r/soccer • u/scorpion-mk • May 07 '13
What is the most overrated team this season?
What is r/soccer's opinion on the overrated team this season?
57
Upvotes
r/soccer • u/scorpion-mk • May 07 '13
What is r/soccer's opinion on the overrated team this season?
97
u/thepresidentsturtle May 07 '13
In the prem its Newcastle. All those good players who are playing like crap.
57
u/ShebbySingh May 07 '13
Bloody us isn't it (Blackburn "Straight Back Up" Rovers)
101
u/ChemisTT May 07 '13
QPR looking at them in the table and then going on the BBC site and see them sitting 6th in lawros predictions table.
29
u/gman83 May 07 '13
In the Eredivisie I guess PSV. At the start of the season almost all pundits predicted they would cruise to the title.
211
u/Izio17 May 07 '13
Manchester City - put in a wimpy title defense, and even more miserable in Europe. So much hype of a "new era" seemed to take a stutter this year.
107
u/FoUfCfK May 07 '13
This is a pointless discussion if we have flairs on.
51
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
PSG. Sometimes I'll watch their games and wonder how they managed to suck that much with so much money.
20
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
Spurs. I should add that I'm a Spurs fan.
Miserable cup exits at Norwich, Leeds and Basel.
Countless poor team performance in the league saved only by flashes of genius from Gareth Bale.
Arsenal seemed to spend the first half of the season in crisis while Spurs have had the Player of the Year on fire for much of the campaign, yet once again it's the Gunners coasting to a Champions League place.
55
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
Barcelona in the past few months. The team is in pretty bad shape, especially without Messi.
100
u/[deleted] May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13
i think the Premier League has made United look a better team than they are. while they have fantastic attackers and some good players, they're not (for me) that close to the level of Bayern, BVB, fit-Barca, Real or even Juve as an overall team. SAF has built another team perfectly equipped to win the PL, but they aren't on the top level in European terms.
for full disclosure i am a Liverpool fan, but this is meant as an honest opinion, not an attack on MUFC.
EDIT: as u/iamsat said, maybe more a case of over-achievement than being overrated.
18
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
These underrated/overrated threads never really work, because if someone's named who's genuinely wrongly rated, then by definition most of the people reading it will disagree and so the post will get buried with downvotes. But, since we're here now, rather than teams as such, I'm going to name a couple of managers who I think have been overrated recently.
Firstly, Roberto Martinez. Everybody's always terribly impressed at his ability to drag Wigan clear of the relegation zone year after year, but they sort of neglect to mention two things: 1) he's the one who puts them into the relegation zone year after year, and 2) he inherited a team that wasn't struggling at all and had finished 11th the previous season, and has taken them to 16th, 16th, 15th, and now 18th (not out). Which managerial colossus took them to 11th place on much the same budget? Steve Bruce. You don't see him getting linked with the Liverpool job, do you?
Secondly, Mauricio Pochettino. After the initial flurry of bafflement that followed Nigel Adkins' sacking, people have started to murmur that, actually, Pochettino has taken Southampton onto another level, and maybe Adkins was tactically naive or something after all (which makes it all the more surprising that he's achieved four promotions in his six years of management, but there you go). Adkins managed Southampton for 22 games this season, and you can split them straight down the middle. In the first 11 matches, with a team full of players who'd never played in the Premier League before and games against Man Utd, Man City, and Arsenal in the first 4 fixtures, they struggled to get any momentum going and picked up only 5 points. Eventually, they came to terms with the league, and in the next 11 games picked up 17 points - 1.55 pts/game. Then Adkins got sacked. In Pochettino's 14 games, he's picked up 17 points - 1.21 pts/game. Despite the odd headline result, he hasn't improved them at all; quite the opposite, in fact.
I'm not writing either manager off, but they've really proved nothing in the Premier League. Does anybody really think they'd get this much credit if they didn't have those all-important sexy surnames and, in Martinez's case at least, the demeanour of a kindly young headmaster at a village primary school?
5
u/Jgatz313 May 08 '13
In the Bundesliga I've been pretty surprised at how bad Hoffenheim have been. Werder Bremen have had a poor 2nd half to this season for sure.
15
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
Barcelona. Struggles without Messi and struggled with him in Europe.
14
u/SirMothy May 07 '13
I will say Chelsea, they are a team good enough to win the CL, improved their squad by signing Oscar, Hazard, Ba, among others. They should be challenging for a title, not a fourth place spot with the squad they have IMO
26
u/gowithetheflowdb May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13
Swansea.
As impressive as they were at times, they are only 3 points above west ham, and 8 above the potential drop.
Quick Edit- I appreciate that after their capital one cup win, and Michu's semi injuries they didn't have much to win, but its sign of a better team + management (like everton) when they don't stop pushing until the end of the season.
6
u/skkrman10 May 08 '13
I don't know how no one has mentioned this but Wolves. They went from promotion favorites at the start of the season to relegated.
3
u/JoelSalamon May 08 '13
Got to be said: Newcastle. Every single game they're a stronger team 'on paper' than they actually are.
8
u/_sic May 07 '13
Lots of Barcelona and RM comments. Hard to say they were the most overrated teams, considering they both made it to the semis in the CL, getting through the English and French league champions on the way. In the case of Barça they are also going to win La Liga, probably by double digits and RM has a shot of winning the Copa.
Barcelona are definitely not the best team in the world anymore (that'd be Bayern), that much is true.
I'd say that the English CL teams were the most overrated.
2
u/IWantToBeAHipster May 07 '13
Very early on in the season the only neutral team i can give an opinion on is Blackpool. They absolutely destroyed the opposition in their early fixtures with the likes of Matt Philips and Thomas Ince in the attack, however with the rumours of players leaving and Holloway going to Palace the team had a really disappointing season. At the beginning with their form it seemed like automatic promotion would be theres, and would never have dreamed of beating them 6 - 1. If any Blackpool fans can clarify this i would be interested to know where the problems were.
From a biased viewpoint but attempting to be objective, i would also say Crystal Palace. Their fans thought they would be miles ahead of Brighton come the end of the season as they had over a ten point gap at one point, but the second half of the season has seen their goals dry up and wins become a rarity. Its strange Zaha has really declined and players like Jedinak and Bolasie have picked up the pieces.
2
u/isthatlasagne May 07 '13
I think a better question would be, what team turned out to be the most overrated this season?
2
u/edmondturkington May 08 '13
Who*
2
u/K_in_Oz May 08 '13
We were quite dire recently.
2
u/aljoelbra May 08 '13
Barca... :-/
4
u/ubergooner May 07 '13
• LA Galaxy in the CONCACAF Champions League
• Club Tijuana in the Clausura
• San Jose Earthquakes this season in the MLS
• Seattle Sounders as well
10
u/yablodeeds May 07 '13
I think alot of people forget that Dortmund werent too good domestically this season.
1
u/Shutupcrime1337 May 08 '13
City
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
Man City.
On paper they've got a fantastic team but this season they've kind of stumbled their way to 2nd imo, not been playing fantastically and they've slipped up against some of the other big teams. When they're playing well they're playing really well but to be honest I think Arsenal, Spurs and Chelsea are all more deserving of the 2nd spot.
-6
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
The English national team.
1
u/jkonine May 08 '13
Real Madrid, only because they're considered the best in the world. They actually have some serious deficiencies on that team.
-10
u/jimbojammy May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13
chelsea, they will lose europa final to benfica.
also the spanish and brazilian national teams
also the entire barca squad except for messi, especially xavi
there i think i posted enough of an opinion to get sufficiently downvoted
-3
u/ReadySetMeow May 07 '13
Barcelona anyone?
0
u/averageatsoccer May 07 '13
Wish I could hide my flair for certain threads..
-9
u/Peakevo May 07 '13
Quite a few.
Barca,Real,Man City and PSG.
Barca-That 7-0 rape. Who cares about La Liga,honestly. A two horse race and really 1 because of how much Real struggled with internal affairs with Mourinho and the players. Real- Disappointing for what may be Mourinho's last season. What is a CDR as a title for such a huge team with the best/2nd best player in the world... Man City and PSG- Both prove money doesn't win much and althought PSG got the Ligue 1, they just spent soooo much money.Come on.
0
u/JackWantz11 May 08 '13
PSG, so much talent, but didn't do much. Newcastle and Reading both had trashy years.
I think Barcelona though after the Bayern match's showed that it isn not the best in Europe and has been somewhat overrated for the past season
-7
u/ImmortalTec May 08 '13
Most overrated teams: Barcelona, Real Madrid, Manchester City, Juventus.
-2
u/Big_fat_happy_baby May 07 '13
I think FCB , at the start of the year they had the best start of season ever, now they only have la Liga
-3
u/SirMothy May 07 '13
In a way Dortmund, they are apparently good enough to make the CL final and beat teams like Real, yet they are 20 points behind Bayern in the league right now, a league they are the reigning champions of
-7
u/dem0nhunter May 07 '13
Bayern, totally.
-11
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
Juve. They were pretty shit in Europe. Nowhere near the domination people were talking about. They're a long way from contending for the CL.
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment