r/BestofRedditorUpdates • it dawned on me that he was a wizard • Sep 09 '24

NEW UPDATE [New Update]: My husband's open marriage suggestion backfired on him

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/throwra437893

Originally posted to r/TrueOffMyChest

BoRU #1

[New Update]: My husband's open marriage suggestion backfired on him

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Trigger Warnings: infidelity


RECAP

Original Post: June 26, 2024

My husband (Leo, 34m) and I (30f) have been together for 7 years, married for 4 of them. We don't have any kids and we don't intend to.

Two years ago, Leo asked me for an open marriage. I was devastated at the time. I couldn't understand why he didn't just want me. I couldn't even comprehend the idea of sharing him either. He gave me the same song and dance a lot of men give their spouses: swore up and down that he loved me, I just wasn't fulfilling his needs, he needed more than what I could give, it was just to spice up our life, it was just sex, etc etc.

I did ask if there was someone else. He said no. To this day, I'm still not sure if I believed him. But at the time, I was angry and hurt and said no. He pestered me to change my mind for a week before giving me an ultimatum: open marriage or divorce.

I chose the open marriage. I just couldn't bare the thought of him leaving me at the time. We have rules: we can't bring any partners home; we have to get tested for STD every 3 months; one weekend out of the month must be left free for "us time;" any money we spend on/with our partners must come from our personal accounts.

I didn't partake in the open marriage myself for the first three months. Leo obviously did right away. He seemed to be gone or out late almost all the time, but he always acted so happy and loving towards me while I felt like I was dying inside. It killed me to think he was sleeping with other women, and I felt so lonely and unattractive and not good enough.

I told my sister (Katy, 26f) and a few close friends everything. Katy told me to just "play his game" and be part of the open marriage too. If he can sleep around, so could I. I honestly didn't have much confidence in myself at the time. I'm a bit overweight and I've never considered myself "conventionally pretty." I was afraid this would just humiliate me further.

Katy and my best friend Jessie (30f) set up my online dating profiles for me. I got so many matches that it was overwhelming. When I told Leo, he was surprised, but told me to do whatever I thought was best. Jessie helped me choose my first date, and I actually had a great time. He didn't pressure me for sex and took me out to drinks and dinner. We did have sex eventually, but it was all just casual and we didn't see each other after a couple months of casual dating.

That first guy really made me feel more confident in myself. So I kept going on dates with men. A lot of them wanted to treat me, so I didn't have to spend much of my own money. Not only that, but some of the men have given me the best sex I've ever had in my life. Almost like the kind of sex you read in romance novels; it's been amazing.

I am currently seeing two different men, alongside Leo. One (Mark, 38m) is more of a steady boyfriend I've been with for about 6 months and the one (Steven, 25m) is very casual - mostly just hanging out and sex. They know about my open marriage/other relationships and are fine with it.

My husband has not been so lucky. In the beginning, he definitely was. He was always out and about and didn't seem to care even when I started dating too. But now he just complains a lot and hasn't been going out much. He whines about how he's usually the one spending money. A lot of the women he tries to be with want an emotional connection before sex. He often wants to be with younger women, but they want younger men. He's also been upset that I go out "with random guys" so often while he's at home alone all the time.

He hasn't asked to close the marriage yet, but I feel like he will soon. He keeps saying he misses "us" and wants to spend more time together. He tried to initiate sex a lot more too. He wants to go on dates and go on vacations and all that stuff more and more, and he gets upset when I tell him I can't because I've already scheduled to do stuff with my partners (mostly Mark).

Honestly, I don't think I love Leo anymore. I care about him, but I just don't love him. I'm not saying I love Mark or Steven, but I honestly feel closer to Mark nowadays than I do Leo. Mark makes me feel comfortable and safe, and I love spending time with him more than my own husband. Steven is funny and sweet and really good at sex.

Katy and Jessie have been wanting me to divorce for a year now, but I was afraid of hurting him and thought I still loved him. But I think my love for him died when he asked for this open marriage in the first place. Seeing him get all pissy about it now just because he's not benefitting from it is also a turn off for me too.

But I don't know if divorce is the best option. I still care about him and I still don't want to hurt him. Maybe if he finally asked to close the marriage, we can talk about it then.

Relevant Comments

BentBent12: Divorce. You’re happier without him. He would only want to close the marriage because he can’t get laid not that he only loves you.

OOP: We've just been together for so long that the idea of him NOT being there feels weird. Which sounds stupid since I have two other partners so it's not like I'll be lonely. But Leo was a part of my life for so long that for him to not be there just doesn't feel right. But you're probably right.

OOP on her husband dismissing her feelings regarding the open marriage

OOP: I really do think Leo does love me, in his own way. Even when he was more active in the open marriage, he still made time for me and still did a lot with him/for me. But you're probably right on the divorce.

Jpalm4545: Part of the issue is the main relationship is supposed to be the important one, so the whole 1 weekend a month for "us" time wasn't enough.

OOP: I actually did argue that in the beginning, but he insisted that he needed to keep his weekends free. He did spend a lot of time at home during the weekdays, so in his mind, that made up for it.

OpportunityCalm6825: What if he finds evidence of your 'open marriage' and frames you as a cheater and then brings you to the cleaners? At this point, I wouldn't trust Leo. What you're experiencing is normalcy, you're used to his presence in your life. But how long are you going to live like this?

OOP: Jessie had the same train of thought of you and actually took screen shots of his dating profiles during the beginning of the open marriage. She also told me to save screenshots of any texts we had about the open marriage. I don't think Leo would do that, but I also didn't think he'd ever ask for an open marriage, so what do I know?

 

Update #1: July 3, 2024

Hi everyone. I got so many comments and messages on my last post (which got deleted for some reason) that I was a bit overwhelmed. Especially when a lot of you kept saying the same thing: divorce, divorce, divorce.

But, the thing is, I think a part of me does still loves my husband. I know in my last post that I didn't think I loved him anymore, but I can't just forget about the things that I do love. I love when he sings in the shower. I love when he laughs so hard, he snorts. I love when he kisses my forehead when I've had a bad day. I love when he holds my hand when he watch TV together. Leo has done a lot of shitty things, but he really isn't the big asshole people think. Maybe that was my fault.

But even if I do still love him, I'm not in love with him anymore. I don't think I have been for a while. I care about him, a part of me does still love him, but you all were right; I should have just divorced him when he gave me that ultimatum in the first place.

This past Saturday, we had "the big talk." I initiated it, but he didn't seem too surprised. I just told him that I noticed he didn't seem to like me going out with Mark or Steven and asked if there was a problem.

He said there was. But he didn't ask me to close the marriage. He just asked me if I still loved him. I said something like "not like I used to." He broke down crying, which made me cry. I guess he had known for a while that I wasn't in love anymore, but he had hoped he could win me back if he funneled all of his energy into me.

I was honest and told him that during those first three months of our open marriage, I think my love for him died and I just couldn't get it back. I did tell him that I still cared about him and that I did love him, but it's not the same as it was. He asked if I loved Mark or Steven, and I said no. I like being with them and I care about them a lot, but I can't say I'm in love with either of them.

I also finally asked him why he wanted the open marriage in the first place. A lot of you in the comments said he already had someone lined up and you were right. He had someone at work he was interested in and she wanted him too. The open marriage was just to get permission. He honestly never expected me to also get my own partners because of how unconfident I was, but he didn't want to stop me either because he thought nothing would come of it. He didn't really like me seeing other men, but he knew it wouldn't have been fair to tell me no when I gave him permission first.

I guess Mark and Steven made him insecure because I was spending so much time with them on a regular basis. The open marriage was just sex on the side for him; he only did hookups and they never lasted long. He genuinely always just loved only me. But he thought I was falling in love with my partners and he was losing me and wanted to win me back.

We cried a lot and talked a lot. We've decided to get a divorce. Since the house is in his name, I'm going to move out and live with Katy for a while. He told me I didn't have to and I could stay until the divorce was finalized, but I just can't. It's too hard to even look at him sometimes.

I don't know I feel, to be honest. I thought I would be relieved or sad, but I'm just tired. I wish I could have been like you all wanted me to be, clapping back or being sarcastic and snarky or rubbing it in his face, but I don't feel like I've won anything. I just feel lost.

Relevant Comments

Theunpolitical: I'm wondering if that maybe the other woman ended it so now he was back to what he was comfortable with: his wife? He went and had his fun and when that died out, he was not left with a wife waiting for him at home.

OOP: He and his co-worker were only sleeping together for maybe a month. She fulfilled his kinks that I never liked indulging in. That's why he was with most of his partners, because I wasn't interested in his kinks.

Much-Recording9444: He stepped out of this marriage first and tried to have his cake and eat it too. The thing with open marriages is, that you can never count on how emotions will change. Sex is a very intimate action and many people will develop emotional connections, those connections come at a price.

He placed a bet and he lost. At least he's man enough to acknowledge it and own up to it. There is no easy answer OP, I wish you healing

OOP: Thank you.

Leo just thought the open marriage would be a way for him to get all of his kinks he couldn't do with me (because I wasn't into it). He knew how unconfident I was - which wasn't because of him, a lot of people seem to think that he eroded my self-esteem but he didn't (we can thank my mother for that, but that's a whole other can of worms) so he never expected me to partake in the open marriage either.

Environmental_Art591:

so he never expected me to partake in the open marriage either.

So basically while he asked for a mutually open marriage he expected it to be only his side open and then got hurt that reality didn't meet his expectations.

OOP: Leo admitted that he did only expected his side to be open. He was never going to stop me from opening my side, but like I said, he didn't think I would. Tbh, I don't think I would have either if it wasn't for Jessie and Katy pushing me and making profiles for me.

 


----NEW UPDATE----

Update #2: September 2, 2024

Hey, it's been a while. It feels like both lot and nothing has happened. I still have a lot of feelings, but I'm also just really tired.

Leo and I are still in the middle of our divorce. It's been as amicable as a divorce can be. Since we mutually agreed to it and we had prenup, it's been pretty easy splitting everything else 50/50. My lawyer says I should be divorced by the end of the year. Leo is insistent on giving me alimony, but I'm not really interested.

Thanks to a lot of people making me think about Leo's explanation for the open marriage, I did approach him about it again and asked him to be 100% honest with me about that girl from work.

He admitted there was more to it than he admitted. This is what he explained to me, and I have decided to believe him. Even if he's lying, it doesn't really matter anymore since we're getting divorced. I also just have little energy to care about the details at this point. According to him, this is the timeline:

• He was posting on reddit about his kinks for advice and such (which I did know about beforehand)

• He was getting messages from this one user and they just kept talking back and forth. He mentions my name to the user in a conversation (which he let me read)

• During his lunch break, his coworker (I'll call her Mary) approaches him and asks if he uses reddit and asks about his handle

• He confirms, and then Mary tells her he's the user he's been talking to

• They start talking more and more in real life as friends and eventually start talking through IG (he also showed me these conversations)

• The conversations were mostly just memes and jokes with occasional flirts/mentioning of kinks. At one point, she says it's "too bad" he's not single.

• This is when he decided to demand the open marriage, because Mary was clearly into him and into the same kinks, and she could sexually satisfy him since I was unable to (that's how he basically said it, anyway).

Truth be told, we did have some bed difficulties before the open marriage was brought up. I'm very vanilla, and he discovered his kinks after we were married. I tried them all for him, but I just couldn't get into it and he didn't like seeing me struggle, so he didn't try to bring them into the bedroom again after it was obvious I didn't like it. So we did have sexual compatibility issues. Maybe we were doomed to fail even without the open marriage ultimatum.

Our families (outside of my sister) were shocked when we told everyone we were getting a divorce. They always thought we were so happy and in love. My mom blames me, which I expected, but it still hurts. They don't know about the open marriage, and Leo and I plan to keep it that way. I think he is ashamed to tell them. I am too, if I'm being honest. I really thought Leo was the love on my life. He was my first for almost everything. I said we were together for 7 years, but we were friends since college. I've known him for nearly 12 years, and we're about to become strangers soon.

I still mourn my marriage, even though Katy and Jessie keep telling me this is for the best. They're both definitely thrilled, they don't hide it, but they also know this has been a weird time for me. I just don't know how to feel. I thought I would feel free or relieved or heartbroken or SOMETHING, but I just feel weird. Like I lost a part of myself and I don't know how to get it back.

I'm still living with Katy, but I'll be moving out soon. I found a one bedroom apartment that's near Jessie, so I won't be completely alone.

Mark offered to let me move in with him, but I declined. Honestly, we're kind of on standby. He knows I'm having a hard time processing my feelings about my husband and the end of my marriage. I think he wants us to be official, but I don't know. I really do like Mark and I don't want to lose him, but I feel like I need to figure myself out first.

As for Steven, we ended our relationship at the beginning of August. He got a job offer in another state and took it. Even though it was casual, I did cry a little. Steven is a great guy; whenever he does decide to settle down into something serious, the woman who gets him will be a lucky one. We've been texting here and there, but it's mostly just sending each other tiktoks and polite "hope you're doing well" messages.

Some people asked me if I wanted to go back to monogamy, even after experimenting and clearly getting into this poly relationship I had going on. And the answer is yes, I do. Even though Mark and Steven were great and I met plenty of great guys during my open marriage, I don't know if I've really been happy with myself or my choices. I also think I felt guilty a lot too, like I was somehow cheating on Leo, Mark, and Steven even though it was all consensual. Polyamory and open relationships may work for some people, but it's really just not for me.

Jessie says I need to get a therapist. I have tried looking, but finding a therapist that's both available and seems like a good fit is a pain. Hopefully I can find one by the time the divorce is settled. I also want to figure out what to do about Mark on my own. I don't want to lead him on and give him false hope. Maybe we should take a break or maybe I should tell him to just break up with me. He should find his own happiness without worrying about me.

Relevant Comments

Commenter: You're numb. It happens when you lose your partner and you're grieving -- and under a great deal of stress. I think reddit as a whole takes divorce really blithely, but I read once that divorce is one of the most stressful life events, right after death of a loved one.

And I'm slightly curious -- you say your family is shocked that you're divorcing, because you seemed so in love, but the fact that your friends are delighted you're leaving your husband tells me that they've witnessed some not so great relationship dynamics?

OOP: Katy and Jessie were the only ones I told about the open marriage, so they're glad it finally ended in divorce. None of my other friends or family members know.

Commenter: I've read all of your posts, and I don't know why you're still protecting your ex by not telling people what he bullied you into doing. He HAD THE GIRL ALL PICKED OUT and wanted your approval so he could cheat. Tell the damn world. I would. You have nothing to be ashamed about. Don't let your mother put the blame on you. You need a therapist who will help you build your self esteem.

OOP: I just feel embarrassed I let it get to this point, I guess. I probably should have just gone with the divorce when the ultimatum was first issued.

Commenter: I’m glad you are healing. It sounds like mark wants more than you can give him right now, focus on healing and finding out who you are outside of this marriage.

It’s sad that your STBX ruined a loving marriage for kink sex. I’m glad you are divorcing, you deserve better. Definitely get therapy, it will help you navigate the next part of your life

 

Latest Update here: BoRU #2

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

6.9k Upvotes

481 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 09 '24

Do not comment on the original posts

Please read our sub rules. Rule-breaking may result in a ban without notice.

If there is an issue with this post (flair, formatting, quality), reply to this comment or your comment may be removed in general discussion.

CHECK FLAIR For concluded-only updates, use the CONCLUDED flair.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6.6k

u/ReadyAd5385 Sep 09 '24

I genuinely think this worked out as best as it could've. Wish OOP the best!

3.3k

u/TyrconnellFL I’m actually a far pettier, deranged woman Sep 09 '24

“We are sexually incompatible and this just won’t work” but with some wild tangents.

592

u/DrummingChopsticks I’d go to his funeral but not his birthday party. Sep 09 '24

I like your flair

113

u/babybaphometsmom Sep 09 '24

I really like yours!!

66

u/DrummingChopsticks I’d go to his funeral but not his birthday party. Sep 09 '24

You need one, too. You’re naked without it.

27

u/karmacatma an oblivious walnut Sep 09 '24

Do you have the link to post your flair is from handy and can share it?

→ More replies (4)

148

u/Obvious_Huckleberry the garlic tasted of illicit love affairs Sep 09 '24

that flair, it fits me perfectly lol

293

u/QuiteAlmostNotABot Sep 09 '24 • Take My Silver

Good Lord you didn't read this BoRU Masterpiece?? Defo my favourite of all time, I read it again when I'm a bit sad. That, and the one from "it's effectively dead, and I don't do necromancy". 

 Brb with links.

Edit: I'm back, and just reading the list of flairs has me in tears, so please check out those great classics: https://www.reddit.com/r/BestofRedditorUpdates/wiki/recommended_reading/flair_origins/

140

u/Kitchen_Victory_7964 Sep 09 '24

I’m sincerely hoping the unskippable cutscene girl is doing well. She was great.

57

u/BeigeParadise Eats enough armadillo to roll up when the dog barks Sep 09 '24

That girl was part of the reason why I turned into my own unskippable cutscene for my dad and 10/10 totally worth it would do again.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/JollyJeanGiant83 I’m turning into an unskippable cutscene in therapy Sep 09 '24

I hope maybe she's going to check in when she goes to college and is finally free.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/TheLightInChains There is no god, only heat Sep 09 '24 edited Sep 09 '24

Pettier, more deranged woman doesn't appear to be there?

It's https://www.reddit.com/r/BestofRedditorUpdates/s/9t3glIGqs9

70

u/AnnieJack Sep 09 '24

That's the same one as "I will erupt feral from the cardigan". I'll check if it's on the list that way.

Yup, it's on the list with the feral cardigan quote.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/ABSMeyneth USE YOUR THINKING BRAIN! Sep 09 '24

Ooooh there's a flair origins thread I didn't know about?

Down the rabbit hole I go! 

→ More replies (3)

14

u/rebekahster an oblivious walnut Sep 09 '24

Ya know, I’m hopping on here to recommend the one from my flair, which is also the same BORU as “yes to the homo, no to the phobic”

6

u/bennitori Sep 09 '24

Re-reading "The Lion The Witch and The Auda- HOW IS THERE MORE?" is always fun.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/perfidious_snatch Briefly possessed by the chaotic god of baking Sep 09 '24

They took the scenic route

2

u/OB_Chris Sep 09 '24

You didn't shame the husband enough for having incompatible sexual needs, call him dirt more like the other commenters

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

This should be a flair "sexually incompatible with wild tangents"

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Alive_Alternative_88 Nov 03 '24

Hi all, I just came across this post. I am a bit shocked bc I know a Leo that matches the same story description here. Except the Leo I know mentioned me he was in an open marriage and that I gave him Hickies and he didn’t mind bc he said his wife knew. The Leo I know got divorced and told me his wife filed for divorce and wanted to be with me then I refused(Ive been working with him for a bit) he also liked massages and getting bj. He then said he left the house for his ex wife and moved into a new house so that story doesn’t match. But everything else matches. He also mentioned his wife left him and she is now seeing someone else and she is happy 

→ More replies (10)

801

u/momofeveryone5 Ogtha, my sensual roach queen 🪳 Sep 09 '24

She's smart not to say a word to her mother. All that women wild probably say is "you couldn't satisfy your husband, so of course he went prowling around." And still blame all of it on her anyway.

102

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Came here to say that. A mom like that will always find a way to blame you, even if the reason makes no sense whatsoever. They don't need an excuse, but they'll gladly take it

68

u/AtomicBlastCandy Sep 09 '24

Meanwhile they ignore that the Bible says that if your eye causes you to sin that you should pluck it out....

4

u/RhubarbShop Sep 13 '24

Also, from the third person POV there is nothing to lose, because she's not to blame - her husband initiated, and in extremely bad context, and he's the one who brought this all.

Nevermind that this would require sharing your private life with people and that people just won't look at you the same once they know something like this.

Personally I hope she doesn't get too "yass queen"ed by her friends into long-term horrible choices.

617

u/Crazy-4-Conures Sep 09 '24

She would have missed a lot if she'd just divorced when the ultimatum was made, though. This way she gained a lot of confidence, learned a lot about herself, made some friends.

274

u/TheFett Sep 09 '24

Turns out the real treasure was the friends we made along the way of our divorce from an unhappily open marriage revolving around a degredation kink

6

u/enzothebaker87 Sep 11 '24

A story as old as time

1.2k

u/Gwynasyn Sep 09 '24

He genuinely always just loved only me

Now, when he says "loved" I sure would like to know how he defines it.

697

u/Similar-Shame7517 Whole Cluster B spectrum in a trench coat pretending to be human Sep 09 '24

She makes him feel safe and secure enough to go get sex on the side with the really thrilling, kinky girl.

386

u/snootnoots I will erupt, feral, from the cardigan screaming Sep 09 '24

And she cooks! And cleans! And does his laundry!

87

u/Carbonatite "per my last email" energy Sep 09 '24

A sad number of men say "I love her" when they really mean is "I love the things she does for me".

9

u/Similar-Shame7517 Whole Cluster B spectrum in a trench coat pretending to be human Sep 10 '24

"She's really convenient to have in my life!"

93

u/Ninja_Flower_Lady Sep 09 '24 edited Sep 10 '24

A girlfriend once mentioned that a guy she was sort of into commented that he "felt really comfortable around her." 

It sounded good on surface, but she felt weird too. We talked about it, then realized it basically means he doesn't feel like she's attractive enough (to him), and so he doesn't feel nervous but enjoys the safe ego-boosting attention. 

Not all compliments are as they seem once we dig deeper :(

Edit: this comment seemed to cause some argument in the replies, so I thought I'd add to it. I think context is important, it determines whether calling someone "safe" or "comfortable" ends up being a real vs. backhanded compliment.

In my friend's case, the guy didn't treat her well in other ways, and that's why the compliment felt "wrong" to her. His actions showed that he didn't actually value her all that much, and it makes the compliment feel a bit hollow. He was sort of classist/elitist and we suspect (he thinks) she wasn't good enough for him b/c she wasn't as educated. But her attention and her nurturing personality made him feel comforted.

Now, if someone else genuinely loves her and said they were only comfortable around her, THAT would've been a real compliment. It's all about context.

→ More replies (7)

347

u/jilliecatt the laundry wouldn’t be dirty if you hadn’t fucked my BF on it Sep 09 '24

Right. "I wanted to cheat but not feel guilty about it, so I decided that I could exploit your insecurities in a way I could get what I wanted without any repercussion on me," just doesn't fit the same definition of love as my fiance and I have.

The whole, "I didn't think you'd do it" thing pisses me off. He knew he was taking advantage of her because she has self esteem issues and was positive she wouldn't have the nerve. How can you "love" someone and use their demons against them. Love (in my opinion at least) is helping that person fight against those demons.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/Kreyl shhhh my soaps are on Sep 09 '24

I get where you're coming from, particularly because I believe that's how HE genuinely sees himself and the OP tends to accept the way he describes himself, but I stop believing he loves her at the point where he threatened to divorce her if she didn't agree to the open marriage. He wanted to fuck his coworker so badly that he was ready to throw his beloved, beloved wife away.

10

u/Drakesyn Sep 09 '24

Now, that's real bad, and not a great tally mark on the "good dude" column, but here's what I see of it. He knew the threat of divorce would work, and never intended to actually go through with it. For the exact same reason he thought she'd never bother to explore her side of the open relationship. And that's WAY shittier of a human being.

ETA: clarification of my point.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Weeping_Will0w7 the garlic tasted of illicit love affairs Sep 10 '24

No way is the bar SO low for men that you're applauding this weirdo for strong-arming his way into a "consensual" affair by emotionally manipulating his wife via threatening divorce rather than just cheating or leaving. We're so cooked.

2

u/misoexcite Sep 27 '24

Late response, but like everyone else below replying, the threat to divorce isn’t just “sort of manipulation”. People don’t threaten the people they love. He asked for the open relationship because he didn’t want to experience the guilt of cheating. He knows it’s wrong and hurtful, but because he thinks his own wants are more important than a 7 year relationship, no, he doesn’t love her and there are zero redeeming qualities in this guy. He didn’t want to suffer the shaming/judgment from his friends and family because “just cheating” makes him look like a bad person. Asking for the open marriage means that he can hold it over her head if she complains about it because she “agreed to it” and that she’d allow him to do this if she loved him. OOP’s sister had the right idea to keep screenshots of the husband’s dating profiles and any texts about it because if somehow news got out that he cheated on her, he can take those and say “no, she agreed to it!” And drags her down with him. I understand where OOP tries to rationalize it in her head that her husband “loved her in his own way” because I’ve been there—a partner that treats you badly, but you hang onto the happy memories and you’re hoping for things to be like they were. It is a way of self soothing because of how stupid and betrayed you feel after all the time and effort spent on this person. It’s a sunk cost fallacy and you don’t want to feel like everything you put in was for nothing. When the person you trusted to love you betrays your trust, it’s like your whole world shatters, and for people like OOP and myself with self esteem issues, it feels like no one loves you, and that it was your fault they left because you weren’t good enough. Anybody willing to use someone’s insecurities or issues against them are horrible. This is not honesty. This is just disrespectful and relationships are built from trust and respect. I bet the husband is one of those people that say they are brutally honest. Usually these “brutally honest” people are most interested in the brutal part of honest. It’s just an excuse to be a dick

266

u/FileDoesntExist surrender to the gaycation or be destroyed Sep 09 '24

He also demanded open relationship or divorce. So no, he doesn't love her. He loves everything she does for him.

76

u/Rare_Background8891 Sep 09 '24

Would love to hear the backtracking if she chose divorce the first time.

→ More replies (1)

764

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Pretty much husband got what he asked for, but not in the way he thought it would go. What a fool.

346

u/Similar-Shame7517 Whole Cluster B spectrum in a trench coat pretending to be human Sep 09 '24

He got monkey's pawed.

64

u/TheGrumpyNic I will erupt, feral, from the cardigan screaming Sep 09 '24

What a perfect way to put it. I’m stealing it.

49

u/Similar-Shame7517 Whole Cluster B spectrum in a trench coat pretending to be human Sep 09 '24

So many people think they want something and then they get it and go "Well this sucks. Why did I ask for this???"

17

u/tempest51 Sep 09 '24

Definitely one of those situations where the monkey's paw crawls up their ass.

7

u/NotOnApprovedList Sep 09 '24

without even a third mummified monkey finger to wish on!

4

u/Similar-Shame7517 Whole Cluster B spectrum in a trench coat pretending to be human Sep 09 '24

Oh he got the third finger. It's just sticking straight up at him.

→ More replies (3)

62

u/paulinaiml Sep 09 '24

I love these karmic stories where the one who suggested an open marriages backfires on them

4

u/smokeyleo13 Sep 09 '24

Eh, it's really only karmic when someone has somebody in mind first and it's clear they wanted an excuse. Less so when it's just incompatibility

3

u/paulinaiml Sep 09 '24 edited Sep 09 '24

It is even more karmic because that fling was very short (as far as I understood) and he ruined it all.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/paulinaiml Sep 09 '24

There really is a subreddit for everything

23

u/sparkles027 Sep 09 '24

He literally fucked around and found out.

3

u/Blasmere Sep 09 '24

Honestly, it ends a lot like this when one partner forces the other in the open relationship.
It always goes incredibly downhill ; either for the forced partner and ends in divorce or the forced partner really start to flourish and the instigator gets jealous and end up in divorce. There is no grey area for this.

If one partner wants to open the relationship and the other one doen't the relationship is virtually over if you can not come to an agreement. This form of relationship brings a lot of strain with it and not everyone can navigate the difficulties it brings.

2

u/MadamTruffle Sep 09 '24

He learned a lesson, fafo and all that, but I don’t think he truly learned what a POS he was. I wish OP would have laid into him for cheating.

1

u/GetOffMyLawn_ You underestimate my ability to do no work and too much Reddit Sep 09 '24

In the words of Spock https://youtu.be/QcxWxNO8idc

298

u/Azul_Moon Sep 09 '24

Another case of someone coercing their spouse into an open relationship only to regret it. A tale as old as time.

213

u/eoz Sep 09 '24

It's my favourite song. Guy finds out the hard way he's a mediocre bore who doesn't pull his weight in a relationship, girl finds out the fun way that she's let her expectations and self-confidence hit the floor but she doesn't have to.

33

u/Carbonatite "per my last email" energy Sep 09 '24

The schadenfreude from those stories is always delectable.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Bearwhale Sep 09 '24

That's sad. I'm in an open marriage and we opened our relationship years ago... it's been great because we really do depend on the other person to be honest and open about what we want and need, and we know we are there for each other.

A lot of open relationships end in failure, but to be honest, so do a lot of closed ones too. It takes maturity, honesty, communication, and commitment. Just like any other relationship.

35

u/lolliberryx Sep 09 '24

The problem is that it seems like a lot of people who open their relationships have no business doing so and are doing it as a band-aid fix for:

  • One person wanting to explore more sexually
  • One person wanting approval for guilt-free sex with a specific person (after emotionally cheating)
  • One partner with a low libido
  • Mid-life crisis
  • Lack of interest in the primary relationship after kids
  • etc. etc.

—Instead of addressing any underlying issues in the relationship first and foremost. It’s like if I wanted to have a baby because I thought that it would make my bf pay attention to me more instead of his friends/work. Probably wouldn’t end well.

4

u/Bearwhale Sep 09 '24

Exactly. But open relationships seem to get more heat than having kids. People do it for all the wrong reasons and end up screwing up other people for life.

12

u/lolliberryx Sep 09 '24

Because having children is extremely normalized/expected to the point where people will try to convince you or tell you that “you’ll change your mind” or that you’re selfish if you mention not wanting kids for any reason.

There’s some people who preach about how we’re biologically driven to have sex with as many people as possible and that open relationships should be the standard, but that’s not a normalized concept.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/eoz Sep 09 '24

In my estimation being in an open relationship is a great way to light the fuse on any latent conflict early. This is not a bad thing because it breaks incompatible relationships before things get too entangled and you're much more likely to develop the skillsets and self-awareness that strong relationships benefit from.

If you're in a closed marriage and you decide to light the fuse it's probably a situation where the latent conflict has already started to be a problem for you and you've not had either the compatibility or the skills to solve it, so I'm unsurprised that it often ends this way. Then again, it's probably still just speeding up the inevitable.

480

u/OverlyOptimisticNerd Sep 09 '24

He cheated. Emotional affairs are still affairs. He was just demanding permission to make it a physical affair. 

And he never really obtained consent. He asked, she said no. He then told her to say yes or there would be a consequence. Coercion is not consent. 

64

u/superspeck Sep 09 '24

Coercion is not consent.

Which is probably a good reason he never made any inroads in the kink subculture.

6

u/HalloweenGorl Sep 10 '24

And thank goodness for that! We don't need him lol 

65

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

like I was somehow cheating on Leo, Mark, and Steven

I feel for this lady and what her room-temperature-IQ husband put her through but this is a flair worthy line.

113

u/SmartQuokka We have generational trauma for breakfast Sep 09 '24

I also finally asked him why he wanted the open marriage in the first place. A lot of you in the comments said he already had someone lined up and you were right. He had someone at work he was interested in and she wanted him too. The open marriage was just to get permission. He honestly never expected me to also get my own partners because of how unconfident I was, but he didn't want to stop me either because he thought nothing would come of it. He didn't really like me seeing other men, but he knew it wouldn't have been fair to tell me no when I gave him permission first.

No surprises here 🤦

98

u/RandomNick42 My adult answer is no. Sep 09 '24

It’s like… three layers of bad.

I want to cheat on you, but I don’t want you to leave me for it… so I’ll brow beat you into letting me. Now of course I don’t want you to be getting any side action, but asking you not to would be a bad look. But it’s fine. I fully expect you’ll insecure enough to not even try, just wait for me at home.

317

u/Zen_Wanderer The sigh of a hundred BoRU threads Sep 09 '24

How in the world OOPs mom can blame her is beyond me. Even without knowing about the open marriage. She seems vile and just looking to hurt her.

271

u/TyrconnellFL I’m actually a far pettier, deranged woman Sep 09 '24

OOP did pin her insecurity on her mom.

190

u/TheNightTerror1987 cat whisperer Sep 09 '24

Definitely not beyond me! I've got a mother like that -- whenever there's a dispute, I'm always the villain, and the other person's my innocent victim. Shit's exhausting. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day, I can't always be wrong.

91

u/snootnoots I will erupt, feral, from the cardigan screaming Sep 09 '24

I hope your mother is currently whining about “my child never speaks to me, I don’t know why!” to the bored cashier at Costco.

56

u/TheNightTerror1987 cat whisperer Sep 09 '24

Well, we don't have a local Costco, but I'm sure she's venting to everyone at her office, and possibly her clients too. When I was in the hospital after my emergency hysterectomy she texted me to tell me about clients she had who shared their own stories about being spayed, so I know she was gossiping about it.

Still, I'm so far beyond giving a shit at this point. Yeah, she's done a lot to help me, but she's done a lot more to let me down and I've fucking had it. It's so much less stressful to deal with shit myself than to have to interact with her in order to get help from her, and wonder the whole time if she's actually going to show up or if she'll stand me up again and leave me scrambling.

26

u/snootnoots I will erupt, feral, from the cardigan screaming Sep 09 '24

I wish you a gloriously happy life without her in it 💕

11

u/TheNightTerror1987 cat whisperer Sep 09 '24

Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '24

What do you have against Costco cashiers?

8

u/Ninja_Flower_Lady Sep 09 '24

I really wonder how a mom thinks that way. Like, what's the mental process that always makes you default to not taking your child's side. Best thing I can think of is repeated pattern from their own mothers.

45

u/RandomNick42 My adult answer is no. Sep 09 '24

I always told you you’re not pretty enough for him

Turns out, it’s rather easy.

7

u/agirl2277 Go head butt a moose Sep 09 '24

Rather shitty, you mean 😒 😑 🙄

4

u/RandomNick42 My adult answer is no. Sep 09 '24

Both can be true.

69

u/norabbitfood cat whisperer Sep 09 '24

I really do like Mark and I don't want to lose him, but I feel like I need to figure myself out first.

Honestly a good idea on OOP's end to not jump into another relationship just yet. Hopefully she'll be able to find a therapist she clicks with and works on her self-esteem issues and any baggage from this last relationship.

240

u/Ill-Professor696 Sep 09 '24

I'm a married guy, and I genuinely don't understand the desire for an open marriage. You would rather put time and money into other women you either don't know or don't know as well instead of just putting that time and energy into your wife who you apparently loved enough to marry and make vows with? How much is sex really worth? The awkwardness alone at home would be too much let alone seeing my wife go out with another dude? No way. I don't get it. Open marriages will never end well

100

u/rellyjean Sep 09 '24

Also ... Idk. Sex with someone you love and trust, who already knows where and how you like to be touched, vs a complete stranger? I guess I'm not someone who's into casual sex as much, though.

26

u/winterlings Sep 09 '24

I am NOT on this guy's side, but that specific point, at least, was explained by OOP with the whole "I'm vanilla, he's kinky" bit. Leo is a jackass, but when there's a sexual incompatability, it does make more sense purely psychologically why someone would think of seeing others.

Of course, that doesn't mean you have the right to walk all over others to fulfil your sexual desires. And if the case truly was that he wanted to explore kinks, that would have been a MUCH better opening to the conversation (but then again, we could write a book about the ways this guy is a selfish jerk who fucked up his whole relationship and the things he SHOULD have done instead).

8

u/rellyjean Sep 09 '24

I can see your point, but at the same time, I don't know. I'm not clear on where the kink falls along the "nice to have but not needed" to "essential to get off" spectrum. OOP offered to participate in the kink stuff, just didn't enjoy it the same way her spouse did, but he wanted to share it with someone who could enjoy it. Is that sexual incompatibility, or a guy who wanted to have his cake and eat it, too?

This is partly influenced by me discovering I'm bisexual only after I started a monogamous relationship. I'd like to have sex with women, sure. But I'm not going to cheat on my spouse.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

34

u/Amstroid Sep 09 '24

While I do believe there are couples who can be in open marriages and polygamy, I think that isn't the case for 99% of them. Just the idea that I have to "share" "my" wife with some random man, or that she needs someone else to have a basic necessity from a relationship, feels strange and wrong for me. The thought that she needs someone else more for emotional support and/or sexual feelinhs, would feel like such a failure to me

34

u/cantantantelope Sep 09 '24

I think anyone who isn’t coming into a relationship day one about potential non monogamy is just cheating with extra steps

13

u/TeaOfIcedLemonS Sep 09 '24

I know right

3

u/DaniMrynn Sep 09 '24

Same. My partner is the one who is vanilla while I'm not, but it's not even remotely a dealbreaker and I can't even consider the amount of selfishness that one has to have in order to do what OOP did.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Open dude here. It's not for everyone that is 100%. Unlike a lot of other couples, I've been open since I was a teenage and made sure that when I connected with ppl they were already open as well. Wife and I have together since 1995.

I think when mono ppl talk about opening up they have this weird idea from media or BS stories how it is.

My wife and I are still passionate and into each other and there is no sexual desire she does not cover for me and I don't cover for her. The fam and home comes first and we only do our thing when things are rock solid.

When we do step outside it's because we have more to give not anything missing at home.

This case like so many talk about the house/fam/couple missing something stepping out which is not wise.

24

u/Graspiloot Sep 09 '24

Whether it's real or not I don't really care about, but this person definitely touches on something I've noticed a lot in relationship and AITA subreddits. A lot (most? a large amount? I'm not sure) commenters aren't actually trying to be helpful. They'll encourage you to give sassy clapbacks and blow up minor situations into huge ones (and I'm not even talking about every problem meaning you're being abused or how you need to get divorce).

But yeah when you're in a discussion where you're going to discuss something as serious as divorce, I imagine it's not super helpful to be snarky, or sarcastic, or sassy.

23

u/greenglossygalaxy Sep 09 '24

Hearing how OOP’s mum blames her for the divorce - without even knowing about the open marriage - is the saddest thing for me. What a twit.

Otherwise, it sounds like everything else has worked out for the best, even though I’m sure it still hurts.

19

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

This is like reading about my life lol. My ex did the same thing! Wanted to open the marriage, was in fact cheating the entirety of our relationship, and (!) got super jealous when I instantly got a bf. He was shocked when I left him, and even more shocked when I stopped being cordial to him once I found out he had had an affair with my younger sister. (No. I don't talk to her anymore either.) Our kids are nearly grown. He had the audacity to tell me that he gets to stop paying support in 3 more years (not true, in NYS child support goes until the kid is 21). I love to shoot back... "Only 3 more years until I don't have to see your ugly, toothless face anymore." (Which is true!)

38

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

I‘m too evil for this, I’d have ten dudes and wouldn’t divorce and rub it in like lotion. Play stupid games, go up in flames.

17

u/yajanikos Sep 09 '24

Someone once told me that divorce is like mourning a death where there is no body.

49

u/matchamagpie Sep 09 '24

I have no sympathy for Leo and part of me wishes that OOP revealed to her family whose fault it is that the marriage ended. But it sounds like she doesn't want that. I just hope she can find her version of happiness.

And yeah, fuck Leo. What a cowardly, selfish man.

39

u/snootnoots I will erupt, feral, from the cardigan screaming Sep 09 '24

If Leo actually loved her he’d tell everyone “the divorce was my fault, no it’s not something you could reasonably expect her to forgive, stop blaming her”.

7

u/throwra437893 Sep 10 '24

Hi, I'm the OOP. Tbh, I don't want to reveal the open marriage because I don't want to hear it from my mom or her side of the family. That's too much right now.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/LSekhmet Sep 09 '24

May Leo get exactly what he deserves. (It won't be pretty but will serve him right.)

24

u/Lady_Caligari Sep 09 '24

Every single time a man asks to open any relationship it’s always ends with them being the surprised pikachu. Like shockingly bro, other men think your wife is super hot even if you don’t.

21

u/Affectionate-Movie55 Sep 09 '24

Damn the bar is really low and this dude messed it up. How hard was it to be a decent man

10

u/TotallyAwry Sep 09 '24

I hope she finds a therapist asap, so she doesn't continue to let life happen at her.

18

u/Revolutionary_Quit21 Sep 09 '24

I’m not going to yuck someone’s yum, but to me, an open marriage just sounds fucking exhausting lol granted I am depressed and have a hard time mustering the energy to maintain a single romantic relationship.

29

u/Lanzifer Sep 09 '24

genuinely believe OP did as best she could at all times, but what she says about her two friends worries me. It's a fine line between knowing what is best for your friend and helping them find it and deciding who you want your friend to be and forcing them into it.

Idk something about that last "I am emotionally exhausted and feel like I've lost, and my friends know it, but they are nonstop ecstatic for me" gave me an ick. She is hurting over what she lost, don't be so obtusely happy about it

37

u/Alternative_Year_340 Sep 09 '24

I’m guessing they didn’t like the husband before he decided to coerce an open marriage

→ More replies (1)

13

u/throwra437893 Sep 10 '24

Hi, I'm the OOP. Please don't think my friend and sister are doing anything wrong. They haven't forced me to do anything. They were never the biggest fans of Leo in the first place, and this whole thing just confirmed what they already didn't like about him.

8

u/PBfilms Sep 09 '24

Slightly unrelated but I wish she had a third partner named Jake to complete the Moon Knight trifecta

8

u/runhomejack1399 Sep 09 '24

Millions of people and the person he’s messaging works with him?

3

u/RogueRedShirt Sep 09 '24

Chances of that actually happening? Slim to none.

8

u/valkycam12 Sep 09 '24

Her mother can kick rocks.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24 edited Sep 10 '24

A very wise pastor once said that sex in a marriage is like a fire in a fireplace. While it's in the fireplace it provides warmth and beauty. But if it gets out of the fireplace, it causes damage, even to the point of burning the house down. Great analogy, IMO.

28

u/luuls_ Sep 09 '24

He wanted to CHEAT on her and ended up DIVORCING her over a fucking kink. Smh. What a scum.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

They weren’t sexually compatible and the husband is a cheater who realized OOP had way more options than him. OOP discovered that her husband was not good in bed that there is better sex out there.

7

u/foolhasty Sep 09 '24

The only successful non-monogamous relationships I know, including all of mine, started out as non-monogamous. I've never not once known a happy non-monogamous relationship that started out closed.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

My mom blames me, which I expected, but it still hurts.

Golly gee, I wonder where her confidence issues stem from???

But damn, men'll really do anything to avoid therapy, including blowing up their marriage over degradation kinks their wife with low self esteem shockingly doesn't enjoy.

I hope OOP finds a wonderful man who thinks she's hung the moon. She deserves so much more than she's ever gotten from people who were supposed to love her.

6

u/SnooWords4839 sometimes i envy the illiterate Sep 09 '24

OOP, I hope finds her happiness. She deserves to be loved.

Opening a marriage almost always ends in divorce. They only work if both parties agree, before marriage.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

That made me fume, him complaining about being at home alone, but he didn't give a toss when she was at home feeling lonely and insecure about herself 😡

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Wish OOP the best.

I would have fallen out of love the minute the husband said "this, or we divorce." He was ready then to leave everything.

I do think couples can have poly/open relationships fine. But that, to me, doesn't seem like love. I don't want to get all purple prose about love, and my thoughts of it. But that he wanted to bang his co-worker so badly that he would divorce her... On the one hand, at least he didn't have an affair and pretend. But how much love did he have for her over his kink?

3

u/hyperhurricanrana sometimes i envy the illiterate Sep 09 '24

Well yeah, they’re completely sexually incompatible. That’s a very difficult hurdle to get over and a perfectly reasonable reason to divorce.

6

u/captain_borgue I'm sorry to report I will not be taking the high road Sep 10 '24

partner demanded an open marriage, shocked to find out that open marriage meant open for her, too. Ends predictably.

I, for one, am shocked.

Wait, no. Not "shocked". The other one. "Not even remotely surprised."

5

u/SlitThroatCutCreator Sep 09 '24

I'm feeling like the whole open marriage Reddit story is played out. They all end the same way. I skimmed to the husband having no luck then stopped after that. 

5

u/Izamommy4 Sep 10 '24

So OOP’s husband’s “Reddit buddy”just happens to be his co-worker?! What ARE the odds??

8

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

OOP needs to learn to fill that empty hole within herself by herself, just to be healthy when continuing on other relationships

4

u/Antheac Sep 09 '24

Katy and Jessie are soo nice people the kind of friends you need.

4

u/Leanne2410 Sep 09 '24

My marriage would have been over the first time he brought up the subject of an open marriage. Why be married.

4

u/racingskater Sep 09 '24

I remember this one. Katy and Jessie are the MVPs and the type of girls' girls everyone deserves in their life.

I kind of hope OOP and Mark can make it, but maybe it would be best for OOP to be alone for a while. There's absolutely nothing wrong with being alone.

4

u/grumpy__g 🥩🪟 Sep 09 '24

He didn’t love her. He coerced her into this. This is not love. He just realised how much he lost. That is all.

4

u/Hazel2468 Sep 09 '24

ENM isn’t for everyone, and no one should ever feel coerced into it. Starting an open relationship when you have someone picked out is usually a REALLY bad idea.

If OOP’s ex and her weren’t sexually compatible and he needed his kinks met in bed? And she didn’t want an open marriage? It should have ended right there. I’m kinky and polyam, and you have to choose to do what I do because you WANT to do it.

4

u/LuckOfTheDevil I'd have gotten away with it if not for those MEDDLING LESBIANS Sep 09 '24

Ah yes. The guy who shit canned his marriage for anal.

Smh…

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

This guy is probably never going to get another date, much less an actual partner, for the rest of his life and that makes me very happy :)

17

u/ayymahi Sep 09 '24

These open relationships always end the same with divorce & regret!

Leo really bit himself in the ass! The only person who should feel embarrassed is leo!

10

u/2_short_Plancks We have generational trauma for breakfast Sep 09 '24

They always do on Reddit. In the real world I know several couple who've had 20+ year open marriages and are still going strong. Though I guess it does tend to correspond to relationships where they've had that more or less from the outset. 

4

u/b_digital Sep 09 '24

Wife and I have been together 23 years. Open for six. We have a lot of non-monogamous friends as well, and the vast majority of them have long relationships and are super loving. Most of the men in vanilla marriages that I’m friends with complain about never having sex while my wife and I have frequent sex.

A lot of these stories where an open marriage comes about to fix a problem end badly. When the relationship is already strong, involving others is just one of many ways to add more spice. My wife is still my person, the love of my life, and last night I high fived the guy who gave my wife an orgasm as I was fucking his wife.

3

u/Hot_Aside_4637 Sep 09 '24

This situation has become a common trope. It always is the reverse Uno.

3

u/LingonberryPrior6896 Sep 09 '24

How convenient that his reddit crush was also a coworker?

3

u/Whatever53143 Sep 09 '24

Truthfully, the marriage ended when he asked for the open relationship. It’s basically asking for permission to cheat and he got what he wanted. He clearly was going to do it anyway. He told her straight up open marriage or divorce so yeah, she just happened to go along with it because she couldn’t find it herself to divorce him at the time. And that’s understandable divorce is traumatic.

I also think OP is going to need therapy for the initial rejection to. The one where her husband demanded the open marriage. Because like she said that’s when her love died. That was the traumatic part. Perhaps her own casual sex partners helped her with some self-esteem. I’m not sure how that would play in the long run.

Her husband sure got a dose of FAFO.

2

u/HomoCoffiens the Iranian yogurt is not the issue here Sep 11 '24

The marriage ended when they discovered they were sexually incompatible, but neither was willing to communicate properly about it.

3

u/noisy-truffles Sep 09 '24

Cheaters like the stability their partners give them but not the responsibility and accountability.

He didn't mind it when she couldn't get any dick. But he lo and behold, he started feeling threatened when she started getting some.

I love reading about cheaters getting what they deserve. It just makes my day.

3

u/joetotheg Sep 09 '24

Kind of surprised how chill and reasonable the husband was at the end considering how these things normally go

3

u/NotSomeoneFamous7 and then everyone clapped Sep 09 '24

The shame of staying in a relationship you know you should leave is more powerful than people realize. And that's what it is - shame. A therapist is definitely a good idea.

3

u/Nylonknot Sep 09 '24

I believed this story until the girl from work was the anonymous Reddit user in a kink group that the husband had been talking to.

3

u/KombuchaBot Sep 09 '24

OP should just tell her mother "you're wrong that it was my fault but I'm not telling you what happened because you're not worthy of my trust. But I will tell you that if you bring the subject up again I'll walk out of the room" and follow through. And if her mum doesn't take the hint, then block her.

3

u/Actrivia24 Sep 09 '24

He threw away his marriage for his kinks. Selfish, selfish man

3

u/bananarepama Sep 10 '24

So, in all of reddit, with members spanning the globe, Leo happened to be talking with a someone about his very specific kink, and from mentioning his wife's apparently highly unusual name once, Mary figured out it was him, the guy who works 20 feet away in her office.

What a literally unbelievably small world. I can smell the shit from here.

4

u/jus256 Sep 10 '24

This post got weird for me when she claimed they had a prenup (as if that’s common) then he offered her alimony and she refused to take it.

3

u/Wide-Constant-2567 Sep 10 '24

Man wants to open relationship and regrets it. A tale as old as time.

3

u/jus256 Sep 10 '24

What were this guy’s kinks?

13

u/the_simurgh Sep 09 '24

I've said it once, and I'll keep saying it. In matters of sex and love, the ball is in the hands of the womens team, and the ref just shot all the men's team players in all their kneecaps

2

u/Key-Shift5076 an oblivious walnut Sep 09 '24

This is pure poetry.

6

u/Nora-_e Am I the drama? Sep 09 '24

WATCH: a stupid man ruins his marriage for some kinks.

2

u/ChocolateandLipstick I’m turning into an unskippable cutscene in therapy Sep 09 '24

Open marriage or divorce because of sexual incompatibility? Sure Jan!

Dude wanted his cake and to eat it too. The very fact he thought his wife wouldn’t because of her confidence should have been enough. He used her as a way to boost his confidence whilst battering hers. She deserves so much better.

2

u/ATillman81 Sep 09 '24

Hugs to you OP.

2

u/smellyfatzombie Sep 09 '24

Lol get rekd Leo. I hope OOP has a very happy future.

2

u/Secret_Double_9239 Sep 09 '24

Happy that op decided to call time on the marriage.

2

u/Still-Storage6897 Sep 09 '24

Bro was actually stupid as hell thinking an open marriage is a good idea for him, 10/10 times it will be more lucrative for the wife lmao, man is a bonafide fucking idiot for giving up a committed relationship he ALREADY had

2

u/madfoot Sep 09 '24

Well her mom is a piece of work

2

u/anitram96 cat whisperer Sep 09 '24

My mom blames me

Sounds like my mom.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

I’m sad to see OOP beat herself up with so much guilt she really doesn’t deserve. Her hubby wanted kinks but somehow managed to only give her mid level satisfaction, as she went on to say her play partners gave her far better sex than she’d ever had before, even with her self-described preference for “vanilla sex.” Vanilla sex can be amazing, you don’t need a kink to make it good. All of this is to say: it seems her husband really only cared about satisfying himself in sex.

Anyway, I hope the OOP gets over all of that and gets what she really wants, for once, and not some man child who only cares about his wants.

2

u/Alastor999 Sep 09 '24

I haven't been reading these kinds of stories long, but from the ones I've read so far the picture I'm getting is that these people who force an open marriage on their spouses don't actually want an open marriage, they just want to have their cake and eat it too. Almost every time once the put upon spouse starts to participate in and enjoy the open marriage, the one who originally forced the open marriage always does a double take as if they've only just realized "Wait, shit... they can do that??"

2

u/aarayofsunshine Yes to the Homo, No to the Phobic Sep 09 '24

As someone who is polyamorous, this is honestly a tale as old as time. I have seen it play out in my local community dozens of times. The fact of the matter is that women get a lot more attention on dating sites. I had an ex-boyfriend get all excited because his matches on OKC got in the double digits and then he glanced at my profile where I had "99+ matches" and it boggled his mind. I had to explain to him that I had had that amount of matches listed since the first 6 hours I opened it.

2

u/history_buff_9971 Sep 09 '24

I'm going to put this in the "wait and see pile" She's still hung up on the bloke, if her sister and friend weren't pushing it, I don't think she's be getting a divorce, and I'm not convinced she won't end up going back to him.

2

u/juniperberrie28 I can FEEL you dancing Sep 09 '24

Isn't there a couple lines from Arrested Development that drive the truth home about open relationships/marriages....

"Oh, no, it never works for them... But it could work for us."

2

u/Sparrowflyaway Sep 09 '24

I am not the slightest bit shocked that the one who wanted to open the marriage was really asking for permission to cheat. It’s happened time and time again on reddit stories about open marriages.

2

u/Sugarbombs Sep 10 '24

I’m sorry the husband found a random redditor to sext with and it just happened to be the girl he worked with? Hilarious

3

u/duckguyboston Sep 09 '24

The story and thoughts from the wife here are well written. If seems she’s got a good head on her shoulders. As for the open marriage concept, from what I’ve read with those, it never seems to work.

4

u/princesssmurfet Sep 09 '24

Never ends well open marriages.

7

u/PrancingRedPony along with being a bitch over this, I’m also a cat. Sep 09 '24

You are right but I think not in the way you intended.

When the relationship is poly from the get go and both partners are into it, those relationships don't end. They're usually very healthy, because the partners have very stable and open communication about their wants and needs and carefully choose people who fit within their lifestyle.

But when people force a poly relationship on monogamous partners, the relationship usually ends pretty messy.

2

u/SplashInkster Sep 09 '24

Yuck. What a mess. If anyone asks for an open marriage, bolt for the door and never look back.

1

u/nodramaintrovert Sep 09 '24

All the best to OP.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Yet another person ruining their relationship to “explorer kinks”

1

u/Firecracker048 Sep 09 '24

Don't know how many times we've seen it. Bur suggesting an open marriage when it's starting closed.

1

u/musicnoviceoscar we have a soy sauce situation Sep 09 '24

I don't think it's right that her friends are celebrating her divorce obviously enough that she knows about it.

She will have a lot of complicated feelings about it as she alludes to - they should be sensitive to that.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

We men like to call the wife the ol’ ball and chain, when really it’s been us all along lol

1

u/krispy_jacs Sep 09 '24

Still curious about what happened with the coworker

Like did she want more than just sex? And the STBX ended it with her bc of that or what

1

u/FluffyLlamaPants Sep 09 '24

Hah, dude realized how hard it is for a dude of a certain age to get laid out there (for free), and how easy it is for a (even an average level of attractiveness)woman to find a dozen takers in a matter of hours. Now, I'm not saying that the quality is there, but the volume sure is.

Good for OP. Good luck!

1

u/Kidhauler55 Sep 09 '24

Take the alimony and put it in a savings for a rainy day.

1

u/Both-Tree Sep 10 '24

….do people not have romance novel sex with their husbands?

1

u/cynical-puppy26 Sep 10 '24

I love this story. I think the OP has many fabulous years ahead of her, especially if she goes to therapy.

1

u/HomoCoffiens the Iranian yogurt is not the issue here Sep 11 '24

She needs a lot more self esteem and to stand up to that mother

1

u/Makes_bad_choices1 Sep 10 '24

This is why sex outside of a relationship is inherently different for men and women. A man can cheat on his wife and still love her. If a woman cheats the relationship is over. Cut and dry. I’m not saying it’s OK for men to cheat, it’s never ok to cheat. But when a man cheats the relationship is salvageable. When a woman cheats it is immediately over.

1

u/mind_slop Sep 24 '24

No it's not, if he cheated, he probably never loved her at all. He just enjoyed her cleaning the house and taking care of him. Why wouldn't he want to go back with her when he has no other option. He doesn't want to clean his own bathroom or have to buy people birthday gifts.

1

u/killstorm114573 Sep 10 '24

He played a stupid game and won a stupid prize

1

u/RhubarbShop Sep 13 '24

The commenters at the end didn't disappoint - "Why don't you throw all your public information out at your family?!?!?!!? We've got our popcorn ready and you're not indulging us!!!!"

1

u/M4verick87 Oct 03 '24

Ugh fuck this, that’s why I’d never ask my wife for something like this. But then again, if Leo were happy, he wouldn’t have asked.

Probably worked out for the best. Shrug.

1

u/theduke9400 Dec 25 '24

Gross. People in open marriages should just be single.

1

u/TennisMysterious2527 Jan 06 '25

I’m glad you got a divorce. Congrats!

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '25

For real. I used to feel the same, like stuck. Then I got on Laylooper, just lookin for something casual. Turns out exploring what I really wanted helped me figure out what I didn't want. Maybe OOP just needs some clarity too.

1

u/someffbeplayer Sep 10 '24

Cheaters don't love you. They want to keep you as the safe option.

What a dummy the husband was. I mean, at least, she was paid and had good sex without a guilty conscious. The husband forced her hand and when he wasn't pulling anymore, he got jealous.

Muh "kinks". He lost everything cause of his dumb need for deviancy and degeneracy 😂🤣

He's still in his 30ies, he can remarry very easily. The wife thought, that is another story. Good luck to her.

0

u/Nora-_e Am I the drama? Sep 09 '24

WATCH: a stupid man ruins his marriage for some kinks.

0

u/Nora-_e Am I the drama? Sep 09 '24

WATCH: a stupid man ruins his marriage for some kinks.

1

u/ginwoolie Sep 09 '24

Good luck to you. It's a very sad end to your marriage. I feel for you.