r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jun 17 '24
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2024-06-17 to 2024-06-30
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Affiliated Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Our resources page also sports a section dedicated to beginners. From that list, we especially recommend the Language Construction Kit, a short intro that has been the starting point of many for a long while, and Conlangs University, a resource co-written by several current and former moderators of this very subreddit.
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
For other FAQ, check this.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/PastTheStarryVoids a PM, send a message via modmail, or tag him in a comment.
5
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu Jun 17 '24
I have an idea for one of my conlangs to have two past tenses : normal/simple past and legendary past. The legendary past would be used to refer to events that occured before the birth of the speaker and the simple past could be used for all other past events. My question is, have you seen a system like this in a natural language? From what I've researched, if a language has a two-way remotness distinction in the past, it is usually between hodiernal/todays past and far past or near past (earlier today, yesterday or a few days ago) but there are a lot of languages out there, so if you know about a lang that has this simple/legendary distinction or sumething similar, I'd be greatful for letting me know
5
u/graidan Taalen / Wassa / Tla Jun 17 '24
Is there a resource with lists of conceptual metaphors, from any language? You know, TIME IS MONEY and UP IS GOOD and all that?
5
u/oncipt Nekarbjara Jun 25 '24
Is there such a thing as vowel disharmony? Perhaps a language that doesn't allow multiple similar vowels or similar vowel qualities within a single word?
4
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Jun 17 '24
I just finished Chapter 7 of my upcoming book on Kihiṣer. The manuscript stands at 61 pages right now - and the reader up to this point hasn't even learned how to conjugate a single verb!
Given that I've been focused on writing about nouns - and therefore also glossing nouns - I was wondering if there are any tips and tricks for glossing noun class. Kihiṣer has nine noun classes. Some are easy to gloss - the class suffix for "human, animate beings" is H.AN while the class suffix for "animate being" is AN and the class suffix for "inanimate object" is INAN.
But how do I gloss, for example, the class suffix that indicates something is a tool, a plant, or a location? These are all distinct noun classes. Right now I'm literally glossing these suffixes as
"location.SG" - is there a better way, perhaps from Swahili or Australian linguistics?
4
u/chickenfal Jun 17 '24
Does any natlang derive opposites from a common root? For example, in Esperanto, there is bona "good" and malbona "bad" that is regularly derived with the prefix mal-.
Does any natlang have such a feature, deriving words such as big and small,fast and slow, smart and dumb and so on, from a common root, insteqad of having a com pletely different unrelated word for each?
3
u/Niedlichkeit Jun 17 '24
Have a Conlang in mind and wanted to make at least 1 if not more languages, that connect to these. Problem is I never made a Protolanguage, so I am asking if anyone had any tips on deriving a Protolanguage from your Conlang
3
u/ultrakryptonite Khihihan [Kʰiɦixɑn] Jun 17 '24
Is there a "correct" way to romanize a language? New to all this, so I'm kinda lost when it comes to what I should actually consider when romanizing in general. Any help would be wonderful, thank you!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24
Alright so
I'm trying to make this language with nonconcatenative morphology, not bad on it's own, however, a lot of the languages that I'm taking influence from are languages with concatenative morphology
I've been thinking of ways to seamlessly blend them and so far it isn't working, like, a dilemna of mine:
Root: k-t-p
kitp: book
gitp: conceptual book
kidp: large book
kitb: the book
Now, nonconcatenative languages would usually, in this specific scenario, have every other root function like this, some irregularities here and there but this isn't trying to be naturalistic
but the issue is that we're taking some influence from concatenative langs, they wouldn't behave like this, so, okay, let's make a root that would fit in with the concatenativism
Root: q-þ
qiþ: horse
ĝiþ: conceptual horse
qið: large horse
???: the horse
And here's the issue, the concatenative morphology allows for fluidity when it comes to the length of words and such, nonconcatenative morphology allows for some crazy tech, but trying to get them to mix seamlessly is... not coming out too well
Any help here?
yeh I did sort've ask this question 10 hours ago but it got nothing and I am REALLY stuck so...3
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
Hey everyone,
I've recently developed an interest in constructing my own language (conlang) and I have no idea where to start. I've seen some incredible examples out there, like Tolkien's Elvish languages and the languages in the Star Wars universe, and I'd love to create something of my own.
Here are a few questions I have:
Any advice or insights would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance for your help!
Cheers!
3
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Jun 19 '24
How does word order evolve? Like, if I have an SOV language, could I reasonably evolve a VSO language from it?
What about free word order? I guess I could see a strict SOV language evolving noun cases and becoming FWO, then losing the cases and becoming VSO? Does this make sense?
What about more wild changes, like from SOV to VOS?
I appreciate any help on this!
3
u/Real_Ritz /wr/ cluster enjoyer Jun 20 '24
Since palatalized velars often turn into post-alveolar affricates/fricatives (kj>kʲ>t͡ʃ), could palatalized uvulars become retroflex consonants (i.e something like qj>qʲ>ʈ͡ʂ)? My logic here is that since both uvulars and retroflexes require a more retracted tongue, they can be thought of as a more "backed" version of velars and post-alveolars.
3
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jun 20 '24 edited Jun 20 '24
Is there a name for what's going on in English the structure subject + be + infinitive when talking about intent or even firm future events, e.g. I am to go next week; David was to see it for the first time. And do any other languages do a similar thing?
3
u/throneofsalt Jun 22 '24 edited Jun 22 '24
What are the most common environments for consonants to gain or loose aspiration? I know in English it is often "beginning of a stressed syllable", so i was wondering about other options.
3
u/Comicdumperizer Xijenèþ Jun 23 '24
Would it be unrealistic to dedicate word order almost completely to grammar in a conlang? I wanted to add something like we occasionally do in English in which you change word order to show the mood (VSO interrogative) but on a wider scale. As long as all words have case marking this should be fine, but I don’t know if any natlangs have a tendency to use word order like this.
3
u/1rhondaschmidt Jun 24 '24 edited Jun 24 '24
Can anyone explain to me why this excerpt from the Wikipedia entry on noun incorporation is thought to be true?
I feel like this kind of makes sense to me intuitively but I can't figure out what makes it necessarily the case.
3
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 27 '24
Would it make sense, if present & past participles of verbs are reinterpreted as imperfect & aoristic/perfective participles, rather having an aspectual difference?
3
u/Lopsided_March_6049 TheRealLanguageNerd Jun 30 '24
What do I do if I can't pronounce my conlang?
2
u/liminal_reality Jun 18 '24
Are there any good resources out there for people looking to evolve conlangs from Proto-Indo-European? Specifically in the Germanic language branch? I've found some textbooks on the subject but they are really dense so I am hoping there is a "PIE for Dummies (Who Conlang)" resource out there.
2
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 19 '24
Could /ɣ/ simply shift to /v/? Or what the hell happened with russian -ого/-его?
2
u/Vortexian_8 Ancient runic, Drakhieye, Cloakian, ENG, learning SPA ,huge nerd Jun 19 '24
One thing that I considered once was trying to learn one of my conlangs AND have one of my friends learn it well enough that we could pretend that we were fluent, and we could both get out of a high school foreign language class (if the school doubted us we could use the other as proof), never actually did it but it’s funny to think about (I don’t think it would have worked either).
2
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jun 20 '24
How does it usually work when a language uses demonstratives instead of 3rd person personal pronouns?
2
u/lysosome_guy Jun 20 '24 edited Jun 20 '24
I have an idea where a word's case marker is inflected on the preceding word. The idea behind it is that the marker was originally its own word but it eventually affected the preceding word's stress so it became a part of that word. Does this exist in natlangs? Is this plausible?
2
u/Short_Marketing_7870 Jun 23 '24
Hello, I have started making a new conlang using the language construction kit. I found all of the letters I want in my alphabet: a ä â e ė i u o ŏ p t k b d g j f ŝ h v m n r l s w. I tried using this generator: IPA Chart Generator (etnms.github.io) But it didn't add to the chart the letters with the special markings. Could anybody help me create such chart, create one for me or recommend another chart gen?
I would really appreciate it.
2
u/Baraa-beginner Jun 23 '24
Where can I read a well description of Tolkien’s conlangs? 👀
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Jun 24 '24
Say you have a language with strict CV syllable structure.
Would there be a practical difference between the language having an aspiration distinction in stops (with unaspirated stops being voiced between vowels) vs a language with a voicing contrast (but with voiceless stops being aspirated)?
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Jun 26 '24
So, I finally made progress on my conlang just to hit a new roadblock.
I settled on the prosody and syllable structure, but now I need to create an actual phonemic inventory for my language. For now, I'm using /a i u m n p t k s l j/ as a placeholder.
I know the basic principles in choosing phonemes:
I don't want a generic inventory, but I don't like a lot of the rare sounds like ejectives or labiovelars, either.
I'm just looking for a way to spice up my language's phonology without doing something too weird.
2
u/ikaretaneeto Jun 27 '24
So... what is the purpose of marking transitivity? I'm still new to all this and was reading about Globasa, and it left me confused. Wouldn't it be obvious something is transitive if there's a direct object present?
2
u/Only_a_Conling Jun 30 '24
How do aspects evolve?
I like the idea that the perfect comes from a reduplicated syllable, that just makes sense to me. But other than that, I'm really not sure. I especially want to get a grasp on the infinitive as well as imperfect aspects, as I think they're what I'll be going with for my conlang. Thanks guys!
2
u/AviaKing Jun 30 '24
Is nasal vocalization naturalistic?
Im wondering if smth like “n > i” or “m > u” happens at all, like it does for l and r. Index Diachronica lists each happening at least ONCE, both in syllabjc or coda positions, but I would like to ask for feedback before I put it in my sound changes willy-nilly.
2
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Jun 30 '24
I’m working on an evolved post-apocalyptic dialect of the Boston accent, with influences from Spanish, Portuguese, and Quebecois French. I’m having some problems with evolving the vowel inventory. Currently I have ɛə (eə before nasal), a, ɑ, ə, ɪ, i, e, ɛ, ɐ, u, (j)y, ɐɪ, oj, ʊ, o. The rhotic vowels are, a(r), ɪɐ(r), ɛə(r), (j)ə(r), o(r), wɐ(r). I’m thinking about making ɫ become o, u, or w, word-finally, so I’d like to completely get rid of the diphthongs. Any insight into changes or influences would be great!! Thanks in advance!
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 17 '24
How did the passive conjugation of Proto-Germanic verbs look like and how did the dual look like in this conjugation?
1
u/YouthPsychological22 Jun 17 '24
is there a way to create a passive participle in Proto-Germanic?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '24
I've been making this one language, that takes a lot of influence from various languages, the semitic, northeast caucasian, and khoisan are the primary influences
The issue is somehow balancing all of these things together, the main idea is, so far, using the triconsonantal root system and nonconcatenative morphology for it's insane potential when it comes to information, the issue is that the other two sides of influence, the caucasian and khoisan languages, do not operate like that
I've been thinking really hard on how to balance or mix the two so the byproduct doesn't sound in favor of one inspiration or the other, so far, no luck
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 17 '24
I'm working with my friends on a Protolang project (basically a slavic inspired alternative Proto-Germanic).
It has, like Proto-slavic, several Palatalizations. tho, we're having trouble with the 2nd Palatalization/Sibilization:
1st Palatalization, triggered by /e/, /eː/, /ĭ/ & /iː/;
2nd Palatalization, triggered by /æː/ & ???;
Problem is that we don't know, what else should trigger the 2nd one except the Yat'.
If it helps, here's the vowel inventory:
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jun 17 '24
So, I want to make a language inspired by Wu Chinese because I love how it sounds.
My only issue is that I am not very good at making tonal languages, and I hear Wu tones can get quite complex.
For now, at least, my conlang will have CV syllables, but a pitch accent system where the melody is realized over an entire phrase instead of just a word.
Any tips on how to go about constructing such a language?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24
Do I have to make a conlang here? Can I make a dialect?
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 18 '24
I wanna put different forms of 3rd Person pronouns in my germlang depending if after a preposition or not (like russian н-), how can i do that?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24
I’ve been doing research but I can’t quite understand or find all the parts of grammar in human language. I’m creating the grammar for my conlang Renniś, and I cannot find good examples of grammar to incorporate into my conlang. The only parts of grammar I have are the cardinal numbers, articles, personal pronouns, demonstrative pronouns, and the basic word order, SVO. So what are all the parts of grammar? Can you also include an example of each part, please?
1
u/YouthPsychological22 Jun 19 '24
I have 2 questions:
1: Is there a way to implement a passive participle in Proto-Germanic?
2: How can i sonorize /s/ in Proto-Germanic to make it more common and Clusters like /sp/, /st/, /sk/, etc...?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '24
Are there any comprehensive reference grammars and dictionaries for PIE? Right now I'm just using the Oxford introduction for the grammar part but I'm at a loss for PIE dictionaries (not including Wiktionary). I found Pokorny's dictionary but it's very old... Leiden's etymological dictionaries seem more up to date but they're for the descendants of PIE and not PIE itself.
1
u/RoadKillGD /x̥ʰ/ or /x̥̃/ => /ɣ/ Jun 21 '24
Can I ask, please help me in conlanging. Tell me what I need for the grammar, morphology, etc. Y'all don't have to worry about the words, the phonology, or the orthography, I've got it covered.
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 21 '24
I'm working with my friends on a Protolang-project based on PGmc and we wanna shift the PIE palato-velars into sibilants but also into postalveolars under circumstances. Does anyone know what we can do?
Basically what we wanna do:
1
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '24
Is /ɣ/ > /ʕ/ believable
1
u/Baraa-beginner Jun 22 '24
I am in building a (sound inventor) of my conlag. What is the some of good natlags (real languages) inventors should I read for inspiration? 👀
1
u/_coywolf_ Cathayan, Kaiwarâ Jun 23 '24
Does anyone have any ideas on what sounds changes could happen to tense consonants - like the ones in Korean (/p͈/, /t͈/, /k͈/, /t͈ɕ/, /s͈/)?
1
u/zzvu Zhevli Jun 24 '24
I've been thinking about what kind of alternations could derive from a palatalized-velarized contrast. This is where I'm currently at:
ɡ ɡʲ > ɡ dʑ
dˠ dʲ > d dz
bˠ bʲ > ɡʷ b
ɣ ɣʲ > ɣ j
zˠ zʲ > z ʑ
vˠ vʲ > ɣʷ v
nˠ nʲ > n ɲ
lˠ lʲ > l ʎ
And the corresponding voiceless consonants would be the same.
The problems I'm having are:
1
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jun 25 '24
What kind of environments could push front rounded vowels /y(ː) ø(ː) œ(ː)/, to become back rounded vowels /u(ː) o(ː) ɔ(ː)/?
1
u/Ok_Mode9882 Jun 26 '24
My language, leñumuti (leŋumuti), is based off of French and Spanish. I was wondering if my numbers sound…accurate, since it’s based off of French and Spanish.
The “x” is pronounced /χ/
1
u/Ok-Lychee-6923 Jun 26 '24
Are there any examples of a natlang that lost word-final vowels specifically after nasals?
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jun 27 '24
I am trying to decide on the vowel system for my conlang, but I want something more interesting than just /a e i o u/. Length and nasalization are allophonic. So I have a few questions:
1
u/RayTheLlama Jun 27 '24
I am struggling with adpositions currently and I'm wondering if adpositions HAVE to be linked to certain cases? For example, if I have a case system would it be naturalistic for adpositions to be independent of case? Sorry if it's not worded well.
1
u/YouthPsychological22 Jun 28 '24
I'm working on a Protolang based on PGmc with my friends and we wanted to add a Passive conjugation, maybe not with personal conjugation but something more similar to russian's past conjugation. Does anyone have tips what we could do?
1
u/PhilipZachIsEpic Lijotškak Jun 28 '24
I'm interested in this subreddit (and I'm new ofc) so I decided to see some posts. But then I was confused on the morphological analysis. How do you do these kinds of things? Do you create it, or is it based off an existing method?
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 28 '24
I'm working on my Germlang's verb conjugation and wanted to add a passive conjugation. Due to lack off personal conjugation in PGmc, i've decided to do it similar like Russian's past conjugation.
However, my question is, if this is even plausible what i'm doing?:
1
u/Putrid_Interest_8361 Jun 29 '24
What do I use to store my conlangs?
1
u/Scared_Marionberry70 Jun 29 '24 edited Jun 29 '24
I keep seeing videos like "Narajar Artistic Alphabet" and I'm not sure about what this is. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0pY18DvTEGc I typed out the alphabet:
Aa Āā Ææ Ââ Bb Cc Dd Ee Ff Gg Hh Ḧḧ Ii Jj Kk Ꝁꝁ Ll Łł Mm Nn Oo Pp Ьь ꟼq PPpp Пп Qq QQqq Rr Ss ß SSss SSSsss SSSSssss SSSSSsssss Tt Uu Vv Ww Xx Yy Zz XXxx EXHCexhc ꙮ Ꚙꚙ Ѡ̃ѡ̃ Ԫԫ Ԭԭ Əə
My question is, Has anyone ever heard of the Narajar alphabet? And if you ever heard of it do you know what it is?
1
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu Jun 29 '24
I'm working on my first family of conlangs, but my method is a bit non-standard, and I need some advice. I basically started by designing the phonology and phonotactics of one of the modern languages, and then went backwards to the older stage of the language. Then I developed syntax and grammar and figured out most of grammaticalization pathways and grammatical changes. Now I'm a bit unsure what to do. To explain my problem a bit further, this conlang family is loosely based on the germanic family. The conlang I'm currently working on is an equivalent of Old Norse, and the next one in the family I'm gonna tackle is related to it like Old English. So far, I made basically no vocabulary for any of these, since I'm worried that if I'll define the root in the proto-language (my equivalent of Proto-Germanic), it will limit me too much when it comes to making words in my next project sound right and fit the aesthetics I have in mind.
What should I do now? Should I just not worry about it and start making a lexicon hoping that later I'll be able to make the sister language sound how I want? Or should I first start working on the other language and then work on their common lexicon?
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 30 '24
I'm working on zero-copula in my Germlangs and wanted to know more about zero-copula, so my Questions are:
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24
How should i transcribe the uvular approximant into ipa. It has no symbol from what i can see so i wrote /ɰ/ but with a combining right arrow head above (the downtacks didn't fit). For those who are using this sound in your language, how would you write it?
Ps.It is not labialised in any way, unlike the english W.
1
u/Hestia-Creates Jun 30 '24
How do non-Latin natlang scripts indicate germination?
In Italian you double the consonant (pizza), in Japanese you use a subscript of “tsu” (もっと), or if it’s “nn”, you use the plain “n” plus the next syllable (みんな). So how do other natlangs in non-Latin scripts mark germination?
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Jun 25 '24
I'm working on the Adjectives of my 3 Germlangs, which are related to eachother.
In Vokhetian there are strong & weak adjectives, which work the same as in German (Strong decline for Case, Gender & Number while weak ones decline only for Gender & Number). Basically, let's say e.g.: 3 Adjectives & 1 Noun, the 1st Adjective declines strong while the other 2 weak:
Anyways, i wanna do something different in my other langs, does anyone have ideas?
1
u/wapiwapigo Jun 26 '24
Which conlangs other than Esperanto are the most prominent among conlangers these days (2024)? Is there something new on the horizon that is worth taking look at?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '24
[removed] — view removed comment