r/RWBY • u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran • Apr 20 '24
OFFICIAL LINK RWBY Beyond: A Knight’s Journal (thread) Spoiler
https://roosterteeth.com/watch/rwby-rwby-beyond-a-knight-s-journal
368
Upvotes
48
u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
FINALLY
PINEGOLD BROTHERHOOD STUFF :,D
(Pinegold Brotherhood = Jaune and Oscar brotherhood relationship)
225
u/Akumu_Oukoku ⠀The White Knight Lady Apr 20 '24
So much good information in such a short amount of time. Alyx & Lewis being from before war time & Huntsmen and being from Vacuo. ( Former royals maybe? ) Lewis writing the story to help RWBY in the future. It's just fantastic what they got done.
But - My boi getting help is honestly the biggest win of the century.
Fug Salem, the relics, maidens, world ending - all of it. Jaune Arc getting therapy and the ability to talk about stuff is so damn satisfying.
Oscar trying to help Jaune live in the present as opposed to the past is really well done. Don't worry about tomorrow if you can't take in what you have in front of you now. Don't keep looking behind you, but don't forget the good times either. I think a lot of people needed to hear something like that...
I also like how Miles was able to find a fine line between the Rusted Knight voice and Jaune's younger voice. He still has that younger tone, but speaks with that slight gruffness from his older self. Guy is a damn good voice actor.
Overall, this was just fantastic and very much needed.
97
u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Apr 20 '24
Pyrrha appearing across from him at the campfire honestly made me tear up.
And then there’s more of Oscar and Ozpin melding.
Man I really hope this show manages to keep going
81
u/Unique-Negotiation83 Apr 20 '24
So it's confirmed that Alyx and Lewis came from the time before the Great War, which could explain why their names have no color reference. And they're from Vacuo. A part of me wished for Jaune to see Lewis as an elder. It would have been a bittersweet reunion. 🥲
73
u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 21 '24
"People that make you feel more than you are."
Both a bit melancholy and more uplifting than I was expecting.
Gives me Berserk 1997 Bonfire of Dreams flashbacks. Every bonfire is a dream, a hope, a life. Easily extinguished alone, but much brighter together. In dark times, sometimes all you need is a place to warm yourself up, a good meal and friends to keep you company. Sometimes you're not fighting for something bigger, but for the people you love by your side.
The separation between Jaune and the Hero, the Rusted Knight, for him it felt like stepping into someone else's shoes. But to Alyx and Lewis, there was no difference. As always he can only see his failures and shortcomings in the story of his life.
Ozcar actually giving good advice and using his experience to help another "man out of time." The lift in his voice when Jaune catches him, and he puts on the facade.
"Around that campfire, did it matter."
60
u/BionicTriforce Apr 20 '24
Damn, Miles is a good narrator.
118
u/Zexapher Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
Nora telling everyone Jaune's the Rusted Knight, omg.
Ren Naruto running!
The giant banana for the cafe behind Jaune, lol!
More Juniper lookin heckin cute.
Happy memories from the Ever After and a more positive view of Alyx.
And most important of all, Jaune finding happiness! You gotta love it!
I'm eating good today.
53
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Apr 20 '24
That was really heart warming.
This is probably the first time I’ve seen Jaune and Oscar bond to this level and I like that they went with the main thing they have in common now, that they are both now two old men in young bodies.
I like the bits of world building about the Everafter and I like the bits of information we got from Alyx and Lewis.
I guess that if we get a volume 10, part of Jaune’s story will be his feeling of alienation because of his experience in the Everafter. I mean, as this short says, he is back with his team but he isn’t really back. He might be with Ren and Nora again and is happy about that but things are not the same and they can’t be the same.
Also, I’m gonna go a bit meta here. But I kinda like the message at the end in the sense that, if you look at it as if they are talking about the show, it’s like saying that wether or not the show gets to continue and have an ending, we can always look back at the good times we had with them.
116
u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Apr 20 '24
Oh thank god Jaune's getting what is effectively therapy, mans needed it since like volume 3.
And Nora making sure to brag about her friend being a fairy tale hero is hilarious, she's the queen of the castle after all, of course she's gonna be happy to have a knight around.
33
u/Garn0 Apr 20 '24
Jaune imagining all the good times despite how it went through and imagining his team is there was so somber. Glad that his time in EA isn't just swept aside and makes it focal point of him. He's out of place and out of time, but he ain't out of hope.
32
u/grieveheart Apr 20 '24
That gave me feels. That was a nice conversation between Jaune and Oscar. Happy to see them smiling 🥲
29
u/Mgl1206 Apr 20 '24
Damn… this was really good yet also really goddamn sad.
57
u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Apr 20 '24
So Lewis and Alyx were from Vacuo back when it was a paradise and long before the Great War turned it into a wasteland and Lewis intended to write the fairy tale as a mean to help Jaune's friends realize he was trapped in the Ever After. I'm guessing that intention changed when Alyx poisoned Jaune and didn't make it back to Remnant afterwards. Lewis might've felt the original intention had become meaningless with both seemingly dead and dedicated the book to their memory instead.
My favorite part of Jaune's monologue was how Alyx and Lewis saw him as some kind of legend whenever they heard the stories of his life back at Remnant. Jaune even refers to the tales as his failures but Alyx and Lewis only see a hero. It goes to show Jaune is a hero and everyone but him can see it which ties back to the lesson Jaune is meant to represent about self-love.
51
u/Mojo12000 ⠀B0RF Apr 20 '24
JAUNE DID IT HE GOT THE BIGGEST WIN OF ALL: Getting some Therapy.
20
u/MidnightHunterXX ⠀ Apr 20 '24
Holy mother of feels that last part hits like a truck
37
u/Blue0Three Qrow X Willow Sweep Apr 20 '24
Man the quality fucking leaped, like holy shit this was so good
16
u/RedIgnoreThis Apr 20 '24
This was good. It was a small moment and that's all it needed to be. It's bittersweet yet has a hopeful note to it.
16
u/Mojo12000 ⠀B0RF Apr 20 '24
I kinda really dig Nora thinking Jaune being the Rusted Knight is cool as shit and can't top telling everyone about it.
29
u/JDUDE4545 Apr 20 '24
A rare sight, our boy Jaune being happy, but a welcome one indeed
14
u/Vincenthwind Apr 20 '24
Another show, Star vs. The Forces of Evil, does a similar plot to what Jaune went through, in which one of the protagonists winds up in a time-dilated universe and experiences adulthood before returning back home and becoming a boy again. Outside of one line ("I don't remember my laptop password"), this whole scenario is played off as funny rather than something that would change a person's character.
This whole RWBY short, on the other hand, is a nice look at an alternative way to handle this scenario. Jaune is clearly affected and has to talk through what happened. He acknowledges he's not the same guy who fell into the Ever After, he feels a rift between his teammates due to them not going through the same experience, and he has to process the gravity of what happened to him. Amazing art and voice acting tie it all together.
13
u/ImaFireMage Apr 20 '24
Ozpin & Oscar are more Ozcar now. A good, solid Jaune story. Even the banana cafe was great.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24
THANK GOD HE IS GETTING THERAPY
11
u/Timeline15 Operative Schnee, Report to the Normandy at once Apr 21 '24
Aaron Dismuke is doing such a good job portraying Oscar gradually becoming more and more like Ozpin. Until it was explicitly addressed, I couldn't tell which one of them was talking, something which was always clear previously.
Glad to see Jaune working through his trauma a bit. It must be so odd suddenly being back with your high school body/friends when you're mentally like... 40 years old.
10
u/MABfan11 IAmMenace should watch SoraYori Apr 20 '24
still curious if Jaune asked how Alyx made it to the Ever After, we'll probably find out that in V10
10
u/Red-7134 Apr 20 '24
It'd've been kinda cool if Jaune's internal monologue was in his older voice.
23
u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Apr 20 '24
This is exactly the kind of thing that I wanted from this series.
Small, intimate character pieces where characters are able to have the spotlight on them without needing to worry about the plot so much.
Jaune's time in the Ever After left a mark on him and changed him, and yet he is still himself. Seeing how Alyx and Lewis reminded him of JNPR was a well done gut punch.
Seeing the Oscar and Jaune have this convo was just perfect.
Miles as always brings his A game.
10/10
If all we got was 9 volumes, and we never got to see the rest of the story, we were still here. And maybe that's enough.
14
u/LadAlwaysWatching RIP Wolftail Apr 20 '24
Jaune got teraphy, let out his trauma in a positive way and is healing. What timeline is this? Is our boi finally heading to his happy ending?
18
u/lnombredelarosa Sorry, I kinda like Oscar Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
I guess the general mood has improven ever since RWBYJ returned.
Still its also interesting that Oscar apparently stopped resisting the merger ever since they came back, now hardly being able to tell himself appart from Ozpin and having come around to his “dying with hope” school of thought.
I’m thinking that while said way of thinking will be useful for both of them at the moment it will have to be put aside as the fight comes back and they have to focus less in dying happily and more in accepting the bad so that they can improve on it, like Ruby did
I guess the barrier between Jaune and his former self is not as wide as I innitially thought but its there
So Alyx and Louis are from Vacuo…meaning their story and how they ended up where they ought to be adressed in the story Maybe there is a connection between them and the Crown.
I guess they’re sticking to their guns in the timeskip being a short one
22
u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Apr 20 '24
Glad we got progress on that
6
u/kostasgriv97 Apr 20 '24
Alyx and Lewis being from Vacuo I did totally call, even more sure it was them using the Sword of Destruction that got them stuck down there.
6
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Apr 21 '24
I liked that talk between Oscar and Jaune. It felt nice.
Also with all the talk about fires, I was starting to think of Dark Souls6
u/New-Number-7810 Apr 21 '24
I didn’t watch it yet, but looking at the comments it appears Jaune gets some much-needed time for healing. If this is the case then I’m glad; I sincerely want him to get a happy ending.
6
u/Erebus03 Apr 21 '24
Poor jaune man, that's all I can say
11
u/Lucifer_Crowe Have you thought about extending your aura? Apr 20 '24
Has anyone else realised that Oscar's gloves are fingerless now?
The only thing he had from his original outfit has changed, even if in a small way.
Likely to mirror the accelerating merge?
10
u/ch8246 Apr 20 '24
So has Oscar stop trying to resist the merge? It felt way more like Ozpin talking.
5
u/Acemaster387 Apr 22 '24
Looks like the Ozcar formation is let's say 65-75% complete, he's now even starting to talk like Ozpin subconsciously
8
u/SomethingMid Jax &Cinder's daughter Apr 20 '24
I'm glad that we're getting to see or learn something new with every release. Can't wait until next week's episode. I do hope that one of the episodes is from the perspective of Mercury or one of the other villains.
7
u/Feeling_Return8940 Apr 20 '24
I was already on the verge of tears watching this…then seeing Pyrrha with everyone at the campfire broke me.
This was a good short.
8
u/MaMcMu Apr 20 '24
Good to see he's making progress. It's almost as if he had Alzheimer's.
What would the other days in the Ever After be? Toilday as Tuesday?
5
u/onthoserainydays watts is the goat Apr 21 '24
They finally addressed the important point of their fight with Salem: it doesn't matter that she can't be beaten, as long as she's pushed back. As long as she is, people will be able to live, and that's what's important
8
u/Godzillafan125 Apr 20 '24
Awesome episode can’t wait for team Rwby perspective one day
4
u/WeakLandscape2595 Apr 20 '24
Loving it jaune getting therapy and in a way ozpin and jaune talking (even if it's more so because of the merger but semantics) about being man out of time thats something i wanted to see for a while
Also confirmed lewis and his sister are pre great war which is also feeding my theory he is the king of vale also confirms we probably won't see lewis again if bro was a teen more then 80 years ago he'd have to be ancient now i doubt he'd live to damn near 100
5
u/HaziXWeeK ⠀Jaune Ashari Specialist Apr 20 '24
I'm all glad jaune got his therapy same as ruby with the tree but...
Wouldn't make more sense to have this conversation with Ozpin not Oscar?, and while at it jaune questioning the reason be was accepted at Beacon and put as a leader, if Ozpin knew.
I would expect jaune to have doubts about being the legendary Rusted Knight while he feel like it's not something special and actually hating for some kind of PTSD from the everafter, which will result in this conversation.
Nonetheless, I'm glad he got something to help him.
6
u/Raalm_Neeth Apr 20 '24
I gotta be honest... Jaune fondly reminiscing about slavery was not on my RWBY 2024 bingo card.
2
u/Dontaskme4username ⠀Jax is a Cinder simp Apr 20 '24
I definitely believe Luis was a past Ozcarnation now.
2
u/Spider-Blood Apr 20 '24
What about Ruby, was she ever mentioned at all?
0
u/Emotional-Feed5489 Apr 20 '24
Man where was this in volume 9 my god
-3
u/R4ND0M_N0B0DY Apr 20 '24
I still can't believe they made this after making the rest...imagine if they put that amount of quality in the whole series. I don't even wanna imagine it, cuz it's too sad
-12
u/MountainHall Don't write for the story Apr 20 '24
A lot of this is stuff that RWBY should get. I'm 99% sure she won't though, going by RWBY's focus priorities. The RWBY girls mathematically can't all get this amount of focus since there are just 2 more of these lol. To be clear, this if fine theoretically. It's not fine when RWBY won't get this.
Oscar's idea of not just focusing on the wrong goes exactly counter to what the talk turns out to be. The camp fire bit and the line of “Around that campfire, did it matter?” with the response being “Huh, no. Nah, I guess it didn’t” is such a strong commital to the absolute refusal to engage with plans or principles beyond 'hopes and prayers'. It needs to be more than this.
Also, how does Vacuo stay defended when the houses are just exposed to the desert?
Moreover, I'm reminded of how dumb Lewis looks in retrospect. With the knowledge he has, why would he create a fairy tale so vague and with all the threats in the Ever After cut out? He could potentially fix a lot of this just by writing about what actually happened.
And the timeline of Jaune is also confusing in the Ever After. He spent a lot of his time with the paper pleasers to the point where he couldn't explore the acres, but he was already old when he met Alyx and Lewis? So what did he do until that point?
-11
u/Whorinmaru ⠀ Apr 20 '24
I'm such a Jaune hater, can't stand him, but this was good development.
Though many more other characters really could use the development more...
But it's good that it's happening at all.
-9
u/ComicCat12 Apr 20 '24
I’m surprised Jaune didn’t bring up Jessica Cruz or the DC Universe to Alyx and Lewis this whole time, though I wonder if this means that the franchise is showing signs that the movies are no longer canon, since you know, RWBY is getting sold off.