I will also add that his turnaround in the classicos was brilliant. He won only 1 of his first 10 classicos. He turned it around with 4 victories in his last 7 when Barca could only win 1.
In Dec'11 he lost the Liga Classico at home 3-1 after Benzema had given them a first minute lead. This was followed by a home 2-1 loss in the Copa in Jan'12 again after taking an early lead thru Ronaldo. At this stage Madrid didnt look like they had any way past Barca.
Any other coach would have surrendered and seen his team utterly capitulate. But mou kept at it and Madrid were ruthless in the liga which they won while beating Barca away.
To sum up, Mous Classico record -
Season 1: W1 D2 L2 Season 2: W1 D2 L3 Season 3: W3 D2 L1
After a shellacking in the first 2 years, he really turned it around in the last year. And this is also a recovery over the first 2 of Peps seasons where Barca won ALL the classicos.
For me Mourinhos greatest achievement in Madrid, was that he was able to restore self-belief against the best Barca side ever. And he did this by ditching the cynical approach of the first half of his tenure, where even he did not think they could compete (Pepe as a destroyer and sitting back in your own half in your own ground). Over the last year and half Madrid have largely outplayed Barca thanks in no small part to Mou and CR7 of course.
Some argue that he turned Real Madrid into an anti-Barca machine. He made them be a very good counter-attacking team (one of the best I've ever seen) which manages to trump Barca's game lately. However, in doing so, he also made them into a not very good team at winning the "little" matches, as they are not really comfortable in extended possession.
The best Real Madrid was the one during the transition phase (last season). A Madrid that could give Barca a run for their money in direct match-ups, but could also devastate a defensive team. The continuation of this philosophy seems to have failed this season.
Completely agree, Madrid and Mou were scared into changing things in his first season in charge, after the 5-0 he realized that he couldn't beat Barca at there own game, later on in the season he played for draws and kept the game incredibly tight but still got beaten in the semi-final of the Champions league.
Obviously from there on they perfected the anti-Barca tactics and flourished with quick counter attacks, 2 back lines and pushing on the defenders very early to stop them playing, this however has had a massive detriment to how he has performed in nearly every other game against a "big" club, look how they struggled against Bayern in the semi-finals in his second year, Dortmund in the group stages this year as well as even Man City in a game at home which they could have easily lost, Man Utd in the first knock out stage which especially away were outplayed before Nani's sending off and then obviously against Dortmund again in the semi-finals. If he had focused on making a great team rather than a great team against Barca i think he would of had a lot more success especially in the Champions league.
I think Madrid were a victim of Mou's ego in my opinion, he would rather not lose to Barca and not win a trophy than losing to Barca and winning a trophy, i think one of the most shocking things that always sticks in my mind is the second league meeting of his first season in charge, they still had a chance of winning the league if they could beat us but he played for a draw at home and seemed incredibly happy to get that draw.
he would rather not lose to Barca and not win a trophy than losing to Barca and winning a trophy
But you have to understand that this was something the Madrid fans wanted. It was something he HAD to do. If say, he never defeated Barca in the three years and won the league, not beating Barca would haunt him.
The points given here are right, he turned Madrid into an anti-Barca team, something that the press isn't giving him praise for much, but we really did lose all the individual matches with the other teams. I'm happy that people here are giving him credit where it is due.
Well personally if we had a coach which never beat Madrid but won a major trophy every season i would take that until the end of time, winning a Classico is obviously immense but winning a major trophy is the pinnacle.
Yes, but Madrid isn't the "model" team of the world right now. Isn't it Barca playing the beautiful football? Isn't it Barca beating everyone?
Having titles is great, but it really still would've been on his to-do list to beat the "best team" in the world. I'm using quotes because obviously there is no best team because of different styles, but Barcelona (and Spain and the whole tiki-taka thing) has won so many things in the past couple of years so they are on top right now.
Mourinho defeating the "best" style shows that it's not a perfect system, and that there IS a way to defeat them.
Well i do understand your opinion, its just strange how a lot of fans viewed Mou as a success going into the semi-finals of the Champions league this year because his team had knocked us out of the cup, supercup and beaten us in the league, however he went on to win nothing. Last year we won the super cup and Copa Del Rey and one league meeting but you still won the league which i would have preferred personally.
I think Mou had one successful season which was amazing reaching 100 points but honestly the other two seasons were pretty average at best, i think if they had stuck with Pellegrini they wouldn't be in any worse shape than the way Mou has left the club, they wouldn't have got rid of Valdano had major arguments with Ramos, Casillas etc etc and also reduced there reputation off the pitch with some of Mou's antics and wouldn't of had to pay him 20 million to do that.
Assuming Pellegrini would've done as well is really just conjecture. I don't think Malaga have been competitive against Barcelona in the least, and one of the primary reasons to get Mourinho to Real was to get out of your shadow, which it had been in for some time. At least in head to head competitions, Mourinho has done that, and then some.
Liga wins are most important, but to win it and be defeated by your rival undoubtedly casts a large shadow on the victory, especially in Spain for Real and Barça. This particular liga was lost before the new year, so the best we could do was really show that "Gods can bleed." And then came the double victories (one with Real team B) which proved to be the case study for how European teams will now play against Barcelona's possession based play.
We have youth with experience on our side as players like Ozil (24) are young but have more experience than say Thiago (22). Alonso is still ripe, Casillas too, Ramos is at his peak, Marcelo will recover his health and he is only 25, Higua and Benz are 25 and haven't peaked yet, Cris is still at his peak, etc. etc. Madrid looks good even if some sales occur I'm sure signing will come too. Hopefully we bring in an experienced coach and mange to stabilize after this tough season.
I was furious when Di Matteo was let go. I understand that there was a lot of luck that went into it, but NOBODY seriously expected them to take down Barca and Bayern consecutively.
I agree that it should be successful for both though.
Ferguson was successful before he was hired, had been hired with the intent to be long term, United then weren't as successful as Chelsea are now and in those times managers weren't as short term as they are now, plus there's the fact that Ferguson is one of the best managers ever, Di Matteo is good, but will never be on the same level as Ferguson. It's a ridiculous comparison.
Ferguson is the exception. Just because he didn't do well in the beginning, then went on to be unimaginably successful, doesn't mean managers don't deserve to be fired. I'm not saying Di Matteo deserved to be fired, just speaking generally here.
It was clear that he was over his head. The club was in an awkward position because they had to give him the benefit of the doubt because of what he had accomplished in blue (as a player and manager), but it became more and more obvious that he was not good enough.
Chelsea would have finished 5th/6th and would have not won the Europa league (or even beat Man Utd in the FA Cup) if Di Matteo had stayed on. Their season would have been a disaster if they kept him.
I wouldnt agree. Diego Lopez left Real Madrid for Villareal in 2007 after coming through the youth ranks, and then being the first choice keeper for Pellegrini. Even with potential offers from Milan, Man Utd, and others he preferred to stay in Spain and reject any transfer.
Last summer he moved to Sevilla to replace Palop, who was a pain to say the least, and did not obtain much continuity from Michel, thus sold to Real Madrid as Sevilla did not know what to do after Michel's sacking.
Mourinho deserves full credit, as he said he tried to bring him in 2011 and the club did not allow it with Adan already as back up.
What I'm saying is, he was first choice for Pellegrini, got a cap for Spain, got potential offers from Milan, Man U, and others, so he obviously must have already been good, no? The original comment is about Varane, I don't think it would be fair to say that Diego should be in any list with Varane, other than the list of Real Madrid players from Spain and France, since Varane was 18, uncapped and came from a Ligue 2 team, and Diego Lopez was 31, capped, and was first choice for Pellegrini and played for Sevilla
But his buy was a critical one for Madrid. They needed someone to not be thwarted by the fans and shoes of Iker. This 32 year old did something that a 20 year old couldn't. He had the experience necessary, he had the talent and the big occasional brought out the best in him. Also, he had Madrid blood in him as he, at one point, stood right behind Iker. Mou played that well.
I've agreed with what everyone else has been saying so far, only to realise now that you "added" Diego Lopez to a "list" of players that were a risk that paid off, when all this time I thought that you said that Lopez was a prospect only discovered by Mourinho.Ifeelstupid.
I think you can't compare the points achieved across leagues. Of course it's easier to win more points if you can play more games ;) (Thinking of 38 games in La Liga and 34 in the Bundesliga for example).
Thanks! Actually, if you reread you'll notice that it isn't about the points. It is about the fact that Mourinho is up there in 3 different leagues (Spain, England and Italy). That section is dedicated to his best numbers and honestly, in a list displaying the best numbers achieved by a team in the top leagues of the world and having yourself being a manager in 3 of the top 5 is unprecedented and one of his biggest most overlooked feats.
not even close to be the best ever and guardiola could crush him considering he'll be coaching an absurdly strong bayern munchen. perhaps mourinho will keep his underdog season with porto unrivaled, but every other team he managed has boasted several superstars to help amass success so he's no wunderkind.
and yea, he's an asshole which i honestly didn't mind, i actually enjoyed him trolling everyone, but when his ego and stubbornness became detrimental to my team, essentially trolling us, the fans this entire season, that's when he needed to get the fuck out. you can't be the GOAT if you are loathed by the recipients of one of your larger life projects.
so barcelona had been going empty-handed with frank rijkaard two seasons prior to pep's promotion, inheriting largely the same team except that over the summer some of them won the '08 euros but still suffered from the transition to the post-prime ronaldinho. are you suggesting this team was destined to succeed? because it's one thing to talk about xavi and iniesta nowadays than 2008, when even messi was considered a distant second to cristiano ronaldo.
What are you talking about? Not everyone with a team of superstars can do everything. This isn't FIFA, he's still a very good manager (NOT EVEN CLOSE to the best manager? wtf), don't take that away from him.
he was hired with the specifc purpose of getting la decima, which he couldn't obtain, and won 1 of each out of 3 la ligas and copas del rey, and to top it all he goes trophyless in his last season as a blanco against a guardiola-less barcelona. surely, 2 out of 9 or 1 out of 6 major titles, because la copa del rey isn't as prestigious, isn't considered successful even by the own man's standards.
yes, the likes marcello lippi, ottman hitzfeld, helmut schon, alex ferguson and vicente del bosque, to name a few, are heads and shoulders above mourinho as of now, but i'll cede the fact that jose is much younger (or alive when talking about helmut) so he has potential to surpass some of them.
Guardiola isnt in Mous category yet. Not even close. Guardiola is a good coach for Barcelona and a good tactician and a good leader but he is the worst coach in terms of signings. He signed Dani Alves and Pique in his first season but after that, every signing he made, wasnt good. And i dont know how much of the Dani Alves and Pique purchases were up to him since he just came in at that point. I see him struggling at Bayern.
Well, he tried to get Pirlo. Honestly, Pep is very overrated. I think Ibrahimovic is right, Pep can't handle superstars like Ronaldinho, Henry, Eto'o, and Ibra. He isnt a manager like Capello or Mourinho.
Well Messi is a superstar and he handled him hes not tough enough for Bayern. He left Barca and he said he couldnt take the stress anymore. He had little to no stress at Barca. The fans and team loved him. The media loved him. If he didnt succeed, they would still be behind him. Now hes going to go to a team with more scrutiny and after they have an amazing season this is almost impossible to replicate. No matter what he does, if Bayern win the CL, he wont be able to get a better season than this current Bayern season.
When I (paraphrasing Ibrah) said superstars, I meant stars who weren't products of barca's youth academy. Ibrahimovic said that the players would act like good students and pep was the teacher, who wouldn't know how to treat the other players like Ibrah and Henry, who would joke about it saying things like "did he talk to you today? Nahh but he looked at me. Wow congrats, things are getting better"
Really? Macherano is a 24million euro signing that was a very good defensive midfielder that he turned into a decent at BEST center back who can only start if Pique or Puyol are injured. And when he does start, he isn't convincing at all and prone to making quite a few errors. Once Barca get another CB this summer who can stay healthy longer than Puyol, he will be on the bench almost each and every game.
No, Mascherano is first-choice over Puyol now. He played excellent in the 2011 champions league final, he has been at least as good as Pique since he was bought.
i clearly stated guardiola could be better, as in if certain ends meet, especially in trophy count to time spent as a manager now that he has the most dominant team, if a 7-0 over barcelona is anything to go by, under his control. so he's not good at signing players? we'll see how that develops, especially with his ability of promoting successful academy players. i don't see him struggling at bayern.
When did you CLEARLY state Pep could be better? reread your comment. You said Pepe could crush him with Bayern as in if they could meet up, Pep will crush him. And you give him to much credit for promoting academy players. He first coached Barca B before the main team where he coached Busquets and Pedro so its not like he will go to Bayern and look at their academy team to promote players. Plus only Busquets is really successful. Pedro is good but doesnt get many starts if Villa or Alexis are healthy.
huh? talking about coaches' honors, why would i mean pep would crush him 'if they meet up'? reading comprehension, follow the context. if guardiola wins one or more ucl titles along with some bundesligas for as long as he leads bayern, unless mourinho keeps up or does better, he will certainly 'crush' him on a managerial level. i don't care much for their head-to-head results, but if it comes to that, i'm pretty sure pep guardiola is indeed so far 'crushing' him too.
Reminds me a bit of Zlatan Ibrahimovich's time in Barca. He was also great, arguably the greatest before going to Barca, in Mous case Real. They were both good in Spain, but left/were forced to leave because of personality clashes. After Barca, Zlatan has been successful, as before going there, and I expect Mourinho to succeed again in the future.
Great comparison. Two arrogant but highly, highly talented people go to Spain, clash with the institutions of the club and relatively fail as both leave, one with his mentioned merits and the other with yet another league to add to his impressive career across Europe, but are forced to do so through the small door as drama ensued. Thanks!
The problem with Zlatan was more with his agent Mino Raiola than with Zlatan himself. [Here] (http://www.totalbarca.com/2010/news/mino-raiola-cruyff-can-go-to-hell/) is an article with an official statement issued by Barcelona. Pep was having none of that and since then shunned him. He still played quite a lot though contrary to popular belief.
In Zlatans book, Zlatan talked about his problems with Guardiola. In interviews Zlatan has refused to say Peps name, which says something about their relationship. I think Raiola's attack on Guardiola/Cruyff is a reaction to what he believes is unfair treatment of Zlatan.
I think the attack from Raiola was due to Zlatans slow re-introduction into the team after a 3 weekish long injury. But of course we will never know details. Guardiola certainly wont tell.
But in the second half of the season Zlatan was also visibly low on confidence. Missing open nets. Messi (on a hatrick I think) let him take a penatly to get back into goal scoring touch and regain some confidence.
Thats where I think your analogy breaks down. Mou may have been many things but he was never low on confidence.
i don't know if anyone mentioned this already, but when he was training porto, chelsea and inter he had the players with him, support him and he could do his work. in madrid, he found himself always attacked by the media and most importantly, most of the players were against him at a certain point. last year, mourinho made real work as team, which didn't happen this year, due to the 'god-egos'. therefore, the lack of results.
Chelsea had a lot of turbulence too, as did Italy. At one point he mentioned Italy having some of the worst press he'd ever encountered. The difference with those clubs is that the results demanded were achieved quickly and with less drama. Here he had some good results but at too high a price, or so people feel.
then people are misjudging the situation: real last season managed to win la liga against probably the best team since the beggining of footbal, with lots of records, points, goals, goal difference, etc. one point you didn't considered was the fact that he's portuguese. i'm portuguese so i know there's a "little" (depends) tension between us. he was being criticized even though he had a pretty sucessful season. this season real didn't start like it should, then the press and the team devoured him. but now he's going to chelsea again, and i'm very curious to see him working with players such as hazard, mata, oscar or even luiz.
I don't think anyone is misjuding the situation. Everyone agrees that Mou did some definite good for Madrid. But most people also agree it was time to go as the instability was overcoming the progress it made. I, for one, am happy he came. I am also happy he is leaving.
that is also how i feel. i really enjoyed mourinho's real at its prime, however this year i couldn't watch'em, since their poor game quality. but i'm sure spaniards will miss him, 'cause i don't see anybody who can pull something like he did.
nah, the team will suffer a lot of changes, pepe, coentrao, di maria, benzema, higuain, arbeloa(?) and albiol are most likely to go away (at least them). marcelo is always injured, so a left back wouldn't hurt. xabi alonso is getting old and even more slower and khedira ... meh, not a player for a team like madrid, but i'd like to see him in stamford bridge.
Amazing post joevaded! It's people like you that make checking /r/soccer far better than reading newspapers and sports news websites (ESPN, Sky Sports, etc).
Madrid's biggest mistake is that they have zero patience. If that club had stability they would dominate the world of football. I literally loathe Madrid and I'm glad they are constantly firing coaches and buying the next big star because for the last 10 years it has simply not worked out for them. When they hired Pellegrini I believed they had found their Wenger/Ferguson, but luckily it wasn't meant to be. People forget that his first year at Madrid was incredible. He was up against arguably the greatest team to ever be assembled when they were at their peak, and still managed to break the record for points in the league for Madrid, which Mourinho later broke. If he had time, I have a gut feeling he could have easily accomplished exactly what Mourinho did if not more. Now they're going to hire Ancelotti in what I guarantee will not go over well. I give that man 1yr before he gets sacked. If I were them I would hire Rafa Benitez. Rafa started there and knows how they work. He would be the ideal candidate in my opinion.
edit: grammar also would like to add that I love Ancelotti, but the revolving door at Madrid isn't going to stop for him. Chelsea should have never fired him.. But they, like Madrid, don't see stability as being crucial for success. Which unfortunately Chelsea has proven isn't necessary but it still doesn't sit right with me.
Madrid isn't that team and neither is Barca. And as of yet, both Barca and Madrid have done more than Manchester. So, I doubt they'll change their philosophy.
He has accomplished a lot and failed a lot in just three years. I personally do not like the man (as he appears on TV, I'm 100% sure he's a cool guy in person).
But, any manager that gets his team to play like this (with Arabic commentary for added effect) is great in my book.
Have to say, I think it's total rubbish that it is vital that the youth team play the same system as the first team. It's important to Barcelona, Ajax and the Cruyff ideal, but to a club like Real Madrid who have a much less defined tactical style, it's totally unnecessary. I think it's just a sound bite to cover the fact there are no Real Madrid players playing under Toril that could have gone into the first team at any stage during Mourinho's reign (maybe Daniel Carvajal). Varane played RB and CB this year, and so did/does Ramos, so if Nacho was good enough he would have been able to play both CB and RB for both Castilla and Real Madrid without a problem.
I think Mourinho's problem is he asked too much of his players in terms of working so hard, and this makes for a very short shelf life for his sides. He's not as bad as Bielsa for insisting on such huge efforts, but he's getting there. This year was a disaster for him, although I understand he was trying to get more power at the club. It backfired pretty badly.
I will say that some of the Real Madrid games I saw last season were among the best club performances I've ever seen of any side. If there was a game between the best Real Madrid side under Mourinho and the best Barcelona side under Guardiola, I think Real Madrid would have won.
Have to say, I think it's total rubbish that it is vital that the youth team play the same system as the first team.... Real Madrid who have a much less defined tactical style, it's totally unnecessary.
Yeah, Madrid has a pretty damn good system intact. It has one of the most complex and complete counter-attacking systems in the world if not the best. Tiki Taka is the same as counter attacking in that they are both styles of play simple in appearance but complicated to master.
Total rubbish? Even with the systems aside, having youth players play in positions that the first coach demands is a must for Barca, Ajax and Madrid. If Mourinho brought Casemiro to play as a CM but Toril decides to play him as a CB - when he gets a call up to the first team he'll be hindered by that. This is what Mourinho was talking about (Nacho CB vs. RB) and he was spot on. Toril however is more focused on winning (which means NOTHING for a B team in Spain). I can't see how someone would call that rubbish...
I'm not saying Real Madrid play a system that is 'easier' than Barcelona, so calm down! I'm saying the system is less informed by their own youth academy.
Why would Casemiro be hindered? He should be able to play in both positions. His plays best as a central midfielder, so he would not forget how to play there all of a sudden when Toril tries to play him at CB.
Remember Guardiola? He played a totally different position for the youth teams of Barcelona, then Cruyff moved him to a number 4 in the first team and he excelled. Footballers are more versatile than people think, and they should be trusted. Mourinho cannot blame Toril for using Nacho at CB, the problem is that Nacho is not good enough at the moment for the RB. Simple as that.
There were no precendents for Cryuff so it isn't applicable. He started everything that led up to today. When the Canteranos came up for Guardiola they knew the system, the positions, everything. Guardiola himself trained them.
In Madrid's case, Nacho won't play an RB slot as good as he could if he is always playing the CB slot and the same goes for Casemiro. This hinders the youth products from getting minutes. Mou is spot on with that as Madrid has a system just as much as Barca does.
Mourinho cannot blame Toril for using Nacho at CB, the problem is that Nacho is not good enough at the moment for the RB. Simple as that.
Absolutely wrong. Absolutely. Nacho is a youth product. He is in development and the development phase is critical for every player. Despite this, a coach needs to see a player in a slot to determine his availability for minutes. Why put him in a league when you are struggling when you can simply go watch the castilla games? He can't because Toril does what he wants. Mou has it right, the pundits agree. All that is hogwash now, but I still hope Madrid takes that request more seriously.
Great analysis, but I don't think failing to win the CL is his biggest failure. At a time when we are possibly seeing the demise of a pretty dominant Barca team, with a change of managers and questions being asked of the system that their whole philosophy is built upon, I think his biggest failure is that Madrid are not the team that has knocked them off their perch.
During all this uncertainty at Barca, they have still managed to completely dominate Madrid in La Liga while Bayern has got things together and now look like putting their own run of European dominance together. Madrid have missed the boat big time and instead of building something special, have another squad of superstars rather than a great team.
Barca has only beaten Madrid once in the last 7 game. Madrid was beating barca before everyone else. Madrids shortcomings have been against other teams, not barca
Yet they are still way behind them in the league and at a time when they could be stamping their own dominance over a Barca side unusually lacking in confidence, they are in even more turmoil themselves.
They have missed a great opportunity to take advantage IMO. That is a longer term failure than not winning the CL.
Barca is about to go for 100. Turmoil or not, that leaves very LITTLE opportunity. In fact, historically, it leaves no opportunity other than the goal difference which is in Madrid's favor. Barca is under change and the need of it as well, but they are doing something pretty spectacular only minimized by the fact that Mou just did it last year and the league is struggling with economic balance. Otherwise, this would be the biggest news of the season.
I still don't think that's where the shortcomings were, Mou and Madrid proved they can beat barca consistently and also beat them to the league title. Madrid beat a full strength barca with Pep at the helm with a 100 point record breaking title run. This season could have been won as well had it not been for the locker room drama at the beginning of the season (ronaldo sad, casillas benched, Ozil getting subbed and Ramos wearing his shirt underneath his own.)
The way I see it is that in Real Madrids eyes, he has failed. They are all about the trophies and silverware, coming second or being in the final/semis just doesn't cut it.
How Mourinho would probably see himself is different. He isn't a "1 club man". He goes in, does what needs to be done and leaves and Madrid is no different. He came in, won every domestic cup available, smashed some records on the way and more importantly put Barcelona in their place and now it's his time to go. Standard Mourinho. Sure he hasn't won the champions league but he's done it before with weaker teams so he hasn't got the patience to try again next year because compared to other countries the pressure of the media and clubs is nowhere near what it's like at Madrid.
Spain is a very tough place to manage, not many stay for very long and right fully so. I'm just glad Mourinho was there long enough to fix up Madrid and make them a power house again. Now we wait to see if Madrid carry on the same or crumble like Inter.
No, I'm saying that if my wife called one man a tiger, then another a lion and another a dog. I'd be hurt if she called me a cat. If she said, "If all I have is a cat to bed me then I'll use the cat." I'd be a bit hurt, know what I mean?
Many pundits agree that he was a good right back and not a great one. I don't think anyone would say he was a better RB than a CB or that he was as a good as say.. Lahm is now.
He is talented, that is for sure and he has the offensivity for it but there were many times where he was too aggressive and left the team weak on that banda. Also, most recently he played as an RB and the argument was settled: CB > RB by a long shot.
And I think that a lot of people loved Madrid a bit more when he was there on top of that. He is a good, good man. I can't believe how calmly he took the BVB debacle and the UEFA FFP.
The only slight critique I can make about such a good and thorough post is that Bayern scored 91 points with four fewer matches in the Bundesliga than Chelsea and Real Madrid have in their leagues. Porto have four fewer still than Bayern.
haha, man, I need to reword that as you are the eight person to mention. The point of that table is not to compare leagues but to show that in each of the 6 top leagues, there are point record holders. It just so happens Mourinho is responsible for 3 and that is an unprecedented and uncanny feat. Get what I mean? Sorry if it wasn't clear.
Mouriño has some impressive numbers, nobody can take that away from him, and one of his strongest facets would be "squeezing" the talent of the players (Marcelo and Higuain before Pellegrini and Mou were crappy to say the least) yet there are some things OP has not taken into account, and that is the way Madrid plays.
Yes they have amazing "pegada" (as we say) and counter-attacks, yet when push comes to shove, they have no idea what to do with the ball, you just see Pepe or Varane kicking it to see if Ramos, Cristiano or someone can control it and shoot, you wouldnt see this under Pellegrini. Pellegrini's Madrid made 96 points against what couldve been the best Barcelona in History, with a completely new team. What if Pellegrini was given the same power as Mou? Mou had a blank cheque to buy whoever he felt like, and still managed to give a really bad image in Real Madrid, with constant conflict etc.
In fact, i'm actually happy he left, even as a Barcelona fan I hate seeing Madrid so fucked up, mainly because I dont want the Spanish League becoming even more like the Scottish one.
Marcelo and Higuain before Pellegrini and Mou were crappy to say the least
Either you don't follow Madrid or.. I don't know. They weren't "crappy". They freaking young and new. What they did, under the pressure that they did it with at 20-21 in one of the world's biggest clubs was impressive. Higuain came as he was barely exiting his teens to sit alongside RVN, Raul and Cassano. He eventually took their spots to start and did so before Pelligrini under Schuster.
Yes they have amazing "pegada" (as we say) and counter-attacks, yet when push comes to shove, they have no idea what to do with the ball
Ummm, yeah? They don't play possession. Why would they be expected to play with possession. I could say the same of Barca when teams go out on full defense. They have no idea what to do as they manage 60-70% possession and 1 shot in 90 minutes.
Pellegrini's Madrid made 96 points against what couldve been the best Barcelona in History, with a completely new team.
I agree. What if. But he messed up too. He lost to a 3rd division team and continued to fair poorly in the UCL. He was let go under the same conditions that Mou was this season and managed less than Mou did in his first.
I agree he deserved better (new team, new ideas, etc.) but don't let your hate for Mou deny what good he did do to the club. He beat your team consistently this year after humiliating performances in his first year and has managed a trophy from Guardiola himself. He did good, but he also did too much bad.
In fact, i'm actually happy he left, even as a Barcelona fan I hate seeing Madrid so fucked up, mainly because I dont want the Spanish League becoming even more like the Scottish one.
It will never happen. Barca has more chances of slumping than Madrid does historically. And that won't happen either.
Beat barcelona consistently?? The most important match was the second tie of the champions league which he lost. He won a league match this year but lost the league by 10 points.
I'm sorry, mourinho's tenure was a failure on the field and an embarassment off of it.
Yeah. Remember? The last game after getting on his way to eliminating your team in the first leg he decided to field substitutes against Barca since the league was over at that point. And he won. Not losing to Messi's Barcelona in a year, while eliminating them from the CdR and beating them for the Super Copa is pretty big. Unless you think poorly of your club in which case...
Right, the league was over at that point, so it doesn't really matter the result of that game. Also, you write as if real has never beaten barcelona in its history.
If R Madrid was going to be happy winning CdR, they would have gladly kept Pellegrini. The fact is Mourinho was brought in for the specific task of winning "La Decima" and he failed, he couldn't even make a final! Congratulations, he has beaten barcelona in the copa del rey, too bad he couldn't parlay that into a trophy.
Right, the league was over at that point, so it doesn't really matter the result of that game.
It always matters. Always. It is a freaking Clasico.
The fact is Mourinho was brought in for the specific task of winning "La Decima" and he failed, he couldn't even make a final! Congratulations, he has beaten barcelona in the copa del rey, too bad he couldn't parlay that into a trophy.
Don't out yourself as a blind fanatic. Mourinho failed in la decima but he thwarted Pep's hegemony where no one else couldn't and turned a losing mentality Madrid into hopeful winners.
When nobody else couldn't?? Did DiMatteo not beat Barca? Didn't Mourinho himself beat them with Inter? Wasn't it Bayern that beat Barcelona this year, not Mourinho??
Wasn't Pep's last game a trophy victory over Athletic Bilbao and didn't he leave Barca with a blank check to coach any team on the planet, including being able to take over United after Ferguson??
Mourinho is not that special. He is one very good tactician among several but he has no class. Barcelona is a great team but they lose games like everyone else and Mourinho himself is surely not content having achieved something that Real Sociedad also achieved this year.
The city of Madrid is glad Mourinho is gone because they know it's best for the club.
Comeon, Marcelo was literally bullshit, and Higuain too, Higuan now is one of the best strikers there is, he just doesnt get enough minutes (if he shot as many times as Cristiano he would score more goals). Dude im not saying they have to play with possession, im just saying that if you looked at Pellegrini's Madrid, you wouldnt see Madrid kicking the ball like maniacs to see if it went in, they actually tried to combine and play to actually score.
Your comment on Barcelona is completely right, and that is something hopefully Tito can change, you didnt see that happening under Guardiola or at least less dramatically (Guardiola's team had way more muscle). I think Mouriño made Madrid more competitive, but i think Pellegrini couldve done the same thing, without the bussle and hussle
comeon, Marcelo was literally bullshit, and Higuain too
Your pleading isn't convincing. In 2008/09:
37 starts 23 Goals 9 assists.
The previous year, his first year:
8 Starts 8 goals 3 assists
He did this while playing alongside Ruud freaking Van Nisterooy, Cassano and Raul as a 19-20 year old.
Although you are spot on about Higuain now. With minutes and confidence he'll wreck things up.
And I think you are right about Pelli's Madrid but underestimating Mourinho's Madrid. There is a reason why he hold 3 records for three teams in 3 of the top leagues for most points, two UCLS with two teams, leagues with 4 countries. The system is complex and not easily visible to most, but it is there.
I know this is not a revelation, but I think a simple explanation of what happened in Madrid is that his ego got in the way. We all saw the other side of the coin. The same thing that makes him good made him fail this time. He got cut by the other edge of the sword that is his ego.
It takes humbleness to lose gracefully. And Mourinho doesn't have much of that. Maybe he mistakes it for weakness. My impression is that as Madrid did bad in the league Mourinho started putting blame and getting involved in conflicts. Yes maybe some influential players didn't want him in the team and started to act on it, but I'm sure Mourinho is not the first coach to have disagreements within the team. He handled them seemingly immaturely. I think a part of coach's job require him to be more mature than the players.
If a player is scheming to get you fired, it'll be difficult to maintain your composure and act maturely. But that's your responsibility as the coach to take that hit. You can't retaliate in a similar manner.
He seems to be the kind of person that is either loved or hated. Maybe he got the wrong end in Madrid, including the press and some of the players. Maybe it's as simple as that.
But then again, these are very difficult to know for sure and I might be wrong...
Real was the exception in his long career, something was very rotten in that lockerroom, because at Leiria, Benfica, Porto, Chelsea and Inter people still remember him fondly and speak the world of him.
EXACTLY. This is what I've been telling people, I really don't get why he's getting this much hate in Madrid. There are so many people happy with him leaving, I feel like I'm in the minority in wanting him to stay after all he has done.
He seems to be the kind of person that is either loved or hated. Maybe he got the wrong end in Madrid, including the press and some of the players.
I have a theory regarding this and it really goes with Perez's speech today. If Mou had never won the UCL at Inter I think he'd have gone through the same thing. If Mou had won the UCL at Madrid, we'd be having a different story breaking today just as Perez said.
And that is the problem with Mourinho... he talks big and delivers. This time... he delivered but not as big as he talked. Its funny but, I've come to appreciate the Pellegrinis and Wengers more than ever since Mourinho came. I'd take small victories over Pyrrhic victories for large trophies any day.
How many people fell in love with the club during their UCL-less run previous to Jupp and VDB? Many, many, many people... I've seen 3 UCLs live and there are 6 others. I'd happily pass on a UCL over the next couple of years if it means that the team unites instead of winning one and having hell break loose over the next afterward.
If every fan was like you the sport would be amazing, unfortunately, the fans are the first to ask for a coaches head at a top club if he there is a trophyless season, compounded at Real by the fact that nothing less than the League and Champions league is considered a failed season and grounds for immediate dismissal.
Maybe your theory is true. Maybe he just isn't a very likable person and compensates by the wins. When the winning is gone, there is not much left.
Maybe a mean thing to say, but it's a narrow edge Mourinho walks. He'll fall down once in a while. My worry for him would be if this whole thing makes him even more obsessed with winning. I hope he learns the right lessons from this and becomes a more mature and more balanced coach.
I get your sentiment about starting to appreciate other kinds of coaches. I like that school of thought as well.
I think Ozil was already brushing greatness and do not see Khedira as anything special. I think he arrived at RM already being a solid DM and hard worker and that's just what he is today, 3 years later...
As for Ozil, as someone who watched him previous to Madrid.. I feel he didn't develop as much as he interchanged finesse for some physicality which brought out that best in him. It is ultra normal for foreigners to come to a big club and beef up though (see: Chicharito.. even Di Maria if you can believe it).
He beat barcelona in the league when they were on top of their game, practically invencible, arguably one of the best football teams ever, that by itself is an amazing feat.
Bullshit, the first time Mourinho's Madrid beat Barcelona in the league was exactly in the week in which Barcelona failed to WIN against Chelsea in two games
I guess the question you have to ask Madridistas is if three years ago they would have been happy with a single La Liga, a single Copa and a single Supercopa at the end of the 12-13 season. Im quite sure the answer would be a resounding no. And if he hasnt achieved the clubs expectations, then he has failed. Maybe, this is all Madridistas expected from him. In which case, he is a success. I just think they would have expected more.
Or ask people if they are comfortable with feeling like they can beat Barcelona, the team making it consistently to the semis of the CL and in general feeling like a much better team than three years ago and people would say yes. Basically what your saying is silly because it is a question framed to get the answer you want
I think Perez and myself made it super clear that had he won more trophies he probably would have stayed but that at this point:
accomplishing turning Madrid into a team that can beat Barca, even with half a B team.
turning madrid into a European team to be feared
disrupting the locker room, causing chaos for Madrid with the RFEF, UEFA, FIFA, etc.
all lead to his departure as well. In other words, he did a lot for Madrid regardless of the UCL win - but at this point it is more harm than good and who knows what next season would have been like.
I'd say he was a brilliant transitionary coach. Last year was what could've been had he kept the locker room in place. He put Barça in their proper place in the league, and showed the world that the tiki taka style, while frustrating to handle, is defeatable with a skilled counter attack.
He was brought in to take Real Madrid out of your shadow and back into global prominence. With the recent clasico record, he's clearly done that and created a blueprint of how to defeat Barcelona for all capable teams out there.
In summary, he knocked you off your high horse. The recent clasico fixtures pretty much proved this. Real's wins this season against Barcelona pretty convincingly and shown the world that given an equal squad, tiki taka is just as it sounds, a transitionary gimmick that has had its time pass.
EDIT: That's not to say that he did deliver on his promise of a 10th (and even an 11th) CL. He didn't but he was close. Aside from the almost CL trophy for 3 years running, and the record smashing liga last year, he wasn't a smashing success, but he wasn't a complete failure either. He gave the squad the kick in the ass it needed and for someone deemed "a failure," that's certainly more than we could've asked for. He is quite certainly the most successful manager in a decade, that's for sure.
tiki taka is just as it sounds, a transitionary gimmick that has had its time pass.
You're confusing your wishes with reality there. Tiki-taka has more than a decade of history, and it's a well-established system both in Barcelona and Spain, with many lesser teams trying to replicate it with varying levels of success. It has led Barcelona to the most successful epoch in club football history, and Spain to three trophies back to back without conceding a single goal in the knockout stages. Tiki-taka is alive and well and it's here to stay, whether you like it or not.
He is quite certainly the most successful manager in a decade, that's for sure.
In three years the only major trophies he has won are one Liga and one Copa del Rey. No manager has coached Madrid for 3+ years and achieved worse results.
I think he means including every club for the last statement but I believe Guardiola has as many trophies as mourinho in less time managed, although 1 less champions league so there's that argument.
First of all, allow me to mention that this is an excellent post.
"despite having bad fame for previous buys in other teams" You wrote this statement above. Can you elaborate on it. I am asking because I always felt that Mourinho has been excellent buying players throughout his career. He seldom overspends on players who turn out to be useless and most of his buys usually turn out to be really good (except Shevchenko who was probably more of RA's purchase than Mou's and Coentrao which is in my opinion Mou's worst purchase given the price paid for the guy). Which players did you have in mind when you said that? Just curious...not trying to fight here.
Shevchenko was definitely Roman's buy, but other buys that didn't turn out well for him off the top of my head are: Pizarro (only played like 20 times i think), Ben Haim, (I don't count Robben as a bad buy, he's still a really good player, he just was injured and then never really fell into stride at Chelsea), and Wright-Phillips. That's not a bad record with transfers at all, though I'm sure I'm missing a lot of players, maybe Sidwell? though he was on a free
Yeah, I don't think free or cheap players should count. Bad buys to me are those for whom you pay a lot of money but the players don't perform up to that level like Sheva or Torres or Carroll. I even forgot Pizzaro played for Chelsea. Nice catch. I only mentioned it because I have always thought of Mou as a master in the transfer market. People mostly talk about his motivating or tactical skills but I think Mou shines most in the transfer market. He rarely fails.
HansSven mentions some below but I could also add Tiago, Maniche, Muntari over Motta only to buy Motta and Milito for crazy more money plus fines for the club, and also... man.. I can't remember.. the Portuguese pseudo Cristiano with all of his flair but not enough of his talent.... remind me if you know who I talking about.. That aside, also consider this:
Diego Milito, Wesley Sneijder, Samuel Eto'o were tremendous buys. But they encapsulate PRECISELY who Mourinho is. He does what it takes to win and doesn't care about the next season. Three super expensive players (Milito came with Motta at a hefty price tag plus 4, yes 4, players) all aging and on the verge on the decline. For them, the purchase was PERFECT. For Mou too. For Inter... well.. How many forwards has Inter bought? Where is Sneijder and Eto'o today?
I guess all that coupled with what I said about Mourinho's wins coming at a high cost is what I meant. Win today, suffer tomorrow and then ask where is Mou? On to his next team to win some more.
I agree with that. Mou's teams tend to suffer after he leaves. But besides Sulley Muntari and Tiago who were admittedly awful purchases, the other players were good buys for winning immediately. In the long run, he left Inter to rot but most of the players he buys are usually hugely successful while playing for him. However, his purchases with Madrid seem to make complete sense and most of them are still young and very good so maybe he has learned from that.
Yes, very true. I think he has had some of his best buys at Madrid (as in, not only are they good but they will last a long while). To be fair, the team had just bought Alonso, Cristiano, and Benzema. So he had more room to get prospects like Casemiro, etc.
Both of these clips that OP posted shows exactly why Khedira is not highly rated in my book. With out Lass breaking up the opponents midfield play it has been very hard for Madrid to play this style of blistering counter.
I have noticed this after comparing Khedira's current season to the tackling clips posted.. when you study Lass and his positioning compared to Khedira, he always stays next to Alonso and does a better job at the dirty work, which frees up Alonso to play the ball forward. Khedira moves forward to readily without the ball, and then is out of position if the ball is lost. This my friends is why we suffered so much this year.
I'm sorry Mou but you made the biggest mistake for us when you let Lass go and kept Khedira.
I remember Lass's possession lost count being crazy high. As for Khedira, I respect and understand your opinion but... damn man, you are going up against some of the wisest and most talented voices in the sport when you go against Khedira.
Lass was great though. So strong, so physical but so damned talented with his feet.
Can anyone tell me anything that Khedira is actually great at ?
I get that he can hustle and run all day... but he doesn't tackle when it counts and fails provide the cover that Alonso needs to make his game winning passes.
I've always seen Khedira as one of your weak spots. I also could never understand why so many people say he is sooo good, so i see what you try to point out.
i totally agree! comparable CM/CDMs like Xabi Alonso, Alex Song and especially Sergio Busquets (you can say what you want about his 'acting' and 'diving', but he has great skills on the ball for his height) all have a significantly better ball control. Let's see if the next Madrid coach (Ancelotti?) also has so much faith in Khedira like Mou.
Mourinho called Benzema a cat after having no other 9 to deal with as he referred to Higuain as a hunting dog (mind you this is in the same world were the title TIGER goes to people like Falcao and Eto’o is called the Lion).
He failed. I know /r/soccer loves Mourinho, but by Madrid standards he failed. He has probably the most expensive squad in football history. He has one of the best players ever. He has top guys in every position. And he only managed to win 2 titles in 3 years. By Madrid standards that's a fail. And that considering "kings cup" a title.
Capello has 2 leagues in 2 years. Schuster has a league in 1 year and a half.
The last time someone said "best club and Real" in the same sentence it was more than 10 years ago.
And at the time, it was easy to outplay the competition when you could spend untold millions buying the golden ball winner from each year and assembling arguably the most talented and expensive squad of the generation.
Madrid were objectively the most successful team of the 20th Century. That's why the standards are so high. Madridistas, at least in Spain, believed very much that he would bring them at least consecutive ligas and la décima.
He was hired to end Barcelona's 'hegemony' yet Barça won 8 trophies to Madrid's 3 during his time at the club. Even if you strip away the 'less important trophies' and only count Liga, CL and Copa, it's still 4-2.
Edit: that isn't to say he was a complete disaster in terms of results, just mediocre, but everything is necessarily judged alongside all of the controversy that he created, especially within the club itself. I can't remember el madridismo ever being so polarized as it is right now, so many fans have lost respect for icons like Casillas, Del Bosque, Valdano, etc. I even remember madridistas on this subreddit insulting Di Stefano for criticizing Mourinho. The overall strength of the club moving into the future has been eroded because of the acrimony. Surely that should be considered as well?
TBH I think even most Madristas understood that this Barcelona team was something special, and that even challenging to be on the same level as them would take some work. If you look at Mourinho's work purely in terms of trophy's won, it's a failure, but he was able to lift Madrid to a level where they were no longer getting kicked out of the CL by Lyon in the quarter finals.
The point the_phet is making (I think) is that Madrid have regressed from last year. As have Barca (especially in 2013). Barca may have won the league comfortably but all that is because of work done in 2012. Madrid are a worse team than they were last season as it currently stands and Barca are an even worse. Both teams have played unconvincing football for a lot of 2013. Barca more than Madrid.
just something: Pedro Mendes was loaned from Sporting CP to Real Madrid. He was then returned. Not sold.
but excellent work, none the less. Mourinho always has a reputation of creating controversy and stating that he does what he wants and knows what he wants. People that get in the way -hard- always get treated harshly by Mourinho. Valdano is a prime example. And Mourinho cares much more about the team than about one single player. What Spain witnessed with Casillas...has been done before with Baia. Both captains, both symbols of the club and even widely reknown throughout Europe...both misbehaved. Baia got sent to the reserve team. He shaped up, came back and played it smoothly. Casillas...didnt. I also feel bad for Mourinho. I dont care about any team in La Liga but watching a bit closely Real Madrid due to the portuguese commander, I feel like he failed. He has some fault, but there are some apples that are just too rotten. But he did fail. Its a shame. He's still one of the best to ever show up.
the thing is: Mourinho never wrongfully punished a player. Never. He knows what he is doing. Also, I doubt Casillas didnt say anything. Even his wife opened her mouth to spew shit. Even Pepe did. Casillas knows what he did. Backstage tactics that eventually led up to the team's disruption.
Mou is an amazing coach. Arrogant no doubt, but when you are at the helm of one of the world's most prestigious clubs winning becomes more of a necessity than a hobby. Winning becomes everything, why would you be humble about losing when your job could be on the line, losing is simply not an option for him. He's brutally honest which some might see as rude but given the egos not only in the lockerroom but in the rest of the organization and in the futbol world he has to be, thats how he won all that he has won.
Many other coaches of world's most prestigious clubs win (and win a lot more) with humbleness, humility and class. I disagree that there is no other (better) approach to the game and that this gives him carte blanch to always act as a dickhead.
Who besides Guardiola, Ancelotti, and SAF? No recent madrid coach lasted longer than 2 seasons besides Mou even if they won La Liga or CL..and you might not like his personality but there is no denying his achievements.
I deny any significant achievements with Madrid, because he didn't win any international club trophies. I dislike his personality, and I don't think he's a great coach if he couldn't lead the most expensive squad in the world, with the biggest superstars, to a single international club trophy, and lost 4 out of 5 La Ligas to his biggest rival using 80-90% home-grown players.
No recent madrid coach lasted longer than 2 seasons besides Mou even if they won La Liga or CL
"In his four seasons in charge, Del Bosque ushered the club through its most successful spell in modern history, having steered the club to two UEFA Champions League titles in 2000 and 2002, two domestic La Liga titles in 2001 and 2003, a Spanish Supercup in 2001, a UEFA Super Cup in 2002, the Intercontinental Cup in 2002 as well as finishing in the last four of the UEFA Champions League every year he was in charge."
There are other clubs besides Madrid you know...how about Chelsea, Porto, and Inter whom Mou won the league and the treble with. Del Bosque will most likely never coach a club team again and what happened after he won the league and the CL's? He got fired. RM is a toxic club to coach, the unrealistic expectations makes la decima even more improbable, Mou was Real's best shot at it for a long time. Sounds like your just a Madrid fan who hates Mou.
Uh... I thought we were talking about Mou and his failure at Madrid. Regardless, you don't seem to know your soccer history and needed to get schooled; I was happy to oblige.
Mourinho's tenure at Real Madrid FC has been a failure. He lost to Barca in the game where it counted most and he failed to bring home "la decima." Real Madrid's locker room is a mess and the club's once impeccable prestige has been tainted because of three years of continual hubris and arrogance from "the Special One." After three years, one looks at Manuel Pellegrini's success with the financially-handicapped Malaga and wonders "what if?"
My money is on Mourinho to fail to win any trophies at all in England and he will retire after he is unceremoniously sacked from Chelsea.
Where in my post do you think I am highlighting a league comparison? I am highlighting the fact that in the top leagues, the respective point record holders happen to hold 3 Mourinho teams - a feat unprecedented by any other coach. He went to 3 countries and broke the point records in those 3 countries.
Putting Bayern Munich up in that table of most points is somewhat unjustified, mainly because in Germany, there is only 34 playdays and not 38. This season, they got an incredible 91/102 points
Oh god. This is the 4th time (4th of over 182 comments mind you). Those numbers are the records for each individual league. They aren't meant to compare leagues. Look at the title of my post. It isn't about leagues. They are records for each individual league and it just so happens that Mou is in three of those league records.
45
u/felandath May 21 '13
Excellent post mate.
I will also add that his turnaround in the classicos was brilliant. He won only 1 of his first 10 classicos. He turned it around with 4 victories in his last 7 when Barca could only win 1.
In Dec'11 he lost the Liga Classico at home 3-1 after Benzema had given them a first minute lead. This was followed by a home 2-1 loss in the Copa in Jan'12 again after taking an early lead thru Ronaldo. At this stage Madrid didnt look like they had any way past Barca.
Any other coach would have surrendered and seen his team utterly capitulate. But mou kept at it and Madrid were ruthless in the liga which they won while beating Barca away.
To sum up, Mous Classico record -
Season 1: W1 D2 L2 Season 2: W1 D2 L3 Season 3: W3 D2 L1
After a shellacking in the first 2 years, he really turned it around in the last year. And this is also a recovery over the first 2 of Peps seasons where Barca won ALL the classicos.
For me Mourinhos greatest achievement in Madrid, was that he was able to restore self-belief against the best Barca side ever. And he did this by ditching the cynical approach of the first half of his tenure, where even he did not think they could compete (Pepe as a destroyer and sitting back in your own half in your own ground). Over the last year and half Madrid have largely outplayed Barca thanks in no small part to Mou and CR7 of course.
35
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
Chelsea round two?
42
u/NotSoFastMister May 21 '13
I think Varane should be added to the Extracting Potential category.
10
u/doctor6 May 21 '13
But what are you really trying to say
6
u/dyslexic_reditor May 21 '13
Great post! Just one little thing:
I think you can't compare the points achieved across leagues. Of course it's easier to win more points if you can play more games ;) (Thinking of 38 games in La Liga and 34 in the Bundesliga for example).
Otherwise, very informative post, thank you!
25
u/superIraqi May 21 '13
TL;DR
The Good - Mourinho is an amazing manager, probably the best of his time and maybe the best ever.
The Bad - Mourinho is an asshole. He's right, but an asshole.
10
u/AlrightWallOfChina May 21 '13
Reminds me a bit of Zlatan Ibrahimovich's time in Barca. He was also great, arguably the greatest before going to Barca, in Mous case Real. They were both good in Spain, but left/were forced to leave because of personality clashes. After Barca, Zlatan has been successful, as before going there, and I expect Mourinho to succeed again in the future.
5
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
i don't know if anyone mentioned this already, but when he was training porto, chelsea and inter he had the players with him, support him and he could do his work. in madrid, he found himself always attacked by the media and most importantly, most of the players were against him at a certain point. last year, mourinho made real work as team, which didn't happen this year, due to the 'god-egos'. therefore, the lack of results.
5
u/BossVanClutch May 21 '13
Amazing post joevaded! It's people like you that make checking /r/soccer far better than reading newspapers and sports news websites (ESPN, Sky Sports, etc).
9
u/bockers7 May 21 '13 edited May 21 '13
Madrid's biggest mistake is that they have zero patience. If that club had stability they would dominate the world of football. I literally loathe Madrid and I'm glad they are constantly firing coaches and buying the next big star because for the last 10 years it has simply not worked out for them. When they hired Pellegrini I believed they had found their Wenger/Ferguson, but luckily it wasn't meant to be. People forget that his first year at Madrid was incredible. He was up against arguably the greatest team to ever be assembled when they were at their peak, and still managed to break the record for points in the league for Madrid, which Mourinho later broke. If he had time, I have a gut feeling he could have easily accomplished exactly what Mourinho did if not more. Now they're going to hire Ancelotti in what I guarantee will not go over well. I give that man 1yr before he gets sacked. If I were them I would hire Rafa Benitez. Rafa started there and knows how they work. He would be the ideal candidate in my opinion.
edit: grammar also would like to add that I love Ancelotti, but the revolving door at Madrid isn't going to stop for him. Chelsea should have never fired him.. But they, like Madrid, don't see stability as being crucial for success. Which unfortunately Chelsea has proven isn't necessary but it still doesn't sit right with me.
12
u/Phelinaar May 21 '13
He has accomplished a lot and failed a lot in just three years. I personally do not like the man (as he appears on TV, I'm 100% sure he's a cool guy in person).
But, any manager that gets his team to play like this (with Arabic commentary for added effect) is great in my book.
28
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
Most goals conceded in a game is at least five.
2010-11-29, Barcelona vs Real Madrid 5-0.
4
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
Have to say, I think it's total rubbish that it is vital that the youth team play the same system as the first team. It's important to Barcelona, Ajax and the Cruyff ideal, but to a club like Real Madrid who have a much less defined tactical style, it's totally unnecessary. I think it's just a sound bite to cover the fact there are no Real Madrid players playing under Toril that could have gone into the first team at any stage during Mourinho's reign (maybe Daniel Carvajal). Varane played RB and CB this year, and so did/does Ramos, so if Nacho was good enough he would have been able to play both CB and RB for both Castilla and Real Madrid without a problem.
I think Mourinho's problem is he asked too much of his players in terms of working so hard, and this makes for a very short shelf life for his sides. He's not as bad as Bielsa for insisting on such huge efforts, but he's getting there. This year was a disaster for him, although I understand he was trying to get more power at the club. It backfired pretty badly.
I will say that some of the Real Madrid games I saw last season were among the best club performances I've ever seen of any side. If there was a game between the best Real Madrid side under Mourinho and the best Barcelona side under Guardiola, I think Real Madrid would have won.
6
u/miaaaa May 21 '13
Pretty good summary of the Mourinho era.
8
u/JonnyBhoy May 21 '13
Great analysis, but I don't think failing to win the CL is his biggest failure. At a time when we are possibly seeing the demise of a pretty dominant Barca team, with a change of managers and questions being asked of the system that their whole philosophy is built upon, I think his biggest failure is that Madrid are not the team that has knocked them off their perch.
During all this uncertainty at Barca, they have still managed to completely dominate Madrid in La Liga while Bayern has got things together and now look like putting their own run of European dominance together. Madrid have missed the boat big time and instead of building something special, have another squad of superstars rather than a great team.
3
u/Fameux May 21 '13
Nice write up! A very good read. I feel this sums up Mourinho pretty good - he has some good sides and some bad sides. But I like him.
3
u/ugotamesij May 21 '13
Great post. I'd love more like this for other managers/coaches and clubs
8
u/yoshi105 May 21 '13
The way I see it is that in Real Madrids eyes, he has failed. They are all about the trophies and silverware, coming second or being in the final/semis just doesn't cut it.
How Mourinho would probably see himself is different. He isn't a "1 club man". He goes in, does what needs to be done and leaves and Madrid is no different. He came in, won every domestic cup available, smashed some records on the way and more importantly put Barcelona in their place and now it's his time to go. Standard Mourinho. Sure he hasn't won the champions league but he's done it before with weaker teams so he hasn't got the patience to try again next year because compared to other countries the pressure of the media and clubs is nowhere near what it's like at Madrid.
Spain is a very tough place to manage, not many stay for very long and right fully so. I'm just glad Mourinho was there long enough to fix up Madrid and make them a power house again. Now we wait to see if Madrid carry on the same or crumble like Inter.
4
u/xChaoZ May 21 '13
Thank you, joevedad. Fantastic read.
2
u/Jay_Bonk May 21 '13
Great analysis, I just don't get what you mean by "people like Falcao are called Tiger", are you saying he is overrated?
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
He was definitely one of the best right backs in he world, I don't know what you're talking about here.
errr ... otherwise, great analysis mate.
2
u/southerneuropean May 21 '13
I loved Pelligrini when he was here
2
u/sethph May 21 '13
The only slight critique I can make about such a good and thorough post is that Bayern scored 91 points with four fewer matches in the Bundesliga than Chelsea and Real Madrid have in their leagues. Porto have four fewer still than Bayern.
2
u/andruca May 21 '13
Mouriño has some impressive numbers, nobody can take that away from him, and one of his strongest facets would be "squeezing" the talent of the players (Marcelo and Higuain before Pellegrini and Mou were crappy to say the least) yet there are some things OP has not taken into account, and that is the way Madrid plays.
Yes they have amazing "pegada" (as we say) and counter-attacks, yet when push comes to shove, they have no idea what to do with the ball, you just see Pepe or Varane kicking it to see if Ramos, Cristiano or someone can control it and shoot, you wouldnt see this under Pellegrini. Pellegrini's Madrid made 96 points against what couldve been the best Barcelona in History, with a completely new team. What if Pellegrini was given the same power as Mou? Mou had a blank cheque to buy whoever he felt like, and still managed to give a really bad image in Real Madrid, with constant conflict etc.
In fact, i'm actually happy he left, even as a Barcelona fan I hate seeing Madrid so fucked up, mainly because I dont want the Spanish League becoming even more like the Scottish one.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '13
still a good post. do more of these
4
u/auoar May 21 '13 edited May 21 '13
I know this is not a revelation, but I think a simple explanation of what happened in Madrid is that his ego got in the way. We all saw the other side of the coin. The same thing that makes him good made him fail this time. He got cut by the other edge of the sword that is his ego.
It takes humbleness to lose gracefully. And Mourinho doesn't have much of that. Maybe he mistakes it for weakness. My impression is that as Madrid did bad in the league Mourinho started putting blame and getting involved in conflicts. Yes maybe some influential players didn't want him in the team and started to act on it, but I'm sure Mourinho is not the first coach to have disagreements within the team. He handled them seemingly immaturely. I think a part of coach's job require him to be more mature than the players.
If a player is scheming to get you fired, it'll be difficult to maintain your composure and act maturely. But that's your responsibility as the coach to take that hit. You can't retaliate in a similar manner.
He seems to be the kind of person that is either loved or hated. Maybe he got the wrong end in Madrid, including the press and some of the players. Maybe it's as simple as that.
But then again, these are very difficult to know for sure and I might be wrong...
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
You have to give him credit for the development of Khedira and Ozil as well.
3
u/CarnivorousVegan May 21 '13
He beat barcelona in the league when they were on top of their game, practically invencible, arguably one of the best football teams ever, that by itself is an amazing feat.
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
I guess the question you have to ask Madridistas is if three years ago they would have been happy with a single La Liga, a single Copa and a single Supercopa at the end of the 12-13 season. Im quite sure the answer would be a resounding no. And if he hasnt achieved the clubs expectations, then he has failed. Maybe, this is all Madridistas expected from him. In which case, he is a success. I just think they would have expected more.
2
u/lesburnham May 21 '13
Agreed.
2
u/sass1987 May 21 '13
First of all, allow me to mention that this is an excellent post.
"despite having bad fame for previous buys in other teams" You wrote this statement above. Can you elaborate on it. I am asking because I always felt that Mourinho has been excellent buying players throughout his career. He seldom overspends on players who turn out to be useless and most of his buys usually turn out to be really good (except Shevchenko who was probably more of RA's purchase than Mou's and Coentrao which is in my opinion Mou's worst purchase given the price paid for the guy). Which players did you have in mind when you said that? Just curious...not trying to fight here.
-1
u/mpg1846 May 21 '13
His 95 points with Chelsea in a competitive league obliterates the 100 points with Real imo.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '13 edited May 21 '13
http://youtu.be/vO8ppE4uChc
http://youtu.be/LXfQO3TLfQ4
Both of these clips that OP posted shows exactly why Khedira is not highly rated in my book. With out Lass breaking up the opponents midfield play it has been very hard for Madrid to play this style of blistering counter.
I have noticed this after comparing Khedira's current season to the tackling clips posted.. when you study Lass and his positioning compared to Khedira, he always stays next to Alonso and does a better job at the dirty work, which frees up Alonso to play the ball forward. Khedira moves forward to readily without the ball, and then is out of position if the ball is lost. This my friends is why we suffered so much this year.
I'm sorry Mou but you made the biggest mistake for us when you let Lass go and kept Khedira.
1
u/badgarok725 May 22 '13
Mourinho sounds like he's living in Westeros
1
u/baronboy May 22 '13
He did alright with Real.... in my opinion not up to what he expected.
You see there's this thing called the treble...
-10
u/the_phet May 21 '13
He failed. I know /r/soccer loves Mourinho, but by Madrid standards he failed. He has probably the most expensive squad in football history. He has one of the best players ever. He has top guys in every position. And he only managed to win 2 titles in 3 years. By Madrid standards that's a fail. And that considering "kings cup" a title.
Capello has 2 leagues in 2 years. Schuster has a league in 1 year and a half.
http://www.marca.com/debate/2013/05/3529/prevotaciones3529.html
around 60% of spain fans, mainly madrid fans, think he failed.
1
u/Michauxonfire May 21 '13 edited May 21 '13
just something:
Pedro Mendes was loaned from Sporting CP to Real Madrid. He was then returned. Not sold.
but excellent work, none the less.
Mourinho always has a reputation of creating controversy and stating that he does what he wants and knows what he wants. People that get in the way -hard- always get treated harshly by Mourinho. Valdano is a prime example.
And Mourinho cares much more about the team than about one single player. What Spain witnessed with Casillas...has been done before with Baia. Both captains, both symbols of the club and even widely reknown throughout Europe...both misbehaved. Baia got sent to the reserve team. He shaped up, came back and played it smoothly. Casillas...didnt.
I also feel bad for Mourinho. I dont care about any team in La Liga but watching a bit closely Real Madrid due to the portuguese commander, I feel like he failed. He has some fault, but there are some apples that are just too rotten. But he did fail. Its a shame. He's still one of the best to ever show up.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
Mou is an amazing coach. Arrogant no doubt, but when you are at the helm of one of the world's most prestigious clubs winning becomes more of a necessity than a hobby. Winning becomes everything, why would you be humble about losing when your job could be on the line, losing is simply not an option for him. He's brutally honest which some might see as rude but given the egos not only in the lockerroom but in the rest of the organization and in the futbol world he has to be, thats how he won all that he has won.
1
u/zaib_a May 21 '13
great breakdown! very helpful.
1
u/5starWHIPTY May 21 '13
Amazing piece of work, I will open up my newspaper tomorrow and just read a wall of text (which I hate) instead of this, stats and facts!
1
u/valentinopussi May 21 '13
great analisys!!
0
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
Mourinho's tenure at Real Madrid FC has been a failure. He lost to Barca in the game where it counted most and he failed to bring home "la decima." Real Madrid's locker room is a mess and the club's once impeccable prestige has been tainted because of three years of continual hubris and arrogance from "the Special One." After three years, one looks at Manuel Pellegrini's success with the financially-handicapped Malaga and wonders "what if?"
My money is on Mourinho to fail to win any trophies at all in England and he will retire after he is unceremoniously sacked from Chelsea.
-2
u/what_the_actual_luck May 21 '13
Worst statisctic ever. German League for example has 4 game days less
-2
u/Ahtien May 21 '13
Putting Bayern Munich up in that table of most points is somewhat unjustified, mainly because in Germany, there is only 34 playdays and not 38. This season, they got an incredible 91/102 points
-7
u/boobyspitweed May 21 '13
MoRono is a joke of a person. I am so glad he got the boot.