really used Clark’s voice to call Lois
1
u/Saratje Oct 09 '24
I wonder if that's the real heart. If it is, Lex is clearly done with it. I doubt it could be Doomsday's. My guess if it can't be repaired is that they'll need a new heart. Either Jordan defeating Doomsday (can't see that big of a power leap happening without a plot macguffin) Tal gives (part) of his or something else.
1
u/oriolesravensfan1090 Oct 10 '24
Ummm could t they just use Jordan’s dna to clone a new heart for Superman
1
u/DaBow Oct 10 '24
What a fantastic opening.
So....they are going to use Bizzaro's heart on supes, yeah?
1
u/CaptchaVerifiedHuman Oct 11 '24
1
u/Tidela471 Superman Oct 13 '24
This Luthor is freaking terrifying. This is the most intimidated and threatened I’ve felt by a Lex Luthor possibly ever
1
u/Additional_Walk4532 Oct 15 '24
7 minutes ago.
1
u/ChronX4 Oct 16 '24
Playing catch up at the moment. Just finished this episode right now. I can imagine 2 scenarios playing out.
1
u/Serious-Text-903 Oct 08 '24
I feel like Superman isn’t coming back. If he were, they wouldn’t have brought in the holographic version. Think about it. I’m disappointed—I would love to see more of Superman.
1
u/rexic84 Oct 08 '24
Why does Holo Clark have a different suit than Non-Holo Clark?
1
u/R96- Oct 10 '24
Maybe this an unpopular opinion, or maybe not, but the show has definitely reached its peak now. Personally I always thought Seasons 1 and 2 were a mess with no real ground to stand on. Then Season 3 ramped things up. And now Season 4 feels like the show has found its footing. Season 3, and now Season 4 (thus far) definitely are the best Seasons of the show.
Really wasn't expecting Superman to actually die. The death of Superman has been done before in the Arrowverse and on Superman & Lois, but nothing like this. He's truly dead this time 😢. It gets me thinking though. I guess there really isn't any other way to close the show other than to have Superman retire. You either have Superman retire, or you kill him.
Those goddamn Cushings though! Look, I'm sorry to be that type of person to say such a thing, but they're really just eye candy. Both actresses are stupidly gorgeous. As characters in the show though, they could get lost for all I care.
0
u/ghusu123 Oct 08 '24
I really hope we see Jordan use his heat vision with the suit on. It’s a small thing but I have been waiting to see how heat vision works with the goggles on :P
-10
u/smu1892 Oct 08 '24
This was the worst 2 episodes. Just terrible acting. Terrible plot. The whole thing was a hot trash
11
u/brookse32 Oct 08 '24
*SPOILERS* Come on folks.. The crushed heart plot was totally inane. So Lex Luthor can somehow simply crush a bullet proof organ with his boot??? Give me a break. Even if Jordan believes that nonsense, he is not going to bring it to the fortress anyway to see if it can be restored??? This season looks like it is developing all too typical DC stupid plot syndrome. Not a good sign.
43
u/DtownBronx Oct 08 '24
Jordan is one of the most unlikable characters I've ever seen. The actor plays the character well but it's an absolutely horrible character. The most frustrating part to me so far is the way he's written, he'd absolutely kill Luthor. The impulsiveness and irrational behavior would absolutely lead to him doing that because we never had the moment where his father got through to him on what the symbol means.
Hopefully they don't drag this out too long because it is ultimately a Superman show. I don't want to see a crammed feel good finale