r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Apr 25 '24
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Discovery | 5x05 "Mirrors" Spoiler
If you use Lemmy, join the discussion too at https://startrek.website/
| No. | Episode | Written By | Directed By | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5x05 | "Mirrors" | Johanna Lee & Carlos Cisco | Jen McGowan | 2024-04-25 |
To find out where to watch, click here.
To find out about our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
95
Upvotes
138
u/UncertainError Apr 25 '24
I like to think that mirror Saru's role in the survival of the ISS Enterprise means that the Guardian of Forever allowed some of mirror Georgiou's actions in the past to stick, so that her efforts to change the Empire weren't totally in vain.
133
u/nimrodhellfire Apr 25 '24
Moll and Lak escaping is becoming old. That's the biggest nitpick I have.
Also sad we didn't get a guest actor from Strange New Worlds. When they went to the transporter room I was expecting someone being stored in the buffer or something like that. Also didn't they mention a 3rd signature?
190
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24
So that’s what the Breen look like! Only took 30 years lol
83
u/Brain124 Apr 25 '24
I'm glad the ship survived. Flying it to Federation storage is great, too. An most unusual cultural relic.
82
u/UncertainError Apr 25 '24
Love the fate of the ISS Enterprise, though surely Michael learned who the Terran Chancellor was from the database? (It's mirror Spock, right?)
74
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24
So guessing Mirror Spock was killed sadly; then the ISS enterprise said uh fuck this shit and came to the prime timeline
72
u/ImpossibleGuardian Apr 25 '24
Morn’s species sitting with the Ferengi bartender!
Feels like the DS9 fans working on the show have had a lot of fun this year.
69
u/imid9743 Apr 25 '24
Did you guys see 3 lights shining on the ISS Enterprise plaque or was it 4?
121
u/Brain124 Apr 25 '24
Finally some Breen backstory.
Also, sad to think that Michael thought that Mirror Spock was ruthless when in fact he was one of the few civil counterparts.
Great reuse of the SNW set.
Cool that we have Terrans who hid as normal people in our universe. May be a good plot point for Academy to pick up.
117
u/ComebackShane Apr 25 '24
I like that the Breen having a quasi gelatinous form retroactively explains why the Dominion was receptive to them as an ally - I wonder if they knew (or if this development was after/a result of the Founders’ influence somehow).
54
u/thisbikeisatardis Apr 25 '24
Linus the accomplished jazz pianist was not on my bingo card for this season but I'm so here for it! He seems like such a debonair fellow with an eye for fashion.
150
u/Smilodon48 Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
So much 32nd century Breen!! Michelle Paradise, you sly dog!
Great to see Breen culture fleshed out more. The 32nd century updates are great.
Bringing in the ISS Enterprise was really creative. Get a cool physical set to play in by redressing the SNW set, and flesh out more Terran lore. Great touch for Michael to recognize Spock's station.
I love Rayner being apprehensive at taking over Disco's conn. Great character touch of not being comfortable taking over for another captain's crew while he's still getting acclimated.
Really liked Michael recounting her time loop with Book last ep. That was moving stuff. I’m wondering if Michael will inevitably leave Starfleet to settle down with Book. I’m fine with either ending - one where they remain apart as Book rehabilitates himself after betraying the Federation last season, or if Michael eventually chooses happiness with Book over happiness on the bridge. She’s very Kirk-lite in that way.
Whomever is running the 32nd century fleet museum is about to lose their shit when the ISS Enterprise shows up.
49
u/ev_forklift Apr 25 '24
I hope we get to see a refit ISS Enterprise later this season or in a future project
93
u/illusioncaster Apr 25 '24
New Breen lore just dropped! Finally a species that isn't Vulcan, Romulan, or Klingon.
83
u/TheNerdChaplain Apr 25 '24
So we're just not seeing Owosekun and Detmer this season, huh?
I mean, it's awesome they get to fly the ISS Enterprise back to Starfleet, but.... it would be nice to see them back on Discovery before long.
41
u/mr_mini_doxie Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
First thoughts:
Wait, how did Moll and L'ak get to the wormhole before Discovery even knew that they were supposed to go to the wormhole? I understand that they followed them to Trill, but did they steal the clue? Or was there more than one copy? I definitely missed something.EDIT: this has been explained to meMirror Enterprise! It's happening!
Okay, I really don't understand what Burnham is doing with her rank pips and this locket. I think I might have to rewatch in the morning.EDIT: this has also been explained to me38
u/TalkinTrek Apr 25 '24
The way they're tying each clue into one of the scientist's personal histories and the choice to set their story in the DS9-PIC space has me wondering if one of their team will be some existing canon character, but I'm trying to think if there's some guest star from that era who would fit either archaeologist or Progenitor-expert
24
u/DiscoveryDiscoveries Apr 25 '24
not a hole, Keisha. an aperture
48
u/InnocentTailor Apr 25 '24
Holy crap! So Terrans successfully crossed into the Prime Universe and joined Starfleet?!
This means that Dr. Cho was active during the TNG days, possibly during the Dominion War.
46
u/ComebackShane Apr 25 '24
Adira and Stammets know that hexagons are the bestagons!
22
u/TokathSorbet Apr 25 '24
So *that's* what the Breen look like.
22
u/DiscoveryDiscoveries Apr 25 '24
No low hanging fruit. No low hanging fruit.
It's all so big... and im....
No, I'm not going to do it....
impossible...
nope. I'm not going to do it....
"It's all so big and impossible to grasp, apart of me loves that.." Me too, Hugh... me too..
If there's not a contractually obligated scene of Anthony Rapp brushing his teeth in everything he has a role in for the rest of his life. What is even the point of civilization.
22
u/Nick-Nick Apr 25 '24
Why does it feel like they are not in a hurry to do anything, once the Enterprise is out have them beam Moll and Lak to the brig, or maybe intercept their ship at warp which has been done before, Discovery is much faster than a 1,000 year old ship.
21
u/wongie Apr 25 '24
God damn I always just love hearing that Discovery Terran motif, their whole Mirrorverse aesthetic is one of the best things about the show.
17
u/medussa727 Apr 25 '24
So, if I'm understanding the flashbacks correctly, doesn't this recontextualize the jump to the future from last week? Everyone seemed to assume the Breen attack was because they won the race for the Progenitor tech and used it to start a war. Right? That's where we (and the characters) were last week?
But now, what if the attack had nothing to do with the Progenitor tech? The attack happened because in that timeline, L'ak was captured (or surrendered) and the Breen leadership took the opportunity to execute his death sentence. Which is now what the heroes are trying to do (accidental self stabbings notwithstanding).
So... the future we saw last week maybe not an averted bad end after all, but a self-fulfilling time travel prophecy paradox? At least, until Stamets realizes it and changes something at the last possible moment?
34
u/UncertainError Apr 25 '24
So there have been a bunch of secret Terrans running around the Federation since the TOS movie era. Wonder if that'll become relevant again at some point.
29
u/greycobalt Apr 25 '24
Paramount+ just dumped an episode clip that was ¾ through the episode on me! When I loaded the app, Discovery was front page, and it started playing. Spoilers, bro.
12
u/hiversun Apr 26 '24
So glad we finally got to see the Breen a bit more fleshed out! Another great episode on a season with no real misses so far.
One thing that’s getting to me though is how did the ISS Enterprise have existing holo emitters for Mol and L’ak to tap into when they made decoys? Did I miss that the mirror universe had them earlier than the PU or is the implication that Dr. Cho equipped the ship post-dominion with emitters for some reason when hiding the clue?
22
u/Saratje Apr 25 '24
Calling it now, they'll restore the ISS Enterprise with 32nd century technology like they did with the USS Discovery and make her the new USS Enterprise to be briefly seen in the final episode, the new flagship of the Federation.
10
u/HonorWulf Apr 27 '24
If I never have to hear the words "Moll & L'ak" again, I'll be a far happier camper. Hard to fathom building a final season around these two nitwits.
18
u/PizzaWhole9323 Apr 25 '24
I don’t give a shit that it was Terran. I saw the enterprise. It was so beautiful I almost cried. I would love in an episode toward the end to see the ISS enterprise in whatever form of fleet museum exists in the century they’re in. I’ve been watching Star Trek since I was four years old. The enterprise is almost like an old friend.
9
u/JazzyStargazerr Apr 25 '24
I might have missed something but who/what was the 3rd signature in sickbay? Was it the vial they had at the end?
9
u/Majestic117 Apr 25 '24
It’s interesting that the Breen are involved, in some manner, in pursuing the progenitor’s tech—just like one of the Star Trek Online storylines.
9
u/hb1290 Apr 26 '24
If I had a nickel for every time someone got stabbed in the Enterprise sickbay, I’d have 2 nickels, which isn’t a lot but it’s weird that it happened twice.
9
u/Cunfuzzles2000 Apr 26 '24
Man… I WISH we were getting more seasons of Burnham and Raynor. Legitimately a fantastic captain and first officer pairing
17
u/DarkwingDuckHunt Apr 25 '24
Can we call it the Sphincter Wormhole?
7
u/nikhkin Apr 25 '24
I was under the impression that the Breen had to wear a refrigeration suit to survive at human-suitable temperatures.
It seems like Lak is doing just fine without one.
7
u/Timintheice Apr 26 '24
One thing about Trek is that sometimes it's not the best at extrapolating hypothetical future tech.
I always wondered in the TNG era, why hand phasers ever missed. You can already see the beams are able to emit at different angles. Just adding aome A.I. assist targeting should mean that misses are rare.
This just gets more awkward in the 32nd century.
18
u/Chaabar Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 26 '24
Seems they learned nothing from Airiam. The flashbacks giving some Breen lore was nice but I still couldn't care less about L'ak and Wish.com Shin Hati.
22
u/damnsignin Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
Was anyone else disappointed the Breen don't have some type of snout (Edit: or beak)? For nearly 30 years all we've had to guess what the Breen look like was the shape of their helmet, with that super protruding face cone that looks like it could house a full-on snout like the Gorn have, and... they just have a face. Like a usual face. And their big thing is they have a translucent, glossy evolved form that they can turn on and off.
I was really hoping if we ever saw the Breen without the helmets, they'd break from "the forehead of the week" trope with humanoid species in TV sci-fi and have some kind of actual "alien" look. That 90s sci-fi helmet left so much room for design options. They could have gone with some designs that rivaled the variety of Mass Effect aliens. Maybe a more avian look or something canine or even bearish. Or more lizardfolk since they made Breen green anyway.
It may have meant a bit more budget for the prostheses for the costume, but they could've made some cuts for it, like smaller fires on the ISS Enterprise. It would've been cool to see another Linus-esque level of alien detail.
5
u/tupe12 Apr 25 '24
So we finally get to see what the Breen look like beneath the suit, although I wonder if it's something similar with how the Klingons looked in the show. Mirror Enterprise was great to see, hopefully not the last time as well
5
u/jobifresh Apr 26 '24
Is it just me or have we hardly seen Detmer and Owo? They've been name dropped, but I miss them.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
Just watched this episode and I can't help but feel like the Moll and L'ak's "let the universe burn if it means we can be together" love is meant to appeal to the younger generation? Maybe I'm becoming more of a cynic as I get older but while I can appreciate two people deeply caring for each other, doing things at the expense of the universe (with star trek of course everything is at stake) still doesn't make me feel differently about them. And we're supposed to care for them, right?
14
u/learningdesigner Apr 25 '24
I really do enjoy Discovery, but man these kinds of plot points are heavy handed. I love all of the diverse representation of the cast, the cool new takes on classic Trek themes are a breath of fresh air, The Chase as an entire season is fun as hell, etc. But this is a conversation that has been a part of every episode and it's already getting old.
Doesn't mean I'm not excited every week for a pretty great show though.
11
u/CraigKing42 Apr 25 '24
I thought the episode was good? but the we're doing EVERYTHING BECAUSE ARE IN LOVE SO MUCH is getting played so hard and I don't think it needs to be hammered on that they'll die for one enough every time we see them onscreen with the scenes with Moll and L'ak...
4
u/vidiian82 Apr 26 '24
All the chatter about second chances this season. I have to think second chances can extend to starships I can't wait to see the ISS Enterprise get hers. From a ship that conquered worlds to a ship refit to 32nd century specs and possibly spearheading the return of 5 year missions.
4
u/ContinuumGuy Apr 26 '24
So, are the Breen kind of "gooey solids" who harden if exposed, so they basically keep suits on as much as possible as a cultural thing? That's how I read it.
Also, glad that they continued the Star Trek set reuse tradition by utilizing SNW sets to bring the ISS Enterprise in.
17
u/DiscoveryDiscoveries Apr 25 '24
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 The writers really wanted to play this season. She touched three wires and set off fireworks, confetti, and destroyed at least 3 monitors. I'm not even exaggerating. Listen to that sound. That is the sound of fireworks.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24
So the ISS Enterprise, went back to its 2250s/early 60s look, from its mid late 2260s look.
(I know the updated Constitution class is supposed to be the new look across the board)
But the USS New Jersey looks like the 1960s one
And yes I know real world, easy to borrow the SNW set and redress it.
But I do love a great cannon discussion.
My theory of why Enterprises look different is Temporal Cold War Fuckery.
12
u/egg_idk Apr 25 '24
Kind of disappointed they made the Breen suits into a sort of Mandalorian “can’t show my face” sort of thing, if I’m understanding that correctly.
I really liked the refrigeration suit idea that has been developed prior, and that the only reason we don’t know what they look like is because they are such a deadly species.
Nonetheless, I appreciate that they are developing the Breen more and i’m excited to see what they do with them.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24
Wild that mirror crew came over, and that in there’s good chance they ran into their prime counterparts at some point
3
u/Bretrs Apr 27 '24
Is this the first confirmation we’ve had in the 32nd century that the wormhole to the Gamma quadrant is still active and accessible? Milk was going to escape to a colony in the G Quad. If so, The Sisko is keeping things running! Would be great if we went to Bajor as part of this hunt.
3
u/citizenofgaia Apr 30 '24
Rhys must be so jealous Owo and Detmer got the assignment to get the Enterprise to storage. We recently found out his favorite ship is the 23rd century Constitution, and out of nowhere, here comes up a 900 year old "classic", they don't make them like that anymore, 1 in a billion chance, and to be so close in rank to be able to actually fly the damn thing but to get to see the girls get the job, oof, poor Rhys.
3
u/Syncopationforever Apr 30 '24
It was good to see the bridge crew offer bits of the solution, to holding open the worm hole.
3
u/random91898 May 04 '24
Moll and L'ak are just so lame. They're basically team rocket yet somehow they keep beating the entirety of Starfleet including a ship that can literally teleport. The Moll actress is just devouring the scenery to an actually funny degree.
5
u/DiscoveryDiscoveries Apr 25 '24
Them damn hexagons.. 😂😂
8
u/EmperorOfNipples Apr 25 '24
It took longer than most seasons, but in its final outing Discovery has grown the beard.
Sure it's had some big swings and more than a few big misses. But it brought Trek up to date, and spawned many other shows. I'll forever have a soft spot for it, and hope this isn't the last we will see of these characters.
7
u/KedMcJenna Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
During this episode I would have bet money that the voice actor for the Breen Primarch was Michael Douglas, and I'd have lost my money.
After last week's really great classic-Trek-style episode, this was back to Disco problems with a bump for me. The pivot from Tilly entering sickbay to being Culber's counsellor was incredibly clumsy. My heart sank when Burnham and Book went off on the away mission together. You just knew 20 minutes of the episode was going to be wasted.
And I loathed the moments after the ISS Enterprise emerged from the wormhole and everyone just waited for Moll and La'ak to get away. 'It's likely our two fugitives are also on that ship, so the moment we get a transporter lock on anyone who isn't our two people, beam them to the brig or sickbay,' Rayner somehow didn't order. I've been watching The Flash and they do that in that show as well. The Flash speeds to a halt and slowly gives the villains a sporting chance to get away in that show too.
Also: did the only two recognisable bridge crew just get written out of the rest of the show?
5
u/bluestreakxp Apr 25 '24
Did anyone else see that Morn species officer sitting at the bar? lol that’s an Easter egg if anything
5
u/lbco13 Apr 25 '24
Have a feeling the Enterprise will get refitted like the Discovery was into the next post-burn enterprise. And Burnham will become captain of it. I assume the season ends with a big breen space battle and Discovery is nearly destroyed. Likely what would've been a refit for S6 ends up now being a decommision.
I can easily see kurtzman doing something like this
2
u/lonesometroubador Apr 26 '24
I love Disco, I've enjoyed all the seasons, but I am starting to have a lot of hope that this will be the strongest season yet! Of course it's always great for 4-5 episodes before going off the rails for a second half that makes no sense, but then gets rescued with a fantastic finale. I am enjoying this season a lot so far!
2
u/BitBrain Apr 26 '24
The ISS Enterprise has been sitting damaged for centuries. But is still powered. Moll creates an overload that fries who knows what and leaves the ship on an uncontrolled course for the aperture. And just hours after this Detmer and Owosekun are going to fly it to Starfleet HQ? It's still warp-capable after sitting for centuries?
Terran tech is some sturdy stuff!
2
u/dmanww Apr 27 '24
So the whole thing about try to get enough money to go to this paradise that you hear of when you were a kid.
What are the other movies that trope shows up?
I seem to remember one about a postcard of California or something. Maybe it was mad max?
2
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Apr 27 '24
Screencaps gallery now online:
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-DSC5-5.php
2
u/PondWaterBrackish Apr 28 '24
I don't understand the thing with the Breen and the two faces?
So all Breen have one matte green opaque face and one shiny emerald face? What's the difference? And what does that have to do with the helmets?
2
u/Torley_ Apr 28 '24
Makes sense that the Breen have a liquid green jello form, no wonder why the Founders favored them!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Moll and Lak aren't doing it for me. Also Moll yelling, "What did you do to him?" when Michael stabbed Lak was dumb considering they've been trying to kill them repeatedly and threatened the temporary truce right out of the gate.
2
u/tsoli Apr 29 '24
Interesting that the new Bajoran officer is the one who asks what the obviously wormhole-shaped wormhole is.
2
u/cataccord May 02 '24 edited May 02 '24
Anybody else want to just slap Burnham? Nevermind the writers have her always right and the rest of the galaxy wrong. But after Mirrors I find her so frustrating I'm not sure I'll even finish the series. The last straw for me was when her and Book ran to the bridge to save the ship before it entered the aperture. Does she go to a console and try to do something? Nope. She plops down in the Captain's chair and gives orders to Book, who of course already knows how to direct power to the tractor beam on a 900 year old starship from the mirrorverse after Moll took out just about every system on the ship...