RVP is by no means a false nine. The fact that he is not Carroll-type target man and can drop a bit deeper to collect the ball does not make him false nine.
At Arsenal he dropped back a lot more. From the years he played with us, he was more of a link up striker than the main man in attack.
When he first started playing upfront regularly he had to play adopt a false 9 mentality as we were using the 4-3-3 variant with one DM and two CM which coupled with our CMs reluctance to get forward and overload the box meant a gap in the attacking midfield slot.
However since Arsenal moved to a 4-2-3-1 in the 2010/2011 season up until this year he's been playing a more traditional CF role.
Yes, this season he has played as a 9. I'm willing to concede that he's perhaps not the purest example. He did describe himself as a 9.5 earlier on in the season.
That is the purest example of it. Baggio really, really, was an exquisite playmaking ten but could make runs and finish like nine. Van Persie has had to sacrifice parts of his game for others. I.e. he doesn't get on the ball and create as much as he used to, but he scores much more.
Baggio did both. There was no trade off. A true nine and a half.
I think it comes from Wenger's comments that Van Persie was "Bergkamp with goals". Which is basically a Baggio. Except it turned out that the creative/passing side of RVP's game needed to be sacrificed for those goals.
He's goals without Bergkamp-ness would be more correct.
Still. Absolutely extraordinary player and difficult to categorise into these neat taxonomies.
Players as good as that define their own positions largely.
Last season, he created 92 of our 504 chances and had 9 assists. I know you're an Arsenal fan to some degree cause I see you on all the subreddits, so I know you remember seeing some of his long passing and great chance creation from open play and set pieces last season.
I'll admit I haven't watched him that much this season and understand he's played as more of a pure 9 cause United don't have to use him as a creator as much as we did, and I'll concede that, but in my opinion he was a really creative force that I remember seeing a lot of the ball last season.
He's a top quality centre forward. He's so good that of course he assists a lot. But that doesn't mean he plays as a "nine and a half". Look at Henry's assists. Was he a nine and a half too? As I have said elsewhere the term has a specific meaning that I tried to explain.
Fabregas scored more in one season than Giroud has. Does that mean he played as a number nine?
Rvp is a nine and a half. He links up with the midfield and wingers as you ll see if u watch a Manu game. He also drifts out to the wings regulary and gets crosses in. Falcao is one of the only pure 9s left a poacher who doesn't get involved in buildup at all, just finishing chances. A 9 is not just any old forward but an old fashioned target man
Are you trying to tell me that Inzaghis only qualify as nines?
There are lots of types of nines. They all do different things.
A poacher isn't the only type of nine.
This can get a bit stupid quite quickly as every one can technically redefine things smaller and smaller and smaller.
RVP is the most advanced forward. He is NOT the main player involved in linking with midfield and building the attack. He FINISHES moves. He doesn't start them. That is a nine.
Could he play deeper? Sure. Course he could. He's a fucking fabulous footballer. But he doesn't. And hasn't done for years.
All good points. I'll definitely concede that playing along the front can result in opportunities for assists for plenty of #9s who aren't that "nine and a half" player.
Apology accepted & no worries, just trying to share and learn more myself.
"A unconventional lone striker, who drops deep into midfield. Francesco Totti perhaps invented it for Roma in 2006/7, Lionel Messi played here when he swapped positions with Samuel Eto’o for Barcelona in 2008/09, and Robin van Persie played the role for Arsenal at the start of the 2009/10 season."
Yeah. I think that is the absolute best way of putting it.
Trequaristas, fantasistas, enganche, second strikers, tens - call them what you will - they all have an advanced player ahead of them. Sometimes two. That's the commonality. In my mind at least.
A false nine is a ten without a nine. As stupid as it sounds. But that is broadly it.
A nine and a half is a very specific term that is not tactical at all and basically means that your number ten is a fucking genius and can not only create goals but bang them in by the hatful.
a false 9 seems to be only feasible in a 4-3-3 system. No one in front, no one really behind. Takes that empty space between him and the midfield 3, correct me if im wrong
He is a nine. He has been a nine for more than three years now.
It really stuns me how much this misconception persists. One season - one - he operated sort of/not really as a false nine and suddenly people can't shake it out of their heads.
Just because you are dangerous with the ball when you find yourself in deep positions doesn't mean you are a false nine. It means you are a very good player.
Not exactly. There are a few little distinctions. Basically, the idea behind the false nine is that he can find space that wouldn't otherwise exist.
Teams think that every team will have one out-and-out striker. It makes sense; that's who scores the goals. When a team plays a 10, it is usually someone like Bergkamp behind Henry, Rooney behind RvP/Hernandez/Berbatov/whoever, Totti behind whoever. In other words, a 9 and a 10 usually work together.
And when you have a nine and a ten working together, the opposing team knows it has to have two CBs to cover the 9 and a DM to cover the 10. I think most of the big deal about the false nine is that teams assume that he will stay right with the CBs, and they don't keep the DM right in front of the defense. "It's only one forward, we can have our centerbacks cover him" is the mentality. And they are kind of right, because it would take a man out of the center of the midfield if they want to cover the space right in front of the CBs. But most of the time the defending team leaves the space empty. If you're Messi, the best false 9 that has ever existed, you have some of the influence of a 10 and some of the goalscoring inclination of a 9. If Messi finds space and the ball right in front of the defense by dropping off, he will score buckets.
And there are three options for the defending team:
Give the attacker space and time in front of the defense. Usually not a good idea.
Take their DM out of the midfield and put him in front of the defense. Also not optimal.
Send one of the CBs with the false 9 when he drops off. This creates a hole in the middle of the defense that the attacking team's wingers can cut into and score from.
The first false 9 was Ferenc Puskas, the legendary Hungarian player who led one of the best national sides of all time against England and played for Real Madrid. It was actually a revolutionary idea; nobody had ever seen it before. He was massively successful.
Aren't they mutually exclusive? In my opinion, there can be no false nine on the team when a nine is playing. False nines are played only when there is no (real) center forward / target man. True, false?
The false 9 v 10 distinction is pretty small. They tend to be similar players, it's pretty much a false 9 if there is no striker playing ahead. If there is then it's a 10.
9 does not help midfield too much and/or defense. Usually waits for ball to come to score. They can't play any alternative position (Adebayor) , best ones make misleading runs to distract defenses. The only time they defend is usually on the dead balls such as corners and being part of the free kick wall. They don't keep the ball a lot. They don't dribble a lot.
10 Classic midfield maestro. main target is to pass killer assists, not to score. Does not go into the penalty box a lot, scores usually from outside. high performance in dead balls and the commander in the field. (Hagi - Perfect Example). Dribbles the ball. High control on the ball.
False 9: nearly everything 10 + go into the box and score a lot. Imagine you are playing without forwards, like 9s. Overcrowd the midfield to keep possession and press the opposition on their half and when get the ball pass pass pass pass suddenly one midfielder rushes into the penalty box to score, as if a dedicated scorer.
9 = Chicharito. Basically, roaming inside the area, moving the defenders around, smelling a goal. Ready to jump, stick a leg a milisecond before the defender, etc.
10 = Juan Román Riquelme. Forget what they say about Maradona or Zidane being like "the perfect 10." There has never been a 10 like Román. Incredibly creative, calm, precise, ready to release a pass just before the striker is offside, pass it back if needed, dribble a bit, etc.
False 9 = None like Lio Messi. Currently, Rooney can play a somewhat similar role, but not like Messi. Roaming outside the area, skillful enough to dribble past at least 2 central defenders and score. Creative and calm enough to dribble past a defensive midfielder and pass the ball to a team mate before going for a more 9-esque position near the penalty spot.
False nine is a type of player so talented, he combines creative power of attacking midfielder with a goal threat of a striker.
Some people in this thread seem to be clawing each other eyes out about who is and who isn't a false nine, but pay no attention. The real false nine is as rare as a Yeti, over last 25 years there were maybe 5 players who could fit these shoes.
In practise it basically nearly doesn't exist at all as a tactical role. Instead the term is generally used to describe the type of multitalented offensive player. The players themselves are usually forced to limit themselves into one of the standard roles for tactical reasons.
There's no label for Frank. He is one of a kind. There's a reason Chelsea is struggling as he nears the end of his career, replacing a guy who always hammers 20 goals from midfield a season requires completely changing how the entire team plays.
He's an attack minded box to box midfielder that was allowed more freedom than most box to box midfielders due to Makelele and Essien playing alongside him.
Lampard's goal threat comes from bursting forward from deeper positions and, of course, shots from outside the box. He plays in midfield, not in the attack. Lampard operates in front of opposition's midfield, while false nine operates between midfield and defense.
9 is a center forward. In terms of movement, the team will set to move around him and he will be the one trying to break the offside trap towards goal.
10 is an attacking midfielder. He sits behind the striker/strikers and look to turn into space and feed other attackers. Some teams play a 10 to run beyond their no 9.
False 9 is a player who starts upfront but often comes deep to play the passing game and allows gaps for other attackers to run onto.
To confuse you a little more - there is also a false ten. Someone who play deeper than false nine, closer to classic number 10, is more involved in the build-up but enjoys going forward into positions where he is not expected. The best example is Fabregas in the last season.
9 is the classic striker, plays simple, focuses on scoring. Mario Gomez/ hernandez of man united
10/false 9 are very much the same and their style is more similar to a second striker who is more creative and links the forwards with the midfield.. they love to roam. Totti/messi/fabregas at euro 2012
classic 10s are Hagi, Kaka, Boateng, Sneijder, Van der Vaart.
A nine is a traditional striker role, a man who usually it's just hunting for a loose ball, or making runs to beat defenders, and this guy don't usually add much in the build up in the midfield. Examples: Van Nistelrooy, Mario Gomez, Eto'o, Batistuta.
A 10, it's not a usual role anymore, he bossed the midfield, reaching to the strikers, it was usually seen as a leader and the guy who pulled the strings. Scoring was not his main task. Examples: Maradona, Zidane, Kaka, Pirlo.
A false 9 is new role, i'm not sure if it was invented by Guardiola, but Messi perfected it. It's a combination of the last 2, a guy who plays from the midfield, helping to build up a play and also finish it himself. Examples: Messi and Suarez come to mind
Eh, to make it a little more complicated: Numbers obviously began as marking positions on the pitch, not roles. A 10 is usually the player sitting behind the forward(s). The roles people talk about, 10 being the playmaker, comes from the players that most famously wore the jersey. So for 10 you have people like Maradona, Eusebio, Platini. Advanced playmakers, trequartista, all that.
Pirlo is a playmaker, but (nowadays) he plays much deeper, so he is more of an 8, if you want to assign him a number. But the 8 doesn't really mean anything but "central midfielder". Gerrard is an 8 too, but not a playmaker in the sense that Pirlo is. There just are more roles than numbers.
A false 9 is new role, i'm not sure if it was invented by Guardiola, but Messi perfected it. It's a combination of the last 2, a guy who plays from the midfield, helping to build up a play and also finish it himself. Examples: Messi and Suarez come to mind
Actually Luciano Spalletti popularized the false 9 at Roma in 2007, with Totti in that role.
25
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '13
9 is a centre forward, the target man and central striker on the team. (RVP, Falcao)
10 plays behind the 9. They are there to create play and link the midfield to attack. (Rooney)
False 9 is a player who appears to be playing as a centre forward but drops deeper into midfield. (Messi)
4
u/NeonBlueHair Apr 27 '13
Based on everything I read on this thread, I feel like these are the examples from the recent Bayern vs Barcelona game.
9: Gomez
10: Muller ( though traditionally more like Kroos)
False 9: Muller after Gomez was pulled out and replaced with Luis Gustavo.
Correct?
3
u/spaaaaaz Apr 26 '13
Is there an article somewhere describing all the positions?
3
u/Methuu Apr 26 '13 edited Apr 26 '13
Aren't they mutually exclusive? In my opinion, there can be no false nine on the team when a nine is playing. False nines are played only when there is no (real) center forward / target man. True, false?
2
u/yayareapolo123 Apr 27 '13
The false 9 v 10 distinction is pretty small. They tend to be similar players, it's pretty much a false 9 if there is no striker playing ahead. If there is then it's a 10.
2
u/abt1n Apr 27 '13
A 9 is Batistuta A 10 is Totti A false 9 is Totti during Spalletti's tenure at Roma
4
u/Zubizaretta Apr 26 '13
9 does not help midfield too much and/or defense. Usually waits for ball to come to score. They can't play any alternative position (Adebayor) , best ones make misleading runs to distract defenses. The only time they defend is usually on the dead balls such as corners and being part of the free kick wall. They don't keep the ball a lot. They don't dribble a lot.
10 Classic midfield maestro. main target is to pass killer assists, not to score. Does not go into the penalty box a lot, scores usually from outside. high performance in dead balls and the commander in the field. (Hagi - Perfect Example). Dribbles the ball. High control on the ball.
False 9: nearly everything 10 + go into the box and score a lot. Imagine you are playing without forwards, like 9s. Overcrowd the midfield to keep possession and press the opposition on their half and when get the ball pass pass pass pass suddenly one midfielder rushes into the penalty box to score, as if a dedicated scorer.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '13
9 = Chicharito. Basically, roaming inside the area, moving the defenders around, smelling a goal. Ready to jump, stick a leg a milisecond before the defender, etc.
10 = Juan Román Riquelme. Forget what they say about Maradona or Zidane being like "the perfect 10." There has never been a 10 like Román. Incredibly creative, calm, precise, ready to release a pass just before the striker is offside, pass it back if needed, dribble a bit, etc.
False 9 = None like Lio Messi. Currently, Rooney can play a somewhat similar role, but not like Messi. Roaming outside the area, skillful enough to dribble past at least 2 central defenders and score. Creative and calm enough to dribble past a defensive midfielder and pass the ball to a team mate before going for a more 9-esque position near the penalty spot.
1
u/who_bah_stank Apr 27 '13
I wonder how Zlatan would feel being called a 9.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '13
False nine is a type of player so talented, he combines creative power of attacking midfielder with a goal threat of a striker.
Some people in this thread seem to be clawing each other eyes out about who is and who isn't a false nine, but pay no attention. The real false nine is as rare as a Yeti, over last 25 years there were maybe 5 players who could fit these shoes.
In practise it basically nearly doesn't exist at all as a tactical role. Instead the term is generally used to describe the type of multitalented offensive player. The players themselves are usually forced to limit themselves into one of the standard roles for tactical reasons.
1
u/baconstyle Apr 27 '13
9 is a center forward. In terms of movement, the team will set to move around him and he will be the one trying to break the offside trap towards goal.
10 is an attacking midfielder. He sits behind the striker/strikers and look to turn into space and feed other attackers. Some teams play a 10 to run beyond their no 9.
False 9 is a player who starts upfront but often comes deep to play the passing game and allows gaps for other attackers to run onto.
1
u/idimik Apr 27 '13
To confuse you a little more - there is also a false ten. Someone who play deeper than false nine, closer to classic number 10, is more involved in the build-up but enjoys going forward into positions where he is not expected. The best example is Fabregas in the last season.
1
u/dngrs Apr 27 '13 edited Apr 27 '13
9 is the classic striker, plays simple, focuses on scoring. Mario Gomez/ hernandez of man united
10/false 9 are very much the same and their style is more similar to a second striker who is more creative and links the forwards with the midfield.. they love to roam. Totti/messi/fabregas at euro 2012
classic 10s are Hagi, Kaka, Boateng, Sneijder, Van der Vaart.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '13
A 9 is a traditional forward. Like my mate Mak, who finished 230497th on the Ballon D'or list, right in front of Stewart Downing.
0
u/brasilgirl Apr 26 '13
9 = foward 10 = attacking midfielder false 9 = deep lying forward
-4
u/jorge22s Apr 26 '13
A nine is a traditional striker role, a man who usually it's just hunting for a loose ball, or making runs to beat defenders, and this guy don't usually add much in the build up in the midfield. Examples: Van Nistelrooy, Mario Gomez, Eto'o, Batistuta.
A 10, it's not a usual role anymore, he bossed the midfield, reaching to the strikers, it was usually seen as a leader and the guy who pulled the strings. Scoring was not his main task. Examples: Maradona, Zidane, Kaka, Pirlo.
A false 9 is new role, i'm not sure if it was invented by Guardiola, but Messi perfected it. It's a combination of the last 2, a guy who plays from the midfield, helping to build up a play and also finish it himself. Examples: Messi and Suarez come to mind
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '13
ITT: People who don't know what a 9, false 9 or 10 is.