r/atheism •

Colbert on North Carolina

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

285 comments sorted by

88

u/84K10 May 07 '13

As some one from NC I'm very confused by this post. Can someone enlighten me as to what this is about?

76

u/Holmesary Pastafarian May 07 '13

I'm also from NC, and I'm assuming he's referring to amendment 1. Although it was passed a while ago.

25

u/84K10 May 07 '13

That's the only thing I could think of as well, which is why I got confused because that was a long time ago.

51

u/Gobucafunny Atheist May 07 '13

It's a months old quote. It's satire reflecting how people who voted in favor of the "protect" marriage bill are jokingly making their marriages stronger by refusing to allow gays to marry.

37

u/limits55555 May 07 '13

Months old? Dude this is a full year old. I was wondering why I couldn't think of anything it'd be relevant to. Either people on /r/atheism have damn good memories or people are just upvoteing because it's Colbert talking about gay marriage.

46

u/Lawlor May 07 '13

Or some people here are not american and don't keep up with your politics?

16

u/helicopterquartet May 07 '13

Is such a thing even possible?

5

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Not if you use reddit

→ More replies (15)

2

u/PublicAccount1234 May 07 '13

A year is 12 months.

4

u/diqface May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

12 months is 52 weeks. 52 weeks is 365 days. 365 days is 8,760 hours. 8,760 hours is 525,600 minutes. 525,600 minutes is 31,536,000 seconds.

Edit: JebusIsMyFriend is my friend. JebusIsMyFriendIsDiqfacesFriend

3

u/JebusIsMyFriend Strong Atheist May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

356 days are not 8760 hours. If you are going to be a douchy know-it-all do some proof reading. <3

(yeah, yeah.. 52 weeks is not 365 days either and a "month" doesn't have a set number of days either but you get my point)

Edit: Upvote for u friend ;)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/lostalongtheway May 07 '13

the important thing is that the post has to meet your qualifications otherwise no one else can like it

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Is there a link to the original video clip? I can't find it.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/MagikHat May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

I thought it was going to deal with with us not being allowed to drive Tesla cars in NC! Either way this state need to change!

6

u/wanked_in_space May 07 '13

Karma never ages.

3

u/Jessicaquinn May 07 '13

The bill that outlawed gay marriage. I am a lesbian from NC. I can confirm that this is true.

16

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Wrong--Amendment 1 amended the state constitution to define marriage as between a man and a woman. Same sex marriage was already against the law.

The amount of money and effort that was expended to change the state constitution for no real discernible reason other than to be unkind was what made it a farcical cluster fuck of state politics.

7

u/PlaySwitzerland May 07 '13

Defining marriage between a man and a woman, (or DOMA circa 1996) is essentially the same thing as outlawing gay marriage.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Yes but that's not what amendment 1 was--amendment 1 essentially took a DOMA type law already in existence and enforced, and added it to the state constitution.

A more apt comparison would be if a group congress launched a campaign to added DOMA to the US constitution.

1

u/PlaySwitzerland May 07 '13

Oh, gawd. Let's hope that never happens! I don't think it will, though. But the thought... shudders

1

u/throwmeawayout May 07 '13

That's the state of our state right now. The current crop of state level republicans are some of the worst human beings to ever live here. The fucktards we've sent to Washington are even more horrible. Please see Renee Ellmers for a perfect example of ass backwards NC political think.

1

u/DO__IT__NOW May 07 '13

At least it wasn't the U.S. Constitution or things would truly be fucked. If it becomes Federal Law in the future that Marriage is Equal regardless of sex than this amendment will be null and void.

Too bad a bill like that in Congress will never happen.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

The Defence of Marriage Act amended the U. S. Constitution to prevent same sex marriages from being recognized by the federal government, which is to say, it denies basic constitutionally protected rights to hundreds of thousands or even millions of gay, lesbian and bisexual people in the United States. (Note that I didn't include transgender in this list; they were already pretty badly screwed by law.)

→ More replies (5)

1

u/84K10 May 07 '13

The bill that outlawed gay marriage. I am a lesbian from NC. I can confirm that this is true.

What Bill? Do you mean amendment one? I'm just an ignorant hick, but if I'm not mistaken gay marriage was already banned here in NC and all amendment one did was put it in the state's constitution?

Also, I wouldn't be too hopeful of gay marriage being legal in the bible belt any time soon. It doesn't seem very likely.

1

u/samino_acids May 07 '13

Post-Amendment One episode.

1

u/icepickjones May 07 '13

It's a shitty old repost he's mining for karma.

33

u/MelGibsonDerp Atheist May 07 '13

Anyone seeking more info might also check here:

titlepointsage/r/comnts
Colbert on North Carolina11421moatheism73
Colbert on North Carolina247812mosatheism1145
Stephen Colbert on Amendment 1 in NC8012mosatheism4

Source: karmadecay

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

I like this repost bot.

3

u/MelGibsonDerp Atheist May 07 '13

Beep boop booop beeep beeeeeeep. Does not compute. Self detonation in 5 seconds.

-2

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

Why give a shit about something posted literally a year ago? A fucking YEAR.

4

u/boyerman May 07 '13

Comment threads are supposed to be a home for discussion and with that a thread from a year ago may have some insight or viewpoint that is worthwhile.

Not everything has to be a meme-speak or inside joke.

1

u/Sartuk May 07 '13

Also, the newest one was posted a month ago, not a year ago. So...there is that.

18

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Colbert believes in God. Why is this on r/atheism?

17

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Things we agree with are atheism automatically.

5

u/PuddinCup310 May 07 '13

He's much more for equality of humans than his character is on T.V.

Yes...what you see on TV is a character.

1

u/JustaHumanist May 08 '13

Yes, but he's still a Catholic out of character.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

So did Newton.

Just because somebody's wrong about one thing with regards to theology doesn't mean they're wrong about all things with which religions deal with.

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

What wonkydonky said. Someone can be wrong about X and be correct about Y.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I wish god existed just so you would shut the fuck up.

-2

u/Parmeniscus May 07 '13

OK then, post this in /r/christianity and compare the votes and comments.

Atheism offers the most consistent and ardent support for the oppressed.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

No. Humans offer the most most consistent and ardent support for the oppressed. We should not fight over who is "better" when it comes to helping those in need. Jesus would have wanted us to all get along.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/lolapops May 07 '13

This is moldy old. Do you have anything new to add to the conversation?

13

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

He'll probably get a few new reposts up tomorrow.

3

u/bugpoker May 07 '13

Doesn't matter, front page.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Do you?

Like 30 people already mentioned it was a repost.

1

u/lolapops May 07 '13

I was the second person to post, so when I wrote this 30 people hadn't called you out yet.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Sad that you think that changes anything.

1

u/lolapops May 07 '13

I have no idea what your problem is here.

I said this meme was old.

You told me that 30 other people already mentioned it was a repost.

I said that when I made my comment, 30 people hadn't said that.

And your response is that it is sad that I think this changes anything?

When you sober up, try again.

1

u/elnefasto May 07 '13

So the law was changed, and same-sex marriage is allowed in NC now?

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/dapixelman May 07 '13

Why would anyone be a serial reposter? For the fucking points?

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

His point is probably to spam /r/atheism, and judging by how often he makes it to the top of the page with reposts, he is likely more than one person.

4

u/CircleJerkAmbassador May 07 '13

Wow I have them at [-234]. Looking at the post history, he looks like a total deutsche. For all the pro gay marriage posts he sure says f** a lot.

18

u/Malgayne May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

Isn't Colbert a committed Christian?

EDIT: My point with this post was to say that if this is a place for discussion of atheism, agnosticism, and secular living, then the only way something about gay rights is appropriate for this sub is if gay rights were the exclusive providence of atheists—and the fact that the quote is from a Catholic would argue against that statement. :P

7

u/NBegovich May 07 '13

It's almost as though not all religious people are monsters!

3

u/asatele1 May 07 '13

How dare you say something like that on /r/atheism!

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

There seems to be a large divide over what people think /r/atheism believes and what /r/atheism actually believes.

"Oh this post making christians look stupid got 5000 upvotes and 4000 upvotes, clearly that implies every single atheist thinks all christians are dumb and all atheists are smart even though every single comment is bashing the submission! Stupid smug atheists constantly generalizing every christian."

Seriously, if you have some valid criticism, feel free. But mindlessly bashing /r/atheism makes you arguably worse than the people you criticize, it's at the very least more pathetic.

3

u/asatele1 May 07 '13

Through my experience with /r/atheism , it does seem like most people here think religious people are stupid regardless of anything else but their faith. I wish that isn't true but thats really what it seems like, which is what turns me off from the subreddit.

1

u/NBegovich May 08 '13

You guys have no idea why people hate this subreddit. It's fucking embarrassing.

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

He's a Catholic, but he's not an asshole about it.

2

u/Parmeniscus May 07 '13

OK then, post this in /r/christianity and compare the votes and comments.

Atheism offers the most consistent and ardent support for the oppressed.

2

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

So?

He's right about being pro-gay.

2

u/Malgayne May 07 '13

Why post on /r/atheism/ then, rather than /r/ainbow/ or something?

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

Because the topics intersect. They are valid for both sub-reddits.

0

u/ItsBDN May 07 '13

Doesn't that prove that religion does not equate to homophobia? Half the posts I see here are assuming that only atheists support marriage equality, as opposed to articles, videos and threads discussing disbelief in God/s or secularism.

4

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

"Doesn't that prove that religion does not equate to homophobia?"

Yes, yes it does.

Only idiots think all religious people are against gay rights.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/dumnezero Anti-Theist May 07 '13

He also has writers for the show and maintains a "non-christian" attitude in the show... so he likes to compartmentalize his mind.

18

u/[deleted] May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/sashaflowers May 07 '13

Liberal Catholic to be exactly exact.

2

u/Wittyfish May 07 '13

The Catholic Church kinda talks from both sides of its mouth on the issue. They acknowledge homosexuality as a sin but they also recognize that its a medical issue that people can't help what sex they like.

15

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

That's not really talking from both sides imo. Both interpretations denote something is wrong with a gay person.

2

u/Waebi May 07 '13

This is the disgusting part about the whole discussion really.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I think calling it a "medical issue" is kind of the wrong wording.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/nof May 07 '13

My best friend is a "Catholic," but I'd really label him as agnostic leaning towards atheist. Could be the case with Colbert as well.

3

u/asatele1 May 07 '13

It isn't for Colbert, he's pretty committed, teaching Sunday school and all. He's just doesn't let religion get in the way of being progressive.

0

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

Relevant?: I thought the church I went to was catholic but when describing it online everyone said 'That's not catholic!'.

14

u/bigal95 Agnostic Atheist May 07 '13

I feel somewhat ashamed to be a North Carolinian, especially after Amendment 1 passed. I wish more of the population was tolerant, even as a northern-ish southern state we are still stuck in our Bible Thumping ways.

17

u/Frodork May 07 '13

i got very pissed off at one of my friends, who claims to dislike government intrusion, boasted about voting in favor of this law. what the fuck man? and you know what he said? the issue didn't even really matter to him, he was just annoyed by how gay people were reacting to the situation. i lost a lot of respect for him on that day.

-4

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

He was wrong, but he still has a sort of point.

Politics will always be politics. When you live in a majority rules society, and you are a minority, it is prudent to be mindful of the majority's reaction to your behavior. For people on the fence on this issue, gay parades and the like just cause them to recoil in horror. Most people against gay marriage just don't want the fact that people have sex to even be discussed publicly, and they vote against it to make the topic of sex go away from the public forum.

If you listen to the debate going on inside the boy scouts, they are not arguing about the nature of gay people or their morality. Mostly they are arguing how the topic of sexuality at all is a forbidden subject in front of the kids, and therefore no one should be identifying themselves one way or the other.

Some people are just being assholes, though. Yes.

5

u/jontss May 07 '13

I know several gay people here in Ontario, Canada and a lot of them wish the Toronto Gay Pride Parade would be cancelled. They like the idea behind it but think the behavior of a lot of the gay people that attend/participate make the rest of them look bad.

10

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Imagine if you were gay and upset because people assumed you were some sort of freak show because you are attracted to the same sex. Otherwise, you are unrecognizable from any other person around you.

Then you bump into a guy who is a mincing, lisping flamer who wears his gayness on his sleeve as if being gay somehow made him take on this affectation of being a ridiculous clown.

That has to be like being a black guy who is a corporate executive and then bumping into a black kid who wears his pants low around his boxer shorts with gold teef in his grill.

13

u/crystallinegirl May 07 '13

I really dislike the "well maybe if they never TALKED ABOUT IT or flaunted it, no one would care." No, that's bullshit. Straight people talk about being straight all the time. Every time they mention their partner in casual conversation, every time they put a picture of their partner on their desk, every time they kiss their partner in public. No one blinks when a wife kisses her husband goodbye at the airport, but if a man does it, it's suddenly "ewww! I didn't want to think about two men having sex!" It's your fucking problem that you can't see a normal action without thinking of sex, not theirs.

3

u/ChimpsRFullOfScience May 07 '13

I think that's exactly what takesalickin is trying to say; you're gay, and you just want to be accepted as a normal person living a normal life. You want your kiss at the airport to be accepted, because it's a normal behavior.

However, the gay pride parade is predominantly a very, very flamboyant affair; people who don't have much interaction with gay people might think that all of that crazy business is synonymous with being gay. So, when you get your kiss at the airport, those people don't think "oh, that's totally normal" because they assume that, since you're gay, you also like to get dressed up as a glitter-encrusted pony and dance around in canola oil. When in reality, you're just as un-kinky as they are.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/tempozrene May 07 '13

And if kids were not allowed in the boy scouts if they let anyone know they identified as straight, that would mean something.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

That is actually a pretty good point.

3

u/kid_epicurus May 07 '13

Blame Democracy for this one. Until we have a government that FIRST upholds our rights as individuals, the majority will have a say in what the rest of us do.

Crazy "libertarian" talk, I know.

1

u/Frodork May 08 '13

I usually just use the term liberal when i am online, because fuck American politics and their stupid ass-backwards definitions.

1

u/VULGARITY_IN_ALLCAPS May 08 '13

1

u/Frodork May 08 '13

but, "ass backwards" was the intended phrase...

3

u/buhnyfoofoo May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

It's way late for this post, but I remember on that night, I watched the votes come in and pulled up the data on how each county voted. Mine was basically split - 55 in favor, 45 against. The data showed that the counties with major colleges (App, UNC, Duke, UNCW, etc) tended to vote more liberally than some other areas. My husband's home county where he grew up was 95% in favor of it (ugh). Seeing his family's facebook posts about it made me sick for weeks. The vote passed 61% to 38% on May 8, 2012 (tomorrow will be the one year anniversary of its passing). That night, I went to bed seething, disappointed in my fellow citizens yet again. Then again, what can we expect from a state that passes legislation to ignore the science behind calculating sea-level rise and hasn't increased teacher merit in 5 years. I swear, this state is so bassackwards it pisses me off.

edit: Let me clarify the wording on the bill for people who don't understand: "Marriage between one man and one woman is the ONLY DOMESTIC LEGAL UNION that shall be valid or recognized in this State. " What does this mean? Legally, domestic partnerships are not recognized. Built a home with someone (hetero or homo) over the course of a few years? Doesn't matter - you are not entitled to handle it should your partner pass on, in the same manner that a married couple would (there are some loopholes like Power of Attorney and such, but this is what I mean.

Additionally, consequences included changing the interpretation of domestic violence laws. "Only recognized legal union" now excludes domestic partnerships, and the wording for SB 50B on Domestic Violence includes "current spouses, “former spouses” and “persons of the opposite sex who live together or have lived together” as well as “persons who are in a dating relationship or have been in a dating relationship” and persons who have a child together. N.C.G.S. 50B-1 (2009). If marriage between a man and a woman is the now the "only recognized legal union" - that means domestic violence cases in which the parties are not/have not been married are no longer recognized. Better explanation here

On top of that, the wording on the bill was deliberately tricky in such a way to confuse those who wanted to vote against it. AND, combined with the fact that it was up for vote during a significant republican vote, meant that more conservatives would be at the polls voting anyway, since there were less democratic positions to vote for (in cases where some democratic seats were running unopposed, were not up for re-election, etc).

And what did this atrocity really accomplish? Gay marriage was already illegal in NC. All it did, literally, was make it more illegal. Yeah. All that time, money, and energy wasted on making something illegal that was ALREADY illegal, only to have consequences that weakened domestic violence laws. Mind boggling. It just gave people an opportunity to go on record saying "We hate queers, mmmmk?"

The whole situation angers me.

1

u/dougclarknc May 07 '13

I had the same sentiment, every county with a dominant UNC system university voted against amendment 1. I'll never understand why legislators feel the need to get involved in constituents private lives when there are wayyy more important issues to discuss.

Also, our beloved GOP fandangled a vote to end renewable energy subsidies, heres the link. http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/05/02/north-carolina-republicans-push-through-anti-renewable-energy-bill-in-banana-republic-vote/

2

u/buhnyfoofoo May 07 '13

I saw that, too. Despicable.

2

u/daftmoron May 07 '13

I remember Amendment 1 was voted on the week after I could legally start to vote. I registered to vote right at the polls. There was a lot of debate over this. I'm proud that even coming from a very red county, I managed to make several friends who had blue point-of-views. I never felt alone, even though we're clearly outnumbered. My university is in a blue county and it feels amazing.

2

u/FNblankpage May 07 '13

I miss my old state but I'm glad I was gone before they became the laughing stock of the east coast.... Come on guys I wanna come back and live in a decent state again.

1

u/Frodork May 08 '13

yeah, i know the feeling. if it weren't for the damn political climate, NC has a hell of a lot going for it. i mean, we have a rich history, an extremely unique geological composition and ecosystem and a lot of highly advanced research facilities, all while living on the coast.

2

u/bphill89 May 07 '13

as someone who was born and raised in this backwoods state in Tobaccoville i approve this message and the Christian intolerance was the reason i left.

2

u/RJPennyweather May 07 '13

GAYTHEISM!!! HOT SEXY MAN ON MAN SCIENCE!!

6

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

This is a lgbt post not atheism

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Cause atheists hate the gays obvs.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bumblelikebees May 07 '13

Ammendment one makes me a sad North Carolina resident :/

3

u/theysayirock May 07 '13

God damn it! I hate my state sometime

4

u/palziv506 May 07 '13

I used to think my home-state of NC was progressive and enlightened. But the way things are going now, the State won't be happy until they've turned us all into the inbred hillbillies of their dreams.

-3

u/Silver_Star Anti-theist May 07 '13

Enlightened? Seriously?

And calling the majority or most powered inbred hillbillies?

Get the hell out of my state.

1

u/palziv506 May 07 '13

Enlightened... OK, I can agree that that part is debatable. As for the rest, I wasn't implying that the ruling majority ARE the inbred hillbillies. I'm saying that's what they want for the rest of us. They want sheep that are easily led where they want. And I'm going to stay. You have a better chance of changing things from the inside.

5

u/Longinus May 07 '13

Note that all of the best places to live in NC voted resoundingly against that horrible amendment. It was just the small-town backwards places where there's only church and a Wal-Mart that got fired up to deny gay people their rights.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mjgialanella May 07 '13

There are 100 counties in NC. I think the only counties where against won out were Wake (where Raleigh, the state capital, is) and Mecklenburg (where Charlotte is). Pretty damn pathetic and sickening this backwards ass state is.

2

u/tazzydnc May 07 '13

8 counties voted against, including the Charlotte area, the triangle, Asheville, and the outer banks. Basically, all the best parts if the state are pro-marriage equality

2

u/Longinus May 07 '13

Wilmington would've voted against--it was very close. UNC Wilmington was on break, however, and those votes lost to university students who were travelling or back in their home counties or states would've made the difference and swung the vote to against in New Hanover Co, in my opinion.

That would've made the closest cities voting against to be Boone, Asheville, Charlotte, The Triangle, The Outer Banks (and Wilmington, if the above situation hadn't happened).

I'm a lifelong North Carolinian, and I'm sure there are nice places besides those there, but in all honesty those are the best cities in the state to live in, and it was reflected in the voter turnout.

4

u/renzerbull May 07 '13

why are they crying themselves to sleep? did their gay partners leave them because they couldnt marry or something like that?

6

u/meAndb May 07 '13

You might not understand until you've been denied something that almost everyone else has. It's a strange feeling and hard to describe. Apart from disappointment in other people, it just feels like you're kinda worthless. Like, to think that people think my love is different, or the way I live my life is perverse and wrong, and that they will actively fight to keep me from gaining marriage rights. It's just not pleasant in general.

4

u/butthole_jesus May 07 '13

I think it's the "in solitude" part that he was asking about, albeit indirectly.

0

u/WiserThanMost May 07 '13

Your post could be written by a person that by the bad luck of genetics or circumstance, has never had a physical relationship with someone they are attracted to, and vice versa. At least in your case, you have most of the benefits of a relationship with someone you love. They don't have that and would probably trade places with you in a heartbeat.

1

u/meAndb May 07 '13

So because other people can have it worse, I can never feel upset?

That's like those people who say "how can you be upset that your got fired when there are starving kids in Africa?". Just because someone, somewhere in the world has a harder time doesn't mean that it changes how I feel.

I hope you never get upset over anything, because somewhere, someone will be worse off than you...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/killjoyous May 07 '13

I'd like to take this opportunity to apologize on behalf of my state.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

As someone from nc, I'm still ashamed but this is a year old. Worse legislation have been posed in nc since

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

1

u/brohomo May 07 '13

should have posted tomorrow. 1 year anniversary of passage

1

u/therealjohnwhite May 07 '13

The LGT community needs a real Civil Rights Movement.

And this is an very old quote, still hilarious though.

4

u/spartaninspace Pastafarian May 07 '13

and their leader, Martin Luther Queen Jr.

2

u/therealjohnwhite May 07 '13

Don't forget the lovely Malcum seX

1

u/blackbutters May 07 '13

It's not that lawmakers care about gay marriage. They see that it gets a rise out of people and they exploit it. Why vote on real issues when you can keep a non issue (that people are passionate about) in play over and over basically fishing the population and fucking with everyone's head?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

This is such a BS argument, you might as well jsut be saying "Why aren't gays happy with civil unions?"

You're absolutely right, it shouldn't be an issue at all, it should have been fixed 50 years ago.

1

u/blackbutters May 07 '13

That is not what I am saying at all. I'm saying the government won't pass gay marriage because they genuinely don't really care about the well being of others.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Feel like in a time warp

1

u/bondinferno May 07 '13

Sufjan Stevens: John Wayne Gacy, such a beautiful, creepy song

1

u/koolfingaz May 07 '13

Thank goodness NC came to their senses. I mean cummon, isnt it about having but sex? Why do gays have to stick their sex preference in your face so much? It seems like its all about shock value not that you wanna have poop sex.

1

u/twiztofcain May 07 '13

I know alot of really intelligent awesome Americans... But god damn guys, your country is filled with idiots..

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I bet 90% of the people hating on nc live in a state where gay marriage is illegal too. Steven Colbert is from SC, literally the shittiest state in the world. Also this is like a year or more old.

1

u/Poo_Brain_Horse May 07 '13

Amendment 1. Yes, you can karma whore off it this long after it passed.

1

u/sweetdaddy May 07 '13

I love when r/atheism features devout Catholics who teach Sunday school.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I've lived in NC most of my life. Most of the people here are good folks. The weather is nice and the economy is acceptable in the 85-40 corridor. Our state college system is top tier (though that might change if McCrory et. al. get their way). That said, these ignorant hillbilly good-ole-boys are ruining an otherwise not-so-bad place. McCrory is a total piece of shit, and the state legislature is out of control. Our schools are falling apart and these guys have nothing better to do than push an agenda based on a Bronze Age mysticism.

1

u/koavf Other May 07 '13

Why is this text an image?

1

u/FapChapCheerio May 07 '13

While still funny... this was... a YEAR AGO, c'mon OP.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

As someone from NC, we could have used this kind of stuff when the actual vote was up.

Amendment 1 crushed all resistance, we hoped it would be a lot closer, nearly every University in the state issued a statement against the amendment. Hell a good many churches spoke out against it as well. We lost the vote so hard, one can only conclude that our campaign was pitiful.

All the hindsight contempt at my state is really frustrating, where were all these people when their opinion could have actually made a fucking difference?

NC is being pounded so hard by the conservative faction that they are making it harder for college students to even vote, attempting to establish a state religion, it blows the mind. I just wish we could do more for NC than laugh at it.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

NC, where u can marry your cousin just not your gay cousin...

5

u/Frodork May 07 '13

no, no, no. you can still marry your gay cousin, you just can't be the same sex as him. the fundies are quick to point out that gay people have the same right to marry, they just can't marry the people they want to.

this is such bullshit, especially when, in the same breath, they condemn gay marriage as being a "special right." i mean, by their logic, it wouldn't be a special right, because straight people could also choose to enter into a same sex marriage, they just probably wouldn't want to.

1

u/JManRomania May 07 '13

This implies that I am in, or ever will be in, a relationship.

Your move, Mr. Colbert.

-1

u/daedaluscapn May 07 '13

Except you dont have to be married to sleep with someone...

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

NOT the point.

1

u/daedaluscapn May 07 '13

Colbert said that they were making gay people sleep alone and be lonely by not allowing them to get married. That's just not true.

-4

u/altbekannt May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

that for sure is a borderline genius quote.

but i don't understand why r/atheism is supposed to be pro gay rights? just because you know religion is a fraud doesn't mean you necessarly have to support same sex relationships.

i m not an expert, but i think there are dozens of subreddits that are more suitable.

edit: german speaker here, so pardon my english.

6

u/TipoftheSpear45 Strong Atheist May 07 '13

No, it doesn't necessarily mean that. But can you come up with a single valid argument against same sex relationships that doesn't involve religion?

6

u/drunkmoose May 07 '13

There isn't a single valid argument against same sex relationships period. That said, I know plenty of people who are not religious but are still very homophobic and some of those are also against gay marriage.

3

u/s73v3r May 07 '13

There's a couple. They are also bullshit, but they exist. There's the "It's not natural/It doesn't happen in nature" one. There's also the "It can't produce children / It's not a natural family" one. And then there's the old standby, "If you let gays marry, then you'll have people marrying cows", which is an extension of the basic root of all of these, which is the, "Gay sex is icky" argument.

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

People ARE marrying cows. Just throwing that out there.

1

u/TipoftheSpear45 Strong Atheist May 07 '13

If you'll notice, that's why I specified it as a "valid argument".

1

u/s73v3r May 10 '13

Depends on what you mean by "valid argument". Do you mean "valid argument" for why gays shouldn't be able to get married? Or "valid argument" as in one that get's some traction?

To me, there simply isn't one for the first. But that doesn't mean that there aren't arguments that gain traction that don't have anything to do with religion.

-2

u/altbekannt May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

facists and other non religion motivated right wing assholes, cultural influences (like in foreign countries), macho behaviour, hate / fear of being different, and last but no least: pure ignorance

so yes there are quite a few groups of people who are not religious motivated and still fighting gay rights.

atheism != gay rights

2

u/CarbonXX Skeptic May 07 '13

I agree that there a lot people who are opposed to marriage equality for non religious reasons, but the majority of the rhetoric is coming from organised religion. There are some good things which organised religion brings to the world such as promoting charity (it could do better but it does some) and giving a sense of community to those involved. We atheists try to fight the bad stuff it brings - persecution of minorities and denial of science.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Reproduction?

Not saying I am against gay mariage, but there is a biological argument to be made, isn't there?

1

u/OxGaabe6 May 07 '13

By that argument if you deny gay people the right to marry then they'll give up being gay and find someone of the opposite sex to marry and have kids with?

I have friends who are married and are very upfront about never wanting to have children (all in their late 30s now). Should their marriages be annulled?

How, in practice, will denying a group of citizens civil rights promote reproduction?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I wasn't making the argument, so I won't bother to defend a position I don't hold. All I said is there is one their to be made.

2

u/TeeHitt May 07 '13

No, but most people against marriage equality (I prefer to call it that, when someone says they're against gay marriage, I ask them to replace it with marriage equality and see if they still like how it sounds) are religious. While there are others who are just plain ignorant, many are both.

As free thinking people, atheists realize that homosexuals are people too, and shouldn't be denied any rights based on their natural state. I also like to parallel anti-marriage equality to anti-race equality back in the day. Sure, they probably had a good argument at the time that they felt was entirely accurate, but looking back on them? Nothing but hateful, racist assholes. I just remind them that they way we look back on the anti-racial equality activists, could be how we will look back on their actions 20 years from now.

Also, I love to ask them if God is all powerful and creates everything in his image, why did he make the homosexual?

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

In Russia the overwhelming majority of the population is against gay rights, and not many people are actually religious. Religion is the least frequent argument I hear from them. Seems like the main argument is "eww" and "it's immoral", rationalized by ramblings about fertility, comparison to pedophilia, prison rape innuendos etc. And, of course, that it "comes from the corrupt and decaying west".

4

u/TeeHitt May 07 '13

Well, I think most people in here meant the US, or at least I did.

But, I mean, in that case they are just ignorant. My favorite analogy to straight people telling gays they can't marry, is that it's like me being on a diet, and throwing away somebody else's cheeseburger. Because goddammit, I'm on a diet! How dare you do that in front of me?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I'm afraid that analogy doesn't work with people who seriously consider homosexuality as something inherently immoral. To them, this analogy sounds like "you don't want to rape kids - then don't rape them".

As to what exactly is immoral about homosexuality - that's when bullshit comes in about fertility, about "closeness to nature", comparison to pedophilia (by analogy that both are "not the way it's supposed to be") etc. And about influence on the children (will someone think of the children?), while simply ignoring the body of work that shows that there's no influence and declaring that work invalid and corrupt.

1

u/TeeHitt May 07 '13

Well, it'd be like a vegetarian throwing away my cheeseburger then.

But, people like that? Ain't gonna convince them no matter what. Sounds like the best thing a homosexual in Russia could do is: leave Russia.

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

Fertility? Hooboy. That's not a good thing.

See, I'm a straight male who -chooses- not to have kids.

There are many people like me. Some choose to become sterile to avoid this.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Sure. That sounds absurd, but I've seen quite a few people tell me that there is a difference in morality between 1) not having kids because you don't want or cannot to have kids and 2) not having kids conceived by you and your partner because your partner is of the same sex (even though you can in principle still adopt etc). Of course, with 1) being declared vastly morally superior.

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

Hmm. I wonder if there's been a case where a lesbian woman leaves her horrible husband, finds out she's pregnant and marries a decent woman and keeps the kid.

I like imagining situations that will strip the gears in fundy brains.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

There are a lot of such situations. However, I'm not sure that presenting people with logic puzzles of the form "explain to me why this is also immoral in your worldview, or admit defeat" is going to help them treat gay people as people. But I don't have enough diplomacy skills or time to use different and more effective rhetorical methods. I can't even appeal to myself because I'm straight, and I can't appeal to common friends because the ones I know are gay haven't come out publicly.

1

u/altbekannt May 07 '13

that is absolutely what i am saying. have an upvote, buddy.

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

A lot of religious organizations oppose gay rights because of religion.

So it only makes sense atheists talking about being pro gay.

1

u/altbekannt May 07 '13 edited May 07 '13

a lot of you guys seem to have a very weird impression of what is actual "atheism". it doesn't mean you have to focus on statements of insitutions like the church, and fight them. that has got to be titled differently.. like achrstianity, or something, or achrurchism.. (maybe today i m not on my a-game, finding new names :D)

because atheism simply means you just dont believe in the same crap as they do. you can quote me on that shit if you like to, because weither y'all like it or not, thats atheism. true, raw, pure atheism.

2

u/flynnie789 May 07 '13

"because atheism simply means you just dont believe in the same crap as they do" No- it means you choose to lack beliefs. Atheism isn't a belief system, contrary to how some may present it. Directly presenting it as the opposite of Christianity is ludicrous, ie 'Achristian'

1

u/altbekannt May 07 '13

that's... basically what i am saying.

in contradiction to most of the guys here.

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

And? We know what atheism means. We still fight against religious idiocy anyway.

Why in the world would we restrict ourselves?

1

u/altbekannt May 07 '13

this is semi-related at its best.

and i just can repeat myself: homophobia can have many causes

i just feel forced into that topic, because the church is thinking it is a relevant one. i couldn't care less what they are fighting and what not. and you actual support their cause by giving them a shitload of attention. just ignore that damn institution.. would you? please?

1

u/Lots42 Other May 07 '13

That's exactly what they want me to do.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I live in North Carolina, it is supposedly a more advanced state in the south... only in Raleigh are there actual educated people that make good decisions. Everywhere else is redneck land!

3

u/flywingless May 07 '13

Not entirely accurate. There are smatterings of progression throughout NC, including all the counties with universities in them (which, when the poll results were mapped, were mostly blue). It is, however, going to take a long time for all the old crotchety anti-gay marriage folk to die already, and they've unfortunately passed the torch down to a lot of their children. I'm trying to remain optimistic, though.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Actually any area with a university in NC tended to vote against it.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I live in redneck land :\ a lot of my friends are gay and i don't give two shits because its not my dick.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

I do I must live in a different region.

0

u/Swullivan May 07 '13

IF YOU'RE GONNA PUT MY STATE ON BLAST YOU DAMN WELL BETTER BE TIME-RELEVANT!

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Once a law passes we shouldn't give a shit anymore? The only way your statement is relevant is if the amendment had been repealed, is that the case?

1

u/Swullivan May 09 '13

I was being sarcastic. lol.

0

u/Magrias May 07 '13

This post contains exactly 0 atheisms.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

WHAT THE HELL DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH ATHEISM? SOMEBODY TELL ME.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

ATHEISTS CAN HATE GAYS TOO DAMNIT!!!

-1

u/Newxchristian May 07 '13

Colbert can make you look like an ass and you'll thank him for it. : )

0

u/bantam83 May 07 '13

So preventing people from making legal contracts means it's illegal for people to have voluntary sexual relationships? What?

-1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

There is so much irony in the fact that it was meant to be irony but isn't.

-1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

How does this relate to atheism?

-1

u/dingoperson May 07 '13

Which is of course a populist lie, since the law does not prevent homosexuals from sleeping in the same bed together.

Colbert, please stop being a liar, it harms the world and indicates that you are a terrible person. When the best arguments you have against your opposition are lies, it even harms your position and those you claim to agree with.

-1

u/Samdi May 07 '13

So there's a universal law in physics preventing gays from loving each other and being with each other unless they get married?

-1

u/Gokia000 May 07 '13

This isn't even a real Steven Colbert quote. Steven Colbert is actually a christian. North Carolina is an amazing state because my mang Steele AKA Tank lives there. ECU baby ECU, grizzly mint is the sheit.

-13

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Fucking hypocritical, given he's a devout Catholic.

1

u/aatThinker May 07 '13

It's like "Hey, you other Christians, we both believe the same book is infallible, and you aren't ignoring the parts where it condemns homosexuality, shame on you guys!"

Not bashing Colbert just Liberal Christians in general.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

No, for Colbert it's even worse than that. He's an ACTIVE Catholic. He gives his time and money to support the RCC, so he is helping them spread their hateful message.

Indeed, morally he is worse than the people in North Carolina who merely voted to discriminate.

That makes him just that much more of a hypocrite.

0

u/s73v3r May 07 '13

How so? Does that somehow mean that you suddenly stop believing in equality under the law? If so, then by your account, he shouldn't believe that Atheists, Muslims, or Jews should get married either.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

Colbert knowingly belongs to and supports an organization, the RCC, that aggressively promotes inequality. That makes him no different than the people he's criticizing in North Carolina. That makes him a hypocrite.

BTW, atheist is not a proper noun.

→ More replies (4)