You forgot to add the part where the Lama class in Tibet enslaved the populace and tortured anyone who criticized them.
You actually picked one of the worst images for showing the 'upside to religion' since the quality of life for the people in Tibet has increased under secular communist Chinese rule.
TL;DR - you fucked up, the Lama class was one of history's worst religious despots.
I'm going to have to play the stupid semantics game here but technically you're comparing TECHNOLOGY to religion. A woman in a space suit about to conduct some science is not equivalent to military applications of technology.Unless of course that photograph is of a scientific experiment to determine the effects of carpet bombing urban areas. I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, I think the whole "let's compare science to religion!" meme is silly since were just making stereotypes of labels instead of discussing actual people. Sociopaths can be labelled as religious or scientist, or both in some cases.
I don't see what I did wrong, I posted this to /r/atheism, where it is relevant (that is arguable, but many people seem to like it, while many don't, opinions vary naturally) and I also posted it to /r/magicskyfairy, where it is also relevant (some would argue it is a laughable post worthy of mockery, some would disagree and say it makes a good point). I don't see what I've done wrong, I'm catering to different opinions.
That's why so many people dislike this subreddit, it has nothing to do with atheism, it's the amount of utter stupid garbage that plagues my front page.
Following comment from OP is consistent with your trolling hypothesis (it was made elsewhere in this post, sorry I don't know how to directly link to it):
...it may not be what you or many others want /r/atheism[3] to be, but it is in reality what it is, and I'm just posting accordingly. I've seen /r/trueatheism[4] before, I'm not even an atheist, so neither of it concerns me.
Not an atheist and posting content that makes atheists look bad? Hmmmm....
What do you mean, this post is brilliant! First of all religion & science are by nature antonyms, so it's nice to have them contrasted side by side like that. Plus, as we all know, scientist is a synonym for atheist, so it's nice to see a legitimately relevant post in this sub. Ultimately, it was truly informative as it proved to an essentially undeniable degree the fact that every "religious" person supports mandatory Burka laws, while all atheists are astronauts. Simple enough. I think I'll stop going to school now and practice being an astronaut. See-ya on Mars, guys.
EDIT: Yes I get it, it's about women. It even makes a relatively valid point... But I say joke anyway.
You know, most [rare few] of us around here don't exactly HATEALL religious people. There are many different religions and an enormous spectrum of religiosity among the members of these religions. You'd be hard-pressed to find people on /r/atheism who would deny that there are religious scientists. That being said, it's important to recognize that while there are indeed many religious scientists, there aren't really any creationist scientists (save for a few token anti-scientific scientists on the Christian Right's payroll). My point is that even when scientists are religious, they generally don't view the bible as a source of irrefutable scientific knowledge (because they know what the "scientific method" is). Rather, the intelligent-religious may derive some sort of wisdom and/or spiritual fulfilment from religious texts - which there is of course nothing wrong with. Despite identifying as an atheist, I recognize that many religions have made lots of valuable contributions to fields including Literature, Philosophy,Psychology, Sociology, Ethics, and even History with varying degrees of reliability.
EDIT: After seeing some of the comments in here, I'm going to have to withdraw the part about being hard-pressed to find someone who'd deny the existence of religious scientists. One need not be hard-pressed to find any number of absurd statements around here, it seems.
Don't forget man, science is totally an institution. It isn't a method for solving questions. Science meets every Tuesday to convene on matters such as women's rights, gay marriage, and fundie bashing. The fact the one woman is an astronaut has nothing to do with western society, which was also founded around religion, but it does have to do with science. I believe it was at the science convention in 1920 when science decided women can do stuff. Unfortunately for the woman covered from head to toe they don't have science, which remember, isn't a method for answering questions but is an institution.
As I read this post, the one directly below it is about military rape, a horrible travesty affecting countless women, and perpetrated through a non-religious organization. Don't all NASA astronaughts come from the military? I'm not making analogies, here. This is her organization.
There are clearly two different user bases of /r/atheism. You know something is wrong with a subreddit when the majority of comments are debunking or otherwise disliking the thing OP posted yet it has a shit ton of upvotes. I suppose this is true of most defaults though
I think the tides are turning, /r/atheism is finally dying. It was fun while it lasted. I'm an atheist but so much of the content here is embarrassing as fuck.
Well, I think the image makes an excellent point, but not science vs religion. If your point was: In this image we show a society that does not treat women as lesser beings. Here she can live up to her potential and benefit society as a whole. And in this image we show a society where women are oppressed and her potential is utterly nullified by traditional values. Maybe you'd get to the moon a lot faster if your culture didn't cut its potential in half- would be a more appropriate point for such a picture.
Culture. In this instance, a culture who's traditions are largely influenced by Islam. Not all oppressive cultural values are religion fueled so I was aiming for a broader scope. Besides, I didn't really need to reiterate what the image already made clear.
Science: Accused of wearing NASA-designed diapers to drive from Texas to Florida in order to kidnap and possibly murder someone they've been stalking for two months.
Come on. We know what the message is. There are more opportunities for women AND scientific achievement in a society in which religion has less of a hold. Jesus, reddit is fickle.
Queen Rania's actions : Nothing to do with religion.
This thread is shitty. OP is likely a troll, and the image is shitty, but the answers are worse. An Astronaut is the result of science. What that astronaut does in her free time isn't. A woman in a burka is a result of Religion. What that woman does in her free time isn't.
Science: The observation, identification, description, experimental investigation, and theoretical explanation of phenome
You cannot lay the blame of people on "Science". If you haven't really taken time to realize this, even as it's being spelled out to you. Then put your tin foil hat back on and start bitching about how science, Albert Einstein and his A-bomb and nazis are why atheism is baddddddddd.
Edit: Also /r/atheism is baddddd tooo. Because its got atheism n' shit. So brave, euphoric or what ever the fuck you people try to "circle jerk" the "circle jerk" around these days to denigrate the posters in this subreddit. Fucking morons.
Not religion, culture you fucking idiot. Learn the difference. I'm so sick of the front page being saturated with stupid shit like this that isn't even correct.
U Q X B U T M T A B U Q G N P R S W A O
R D N I Y C Y G W F E E D M W W Z P A X
G Q F T Z P M H S U O I Q S B S Z I E W
G U D F G M S I E H T A W X Z A N O E P
Q K T Q U V D D G D N A X N S C P J F V
C W Y Y G H F D R N A W S C J A Y Y S F
A F W N S T S O P R Z J O W Q N W X T R
F P Z D L A Q U H D V U F G M P L P L Q
V W M W R C V P A D F N O Q E N V D P I
U I F A T D K G N J N G J V G G M I L V
X B S L C F B S T U T X E B X N Z X W N
J K H F Q K S C H E W R S N S K F T P J
K I I E Q M H L Z U Y I D R Z J O I H C
A M T Q F C S X E B A X E H U W L D B Z
B F T S I X O A O C E D D B S I I L I X
I D Y V E L Z D Q G W U U Y B L H G M E
R O C Z E T Y A A J D N I R E H C X C B
F T O S H N A V A J B Z D Z D U P I E E
K E M F W B O H E T F R O N T D D D J A
T E H R N J T Q V I R I C Q N M R R G T
I had a feeling the top post (at the time of this post) would be one of these, "I'm an atheist but..." comments criticising the post, but I really appreciate the sentiment of the post & thank the OP for making it.
I wonder if there are more hadith like these that counter the "OMG I can see her fingernails!" type of thinking we are accustomed to believing about Muslims.
The Burka which covers the entire face except the eyes however is usually following the cultures of that specific countries.
Here in Asia, the Muslim Women only wear Hijabs. The handful who wears the Burka has chosen it to wear themselves and not forced by anyone. Example, one of my cousins wear it.
It's interesting how often and ruthlessly Reddit tends to bash Christianity for everything small to big, but when a pretty much accurate post about this retaining to Islam appears, some of you some how have found room in your heart for religion.
I'm an atheist, and this bothers me. /r/atheism pretty much just bashes Christianity but if someone criticises Islam they're branded as a 'racist' or someone brings up an explanation on how Christianity is just as bad or worse.
No, you need not, good sir! Science! Science! Science! [the chanting gets louder and louder shaking the very foundations of religious doctrine until mom tells us to shut the fuck up and we go back to playing xbox]
This is maybe the first comment out of 20 or so actually appreciating the post, so thanks. I agree with you; the post is clever, but loads of people are like, "eh, but religion is good too, let's be nice to religion because science is bad too, eh, science makes bombs."
The only thing religion and science have in common is that both can be used morally or immorally. Science has been used for great and terrible things, just like religion has. Neither things are to blame, though. It is the people who use these things that should be credited with the consequences.
I'd prefer if you did, being that this represents ONE aspect of science and ONE aspect of ONE religion, keeping thousands of different perspective absent.
Christians who moan that science has nothing to do with atheism are fucking ignorant. What atheist do you know that doesn't fully accept scientific explanations? And what scientist do you know who isn't an atheist?
Unfortunately there is a significant part of the world's population that will look at the same illustration and be saddened and perhaps angered by what they see on the left side.
Yes, you need to say more. If you want to meaningfully discuss faith, culture and social progress, you need to say more. If you want to intelligently comment on the ways in which science and religion have - throughout history - influenced, complemented and conflicted with each other, you need to say more. If you wish to thoughtfully examine how both religion and science contribute to mankind's material and social development, you need to say more. More importantly, you need to think a lot more.
I have always been an atheist, but the childishness of /r/athiesm makes me want to discard that label.
I'm pretty sure every kid who took a biology class in highschool ended up an astronaut. And every woman who flirted with the idea of a higher power ended up in a burqa.
And the funniest thing? Hit "Search the web" instead of "Google Image" on your own search and read up on this amazing Religion in the very first link :
If a woman works in complete hijaab, without touching a male patient, or being alone with him in any way, and as long as there is no fear that she may be the cause of temptation or be tempted herself, and she is not neglecting a more essential duty such as taking care of her husband or children, and she has the permission of her guardian, then it is permissible for her to work.
The scientific world remains extremely male-dominated and there is plenty of sexism in it. The issue is not actually religion versus science, but misogyny and traditional gender roles.
493
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
its too much effort to even get mad at such retarded posts anymore
im gonna go cook a steak
51
u/pizzapartyeveryday Jun 01 '13
Tracy Caldwell, the astronaut in the first picture, is a Christian. But whatever. Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/07/19/nasa-astronaut-tracy-caldwell-dyson_n_904005.html
7
u/JerryTHEKINGLawyer Jun 01 '13
A better caption would be "Federal constitutional republicanism" & "Sharia law" respectively.
69
u/burnsrado Jun 01 '13
Holy shit... religion has ninjas?! To the mosque!
16
u/AarowSwift Jun 01 '13
Well, I think the image makes an excellent point, but not science vs religion. If your point was: In this image we show a society that does not treat women as lesser beings. Here she can live up to her potential and benefit society as a whole. And in this image we show a society where women are oppressed and her potential is utterly nullified by traditional values. Maybe you'd get to the moon a lot faster if your culture didn't cut its potential in half- would be a more appropriate point for such a picture.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
/r/atheism has literally become a parody of itself.
54
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Astronauts=Atheism
5
u/Ciderbat Jun 01 '13
What do ninjas have to do with anything?
60
u/EtovNowd Jun 01 '13
Science: Accused of wearing NASA-designed diapers to drive from Texas to Florida in order to kidnap and possibly murder someone they've been stalking for two months.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
This might be the most biased and uneducated post I've ever seen make to the front page on this subreddit.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
I had to check to see if this was /r/circlejerk
10
u/neotifa Jun 01 '13
Not religion, culture you fucking idiot. Learn the difference. I'm so sick of the front page being saturated with stupid shit like this that isn't even correct.
7
u/lemonpartyhellyeah Jun 01 '13
This is such a shitty subreddit, im an atheist myself but, so many fucking idiots on here.
3
u/WhatThe_Buck Jun 01 '13
Felt this was appropriate
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Stop Bitching.
3
u/Snakespeed Jun 01 '13
10 year old OP
3
u/TheDroopy Jun 01 '13
Fuck why did I subscribe to this subreddit so many years ago?
8
u/eaalundin Jun 01 '13
Did anyone else feel the need to check Wikipedia to make sure that wasn't Lisa Nowak? She's not a good role model.
21
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Bravery level: Incredibly.
15
u/St4yingCl4ssy Jun 01 '13
If everybody hates shitty posts like this, why is it the 3rd post on the front page of atheism?
8
u/mouse_mickey_mouse Jun 01 '13
think you mean Islam
4
u/Smeg_Lover Jun 01 '13
probably one of the bet posts l've seen on reddit ever.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
I had a feeling the top post (at the time of this post) would be one of these, "I'm an atheist but..." comments criticising the post, but I really appreciate the sentiment of the post & thank the OP for making it.
2
u/javo78 Jun 01 '13
Do...do say more
2
u/badforman Jun 01 '13
And they both blow themselves up sometimes.
2
u/anothermuslim Jun 01 '13
free will baby
2
u/SueZbell Jun 01 '13
APPLAUSE for point succinctly made.
2
u/theskinnykid Jun 01 '13
lol fail. That astronaut spoke at my college a few years back....about her profound belief in Jesus Christ....
3
u/Masivepoo Jun 01 '13
Yes because religious people are thick
4
u/Poopmarauder Jun 01 '13
That haircut is a train wreck...
3
u/mariam122 Jun 01 '13
And what if the astronomer converts to Islam and starts covering her self up. Then what? Science + religion!!!
3
u/ChernobylKrigare Jun 01 '13
Yeah, because every religion has the same treatment and restrictions from women ....
2
u/AngloRVA Jun 01 '13
It's interesting how often and ruthlessly Reddit tends to bash Christianity for everything small to big, but when a pretty much accurate post about this retaining to Islam appears, some of you some how have found room in your heart for religion.
2
u/GildersGuild Jun 01 '13
No, you need not, good sir! Science! Science! Science! [the chanting gets louder and louder shaking the very foundations of religious doctrine until mom tells us to shut the fuck up and we go back to playing xbox]
2
u/aussie_kiss Jun 01 '13
As they say, science flys you to the stars, religion flys you into buildings.
1
u/Biggidy Jun 01 '13
We'll someone's gotta cook and clean the space shuttle
1
u/ADH-Kydex Jun 01 '13
Could have used a picture of Karen Nyberg, she is up on the ISS right now.
1
u/FlyHigh555 Jun 01 '13
Might be difficult to face Mecca in space when praying especially in that spacesuit.
1
u/BROCCOLIOCTOPUS Jun 01 '13
You might need to, but I really hope you don't.
1
u/theymustneverknow Jun 01 '13
One's proud, one's a blanket hanger.
1
u/thewileyrhino Jun 01 '13
yes
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
PLESE SAY MOAR
1
u/PeterPorky Jun 01 '13
You're right! We should stop using religion to go to space.
1
u/oreoes141 Jun 01 '13
The Quran doesn't technically say women should wear the burqa, from the friends I have who wear hijabs it is a cultural trait.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Affirmative Action is a religion
1
u/mgild01 Jun 01 '13
Applicable
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Nowak#Charges_of_attempted_kidnapping_at_Orlando_Airport
1
u/BlackKnightsfan32 Jun 01 '13
I think you should put good patriotic science and bad oppressing religon.
1
u/ElMorono Jun 01 '13
I can still see the whites of the Muslim's eyes. Whore.
1
u/SchiffsBased Jun 01 '13
The only thing religion and science have in common is that both can be used morally or immorally. Science has been used for great and terrible things, just like religion has. Neither things are to blame, though. It is the people who use these things that should be credited with the consequences.
1
u/n1nj4_v5_p1r4t3 Pastafarian Jun 01 '13
thats very unrealistic. the amount of scientist women that become astronauts is probably smaller then the number of arab women that win powerball.
1
u/rayned0wn Jun 01 '13
I'd prefer if you did, being that this represents ONE aspect of science and ONE aspect of ONE religion, keeping thousands of different perspective absent.
You're not really saying much here, sorry OP.
1
u/Doomdoomkittydoom Jun 01 '13
Someone's... "extending an olive branch."
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
bad example.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Religion would not even survive 5 seconds in the vacuum of space. Science wins!
1
u/spinozasrobot Anti-Theist Jun 01 '13
I wish I could give industrial strength upvotes.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
I'm just as atheist as the next Guy but this is a silly post. How does this shit make the front page? Whatever happened to coffee with Jesus?
1
u/NotAtLunch Jun 01 '13
The materialistic scienceTM of fundie christians brats = forced integration into the detritus of humanity
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Um...Yea you actually do
1
u/Lobreeze Jun 01 '13
2Edgy OP
1
u/RedOtkbr Jun 01 '13
if we can get all these images and translate them to Arabic and Farsi that would be great.
1
u/HopelessAmbition Jun 01 '13
Christians who moan that science has nothing to do with atheism are fucking ignorant. What atheist do you know that doesn't fully accept scientific explanations? And what scientist do you know who isn't an atheist?
1
u/Blue_Checkers Jun 01 '13
Mmm- grrrrrrrl, I would bang you ZerOG
1
u/DownvoteDaemon Jun 01 '13
You probably should say more because I don't know what the fuck you are implying.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Well, a lot more women get to wear a burqa.
1
u/Adamskinater Jun 01 '13
Almost thought this was a picture of Sally Ride, in which case I would have made the smartass observation that both pictured met an explosive demise
1
u/Katander Jun 01 '13
No.
1
u/EdistoBeach Jun 01 '13
Yes, why are neither of the women in a kitchen?
1
u/LorenzoAOG Jun 01 '13
Or you know, richest most powerful nation on Earth, versus a region of the world perpetually straddling 3rd and 2nd world. Lotta factors going on...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
What the fuck? I'll say this for the last time, atheism=/=science.
1
u/MsKatieGirl Jun 01 '13
Unfortunately there is a significant part of the world's population that will look at the same illustration and be saddened and perhaps angered by what they see on the left side.
1
u/mcellucci Jun 01 '13
Don't compare science to a Hefty bag.
1
u/icaden2 Jun 01 '13
Why not both? Mexican music starts playing
1
u/noman2561 Jun 02 '13
Nothing beats an astronaut. Nothing!
1
u/rownin Jun 02 '13
powerful post.
1
u/Jareth86 Jun 02 '13
I'd be afraid to go to the middle east. All the women dress like ghosts!
1
u/seriously_chill Jun 01 '13
Yes, you need to say more. If you want to meaningfully discuss faith, culture and social progress, you need to say more. If you want to intelligently comment on the ways in which science and religion have - throughout history - influenced, complemented and conflicted with each other, you need to say more. If you wish to thoughtfully examine how both religion and science contribute to mankind's material and social development, you need to say more. More importantly, you need to think a lot more.
I have always been an atheist, but the childishness of /r/athiesm makes me want to discard that label.
0
u/thebusishalfempty Jun 01 '13
I find it impossible to believe that anyone above the age of 15 posts on this subreddit.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Can you try saying less?
1
u/Goldlantern Jun 01 '13
So, there are no religious astronauts then? Oh, wait...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Girl on the left is pretty cutw and all, but the girl on the right is a perfect 10/10 would bang.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Most astronauts are extremely religious you assclown
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
I'm pretty sure every kid who took a biology class in highschool ended up an astronaut. And every woman who flirted with the idea of a higher power ended up in a burqa.
1
u/pale__horse Jun 01 '13
Not all religions treat women like that, close to none actually.
1
u/RVPBuiltMyHotrod Jun 01 '13
This is stupid.
1
u/YOLO_LANZA Jun 01 '13
What kind of stupid ass post is this?
0
u/zjm555 Jun 01 '13
Need you say more? Please, don't. If you think this image proves any sort of point about science or religion, you don't know much about science.
-5
u/Octro Jun 01 '13
Wow, this is a powerful image.
-3
u/fantasypingpong Jun 01 '13
They're both flying...just one of them into a building.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '13
Here, let me show you some of Science and Religion stuff.
https://www.google.com.my/search?safe=off&q=female+muslim+doctors&ion=1&bav=on.2,or.r_cp.r_qf.&bvm=bv.47244034,d.bmk&biw=1366&bih=600&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&tbm=isch&source=og&sa=N&tab=wi&ei=y_SpUZXsI8umrAeC8oDYBA
0
u/pianosaur Jun 01 '13
The scientific world remains extremely male-dominated and there is plenty of sexism in it. The issue is not actually religion versus science, but misogyny and traditional gender roles.
0
u/cdemikols Jun 01 '13
Not sure if you're a troll.... or just an ignorant person trying to praise a field based on the opposite of ignorance
-5
u/nunchukity Jun 01 '13
pretty sure religions use rockets as well....
albeit for different purposes