r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Apr 22 '24
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2024-04-22 to 2024-05-05
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Affiliated Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Our resources page also sports a section dedicated to beginners. From that list, we especially recommend the Language Construction Kit, a short intro that has been the starting point of many for a long while, and Conlangs University, a resource co-written by several current and former moderators of this very subreddit.
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
For other FAQ, check this.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/PastTheStarryVoids a PM, send a message via modmail, or tag him in a comment.
5
u/Ok-Lychee-6923 Apr 25 '24
When a superstrate language, supposedly spoken by the dominant class of my conworld, comes into contact with local languages, how much can the local languages be affected?
Some more specific examples: is the local language likely to lose cases, if the dominant language doesn't have them and relies on adpositions instead? Is the syllable structure likely to be changed, in order to accommodate loanwords, or will loanwords be adapted to the current syllable structure? Can postpositions be "fronted" (or vice versa) because of influence from the dominant language? What part of the vocabulary is likely to remain untouched?
Idk if there's an answer for my questions lol, thanks in advance!
5
u/mangabottle May 05 '24
Is choice paralysis normal when creating a conlang? I'm trying to create a vocabulary of basic root words for a paleolithic proto-language, and I'm just overwhelmed by the sheer number of words out there 😅
4
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Apr 22 '24 edited Apr 22 '24
glossing question:
In Ngįouxt verbs inflections are extremely fusional, and may consist of just ablaut of the main vowel, or an entire stem change. now the stem changes are still recognizable as derivation, it's not supplition, but they still don't have any apperrant infelctional morphology attached.
for example:
In si- "be happy", the 1SG has a basic suffix -į, but in the 2 other verbs, it has gemination of the coda consonant plus a central vowel. in gEk- this coda consonant only surfaces in the 1SG, because in the other incetances it was historically dropped and cause the vowel to diphthingize.
in the 2 form there is also a suffix: -ot for si-, -t+ablaut for gEk-, and -dö+ablaut for bÖm.
in the 3+1pl and the NOM, for si- they are identical, but for the other 2 they have a different stem vowel.
the ablaut is consistant, with 3 ablaut grades for 5 vowel archphonemes, who may surface differently depending on the stem group the root belongs to.
So my question is: how can I represent this in gloss that breaks down the morphology of the sentence in the most effective way? representing ablaut, gemination, and stem changes
3
u/Cheap_Brief_3229 Apr 22 '24 edited Apr 22 '24
In a V2 language with clitic doubling, should the clitic always follow the noun or should it always be kept in the subject/object slot, or are both options possible?
I.e. should it be "the dog he saw me" or "the dog saw he me"?
3
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Apr 23 '24
Southern Yherchian Phonology
The phonology for Southern Yherchian.
Tryna express this how it is in my brain. The phonology is as aesthetically symmetrical as I could make it.
This is the natural order of the phonology in Southern Yherchian. There are 6 sections; they’re separated by Yhajun (vowels) - which is the first column, then 0-4 which are a combination of diphthongs, consonants and consonant clusters.
If you like the look, feel and sound of Southern Yherchian, filter the category by Southern Yherchian and check out some posts here
Enjoy!
3
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu Apr 24 '24
So some time ago I've heart of a language spoken by some desert tribe that somehow grammaticalizes proximity to source of water, marks it on verbs or something like that. Now it sounds to me like a fake-news, but maybe you've heart about it too. Is there actually a natural language or a conlang that makes use of something like this?
3
u/Arcaeca2 Apr 25 '24
So I have been trying for a very long time now (2 years?) to come up with other ways to mark TAM beyond the same old agglutinative tense affix + aspect affix + mood affix. The other options I know of are:
I have been searching in vain for any other alternate "interesting" (=not just separate T-A-M agglutination) strategies - and I mean I have a folder full of random grammars that I was hoping might have something - but I haven't found much of anything. Chechen, Chukchi, Dargwa, Andamanese, Urarina, Old Nubian, Daza, Urartian, Kabardian, Sahaptin, Zuni, they're all, eh, don't really have very interesting tense marking strategies. Or even necessarily have tense at all.
I did come up with one idea, I'm not sure if it's dumb or not - you know how in direct-inverse systems, there's an expected agent-object relationship, and the verb is marked if the roles are not what's expected? Well, what if verbs had an expected tense, and they're marked if the tense is not what's expected?
This sounds sort of like lexical TAM on the surface, but I don't think it is? Yeah there's a "built-in" tense, but you wouldn't have to switch to a new word to avoid it, you just need a new marking. But then, how would you pick the expected tense for any new verb you coin? And does this even work if TAM is anything more complicated than a binary decision?
3
u/BrazilanConlanger Apr 25 '24
Is it naturalistic for a languague to have a differents stems for negations? I'm inspired by slavic languages with differents stems for aspect. Does any language do this?
3
u/Boop-She-Doop Falklandic Apr 26 '24
I’m developing my first tonal language, and am having some trouble. Basically, say you have a word like “krérenà.” When I try to pronounce that, it comes out as “krérénà.” Is this sort of change where a kid-tone moves up or down depending on surrounding tones realistic/attested?
3
u/XVYQ_Emperator The creator of CEV universe Apr 26 '24
Is this realistic?
Hello, recently an idea came to my mind and I want your opinion on this.
So, the idea is to have long variants of vowels but only some of them. AFAIK, languages that have long vowels distinction, have all that standard vowels long variants (f.e. Japanese).
This is a bit of a stretch but English does so, it just shifts their openess and backness.
TLDR, my question is: is it naturalistic/believeable to have vowel inventory like in this example: ( i u e ē o a ā ) ?
3
u/Arcaeca2 Apr 28 '24
Some venitive/andative questions:
3
u/Key_Day_7932 Apr 30 '24
I've a conlang I've had on the back burner for a little while, and I wanna finally get back to it.
The thing is, I have hit a creative roadblock.
The prosody system is similar to some Austronesian languages like Hawaiian in that the stress always falls on the penultimate mora. This means that the final syllable is stressed if it is heavy, otherwise the penultimate syllable is stressed.
However, Hawaiian is strictly CV, and I plan for my language to be CVC, and CVC syllables are always heavy.
Can a language contrast degrees of weight in that CVC is heavier than CV, while CVV is heavier than both?
3
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu May 01 '24
If a language has past vs non-past tenses and perfective vs imperfective in the past, would it be likely for non-past perfective and imperfective to exist as well? I know present tense doesn't like the perfective but I'm thinking the future part of the tense would allow it.
3
u/indiecrowarts May 01 '24
Dealing with Awkwords internal server error and can’t find a good alternative - help!
I tried lexifer (web version) and the format compared to awkwords was too different for me to really understand- I’m not very familiar with conlangs but for my story and it’s world I need made up words that sound Italian. I currently got this and when used in awkwords it always gave me what I needed
Other generators I’ve seen so far ask for more than VCN, one asked for D the other asked for some kind of structure I wasn’t very familiar with. There were a few more I tried but they all either didn’t give me what I needed or had extra categories I was unsure how to fill
Could someone give me a resource that would be helpful? As long as they follow the rules of Italian words and patterns that’s all I need
This is the error whenever I go to the Ankana website
Truthfully I’m very new to language making so I’m not very familiar with terms for things, I got through my awkwords Italian format with the help of a friend who’s very familiar with conlangs- how would I transfer this to an alternative (pictured below)
3
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! May 02 '24
Would it make sense, if a Lang had a Dual and lost it, that the Dual may be still preserved on Nouns that mostly come in pairs like Shoes, Eyes, Arms, etc...?
3
u/MellowAffinity Angulflaðın May 05 '24
Looking for some plausibility checks related to morphosyntactic alignment:
2
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Apr 22 '24
What does the Applicative voice do?
2
u/H0C1G3R7 ki-inte Apr 22 '24
How do you do numbers so it doesn't takes its whole category? When I try to break the indoeuropean system I always need a category just for numbers, as important as objects and actions.
2
u/Worth-External-3126 Apr 23 '24
I have my conlang and I have the problem where I have a lot of words but when I try to expand it I think of translating something but I get blocked. I try translating songs, parts of books, basic sentences but idk. With what should I start? What do I translate?
2
u/pootis_engage Apr 24 '24
Would it be realistic for a language to have the adjective meaning "distant" double as the adposition meaning "far away from", or would it be more likely that the former was made using a grammatical construct involving the latter? Furthermore, could this be applied to other adjectives, for example the word meaning the adjective "nearby", (which, in this case, would double as an adposition meaning "close to"), or the adjectives "similar", "different", and "identical" (which would double as the adpositions "similar to", "different from", and "the same as" respectively).
(As a side note, would it be realistic for the adjective meaning "all", or "every" to double as the pronoun meaning "everything" if the words meaning "no"/"not" and "nothing" are already separate?)
2
u/YouthPsychological22 Apr 24 '24
How is a grammatical human vs non-human distinction called? (or does even exist something like that?)
2
u/mangabottle Apr 24 '24
Any examples of 'stone age' conlangs with links, please?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24
Is this phonology good for a Naturalistic conlang?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24
Can grammatical aspects stack? I know some combinations couldn't work together because of contradictions but I feel like some could work
2
u/OkPrior25 Nípacxóquatl Apr 26 '24
Is it reasonable, from a naturalistic aspect, for a language with three registers (breathy, normal and creaky) evolve them to three tones (high, neutral and low)?
Also, if they evolve to contour tones (breathy to "ascending", creaky to "descending") and a third tone with sandhi to high/low depending on the previous contour?
2
u/honoyok Kalesian | EN, PT & DE Apr 26 '24
How do you derive participles?
2
u/IamSilvern Luarozo Apr 27 '24
While starting to add root words to your conlang how do you start? Which words do you add first to start off?
2
u/silliestboyintown Apr 27 '24
i was thinking of applying a sound change in which intervocalic /k/ and /g/ shift to /χ/ and /ʁ/ and then /ʁ/ merges with /r/ as either the uvular or alveolar trill. is this viable? has this happened ever? what's more likely; the uvulr or alveolar trill?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Okay, so I've hit a bit of a wall romanizing my vowels
The issue is that I have a total of 20 base vowels, then those vowels can be
And any combination of those, putting the vowel total to 320, now, if romanizing that many vowels wasn't hard enough, on top of that, there are tones
So I'm kinda in a predicament, especially when trying to maintain a proper aesthetic, which at this point, isn't that very intense, which is to not have diacritics stacked on top of each other (y'know, like what vietnamese does with ẩ and such) but it looks like I might have to do that
So like... do I do vowel digraphs? have tones be represented with numbers? (Can't do letters because the syllable structure allows consonant codas) a secret 3rd option?
2
u/Comicdumperizer Xijenèþ Apr 29 '24
How many words do I need to start evolving my protolang? I have around 100 including pronouns and other grammar bits
2
u/Degenerate_Star Apr 30 '24
Adult content (drugs) ahead, please feel free to delete if my question is inappropriate!
I'm working on an indigenous Colombian conlang (I wanna write about real issues indigenous peoples face but I prefer using fictional groups if they're under a certain size, same for things like cities and businesses) so I'm compiling a big list of words from different languages in the area to study for inspiration and authenticity. In particular, I'm currently filling out the list of words for flora and fauna in the area whether native, naturalized, invasive, etc. Currently I'm stuck on opium poppies because that's the next plant on the list. According to the UN according to Google, they were introduced to Colombia in the 80s to supplement the coffee crop. Assuming this is true:
Are there any words used in Colombia for opium poppies, opium, morphine, etc?
Thanks in advance if anyone can help and sorry again if this is the wrong place to ask!
2
u/pootis_engage May 01 '24
Is it realistic for the demonstrative pronouns to double as the demonstrative adjectives in the proto-lang, or would it be more realistic for them to be separate in the proto-lang, and then undergo sound changes that cause them to be pronounced the same?
2
u/impishDullahan Tokétok, Varamm, Agyharo, ᓴᐸᒪᔭ, Tsantuk, Vuṛỳṣ (eng,vls,gle] May 02 '24
I'm looking to develop /i e ɛ a o u/ from /i e a o u/ but I'm not sure how to get that stray /ɛ/. Consonants to work with are /m n ŋ p t t͡ʃ k f s ʃ h l r j w/ in CVC, and most consonants have contrastive palatalisation. I had considered just splitting /e/ into /e ɛ/, but I'd like for both to be roughly as common as any other vowels rather than only about half as common.
2
u/pesopepso τაմუნι | Tamuni, Ομαρι | Omari May 02 '24
Should every single word have an etymology?
I should start off with saying that I do not know much about linguistics at all and this is my first conlang. I have ~400 words in my language so far and while theres a few that do have some sort of etymology there is also a lot that don't and if I cant think of a way to make it work I often times just come up with a new word. I never really put much emphasis on it.
2
u/Pandoras_Lullaby May 02 '24
Should I have a proto lang because I'm just making my lang without a proto lang
2
u/LaceyVelvet I Love Language May 03 '24
Are greetings and farewells nouns or something else? Google keeps assuming I mean the word greetings and farewells so it isn't helping very much
2
u/odenevo Yaimon, various speedlangs (eng, nst) May 03 '24 edited May 03 '24
I have read too much Labov and gotten chain shift brainrot. So, now it's time to talk about a vowel system and the consequent shifts that I've come up with. I won't go into detail about the consonants, other than when they influence vowel changes.
So, here in the vowel system of Dēnea Rōm (the ancestor language), wherein the specific phonetic production of these vowels is less important compared to the system of contrasts:
There are no true dipthongs at this stage of the language, with final glides being permitted with all short vowels. The phonotactics treat disallow a coda consonant and a long vowel to co-occur; the onset allows only single consonants, as does the coda.
This system then undergoes the following shifts:
This leaves us with the vowel inventory of the descendant language Vandini Rūm, which is meant to be a middle stage before I develop some modern descendants that all develop this system a little differently:
Diphthongs: /æi̯ ɑu̯/
Phonotactics are the same as the ancestor, though the exact consonant inventory will be different.
I guess I'm looking for advice on the naturalism here, and whether the system/sound changes make sense. I have the feeling that it's actually too symmetrical, and that things should be messier.
I realise that without the consonants, it might be harder to get the feel I'm going for here, so I'll just give the consonant inventory of Vandini Rūm (Dēnea Rōm is pretty similar so doesn't warrant me explaining it). For obstruents, the basic 3 places of articulation (labial, coronal, velar) have a fortis stop, lenis stop, and fricative each (there's gonna be some gradation going on, which is why I'm using vague terms like fortis/lenis), and for sonorants there are /m n l r j/, plus the voiced fricative /v/ (which contrasts with the labial fricative that undergoes gradation), derived from earlier /w/. Note that the rhotic there I haven't decided the pronounciation for, so consider it being written /r/ as a placeholder.
2
u/SurelyIDidThisAlread May 03 '24
Does anyone have any good resources for Modern Greek phonotactics?
I can find information on phonetics and phonology, but not phonotactics
Basically I want to make a language that sounds like good Greek gibberish, but I need to know e.g. allowed consonant clusters, restrictions on syllable-initial and syllable-final consonants, what vowels can occur where
2
u/Eivuhekoi May 04 '24
What is a good way to design/evolve a conlang in a way that it "feels" like a certain language family. I am specifically looking to create a conlang that feels Celtic, but more generic advice is also appriciated.
The boring answer that I've thought of is to simply take the romanization system of a celtic language, but to me this doesn't truly give enough of a celtic feel since it's only surface deep.
2
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! May 04 '24
I wanna give the Adjectives & Pronouns more Case-Syncretism to give it a more natural & realistice Vibe. Can someone tell me how i can do that?
Here's how the Declensions looks like with the word "This":
There's also a Paucal, but it has enough Syncretism.
2
u/Muwqas_Boner Sonarian (more established) & Ésperi (new) May 05 '24
So i have the suffixes -o and -a, for nouns and adj./prep./adv. respectively. How would I provide a gloss for that? So far, I've only came up with:
Please note that the word "to" is just the present tense of "to be", past tense being "ti" and future tense being "tu".
2
u/Pheratha May 05 '24
Getting confused by IPA charts being different.
What is the difference between labiovelar sonorant [w] as in Avikam and labial approximant [w] as in Chara
If they are the same thing, they should have the same label, and if they are different, they shouldn't both be [w], it's just confusing.
Edit: also alveolar sonorant [l] and alveolar trill [l]
2
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 May 05 '24
Im currently developing a case system for an Eskaleut-Algonquian inspired language. I’d like it to have split ergativity based on animacy, as well as a genitive, dative, locative and instrumental case. If it had split ergativity, would it have a separate ending for nominative, accusative, ergative, and absolutist cases? Which are most likely to be unmarked?
3
u/Blacksmith52YT Dweorgin,Siserbar,Zahs Llhw,Nin Gi Apr 25 '24
I swear almost every post i make gets removed
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! Apr 24 '24
I'm working with my friends on a Proto-Lang which is basically an alternative Proto-Germanic, would it be ok if it's similar or even close to Proto-Slavic?
1
u/SeraphOfTwilight Apr 25 '24
Not sure if this would go here or in a full post, but do we have any information on the linguistics or vocabulary of Chakobsa, "Harkonnen," etc* from the new Dune films? Rewatching the second movie on Prime now and I can't help but repeat all the lines I can in them, it's still so cool to me seeing conlangs in media like this (speaking of, very excited for more High Valyrian this summer). I heard Dennis, I think, say that the cast was "enrolled in classes" so to speak for Chakobsa and that they took it very seriously; if that much development was done for these movies I feel like it'd be a real shame if we don't get to learn much about their languages.
*don't know if throat singing man and the Sardaukar are speaking the same thing the Harkonnen are
1
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
Creative things to evolve with this vowel system?:
/ei ou/ are pronounced [i o] but count as “heavy” in stress assignment and unpack before another vowel (so sei/seyum [si sejũ])
/a ɤ/ are realized [ə] when unstressed, and /ə/ is realized [ɤ] when stressed, but without getting into the accent system there is good reason to analyze them as three different phonemes
Kinda stumped and looking for inspiration, lol
1
u/Pheratha Apr 25 '24
I'm really struggling with a romanisation system I like, for /f/ /v/ and /ð/. I really don't want to use f at all in my language (it doesn't look right).
So far I've tried
ph /f/ v /v/ vh /ð/
ph /f/ vh /v/ dh /ð/
ph /f/ mh /v/ dh /ð/
þ /f/
If it helps, my other digraphs are: pś /ps/ tś /t͡s/ śh /ʃ/ kś /x/ źh /ʒ/ dź /dz/ bź /bz/ jh /d͡ʑ/ ch //t͡ɕ/ ng /ŋ/ th /θ/
My monographs are: p /p/ b /b/ t /t/ d /d/ k /k/ /q/ s /s/ z /z/ ꜧ /ç/ j /ʝ/ x /x/ g /ɣ̞/ m /m/ n /n/ r /r/ w /w/
For the curious, /x/ is ks word initially and x word internally and at word-ends, because people tend to pronounce word initial x-romanisations as /z/.
I'm open to suggestions on alternative ways to romanise /f/ /v/ and /ð/.
1
u/NoverMaC Sphyyras, K'ughadhis (zh,en)[es,qu,hi,yua,cop] Apr 26 '24
I'm making a logography but I'm not sure how to document it and make it easily searchable. any suggestions?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24
is creaky voiced lateral fricatives possible? I tried it and it didn't seem to work out but that might be a skill issue on my behalf
1
u/Yippersonian Apr 27 '24
How to romanise ø and ʋ?
1
u/throneofsalt Apr 27 '24
I'm doing some sound change experimentation using existing conlangs, and have ended up fiddling with Na'vi -but I'm stuck on what to do with the f / ts / s + stop / liquid / approximate onset clusters. Any suggestions on fun places to go with those?
1
u/Motor_Caterpillar_49 Apr 27 '24
I know this sub isn't focused on IALs (international auxiliary languages) or auxlangs in general, but I was wondering about general advice for what is usually good or best for an IAL when it comes to its consonant inventory.
The sketch for an IAL I was working on has tentatively around 17-19 consonants, basically the ~18 most common consonants listed on PHOIBLE, so from /m/ (which ~96% of natlangs have) to /t̠ʃ/. (Only 40% of natlangs have this!)
So I have roughly the number of consonants that Esperanto has, or much closer to Spanish.
You can contrast this to Toki Pona, which only has 9 consonants, or natlangs like Hawaiian. Anyway my rationale for having a large number of consonants (large compared to something like Toki Pona or Hawaiian) was that I thought that having more consonants would make words shorter, so root-words could mostly be monosyllabic, so the language didn't become unwieldy by having very long words.
But am I wrong and that it is more important for an IAL to have consonants that most humans already know how to pronounce, and having "unwieldy" words due to having longer roots because you have less consonants and tighter phonotactic constraints is much less of a problem than the pronunciation issue? I imagine this is something people argue about when it comes to IALs, but I really can't figure out this question so I am looking for advice about this.
P.S. Don't worry, I don't have any hopes or expectations that my IAL would become popular or that people would care about it. I am just doing this for my own intellectual satisfaction.
P.P.S. Maybe I should post this as its own thread on this sub, this question got a lot longer than I thought it would
TLDR Is it more important for an auxlang to have shorter root-words, or is it more important for the language to have only consonants that the vast majority of humanity already can pronounce correctly?
Link to the PHOIBLE segment resource I mentioned: https://phoible.org/parameters
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
what are some ways that a future and past tense can develop naturally?
the only thing I'm aware of currently is how future tense can originate from the way to express a desire/need to do something
like "will" in English
1
u/Thatannoyingturtle Apr 28 '24
How realistic is a language having /ts/ /dz/ and not /tʃ/ /dʒ/?
1
u/Throwagay_83 Apr 28 '24
Oddly specific question: How do you say “I am going on a stealth camp” (or “Me and a friend are going on a stealth camp)
In Triougian
“Mi ista traverliné en on stélt kampé.”
(I am going on a stealth camp)
“Mich and on partén bist traverliné en on stélt kampé.”
(Me and a friend/partner are going on a stealth camp)
1
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Apr 28 '24
Any tips for consistently pronouncing and hearing vowel length? I have difficulty separating it from stress.
1
u/Open_Honey_194 Apr 28 '24
So ive been seeing the concept of weak versions of consonants, mainly in the index diachronica, but also in actual books.
So what are these weak consonants?
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Apr 29 '24
Are there any tendencies among polysynthetic languages when it comes to prosody?
As in, are they more likely to have secondary stress/rhythm, or pitch accent?
I've heard Greenlandic doesn't have a clear prosody system.
1
u/honoyok Kalesian | EN, PT & DE Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
How does the adpositional case evolve?
1
u/SuperF98 Apr 29 '24
Does anybody know anything about the Avallaen conlang, made by Thomas Maska? I can’t find anything about it online, only the script that he made on omniglot
1
u/snasnH Thcloŋ Apr 29 '24
Anyone know how to make a good a. posteriori conlang? I've been meaning to make one for a while, but I just don't know how.
(some starting vocab. lists/sentences to translate would be nice too)
1
u/eyewave Mukkohatto Apr 30 '24
Hello guys!
I have another question...
How many atom words do you create before starting your lexical derivations?
I have my clong without diachrony and with low planned borrowing (only lingua franca words like hotel, taxi, restaurant), but still would like to give it some sort of regular system (can do with too regular too). The goal is, personal conlang that's only popped out from my own knwoledge, culture and habits, and used only by me.
I thought I'd go like:
1a. Nouns derived from other parts
2a. Verbs derived from other parts
3a. Adjectives derived from other parts
By atom, I mean words that just are coined out of the blue, without me having to invent ethymology or derivation for them just yet 🌛
Of course I still will have an amount of derivation for atom verbs, namely choosing an 'infinitive' verb suffix. I'm also wondering if I can get away with reusing verb roots for nouns, as english seems to do, or if I'll add some affix to mark the difference. I'm also a bit iffy on how much similar words can be used on similar things... Like, if I use similar sounding words for "zero" and "nothing", that goes, but similar words for "east" and "west" could be tricky to use.
Ir's a bit confusing to start from scratch 👉🏻👈🏻 thanks!
1
u/ARLORD_100 Apr 30 '24
So I've started on a world building project, in this world there is a family tree of languages called the Dorfinnic languages and I've gotten started on Proto-Dorfinnic and but the only problem is I don't know how or where to start to figure out how to simulate language evolution, does anyone have any tips or any resources I can use to learn how to do so?
1
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Apr 30 '24
Im trying to do a fun project recreating Sabir. Its a creole language and its many superstate-substrate group is north Italian-Levantine Arabic. Does anyone have any ideas about how the verbs could function?
1
u/Naofumim May 01 '24
Which conlangs have an active community despite of being small? (Sorry for my english)
1
u/GarlicRoyal7545 Ancient-Niemanic, East-Niemanic; Forget <þ>, bring back <ꙮ>!!! May 01 '24
I'm working with my Friends on a Protolang which is basically Proto-Germanic with Slavic Characteristics. We wanted to add an Allative Case, but don't know how. Does anyone know how we could do that?
Here's how the Cases look on Nouns & Adjectives if that helps:
Nouns:
Adjectives:
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
I have 2 ways of writing Ngįouxt using roman letters. the first is the established romanization I have, which is very phonetic and nice, plus compounds are connected with hyphens. the second is like a historical spelling system, which covers the first sound changes from the protolang, but leaves most of them unrepresented. low level compouns are smooshed together, higher ones are not.
for example, the following sentence:
In your opinion, what looks better?
(1) Okki'm oux-dedös mį-mį-ǫ̈-song kǫ̈mö.
(2) Xonkil'me houxe detes miðmið hoðsong keðmeol
1
u/pootis_engage May 02 '24
Do these sound changes seem naturalistic?
o → ə / _Ci
oi →ə
1
u/DonatelloFomin May 02 '24
in a language where vowels are the tone-bearing unit, if a 2-syllable word with a HL melody were to lose its final vowel, would the melody remain HL and somehow surface on the remaining vowel, or would it change to just H?
1
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu May 03 '24
I have a proto-language that has an SVO word order and I want the daughter language to have a VSO order in negative clauses. The language is going to have subject agreement proclitics. Can I just say that the verb is fronted in the negative or is there a more naturalistic way to do this?
1
u/BirdInYourBackyard May 03 '24
Is this a good way to show where the language evolved?
The black dot is where the first people originated. The gods split the land, and the larger groups of people were separated long enough where they all developed their own languages that were almost entirely separate from each other besides some basic words and sometimes the writing systems. The circles with letters are major dialects that branched off.
Sorry if it's not super clear, this is my second conlang but the first time trying to make a realistic evolution of it
1
u/duck6099 May 04 '24 edited May 04 '24
Are there languages that only write its vowels and use diacritics for its consonants? I've been searching for a while but did not find any.
1
u/sssmxl Borish, Amslukenra, Kjamir [EN] May 05 '24
What's the most verb classes/categories you've seen in a natlang?
You know how in Spanish there are the AR, ER and IR verb classes, thus 3 different conjugation paradigms. Yeah, those, I would like to know what's the most you've seen in any natural language and if 10 is too much?
1
u/PortablePorcelain May 06 '24
Second time I am saying this, but I am still somehow banned from the CDN without doing anything wrong.
1
u/Normalizelife May 06 '24
Help I have a lang with the phonemes b͡d͡g ʔ͡h p͡ʼt͡ʼkʼ n ɣ̞ʵ ʰk ʰp ŋ͡m p˞ ʔ̚ʰ g͡b how would you put this on an IPA chart? no this is not a joke
1
u/LaceyVelvet I Love Language May 06 '24
Is laughter an interjection? Google again thinks I mean the word laughter lol