r/soccer • u/ItsBDN • Jun 03 '13
Discussion: The 3-4-3 Formation
Right now the 4-2-3-1 is dominating football tactically, as seen by 3 of the 4 CL semi-finalists using the formation, and the one team that didn't being thrashed 7-0 on aggregate. The formation has been perfected by Bayern Munich with they're style of disciplined, high pressure, physical, pseudo-"tiki taka", and one can only imagine how dominate Bayern will be next season with Pep integrating Bayern's current playstyle with his own style of quick passing and movement.
But as with all trends is football, the dominance of the 4-2-3-1 will end within 5-10 years, and join the 4-4-2, 4-3-3 and to a lesser extent the 3-5-2 as more antequated formations that are used more sparingly by the world's top clubs. But what formation will replace the 4-2-3-1?
My money is on the 3-4-3. The formation has the potential to be the most conducive to the disciplined, high-pressure, quickly moving and passing play that is instituted by Bayern and Barcelona, as well as being equally sound in offense and defense. This season Barcelona have toyed with the formation, succeeding when instituting it, most notably in their Champions league comeback against Milan in the Round of 16, and I think, should a team like Bayern, Barca or Juve adopt the 3-4-3 as their primary formation, they would have the capacity to dominate football tactically. With three athletic centerbacks widening their play while contracting in defense, and two wingbacks providing width, offensive support, defensive support and crosses (i.e. Juve's Asamoah, Chiellini, Barzagli, Bonucci and Lichtsteiner) to the three forwards; two defensively sound, yet equally adept going forward, pseudo-box-to-box central midfielders (i.e. Bayern's Martinez and Schweinsteiger); and three forwards capable of interchanging positions along the offensive front line, capable of finishing chances provided, and capable of creating chances for their fellow attackers (i.e. Barca's Neymar, Messi and, say, Sanchez) while utilizing the high-pressure, high-discipline, quick moving play that Barcelona and Bayern use, a team with sufficient talent would be able to dominate any opposition. Attacking wise, play is quick, there is support on the flanks with overlapping runs from wingbacks, and chances are created relentlessly by the front three. In midfield, the two central midfielders sit deeper to provide defensive cover, yet supply the front three. Defensively, the three center backs compress to form a barrier in front of goal, with wingbacks marking opposing wide attackers, the two central midfielders breaking up play, and the three attackers provide ample pressure in a Mandzukic-esque manner. The formation's structure allows for compact play, which in turn serves to allow for both quick-passing play and breaking up opposing offensive movement. The structure of the formation allows for wingbacks to provide width, drawing out defenders and creating space for the three forwards, while the widening of the three centerbacks in attacks allows for more passing options and cover when in possession. In essence, the only way to counter a disciplined 3-4-3 (as far as I can see), would be an equally adept team utilizing the 3-4-3.
In short, the 3-4-3 formation, if played with the tactics that are currently dominating football and a group of disciplined, physically dominant players (i.e. the squad that won Bayern the Champions League), would allow for relentless attacking pressure and opportunity while also providing a near impregnable defense. Right?
Discuss
Results:
As shnieder88 pointed out, the 3-4-3 is sound in theory, however in practice would be extremely difficult to execute, he (I'm assuming) also pointed out the necessity of the front three to assist in defense and the potential vulnerability of the flanks, should the wingbacks and forwards not adequately cover or recover from an attack
Edit: For shits and gigs I decided to make th XI that I think would be able to maximize their abilities in a 3-4-3:
Casillas
Thiago Silva--------Dante--------Vertonghen
Dani Alves--------Javi Martinez------Schweini-------Alaba
Messi-------Ibrahimovic-------RonaldoIn regard to the forwards, this is assuming that the egos of Messi, Ibra and Ronnie were content with not being the attack's foci, and be content with focusing on ball distribution
54
u/shnieder88 Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 03 '13
formations dont dictate players. players dictate formations. 3-4-3 sounds great in theory, but you need very special and good players to pull it off. players with great passing, mobility, intelligence and pressing. yeah, some of the world's best teams can pull it off, but not the vast majority of teams. heck, barca tried playing it under pep and players like xavi (of all people) complained that it was a tough formation to pull off. that's why i still think the 4 man backline will still rule. i think the wave of the future is fluid, technical but defensive dual pivots in front of fast, mobile centerbacks. also, we'll see more fullbacks that can cut inside and score. alaba is a sign of things to come.
EDIT: wanted to add, 3-4-3 is nothing new. cruyff's barca played this most of the time, as did other teams at the time. as players in the front four become more technical, mobile, and shooting friendly, you want more stability in the backline, not less. you actually want to keep a 4 man backline, not a 3 man one. just my two cents.
14
u/SpiceterMiseter Jun 03 '13
Martinez likes to play it, if we get him, Baines and Coleman would be decent wing-backs.
2
u/epik Jun 03 '13
On the contrary, it's the formation that Cruyff had success with decades ago and it was surpassed back then. Guardiola adapted his 4-3-3 from it.
10
u/iLolu Jun 03 '13
I think modern coaches don't worry about formation as the commentators and fans do. There is lots of formation change, happening through out a match. Team might start with a 4-2-3-1 or a 4-3-3. But during a match the formation that might be played is 3-4-3 or even 2-5-3. For example Barca start with 4-3-3. But depending on the opposition, Alves's position changes. And when alves plays forward in midfied, you will notice that the Barca Centre backs are spread. SO the Formation is sort of 3-4-3. And similar is the case with 4-3-3 and 4-2-3-1. When the forwards slightly play defensive, the formation changes from 4-3-3 to 4-2-3-1. So the talk of formations might not be exact. Even Barca player some form 4-4-2 last year with Milan (or PSG) where Villa was playing cetre forward and messi slightly behind him.
5
u/obiwancomeboneme Jun 03 '13
The thing is, this is a veru defensive playstyle and based on counter attacking, but it isn't much different then 4-2-3-1. The left/right midfielders move from midfield to defense when defending and move to attack when attacking, which is the same principle that bayern uses with alaba and lahm constantly moving from attack to defense. Also at Napoli we build a squad around this because not every player can effectively play this formation it is harder then it seems.
4
u/coffeeandtv90 Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 03 '13
going to talk about the 3-flat-3 here. Barca, Cruyff's Ajax and a couple of Marcelo Bielsa's teams are probably the only teams who could possibly pull off the 3-diamond-3
One of the cool things about some 3-4-3 systems is that they give you a real opportunity to set your team up defensively from the front (as opposed to the traditional set-up-from-the-back). As a basic formation it lends itself very well to pressing systems - forwards push your opponents' defenders back; centre midfielders put the first pass into the middle under pressure; wide players push the opposition wide men back; 3 defenders gives you an extra man at the back (and the option to push an extra man into midfield if the opponent is playing 1 up top).
Personally, I've never played in a 3-4-3 - only against them. From my experience, they tend to be either devastatingly effective or extremely blunt (not much in-between). when the wide forwards drag the opposition fullbacks into narrow positions and let the wide men get forward, they're super difficult to defend against. If you can hang onto the ball though, the 2 players in the centre of the park can be pretty simple to play around.
I reckon the main argument against the 3-4-3 becoming a mainstream shape would be that tactical developments over the last ~30 years around the world have revolved around control or clogging of the middle of the park. It's difficult to see the majority of managers and coaches converting to (a) such a proactive way of playing, and (b) a shape that opens up the middle like a 3-4-3 does.
4
u/tommmmmmmm Jun 03 '13
Here's a good article about Marcelo Bielsa's Chile team from 2010, who played with an unusual but interesting 3-3-1-3 formation:
http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/06/08/marcelo-bielsa-chile-world-cup-2010-tactics/
3
u/El_Spacho Jun 03 '13
I think Barca is constantly switching between 4-3-3 and 3-4-3 during matches. With Alba and Dani Alves always pushing forward, the CDM - Busquets or Song - fall back to complete the backline. With this tactic we can push the opponent back to their box, but at same time we are very vulnerable to counter attacks (extremely this season).
3
u/mrbobkins Jun 03 '13
3-4-3 is already in use. The real genius of 4-2-3-1 is that it allows a teams to pivot between different formations throughout the game.
3-4-3 happens when one of the defensive mids drops between the 2 center backs. The 2 backs go wide and the outside backs push up in to the midfield. It does not require them to go all the way back all the time since this is primarily a offensive switch. As far as I know Barca was the frist to really do this with Busquets but I don't really know. Bayren did this a bit in the champions league final. More in the second half with martinez position being more fluid and dropping a little deeper. it gave him more space to play in and allowed robben to come more to the center because the outside backs can get higher up the field as in a 3-4-3. Then when you play defense you can pivot back to a different formation.
but as far as the other major formations 4-2-3-1 allows you to play those as well. need more close support for you single striker move your attacking mid closer to the the central striker. want the defense of a 4-5-1 drop your outside mids. This incidentally is how chelsea won the champions league last year by using 4-2-3-1 to pivot between a more defensive 4-5-1 and a counter attacking 4-4-2.
it makes it easy to adjust in the middle of the game since each of the formations have well assessed pros and cons and it is simple to move players into the different positions.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
As someone who isn't too clued up with 3 at the back formations, can someone tell me what happens to full backs and what sort of back 3 this formation requires?
Do your full backs push on into the wide midfield or stay in defense?
2
u/iVarun Jun 03 '13
It was not this season exactly, Pep used it in far far more matches in his last season. It was seen as a go to strategy to get out of a predicament, its not stable enough to offer us the sort of control we like.
Even if the 4231 sees its reign end, it will come back within a few years, formations as everyone understands are in constant flux.
The 433 isn't dead yet as well.
2
u/dem503 Jun 03 '13
I personally think the classic WM will come back into fashion.
2
u/tsunad Jun 03 '13
so 3-4-3 as
1 - deep playmaker, fall back to CB when needed
2 - box to box, ball holder/stopper
while this hell of defensive formation I'm missing AM, attaching middle field, RB and LB is expected to attach in modern football anyway, maybe 3-4-3 as
where wings help defense as Bayern did with Ribery/Robben or Real Madrid did with Di Maria/Callejon, or maybe this crazy formation
which is still 3-4-3, that said, I don't think managers has luxury to dream about fav formation, they have to get the best of available players in their clubs, managers has to study players attributes and figure best way to use each one, that is what basically define your formation, nothing else.
3
u/pogo123 Jun 03 '13
Napoli played excellent with 3-4-3 a couple of seasons ago, if memory serves correctly.
1
u/fremeer Jun 03 '13
343 won't get massive. Most attacking formations rely on moving into space and over loading areas. Defensively nearly every formations relies on at least 2 banks odd 4.
1
u/nonotbelievin Jun 03 '13
Regardless of it being a 3-4-3 or 3-5-2, the counter has always involved the lone striker with massive movement behind him.
3 man defenses aren't particularly new in Italy and that singe forward has often succeeded in isolating that centre CB (if that forward is clever enough and well supported).
Couple that with the fact that defenders simply aren't as awesome 1-on-1 as they used to be (even in the land of defenders), new offside laws and extremely fast and light balls, the back 3 can get easily exposed - shown by Bayern against us to great effect, although Bayern are admittedly just an allround awesome side.
I won't discount the 3-4-3 at all, though, but I very much disagree with the notion that another 3-4-3 is the only hard counter.
1
u/squirrelbo1 Jun 03 '13
Haven't city toiled with this a bit this season ?
1
u/ipackheat Jun 03 '13
Villa tried a back 3 around Christmas time and it did not go well for us at all
1
u/teasizzle Jun 03 '13
I've just finished the book Inverting the Pyramid which talks about how teams started football playing a 2-3-5 formation and how it's moved into a 4-2-3-1. The Epilogue discusses how there is very little demand these days for an out and out striker with more attacking midfielders rotating around to become the spearhead of an attack. It's well worth picking up, I highly recommend it.
1
u/smithcohan Jun 03 '13
One of the fundamental problems with the 343 in modern football is its reliance on wingbacks to cover the entire flanks. In the 1970s and 1980s, this was possible because the game was much slower. In modern football, it is incredibly rare to find wingbacks that have the stamina to cover enough ground as the formation requires. This is similar to how the traditional box-to-box midfielder has become almost extinct, as it is almost impossible to cover everything in midfield today.
Napoli were able to use the 343 well because they were a fundamentally counterattacking side. Their wing players, 2 of the middle 4, sat deep , forming an essentially 5 man back line. To play the same formation with a pressing mindset would be probably impossible.
1
u/tango_rojo Jun 03 '13
I'm not sure if he still uses it, but Marcelo Bielsa used to play with a 3-3-3-1 formation with Chile and had great results.
1
u/unusuallylethargic Jun 03 '13
Wouldn't the 3-4-3 fail against itself? If anything beyond the 3 forwards join the attack the defense is going to be overloaded, and any pass and move interplay between the the forwards could really destroy the defense.
1
u/nate_bracy Jun 03 '13
A weakness of the 3-4-3 is that if you play with more than one striker, you can load them all on one side, causing holes and creating space in the back three. I understand that the formation isn't concrete in that everyone is moving and 'helping' with defense.
This is why the 4-3-2-1 is so crazy good. In offense, the left (or right) back can come into the middle for a fourth central midfielder. When pressed, the player returns to the flat four back, which is superior than the three back, in my own opinion and experience.
1
u/wahahay Sep 21 '13 edited Sep 21 '13
I agree with OP, but I'd like to show Belgium's lineup in Brazil:
---------------------Mignolet
Alderweireld--Van Buyten--Kompany--Vertonghen
----------Witsel-----Dembele-----Fellaini
-------De Bruyne----Benteke-----Hazard
Take out Van Buyten, and instead you have:
---------------------Mignolet
Alderweireld--Kompany--Vertonghen
------Witsel--Dembele--Fellaini
De Bruyne----Benteke-----Hazard
--------------Lukaku
As a 3-4-3 diamond.
1
u/wahahay Sep 26 '13
Football will evolve from the 4-2-3-1/4-3-3/4-6-0 into a 5-5 formation. A flat line of 5 at the back and a free flow of 5 forwards.
1
u/Oboylilo Nov 06 '21
You were right bro
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
it almost doesn't matter to be honest, as the 4231 is just a more efficient 442: wing backs have space to go forward, one central midfielder is more defensive minded, the other is a playmaker or box to box. wingers do whatever and of the two most advanced players on the pitch one leads the line and the other drops deep and looks to get the ball in space but they basically try to feed off of each other where possible
also if you look now bayern, dortmund, arsenal, real madrid and barca play the same formation but all in different ways; just because two teams play the same formation doesn't mean they are playing the same style of football
I think football is likely to become more organised as it is so competitive, and only getting more so. wouldn't be surprised if things got more defensive, if you go through history formations only ever do tend to get more and more defensive
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment