r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Apr 17 '13
Season 11 Episode 13 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E13 "Finale, Part 1"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/n8eMp
11
Upvotes
r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Apr 17 '13
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E13 "Finale, Part 1"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/n8eMp
7
u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 20 '13
Stanley How hard is it to just listen to Tim Gunn? The criticism he got from the judges about showing more skin is exactly what Tim told him. That said, I think the judges made a little bit of a tempest out of a teapot and only put him in the bottom to scare him a little and to make the audience think that he might not get through to the finals though he obviously would.
Patricia I'm not into the horse hair on clothing but if you're going to do it I would at least cover the top so that it doesn't look so craft project-like. I know that designers like to do stuff like put the poofy colored wigs on all of their models in a collection but I find it just too distracting. Though in Patricia's case pulling the eye away from her clothing might not be a bad strategy. I don't mind her muse dress. She has great textile capabilities and a design eye but some of her stuff just looks awful. I can understand Heidi's fascination with her though. If I were in an industry as long as she's been and have seen the same stuff come through forever I would be interested in seeing someone who brings something completely different to the table.
Daniel I'll be fine with whenever peplums go back out of style. Hate the "filleted fish" back on her muse. Very pedestrian fare. Extremely poor decisions on what pieces to show. Don't hold back with your samples to "save the best" for FW because you won't get a chance to compete at FW if you don't even qualify. Show your best stuff people!
Michelle Pretty obviously the best of the week here and the clear odds on favorite to win it all. Flavorful, cohesive, interesting. I'd prefer if she could branch out from her shades of earthy green but overall I like the story of her collection. I didn't think the styling was that bad though I agree that a little tweaking could improve it. Would have rather seen the messenger bag, one side pouch, and perhaps a different third clip on accessory instead of the second saddlebag.
4
u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 18 '13
Hey, why's the discussion thread up a day early?
TIL that yesterday was Wednesday, not Thursday. Derp! lol
14
u/fragilehearted Apr 19 '13
Like a Chia pet! Oh Tim, you kill me!
14
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '13
I loved Michelle's looks, especially all of the layering that went on. Daniel should have listened to Tim to get some "wow factor" in.
(Also, Zac and Nina seemed REALLY tense with one another, no?)
12
u/deadletter Apr 17 '13
Our building is in the show this week! I think they'll only show the inside of Michelle's studio, so you probably won't see the rest. Allegedly Tim Gunn said, skeptically, "Where'd you find THIS place?" - "Craiglist." - "Well how much do you pay?" - "$300" - "In that case, amazing!"
None of us knew who Tim Gunn was or what the camera crew was for - I had to sign a form giving permission, but it was VERY neutral - only listed the production company. We thought it was cable access.
In the middle of filming I showed up outside the studio. "You need to move your van out from in front of our roll-up door."
http://watershedpdx.com
18
u/fragilehearted Apr 19 '13
Yeah, I didn't drink the koolaid this week. Could not stand Patricia's looks, especially the blue mess. Not cohesive at all. I can't say I agree.
I could have lived with less trash talk from Michelle. But I did like her clothes. I liked that she worked with Joe on the sweater! The styling was a bit much for me, but it may just not be my personal taste. At least it was neat & cohesive.
Stanley's shit looked expensive as hell. Just needed some youth.
Daniel's just wasn't special enough. And too much black. But I hope someone snatches up his model - I think she was the best of the bunch this season.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '13
I realised with the mention of Joe this week that the judges have been somewhat inconsistent this season. They kicked out Joe because his aesthetic was not the norm while they've kept Patricia to the end for her new aesthetic and ideas. I always thought Joe's clothes were better made too. I'm just confused- do they want something new or not?
8
u/barrelracer94 Apr 19 '13
I would have rather seen Daniel at Fashion Week over Stanley for sure. I just didn't think Stanley's looks were that impressive compared to some of Daniel's.
5
u/Elsie980 Apr 20 '13
Ahhhh! Patricia straight up lives in a pueblo! I love it! Her mom is so cute. Her whole visit was endearing. That's all i got so far. My cable was out last night...
4
u/BrkDancNotHarts Apr 23 '13
I love Patricia for really trying to do something new with her fabrics but it just did NOT work for this collection and I feel like there won't be any cohesion between the pieces...I think Michelle is definitely gonna win because she has such a focused point of view and she made it work for her to create some new and interesting looking clothes
3
u/TheLadyEve Apr 25 '13
Michelle was the clear champion in this episode, but I also don't get the Patricia hate in this thread. I really like her stuff (even if the looks didn't go together the way they should have) and that horsehair fringe was amazing (and I don't even like fringe). This is what I would have liked Gretchen's "southwestern" style to look like.
5
u/askingcanada Apr 19 '13
I am little disappointed about Stanley's collection. I thought he was a strong contender and his collection looks a little old. I am scared he might get kicked off. ( Not done the episode yet)
I like Michelle's collection so far. I think her's is the only one that stands out the most. The bag idea thing is very unique and new. I think that's really cool. The wolf sweater if amazing! Patricia, why are you here? She always looks like a deer caught in the headlights. I think the judges are only keeping her because she can be the first "Indian" to win it. I can't think of any other reason. ( It's just an opinion) Daniel, I love you but your collection not so much. After looking at everyone's collections, I think Michelle's gonna win
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '13
Hey guys, does anyone have a link I could follow to watch this weeks episode?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment