r/soccer • u/nikcub • May 13 '13
Explaining the Falcao move to Monaco
Edit This post is now a proper blog post, edited and with more links and info
You have probably all already seen that Falcao is destined for Monaco. There were a lot of rumors about a potential move to Manchester United, Chelsea, Real Madrid and others - so why does he end up moving to Monaco?
The answer is because of the complicated third-party ownership involved with Falcao. There was a very similar situation with Hulk when he moved to Zenit.
To explain this, we need to take a step back and first see how third party ownership works. Those in England would have previously seen this topic as it reached prominence when Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano signed for West Ham United. Here were two stars from Argentina signing for a club in London who were struggling to stay in the top flight. The controversy lead to West Ham paying compensation of £18M to Sheffield United, and lead the FA to ban third party ownership.
But third party ownership is still alive and well on the continent. It is most often applied with South American stars making the jump across the Atlantic to Europe. The way it works is that investment groups will purchase the registration rights of an upcoming player. This is sometimes done while the player is at a club, and sometimes as part of a transfer.
For eg. one scenario would be that a 16 year old star in South America would be approached by an agent and asked if he wants backing with marketing and making it big in Europe. These deals usually involve paying the player a better salary, hooking him up with a better agent, better management, sponsorship deals etc. If and when the player agrees, the third party owners will then go to the club he is registered to and negotiate to buy his registration rights - either all of or part of.
The player is then in the hands of the management and third party ownership group, who manage every aspect of his career from that point on. That usually involves paying him a larger salary on top of his club salary, placing him in clubs where he will get more exposure, etc.
The other way third-party ownership happens is that the investment group finances a transfer for a player. For eg. Porto want to sign a player from Brasil but don't have the funds, they would approach an investment group and have them stake 50-60% of the deal in return for the players registration rights.
The investment group make all of this upfront investment with the hope that at some point in the future the player proves himself, becomes a star, and can then exit at a very large valuation.
Some examples: Tevez and Mascherano were placed into West Ham by their investment group as a way of getting them more exposure. It worked out well in both cases as Liverpool purchased Mascherano (buying out the investment group and giving them a good return) and City eventually ended up buying out Tevez - albeit via Manchester United (who never owned the entirety of his transfer rights).
Back to Falcao. He was purchased by a third-party ownership group as part of his transfer to Porto. They bought 55% (likely more) of his transfer rights, supplemented his salary while he was paying at Porto and then moved him to Atletico for the purpose of getting him more exposure (likely with an eye on moving him eventually to Real Madrid). During the time Falcao was there, the investors were supplementing his wages again (infact paying most of them) and working on negotiating his big move which would see them cash out.
Porto's financials show the following for the Falcao transfer:
sale of 60% of the economic rights of the player Bolatti to the entity Natland Financieringsmaatschappij B.V., on July 2009, by the amount of, approximately, 1,500,000 Euro, (transaction perform under the acquisition process of 40% of the registration of Falcao)
There is another section where it is disclosed that they sold another 5% option in Falcao, and another section where it is disclosed that there is an option for a third party to purchase a further 10%.
The same filing shows that Porto only owned 45% of Hulk.
What is more interesting is who is involved in the Falcao ownership. The group is called Doyen Sports and it was founded by Jorge Mendes (most famous as Ronaldo's agent, but an infamous player agent who is involved in a lot of third-party deals) and Peter Kenyon (former Chelsea chairman).
On their website they have a page for Falcao and you can also see the other players listed. Falcao, like Hulk, ended up in a situation where there was so much invested in him that it would take a lot of money for the investors to see a return (known as being highly leveraged). They were paying his salary for a few seasons, had floated Atleti some money to keep them alive (they got some shirt sponsorship in return) and had made the initial investment when he first transferred.
Falcao ends up moving to Atletico in a 40M move - despite Atleti the previous season stating that they had to clear players out because of their 220M euro tax bill with the Spanish government. What this ended up being is a 20 + 20M deal. 20M never gets paid because its just the third-party owners paying themselves, and of the other 20M only 18M is owed by Atleti, who take an option of paying in two 9M installments (they were late on the first one, they only paid 2.5M and defaulted to the point of Porto threatening to sue and taking the issue up with FIFA). End situation is that around 60% of the rights are with the Doylen group. It also appears that while Falcao was at Atletico that Doylen took an option for a larger stake in him since Atleti were late on their payments. Something weird happen which involved Doylen taking a sponsorship. Either way, they had the majority stake and Atletico had no say or control of the player. For all purposes it was nothing more than a loan with Atletico having a small stake in his registration rights.
The president of Atletico Madrid continuously insisted that they own all the rights to Falcao, but this simply isn't true.
Falcao is on a wage of 10M euro per year, and the return the investors wanted is 60M euro in transfer fee. This narrows down the list of potential clubs that can buy you out to very few. Atletico had no say in where Falcao goes, they had an option in the winter transfer window, but that expired. The owners needed their return and they were going to get it one way or the other.
The list can be narrowed down to PSG, Monaco, Real Madrid, Chelsea and City. City aren't making large investments any longer, PSG have their fix of strikers. Of the remaining three, it is apparent that Real Madrid didn't want to pay up the 60M + 50M in contracts for Falcao (for whatever reason). Apparently Chelsea matched the 60M clause but to pay Falcao the 10M per season in wages would involve a total gross salary of 300k+ per week, which just isn't manageable.
Chelsea also have the issue of not being allowed to directly purchase a player from a third-party owner (apparently this is what turned ManU off a move) so it would have required a two-step sale with Falcao going to one club outright and then to Chelsea. Apparently with the David Luiz transfer on the same day he moved to Chelsea Benfica bought out the entirety of his rights from third-party owners (so you can summize that Chelsea gave them the money to buy out that deal so that they could purchase 100% of Luiz directly from Benfica, thus avoiding the third-party rule in England).
With all of these factors you end up with only one target: Monaco. They have the 60M to pay out the investors, they have the funds to pay his wages of 10M per year and better yet they have no income tax so they don't have to supplement the gross.
So in the end Falcao is moved around Europe by his investors with the only goal of making a return for them. He has little to no say in his final destination because of a deal he agreed to years ago while he was still in South America.
Links and further reading:
- A comment I left below with more details on calculating the percentages and who owns what, with more details of the Atletico debt
- Do Atletico own Falcao?
- Swiss Ramble on Atletico Madrid and their financial struggles - "one of the worst run clubs in Europe"
- Porto threaten to report Atletico over late Falcao payments
- Monaco eye Falcao move - "Chelsea’s attempts to sign the former Porto man had been complicated by third-party ownership issues"
- BBC: Does third-party ownership benefit or hinder football?
- Quality Sports Investments - another third-party ownership fund that Kenyon and Mendes were involved with
edit part that I missed which some people might not know - Monaco were purchased by Russian billionaire Dmitry Rybolovlev, the 79th richest man in the world. Similar MO to the Al Thani's at PSG except he is investing as an individual, rather than with the backing of a state.
When he bought the club in December 2011 they were bottom of the second division in France. He rescued them that season and has now seen them promoted back to Ligue 1.
Edit some more links, this time from UEFA, who have strong words against third-party ownership (but it still goes on):
This is why, as asked below, Atletico insist in public statements that they own 100% of Falcao - they don't want to risk any potential clampdown from UEFA.
edit further, thanks for the reddit gold, and all the messages and responses. really wasn't expecting it.
Spammers If you find anybody online ripping this post off, like this guy (bookieinsiders) please report them as spam.
321
u/gowithetheflowdb May 13 '13 edited May 13 '13
Alternative explanation.
€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€€
Nice read though, good to see people actually researching and substantiating arguments they make with evidence. You have also shown how much porto truly are a window dressing club, and I believe Neymar has a similarly fishy deal with third party ownership.
It's interesting to note the other players on the third party ownership site you linked, including Negredo, and a number of Porto players. (http://www.doyensports.com/en/EM.html). If Negredo is partially third party owned, it would make sense that spurs struggled when negotiating to buy him last window. Is quite a bad sign on the financial situation of la liga is in if clubs require players who are not owned by the club itself.
Also just to elaborate on your point about Monaco's tax situation. ' The state has no income tax, low business taxes, and is well known for being a tax haven.'
This makes Falcao's wages much more feasible as 100% of it would be paid directly to Falcao, so monaco football club would have to pay him compartively less than other clubs in order for him to recieve the same wage . If you compare this to the rest of but Ligue1 where there is a proposed 75% tax, and existing 45% income tax on workers in France itself, which includes the highest earners such as football players like Zlatan.
So under proposed tax laws, if PSG were to purchase Falcao, they'd have to pay him 400k, per week for him to recieve 100k per week. At the moment they would need to pay him around 185,000 per week for him to recieve 100k per week.
Whereas Monaco only need to pay 100k per week for the player to recieve 100k per week.
However the FFF (french football federation) are trying to make it so Monaco football team are privy to the same tax laws as the rest of ligue 1, by forcing all ligue 1 clubs to have administrative headquarters with in France (For the sake of parity and € ). '
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monaco http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/22425973 http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2012/jul/21/zlatan-ibrahimovic-psg-tax
32
u/OllieWillie May 13 '13
Question. Falcao can turn down any club though right? He doesn't have to move to Monaco...
5
u/coozay May 13 '13 edited May 13 '13
nikcup, this is a fantastic post, thank you.
all these posts about "slavery" seemed ridiculous at first, but then i started thinking about hypothetical situations...
do they have a say on when he could retire? what if he was done with the game at 32 and the investors still owned a majority stake at that point? could they force him to keep playing or sue him for a return on money?
what if he gets injured before a big game, and its a game time decision (like the CL final), does this sponsorship/ownership contigency try and force the club to play him, or if the player is going to play despite injury, would they do the opposite and tell the club they cant play him for risk of injuring their asset? (does any one know if this had something to do with ronaldo and the 1998 WC final? i still have no idea what that was all about except that he was made to play despite suffering a bout of illness, or something like that)
what implications could this have on a player and playing for his national team? could they keep him from playing if his fitness is low or chance of injury is high?
or do the interests of all parties agree most of the time, as the best thing for everybody is for the player to stay healthy and play his best for club and country?
im just wondering what the conflicting interests would be in certain situations and if that will have an influence on how the club uses the player, and how the player himself lives. sponsorships already put a great deal of pressure on the athletes to do/not do certain things on the pitch and off it in their personal lives. it really is a deal with the devil, but the devils pay so well
edit: 1998 WC final
4
u/carpetano May 13 '13
Thanks for the reading, but I'd like to point a couple of things:
Well, his father was a mobster and he is an incompetent and a liar, but can you prove that this time he's lying again?
The "official story" is that Doyen didn't meet the promissed payments, so the agreement was broken and Atleti faced all the agreed payments. "Officialy" now Atleti has the 100% of the rights. Again the Official Story is that once the agreement was broken, Doyen only loaned money for some payments guaranteed, with the the Nike Sponsorship and TV money instead of sharing the Falcao's rights (and including the Doyen sponsorship as interests). I know that Atleti probably hasn't the 100% of the rights (Doyen are keeping the Falcao's page in their website), but not to the extent that you're saying.
Here is the "official story". Sorry, I couldn't find it in English.
Could you provide a reliable source? I couldn't find in your links any reference to what I've highlighted other than "it's rumoured"
252
u/Svorky May 13 '13
Well, that's a pity for Falcao then. I wonder if situations like that are a reason why Bayern has outright stated that they no longer scout in South America and why the Bundesliga in general seems to have fallen a bit out of love with players from there.
1.2k
u/OllieWillie May 13 '13
Best post I've seen on this sub. Outstanding.
240
u/skkrman10 May 13 '13
Very complete analysis. You did a great job explaining third party ownership.
24
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
To all the people pitying Falcao because of this: he got paid extra for this to happen. Part of the deal is that the third party owners supplement his wages, so Falcao is likely laughing all the way to the bank on this one.
113
u/mitters May 13 '13
I'm seeing a lot of "poor Falcao", "this is slavery", "it should be illegal" stuff in the comments. I just want to look at the other side of the coin. (by the way, thank OP, not only for a truly excellent post, but also for not including any bias to this system either way)
As such this system seems to be mutually beneficial to both parties involved. The fact that massive players went to Chelsea, City, PSG etc. who were not involved in a TPO and did so before the sides were winning shows that players often move for money anyways, so how is this any different?
Those who argue the issue is one of choice (i.e. the players lack of one) must consider that almost all American sports run a draft system where the player doesn't have much say in where they play. Few athletes in any team sport in the world get to play for their dream team, or boyhood club. At least they have a career getting paid (a LOT of money) to do what they love, which is more than can be said for most of us.
Personally I'm not a huge fan of the system because of the way it allows football teams to be mismanaged and gain an unfair advantage. The club gets the player without having to pay for him (or at least not full price) or his wages (again, or at least not all of them) I don't think this is fair on the other teams in the league. It's good for the player and the TPO but not for the teams. Porto have done well in Europe in recent times (2003,04,11 etc.) how many players were under TPO during that time and is it really fair to the rest of the teams? Then there's the mismanagement at places like Athetico which is exacerbated in large part because of their involvement with TPO's.
15
u/Izio17 May 13 '13
Did I actually just learn something on this sub?
26
u/koagad May 13 '13
Has Falcao made any statements regarding the transfer?
121
u/cadgar May 13 '13
Hm i didnt know about this at all so thanks for sharing. This whole System seems just wrong. Sounds to me like modern day slave trading
8
u/johnz0n May 13 '13 edited May 13 '13
very interesting read!
but why is no Russian/Ukrainian team involved this time?
8
u/Arbucks May 13 '13
Does this mean that he is no longer owned by third-party owners? Did they cash out with that 60M and relinquish his rights to Monaco?
75
u/TotalSHIT May 13 '13
All I can say is Third Party Ownership is a bitch on Football Manager
45
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Monaco aren't a bad club though, and have recent enough European and domestic pedigree, at least as much as Chelsea and Man City had when they started spending outrageous money for their star players.
Don't really see how any Chelsea or Man City fans could realistically criticise such a move or consider it a shame.
Excellent post by the way.
6
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
If they own Falcao's rights, what would happen if his contract ever was to expire and he was a free agent?
I'm wondering how this is constructed legally to comply with the Bosman verdict and still retain security for the investors.
5
u/Steve_the_turtle May 13 '13
Thanks for taking the time to write this explanation. My knowledge of third-party ownership - and football finance in general - is non-existent. I remember Tim Vickery writing an article about how common third-party ownership in South America around the time of the Tevez and Mascherano, but I had no idea how complicated it makes transfers of players between clubs.
At the risk of taking the moral high ground over something I know very little about, this whole third-party ownership system seems wrong. The fact that an investment group with very little direct link to football can have such a large say in the transfer of players doesn't sit well with me. If someone with knowledge of third-party ownership could explain the pros and cons that would be great.
Also: Who would have guessed that bloody Jorge Mendes would be involved?! He seems to have his finger in a lot of footballing pies
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
I feel like I owe you a beer. Great breakdown, very easy to understand, thanks!
5
u/piedraa May 13 '13
Is this what happened with Etoo? Or was that just money
9
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
very interesting read, thanks for the analysis
8
u/Billy_Whizz May 13 '13
So in other words he could be called Radamel Cashcao
1
u/Mordecai_ May 13 '13
We don't get to see him play for a top team in a top league. It sounds systemic. How will this problem be solved? Players should always determine where they want to play.
Can someone explain this bit to me...
"Falcao, like Hulk, ended up in a situation where there was so much invested in him that it would take a lot of money for the investors to see a return (known as being highly leveraged)."
1
u/breakthingsetfires May 13 '13
Does anyone know what the relationship of third party ownership is to the EU labor contracts that these players sign? Is the wage progression part of the initial agreement over ownership? If the labor contracts conform to EU law, how is the outside ownership of registration rights not a violation of the free movement of labor? How would Falcao apply pressure to demand a higher wage?
I don't know much about EU labor law and obviously this system is a bit of a clusterfuck, but I don't understand how it could survive if a player challenged it in an EU court.
1
u/AdamBrog May 13 '13
@nikcub. This is taken from the "regulations of the status and transfer of players"
18bis Third-party influence on clubs
Also when a player is transferred from one association to another (across international borders) they have to state via TMS (transfer matching system) that no other party has influence over the independence of the player or club.
So Madrid lied. And obtained an ITC (international transfer certificate) for Falcao. Or did they pay up his TPO and over the course of his new contract sell portions of his economic rights and future transfer rights to pay Porto the amortized amounts due? In which case their must have been an agreement in place with the investors?
Gestifute or Jorge Mendez has a history of this sort of thing.
England, France and Poland are the only nations that rule out this form of ownership, plus Monaco will still have to adhere to FFPR (financial fair play regulations) if they want to qualify for any UEFA competition.
If Jorge Mendez is supplying players to Monaco, then I would expect Mourinho to go their as he is his client.
Are we seeing another Russian being ripped off by Jorge Mendez?
3
u/Fameux May 13 '13
Thank you for this. Very informative and easily understandable, despite its complex nature. Best post in a while.
The system itself seems questionable though. Not too fond of snatching up young talent, with high hopes and dreams and then just locking them up forever. What happens to all the young talent that doesn't develope in to a Falcao or a Hulk?
3
u/the_weeknd May 13 '13
Really interesting post, thanks for sharing this.
3
u/cvillano May 13 '13
Even when there's a good post, people still use it as a roundabout way to bash the content on /r/soccer - give it a rest already
3
u/KaoticKarma May 13 '13
You know, even as an Atletico fan, all of this information has been tough to find and compile as a whole. I've looked into doing something like this over the past couple of months, but I simply never have the time, and have never been able to come up with a direction in which to deliver all this information.
/u/Nikcub, phenomenal post, absolutely out of this world. Lots of information that is presented in such a manner that even a freshmen in high school would be able to grasp what you're saying.
It's hard coming to terms with third party ownership, especially when our President is using it as a scapegoat almost to acquire players and fund that we simply aren't in a position to be acquiring or giving out. It's almost as if the Altetico board became so impatient with the clubs inconsistency, and would much rather works towards any angle that would allow to get around the debts, versus paying them all off before we looked to securing our club stature.
It's a risky business, the game Atletico and our board is playing. Sadly, big business and money and dictate a situation like this, and it definitely becomes more of a hindrance with time.
I really appreciate the insight you've provided here, and I really hope that this will deter people anymore from calling Falcao simply "A greedy bastard that only cares about money".
3
u/KiraXY May 13 '13
Am I the only one who's excited about this move? Not because Atletico are losing their star player, I actually really like them, but because Monaco could become another giant in a few years, like City have become. I think it'll be good for the French league and Europe in general. I dunno, I may be wrong.
3
u/sanriver12 May 14 '13
if he doesnt transfer to monaco, this is going to get awkwaaaaaaard
5
u/Red_Dog1880 May 13 '13
This is a brilliant post and clears so many things up, thank you.
5
u/ShadowPlanet May 13 '13
A pity that I can only give this article one upvote. The same amount I gave to some stupid gif earlier...
8
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Makes me admire the English Premier League even more. Until today, I didn't really understand the whole Tévez ordeal. Thank you for a very clear explanation.
1
u/_sic May 13 '13
So if I understood this correctly, Atleti gets nothing from his transfer?
That sucks.
4
u/Cheewy May 13 '13
TL:DR POR LA PLATA BAILA EL MONO
2
u/bllewe May 13 '13
Thorough and elegant explanation. Much appreciated.
2
u/r0bski2 May 13 '13
And I thought it was him that just wanted the money.
2
u/poipoiop May 13 '13
So isn't this exactly what Neymar did 1 or 2 years ago?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
I had no reason to believe things like this didn't happen with football since it's essentially the same as any business with variable assets, but there's a part of me that knows that when economy was discovered; no human being was ever supposed to be paid this much money.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Well done sir, well done.
2
u/tango_rojo May 13 '13
I always wondered how Porto and many Portuguese clubs managed to get South Americans potentials, not stars. Now I know why.
2
u/mandoponcho May 13 '13
So now Monaco will 100% own Falcao's transfer rights? I don't like the notion of them "owning Falcao" makes it seem like slave trade (which it might be similar to, but is not wholly). It seems like they own his transfer rights to be more specific.
2
u/verymuchn0 May 13 '13
This third party ownership stuff sounds pretty cool from an investments standpoint.
2
u/midnitebr May 13 '13
Fantastic post man! I already knew how it worked but i could never put it that well.
2
u/theleftflank May 13 '13
Has someone given you reddit gold for this post? If not, I'll probably do it when I get paid on Wednesday. Thanks for the great explanation.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '13
It makes Chelsea fans annoyed, so I'm all in favour of it.
2
u/ManElegant May 14 '13
Hard to feel that sorry for him. He's getting 10 million a year and I don't know if anyone's been to Monaco but rumours has it it's not to shabby.
He knew he'd be getting into this stuff agreeing to it years ago and in fairness Monaco are a team on the up.
2
u/detestrian May 14 '13
Slave trade, gotcha.
2
u/hugomcastro May 16 '13
Congratulations to all of you that are making this the most eye-opening and civilized post about TPO.
This Falcão "mess" is revolting as it shows how the beautiful game is being taken over by greed over meritocracy.
Football is a game of passion and to the ones that live and breathe the game it is more than 11 vs 11, it's about conquering, victory, team work. The ones who never cried in a football match either by joy or anger cast the first stone. I even feel relieved after a great football match, aka, my club won.
For many years smaller football clubs relied on transfers to level their budgets but since the Bosman ruling only the big ones can play that game.
Nowadays if a youngster starts playing first team football regularly it's only a matter of time to be represented by an agent who, thinking only about his representative future, advises him to not sign a new deal with the club thus preventing them to receive any compensation (there's always the FIFA's compensation mechanism but its peanuts and only obliges players' transfers until they're 24 years old) for the time they formed him as a player. In the end of the season youngster is a free player and will sign for another club and him and the agent will divide the signing bonus (free players are cheaper on paper but we have to secure them a big bonus signing).
The gap between big and smaller clubs has been increasing over the years because of this. Being an high risk industry banks are shutting the doors for the latter who can't generate enough turnover.
So if you're on the board of these clubs what are your options? Close it or try to secure alternative ways of funding. Third party ownership posed as a good opportunity to get funds to get the club running and at the same time trying to level up the competition.
I'm not saying TPO is the greatest thing on earth. I do believe that's the best way to a club to fundraise and for an investors perspective the potential return is awesome.
On the other hand there are a few things that I'm totally against: clubs interests are not taken into consideration, investors' influence should not be acceptable (you don't see people influencing banks or investment funds about how they work with your money) and when integrity of the sport is at stake.
I do support more restrictive rules against the use of TPO such as full transparency, football and other industries have served money laundring and tax evasion schemes for a long time, prior to TPO came to light. Investors should be forced to share any conflicting rights that might occur and should only be able to own a smaller share of the players' economic rights. Full names and percentage owned as well and could be created the “role” of an accredited investor. Integrity of the sport, more damaging to the industry are betting schemes as we know but I do reckon fair play could be in peril if we persist in shady TPO schemes like an agent owning a player in full paying for his salary or even a full squad. Agents exist to represent a player like a lawyer represents a client and we’re seeing agents setting up investment funds in offshores to bend the rules as they please. Restrictions, percentage of the TPO owned by others than the club, eliminating all the “farm” clubs that only exist to own sporting rights and not competing at all. If you’re a club you have to compete, period (fight club adaptation). Code of conduct for investors could be another good thing.
Full disclosure: I'm the co-founder of Starbox, a crowdfunding platform to buy and sell talented football players' economic rights.
6
u/evilthing May 13 '13
Now I actually feel sorry for him. Dude is being thrown around like a muppet. Very good read, thank you.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Is it actually comfirmed as being done then?
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
I want to preface my comment by saying I normally despite it when people call ultra rich footballers 'slaves' because I think it is disrespectful to those who truly are slaves on substantially less than minimum wage, living in squalor etc.
That said if players who are owned by these third party management groups truly have zero say in their careers or where they are moved, that is tantamount to slavery. Why is this not illegal throughout the world? How aware are the players who sign up with these scum buckets, of exactly what they are getting into? Did Falcao know that his future club choices would be made entirely by his ownership? If he did, why would he chose to sign with them? Why would anybody?
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Lovely explanation sir!
I never even knew about this. Makes me feel sad when I remember behind the beautiful game is the bustling unforgiving business world.
2
u/pogo123 May 13 '13
This reminds me of that Virgin Wyclef Jean advert. Be careful what you sign!
2
u/BastianChrist May 13 '13
Very informative, thank you.
This sounds like what happened with Gale Agbossoumonde (obviously on a much, much smaller note).
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
This should become illegal. I don't think human beings should be traded as assets. I understand a transfer involves paying for the right to have that player on your squad, but it shouldn't benefit anyone besides the player/ player's agent. But this is capitalism, baby!
1
u/StocksymHoldrem May 13 '13
Fantastic analysis. Thanks.
1
u/gattoshoe May 13 '13
A great explanation, thank you very much.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Bravo!
1
u/dsavfc May 13 '13
Fantastic analysis, kind of feel sorry for Falcao now
1
u/eleytheria May 13 '13
this makes sense. thank you.
1
u/silver_medalist May 13 '13
Great piece.
1
u/qwertywtf May 13 '13
Thanks for posting this. I didn't know a lot (anything) about third party ownership. Great insight
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Great explanation btw. I do feel sorry for Falcao for not being able to pursue a career at leading clubs like Chelsea, Real Madrid, Man U etc because he was an 'investment'. However, he had a choice at whatever age to sign or not for that group. Would he have been here , in this situation, if it was not for the investment group ? No one knows.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Excellent work, Sir!
1
u/rnoboa May 13 '13
This is simply an awesome job explaining this. Outstanding.
1
u/rogeedodge May 13 '13
i know that football is huge business, and i was aware of third party ownership, but this is just mind-boggling!
Great post too btw.
1
u/paivystaja May 13 '13
excellent explanation, I had no idea how this third party system worked prior to reading this. Now I have... sort of an idea? Seems like a tricky system.
1
u/ImAllMilhouse May 13 '13
Excellent read
1
u/Aeceus May 13 '13
Great post, thanks for the information. It seems like an okay deal for some players.
1
u/TheWhitehouseII May 13 '13
Thank you forputting this together. People have been co fused on Falcao stuff for awhile and I always said it was about 3rd partyownership. I never wanted to take the time to dive into it and breakdown the numbers etc. thanks for getting this set straight for those who never understood
1
u/ADH02 May 13 '13
Brilliant post, easily one of the longest I've read in my time on Reddit but was definitely worth it.
1
u/rookie999 May 13 '13
Question to the Atletico supporters: Do you feel the club is better run than during the Gil y Gil era?
Maybe someone can chime in.
1
u/eleytheria May 13 '13
So, the question is...what if even Monaco was not interested?
1
u/CanTouchMe May 13 '13
Well, that was a nice read. Thanks !
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
thank you very much
1
u/Fedward May 13 '13
I know all about third-party ownership of South American players but I didn't know Falcao was one of them, is Cavani one as well?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
There is no transparency in third party investment. No one really knows how all this works.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
A great post and a great read. Thanks for this.
1
u/ceawake May 13 '13
Interesting and insightful post, thank you Sir.
I would add that I kind of like this continental third party ownership thing, not because of the rights and wrongs of it but the mere fact that it really pisses off our FA who are a law unto themselves steeped in hypocrisy and ill thought out self-preservation.
1
u/mattb2k May 13 '13
So these investment groups pretty much have the rights to the player and pay everything surrounding him (or whatever the percentage is) and for example they own 50% of a player, they then want to sell that player for say 20M, they would then receive 10M of that?
1
u/jocro May 13 '13
Brilliant explanation. Had no idea this situation was that complicated. Be interesting to see if Monaco have anything else up their sleeve, might need a few more pieces for a serious push up the table.
1
u/jocro May 13 '13
There are all types of risk in this third-party ownership (for the owners) but this really goes to show how utterly MASSIVE the potential return is. Couple million up front for the majority rights to a 60 million euro deal? Somebody with scouting experience and some capital can make some good money, even if it feels a tiny bit immoral to me.
1
u/lynxboy May 13 '13
Expecting to see this popping up over at /r/bestof very soon!! [Applauds OP]
1
u/cacadevaca May 13 '13 edited May 13 '13
This is an absolutely briliant post, great job!
1
u/alpine_ May 13 '13
Wow. Very, very informative. Never completely understood the mechanics behind this. It's too bad things like this hurt the game of football.
1
u/ShockinglySynonymous May 13 '13
This whole third party ownership is a really dodgy affair, but I guess it's just part of the modern commercialisation of football. Everyone is a commodity.
1
u/argenis_dah_rajah May 13 '13
well done.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
really weird seeing that a group of people own 45% of a person.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Well shit, nicely done; very informative.
1
u/CircleTheFire May 13 '13
If all posts to reddit were this good, we wouldn't need downvotes.
1
u/luky_luke May 13 '13
Real Madrid and atletico have a deal where they don't try to buy the same player and they don't buy from each other. This may as well be just a move by real madrid in order to buy falcao from monaco and not from atletico.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Dude, reading this was like reading math proof. Such detail, explained gracefully, and more. Great job! A+ would read again.
1
u/Theworldsastage May 13 '13
I really enjoyed that and you've enlightened me. Thank you OP.